-
Rapidly Rotating Wall-Mode Convection
Authors:
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Keaton J. Burns,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Keith Julien
Abstract:
In the rapidly rotating limit, we derive a balanced set of reduced equations governing the strongly nonlinear development of the convective wall-mode instability in the interior of a general container. The model illustrates that wall-mode convection is a multiscale phenomenon where the dynamics of the bulk interior diagnostically determine the small-scale dynamics within Stewartson boundary layers…
▽ More
In the rapidly rotating limit, we derive a balanced set of reduced equations governing the strongly nonlinear development of the convective wall-mode instability in the interior of a general container. The model illustrates that wall-mode convection is a multiscale phenomenon where the dynamics of the bulk interior diagnostically determine the small-scale dynamics within Stewartson boundary layers at the sidewalls. The sidewall boundary layers feedback on the interior via a nonlinear lateral heat-flux boundary condition, providing a closed system. Outside the asymptotically thin boundary layer, the convective modes connect to a dynamical interior that maintains scales set by the domain geometry. In many ways, the final system of equations resembles boundary-forced planetary geostrophic baroclinic dynamics coupled with barotropic quasi-geostrophic vorticity. The reduced system contains the results from previous linear instability theory but captured in an elementary fashion, providing a new avenue for investigating wall-mode convection in the strongly nonlinear regime. We also derive the dominant Ekman-flux correction to the onset Rayleigh number for large Taylor number, $\textit{Ra} \approx 31.8 \,\textit{Ta}^{1/2} - 4.43 \,\textit{Ta}^{5/12} + \mathcal{O}(\textit{Ta}^{1/3})$ for no-slip boundaries. However, we find that the linear onset in a finite cylinder differs noticeably compared to a Cartesian channel. We demonstrate some of the reduced model's nonlinear dynamics with numerical simulations in a cylindrical container.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2025; v1 submitted 30 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
The solar dynamo begins near the surface
Authors:
Geoffrey M Vasil,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Kyle Augustson,
Keaton J Burns,
Jeffrey S Oishi,
Benjamin P Brown,
Nicholas Brummell,
Keith Julien
Abstract:
The Sun's magnetic dynamo cycle features a distinct pattern: a propagating region of sunspot emergence appears around 30 degrees latitude and vanishes near the equator every 11 years. Moreover, longitudinal flows called "torsional oscillations" closely shadow sunspot migration, undoubtedly sharing a common cause. Contrary to theories suggesting deep origins for these phenomena, helioseismology pin…
▽ More
The Sun's magnetic dynamo cycle features a distinct pattern: a propagating region of sunspot emergence appears around 30 degrees latitude and vanishes near the equator every 11 years. Moreover, longitudinal flows called "torsional oscillations" closely shadow sunspot migration, undoubtedly sharing a common cause. Contrary to theories suggesting deep origins for these phenomena, helioseismology pinpoints low-latitude torsional oscillations to the Sun's outer 5-10%, the "Near-Surface Shear Layer". Within this zone, inwardly increasing differential rotation coupled with a poloidal magnetic field strongly implicates the Magneto-Rotational Instability prominent in accretion-disk theory and observed in laboratory experiments. Together, these two facts prompt the general question: Is it possible that the solar dynamo is a near-surface instability? Here, we report strong affirmative evidence in stark contrast to traditional paradigms focusing on the deeper tachocline. Simple analytic estimates show that the near-surface magneto-rotational instability better explains the spatiotemporal scales of the torsional oscillations and inferred subsurface magnetic field amplitudes. State-of-the-art numerical simulations corroborate these estimates and, strikingly, reproduce hemispherical magnetic current helicity laws. The dynamo resulting from a well-understood near-surface phenomenon improves prospects for accurate predictions of full magnetic cycles and space weather, impacting Earth's electromagnetic infrastructure.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2024; v1 submitted 11 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Iterative Methods for Navier--Stokes Inverse Problems
Authors:
Liam O'Connor,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Evan H. Anders,
Kyle C. Augustson,
Keaton J. Burns,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Benjamin P. Brown
Abstract:
Even when the partial differential equation underlying a physical process can be evolved forward in time, the retrospective (backward in time) inverse problem often has its own challenges and applications. Direct Adjoint Looping (DAL) is the defacto approach for solving retrospective inverse problems, but it has not been applied to deterministic retrospective Navier--Stokes inverse problems in 2D…
▽ More
Even when the partial differential equation underlying a physical process can be evolved forward in time, the retrospective (backward in time) inverse problem often has its own challenges and applications. Direct Adjoint Looping (DAL) is the defacto approach for solving retrospective inverse problems, but it has not been applied to deterministic retrospective Navier--Stokes inverse problems in 2D or 3D. In this paper, we demonstrate that DAL is ill-suited for solving retrospective 2D Navier--Stokes inverse problems. Alongside DAL, we study two other iterative methods: Simple Backward Integration (SBI) and the Quasi-Reversible Method (QRM). Our iterative SBI approach is novel while iterative QRM has previously been used. Using these three iterative methods, we solve two retrospective inverse problems: 1D Korteweg--de Vries--Burgers (decaying nonlinear wave) and 2D Navier--Stokes (unstratified Kelvin--Helmholtz vortex). In both cases, SBI and QRM reproduce the target final states more accurately and in fewer iterations than DAL. We attribute this performance gap to additional terms present in SBI and QRM's respective backward integrations which are absent in DAL.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
The photometric variability of massive stars due to gravity waves excited by core convection
Authors:
Evan H. Anders,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Matteo Cantiello,
Keaton J. Burns,
Benjamin A. Hyatt,
Emma Kaufman,
Richard H. D. Townsend,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Adam S. Jermyn
Abstract:
Massive stars die in catastrophic explosions, which seed the interstellar medium with heavy elements and produce neutron stars and black holes. Predictions of the explosion's character and the remnant mass depend on models of the star's evolutionary history. Models of massive star interiors can be empirically constrained by asteroseismic observations of gravity wave oscillations. Recent photometri…
▽ More
Massive stars die in catastrophic explosions, which seed the interstellar medium with heavy elements and produce neutron stars and black holes. Predictions of the explosion's character and the remnant mass depend on models of the star's evolutionary history. Models of massive star interiors can be empirically constrained by asteroseismic observations of gravity wave oscillations. Recent photometric observations reveal a ubiquitous red noise signal on massive main sequence stars; a hypothesized source of this noise is gravity waves driven by core convection. We present the first 3D simulations of massive star convection extending from the star's center to near its surface, with realistic stellar luminosities. Using these simulations, we make the first prediction of photometric variability due to convectively-driven gravity waves at the surfaces of massive stars, and find that gravity waves produce photometric variability of a lower amplitude and lower characteristic frequency than the observed red noise. We infer that the photometric signal of gravity waves excited by core convection is below the noise limit of current observations, so the red noise must be generated by an alternative process.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Orthogonal signed-distance coordinates and vector calculus near evolving curves and surfaces
Authors:
Eric W. Hester,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
We provide an elementary derivation of an orthogonal coordinate system for boundary layers around evolving smooth surfaces and curves based on the signed-distance function. We go beyond previous works on the signed-distance function and collate useful vector calculus identities for these coordinates. These results and provided code enable consistent accounting of geometric effects in the derivatio…
▽ More
We provide an elementary derivation of an orthogonal coordinate system for boundary layers around evolving smooth surfaces and curves based on the signed-distance function. We go beyond previous works on the signed-distance function and collate useful vector calculus identities for these coordinates. These results and provided code enable consistent accounting of geometric effects in the derivation of boundary layer asymptotics for a wide range of physical systems.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2023; v1 submitted 6 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Corner cases of the tau method: symmetrically imposing boundary conditions on hypercubes
Authors:
Keaton J. Burns,
Daniel Fortunato,
Keith Julien,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
Polynomial spectral methods produce fast, accurate, and flexible solvers for broad ranges of PDEs with one bounded dimension, where the incorporation of general boundary conditions is well understood. However, automating extensions to domains with multiple bounded dimensions is challenging because of difficulties in imposing boundary conditions at shared edges and corners. Past work has included v…
▽ More
Polynomial spectral methods produce fast, accurate, and flexible solvers for broad ranges of PDEs with one bounded dimension, where the incorporation of general boundary conditions is well understood. However, automating extensions to domains with multiple bounded dimensions is challenging because of difficulties in imposing boundary conditions at shared edges and corners. Past work has included various workarounds, such as the anisotropic inclusion of partial boundary data at shared edges or approaches that only work for specific boundary conditions. Here we present a general system for imposing boundary conditions for elliptic equations on hypercubes. We take an approach based on the generalized tau method, which allows for a wide range of boundary conditions for many different spectral schemes. The generalized tau method has the distinct advantage that the specified polynomial residual determines the exact algebraic solution; afterwards, any stable numerical scheme will find the same result. We can, therefore, provide one-to-one comparisons to traditional collocation and Galerkin methods within the tau framework. As an essential requirement, we add specific tau corrections to the boundary conditions, in addition to the bulk PDE, which produce a unique set of compatible boundary data at shared subsurfaces. Our approach works with general boundary conditions that commute on intersecting subsurfaces, including Dirichlet, Neumann, Robin, and any combination of these on all boundaries. The boundary tau corrections can be made hyperoctahedrally symmetric and easily incorporated into existing solvers. We present the method explicitly for the Poisson equation in two and three dimensions and describe its extension to arbitrary elliptic equations (e.g. biharmonic) in any dimension.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2024; v1 submitted 30 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
A mushy source for the geysers of Enceladus
Authors:
Colin R. Meyer,
Jacob J. Buffo,
Francis Nimmo,
Andrew J. Wells,
Samuel Boury,
Tara C. Tomlinson,
Jamie R. G. Parkinson,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
Enceladus is a primary target for astrobiology due to the $\rm H_2O$ plume ejecta measured by the Cassini spacecraft and the inferred subsurface ocean sustained by tidal heating. Sourcing the plumes via a direct connection from the ocean to the surface requires a fracture through the entire ice shell ($\sim$10 km). Here we explore an alternative mechanism in which shear heating within shallower ti…
▽ More
Enceladus is a primary target for astrobiology due to the $\rm H_2O$ plume ejecta measured by the Cassini spacecraft and the inferred subsurface ocean sustained by tidal heating. Sourcing the plumes via a direct connection from the ocean to the surface requires a fracture through the entire ice shell ($\sim$10 km). Here we explore an alternative mechanism in which shear heating within shallower tiger stripe fractures produces partial melting in the ice shell and interstitial convection allows fluid to be ejected as geysers. We use an idealized two-dimensional multiphase reactive transport model to simulate the thermomechanics of a mushy region generated by an upper bound estimate for the localized shear heating rate in a salty ice shell. From our simulations, we predict the temperature, porosity, salt content, melting rate, and liquid volume of an intrashell mushy zone surrounding a fracture. We find that the rate of internal melting can match the observed $\rm H_2O$ eruption rate and that there is sufficient brine volume within the mushy zone to sustain the geysers for $\sim350$ kyr without additional melting. The composition of the liquid brine is, however, distinct from that of the ocean, due to partial melting. This shear heating mechanism for geyser formation applies to Enceladus and other icy moons and has implications for our understanding of the geophysical processes and astrobiological potential of icy satellites.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2023; v1 submitted 13 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
On the stability of isothermal shocks in black hole accretion disks
Authors:
Eric W. Hester,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Martin Wechselberger
Abstract:
Most black holes possess accretion disks. Models of such disks inform observations and constrain the properties of the black holes and their surrounding medium. Here, we study isothermal shocks in a thin black hole accretion flow. Modelling infinitesimal molecular viscosity allows the use of multiple-scales matched asymptotic methods. We thus derive the first explicit calculations of isothermal sh…
▽ More
Most black holes possess accretion disks. Models of such disks inform observations and constrain the properties of the black holes and their surrounding medium. Here, we study isothermal shocks in a thin black hole accretion flow. Modelling infinitesimal molecular viscosity allows the use of multiple-scales matched asymptotic methods. We thus derive the first explicit calculations of isothermal shock stability. We find that the inner shock is always unstable, and the outer shock is always stable. The growth/decay rates of perturbations depend only on an effective potential and the incoming--outgoing flow difference at the shock location. We give a prescription of accretion regimes in terms of angular momentum and black hole radius. Accounting for angular momentum dissipation implies unstable outer shocks in much of parameter space, even for realistic viscous Reynolds numbers of the order $\approx 10^{20}$.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Convection in a mushy-layer along a heated wall
Authors:
Samuel Boury,
Colin R. Meyer,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Andrew J. Wells
Abstract:
Motivated by the mushy zones of sea ice, volcanoes, and icy moons of the outer solar system, we perform a theoretical and numerical study of boundary-layer convection along a vertical heated wall in a bounded ideal mushy region. The mush is comprised of a porous and reactive binary alloy with a mixture of saline liquid in a solid matrix, and is studied in the near-eutectic approximation. Here we d…
▽ More
Motivated by the mushy zones of sea ice, volcanoes, and icy moons of the outer solar system, we perform a theoretical and numerical study of boundary-layer convection along a vertical heated wall in a bounded ideal mushy region. The mush is comprised of a porous and reactive binary alloy with a mixture of saline liquid in a solid matrix, and is studied in the near-eutectic approximation. Here we demonstrate the existence of four regions and study their behavior asymptotically. Starting from the bottom of the wall, the four regions are (i) an isotropic corner region; (ii) a buoyancy dominated vertical boundary layer; (iii) an isotropic connection region; and (iv) a horizontal boundary layer at the top boundary with strong gradients of pressure and buoyancy. Scalings from numerical simulations are consistent with the theoretical predictions. Close to the heated wall, the convection in the mushy layer is similar to a rising buoyant plume abruptly stopped at the top, leading to increased pressure and temperature in the upper region, whose impact is discussed as an efficient melting mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
The rotational influence on solar convection
Authors:
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Keith Julien,
Nicholas A. Featherstone
Abstract:
This paper considers the dominant dynamical, thermal and rotational balances within the solar convection zone. The reasoning is such that: Coriolis forces balance pressure gradients. Background vortex stretching, baroclinic torques and nonlinear advection balance jointly. Turbulent fluxes convey what part of the solar luminosity that radiative diffusion cannot. These four relations determine estim…
▽ More
This paper considers the dominant dynamical, thermal and rotational balances within the solar convection zone. The reasoning is such that: Coriolis forces balance pressure gradients. Background vortex stretching, baroclinic torques and nonlinear advection balance jointly. Turbulent fluxes convey what part of the solar luminosity that radiative diffusion cannot. These four relations determine estimates for the dominant length scales and dynamical amplitudes strictly in terms of known physical quantities. We predict that the dynamical Rossby number for convection is less than unity below the near-surface shear layer, indicating strong rotational constraint. We also predict a characteristic convection length scale of roughly 30 Mm throughout much of the convection zone. These inferences help explain recent observations that reveal weak flow amplitudes at 100-200 Mm scales.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Single-hemisphere dynamos in M-dwarf stars
Authors:
Benjamin P. Brown,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Keaton J. Burns
Abstract:
M-dwarf stars below a certain mass are convective from their cores to their photospheres. These fully convective objects are extremely numerous, very magnetically active, and the likely hosts of many exoplanets. Here we study, for the first time, dynamo action in simulations of stratified, rotating fully convective M-dwarf stars. Importantly, we use new techniques to capture the correct full ball…
▽ More
M-dwarf stars below a certain mass are convective from their cores to their photospheres. These fully convective objects are extremely numerous, very magnetically active, and the likely hosts of many exoplanets. Here we study, for the first time, dynamo action in simulations of stratified, rotating fully convective M-dwarf stars. Importantly, we use new techniques to capture the correct full ball geometry down to the center of the star. We find surprising dynamo states in these systems, with the global-scale mean fields confined strongly to a single hemisphere, in contrast to prior stellar dynamo solutions. These hemispheric-dynamo stars are likely to have profoundly different interactions with their surroundings, with important implications for exoplanet habitability and stellar spindown.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Improved phase-field models of melting and dissolution in multi-component flows
Authors:
Eric W. Hester,
Louis-Alexandre Couston,
Benjamin Favier,
Keaton J. Burns,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
We develop and analyse the first second-order phase-field model to combine melting and dissolution in multi-component flows. This provides a simple and accurate way to simulate challenging phase-change problems in existing codes. Phase-field models simplify computation by describing separate regions using a smoothed phase field. The phase field eliminates the need for complicated discretisations t…
▽ More
We develop and analyse the first second-order phase-field model to combine melting and dissolution in multi-component flows. This provides a simple and accurate way to simulate challenging phase-change problems in existing codes. Phase-field models simplify computation by describing separate regions using a smoothed phase field. The phase field eliminates the need for complicated discretisations that track the moving phase boundary. However standard phase-field models are only first-order accurate. They often incur an error proportional to the thickness of the diffuse interface. We eliminate this dominant error by developing a general framework for asymptotic analysis of diffuse-interface methods in arbitrary geometries. With this framework we can consistently unify previous second-order phase-field models of melting and dissolution and the volume-penalty method for fluid-solid interaction. We finally validate second-order convergence of our model in two comprehensive benchmark problems using the open-source spectral code Dedalus.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Convective dynamics with mixed temperature boundary conditions: why thermal relaxation matters and how to accelerate it
Authors:
Evan H. Anders,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Lydia Korre
Abstract:
Astrophysical simulations of convection frequently impose different thermal boundary conditions at the top and the bottom of the domain in an effort to more accurately model natural systems. In this work, we study Rayleigh-Benard convection (RBC) under the Boussinesq approximation. We examine simulations with mixed temperature boundary conditions in which the flux is fixed at the bottom boundary a…
▽ More
Astrophysical simulations of convection frequently impose different thermal boundary conditions at the top and the bottom of the domain in an effort to more accurately model natural systems. In this work, we study Rayleigh-Benard convection (RBC) under the Boussinesq approximation. We examine simulations with mixed temperature boundary conditions in which the flux is fixed at the bottom boundary and the temperature is fixed at the top ("FT"). We aim to understand how FT boundaries change the nature of the convective solution compared to the traditional choice of thermal boundaries, in which the temperature is fixed at the top and bottom of the domain ("TT"). We demonstrate that the timescale of thermal relaxation for FT simulations is dependent upon the initial conditions. "Classic" initial conditions which employ a hydrostatically -- and thermally -- balanced linear temperature profile exhibit a long thermal relaxation. This long relaxation is not seen in FT simulations which use a TT simulation's nonlinear state as initial conditions ("TT-to-FT"). In the thermally relaxed, statistically stationary state, the mean behavior of an FT simulation corresponds to an equivalent simulation with TT boundaries, and time- and volume-averaged flow statistics like the Nusselt number and the Peclet number are indistinguishable between FT and TT simulations. FT boundaries are fundamentally asymmetric, and we examine the asymmetries that these boundaries produce in the flow. We find that the fixed-flux boundary produces more extreme temperature events than the fixed-temperature boundary. However, these near-boundary asymmetries do not measurably break the symmetry in the convective interior. We briefly explore rotating RBC to demonstrate that our findings with respect to thermal relaxation carry over to this more complex case, and to show the power of TT-to-FT initial conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2020; v1 submitted 28 February, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
The Magnetorotational Instability Prefers Three Dimensions
Authors:
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Morgan Baxter,
Andrew Swan,
Keaton J. Burns,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Benjamin P. Brown
Abstract:
The magnetorotational instability (MRI) occurs when a weak magnetic field destabilises a rotating, electrically conducting fluid with inwardly increasing angular velocity. The MRI is essential to astrophysical disk theory where the shear is typically Keplerian. Internal shear layers in stars may also be MRI unstable, and they take a wide range of profiles, including near-critical. We show that the…
▽ More
The magnetorotational instability (MRI) occurs when a weak magnetic field destabilises a rotating, electrically conducting fluid with inwardly increasing angular velocity. The MRI is essential to astrophysical disk theory where the shear is typically Keplerian. Internal shear layers in stars may also be MRI unstable, and they take a wide range of profiles, including near-critical. We show that the fastest growing modes of an ideal magnetofluid are three-dimensional provided the shear rate, $S$, is near the two-dimensional onset value, $S_c$. For a Keplerian shear, three-dimensional modes are unstable above $S\approx0.10S_c$, and dominate the two-dimensional modes until $S\approx2.05S_{c}$. These three-dimensional modes dominate for shear profiles relevant to stars and at magnetic Prandtl numbers relevant to liquid-metal laboratory experiments. Significant numbers of rapidly growing three-dimensional modes remain well past $2.05S_{c}$. These finding are significant in three ways. First, weakly nonlinear theory suggests that the MRI saturates by pushing the shear rate to its critical value. This can happen for systems, like stars and laboratory experiments, that can rearrange their angular velocity profiles. Second, the non-normal character and large transient growth of MRI modes should be important whenever three-dimensionality exists. Finally, three-dimensional growth suggests direct dynamo action driven from the linear instability.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Dedalus: A Flexible Framework for Numerical Simulations with Spectral Methods
Authors:
Keaton J. Burns,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Benjamin P. Brown
Abstract:
Numerical solutions of partial differential equations enable a broad range of scientific research. The Dedalus Project is a flexible, open-source, parallelized computational framework for solving general partial differential equations using spectral methods. Dedalus translates plain-text strings describing partial differential equations into efficient solvers. This paper details the numerical meth…
▽ More
Numerical solutions of partial differential equations enable a broad range of scientific research. The Dedalus Project is a flexible, open-source, parallelized computational framework for solving general partial differential equations using spectral methods. Dedalus translates plain-text strings describing partial differential equations into efficient solvers. This paper details the numerical method that enables this translation, describes the design and implementation of the codebase, and illustrates its capabilities with a variety of example problems. The numerical method is a first-order generalized tau formulation that discretizes equations into banded matrices. This method is implemented with an object-oriented design. Classes for spectral bases and domains manage the discretization and automatic parallel distribution of variables. Discretized fields and mathematical operators are symbolically manipulated with a basic computer algebra system. Initial value, boundary value, and eigenvalue problems are efficiently solved using high-performance linear algebra, transform, and parallel communication libraries. Custom analysis outputs can also be specified in plain text and stored in self-describing portable formats. The performance of the code is evaluated with a parallel scaling benchmark and a comparison to a finite-volume code. The features and flexibility of the codebase are illustrated by solving several examples: the nonlinear Schrodinger equation on a graph, a supersonic magnetohydrodynamic vortex, quasigeostrophic flow, Stokes flow in a cylindrical annulus, normal modes of a radiative atmosphere, and diamagnetic levitation. The Dedalus code and the example problems are available online at http://dedalus-project.org/.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2019; v1 submitted 24 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
The "Sphered Cube": A New Method for the Solution of Partial Differential Equations in Cubical Geometry
Authors:
Keaton J. Burns,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Benjamin P. Brown
Abstract:
A new gridding technique for the solution of partial differential equations in cubical geometry is presented. The method is based on volume penalization, allowing for the imposition of a cubical geometry inside of its circumscribing sphere. By choosing to embed the cube inside of the sphere, one obtains a discretization that is free of any sharp edges or corners. Taking full advantage of the simpl…
▽ More
A new gridding technique for the solution of partial differential equations in cubical geometry is presented. The method is based on volume penalization, allowing for the imposition of a cubical geometry inside of its circumscribing sphere. By choosing to embed the cube inside of the sphere, one obtains a discretization that is free of any sharp edges or corners. Taking full advantage of the simple geometry of the sphere, spectral bases based on spin-weighted spherical harmonics and Jacobi polynomials, which properly capture the regularity of scalar, vector and tensor components in spherical coordinates, can be applied to obtain moderately efficient and accurate numerical solutions of partial differential equations in the cube. This technique demonstrates the advantages of these bases over other methods for solving PDEs in spherical coordinates. We present results for a test case of incompressible hydrodynamics in cubical geometry: Rayleigh-Bénard convection with fully Dirichlet boundary conditions. Analysis of the simulations provides what is, to our knowledge, the first result on the scaling of the heat flux with the thermal forcing for this type of convection in a cube in a sphere.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Predicting the Rossby number in convective experiments
Authors:
Evan H. Anders,
Cathryn M. Manduca,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
The Rossby number is a crucial parameter describing the degree of rotational constraint on the convective dynamics in stars and planets. However, it is not an input to computational models of convection but must be measured ex post facto. Here, we report the discovery of a new quantity, the Predictive Rossby number, which is both tightly correlated with the Rossby number and specified in terms of…
▽ More
The Rossby number is a crucial parameter describing the degree of rotational constraint on the convective dynamics in stars and planets. However, it is not an input to computational models of convection but must be measured ex post facto. Here, we report the discovery of a new quantity, the Predictive Rossby number, which is both tightly correlated with the Rossby number and specified in terms of common inputs to numerical models. The Predictive Rossby number can be specified independent of Rayleigh number, allowing suites of numerical solutions to separate the degree of rotational constraint from the strength of the driving of convection. We examine the scaling of convective transport in terms of the Nusselt number and the degree of turbulence in terms of the Reynolds number of the flow, and we find scaling laws nearly identical to those in nonrotational convection at low Rossby number when the Predictive Rossby number is held constant. Finally, we describe the boundary layers as a function of increasing turbulence at constant Rossby number.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2019; v1 submitted 11 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Tensor calculus in spherical coordinates using Jacobi polynomials, Part-II: Implementation and Examples
Authors:
Daniel Lecoanet,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Keaton J. Burns,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Jeffrey S. Oishi
Abstract:
We present a simulation code which can solve broad ranges of partial differential equations in a full sphere. The code expands tensorial variables in a spectral series of spin-weighted spherical harmonics in the angular directions and a scaled Jacobi polynomial basis in the radial direction, as described in Part-I. Nonlinear terms are calculated by transforming from the coefficients in the spectra…
▽ More
We present a simulation code which can solve broad ranges of partial differential equations in a full sphere. The code expands tensorial variables in a spectral series of spin-weighted spherical harmonics in the angular directions and a scaled Jacobi polynomial basis in the radial direction, as described in Part-I. Nonlinear terms are calculated by transforming from the coefficients in the spectral series to the value of each quantity on the physical grid, where it is easy to calculate products and perform other local operations. The expansion makes it straightforward to solve equations in tensor form (i.e., without decomposition into scalars). We propose and study several unit tests which demonstrate the code can accurately solve linear problems, implement boundary conditions, and transform between spectral and physical space. We then run a series of benchmark problems proposed in Marti et al (2014), implementing the hydrodynamic and magnetohydrodynamic equations. We are able to calculate more accurate solutions than reported in Marti et al 2014 by running at higher spatial resolution and using a higher-order timestepping scheme. We find the rotating convection and convective dynamo benchmark problems depend sensitively on details of timestepping and data analysis. We also demonstrate that in low resolution simulations of the dynamo problem, small changes in a numerical scheme can lead to large changes in the solution. To aid future comparison to these benchmarks, we include the source code used to generate the data, as well as the data and analysis scripts used to generate the figures.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Perspectives on Reproducibility and Sustainability of Open-Source Scientific Software from Seven Years of the Dedalus Project
Authors:
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Keaton J. Burns,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
As the Science Mission Directorate contemplates establishing an open code policy, we consider it timely to share our experiences as the developers of the open-source partial differential equation solver Dedalus. Dedalus is a flexible framework for solving partial differential equations. Its development team primarily uses it for studying stellar and planetary astrophysics. Dedalus was developed or…
▽ More
As the Science Mission Directorate contemplates establishing an open code policy, we consider it timely to share our experiences as the developers of the open-source partial differential equation solver Dedalus. Dedalus is a flexible framework for solving partial differential equations. Its development team primarily uses it for studying stellar and planetary astrophysics. Dedalus was developed originally for astrophysical fluid dynamics (AFD), though it has found a much broader user base, including applied mathematicians, plasma physicists, and oceanographers. Here, we will focus on issues related to open-source software from the perspective of AFD. We use the term AFD with the understanding that astrophysics simulations are inherently multi-physics: fluid dynamics coupled with some combination of gravitational dynamics, radiation transfer, relativity, and magnetic fields. In practice, a few well-known open-source simulation packages represent a large fraction of published work in the field. However, we will argue that an open-code policy should encompass not just these large simulation codes, but also the input files and analysis scripts. It is our interest that NASA adopt an open-code policy because without it, reproducibility in computational science is needlessly hampered.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Anomalous chained turbulence in actively driven flows on spheres
Authors:
Oscar Mickelin,
Jonasz Słomka,
Keaton J. Burns,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Luiz M. Faria,
Jörn Dunkel
Abstract:
Recent experiments demonstrate the importance of substrate curvature for actively forced fluid dynamics. Yet, the covariant formulation and analysis of continuum models for non-equilibrium flows on curved surfaces still poses theoretical challenges. Here, we introduce and study a generalized covariant Navier-Stokes model for fluid flows driven by active stresses in non-planar geometries. The analy…
▽ More
Recent experiments demonstrate the importance of substrate curvature for actively forced fluid dynamics. Yet, the covariant formulation and analysis of continuum models for non-equilibrium flows on curved surfaces still poses theoretical challenges. Here, we introduce and study a generalized covariant Navier-Stokes model for fluid flows driven by active stresses in non-planar geometries. The analytical tractability of the theory is demonstrated through exact stationary solutions for the case of a spherical bubble geometry. Direct numerical simulations reveal a curvature-induced transition from a burst phase to an anomalous turbulent phase that differs distinctly from externally forced classical 2D Kolmogorov turbulence. This new type of active turbulence is characterized by the self-assembly of finite-size vortices into linked chains of anti-ferromagnetic order, which percolate through the entire fluid domain, forming an active dynamic network. The coherent motion of the vortex chain network provides an efficient mechanism for upward energy transfer from smaller to larger scales, presenting an alternative to the conventional energy cascade in classical 2D turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2017; v1 submitted 16 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Conversion of Internal Gravity Waves into Magnetic Waves
Authors:
Daniel Lecoanet,
Geoffrey M Vasil,
Jim Fuller,
Matteo Cantiello,
Keaton J Burns
Abstract:
Asteroseismology probes the interiors of stars by studying oscillation modes at a star's surface. Although pulsation spectra are well understood for solar-like oscillators, a substantial fraction of red giant stars observed by Kepler exhibit abnormally low-amplitude dipole oscillation modes. Fuller et al. (2015) suggests this effect is produced by strong core magnetic fields that scatter dipole in…
▽ More
Asteroseismology probes the interiors of stars by studying oscillation modes at a star's surface. Although pulsation spectra are well understood for solar-like oscillators, a substantial fraction of red giant stars observed by Kepler exhibit abnormally low-amplitude dipole oscillation modes. Fuller et al. (2015) suggests this effect is produced by strong core magnetic fields that scatter dipole internal gravity waves (IGWs) into higher multipole IGWs or magnetic waves. In this paper, we study the interaction of IGWs with a magnetic field to test this mechanism. We consider two background stellar structures: one with a uniform magnetic field, and another with a magnetic field that varies both horizontally and vertically. We derive analytic solutions to the wave propagation problem and validate them with numerical simulations. In both cases, we find perfect conversion from IGWs into magnetic waves when the IGWs propagate into a region exceeding a critical magnetic field strength. Downward propagating IGWs cannot reflect into upward propagating IGWs because their vertical wavenumber never approaches zero. Instead, they are converted into upward propagating slow (Alfvenic) waves, and we show they will likely dissipate as they propagate back into weakly magnetized regions. Therefore, strong internal magnetic fields can produce dipole mode suppression in red giants, and gravity modes will likely be totally absent from the pulsation spectra of sufficiently magnetized stars.
△ Less
Submitted 26 December, 2016; v1 submitted 26 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Turbulent Chemical Diffusion in Convectively Bounded Carbon Flames
Authors:
Daniel Lecoanet,
Josiah Schwab,
Eliot Quataert,
Lars Bildsten,
F. X. Timmes,
Keaton J. Burns,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Benjamin P. Brown
Abstract:
It has been proposed that mixing induced by convective overshoot can disrupt the inward propagation of carbon deflagrations in super-asymptotic giant branch stars. To test this theory, we study an idealized model of convectively bounded carbon flames with 3D hydrodynamic simulations of the Boussinesq equations using the pseudospectral code Dedalus. Because the flame propagation timescale is much l…
▽ More
It has been proposed that mixing induced by convective overshoot can disrupt the inward propagation of carbon deflagrations in super-asymptotic giant branch stars. To test this theory, we study an idealized model of convectively bounded carbon flames with 3D hydrodynamic simulations of the Boussinesq equations using the pseudospectral code Dedalus. Because the flame propagation timescale is much longer than the convection timescale, we approximate the flame as fixed in space, and only consider its effects on the buoyancy of the fluid. By evolving a passive scalar field, we derive a {\it turbulent} chemical diffusivity produced by the convection as a function of height, $D_{\rm t}(z)$. Convection can stall a flame if the chemical mixing timescale, set by the turbulent chemical diffusivity, $D_{\rm t}$, is shorter than the flame propagation timescale, set by the thermal diffusivity, $κ$, i.e., when $D_{\rm t}>κ$. However, we find $D_{\rm t}<κ$ for most of the flame because convective plumes are not dense enough to penetrate into the flame. Extrapolating to realistic stellar conditions, this implies that convective mixing cannot stall a carbon flame and that "hybrid carbon-oxygen-neon" white dwarfs are not a typical product of stellar evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2016; v1 submitted 29 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
A nonlinear model for rotationally constrained convection with Ekman pumping
Authors:
Keith Julien,
Jonathan M. Aurnou,
Michael A. Calkins,
Edgar Knobloch,
Philippe Marti,
Stephan Stellmach,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
It is a well established result of linear theory that the influence of differing mechanical boundary conditions, i.e., stress-free or no-slip, on the primary instability in rotating convection becomes asymptotically small in the limit of rapid rotation. This is accounted for by the diminishing impact of the viscous stresses exerted within Ekman boundary layers and the associated vertical momentum…
▽ More
It is a well established result of linear theory that the influence of differing mechanical boundary conditions, i.e., stress-free or no-slip, on the primary instability in rotating convection becomes asymptotically small in the limit of rapid rotation. This is accounted for by the diminishing impact of the viscous stresses exerted within Ekman boundary layers and the associated vertical momentum transport by Ekman pumping. By contrast, in the nonlinear regime recent experiments and supporting simulations are now providing evidence that the efficiency of heat transport remains strongly influenced by Ekman pumping in the rapidly rotating limit. In this paper, a reduced model is developed for the case of low Rossby number convection in a plane layer geometry with no-slip upper and lower boundaries held at fixed temperatures. A complete description of the dynamics requires the existence of three distinct regions within the fluid layer: a geostrophically balanced interior where fluid motions are predominately aligned with the axis of rotation, Ekman boundary layers immediately adjacent to the bounding plates, and thermal wind layers driven by Ekman pumping in between. The reduced model uses a classical Ekman pumping parameterization to alleviate the need for spatially resolving the Ekman boundary layers. Results are presented for both linear stability theory and a special class of nonlinear solutions described by a single horizontal spatial wavenumber. It is shown that Ekman pumping allows for significant enhancement in the heat transport relative to that observed in simulations with stress-free boundaries. Without the intermediate thermal wind layer the nonlinear feedback from Ekman pumping would be able to generate a heat transport that diverges to infinity. This layer arrests this blowup resulting in finite heat transport at a significantly enhanced value.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
A Validated Nonlinear Kelvin-Helmholtz Benchmark for Numerical Hydrodynamics
Authors:
Daniel Lecoanet,
Michael McCourt,
Eliot Quataert,
Keaton J. Burns,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Benjamin P. Brown,
James M. Stone,
Ryan M. O'Leary
Abstract:
The nonlinear evolution of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability is a popular test for code verification. To date, most Kelvin-Helmholtz problems discussed in the literature are ill-posed: they do not converge to any single solution with increasing resolution. This precludes comparisons among different codes and severely limits the utility of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability as a test problem. The lack…
▽ More
The nonlinear evolution of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability is a popular test for code verification. To date, most Kelvin-Helmholtz problems discussed in the literature are ill-posed: they do not converge to any single solution with increasing resolution. This precludes comparisons among different codes and severely limits the utility of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability as a test problem. The lack of a reference solution has led various authors to assert the accuracy of their simulations based on ad-hoc proxies, e.g., the existence of small-scale structures. This paper proposes well-posed Kelvin-Helmholtz problems with smooth initial conditions and explicit diffusion. We show that in many cases numerical errors/noise can seed spurious small-scale structure in Kelvin-Helmholtz problems. We demonstrate convergence to a reference solution using both Athena, a Godunov code, and Dedalus, a pseudo-spectral code. Problems with constant initial density throughout the domain are relatively straightforward for both codes. However, problems with an initial density jump (which are the norm in astrophysical systems) exhibit rich behavior and are more computationally challenging. In the latter case, Athena simulations are prone to an instability of the inner rolled-up vortex; this instability is seeded by grid-scale errors introduced by the algorithm, and disappears as resolution increases. Both Athena and Dedalus exhibit late-time chaos. Inviscid simulations are riddled with extremely vigorous secondary instabilities which induce more mixing than simulations with explicit diffusion. Our results highlight the importance of running well-posed test problems with demonstrated convergence to a reference solution. To facilitate future comparisons, we include the resolved, converged solutions to the Kelvin-Helmholtz problems in this paper in machine-readable form.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2021; v1 submitted 11 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Numerical Simulations of Internal Wave Generation by Convection in Water
Authors:
Daniel Lecoanet,
Michael Le Bars,
Keaton J. Burns,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Eliot Quataert,
Jeffrey S. Oishi
Abstract:
Water's density maximum at 4C makes it well suited to study internal gravity wave excitation by convection: an increasing temperature profile is unstable to convection below 4C, but stably stratified above 4C. We present numerical simulations of a water-like fluid near its density maximum in a two dimensional domain. We successfully model the damping of waves in the simulations using linear theory…
▽ More
Water's density maximum at 4C makes it well suited to study internal gravity wave excitation by convection: an increasing temperature profile is unstable to convection below 4C, but stably stratified above 4C. We present numerical simulations of a water-like fluid near its density maximum in a two dimensional domain. We successfully model the damping of waves in the simulations using linear theory, provided we do not take the weak damping limit typically used in the literature. In order to isolate the physical mechanism exciting internal waves, we use the novel spectral code Dedalus to run several simplified model simulations of our more detailed simulation. We use data from the full simulation as source terms in two simplified models of internal wave excitation by convection: bulk excitation by convective Reynolds stresses, and interface forcing via the mechanical oscillator effect. We find excellent agreement between the waves generated in the full simulation and the simplified simulation implementing the bulk excitation mechanism. The interface forcing simulations over excite high frequency waves because they assume the excitation is by the "impulsive" penetration of plumes, which spreads energy to high frequencies. However, we find the real excitation is instead by the "sweeping" motion of plumes parallel to the interface. Our results imply that the bulk excitation mechanism is a very accurate heuristic for internal wave generation by convection.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2015; v1 submitted 9 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Conduction in low Mach number flows: Part I Linear & weakly nonlinear regimes
Authors:
Daniel Lecoanet,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Ellen G. Zweibel,
Keaton J. Burns,
Jeffrey S. Oishi,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
Thermal conduction is an important energy transfer and damping mechanism in astrophysical flows. Fourier's law - the heat flux is proportional to the negative temperature gradient, leading to temperature diffusion - is a well-known empirical model of thermal conduction. However, entropy diffusion has emerged as an alternative thermal conduction model, despite not ensuring the monotonicity of entro…
▽ More
Thermal conduction is an important energy transfer and damping mechanism in astrophysical flows. Fourier's law - the heat flux is proportional to the negative temperature gradient, leading to temperature diffusion - is a well-known empirical model of thermal conduction. However, entropy diffusion has emerged as an alternative thermal conduction model, despite not ensuring the monotonicity of entropy. This paper investigates the differences between temperature and entropy diffusion for both linear internal gravity waves and weakly nonlinear convection. In addition to simulating the two thermal conduction models with the fully compressible Navier-Stokes equations, we also study their effects in the reduced, "sound-proof" anelastic and pseudo-incompressible equations. We find that in the linear and weakly nonlinear regimes, temperature and entropy diffusion give quantitatively similar results, although there are some larger errors in the pseudo-incompressible equations with temperature diffusion due to inaccuracies in the equation of state. Extrapolating our weakly nonlinear results, we speculate that differences between temperature and entropy diffusion might become more important for strongly turbulent convection.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Energy conservation and gravity waves in sound-proof treatments of stellar interiors: Part II Lagrangian constrained analysis
Authors:
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Daniel Lecoanet,
Benjamin P. Brown,
Toby S. Wood,
Ellen G. Zweibel
Abstract:
The speed of sound greatly exceeds typical flow velocities in many stellar and planetary interiors. To follow the slow evolution of subsonic motions, various sound-proof models attempt to remove fast acoustic waves whilst retaining stratified convection and buoyancy dynamics. In astrophysics, anelastic models typically receive the most attention in the class of sound-filtered stratified models. Ge…
▽ More
The speed of sound greatly exceeds typical flow velocities in many stellar and planetary interiors. To follow the slow evolution of subsonic motions, various sound-proof models attempt to remove fast acoustic waves whilst retaining stratified convection and buoyancy dynamics. In astrophysics, anelastic models typically receive the most attention in the class of sound-filtered stratified models. Generally, anelastic models remain valid in nearly adiabatically stratified regions like stellar convection zones, but may break down in strongly sub-adiabatic, stably stratified layers common in stellar radiative zones. However, studying stellar rotation, circulation, and dynamos requires understanding the complex coupling between convection and radiative zones, and this requires robust equations valid in both regimes. Here we extend the analysis of equation sets begun in Brown Vasil & Zweibel 2012, which studied anelastic models, to two types of pseudo-incompressible models. This class of models has received attention in atmospheric applications, and more recently in studies of white-dwarf supernovae progenitors. We demonstrate that one model conserves energy but the other does not. We use Lagrangian variational methods to extend the energy conserving model to a general equation of state, and dub the resulting equation set the Generalized Pseudo-Incompressible (GPI) model. We show that the GPI equations suitably capture low frequency phenomena in both convection and radiative zones in stars and other stratified systems, and we provide recommendations for converting low-Mach number codes to this equation set.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Energy Conservation and Gravity Waves in Sound-proof Treatments of Stellar Interiors: Part I Anelastic Approximations
Authors:
Benjamin P Brown,
Geoffrey M Vasil,
Ellen G Zweibel
Abstract:
Typical flows in stellar interiors are much slower than the speed of sound. To follow the slow evolution of subsonic motions, various sound-proof equations are in wide use, particularly in stellar astrophysical fluid dynamics. These low-Mach number equations include the anelastic equations. Generally, these equations are valid in nearly adiabatically stratified regions like stellar convection zone…
▽ More
Typical flows in stellar interiors are much slower than the speed of sound. To follow the slow evolution of subsonic motions, various sound-proof equations are in wide use, particularly in stellar astrophysical fluid dynamics. These low-Mach number equations include the anelastic equations. Generally, these equations are valid in nearly adiabatically stratified regions like stellar convection zones, but may not be valid in the sub-adiabatic, stably stratified stellar radiative interiors. Understanding the coupling between the convection zone and the radiative interior is a problem of crucial interest and may have strong implications for solar and stellar dynamo theories as the interface between the two, called the tachocline in the Sun, plays a crucial role in many solar dynamo theories. Here we study the properties of gravity waves in stably-stratified atmospheres. In particular, we explore how gravity waves are handled in various sound-proof equations. We find that some anelastic treatments fail to conserve energy in stably-stratified atmospheres, instead conserving pseudo-energies that depend on the stratification, and we demonstrate this numerically. One anelastic equation set does conserve energy in all atmospheres and we provide recommendations for converting low-Mach number anelastic codes to this set of equations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
The Evolution of a Double Diffusive Magnetic Buoyancy Instability
Authors:
Lara J. Silvers,
Geoffrey M. Vasil,
Nicholas H. Brummell,
Michael R. E. Proctor
Abstract:
Recently, Silvers, Vasil, Brummell, & Proctor (2009), using numerical simulations, confirmed the existence of a double diffusive magnetic buoyancy instability of a layer of horizontal magnetic field produced by the interaction of a shear velocity field with a weak vertical field. Here, we demonstrate the longer term nonlinear evolution of such an instability in the simulations. We find that a quas…
▽ More
Recently, Silvers, Vasil, Brummell, & Proctor (2009), using numerical simulations, confirmed the existence of a double diffusive magnetic buoyancy instability of a layer of horizontal magnetic field produced by the interaction of a shear velocity field with a weak vertical field. Here, we demonstrate the longer term nonlinear evolution of such an instability in the simulations. We find that a quasi two-dimensional interchange instability rides (or "surfs") on the growing shear-induced background downstream field gradients. The region of activity expands since three-dimensional perturbations remain unstable in the wake of this upward-moving activity front, and so the three-dimensional nature becomes more noticeable with time.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
