-
Operational Space and Plasma Performance with an RMP-ELM Suppressed Edge
Authors:
C. Paz-Soldan,
S. Gu,
N. Leuthold,
P. Lunia,
P. Xie,
M. W. Kim,
S. K. Kim,
N. C. Logan,
J. -K. Park,
W. Suttrop,
Y. Sun,
D. B. Weisberg,
M. Willensdorfer,
the ASDEX-Upgrade,
DIII-D,
EAST,
KSTAR Teams
Abstract:
The operational space and global performance of plasmas with edge-localized modes (ELMs) suppressed by resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) are surveyed by comparing AUG, DIII-D, EAST, and KSTAR stationary operating points. RMP-ELM suppression is achieved over a range of plasma currents, toroidal fields, and RMP toroidal mode numbers. Consistent operational windows in edge safety factor are foun…
▽ More
The operational space and global performance of plasmas with edge-localized modes (ELMs) suppressed by resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) are surveyed by comparing AUG, DIII-D, EAST, and KSTAR stationary operating points. RMP-ELM suppression is achieved over a range of plasma currents, toroidal fields, and RMP toroidal mode numbers. Consistent operational windows in edge safety factor are found across devices, while windows in plasma shaping parameters are distinct. Accessed pedestal parameters reveal a quantitatively similar pedestal-top density limit for RMP-ELM suppression in all devices of just over 3x1019 m-3. This is surprising given the wide variance of many engineering parameters and edge collisionalities, and poses a challenge to extrapolation of the regime. Wide ranges in input power, confinement time, and stored energy are observed, with the achieved triple product found to scale like the product of current, field, and radius. Observed energy confinement scaling with engineering parameters for RMP-ELM suppressed plasmas are presented and compared with expectations from established H and L-mode scalings, including treatment of uncertainty analysis. Different scaling exponents for individual engineering parameters are found as compared to the established scalings. However, extrapolation to next-step tokamaks ITER and SPARC find overall consistency within uncertainties with the established scalings, finding no obvious performance penalty when extrapolating from the assembled multi-device RMP-ELM suppressed database. Overall this work identifies common physics for RMP-ELM suppression and highlights the need to pursue this no-ELM regime at higher magnetic field and different plasma physical size.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Non-linear modeling of the threshold between ELM mitigation and ELM suppression by Resonant Magnetic Perturbations in ASDEX Upgrade
Authors:
François Orain,
M. Hoelzl,
F. Mink,
M. Willensdorfer,
M. Bécoulet,
M. Dunne,
S. Günter,
G. T. A. Huijsmans,
K. Lackner,
S. Pamela,
W. Suttrop,
E. Viezzer
Abstract:
The interaction between Edge Localized Modes (ELMs) and Resonant Magnetic Perturbations (RMPs) is modeled with the magnetohydrodynamic code JOREK using experimental parameters from ASDEX Upgrade discharges. The ELM mitigation or suppression is optimal when the amplification of both tearing and peeling-kink responses result in a better RMP penetration. The ELM mitigation or suppression is not only…
▽ More
The interaction between Edge Localized Modes (ELMs) and Resonant Magnetic Perturbations (RMPs) is modeled with the magnetohydrodynamic code JOREK using experimental parameters from ASDEX Upgrade discharges. The ELM mitigation or suppression is optimal when the amplification of both tearing and peeling-kink responses result in a better RMP penetration. The ELM mitigation or suppression is not only due to the reduction of the pressure gradient, but predominantly arises from the toroidal coupling between the ELMs and the RMP-induced mode at the plasma edge, forcing the edge modes to saturate at a low level. The bifurcation from ELM mitigation to ELM suppression is observed when the RMP amplitude is increased. ELM mitigation is characterized by rotating modes at the edge, while the mode locking to RMPs is induced by the resonant braking of the electron perpendicular flow in the ELM suppression regime.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2019; v1 submitted 1 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Experimental conditions to suppress edge localised modes by magnetic perturbations in the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak
Authors:
W. Suttrop,
A. Kirk,
V. Bobkov,
M. Cavedon,
M. Dunne,
R. M. McDermott,
H. Meyer,
R. Nazikian,
C. Paz-Soldan,
D. A. Ryan,
E. Viezzer,
M. Willensdorfer
Abstract:
Access conditions for full suppression of Edge Localised Modes (ELMs) by Magnetic Perturbations (MP) in low density high confinement mode (H-mode) plasmas are studied in the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak. The main empirical requirements for full ELM suppression in our experiments are: 1. The poloidal spectrum of the MP must be aligned for best plasma response from weakly stable kink-modes, which amplify t…
▽ More
Access conditions for full suppression of Edge Localised Modes (ELMs) by Magnetic Perturbations (MP) in low density high confinement mode (H-mode) plasmas are studied in the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak. The main empirical requirements for full ELM suppression in our experiments are: 1. The poloidal spectrum of the MP must be aligned for best plasma response from weakly stable kink-modes, which amplify the perturbation, 2. The plasma edge density must be below a critical value, $3.3 \times 10^{19}$~m$^{-3}$. The edge collisionality is in the range $ν^*_i = 0.15-0.42$ (ions) and $ν^*_e = 0.15-0.25$ (electrons). However, our data does not show that the edge collisionality is the critical parameter that governs access to ELM suppression. 3. The pedestal pressure must be kept sufficiently low to avoid destabilisation of small ELMs. This requirement implies a systematic reduction of pedestal pressure of typically 30\% compared to unmitigated ELMy H-mode in otherwise similar plasmas. 4. The edge safety factor $q_{95}$ lies within a certain window. Within the range probed so far, $q_{95}=3.5-4.2$, one such window, $q_{95}=3.57-3.95$ has been identified. Within the range of plasma rotation encountered so far, no apparent threshold of plasma rotation for ELM suppression is found. This includes cases with large cross field electron flow in the entire pedestal region, for which two-fluid MHD models predict that the resistive plasma response to the applied MP is shielded.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2018; v1 submitted 3 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Field-line localized destabilization of ballooning modes in 3D tokamaks
Authors:
M. Willensdorfer,
T. B. Cote,
C. C. Hegna,
W. Suttrop,
H. Zohm,
M. Dunne,
E. Strumberger,
G. Birkenmeier,
S. S. Denk,
F. Mink,
B. Vanovac,
L. C. Luhmann,
the ASDEX Upgrade Team
Abstract:
Field-line localized ballooning modes have been observed at the edge of high confinement mode plasmas in ASDEX Upgrade with rotating 3D perturbations induced by an externally applied n = 2 error field and during a moderate level of edge localized mode-mitigation. The observed ballooning modes are localized to the field-lines which experience one of the two zero-crossings of the radial flux surface…
▽ More
Field-line localized ballooning modes have been observed at the edge of high confinement mode plasmas in ASDEX Upgrade with rotating 3D perturbations induced by an externally applied n = 2 error field and during a moderate level of edge localized mode-mitigation. The observed ballooning modes are localized to the field-lines which experience one of the two zero-crossings of the radial flux surface displacement during one rotation period. The localization of the ballooning modes agrees very well with the localization of the largest growth rates from infinite-n ideal ballooning stability calculations using a realistic 3D ideal magnetohydrodynamic equilibrium. This analysis predicts a lower stability with respect to the axisymmetric case. The primary mechanism for the local lower stability is the 3D distortion of the local magnetic shear.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Three dimensional boundary displacement due to stable ideal kink modes excited by external n=2 magnetic perturbations
Authors:
M. Willensdorfer,
E. Strumberger,
W. Suttrop,
M. Dunne,
R. Fischer,
G. Birkenmeier,
D. Brida,
M. Cavedon,
S. S. Denk,
V. Igochine,
L. Giannone,
A. Kirk,
J. Kirschner,
A. Medvedeva,
T. Odstrcil,
D. A. Ryan,
the ASDEX Upgrade Team,
the EUROfusion MST1 Team
Abstract:
In low-collisionality scenarios exhibiting mitigation of edge localized modes (ELMs), stable ideal kink modes at the edge are excited by externally applied magnetic perturbation (MP)-fields. In ASDEX Upgrade these modes can cause three-dimensional (3D) boundary displacements up to the centimeter range. These displacements have been measured using toroidally localized high resolution diagnostics an…
▽ More
In low-collisionality scenarios exhibiting mitigation of edge localized modes (ELMs), stable ideal kink modes at the edge are excited by externally applied magnetic perturbation (MP)-fields. In ASDEX Upgrade these modes can cause three-dimensional (3D) boundary displacements up to the centimeter range. These displacements have been measured using toroidally localized high resolution diagnostics and rigidly rotating n = 2 MP-fields with various applied poloidal mode spectra. These measurements are compared to non-linear 3D ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) equilibria calculated by VMEC. Comprehensive comparisons have been conducted, which consider for instance plasma movements due to the position control system, attenuation due to internal conductors and changes in the edge pressure profiles. VMEC accurately reproduces the amplitude of the displacement and its dependencies on the applied poloidal mode spectra. Quantitative agreement is found around the low field side (LFS) midplane. The response at the plasma top is qualitatively compared. The measured and predicted displacements at the plasma top maximize when the applied spectra is optimized for ELM-mitigation. The predictions from the vacuum modeling generally fails to describe the displacement at the LFS midplane as well as at the plasma top. When the applied mode spectra is set to maximize the displacement, VMEC and the measurements clearly surpass the predictions from the vacuum modeling by a factor of four. Minor disagreements between VMEC and the measurements are discussed. This study underlines the importance of the stable ideal kink modes at the edge for the 3D boundary displacement in scenarios relevant for ELM-mitigation.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2017; v1 submitted 10 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Plasma response measurements of external magnetic perturbations using electron cyclotron emission and comparisons to 3D ideal MHD equilibrium
Authors:
M. Willensdorfer,
S. S. Denk,
E. Strumberger,
W. Suttrop,
B. Vanovac,
D. Brida,
M. Cavedon,
I. Classen,
M. Dunne,
S. Fietz,
R. Fischer,
A. Kirk,
F. M. Laggner,
Y. Q. Liu,
T. Odstrcil,
D. A. Ryan,
E. Viezzer,
H. Zohm,
I. C. Luhmann
Abstract:
The plasma response from an external n = 2 magnetic perturbation field in ASDEX Upgrade has been measured using mainly electron cyclotron emission (ECE) diagnostics and a rigid rotating field. To interpret ECE and ECE-imaging (ECE-I) measurements accurately, forward modeling of the radiation transport has been combined with ray tracing. The measured data is compared to synthetic ECE data generated…
▽ More
The plasma response from an external n = 2 magnetic perturbation field in ASDEX Upgrade has been measured using mainly electron cyclotron emission (ECE) diagnostics and a rigid rotating field. To interpret ECE and ECE-imaging (ECE-I) measurements accurately, forward modeling of the radiation transport has been combined with ray tracing. The measured data is compared to synthetic ECE data generated from a 3D ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) equilibrium calculated by VMEC. The measured amplitudes of the helical displacement around the low field side midplane are in reasonable agreement with the one from the synthetic VMEC diagnostics. Both exceed the prediction from the vacuum field calculations and indicate the presence of a kink response at the edge, which amplifies the perturbation. VMEC and MARS-F have been used to calculate the properties of this kink mode. The poloidal mode structure of the magnetic perturbation of this kink mode at the edge peaks at poloidal mode numbers larger than the resonant components |m| > |nq|, whereas the poloidal mode structure of its displacement is almost resonant |m| ~ |nq|. This is expected from ideal MHD in the proximity of rational surfaces. The displacement measured by ECE-I confirms this resonant response.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2016; v1 submitted 30 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Non-linear modeling of the plasma response to RMPs in ASDEX Upgrade
Authors:
F. Orain,
M. Hoelzl,
E. Viezzer,
M. Dunne,
M. Becoulet,
P. Cahyna,
G. T. A. Huijsmans,
J. Morales,
M. Willensdorfer,
W. Suttrop,
A. Kirk,
S. Pamela,
E. Strumberger,
S. Guenter,
A. Lessig,
the ASDEX Upgrade Team,
the EUROfusion MST1 Team
Abstract:
The plasma response to Resonant Magnetic Perturbations (RMPs) in ASDEX Upgrade is modeled with the non-linear resistive MHD code JOREK, using input profiles that match those of the experiments as closely as possible. The RMP configuration for which Edge Localized Modes are best mitigated in experiments is related to the largest edge kink response observed near the X-point in modeling. On the edge…
▽ More
The plasma response to Resonant Magnetic Perturbations (RMPs) in ASDEX Upgrade is modeled with the non-linear resistive MHD code JOREK, using input profiles that match those of the experiments as closely as possible. The RMP configuration for which Edge Localized Modes are best mitigated in experiments is related to the largest edge kink response observed near the X-point in modeling. On the edge resonant surfaces $q = m/n$, the coupling between the m + 2 kink component and the m resonant component is found to induce the amplification of the resonant magnetic perturbation. The ergodicity and the 3D-displacement near the X-point induced by the resonant amplification can only partly explain the density pumpout observed in experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Effect of resonant magnetic perturbations on low collisionality discharges in MAST and a comparison with ASDEX Upgrade
Authors:
A. Kirk,
W. Suttrop,
Yueqiang Liu,
I. T. Chapman,
P. Cahyna,
T. Eich,
C. Fuchs,
C. Ham,
J. R. Harrison,
M W. Jakubowski,
S. Pamela,
M. Peterka,
D. Ryan,
S. Saarelma,
R. Scannell,
A. J. Thornton,
M. Valovic,
B. Sieglin,
L. Barrera Orte,
M. Willensdorfer,
B. Kurzan,
R. Fischer
Abstract:
Sustained ELM mitigation has been achieved on MAST and AUG using RMPs with a range of toroidal mode numbers over a wide region of low to medium collisionality discharges. The ELM energy loss and peak heat loads at the divertor targets have been reduced. The ELM mitigation phase is typically associated with a drop in plasma density and overall stored energy. In one particular scenario on MAST, by c…
▽ More
Sustained ELM mitigation has been achieved on MAST and AUG using RMPs with a range of toroidal mode numbers over a wide region of low to medium collisionality discharges. The ELM energy loss and peak heat loads at the divertor targets have been reduced. The ELM mitigation phase is typically associated with a drop in plasma density and overall stored energy. In one particular scenario on MAST, by carefully adjusting the fuelling it has been possible to counteract the drop in density and to produce plasmas with mitigated ELMs, reduced peak divertor heat flux and with minimal degradation in pedestal height and confined energy. While the applied resonant magnetic perturbation field can be a good indicator for the onset of ELM mitigation on MAST and AUG there are some cases where this is not the case and which clearly emphasise the need to take into account the plasma response to the applied perturbations. The plasma response calculations show that the increase in ELM frequency is correlated with the size of the edge peeling-tearing like response of the plasma and the distortions of the plasma boundary in the X-point region.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
