Showing 1–13 of 13 results for author: Tziperman, E

Is ENSO a damped or a self-sustained oscillation?

Authors: Elle Weeks, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: The recharge oscillator (RO) model has been successfully used to understand different aspects of the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO). Fitting the RO to observations and climate model simulations consistently suggests that ENSO is a damped oscillator whose variability is sustained and made irregular by external weather noise. We investigate the methods that have been used to estimate the growth… ▽ More The recharge oscillator (RO) model has been successfully used to understand different aspects of the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO). Fitting the RO to observations and climate model simulations consistently suggests that ENSO is a damped oscillator whose variability is sustained and made irregular by external weather noise. We investigate the methods that have been used to estimate the growth rate of ENSO by applying them to simulations of both damped and self-sustained RO regimes. We find that fitting a linear RO leads to parameters that imply a damped oscillator even when the fitted data were produced by a model that is self-sustained. Fitting a nonlinear RO also leads to a significant bias toward a damped regime. As such, it seems challenging to conclude whether ENSO is a damped or a self-sustained oscillation by fitting such models to observations, and the possibility that ENSO is self-sustained cannot be ruled out. △ Less

Submitted 7 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

The upwelling source depth distribution and its response to wind stress and stratification

Authors: Elle Weeks, Martin Losch, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: Coastal upwelling, driven by alongshore winds and characterized by cold sea surface temperatures and high upper-ocean nutrient content, is an important physical process sustaining some of the oceans' most productive ecosystems. To fully understand the ocean properties in eastern boundary upwelling systems, it is important to consider the depth of the source waters being upwelled, as it affects bot… ▽ More Coastal upwelling, driven by alongshore winds and characterized by cold sea surface temperatures and high upper-ocean nutrient content, is an important physical process sustaining some of the oceans' most productive ecosystems. To fully understand the ocean properties in eastern boundary upwelling systems, it is important to consider the depth of the source waters being upwelled, as it affects both the SST and the transport of nutrients toward the surface. Here, we construct an upwelling source depth distribution for parcels at the surface in the upwelling zone. We do so using passive tracers forced at the domain boundary for every model depth level to quantify their contributions to the upwelled waters. We test the dependence of this distribution on the strength of the wind stress and stratification using high-resolution regional ocean simulations of an idealized coastal upwelling system. We also present an efficient method for estimating the mean upwelling source depth. Furthermore, we show that the standard deviation of the upwelling source depth distribution increases with increasing wind stress and decreases with increasing stratification. These results can be applied to better understand and predict how coastal upwelling sites and their surface properties have and will change in past and future climates. △ Less

Submitted 7 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

On the attribution of weather events to climate change using a fit to extreme value distributions

Authors: Peter Sherman, Peter Huybers, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: Changes in extreme weather events are a potentially important aspect of anthropogenic climate change (ACC), yet, are difficult to attribute to ACC because the record length is often similar to, or shorter than, extreme-event return periods. This study is motivated by the ``World Weather Attribution'' initiative (WWA) and, specifically, their approach of fitting extreme value distribution functions… ▽ More Changes in extreme weather events are a potentially important aspect of anthropogenic climate change (ACC), yet, are difficult to attribute to ACC because the record length is often similar to, or shorter than, extreme-event return periods. This study is motivated by the ``World Weather Attribution'' initiative (WWA) and, specifically, their approach of fitting extreme value distribution functions to local observations. They calculate the dependence of distribution parameters on global mean surface temperature (GMST) and use this dependence to attribute extreme events to ACC. Applying this method to preindustrial climate simulations with no time-varying greenhouse gas forcing, we still find a strong dependence of distribution parameters on GMST. This dependence results from internal climate variability (e.g., ENSO) affecting both extreme events and GMST. Therefore, dependence on GMST does not necessarily imply an effect of ACC on extremes. We further consider whether an extreme value, normal, or log-normal distribution better represents the data; if a GMST-dependence of distribution parameters is justified using a likelihood ratio test; and if a meaningful attribution is possible given uncertainties in GMST dependence. We find, for example, that an attribution of Australia's 2020--2021 Bushfires to ACC is difficult due to the effects of internal variability. For the 2019--2021 drought in Madagascar we find that the small number of available data points precludes a meaningful attribution analysis. Overall, we find that the effects of internal climate variability on GMST and the uncertain relationship between GMST and regional extremes may lead to inaccurate attribution conclusions using the part of the WWA approach examined here. △ Less

Submitted 18 February, 2025; v1 submitted 15 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

An approach for projecting the timing of abrupt winter Arctic sea ice loss

Authors: Camille Hankel, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: Abrupt and irreversible winter Arctic sea-ice loss may occur under anthropogenic warming due to the collapse of a sea-ice equilibrium at a threshold value of CO$_2$, commonly referred to as a tipping point. Previous work has been unable to conclusively identify whether a tipping point in Arctic sea ice exists because fully-coupled climate models are too computationally expensive to run to equilibr… ▽ More Abrupt and irreversible winter Arctic sea-ice loss may occur under anthropogenic warming due to the collapse of a sea-ice equilibrium at a threshold value of CO$_2$, commonly referred to as a tipping point. Previous work has been unable to conclusively identify whether a tipping point in Arctic sea ice exists because fully-coupled climate models are too computationally expensive to run to equilibrium for many CO$_2$ values. Here, we explore the deviation of sea ice from its equilibrium state under realistic rates of CO$_2$ increase to demonstrate how a few time-dependent CO$_2$ experiments can be used to predict the existence and timing of sea-ice tipping points without running the model to steady-state. This study highlights the inefficacy of using a single experiment with slow-changing CO$_2$ to discover changes in the sea-ice steady-state, and provides an alternate method that can be developed for the identification of tipping points in realistic climate models. △ Less

Submitted 20 December, 2022; v1 submitted 28 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 Figures, Supporting Information included. Submitted to Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics

Exploring subtropical stratocumulus multiple equilibria using a mixed-layer model

Authors: Andrea M. Salazar, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: Stratocumulus clouds cover about a fifth of Earths surface, and due to their albedo and low-latitude location, they have a strong effect on Earths radiation budget. Previous studies using Large Eddy Simulations have shown that multiple equilibria (both cloud-covered and cloud-free states) exist as a function of fixed-SST, with relevance to equatorward advected air masses. Multiple equilibria have… ▽ More Stratocumulus clouds cover about a fifth of Earths surface, and due to their albedo and low-latitude location, they have a strong effect on Earths radiation budget. Previous studies using Large Eddy Simulations have shown that multiple equilibria (both cloud-covered and cloud-free states) exist as a function of fixed-SST, with relevance to equatorward advected air masses. Multiple equilibria have also been found as a function of atmospheric CO2, with a subtropical SST nearly 10 K higher in the cloud-free state, and with suggested relevance to warm-climate dynamics. In this study, we use a mixed-layer model with an added surface energy balance and the ability to simulate both the cloud-covered and cloud-free states to study both types of multiple equilibria and the corresponding hysteresis. The model's simplicity and computational efficiency allow us to explore the mechanisms critical to the stratocumulus cloud instability and hysteresis as well as isolate key processes that allow for multiple equilibria via mechanism denial experiments not possible with a full-complexity model. For the hysteresis in fixed-SST, we find that decoupling can occur due to either enhanced entrainment warming or a reduction in cloud-top longwave cooling. The critical SST at which decoupling occurs is highly sensitive to precipitation and entrainment parameterizations. In the CO2 hysteresis, decoupling occurs in the simple model used even without the inclusion of an active SST and SST-cloud cover feedbacks, and the width of the hysteresis displays the same sensitivities as the fixed-SST case. Overall, the simple model analysis and results motivate further studies using higher complexity models. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: Submitted to Journal of Climate 06-12-2022

Is the resonant wave interaction approximation consistent with the dynamics of internal wave fields?

Authors: Golan Bel, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: Nonlinear interaction and breaking of internal ocean waves are responsible for much of the interior ocean mixing, affecting ocean carbon storage and the global overturning circulation. These interactions are also believed to dictate the observed Garrett-Munk wave energy spectrum, which is still unexplained after 50 years of studies. According to the resonant wave interaction approximation, used to… ▽ More Nonlinear interaction and breaking of internal ocean waves are responsible for much of the interior ocean mixing, affecting ocean carbon storage and the global overturning circulation. These interactions are also believed to dictate the observed Garrett-Munk wave energy spectrum, which is still unexplained after 50 years of studies. According to the resonant wave interaction approximation, used to derive the kinetic equation for the energy spectrum, the dominant interactions are between wave triads whose wavevectors satisfy $\mathbf{k}=\mathbf{p}+\mathbf{q}$, and whose frequencies satisfy $ω_{\mathbf{k}}=|ω_{\mathbf{p}}\pmω_{\mathbf{q}}|$. In order to test the validity of the resonant wave interaction approximation, we examine several analytical derivations of the theory. The assumptions underlying each derivation are tested using idealized direct 2d numerical simulations, representing near-observed energy levels of the oceanic internal wave field. We show that the assumptions underlying the derivations are not consistent with the simulated dynamics. In addition, most of the triads satisfying the resonant conditions do not contribute significantly to nonlinear wave energy transfer in our simulations, while some interactions that are dominant in nonlinear energy transfers do not satisfy the resonance conditions. We also point to possible self-consistency issues with some derivations found in the literature. △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 2023; v1 submitted 6 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Mid-depth Ocean Stratification: Southern Ocean eddies vs interior vertical diffusivity

Authors: Xiaoting Yang, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: The mid-depth ocean stratification was fitted by Munk (1966) to an exponential profile and shown to be consistent with a vertical advective-diffusive balance. However, tracer release experiments show that vertical diffusivity in the mid-depth ocean is an order of magnitude too small to explain the observed 1 km exponential scale. Alternative mechanisms suggested that the overturning is mostly adia… ▽ More The mid-depth ocean stratification was fitted by Munk (1966) to an exponential profile and shown to be consistent with a vertical advective-diffusive balance. However, tracer release experiments show that vertical diffusivity in the mid-depth ocean is an order of magnitude too small to explain the observed 1 km exponential scale. Alternative mechanisms suggested that the overturning is mostly adiabatic, that interior diapycnal upwelling is negligible, and that nearly all mid-depth water upwells adiabatically in the Southern Ocean (SO). In this picture, SO eddies and wind set isopycnal slopes in the SO and therefore determine a non-vanishing mid-depth interior stratification even in the adiabatic limit. The effect of SO eddies on SO isopycnal slopes can be understood via either a marginal criticality condition or via a near-vanishing residual overturning conditions in the adiabatic limit. We examine the role of SO eddies vs interior mixing in setting the mid-depth stratification by using eddy-permitting numerical simulations, in which we artificially change the diapycnal mixing only away from the SO. We find that SO isopycnal slopes change in response to changes of the interior diapycnal mixing even when the wind forcing is constant, consistent with previous studies. However, in the limit of small interior mixing, the interior stratification is far from exponential, suggesting that SO processes alone do not lead to the observed stratification. The results suggest that while SO eddies contribute to the non-vanishing mid-depth interior stratification, the exponential shape of the stratification must also involve interior diapycnal mixing. Both SO eddies and interior diapycnal mixing are therefore important in determining the interior mid-depth exponential stratification. △ Less

Submitted 26 August, 2021; v1 submitted 31 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Reconciling the Observed Mid-Depth Exponential Ocean Stratification with Weak Interior Mixing and Southern Ocean Dynamics via Boundary-Intensified Mixing

Authors: Madeline D. Miller, Xiaoting Yang, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: Munk (1966) showed that the deep (1000-3000 m) vertical temperature profile is consistent with a one-dimensional vertical advection-diffusion balance, with a constant upwelling and an interior diapycnal diffusivity of $\mathcal{O}(10^{-4})$ m$^{2}$ s$^{-1}$. However, typical observed diffusivities in the interior are $\mathcal{O}(10^{-5})$ m$^{2}$ s$^{-1}$. Recent work suggested that the deep stra… ▽ More Munk (1966) showed that the deep (1000-3000 m) vertical temperature profile is consistent with a one-dimensional vertical advection-diffusion balance, with a constant upwelling and an interior diapycnal diffusivity of $\mathcal{O}(10^{-4})$ m$^{2}$ s$^{-1}$. However, typical observed diffusivities in the interior are $\mathcal{O}(10^{-5})$ m$^{2}$ s$^{-1}$. Recent work suggested that the deep stratification is set by Southern Ocean (SO) isopycnal slopes, fixed by SO eddies, that communicate the surface outcrop positions to the deep ocean. It is shown here, using an idealized ocean general circulation model, that SO eddies alone cannot lead to the observed exponential temperature profile, and that interior mixing must contribute. Strong diapycnal mixing concentrated near the ocean boundaries is shown to be balanced locally by upwelling. A one-dimensional Munk-like balance in these boundary mixing areas, although with much larger mixing and upwelling, leads to an exponential deep temperature stratification, which propagates via isopycnal mixing to the ocean interior. The exponential profile is robust to vertical variations in the vertical velocity, and persists despite the observed weak interior diapycnal mixing. Southern Ocean eddies link the surface water mass transformation by air-sea fluxes with the deep stratification, but the eddies do not determine the stratification itself. These results reconcile the observed exponential interior deep temperature stratification, the weak diapycnal diffusivity observed in tracer release experiments, and the role of Southern Ocean dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 28 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Tropical and Extratropical General Circulation with a Meridional Reversed Temperature Gradient as Expected in a High Obliquity Planet

Authors: Wanying Kang, Ming Cai, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: Planets with high obliquity receive more radiation in the polar regions than at low latitudes, and thus, assuming an ocean-covered surface with sufficiently high heat capacity, their meridional temperature gradient was shown to be reversed for the entire year. The objective of this work is to investigate the drastically different general circulation of such planets, with an emphasis on the tropica… ▽ More Planets with high obliquity receive more radiation in the polar regions than at low latitudes, and thus, assuming an ocean-covered surface with sufficiently high heat capacity, their meridional temperature gradient was shown to be reversed for the entire year. The objective of this work is to investigate the drastically different general circulation of such planets, with an emphasis on the tropical Hadley circulation and the mid-latitude baroclinic eddy structure. We use a 3D dry dynamic core model, accompanied by an eddy-free configuration and a generalized 2D Eady model. When the meridional temperature gradient $T_y$ is reversed, the Hadley cell remains in the same direction, because the surface wind pattern and hence the associated meridional Ekman transport are not changed, as required by the baroclinic eddy momentum transport. The Hadley cell under reversed $T_y$ also becomes much shallower and weaker, even when the magnitude of the gradient is the same as in the normal case. The shallowness is due to the bottom-heavy structure of the baroclinic eddies in the reverse case, and the weakness is due to the weak wave activity. We propose a new mechanism to explain the mid-latitude eddy structure for both cases, and verify it using the generalized Eady model. With seasonal variations included, the annual mean circulation resembles that under perpetual annual mean setup. Approaching the solstices, a strong cross-equator Hadley cell forms in both cases, and about 2/3 of the Hadley circulation is driven by eddies, as shown by eddy-free simulations and using a decomposition of the Hadley cell. △ Less

Submitted 18 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Exploring the Nonlinear Cloud and Rain Equation

Authors: Ilan Koren, Eli Tziperman, Graham Feingold

Abstract: Marine stratocumulus cloud decks are regarded as the reflectors of the climate system, returning back to space a significant part of the income solar radiation, thus cooling the atmosphere. Such clouds can exist in two stable modes, open and closed cells, for a wide range of environmental conditions. This emergent behavior of the system, and its sensitivity to aerosol and environmental properties,… ▽ More Marine stratocumulus cloud decks are regarded as the reflectors of the climate system, returning back to space a significant part of the income solar radiation, thus cooling the atmosphere. Such clouds can exist in two stable modes, open and closed cells, for a wide range of environmental conditions. This emergent behavior of the system, and its sensitivity to aerosol and environmental properties, is captured by a set of nonlinear equations. Here, using linear stability analysis, we express the transition from steady to a limit-cycle state analytically, showing how it depends on the model parameters. We show that the control of the droplet concentration (N) the environmental carrying-capacity (H0) and the cloud recovery parameter (tau) can be linked by a single nondimensional parameter mu=N/(alfa*tau*H0), suggesting that for deeper clouds the transition from open (oscillating) to closed (stable fixed point) cells will occur for higher droplet concentration (i.e. higher aerosol loading). The analytical calculations of the possible states, and how they are affected by changes in aerosol and the environmental variables, provide an enhanced understanding of the complex interactions of clouds and rain. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2017; v1 submitted 24 August, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 19 pages, 4 figures, accepted to CHAOS

Journal ref: Chaos 27, 013107 (2017), doi: 10.1063/1.4973593

Excitation of slow MJO-like Kelvin waves in the equatorial atmosphere by Yanai wave-group via WISHE-induced convection

Authors: Aviv Solodoch, William Boos, Zhiming Kuang, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: The intraseasonal Madden-Julian oscillation (MJO) involves a slow eastward-propagating signal in the tropical atmosphere which significantly influences climate yet is not well understood despite significant theoretical and observational progress. We study the atmosphere's response to nonlinear "Wind Induced Surface Heat Exchange" (WISHE) forcing in the tropics using a simple shallow water atmo… ▽ More The intraseasonal Madden-Julian oscillation (MJO) involves a slow eastward-propagating signal in the tropical atmosphere which significantly influences climate yet is not well understood despite significant theoretical and observational progress. We study the atmosphere's response to nonlinear "Wind Induced Surface Heat Exchange" (WISHE) forcing in the tropics using a simple shallow water atmospheric model. The model produces an interestingly rich interannual behavior including a slow, eastward propagating equatorial westerly multiscale signal, not consistent with any free linear waves, and with MJO-like characteristics. It is shown that the slow signal is due to a Kelvin wave forced by WISHE due to the meridional wind induced by a Yanai wave group. The forced Kelvin wave has a velocity similar to the group velocity of the Yanai waves, allowing the two to interact nonlinearly via the WISHE term while slowly propagating eastward. These results may have implications for observed tropical WISHE-related atmospheric intraseasonal phenomena. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2010; originally announced February 2010.

Mechanisms of Seasonal - ENSO interaction

Authors: Eli Tziperman, Steve Zebiak, Mark Cane

Abstract: The mechanisms of interaction between the seasonal cycle and ENSO are investigated using the Zebiak and Cane ENSO prediction model. The most dominant seasonal effect is found to be due to the wind divergence field, as determined by the seasonal motion of the ITCZ, through its effect on the atmospheric heating. The next order seasonal effects are due to the seasonality of the background SST and o… ▽ More The mechanisms of interaction between the seasonal cycle and ENSO are investigated using the Zebiak and Cane ENSO prediction model. The most dominant seasonal effect is found to be due to the wind divergence field, as determined by the seasonal motion of the ITCZ, through its effect on the atmospheric heating. The next order seasonal effects are due to the seasonality of the background SST and ocean upwelling velocity, and the corresponding mechanisms are analyzed. It is suggested that the seasonal forcing has a first order effect on ENSO's dynamics. Important aspects of the seasonal forcing may be included in idealized delayed oscillator ENSO models by making the model background seasonally shift from stable to unstable states. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 1995; originally announced August 1995.

Comments: compressed postscript file, figures included Directions for uncompressing are pre-pended to the paper

A linear thermohaline oscillator driven by stochastic atmospheric forcing

Authors: Stephen M. Griffies, Eli Tziperman

Abstract: The interdecadal variability of a stochastically forced four-box model of the oceanic meridional thermohaline circulation (THC) is described and compared to the THC variability in the coupled ocean-atmosphere GCM of Delworth, Manabe, and Stouffer (1993). The box model is placed in a linearly stable thermally dominant mean state under mixed boundary conditions. A linear stability analysis of this s… ▽ More The interdecadal variability of a stochastically forced four-box model of the oceanic meridional thermohaline circulation (THC) is described and compared to the THC variability in the coupled ocean-atmosphere GCM of Delworth, Manabe, and Stouffer (1993). The box model is placed in a linearly stable thermally dominant mean state under mixed boundary conditions. A linear stability analysis of this state reveals one damped oscillatory THC mode in addition to purely damped modes. The variability of the model under a moderate amount of stochastic forcing, meant to emulate the random variability of the atmosphere affecting the coupled model's interdecadal THC variability, is studied. A linear interpretation, in which the damped oscillatory mode is of primary importance, is sufficient for understanding the mechanism accounting for the stochastically forced variability. Direct comparison of the variability in the box model and coupled GCM reveals common qualitative aspects. Such a comparison supports, although does not verify, the hypothesis that the coupled model's THC variability can be interpreted as the result of atmospheric weather exciting a linear damped oscillatory THC mode. △ Less

Submitted 10 March, 1995; v1 submitted 9 February, 1995; originally announced February 1995.

Comments: Paper accepted by Journal of Climate. This is a Latex source file. Figures are included in an adjacent uuencoded file. Directions for uncompressing are pre-pended to the figures. User may wish to obtain postscript version from http://www.gfdl.gov/~smg/pointers/geo_physics_abstracts/GT.html Revisions are merely due to changes in e-print submission format; paper's content has not changed.