-
Unconditionally stable symplectic integrators for the Navier-Stokes equations and other dissipative systems
Authors:
Sutthikiat Sungkeetanon,
Joseph S. Gaglione,
Robert L. Chapman,
Tyler M. Kelly,
Howard A. Cushman,
Blakeley H. Odom,
Bryan MacGavin,
Gafar A. Elamin,
Nathan J. Washuta,
Jonathan E. Crosmer,
Adam C. DeVoria,
John W. Sanders
Abstract:
Symplectic integrators offer vastly superior performance over traditional numerical techniques for conservative dynamical systems, but their application to \emph{dissipative} systems is inherently difficult due to dissipative systems' lack of symplectic structure. Leveraging the intrinsic variational structure of higher-order dynamics, this paper presents a general technique for applying existing…
▽ More
Symplectic integrators offer vastly superior performance over traditional numerical techniques for conservative dynamical systems, but their application to \emph{dissipative} systems is inherently difficult due to dissipative systems' lack of symplectic structure. Leveraging the intrinsic variational structure of higher-order dynamics, this paper presents a general technique for applying existing symplectic integration schemes to dissipative systems, with particular emphasis on viscous fluids modeled by the Navier-Stokes equations. Two very simple such schemes are developed here. Not only are these schemes unconditionally stable for dissipative systems, they also outperform traditional methods with a similar degree of complexity in terms of accuracy for a given time step. For example, in the case of viscous flow between two infinite, flat plates, one of the schemes developed here is found to outperform both the implicit Euler method and the explicit fourth-order Runge-Kutta method in predicting the velocity profile. To the authors' knowledge, this is the very first time that a symplectic integration scheme has been applied successfully to the Navier-Stokes equations. We interpret the present success as direct empirical validation of the canonical Hamiltonian formulation of the Navier-Stokes problem recently published by Sanders~\emph{et al.} More sophisticated symplectic integration schemes are expected to exhibit even greater performance. It is hoped that these results will lead to improved numerical methods in computational fluid dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
A canonical Hamiltonian formulation of the Navier-Stokes problem
Authors:
John W. Sanders,
Adam C. DeVoria,
Nathan J. Washuta,
Gafar A. Elamin,
Kevin L. Skenes,
Joel C. Berlinghieri
Abstract:
This paper presents a novel Hamiltonian formulation of the isotropic Navier-Stokes problem based on a minimum-action principle derived from the principle of least squares. This formulation uses the velocities $u_{i}(x_{j},t)$ and pressure $p(x_{j},t)$ as the field quantities to be varied, along with canonically conjugate momenta deduced from the analysis. From these, a conserved Hamiltonian functi…
▽ More
This paper presents a novel Hamiltonian formulation of the isotropic Navier-Stokes problem based on a minimum-action principle derived from the principle of least squares. This formulation uses the velocities $u_{i}(x_{j},t)$ and pressure $p(x_{j},t)$ as the field quantities to be varied, along with canonically conjugate momenta deduced from the analysis. From these, a conserved Hamiltonian functional $H^{*}$ satisfying Hamilton's canonical equations is constructed, and the associated Hamilton-Jacobi equation is formulated for both compressible and incompressible flows. This Hamilton-Jacobi equation reduces the problem of finding four separate field quantities ($u_{i}$,$p$) to that of finding a single scalar functional in those fields--Hamilton's principal functional $\text{S}^{*}[t,u_{i},p]$. Moreover, the transformation theory of Hamilton and Jacobi now provides a prescribed recipe for solving the Navier-Stokes problem: Find $\text{S}^{*}$. If an analytical expression for $\text{S}^{*}$ can be obtained, it will lead via canonical transformation to a new set of fields which are simply equal to their initial values, giving analytical expressions for the original velocity and pressure fields. Failing that, if one can only show that a complete solution to this Hamilton-Jacobi equation does or does not exist, that will also resolve the question of existence of solutions. The method employed here is not specific to the Navier-Stokes problem or even to classical mechanics, and can be applied to any traditionally non-Hamiltonian problem.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2024; v1 submitted 30 June, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Air Entrainment and Surface Fluctuations in a Turbulent Ship Hull Boundary Layer
Authors:
Naeem Masnadi,
Martin A. Erinin,
Nathan Washuta,
Farshad Nasiri,
Elias Balaras,
James H. Duncan
Abstract:
The air entrainment due to the turbulence in a free surface boundary layer shear flow created by a horizontally moving vertical surface-piercing wall is studied through experiments and direct numerical simulations. In the experiments, a laboratory-scale device was built that utilizes a surface-piercing stainless steel belt that travels in a loop around two vertical rollers, with one length of the…
▽ More
The air entrainment due to the turbulence in a free surface boundary layer shear flow created by a horizontally moving vertical surface-piercing wall is studied through experiments and direct numerical simulations. In the experiments, a laboratory-scale device was built that utilizes a surface-piercing stainless steel belt that travels in a loop around two vertical rollers, with one length of the belt between the rollers acting as a horizontally-moving flat wall. To complement the experiments, Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) of the two-phase boundary layer problem were carried out with the domain including a streamwise belt section simulated with periodic boundary conditions. Cinematic Laser-Induced Fluorescence (LIF) measurements of water surface profiles in two vertical planes oriented parallel to the belt surface (wall-parallel profiles) are presented and compared to previous measurements of profiles in a vertical plane oriented normal to the belt surface (wall-normal profiles). Additionally, photographic observations of air entrainment and measurements of air bubble size distributions and motions are reported herein. The bubble entrainment mechanisms are studied in detail through the results obtained by the DNS simulations. Free surface features resembling breaking waves and traveling parallel to the belt are observed in the wall-parallel LIF movies. These breaking events are thought to be one of the mechanisms by which the air is entrained into the underlying flow. The bubble size distribution is found to have a characteristic break in slope, similar to the Hinze scale previously observed in breaking waves. Finally, several entrainment mechanisms are found in the simulations and their prevalence in the free surface boundary layer is assessed.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Near-Surface Boundary Layer Turbulence Along a Horizontally-Moving, Surface-Piercing Vertical Wall
Authors:
Nathan Washuta,
Naeem Masnadi,
James H. Duncan
Abstract:
The complex interaction between turbulence and the free surface in boundary layer shear flow created by a vertical surface-piercing wall is considered. A laboratory-scale device was built that utilizes a surface-piercing stainless steel belt that travels in a loop around two vertical rollers, with one length of the belt between the rollers acting as a horizontally-moving flat wall. The belt is acc…
▽ More
The complex interaction between turbulence and the free surface in boundary layer shear flow created by a vertical surface-piercing wall is considered. A laboratory-scale device was built that utilizes a surface-piercing stainless steel belt that travels in a loop around two vertical rollers, with one length of the belt between the rollers acting as a horizontally-moving flat wall. The belt is accelerated suddenly from rest until reaching constant speed in order to create a temporally-evolving boundary layer analogous to the spatially-evolving boundary layer that would exist along a surface-piercing towed flat plate. Surface profiles are measured with a cinematic laser-induced fluorescence system and sub-surface velocity fields are recorded using a high-speed planar particle image velocimetry system. It is found that the belt initially travels through the water without creating any significant waves, before the free surface bursts with activity close to the belt surface. These free surface ripples travel away from the belt before appearing to become freely-propagating waves. From sub-surface velocity measurements, it is found that close to the surface, transition to turbulence happens sooner than far from the surface, leading to an overall thicker boundary layer in the vicinity of the free surface. A secondary peak in streamwise velocity fluctuations accompanies this transition to turbulence and this peak reaches a maximum value a short time later before smoothing outward. Using momentum thickness as a length scale and the streamwise velocity fluctuations at the location of this outer peak as a velocity scale, free surface bursting and air entrainment onset are found to depend in some way on Weber number and agreement is found with scaling arguments for air entrainment presented by Brocchini and Pregrine (J. Fluid Mech., 499, 225-254, 2001).
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2017; v1 submitted 16 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
The Turbulent Boundary Layer on a Horizontally Moving, Partially Submerged, Surface-Piercing Vertical Wall
Authors:
Nathan Washuta,
Naeem Masnadi,
James H. Duncan
Abstract:
The complex interactions between turbulence and the free surface, including air entrainment processes, in boundary layer shear flows created by vertical surface-piercing plates are considered. A laboratory-scale device was built that utilizes a surface-piercing stainless steel belt that travels in a loop around two vertical rollers, with one length of the belt between the rollers acting as a horiz…
▽ More
The complex interactions between turbulence and the free surface, including air entrainment processes, in boundary layer shear flows created by vertical surface-piercing plates are considered. A laboratory-scale device was built that utilizes a surface-piercing stainless steel belt that travels in a loop around two vertical rollers, with one length of the belt between the rollers acting as a horizontally-moving flat wall. The belt is operated both as a suddenly-started plate to reproduce boundary layer flow or at steady state in the presence of a stationary flat plate positioned parallel to the belt to create a Couette flow with a free surface. Surface profiles are measured with a cinematic laser-induced fluorescence system in both experiments and air entrainment events and bubble motions are observed with stereo underwater white-light movies in the suddenly started belt experiment. It is found that the RMS surface height fluctuations, $η$, peak near the boundaries of the flows and increase approximately linearly with belt speed. In the Couette flow experiments, a dominant peak in the spectrum of $\partialη/\partial t$ is found at the dimensionless frequency $fH/U\approx 0.7$. In the suddenly started belt experiment, surface fluctuations appear to be strongly influenced by sub-surface turbulence within the boundary layer, while ripples propagate freely when farther from the belt. Additionally, some mechanisms for air entrainment are observed and comparisons are made to predictions of incipient entrainment conditions in Brocchini and Pregrine (J. Fluid Mech., 499, 225-254, 2001).
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
