-
Geometric sensitivity of modal parameters in wind instrument models: a case study on Saxophone intonation
Authors:
Nathan Szwarcberg,
Tom Colinot,
Christophe Vergez,
Michaël Jousserand
Abstract:
The Transfer Matrix Method is a practical approach for modeling plane wave propagation in one-dimensional waveguides. Its simplicity makes it especially attractive for accounting for viscothermal losses, enabling realistic simulations of complex waveguides such as wind instruments. Another strength of this method lies in its fully analytical formulation of wave propagation. Modal parameters natura…
▽ More
The Transfer Matrix Method is a practical approach for modeling plane wave propagation in one-dimensional waveguides. Its simplicity makes it especially attractive for accounting for viscothermal losses, enabling realistic simulations of complex waveguides such as wind instruments. Another strength of this method lies in its fully analytical formulation of wave propagation. Modal parameters naturally arise as by-products of the model, obtained by numerically solving analytical expressions. In this work, the analytical potential of the method is extended by deriving the sensitivity of modal parameters to changes in the geometry of the resonator. These analytical gradients are applied in the context of wind instrument design. A simplified model of a soprano saxophone is used to investigate how octave harmonicity can be optimized through small geometric adjustments. The proposed approach enables predictive adjustments of geometry and offers valuable insight for both sound synthesis and instrument making.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2025; v1 submitted 19 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Register jumps on the clarinet: numerical and in-vitro investigation into basins of attraction and phase-tipping
Authors:
Nathan Szwarcberg,
Tom Colinot,
Christophe Vergez,
Michael Jousserand,
Léonie Maignan,
Hrant Arzumanyan,
Giordano Gatti,
Anthia Patsinakidou,
Pedro Faria Oliveira Morais
Abstract:
When playing the clarinet, opening the register hole allows for a transition from the first to the second register, producing a twelfth interval. On an artificial player system, the blowing pressure range where the second register remains stable can be determined by gradually varying the blowing pressure while keeping the register hole open. However, when the register hole is opened while the inst…
▽ More
When playing the clarinet, opening the register hole allows for a transition from the first to the second register, producing a twelfth interval. On an artificial player system, the blowing pressure range where the second register remains stable can be determined by gradually varying the blowing pressure while keeping the register hole open. However, when the register hole is opened while the instrument is already producing the first register, the range of blowing pressures that lead to a stable second register is narrower than the full stability zone of the second register. This phenomenon is investigated numerically by performing multiple hole openings at different times, for various values of the blowing pressure and the embouchure parameter. In some narrow regions of the control parameters space, the success of a register transition depends on the phase at which the hole is opened. This illustrates an instance of phase-tipping, where the limit cycle of the closed-hole regime may intersect multiple basins of attraction associated with the open-hole regimes. Furthermore, to assess the robustness of the basins of attraction, random noise is introduced to the control parameters before the register hole is opened. Results indicate that the equilibrium regime is more robust to noise than the other oscillating regimes. Finally, long-lasting transient quasiperiodics are investigated. The phase at which the hole is opened influences both the transient duration and the resulting stable regime.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Oscillation threshold of a Raman clarinet with localized nonlinear losses at the open end
Authors:
Nathan Szwarcberg,
Christophe Vergez,
Tom Colinot,
Michaël Jousserand
Abstract:
Localized nonlinear losses are taken into account in a simple Raman clarinet model.The complete system is expressed as an iterated map, enabling to study the stability of the different playing regimes. A parametric study is carried out with respect to three major parameters: blowing pressure, embouchure and nonlinear losses coefficient.The model exhibits the well-known effect of reducing the maxim…
▽ More
Localized nonlinear losses are taken into account in a simple Raman clarinet model.The complete system is expressed as an iterated map, enabling to study the stability of the different playing regimes. A parametric study is carried out with respect to three major parameters: blowing pressure, embouchure and nonlinear losses coefficient.The model exhibits the well-known effect of reducing the maximum blowing pressure until the oscillations stop (extinction threshold) when nonlinear losses increase.Furthermore, the stability analysis also shows that increasing nonlinear losses increases the minimal blowing pressure for which the oscillations start (oscillation threshold).
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2025; v1 submitted 27 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
The Laboratory of Mechanics and Acoustics in Marseilles (France): from the first world war to the present day
Authors:
Sabine Meunier,
Dominique Habault,
Emmanuel Friot,
Philippe Lasaygues,
Hervé Moulinec,
Christophe Vergez
Abstract:
The Laboratory of Mechanics and Acoustics in Marseilles (France) was created in 1941, under the name of Centre de Recherches Scientifiques, Industrielles et Maritimes (CRSIM). But it was actually issued from the French Naval Research Center created in Toulon by the French Navy to work on submarine detection during World War I. LMA is therefore the result of a long and quite amazing story with seve…
▽ More
The Laboratory of Mechanics and Acoustics in Marseilles (France) was created in 1941, under the name of Centre de Recherches Scientifiques, Industrielles et Maritimes (CRSIM). But it was actually issued from the French Naval Research Center created in Toulon by the French Navy to work on submarine detection during World War I. LMA is therefore the result of a long and quite amazing story with several moves and even more name changes. It benefited from all these events and is today established in a new campus with large facilities specially designed for its latest research activities. This article presents the story in some details, summarize the evolution of the research domains through all these years and finally gives a description of the LMA today.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
The nonlinear dynamics of a cantilever beam subject to axial flow in a tapered passage
Authors:
Filipe Soares,
José Antunes,
Christophe Vergez,
Vincent Debut,
Bruno Cochelin,
Fabrice Silva
Abstract:
A cantilever beam under axial flow, confined or not, is known to develop self-sustained oscillations at sufficiently large flow velocities. In recent decades, the analysis of this archetypal system has been mostly pursued under linearized conditions, to calculate the critical boundaries separating stable from unstable behavior. However, nonlinear analysis of the self-sustained oscillations ensuing…
▽ More
A cantilever beam under axial flow, confined or not, is known to develop self-sustained oscillations at sufficiently large flow velocities. In recent decades, the analysis of this archetypal system has been mostly pursued under linearized conditions, to calculate the critical boundaries separating stable from unstable behavior. However, nonlinear analysis of the self-sustained oscillations ensuing flutter instabilities are considerably rarer. Here we present a simplified one-dimensional nonlinear model describing a cantilever beam subjected to confined axial flow, for generic axial profiles of the fluid channels. In particular, we explore how the shape of the confinement walls affects the dynamics of the system. To simplify the problem, we consider symmetric channels with plane walls in either converging or diverging configurations. The beam is modeled in a modal framework, while bulk-flow equations, including singular head-loss terms, are used to model the flow-structure coupling forces. The dynamics of the system are first analyzed through linear stability analysis to assess the stabilizing/destabilizing effects of the channel walls configuration. Subsequently, we develop a systematic nonlinear analysis based on the continuation of periodic solutions. The harmonic balance method is used in conjunction with the asymptotic numerical method to calculate branches of periodic solutions. The continuation-based methods are used to investigate bifurcations with respect to both the reduced flow velocity and the channel slope parameter. From the results presented, we illustrate how continuationbased approaches and bifurcation analysis provide an efficient tool to analyze the nonlinear behavior of flow-induced vibration problems, particularly when reduced/simplified models are available.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Second register production on the clarinet: nonlinear losses in the register hole as the decisive physical phenomenon
Authors:
Nathan Szwarcberg,
Tom Colinot,
Christophe Vergez,
Michaël Jousserand
Abstract:
This study investigates the role of localized nonlinear losses in the register hole on the production of second-register notes. First, an experiment is conducted to study the ability of a register hole to produce second register. A cylindrical tube is drilled with holes of increasing diameter. Five are at the same level as the register hole of a B-flat clarinet, and five are at the same level as t…
▽ More
This study investigates the role of localized nonlinear losses in the register hole on the production of second-register notes. First, an experiment is conducted to study the ability of a register hole to produce second register. A cylindrical tube is drilled with holes of increasing diameter. Five are at the same level as the register hole of a B-flat clarinet, and five are at the same level as the thumb hole. Participant clarinetists are then asked to play with constant control parameters. At the beginning of each measurement, all holes are closed. The operator then opens randomly one of the ten holes.The resulting register is noted. The experiment is replicated numerically by time integration of two different models. The first is the state-of-the-art model based on the modal decomposition of the input impedance of the resonator. The second accounts for localized nonlinear losses in the register hole, through the model from Dalmont and Nederveen (2002). These losses are handled through a variable modal coefficients method. For the first model, simulations never produce second register, for any of the open holes. For the second, the proportion of second-register production is close to the experiment for upstream holes, but remains at zero for downstream holes.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Modal decomposition synthesis for localized nonlinear losses at termination of a woodwind model: influence on sound characteristics
Authors:
N Szwarcberg,
T Colinot,
C Vergez,
M Jousserand
Abstract:
A sound synthesis model for woodwind instruments is developed using modal decomposition of the input impedance, accounting for viscothermal losses as well as localized nonlinear losses at the end of the resonator. To extend the definition of the input impedance to the nonlinear domain, the method incorporates a dependence on the RMS acoustic velocity at a geometric discontinuity. The poles and res…
▽ More
A sound synthesis model for woodwind instruments is developed using modal decomposition of the input impedance, accounting for viscothermal losses as well as localized nonlinear losses at the end of the resonator. To extend the definition of the input impedance to the nonlinear domain, the method incorporates a dependence on the RMS acoustic velocity at a geometric discontinuity. The poles and residues resulting from the modal decomposition are then fitted with respect to this velocity. Thus, the pressure-flow relation defined by the resonator is completed by new equations which account for the dependence with the RMS velocity at the end of the tube. The ability of the model to reproduce the bifurcation diagram of a reed instrument was confirmed in a previous article from the authors [1]. The present work focuses on the influence of localized nonlinear losses on the acoustic pressure signal. Results are discussed with the observations of [2].
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Amplitude-dependent modal coefficients accounting for localized nonlinear losses in a time-domain integration of woodwind model
Authors:
Nathan Szwarcberg,
Tom Colinot,
Christophe Vergez,
Michaël Jousserand
Abstract:
This article develops the design of a sound synthesis model of a woodwind instrument by modal decomposition of the input impedance, taking into account viscothermal losses as well as localized nonlinear losses at the end of the resonator. This formalism has already been applied by Diab et al. (2022) to the study of forced systems. It is now implemented for self-oscillating systems. The employed me…
▽ More
This article develops the design of a sound synthesis model of a woodwind instrument by modal decomposition of the input impedance, taking into account viscothermal losses as well as localized nonlinear losses at the end of the resonator. This formalism has already been applied by Diab et al. (2022) to the study of forced systems. It is now implemented for self-oscillating systems. The employed method extends the denition of the input impedance to the nonlinear domain by adding a dependance on the RMS acoustic velocity at a geometric discontinuity. The poles and residuals resulting from the modal decomposition are interpolated as a function of this velocity. Thus, the pressure-ow relation dened by the resonator is completed by new equations which account for the dependence with the velocity at the end of the tube. To assess the ability of the model to reproduce a real phenomenon, comparisons with the experimental results of Atig et al. (2004) and Dalmont et al. (2007) were carried out. Simulations show that the model reproduces these experimental results qualitatively and quantitatively.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Diversity of ghost notes in tubas, euphoniums and saxhorns
Authors:
Rémi Mattéoli,
Joël Gilbert,
Soizic Terrien,
Jean-Pierre Dalmont,
Christophe Vergez,
Sylvain Maugeais,
Emmanuel Brasseur
Abstract:
The ghost note is a natural note which can be played exclusively on bass brass instruments with a predominantly-expanding bore profile such as tubas, euphoniums or saxhorns. It stands between the pedal note-the lowest natural note playable, or first regime-and the instrument's second regime. However, if the interval between the pedal note and the second regime remains close to an octave regardless…
▽ More
The ghost note is a natural note which can be played exclusively on bass brass instruments with a predominantly-expanding bore profile such as tubas, euphoniums or saxhorns. It stands between the pedal note-the lowest natural note playable, or first regime-and the instrument's second regime. However, if the interval between the pedal note and the second regime remains close to an octave regardless of the instrument, the interval between the pedal note and the ghost note vary from a minor third to a perfect fourth. References about this note are very scarce, and it is not commonly known among tuba players.This study shows that an elementary brass model describing the player coupled to the instrument is capable of bringing both the ghost and the pedal note to light. Here, we adopt a dynamical systems point of view and perform a bifurcation analysis using a software of numerical continuation. The numerical results provided in terms of frequency intervals between pedal note and ghost note are compared with frequency intervals experimentally inferred from recordings of seven different types of tuba, each of them being played by two professional tuba players.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2022; v1 submitted 12 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Minimal blowing pressure allowing periodic oscillations in a model of bass brass instruments
Authors:
Rémi Mattéoli,
Joël Gilbert,
Christophe Vergez,
Jean-Pierre Dalmont,
Sylvain Maugeais,
Soizic Terrien,
Frédéric Ablitzer
Abstract:
In this study, an acoustic resonator -- a bass brass instrument -- with multiple resonances coupled to an exciter -- the player's lips -- with one resonance is modelled by a multidimensional dynamical system, and studied using a continuation and bifurcation software. Bifurcation diagrams are explored with respect to the blowing pressure, in particular with focus on the minimal blowing pressure all…
▽ More
In this study, an acoustic resonator -- a bass brass instrument -- with multiple resonances coupled to an exciter -- the player's lips -- with one resonance is modelled by a multidimensional dynamical system, and studied using a continuation and bifurcation software. Bifurcation diagrams are explored with respect to the blowing pressure, in particular with focus on the minimal blowing pressure allowing stable periodic oscillations and the associated frequency.The behaviour of the instrument is first studied close to a (non oscillating) equilibrium using linear stability analysis. This allows to determine the conditions at which an equilibrium destabilises and as such where oscillating regimes can emerge (corresponding to a sound production). This approach is useful to characterise the ease of playing of a brass instrument, which is assumed here to be related -- as a first approximation -- to the linear threshold pressure. In particular, the lower the threshold pressure, the lower the physical effort the player has to make to play a note [Campbell et al., 2021].Cases are highlighted where periodic solutions in the bifurcation diagrams are reached for blowing pressures below the value given by the linear stability analysis. Thus, bifurcation diagrams allow a more in-depth analysis. Particular attention is devoted to the first playing regime of bass brass instruments (the pedal note and the ghost note of a tuba in particular), whose behaviour qualitatively differs from a trombone to a euphonium for instance.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2022; v1 submitted 16 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Effect of Changing the Vocal Tract Shape on the Sound Production of the Recorder: An Experimental and Theoretical Study
Authors:
R Auvray,
Augustin Ernoult,
S Terrien,
B Fabre,
C Vergez
Abstract:
Changing the vocal tract shape is one of the techniques which can be used by the players of wind instruments to modify the quality of the sound. It has been intensely studied in the case of reed instruments but has received only little attention in the case of air-jet instruments. This paper presents a first study focused on changes in the vocal tract shape in recorder playing techniques. Measurem…
▽ More
Changing the vocal tract shape is one of the techniques which can be used by the players of wind instruments to modify the quality of the sound. It has been intensely studied in the case of reed instruments but has received only little attention in the case of air-jet instruments. This paper presents a first study focused on changes in the vocal tract shape in recorder playing techniques. Measurements carried out with recorder players allow to identify techniques involving changes of the mouth shape as well as consequences on the sound. A second experiment performed in laboratory mimics the coupling with the vocal tract on an artificial mouth. The phase of the transfer function between the instrument and the mouth of the player is identified to be the relevant parameter of the coupling. It is shown to have consequences on the spectral content in terms of energy distribution among the even and odd harmonics, as well as on the stability of the first two oscillating regimes. The results gathered from the two experiments allow to develop a simplified model of sound production including the effect of changing the vocal tract shape. It is based on the modification of the jet instabilities due to the pulsating emerging jet. Two kinds of instabilities, symmetric and anti-symmetric, with respect to the stream axis, are controlled by the coupling with the vocal tract and the acoustic oscillation within the pipe, respectively. The symmetry properties of the flow are mapped on the temporal formulation of the source term, predicting a change in the even / odd harmonics energy distribution. The predictions are in qualitative agreement with the experimental observations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Time-domain numerical modeling of brass instruments including nonlinear wave propagation, viscothermal losses, and lips vibration
Authors:
Harold Berjamin,
Bruno Lombard,
Christophe Vergez,
Emmanuel Cottanceau
Abstract:
A time-domain numerical modeling of brass instruments is proposed. On one hand, outgoing and incoming waves in the resonator are described by the Menguy-Gilbert model, which incorporates three key issues: nonlinear wave propagation, viscothermal losses, and a variable section. The non-linear propagation is simulated by a TVD scheme well-suited to non-smooth waves. The fractional derivatives induce…
▽ More
A time-domain numerical modeling of brass instruments is proposed. On one hand, outgoing and incoming waves in the resonator are described by the Menguy-Gilbert model, which incorporates three key issues: nonlinear wave propagation, viscothermal losses, and a variable section. The non-linear propagation is simulated by a TVD scheme well-suited to non-smooth waves. The fractional derivatives induced by the viscothermal losses are replaced by a set of local-in-time memory variables. A splitting strategy is followed to couple optimally these dedicated methods. On the other hand, the exciter is described by a one-mass model for the lips. The Newmark method is used to integrate the nonlinear ordinary differential equation so-obtained. At each time step, a coupling is performed between the pressure in the tube and the displacement of the lips. Finally, an extensive set of validation tests is successfully completed. In particular, self-sustained oscillations of the lips are simulated by taking into account the nonlinear wave propagation in the tube. Simulations clearly indicate that the nonlinear wave propagation has a major influence on the timbre of the sound, as expected. Moreover, simulations also highlight an influence on playing frequencies, time envelopes and on the playability of the low frequencies in the case of a variable lips tension.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Analytical Determination of the Attack Transient in a Clarinet With Time-Varying Blowing Pressure
Authors:
A. Almeida,
Baptiste Bergeot,
C Vergez,
B. Gazengel
Abstract:
This article uses a basic model of a reed instrument , known as the lossless Raman model, to determine analytically the envelope of the sound produced by the clarinet when the mouth pressure is increased gradually to start a note from silence. Using results from dynamic bifur-cation theory, a prediction of the amplitude of the sound as a function of time is given based on a few parameters quantify…
▽ More
This article uses a basic model of a reed instrument , known as the lossless Raman model, to determine analytically the envelope of the sound produced by the clarinet when the mouth pressure is increased gradually to start a note from silence. Using results from dynamic bifur-cation theory, a prediction of the amplitude of the sound as a function of time is given based on a few parameters quantifying the time evolution of mouth pressure. As in previous uses of this model, the predictions are expected to be qualitatively consistent with simulations using the Raman model, and observations of real instruments. Model simulations for slowly variable parameters require very high precisions of computation. Similarly, any real system, even if close to the model would be affected by noise. In order to describe the influence of noise, a modified model is developed that includes a stochastic variation of the parameters. Both ideal and stochastic models are shown to attain a minimal amplitude at the static oscillation threshold. Beyond this point, the amplitude of the oscillations increases exponentially, although some time is required before the oscillations can be observed at the '' dynamic oscillation threshold ''. The effect of a sudden interruption of the growth of the mouth pressure is also studied, showing that it usually triggers a faster growth of the oscillations.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Prediction of the dynamic oscillation threshold of a clarinet model: Comparison between analytical predictions and simulation results
Authors:
Baptiste Bergeot,
André Almeida,
Christophe Vergez,
Bruno Gazengel
Abstract:
Simple models of clarinet instruments based on iterated maps have been used in the past to successfully estimate the threshold of oscillation of this instrument as a function of a constant blowing pressure. However, when the blowing pressure gradually increases through time, the oscillations appear at a much higher value than what is predicted in the static case. This is known as bifurcation delay…
▽ More
Simple models of clarinet instruments based on iterated maps have been used in the past to successfully estimate the threshold of oscillation of this instrument as a function of a constant blowing pressure. However, when the blowing pressure gradually increases through time, the oscillations appear at a much higher value than what is predicted in the static case. This is known as bifurcation delay, a phenomenon studied in [1] for a clarinet model. In numerical simulations the bifurcation delay showed a strong sensitivity to numerical precision.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Effect of the shape of mouth pressure variation on dynamic oscillation threshold of a clarinet model
Authors:
Baptiste Bergeot,
André Almeida,
Christophe Vergez
Abstract:
Simple models of clarinet instruments based on iterated maps have been used in the past to successfully estimate the threshold of oscillation of this instrument as a function of a constant blowing pressure. However, when the blowing pressure gradually increases through time, the oscillations appear at a much higher value, called dynamic oscillation threshold, than what is predicted in the static c…
▽ More
Simple models of clarinet instruments based on iterated maps have been used in the past to successfully estimate the threshold of oscillation of this instrument as a function of a constant blowing pressure. However, when the blowing pressure gradually increases through time, the oscillations appear at a much higher value, called dynamic oscillation threshold, than what is predicted in the static case. This is known as bifurcation delay, a phenomenon studied in [1,2] for a clarinet model. In particular the dynamic oscillation threshold is predicted analytically when the blowing pressure is linearly increased. However, the mouth pressure cannot grow indefinitely. During a note attack, after an increasing phase, the musician stabilizes the mouth pressure. In the present work, the analytical prediction of the dynamic oscillation threshold is extended to a situations in which the mouth pressure approaches a steady state pressure according to an exponential time profile. The predictions still show a good agreement with simulation of the simple clarinet-model. This situation is compared in terms of dynamic oscillation bifurcation.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Regime change thresholds in flute-like instruments: influence of the mouth pressure dynamics
Authors:
Soizic Terrien,
Rémi Blandin,
Christophe Vergez,
Benoît Fabre
Abstract:
Since they correspond to a jump from a given note to another one, the mouth pressure thresholds leading to regime changes are particularly important quantities in flute-like instruments. In this paper, a comparison of such thresholds between an artificial mouth, an experienced flutist and a non player is provided. It highlights the ability of the experienced player to considerabily shift regime ch…
▽ More
Since they correspond to a jump from a given note to another one, the mouth pressure thresholds leading to regime changes are particularly important quantities in flute-like instruments. In this paper, a comparison of such thresholds between an artificial mouth, an experienced flutist and a non player is provided. It highlights the ability of the experienced player to considerabily shift regime change thresholds, and thus to enlarge its control in terms of nuances and spectrum. Based on recent works on other wind instruments and on the theory of dynamic bifurcations, the hypothe- sis is tested experimentally and numerically that the dynamics of the blowing pressure influences regime change thresholds. The results highlight the strong influence of this parameter on thresholds, suggesting its wide use by experienced musicians. Starting from these observations and from an analysis of a physical model of flute-like instruments, involving numerical continuation methods and Floquet stability analysis, a phenomenological modelling of regime change is proposed and validated. It allows to predict the regime change thresholds in the dynamic case, in which time variations of the blowing pressure are taken into account.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Is the jet-drive flute model able to produce modulated sounds like Flautas de Chinos ?
Authors:
Soizic Terrien,
Christophe Vergez,
Patricio De La Cuadra,
Benoît Fabre
Abstract:
Flautas de chinos - prehispanic chilean flutes played during ritual celebrations in central Chile - are known to produce very particular beating sounds, the so-called sonido rajado. Some previous works have focused on the spectral analysis of these sounds, and on the input impedance of the complex resonator. However, the beating sounds origin remains to be investigated. Throughout this paper, a co…
▽ More
Flautas de chinos - prehispanic chilean flutes played during ritual celebrations in central Chile - are known to produce very particular beating sounds, the so-called sonido rajado. Some previous works have focused on the spectral analysis of these sounds, and on the input impedance of the complex resonator. However, the beating sounds origin remains to be investigated. Throughout this paper, a comparison is provided between the characteristics of both the sound produced by flautas de chinos and a synthesis sound obtained through time-domain simulation of the jet-drive model for flute-like instruments. Jet-drive model appears to be able to produce quasiperiodic sounds similar to sonido rajado. Finally, the analysis of the system dynamics through numerical continuation methods allows to explore the production mechanism of these quasiperiodic regimes.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Explicit Mapping of Acoustic Regimes For Wind Instruments
Authors:
Samy Missoum,
Christophe Vergez,
Jean-Baptiste Doc
Abstract:
This paper proposes a methodology to map the various acoustic regimes of wind instruments. The maps can be generated in a multi-dimensional space consisting of design, control parameters, and initial conditions. The bound- aries of the maps are obtained explicitly in terms of the parameters using a support vector machine (SVM) classifier as well as a dedicated adaptive sam- pling scheme. The appro…
▽ More
This paper proposes a methodology to map the various acoustic regimes of wind instruments. The maps can be generated in a multi-dimensional space consisting of design, control parameters, and initial conditions. The bound- aries of the maps are obtained explicitly in terms of the parameters using a support vector machine (SVM) classifier as well as a dedicated adaptive sam- pling scheme. The approach is demonstrated on a simplified clarinet model for which several maps are generated based on different criteria. Examples of computation of the probability of occurrence of a specific acoustic regime are also provided. In addition, the approach is demonstrated on a design optimization example for optimal intonation.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Response of an artificially blown clarinet to different blowing pressure profiles
Authors:
Baptiste Bergeot,
André Almeida,
Christophe Vergez,
Bruno Gazengel,
Ferrand Didier
Abstract:
Using an artificial mouth with an accurate pressure control, the onset of the pressure oscillations inside the mouthpiece of a simplified clarinet is studied experimentally. Two time profiles are used for the blowing pressure: in a first set of experiments the pressure is increased at constant rates, then decreased at the same rate. In a second set of experiments the pressure rises at a constant r…
▽ More
Using an artificial mouth with an accurate pressure control, the onset of the pressure oscillations inside the mouthpiece of a simplified clarinet is studied experimentally. Two time profiles are used for the blowing pressure: in a first set of experiments the pressure is increased at constant rates, then decreased at the same rate. In a second set of experiments the pressure rises at a constant rate and is then kept constant for an arbitrary period of time. In both cases the experiments are repeated for different increase rates. Numerical simulations using a simplified clarinet model blown with a constantly increasing mouth pressure are compared to the oscillating pressure obtained inside the mouthpiece. Both show that the beginning of the oscillations appears at a higher pressure values than the theoretical static threshold pressure, a manifestation of bifurcation delay. Experiments performed using an interrupted increase in mouth pressure show that the beginning of the oscillation occurs close to the stop in the increase of the pressure. Experimental results also highlight that the speed of the onset transient of the sound is roughly the same, independently of the duration of the increase phase of the blowing pressure.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Prediction of the dynamic oscillation threshold in a clarinet model with a linearly increasing blowing pressure : influence of noise
Authors:
Baptiste Bergeot,
André Almeida,
Christophe Vergez,
Bruno Gazengel
Abstract:
This paper presents an analysis of the effects of noise and precision on a simplified model of the clarinet driven by a variable control parameter. When the control parameter is varied the clarinet model undergoes a dynamic bifurcation. A consequence of this is the phenomenon of bifurcation delay: the bifurcation point is shifted from the static oscillation threshold to an higher value called dyna…
▽ More
This paper presents an analysis of the effects of noise and precision on a simplified model of the clarinet driven by a variable control parameter. When the control parameter is varied the clarinet model undergoes a dynamic bifurcation. A consequence of this is the phenomenon of bifurcation delay: the bifurcation point is shifted from the static oscillation threshold to an higher value called dynamic oscillation threshold. In a previous work [8], the dynamic oscillation threshold is obtained analytically. In the present article, the sensitivity of the dynamic threshold on precision is analyzed as a stochastic variable introduced in the model. A new theoretical expression is given for the dynamic thresholds in presence of the stochastic variable, providing a fair prediction of the thresholds found in finite-precision simulations. These dynamic thresholds are found to depend on the increase rate and are independent on the initial value of the parameter, both in simulations and in theory.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2013; v1 submitted 8 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
A high-order, purely frequency based harmonic balance formulation for continuation of periodic solutions: The case of non-polynomial nonlinearities
Authors:
Sami Karkar,
Bruno Cochelin,
Christophe Vergez
Abstract:
In this paper, we extend the method proposed by Cochelin and Vergez [A high order purely frequency-based harmonic balance formulation for continuation of periodic solutions, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 324 (2009) 243-262] to the case of non-polynomial nonlinearities. This extension allows for the computation of branches of periodic solutions of a broader class of nonlinear dynamical systems. T…
▽ More
In this paper, we extend the method proposed by Cochelin and Vergez [A high order purely frequency-based harmonic balance formulation for continuation of periodic solutions, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 324 (2009) 243-262] to the case of non-polynomial nonlinearities. This extension allows for the computation of branches of periodic solutions of a broader class of nonlinear dynamical systems. The principle remains to transform the original ODE system into an extended polynomial quadratic system for an easy application of the harmonic balance method (HBM). The transformation of non-polynomial terms is based on the differentiation of state variables with respect to the time variable, shifting the nonlinear non-polynomial nonlinearity to a time-independent initial condition equation, not concerned with the HBM. The continuation of the resulting algebraic system is here performed by the asymptotic numerical method (high order Taylor series representation of the solution branch) using a further differentiation of the non-polynomial algebraic equation with respect to the path parameter. A one dof vibro-impact system is used to illustrate how an exponential nonlinearity is handled, showing that the method works at very high order, 1000 in that case. Various kinds of nonlinear functions are also treated, and finally the nonlinear free pendulum is addressed, showing that very accurate periodic solutions can be computed with the proposed method.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
The logical clarinet: numerical optimization of the geometry of woodwind instruments
Authors:
Daniel Noreland,
Jean Kergomard,
Franck Laloë,
Christophe Vergez,
Philippe Guillemain,
Alexis Guilloteau
Abstract:
The tone hole geometry of a clarinet is optimized numerically. The instrument is modeled as a network of one dimensional transmission line elements. For each (non-fork) fingering, we first calculate the resonance frequencies of the input impedance peaks, and compare them with the frequencies of a mathematically even chromatic scale (equal temperament). A least square algorithm is then used to mini…
▽ More
The tone hole geometry of a clarinet is optimized numerically. The instrument is modeled as a network of one dimensional transmission line elements. For each (non-fork) fingering, we first calculate the resonance frequencies of the input impedance peaks, and compare them with the frequencies of a mathematically even chromatic scale (equal temperament). A least square algorithm is then used to minimize the differences and to derive the geometry of the instrument. Various situations are studied, with and without dedicated register hole and/or enlargement of the bore. With a dedicated register hole, the differences can remain less than 10 musical cents throughout the whole usual range of a clarinet. The positions, diameters and lengths of the chimneys vary regularly over the whole length of the instrument, in contrast with usual clarinets. Nevertheless, we recover one usual feature of instruments, namely that gradually larger tone holes occur when the distance to the reed increases. A fully chromatic prototype instrument has been built to check these calculations, and tested experimentally with an artificial blowing machine, providing good agreement with the numerical predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2013; v1 submitted 17 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Flute-like musical instruments: a toy model investigated through numerical continuation
Authors:
Soizic Terrien,
Christophe Vergez,
Benoît Fabre
Abstract:
Self-sustained musical instruments (bowed string, woodwind and brass instruments) can be modeled by nonlinear lumped dynamical systems. Among these instruments, flutes and flue organ pipes present the particularity to be modeled as a delay dynamical system. In this paper, such a system, a toy model of flute-like instruments, is studied using numerical continuation. Equilibrium and periodic solutio…
▽ More
Self-sustained musical instruments (bowed string, woodwind and brass instruments) can be modeled by nonlinear lumped dynamical systems. Among these instruments, flutes and flue organ pipes present the particularity to be modeled as a delay dynamical system. In this paper, such a system, a toy model of flute-like instruments, is studied using numerical continuation. Equilibrium and periodic solutions are explored with respect to the blowing pressure, with focus on amplitude and frequency evolutions along the different solution branches, as well as "jumps" between periodic solution branches. The influence of a second model parameter (namely the inharmonicity) on the behaviour of the system is addressed. It is shown that harmonicity plays a key role in the presence of hysteresis or quasi-periodic regime. Throughout the paper, experimental results on a real instrument are presented to illustrate various phenomena, and allow some qualitative comparisons with numerical results.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2013; v1 submitted 30 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Prediction of the dynamic oscillation threshold in a clarinet model with a linearly increasing blowing pressure
Authors:
Baptiste Bergeot,
André Almeida,
Christophe Vergez,
Bruno Gazengel
Abstract:
Reed instruments are modeled as self-sustained oscillators driven by the pressure inside the mouth of the musician. A set of nonlinear equations connects the control parameters (mouth pressure, lip force) to the system output, hereby considered as the mouthpiece pressure. Clarinets can then be studied as dynamical systems, their steady behavior being dictated uniquely by the values of the control…
▽ More
Reed instruments are modeled as self-sustained oscillators driven by the pressure inside the mouth of the musician. A set of nonlinear equations connects the control parameters (mouth pressure, lip force) to the system output, hereby considered as the mouthpiece pressure. Clarinets can then be studied as dynamical systems, their steady behavior being dictated uniquely by the values of the control parameters. Considering the resonator as a lossless straight cylinder is a dramatic yet common simplification that allows for simulations using nonlinear iterative maps. In this paper, we investigate analytically the effect of a time-varying blowing pressure on the behavior of this simplified clarinet model. When the control parameter varies, results from the so-called dynamic bifurcation theory are required to properly analyze the system. This study highlights the phenomenon of bifurcation delay and defines a new quantity, the dynamic oscillation threshold. A theoretical estimation of the dynamic oscillation threshold is proposed and compared with numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2013; v1 submitted 19 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Oscillation threshold of a clarinet model: a numerical continuation approach
Authors:
Sami Karkar,
Christophe Vergez,
Bruno Cochelin
Abstract:
This paper focuses on the oscillation threshold of single reed instruments. Several characteristics such as blowing pressure at threshold, regime selection, and playing frequency are known to change radically when taking into account the reed dynamics and the flow induced by the reed motion. Previous works have shown interesting tendencies, using analytical expressions with simplified models. In t…
▽ More
This paper focuses on the oscillation threshold of single reed instruments. Several characteristics such as blowing pressure at threshold, regime selection, and playing frequency are known to change radically when taking into account the reed dynamics and the flow induced by the reed motion. Previous works have shown interesting tendencies, using analytical expressions with simplified models. In the present study, a more elaborated physical model is considered. The influence of several parameters, depending on the reed properties, the design of the instrument or the control operated by the player, are studied. Previous results on the influence of the reed resonance frequency are confirmed. New results concerning the simultaneous influence of two model parameters on oscillation threshold, regime selection and playing frequency are presented and discussed. The authors use a numerical continuation approach. Numerical continuation consists in following a given solution of a set of equations when a parameter varies. Considering the instrument as a dynamical system, the oscillation threshold problem is formulated as a path following of Hopf bifurcations, generalizing the usual approach of the characteristic equation, as used in previous works. The proposed numerical approach proves to be useful for the study of musical instruments. It is complementary to analytical analysis and direct time-domain or frequency-domain simulations since it allows to derive information that is hardly reachable through simulation, without the approximations needed for analytical approach.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Nonlinear modes of clarinet-like musical instruments
Authors:
Daniel Noreland,
Sergio Bellizzi,
Christophe Vergez,
Robert Bouc
Abstract:
The concept of nonlinear modes is applied in order to analyze the behavior of a model of woodwind reed instruments. Using a modal expansion of the impedance of the instrument, and by projecting the equation for the acoustic pressure on the normal modes of the air column, a system of second order ordinary differential equations is obtained. The equations are coupled through the nonlinear relation…
▽ More
The concept of nonlinear modes is applied in order to analyze the behavior of a model of woodwind reed instruments. Using a modal expansion of the impedance of the instrument, and by projecting the equation for the acoustic pressure on the normal modes of the air column, a system of second order ordinary differential equations is obtained. The equations are coupled through the nonlinear relation describing the volume flow of air through the reed channel in response to the pressure difference across the reed. The system is treated using an amplitude-phase formulation for nonlinear modes, where the frequency and damping functions, as well as the invariant manifolds in the phase space, are unknowns to be determined. The formulation gives, without explicit integration of the underlying ordinary differential equation, access to the transient, the limit cycle, its period and stability. The process is illustrated for a model reduced to three normal modes of the air column.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Visualization and analysis of jet oscillation under transverse acoustic perturbation
Authors:
Patricio De La Cuadra,
Christophe Vergez,
Benoit Fabre
Abstract:
Schlieren flow visualizations of transverse oscillations of jets submitted to an acoustic perturbation are analyzed in this paper. The aim is to estimate the shape and the position of the median line of the jet. Two methods for image processing are proposed, based on complementary approaches : inter image and intra image analysis. Synthesized images of an oscillating jet are used to validate eac…
▽ More
Schlieren flow visualizations of transverse oscillations of jets submitted to an acoustic perturbation are analyzed in this paper. The aim is to estimate the shape and the position of the median line of the jet. Two methods for image processing are proposed, based on complementary approaches : inter image and intra image analysis. Synthesized images of an oscillating jet are used to validate each method and compare their performances in the case of noisy pictures. Illustrations are then shown on real laminar and turbulent jets. The results obtained using both methods are very close, showing their reliability. Applications investigated in this paper are focused on the estimation of the convection velocity of perturbations along the jet, and the influence of the Reynolds number and of the channel geometry upstream the jet formation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
Interaction of reed and acoustic resonator in clarinetlike systems
Authors:
Fabrice Silva,
Jean Kergomard,
Christophe Vergez,
Joël Gilbert
Abstract:
Sound emergence in clarinetlike instruments is investigated in terms of instability of the static regime. Various models of reed-bore coupling are considered, from the pioneering work of Wilson and Beavers ["Operating modes of the clarinet", J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 56, 653--658 (1974)] to more recent modeling including viscothermal bore losses and vena contracta at the reed inlet. The pressure thres…
▽ More
Sound emergence in clarinetlike instruments is investigated in terms of instability of the static regime. Various models of reed-bore coupling are considered, from the pioneering work of Wilson and Beavers ["Operating modes of the clarinet", J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 56, 653--658 (1974)] to more recent modeling including viscothermal bore losses and vena contracta at the reed inlet. The pressure threshold above which these models may oscillate as well as the frequency of oscillation at threshold are calculated. In addition to Wilson and Beavers' previous conclusions concerning the role of the reed damping in the selection of the register the instrument will play on, the influence of the reed motion induced flow is also emphasized, particularly its effect on playing frequencies, contributing to reduce discrepancies between Wilson and Beavers' experimental results and theory, despite discrepancies still remain concerning the pressure threshold. Finally, analytical approximations of the oscillating solution based on Fourier series expansion are obtained in the vicinity of the threshold of oscillation. This allows to emphasize the conditions which determine the nature of the bifurcation (direct or inverse) through which the note may emerge, with therefore important consequences on the musical playing performances.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
A high order purely frequency-based harmonic balance formulation for continuation of periodic solutions
Authors:
Bruno Cochelin,
Christophe Vergez
Abstract:
Combinig the harmonic balance method (HBM) and a continuation method is a well-known technique to follow the periodic solutions of dynamical systems when a control parameter is varied. However, since deriving the algebraic system containing the Fourier coefficients can be a highly cumbersome procedure, the classical HBM is often limited to polynomial (quadratic and cubic) nonlinearities and/or a…
▽ More
Combinig the harmonic balance method (HBM) and a continuation method is a well-known technique to follow the periodic solutions of dynamical systems when a control parameter is varied. However, since deriving the algebraic system containing the Fourier coefficients can be a highly cumbersome procedure, the classical HBM is often limited to polynomial (quadratic and cubic) nonlinearities and/or a few harmonics. Several variations on the classical HBM, such as the incremental HBM or the alternating frequency/time domain HBM, have been presented in the literature to overcome this shortcoming. Here, we present an alternative approach that can be applied to a very large class of dynamical systems (autonomous or forced) with smooth equations. The main idea is to systematically recast the dynamical system in quadratic polynomial form before applying the HBM. Once the equations have been rendered quadratic, it becomes obvious to derive the algebraic system and solve it by the so-called ANM continuation technique. Several classical examples are presented to illustrate the use of this numerical approach.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2009; v1 submitted 28 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Oscillation thresholds for "strinking outwards" reeds coupled to a resonator
Authors:
Fabrice Silva,
Jean Kergomard,
Christophe Vergez
Abstract:
This paper considers a "striking outwards" reed coupled to a resonator. This expression, due to Helmholtz, is not discussed here : it corresponds to the most common model of a lip-type valve, when the valve is assumed to be a one degree of freedom oscillator. The presented work is an extension of the works done by Wilson and Beavers (1974), Tarnopolsky (2000). The range of the playing frequencie…
▽ More
This paper considers a "striking outwards" reed coupled to a resonator. This expression, due to Helmholtz, is not discussed here : it corresponds to the most common model of a lip-type valve, when the valve is assumed to be a one degree of freedom oscillator. The presented work is an extension of the works done by Wilson and Beavers (1974), Tarnopolsky (2000). The range of the playing frequencies is investigated. The first results are analytical : when no losses are present in the resonator, it is proven that the ratio between the threshold frequency and the reed resonance frequency is found to be necessarily within the interval between unity and the square root of 3. This is a musical sixth. Actually the interval is largely smaller, and this is in accordance with e.g. the results by Cullen et al.. The smallest blowing pressure is found to be directly related to the quality factor of the reed. Numerical results confirm these statements, and are discussed in comparison with previous ones by Cullen et al (2000).
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
Simulation of Single Reed Instruments Oscillations Based on Modal Decomposition of Bore and Reed Dynamics
Authors:
Fabrice Silva,
Vincent Debut,
Jean Kergomard,
Christophe Vergez,
Aude Deblevid,
Philippe Guillemain
Abstract:
This paper investigates the sound production in a system made of a bore coupled with a reed valve. Extending previous work (Debut, 2004), the input impedance of the bore is projected on the modes of the air column. The acoustic pressure is therefore calculated as the sum of modal components. The airrrflow blown into the bore is modulated by reed motion, assuming the reed to be a singl…
▽ More
This paper investigates the sound production in a system made of a bore coupled with a reed valve. Extending previous work (Debut, 2004), the input impedance of the bore is projected on the modes of the air column. The acoustic pressure is therefore calculated as the sum of modal components. The airrrflow blown into the bore is modulated by reed motion, assuming the reed to be a single degree of freedom oscillator. Calculation of self-sustained oscillations controlled by time-varying mouth pressure and player's embouchure parameter is performed using ODE solvers. Results emphasize the par ticipation of the whole set of components in the mode locking process. Another impor tant feature is the mutual innnfluence of reed and bore resonance during growing blowing pressure transients, oscillation threshold being altered by the reed natural frequency and the reed damping. Steady-state oscillations are also investigated and compared with results given by harmonic balance method and by digital sound synthesis.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
Quasi-static non-linear characteristics of double-reed instruments
Authors:
Andre Almeida,
Christophe Vergez,
René Caussé
Abstract:
This article proposes a characterisation of the double-reed in quasi-static regimes. The non-linear relation between the pressure drop $Δp$ in the double-reed and the volume flow crossing it $q$ is measured for slow variations of these variables. The volume flow is determined from the pressure drop in a diaphragm replacing the instrument's bore. Measurements are compared to other experimental re…
▽ More
This article proposes a characterisation of the double-reed in quasi-static regimes. The non-linear relation between the pressure drop $Δp$ in the double-reed and the volume flow crossing it $q$ is measured for slow variations of these variables. The volume flow is determined from the pressure drop in a diaphragm replacing the instrument's bore. Measurements are compared to other experimental results on reed instrument exciters and to physical models, revealing that clarinet, oboe and bassoon quasi-static behavior relies on similar working principles. Differences in the experimental results are interpreted in terms of pressure recovery due to the conical diffuser role of the downstream part of double-reed mouthpieces (the staple).
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Contribution to harmonic balance calculations of periodic oscillation for self-sustained musical instruments with focus on single-reed instruments
Authors:
Snorre Farner,
Christophe Vergez,
Jean Kergomard,
Aude Lizée
Abstract:
The harmonic balance method (HBM) was originally developed for finding periodic solutions of electronical and mechanical systems under a periodic force, but has later been adapted to self-sustained musical instruments. Unlike time-domain methods, this frequency-domain method does not capture transients and so is not adapted for sound synthesis. However, its independence of time makes it very use…
▽ More
The harmonic balance method (HBM) was originally developed for finding periodic solutions of electronical and mechanical systems under a periodic force, but has later been adapted to self-sustained musical instruments. Unlike time-domain methods, this frequency-domain method does not capture transients and so is not adapted for sound synthesis. However, its independence of time makes it very useful for studying every periodic solution of the model, whether stable or unstable without care of initial conditions. A computer program for solving general problems involving nonlinearly coupled exciter and resonator, Harmbal, has been developed based on the HBM. The method as well as convergence improvements and continuations facilities are thorougly presented and discussed in the present paper. Application of the method is demonstrated on various problems related to a common model of the clarinet: a reed modelled as a simple spring with and without mass and damping, a nonlinear coupling and a cubic simplification of it, and a cylindrical bore with or without dissipation and dispersion as well as a bore formed as a stepped cone.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
