-
Spontaneous generation of athermal phonon bursts within bulk silicon causing excess noise, low energy background events and quasiparticle poisoning in superconducting sensors
Authors:
C. L. Chang,
Y. -Y. Chang,
M. Garcia-Sciveres,
W. Guo,
S. A. Hertel,
X. Li,
J. Lin,
M. Lisovenko,
R. Mahapatra,
W. Matava,
D. N. McKinsey,
P. K. Patel,
B. Penning,
M. Platt,
M. Pyle,
Y. Qi,
M. Reed,
I. Rydstrom,
R. K. Romani,
B. Sadoulet,
B. Serfass,
P. Sorensen,
B. Suerfu,
V. Velan,
G. Wang
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Solid state phonon detectors used in the search for dark matter or coherent neutrino nucleus interactions (CE$ν$NS) require excellent energy resolution (eV-scale or below) and low backgrounds to meet their science objectives. Unfortunately, an unknown source of phonon bursts (the low energy excess, or ``LEE'') both dominates all other above threshold background sources and produces shot noise from…
▽ More
Solid state phonon detectors used in the search for dark matter or coherent neutrino nucleus interactions (CE$ν$NS) require excellent energy resolution (eV-scale or below) and low backgrounds to meet their science objectives. Unfortunately, an unknown source of phonon bursts (the low energy excess, or ``LEE'') both dominates all other above threshold background sources and produces shot noise from sub-threshold bursts which greatly exceeds all fundamental noise sources. In this paper, we measure these phonon bursts for 12 days after cool down in two nearly identical multi-phonon sensor channel 1cm$^2$ silicon detectors which differ only in the thickness of their substrate (1 mm vs 4 mm thick). We find that both the correlated shot noise and near threshold shared LEE relax with time since cooldown. Additionally, we show that both shot noise and LEE rates scale linearly with substrate thickness. When combined with previous measurements of other silicon phonon detectors with different substrate geometries and mechanical support strategies, these measurements strongly suggest that the dominant source of both above and below threshold LEE is the bulk substrate. By monitoring the relation between bias power and excess phonon shot noise we estimate that $\varepsilon = \frac{<E^2>}{<E>}$ for sub-threshold noise events is $0.68 \pm 0.38$ meV. In our final dataset, we report a world-leading energy resolution of 258.5$\pm$0.4 meV in the 1mm thick detector. Simple calculations suggest that these Si substrate phonon bursts are likely the dominant source of quasi-particle poisoning in superconducting qubits and sensors that are operated in well shielded and vibration free environments.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2025; v1 submitted 21 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
First demonstration of a TES based cryogenic Li$_2$MoO$_4$detector for neutrinoless double beta decay search
Authors:
G. Bratrud,
C. L. Chang,
R. Chen,
E. Cudmore,
E. Figueroa-Feliciano,
Z. Hong,
K. T. Kennard,
S. Lewis,
M. Lisovenko,
L. O. Mateo,
V. Novati,
V. Novosad,
E. Oliveri,
R. Ren,
J. A. Scarpaci,
B. Schmidt,
G. Wang,
L. Winslow,
V. G. Yefremenko,
J. Zhang,
D. Baxter,
M. Hollister,
C. James,
P. Lukens,
D. J. Temples
Abstract:
Cryogenic calorimetric experiments to search for neutrinoless double-beta decay ($0νββ$) are highly competitive, scalable and versatile in isotope. The largest planned detector array, CUPID, is comprised of about 1500 individual Li$_2^{100}$MoO$_{4}$ detector modules with a further scale up envisioned for a follow up experiment (CUPID-1T). In this article, we present a novel detector concept targe…
▽ More
Cryogenic calorimetric experiments to search for neutrinoless double-beta decay ($0νββ$) are highly competitive, scalable and versatile in isotope. The largest planned detector array, CUPID, is comprised of about 1500 individual Li$_2^{100}$MoO$_{4}$ detector modules with a further scale up envisioned for a follow up experiment (CUPID-1T). In this article, we present a novel detector concept targeting this second stage with a low impedance TES based readout for the Li$_2$MoO$_{4}$ absorber that is easily mass-produced and lends itself to a multiplexed readout. We present the detector design and results from a first prototype detector operated at the NEXUS shallow underground facility at Fermilab. The detector is a 2-cm-side cube with 21$\,$g mass that is strongly thermally coupled to its readout chip to allow rise-times of $\sim$0.5$\,$ms. This design is more than one order of magnitude faster than present NTD based detectors and is hence expected to effectively mitigate backgrounds generated through the pile-up of two independent two neutrino decay events coinciding close in time. Together with a baseline resolution of 1.95$\,$keV (FWHM) these performance parameters extrapolate to a background index from pile-up as low as $5\cdot 10^{-6}\,$counts/keV/kg/yr in CUPID size crystals. The detector was calibrated up to the MeV region showing sufficient dynamic range for $0νββ$ searches. In combination with a SuperCDMS HVeV detector this setup also allowed us to perform a precision measurement of the scintillation time constants of Li$_2$MoO$_{4}$. The crystal showed a significant fast scintillation emission with O(10$\,μ$s) time-scale, more than an order below the detector response of presently considered light detectors suggesting the possibility of further progress in pile-up rejection through better light detectors in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2025; v1 submitted 4 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Modeling and characterization of TES-based detectors for the Ricochet experiment
Authors:
R. Chen,
E. Figueroa-Feliciano,
G. Bratrud,
C. L. Chang,
L. Chaplinsky,
E. Cudmore,
W. Van De Pontseele,
J. A. Formaggio,
P. Harrington,
S. A. Hertel,
Z. Hong,
K. T. Kennard,
M. Li,
M. Lisovenko,
L. O. Mateo,
D. W. Mayer,
V. Novati,
P. K. Patel,
H. D. Pinckney,
N. Raha,
F. C. Reyes,
A. Rodriguez,
B. Schmidt,
J. Stachurska,
C. Veihmeyer
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering (CE$ν$NS) offers a valuable approach in searching for physics beyond the Standard Model. The Ricochet experiment aims to perform a precision measurement of the CE$ν$NS spectrum at the Institut Laue-Langevin nuclear reactor with cryogenic solid-state detectors. The experiment plans to employ an array of cryogenic thermal detectors, each with a mass aroun…
▽ More
Coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering (CE$ν$NS) offers a valuable approach in searching for physics beyond the Standard Model. The Ricochet experiment aims to perform a precision measurement of the CE$ν$NS spectrum at the Institut Laue-Langevin nuclear reactor with cryogenic solid-state detectors. The experiment plans to employ an array of cryogenic thermal detectors, each with a mass around 30 g and an energy threshold of sub-100 eV. The array includes nine detectors read out by Transition-Edge Sensors (TES). These TES based detectors will also serve as demonstrators for future neutrino experiments with thousands of detectors. In this article we present an update in the characterization and modeling of a prototype TES detector.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Results from a Prototype TES Detector for the Ricochet Experiment
Authors:
Ricochet Collaboration,
C. Augier,
G. Baulieu,
V. Belov,
L. Bergé,
J. Billard,
G. Bres,
J-. L. Bret,
A. Broniatowski,
M. Calvo,
A. Cazes,
D. Chaize,
M. Chala,
C. L. Chang,
M. Chapellier,
L. Chaplinsky,
G. Chemin,
R. Chen,
J. Colas,
E. Cudmore,
M. De Jesus,
P. de Marcillac,
L. Dumoulin,
O. Exshaw,
S. Ferriol
, et al. (66 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering (CE$ν$NS) offers valuable sensitivity to physics beyond the Standard Model. The Ricochet experiment will use cryogenic solid-state detectors to perform a precision measurement of the CE$ν$NS spectrum induced by the high neutrino flux from the Institut Laue-Langevin nuclear reactor. The experiment will employ an array of detectors, each with a mass of…
▽ More
Coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering (CE$ν$NS) offers valuable sensitivity to physics beyond the Standard Model. The Ricochet experiment will use cryogenic solid-state detectors to perform a precision measurement of the CE$ν$NS spectrum induced by the high neutrino flux from the Institut Laue-Langevin nuclear reactor. The experiment will employ an array of detectors, each with a mass of $\sim$30 g and a targeted energy threshold of 50 eV. Nine of these detectors (the "Q-Array") will be based on a novel Transition-Edge Sensor (TES) readout style, in which the TES devices are thermally coupled to the absorber using a gold wire bond. We present initial characterization of a Q-Array-style detector using a 1 gram silicon absorber, obtaining a baseline root-mean-square resolution of less than 40 eV.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2024; v1 submitted 28 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Electromagnetic Properties of Aluminum-based Bilayers for Kinetic Inductance Detectors
Authors:
G. Wang,
P. S. Barry,
T. Cecil,
C. L. Chang,
J. Li,
M. Lisovenko,
V. Novosad,
Z. Pan,
V. G. Yefremenko,
J. Zhang
Abstract:
The complex conductivity of a superconducting thin film is related to the quasiparticle density, which depends on the physical temperature and can also be modified by external pair breaking with photons and phonons. This relationship forms the underlying operating principle of Kinetic Inductance Detectors (KIDs), where the detection threshold is governed by the superconducting energy gap. We inves…
▽ More
The complex conductivity of a superconducting thin film is related to the quasiparticle density, which depends on the physical temperature and can also be modified by external pair breaking with photons and phonons. This relationship forms the underlying operating principle of Kinetic Inductance Detectors (KIDs), where the detection threshold is governed by the superconducting energy gap. We investigate the electromagnetic properties of thin-film aluminum that is proximitized with either a normal metal layer of copper or a superconducting layer with a lower $T_C$, such as iridium, in order to extend the operating range of KIDs. Using the Usadel equations along with the Nam expressions for complex conductivity, we calculate the density of states and the complex conductivity of the resulting bilayers to understand the dependence of the pair breaking threshold, surface impedance, and intrinsic quality factor of superconducting bilayers on the relative film thicknesses. The calculations and analyses provide theoretical insights in designing aluminum-based bilayer kinetic inductance detectors for detection of microwave photons and athermal phonons at the frequencies well below the pair breaking threshold of a pure aluminum film.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Light Dark Matter Detection with Hydrogen-rich Crystals and Low-Tc TES Detectors
Authors:
G. Wang,
C. L. Chang,
M. Lisovenko,
V. Novosad,
V. G. Yefremenko,
J. Zhang
Abstract:
Direct detection of nuclear scatterings of sub-GeV Dark Matter (DM) particles favors low-Z nuclei. Hydrogen nucleus, which has a single proton, provides the best kinematic match to a light dark matter particle. The characteristic nuclear recoil energy is boosted by a factor of a few tens from those for larger nuclei used in traditional Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP) searches. Furthermo…
▽ More
Direct detection of nuclear scatterings of sub-GeV Dark Matter (DM) particles favors low-Z nuclei. Hydrogen nucleus, which has a single proton, provides the best kinematic match to a light dark matter particle. The characteristic nuclear recoil energy is boosted by a factor of a few tens from those for larger nuclei used in traditional Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP) searches. Furthermore, hydrogen is optimal not only for spin-independent nuclear scatterings of sub-GeV DM, but also for spin-dependent nuclear scatterings, where large parameter space remains unconstrained. In this paper, we first introduce hydrogen-rich crystals, which include water ice, acetylene, anthracene, trans-stilbene, and naphthalene. These crystals emit two classes of signals under kinetic excitations. One class of the signals is infrared photons, which are from optically active fundamental vibrational modes of molecules and are at corresponding characteristic wavelengths. The other is acoustic phonons, and optical phonons that decay into acoustic phonons. We then discuss the technical status and future researches of low-Tc Transition-Edge Sensor (TES) detectors, which measure single infrared photons and a small flux of acoustic phonons with desirable sensitivities. With theoretical modeling to select the hydrogen-rich crystals for the optimized science reach, development of ultra-sensitive low-Tc TES detectors for readout, and experimentally characterizing transport properties of photons and phonons in the selected hydrogen-rich crystals, a direct detection experiment can be built for measuring the large unexplored parameter space of light DM particles.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2022; v1 submitted 11 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Optical leakage mitigation in ortho-mode transducer detectors for microwave applications
Authors:
Riccardo Gualtieri,
Peter S. Barry,
Thomas Cecil,
Amy N. Bender,
Clarence . L. Chang,
John C. Hood,
Margarita Lisovenko,
Volodymyr G. Yefremenko
Abstract:
Planar ortho-mode transducers (OMTs) are a commonly used method of coupling optical signals between waveguides and on-chip circuitry and detectors. While the ideal OMT-waveguide coupling requires minimal disturbance to the waveguide, when used for mm-wave applications the waveguide is typically constructed from two sections to allow the OMT probes to be inserted into the waveguide. This break in t…
▽ More
Planar ortho-mode transducers (OMTs) are a commonly used method of coupling optical signals between waveguides and on-chip circuitry and detectors. While the ideal OMT-waveguide coupling requires minimal disturbance to the waveguide, when used for mm-wave applications the waveguide is typically constructed from two sections to allow the OMT probes to be inserted into the waveguide. This break in the waveguide is a source of signal leakage and can lead to loss of performance and increased experimental systematic errors. Here we report on the development of new OMT-to-waveguide coupling structures with the goal of reducing leakage at the detector wafer interface. The pixel to pixel optical leakage due to the gap between the coupling waveguide and the backshort is reduced by means of a protrusion that passes through the OMT membrane and electrically connects the two waveguide sections on either side of the wafer. High frequency electromagnetic simulations indicate that these protrusions are an effective method to reduce optical leakage in the gap by ~80% percent, with a ~60% filling factor, relative to an standard OMT coupling architecture. Prototype devices have been designed to characterize the performance of the new design using a relative measurement with varying filling factors. We outline the simulation setup and results, and present a chip layout and sample box that will be used to perform the initial measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Scintillation yield from electronic and nuclear recoils in superfluid $^4$He
Authors:
SPICE/HeRALD Collaboration,
:,
A. Biekert,
C. Chang,
C. W. Fink,
M. Garcia-Sciveres,
E. C. Glazer,
W. Guo,
S. A. Hertel,
S. Kravitz,
J. Lin,
M. Lisovenko,
R. Mahapatra,
D. N. McKinsey,
J. S. Nguyen,
V. Novosad,
W. Page,
P. K. Patel,
B. Penning,
H. D. Pinckney,
M. Pyle,
R. K. Romani,
A. S. Seilnacht,
A. Serafin,
R. J. Smith
, et al. (9 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Superfluid $^4$He is a promising target material for direct detection of light ($<$ 1 GeV) dark matter. Possible signal channels available for readout in this medium include prompt photons, triplet excimers, and roton and phonon quasiparticles. The relative yield of these signals has implications for the sensitivity and discrimination power of a superfluid $^4$He dark matter detector. Using a 16~c…
▽ More
Superfluid $^4$He is a promising target material for direct detection of light ($<$ 1 GeV) dark matter. Possible signal channels available for readout in this medium include prompt photons, triplet excimers, and roton and phonon quasiparticles. The relative yield of these signals has implications for the sensitivity and discrimination power of a superfluid $^4$He dark matter detector. Using a 16~cm$^3$ volume of 1.75~K superfluid $^4$He read out by six immersed photomultiplier tubes, we measured the scintillation from electronic recoils ranging between 36.3 and 185 keV$_\mathrm{ee}$, yielding a mean signal size of $1.25^{+0.03}_{-0.03}$~phe/keV$_\mathrm{ee}$, and nuclear recoils from 53.2 to 1090 keV$_\mathrm{nr}$. We compare the results of our relative scintillation yield measurements to an existing semiempirical model based on helium-helium and electron-helium interaction cross sections. We also study the behavior of delayed scintillation components as a function of recoil type and energy, a further avenue for signal discrimination in superfluid $^4$He.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2022; v1 submitted 4 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Controlling $T_c$ of Iridium Films Using the Proximity Effect
Authors:
R. Hennings-Yeomans,
C. L. Chang,
J. Ding,
A. Drobizhev,
B. K. Fujikawa,
S. Han,
G. Karapetrov,
Yu. G. Kolomensky,
V. Novosad,
T. O'Donnell,
J. L. Ouellet,
J. Pearson,
T. Polakovic,
D. Reggio,
B. Schmidt,
B. Sheff,
V. Singh,
R. J. Smith,
G. Wang,
B. Welliver,
V. G. Yefremenko,
J. Zhang
Abstract:
A superconducting Transition-Edge Sensor (TES) with low-$T_c$ is essential in a high resolution calorimetric detection. With a motivation of developing sensitive calorimeters for applications in cryogenic neutrinoless double beta decay searches, we have been investigating methods to reduce the $T_c$ of an Ir film down to 20 mK. Utilizing the proximity effect between a superconductor and a normal m…
▽ More
A superconducting Transition-Edge Sensor (TES) with low-$T_c$ is essential in a high resolution calorimetric detection. With a motivation of developing sensitive calorimeters for applications in cryogenic neutrinoless double beta decay searches, we have been investigating methods to reduce the $T_c$ of an Ir film down to 20 mK. Utilizing the proximity effect between a superconductor and a normal metal, we found two room temperature fabrication recipes of making Ir-based low-$T_c$ films. In the first approach, an Ir film sandwiched between two Au films, a Au/Ir/Au trilayer, has a tunable $T_c$ in the range of 20-100 mK depending on the relative thicknesses. In the second approach, a paramagnetic Pt thin film is used to create Ir/Pt bilayer with a tunable $T_c$ in the same range. We present detailed study of fabrication and characterization of Ir-based low-$T_c$ films, and compare the experimental results to theoretical models. We show that Ir-based films with predictable and reproducible critical temperature can be consistently fabricated for use in large scale detector applications.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Developing AlMn films for Argonne TES fabrication
Authors:
E. M. Vavagiakis,
N. F. Cothard,
J. R. Stevens,
C. L. Chang,
M. D. Niemack,
G. Wang,
V. G. Yefremenko,
J. Zhang
Abstract:
The reference design for the next-generation cosmic microwave background (CMB) experiment, CMB-S4, relies on large arrays of transition edge sensor (TES) bolometers coupled to Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (SQUID)-based readout systems. Mapping the CMB to near cosmic variance limits will enable the search for signatures of inflation and constrain dark energy and neutrino physics. AlM…
▽ More
The reference design for the next-generation cosmic microwave background (CMB) experiment, CMB-S4, relies on large arrays of transition edge sensor (TES) bolometers coupled to Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (SQUID)-based readout systems. Mapping the CMB to near cosmic variance limits will enable the search for signatures of inflation and constrain dark energy and neutrino physics. AlMn TESes provide simple film manufacturing and highly uniform arrays over large areas to meet the requirements of the CMB-S4 experiment. TES parameters such as critical temperature and normal resistance must be tuned to experiment specifications and can be varied based on geometry and steps in the fabrication process such as deposition layering, geometry, and baking time and temperature. Using four-terminal sensing, we measured $T_C$ and $R_N$ of AlMn 2000 ppm films and devices of varying thicknesses fabricated at Argonne National Laboratory to motivate device geometries and fabrication processes to tune $T_C$ to 150-200 mK and $R_N$ to $\sim$10 mOhms. Measurements of IV curves and time constants for the resulting devices of varying leg length were made using time-division SQUID multiplexing, and determined $T_C$, $G$, $k$, $f_{3db}$, and $R_N$. We present the results of these tests along with the geometries and fabrication steps used to tune the device parameters to the desired limits.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Controlling $T_c$ of Iridium films using interfacial proximity effects
Authors:
R. Hennings-Yeomans,
C. L. Chang,
J. Ding,
A. Drobizhev,
B. K. Fujikawa,
S. Han,
G. Karapetrov,
Yu. G. Kolomensky,
V. Novosad,
T. O'Donnell,
J. L. Ouellet,
J. Pearson,
T. Polakovic,
D. Reggio,
B. Schmidt,
B. Sheff,
R. J. Smith,
G. Wang,
B. Welliver,
V. G. Yefremenko
Abstract:
High precision calorimetry using superconducting transition edge sensors requires the use of superconducting films with a suitable $T_c$, depending on the application. To advance high-precision macrocalorimetry, we require low-$T_c$ films that are easy to fabricate. A simple and effective way to suppress $T_c$ of superconducting Iridium through the proximity effect is demonstrated by using Ir/Pt b…
▽ More
High precision calorimetry using superconducting transition edge sensors requires the use of superconducting films with a suitable $T_c$, depending on the application. To advance high-precision macrocalorimetry, we require low-$T_c$ films that are easy to fabricate. A simple and effective way to suppress $T_c$ of superconducting Iridium through the proximity effect is demonstrated by using Ir/Pt bilayers as well as Au/Ir/Au trilayers. While Ir/Au films fabricated by applying heat to the substrate during Ir deposition have been used in the past for superconducting sensors, we present results of $T_c$ suppression on Iridium by deposition at room temperature in Au/Ir/Au trilayers and Ir/Pt bilayers in the range of $\sim$20-100~mK. Measurements of the relative impedance between the Ir/Pt bilayers and Au/Ir/Au trilayers fabricated show factor of $\sim$10 higher values in the Ir/Pt case. These new films could play a key role in the development of scalable superconducting transition edge sensors that require low-$T_c$ films to minimize heat capacity and maximize energy resolution, while keeping high-yield fabrication methods.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
