-
On Dual Mechanisms Limiting Density in the Negative Triangularity Tokamak
Authors:
R. Hong,
P. H. Diamond,
O. Sauter,
J. Chen,
F. Khabanov,
Z. Li,
D. Liu,
A. Marinoni,
G. R. McKee,
T. L. Rhodes,
F. Scotti,
K. E. Thome,
G. R. Tynan,
M. A. Van Zeeland,
Z. Yan,
L. Zeng,
the DIII-D NT Team
Abstract:
Achieving high plasma density is essential for maximizing thermonuclear power and thus crucial for realizing economically viable fusion energy; however, this is often constrained by a fundamental density limit. This study investigates the L-mode density limit in negative triangularity (NT) plasmas on the DIII-D tokamak, and the results provide novel insights into this long-standing challenge. We r…
▽ More
Achieving high plasma density is essential for maximizing thermonuclear power and thus crucial for realizing economically viable fusion energy; however, this is often constrained by a fundamental density limit. This study investigates the L-mode density limit in negative triangularity (NT) plasmas on the DIII-D tokamak, and the results provide novel insights into this long-standing challenge. We report sustained operations at densities up to 1.8 times the conventional Greenwald limit with 13 MW of auxiliary heating power. Importantly, systematic power scans reveal distinct power scaling relationships for core ($n_{e} \propto P_{\text{SOL}}^{0.27\pm 0.03}$) and edge ($n_{e} \propto P_{\text{SOL}}^{0.42\pm 0.04}$) densities, which suggest different limiting mechanisms at play and point to a more nuanced picture than the traditional paradigm of a single, universal density limit. In this vein, detailed measurements were performed, revealing a complex interplay of macroscopic profiles, radiation patterns, and turbulent transport. Specifically, edge turbulent transport increased as density rose, leading to enhanced divertor radiation and subsequent MARFE onset. The edge density saturated abruptly following MARFE formation. In contrast, the core density continues to increase, ultimately limited by enhanced turbulence that exhibits characteristics of avalanche-like transport. Consistent with enhanced turbulence, toroidal rotation and the $E_r \times B$ flow shear also collapsed approaching the density limit. Taken together, these observations suggest that MARFE dynamics primarily govern the edge density limit, while turbulence-driven transport dominates the core density limit. These results also indicate the feasibility of operations significantly beyond the Greenwald density in high-power NT plasmas.
This can potentially be attained through advanced control of core turbulence and MARFEs.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Operation above the Greenwald density limit in high performance DIII-D negative triangularity discharges
Authors:
O Sauter,
R. Hong,
A. Marinoni,
F. Scotti,
P. H. Diamond,
C. Paz-Soldan,
D. Shiraki,
K. E. Thome,
M. A. Van Zeeland,
H. Q. Wang,
Z. Yan,
the negD-DIII-D Team
Abstract:
The density limit in strongly-shaped negative triangularity (NT) discharges is studied experimentally in the DIII-D tokamak. Record-high Greenwald fractions $f_G$ are obtained, using gas puff injection only, with values up to near 2, where $f_G$ is defined as the ratio of the line-averaged density over $n_G=I_p/(π\,a^2)$, with $I_p$[MA] the plasma current and $a$[m] the plasma minor radius. A clea…
▽ More
The density limit in strongly-shaped negative triangularity (NT) discharges is studied experimentally in the DIII-D tokamak. Record-high Greenwald fractions $f_G$ are obtained, using gas puff injection only, with values up to near 2, where $f_G$ is defined as the ratio of the line-averaged density over $n_G=I_p/(π\,a^2)$, with $I_p$[MA] the plasma current and $a$[m] the plasma minor radius. A clear higher operational limit with higher auxiliary power is also demonstrated, with the ohmic density limit about two times lower than with additional neutral beam injection heating. The evolution of the electron density, temperature and pressure profiles are analyzed as well. The core density can be up to twice the Greenwald density and keeps increasing, while the value at the separatrix remains essentially constant and slightly below $n_G$. The edge temperature gradient collapses to near zero and NT plasmas are shown to be resilient to such profiles in terms of disruptivity. We also present the time evolution of the inverse electron pressure scale length with the value at the last closed flux surface (LCFS) decreasing below the value at the normalized radius 0.9 near the density limit, demonstrating the clear drop of confinement starting from the edge. This inverse scale length ``collapse'' at the LCFS also defines well the characteristic behavior of the kinetic profiles approaching a density limit.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Simultaneous kinetic profile and magnetic equilibrium inference with Bayesian integrated data analysis in preparation for ITER
Authors:
S. S. Denk,
T. B. Amara,
T. Odstrcil,
L. Stagner,
C. Akcay,
T. Slendebroek,
S. P. Smith,
M. A. Van Zeeland,
T. Akiyama,
R. Nazikian
Abstract:
Accurate plasma state reconstruction will be crucial for the success of ITER and future fusion plants, but the harsh conditions of a burning plasma will make diagnostic operation more challenging than in current machines. Integrated data analysis (IDA) based on Bayesian inference allows for improved information gain by combining the analysis of many diagnostics into a single step using sophisticat…
▽ More
Accurate plasma state reconstruction will be crucial for the success of ITER and future fusion plants, but the harsh conditions of a burning plasma will make diagnostic operation more challenging than in current machines. Integrated data analysis (IDA) based on Bayesian inference allows for improved information gain by combining the analysis of many diagnostics into a single step using sophisticated forward models. It also provides a framework to seamlessly combine predictive modeling and data, which can be invaluable in a data-poor environment. As a step towards integrated data analysis at scale, we present a new, fast integrated analysis framework that allows for the simultaneous reconstruction of the kinetic profiles and the magnetic equilibrium with statistically relevant uncertainties included. This analysis framework allows for the systematic evaluation of models using extensive experimental data leveraging DOE supercomputing infrastructure, such as being developed through the DOE-ASCR Integrated Research Infrastructure (Smith, XLOOP). To test the performance and verify the code it was applied to an ITER-like scenario using a realistic machine geometry and diagnostic description. Using artificial data for magnetics, Thomson scattering, interferometry, and polarimetry generated from a known ground truth, the coupled equilibrium and kinetic profile reconstruction problem was solved via the Maximum a posteriori method in approximately three minutes on a multicore CPU including uncertainty quantification. The resulting equilibrium and kinetic profiles were found to be in reasonable agreement with the ground truth.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Effect of the neutral beam injector operational regime on the Alfven eigenmode saturation phase in DIII-D plasma
Authors:
J Varela,
D A Spong,
L Garcia,
Y Ghai,
D Zarzoso,
D del-Castillo-Negrete,
H Betar,
J Ortiz,
D C Pace,
M A Van Zeeland,
X Du,
R Sanchez,
V Tribaldos,
J M Reynolds-Barredo
Abstract:
The aim of this study is to analyze the effect of the neutral beam injector (NBI) operation regime on the saturation phase of the Alfven Eigenmodes (AEs) in DIII-D plasma. The analysis is done using the linear and nonlinear versions of the gyro-fluid code FAR3d. A set of parametric analyses are performed modifying the nonlinear simulation EP \b{eta} (NBI injection power), EP energy (NBI voltage) a…
▽ More
The aim of this study is to analyze the effect of the neutral beam injector (NBI) operation regime on the saturation phase of the Alfven Eigenmodes (AEs) in DIII-D plasma. The analysis is done using the linear and nonlinear versions of the gyro-fluid code FAR3d. A set of parametric analyses are performed modifying the nonlinear simulation EP \b{eta} (NBI injection power), EP energy (NBI voltage) and the radial location of the EP density profile gradient (NBI radial deposition). The analysis indicates a transition from the soft (local plasma relaxation) to the hard MHD (global plasma relaxation) limit if the simulation EP \b{eta} >= 0.02, leading to bursting MHD activity caused by radial AEs overlapping. MHD bursts cause an enhancement of the EP transport showing ballistic-like features as avalanche-like events. Simulations in the soft MHD limit show an increment of the EP density gradient as the EP \b{eta} increases. On the other hand, there is a gradient upper limit in the hard MHD limit, consistent with the critical-gradient behavior. AEs induce shear flows and zonal current leading to the deformation of the flux surfaces and the safety factor profile, respectively, particularly strong for the simulation in the hard MHD limit. Simulations in the hard MHD regime show a decrease of the AE frequency in the saturation phase; this is caused by the destabilization of a transitional mode between a 9/3-10/3 TAE and a 9/3 RSAE that may explain the AE frequency down-sweeping observed in some DIII-D discharges. Reducing the EP energy in the nonlinear simulations leads to a weakening of the plasma perturbation. On the other hand, increasing the EP energy causes the opposite effect. Nonlinear simulations of off-axis NBI profiles indicate a lower plasma perturbation as the EP density gradient is located further away from the magnetic axis.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Design and simulation of an Imaging Neutral Particle Analyzer for the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak
Authors:
J. Rueda-Rueda,
M. Garcia-Munoz,
E. Viezzer,
P. A. Schneider,
J. Garcia-Dominguez,
J. Ayllon-Guerola,
J. Galdon-Quiroga,
A. Herrmann,
X. Du,
M. A. Van Zeeland,
P. Oyola,
M. Rodriguez-Ramos,
the ASDEX-Upgrade team
Abstract:
An Imaging Neutral Particle Analyser (INPA) diagnostic has been designed for the ASDEX Upgrade (AUG) tokamak. The AUG INPA diagnostic will measure fast neutrals escaping the plasma after CX reactions. The neutrals will be ionised by a 20 nm carbon foil and deflected towards a scintillator by the local magnetic field. The use of a neutral beam injector (NBI) as active source of neutrals will provid…
▽ More
An Imaging Neutral Particle Analyser (INPA) diagnostic has been designed for the ASDEX Upgrade (AUG) tokamak. The AUG INPA diagnostic will measure fast neutrals escaping the plasma after CX reactions. The neutrals will be ionised by a 20 nm carbon foil and deflected towards a scintillator by the local magnetic field. The use of a neutral beam injector (NBI) as active source of neutrals will provide radially resolved measurements while the use of a scintillator as active component will allow us to cover the whole plasma along the NBI line with unprecedented phase-space resolution ($ < $ 12 keV and 8 cm) and fast temporal response (up to 1 kHz with the high resolution acquisition system and above 100 kHz with the low resolution one); making it suitable to study localised fast-ions redistributions in phase-space.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Subdominant modes and optimization trends of DIII-D reverse magnetic shear configurations
Authors:
J. Varela,
D. A. Spong,
M. Murakami,
L. Garcia,
E. D'Azevedo,
M. A. Van Zeeland,
S. Munaretto
Abstract:
Alfven Eigenmodes and magneto-hydrodynamic modes are destabilized in DIII-D reverse magnetic shear configurations and may limit the performance of the device. We use the reduced MHD equations in a full 3D system, coupled with equations of density and parallel velocity moments for the energetic particles (with gyro-fluid closures) as well as the geodesic acoustic wave dynamics. The aim of the study…
▽ More
Alfven Eigenmodes and magneto-hydrodynamic modes are destabilized in DIII-D reverse magnetic shear configurations and may limit the performance of the device. We use the reduced MHD equations in a full 3D system, coupled with equations of density and parallel velocity moments for the energetic particles (with gyro-fluid closures) as well as the geodesic acoustic wave dynamics. The aim of the study consists in finding ways to avoid or minimize MHD and AE activity for different magnetic field configurations and neutral beam injection operational regimes. The simulations show at the beginning of the discharge, before the reverse shear region is formed, a plasma that is AE unstable and marginally MHD stable. As soon as the reverse shear region appears, ideal MHD modes are destabilized with a larger growth rate than the AEs. Both MHD modes and AEs coexist during the discharge, although the MHD modes are more unstable as the reverse shear region deepens. The simulations indicate the destabilization of Beta induced AE, Toroidal AE, Elliptical AE and Reverse Shear AE at different phases of the discharges. A further analysis of the NBI operational regime indicates that the AE stability can be improved if the NBI injection is off axis, because on-axis injection leads to AEs with larger growth rate and frequency. In addition, decreasing the beam energy or increasing the NBI relative density leads to AEs with larger growth rate and frequency, so an NBI operation in the weakly resonant regime requires higher beam energies than in the experiment. The MHD linear stability can be also improved if the reverse shear region and the q profile near the magnetic axis are in between the rational surfaces q=2 and q=1, particularly if there is a region in the core with negative shear, avoiding a flat q profile near the magnetic axis.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Onset of nonlinear structures due to eigenmode destabilization in tokamak plasmas
Authors:
Vinicius Duarte,
Herbert Berk,
Nikolai Gorelenkov,
William Heidbrink,
Gerrit Kramer,
David Pace,
Mario Podesta,
Michael Van Zeeland
Abstract:
A general methodology is proposed to differentiate the likelihood of energetic-particle-driven instabilities to produce frequency chirping or fixed-frequency oscillations. The method employs numerically calculated eigenstructures and multiple resonance surfaces of a given mode in the presence of energetic ion drag and stochasticity (due to collisions and micro-turbulence). Toroidicity-induced, rev…
▽ More
A general methodology is proposed to differentiate the likelihood of energetic-particle-driven instabilities to produce frequency chirping or fixed-frequency oscillations. The method employs numerically calculated eigenstructures and multiple resonance surfaces of a given mode in the presence of energetic ion drag and stochasticity (due to collisions and micro-turbulence). Toroidicity-induced, reversed-shear and beta-induced Alfven-acoustic eigenmodes are used as examples. Waves measured in experiments are characterized and compatibility is found between the proposed criterion predictions and the experimental observation or lack of observation of chirping behavior of Alfvenic modes in different tokamaks. It is found that the stochastic diffusion due to micro-turbulence can be the dominant energetic particle detuning mechanism near the resonances in many plasma experiments, and its strength is the key as to whether chirping solutions are likely to arise. The proposed criterion constitutes a useful predictive tool in assessing whether the nature of the transport for fast ion losses in fusion devices will be dominated by convective or diffusive processes.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Prediction of Nonlinear Evolution Character of Energetic-Particle-Driven Instabilities
Authors:
Vinicius Duarte,
Herbert Berk,
Nikolai Gorelenkov,
William Heidbrink,
Gerrit Kramer,
Raffi Nazikian,
David Pace,
Mario Podesta,
Benjamin Tobias,
Michael Van Zeeland
Abstract:
A general criterion is proposed and found to successfully predict the emergence of chirping oscillations of unstable Alfvénic eigenmodes in tokamak plasma experiments. The model includes realistic eigenfunction structure, detailed phase-space dependences of the instability drive, stochastic scattering and the Coulomb drag. The stochastic scattering combines the effects of collisional pitch angle s…
▽ More
A general criterion is proposed and found to successfully predict the emergence of chirping oscillations of unstable Alfvénic eigenmodes in tokamak plasma experiments. The model includes realistic eigenfunction structure, detailed phase-space dependences of the instability drive, stochastic scattering and the Coulomb drag. The stochastic scattering combines the effects of collisional pitch angle scattering and micro-turbulence spatial diffusion. The latter mechanism is essential to accurately identify the transition between the fixed-frequency mode behavior and rapid chirping in tokamaks and to resolve the disparity with respect to chirping observation in spherical and conventional tokamaks.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Energetic particle instabilities in fusion plasmas
Authors:
S E Sharapov,
B Alper,
H L Berk,
D N Borba,
B N Breizman,
C D Challis,
I G J Classen,
E M Edlund,
J Eriksson,
A Fasoli,
E D Fredrickson,
G Y Fu,
M Garcia-Munoz,
T Gassner,
K Ghantous,
V Goloborodko,
N N Gorelenkov,
M P Gryaznevich,
S Hacquin,
W W Heidbrink,
C Hellesen,
V G Kiptily,
G J Kramer,
P Lauber,
M K Lilley
, et al. (19 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Remarkable progress has been made in diagnosing energetic particle instabilities on present-day machines and in establishing a theoretical framework for describing them. This overview describes the much improved diagnostics of Alfven instabilities and modelling tools developed world-wide, and discusses progress in interpreting the observed phenomena. A multi-machine comparison is presented giving…
▽ More
Remarkable progress has been made in diagnosing energetic particle instabilities on present-day machines and in establishing a theoretical framework for describing them. This overview describes the much improved diagnostics of Alfven instabilities and modelling tools developed world-wide, and discusses progress in interpreting the observed phenomena. A multi-machine comparison is presented giving information on the performance of both diagnostics and modelling tools for different plasma conditions outlining expectations for ITER based on our present knowledge.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
