-
Disentangling Core and Edge Mechanisms of the L-mode Density Limit in DIII-D
Authors:
R. Hong,
P. H. Diamond,
O. Sauter,
J. Chen,
F. Khabanov,
Z. Li,
D. Liu,
A. Marinoni,
G. R. McKee,
T. L. Rhodes,
F. Scotti,
K. E. Thome,
G. R. Tynan,
M. A. Van Zeeland,
Z. Yan,
L. Zeng,
the DIII-D NT Team
Abstract:
The L-mode density limit is re-examined on the DIII-D tokamak using a negative triangularity configuration to study the underlying physics. We find the limit may not be a singular disruptive boundary but a multifaceted density saturation phenomenon governed by distinct core and edge transport mechanisms. Sustained, non-disruptive operation is achieved at densities up to 1.8 times the Greenwald lim…
▽ More
The L-mode density limit is re-examined on the DIII-D tokamak using a negative triangularity configuration to study the underlying physics. We find the limit may not be a singular disruptive boundary but a multifaceted density saturation phenomenon governed by distinct core and edge transport mechanisms. Sustained, non-disruptive operation is achieved at densities up to 1.8 times the Greenwald limit ($n_\mathrm{G}$) until the termination of auxiliary heating. Systematic power scans reveal distinct power scalings for the core ($n_e \propto P_\mathrm{SOL}^{0.27\pm0.03}$) and edge ($n_e \propto P_\mathrm{SOL}^{0.42\pm0.04}$) density limits. The edge density saturation is triggered abruptly by the onset of a non-disruptive, high-field side radiative instability that clamps the edge density below $n_\mathrm{G}$. In contrast, the core density continues to rise until it saturates at a level featured by substantially enhanced core turbulence. Core transport evolves from a diffusive to an intermittent, avalanche-like state, as indicated by heavy-tailed probability density functions (kurtosis $\approx 6$), elevated Hurst exponents, and a $1/f$-type power spectrum. These findings demonstrate that the L-mode density limit is determined by a combination of edge radiative instabilities and core turbulent transport.This distinction provides separate targets for control strategies aimed at extending the operational space of future fusion devices.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2025; v1 submitted 3 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Determination of confinement regime boundaries via separatrix parameters on Alcator C-Mod based on a model for interchange-drift-Alfvén turbulence
Authors:
M. A. Miller,
J. W. Hughes,
T. Eich,
G. R. Tynan,
P. Manz,
T. Body,
D. Silvagni,
O. Grover,
A. E. Hubbard,
A. Cavallaro,
M. Wigram,
A. Q. Kuang,
S. Mordijck,
B. LaBombard,
J. Dunsmore,
D. Whyte
Abstract:
The separatrix operational space (SepOS) model [Eich \& Manz, \emph{Nuclear Fusion} (2021)] is shown to predict the L-H transition, the L-mode density limit, and the ideal MHD ballooning limit in terms of separatrix parameters for a wide range of Alcator C-Mod plasmas. The model is tested using Thomson scattering measurements across a wide range of operating conditions on C-Mod, spanning…
▽ More
The separatrix operational space (SepOS) model [Eich \& Manz, \emph{Nuclear Fusion} (2021)] is shown to predict the L-H transition, the L-mode density limit, and the ideal MHD ballooning limit in terms of separatrix parameters for a wide range of Alcator C-Mod plasmas. The model is tested using Thomson scattering measurements across a wide range of operating conditions on C-Mod, spanning $\overline{n}_{e} = 0.3 - 5.5 \times 10^{20}$m$^{-3}$, $B_{t} = 2.5 - 8.0$ T, and $B_{p} = 0.1 - 1.2$ T. An empirical regression for the electron pressure gradient scale length, $λ_{p_{e}}$, against a turbulence control parameter, $α_{t}$, and the poloidal fluid gyroradius, $ρ_{s,p}$, for H-modes is constructed and found to require positive exponents for both regression parameters, indicating turbulence widening of near-SOL widths at high $α_{t}$ and an inverse scaling with $B_{p}$, consistent with results on AUG. The SepOS model is also tested in the unfavorable drift direction and found to apply well to all three boundaries, including the L-H transition as long as a correction to the Reynolds energy transfer term, $α_\mathrm{RS} < 1$ is applied. I-modes typically exist in the unfavorable drift direction for values of $α_{t} \lesssim 0.35$. Finally, an experiment studying the transition between the type-I ELMy and EDA H-mode is analyzed using the same framework. It is found that a recently identified boundary at $α_{t} = 0.55$ excludes most EDA H-modes but that the balance of wavenumbers responsible for the L-mode density limit, namely $k_\mathrm{EM} = k_\mathrm{RBM}$, may better describe the transition on C-Mod. The ensemble of boundaries validated and explored is then applied to project regime access and limit avoidance for the SPARC primary reference discharge parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Ion heating in the PISCES-RF liquid-cooled high-power, steady-state, helicon plasma device
Authors:
S. Chakraborty Thakur,
M. Paul,
E. M. Hollmann,
E. Lister,
E. E. Scime,
S. Sadhu,
T. E. Steinberger,
G. R. Tynan
Abstract:
Radio Frequency (RF) driven helicon plasma sources are commonly used for their ability to produce high-density argon plasmas (n > 10^19/m^3) at relatively moderate powers (typical RF power < 2 kW). Typical electron temperatures are < 10 eV and typical ion temperatures are < 0.6 eV. A newly designed helicon antenna assembly (with concentric, double-layered, fully liquid-cooled RF-transparent window…
▽ More
Radio Frequency (RF) driven helicon plasma sources are commonly used for their ability to produce high-density argon plasmas (n > 10^19/m^3) at relatively moderate powers (typical RF power < 2 kW). Typical electron temperatures are < 10 eV and typical ion temperatures are < 0.6 eV. A newly designed helicon antenna assembly (with concentric, double-layered, fully liquid-cooled RF-transparent windows) operates in steady-state at RF powers up to 10 kW. We report on the dependence of argon plasma density, electron temperature and ion temperature on RF power. At 10 kW, ion temperatures > 2 eV in argon plasmas are measured with laser induced fluorescence, which is consistent with a simple volume averaged 0-D power balance model. 1-D Monte Carlo simulations of the neutral density profile for these plasma conditions show strong neutral depletion near the core and predict neutral temperatures well above room temperatures. The plasmas created in this high-power helicon source (when light ions are employed) are ideally suited for fusion divertor plasma-material interaction studies and negative ion production for neutral beams.
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
PISCES-RF: a liquid-cooled high-power steady-state helicon plasma device
Authors:
Saikat Chakraborty Thakur,
Michael J. Simmonds,
Juan F. Caneses,
Fengjen Chang,
Eric M. Hollmann Russell P. Doerner,
Richard Goulding,
Arnold Lumsdaine,
Juergen Rapp,
George R. Tynan
Abstract:
Radio-frequency (RF) driven helicon plasma sources can produce relatively high-density plasmas (n > 10^19 m-3) at relatively moderate powers (< 2 kW) in argon. However, to produce similar high-density plasmas for fusion relevant gases such as hydrogen, deuterium and helium, much higher RF powers are needed. For very high RF powers, thermal issues of the RF-transparent dielectric window, used in th…
▽ More
Radio-frequency (RF) driven helicon plasma sources can produce relatively high-density plasmas (n > 10^19 m-3) at relatively moderate powers (< 2 kW) in argon. However, to produce similar high-density plasmas for fusion relevant gases such as hydrogen, deuterium and helium, much higher RF powers are needed. For very high RF powers, thermal issues of the RF-transparent dielectric window, used in the RF source design, limit the plasma operation timescales. To mitigate this constraint, we have designed, built and tested a novel liquid-cooled RF window which allows steady state operations at high power (up to 20 kW). De-ionized (DI) water, flowing between two concentric dielectric RF windows, is used as the coolant. We show that a full azimuthal blanket of DI water does not degrade plasma production. We obtain steady-state, high-density plasmas (n > 10^19 m-3, T_e ~ 5 eV) using both argon and hydrogen. From calorimetry on the DI water, we measure the net heat that is being removed by the coolant at steady state conditions. Using infra-red (IR) imaging, we calculate the constant plasma heat deposition and measure the final steady state temperature distribution patterns on the inner surface of the ceramic layer. We find that the heat deposition pattern follows the helical shape of the antenna. We also show the consistency between the heat absorbed by the DI water, as measured by calorimetry, and the total heat due to the combined effect of the plasma heating and the absorbed RF. These results are being used to answer critical engineering questions for the 200 kW RF device (MPEX: Materials Plasma Exposure eXperiment) being designed at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) as a next generation plasma material interaction (PMI) device.
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2020; v1 submitted 22 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Generation of parasitic axial flow by drift wave turbulence with broken symmetry: Theory and experiment
Authors:
R. Hong,
J. C. Li,
R. Hajjar. Chakraborty Thakur,
P. H. Diamond,
G. R. Tynan
Abstract:
Detailed measurements of intrinsic axial flow generation parallel to the magnetic field in the controlled shear decorrelation experiment linear plasma device with no axial momentum input are presented and compared to theory. The results show a causal link from the density gradient to drift-wave turbulence with broken spectral symmetry and development of the axial mean parallel flow. As the density…
▽ More
Detailed measurements of intrinsic axial flow generation parallel to the magnetic field in the controlled shear decorrelation experiment linear plasma device with no axial momentum input are presented and compared to theory. The results show a causal link from the density gradient to drift-wave turbulence with broken spectral symmetry and development of the axial mean parallel flow. As the density gradient steepens, the axial and azimuthal Reynolds stresses increase and radially sheared azimuthal and axial mean flows develop. A turbulent axial momentum balance analysis shows that the axial Reynolds stress drives the radially sheared axial mean flow. The turbulent drive (Reynolds power) for the azimuthal flow is an order of magnitude greater than that for axial flow, suggesting that the turbulence fluctuation levels are set by azimuthal flow shear regulation. The direct energy exchange between axial and azimuthal mean flows is shown to be insignificant. Therefore, the axial flow is parasitic to the turbulence-zonal flow system and is driven primarily by the axial turbulent stress generated by that system. The non-diffusive, residual part of the axial Reynolds stress is found to be proportional to the density gradient and is formed due to dynamical asymmetry in the drift-wave turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Tracing the Pathway from Drift-Wave Turbulence with Broken Symmetry to the Generation of Sheared Axial Mean Flow
Authors:
R. Hong,
J. C. Li,
R. Hajjar,
S. C. Thakur,
P. H. Diamond,
G. R. Tynan
Abstract:
This study traces the emergence of sheared axial flow from collisional drift wave turbulence with broken symmetry in a linear plasma device---CSDX. As the density profile steepens, the axial Reynolds stress develops and drives a radially sheared axial flow that is parallel to the magnetic field. Results show that the non-diffusive piece of the Reynolds stress is driven by the density gradient and…
▽ More
This study traces the emergence of sheared axial flow from collisional drift wave turbulence with broken symmetry in a linear plasma device---CSDX. As the density profile steepens, the axial Reynolds stress develops and drives a radially sheared axial flow that is parallel to the magnetic field. Results show that the non-diffusive piece of the Reynolds stress is driven by the density gradient and results from the spectral asymmetry of the turbulence and thus is dynamical in origin. Taken together, these findings constitute the first simultaneous demonstration of the causal link between the density gradient, turbulence and stress with broken spectral symmetry, and the mean axial flow.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2018; v1 submitted 27 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Deuterium retention and thermal conductivity in ion-beam displacement-damaged tungsten
Authors:
George R. Tynan,
Russell P. Doerner,
J. Barton,
R. Chen,
S. Cui,
M. Simmonds,
Y. Wang,
J. S. Weaver,
N. Mara,
S. Pathak
Abstract:
Retention of plasma-implanted D is studied in W targets damaged by a Cu ion beam at up to 0.2 dpa with sample temperatures between 300 K and 1200 K. At a D plasma ion fluence of $10^{24}/m^2$ on samples damaged to 0.2 dpa at 300 K, the retained D retention inventory is $4.6x10^{20} D/m^2$, about ~5.5 times higher than in undamaged samples. The retained inventory drops to $9x10^{19} D/m^2$ for samp…
▽ More
Retention of plasma-implanted D is studied in W targets damaged by a Cu ion beam at up to 0.2 dpa with sample temperatures between 300 K and 1200 K. At a D plasma ion fluence of $10^{24}/m^2$ on samples damaged to 0.2 dpa at 300 K, the retained D retention inventory is $4.6x10^{20} D/m^2$, about ~5.5 times higher than in undamaged samples. The retained inventory drops to $9x10^{19} D/m^2$ for samples damaged to 0.2 dpa at 1000 K, consistent with onset of vacancy annealing at a rate sufficient to overcome the elevated rate of ion beam damage; at a damage temperature of 1200 K retention is nearly equal to values seen in undamaged materials. A nano-scale technique provides thermal conductivity measurements from the Cu- ion beam displacement damaged region. We find the thermal conductivity of W damaged to 0.2 dpa at room temperature drops from the un-irradiated value of 182 +/- 3.3 W/m-K to 53 +/- 8 W/m-K.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Edge Shear Flows and Particle Transport near the Density Limit in the HL-2A Tokamak
Authors:
R. Hong,
G. R. Tynan,
P. H. Diamond,
L. Nie,
D. Guo,
L. Ting,
R. Ke,
Y. Wu,
B. Yuan,
M. Xu
Abstract:
Edge shear flow and its effect on regulating turbulent transport have long been suspected to play an important role in plasmas operating near the Greenwald density limit $ n_G $. In this study, equilibrium profiles as well as the turbulent particle flux and Reynolds stress across the separatrix in the HL-2A tokamak are examined as $ n_G $ is approached in ohmic L-mode discharges. As the normalized…
▽ More
Edge shear flow and its effect on regulating turbulent transport have long been suspected to play an important role in plasmas operating near the Greenwald density limit $ n_G $. In this study, equilibrium profiles as well as the turbulent particle flux and Reynolds stress across the separatrix in the HL-2A tokamak are examined as $ n_G $ is approached in ohmic L-mode discharges. As the normalized line-averaged density $ \bar{n}_e/n_G $ is raised, the shearing rate of the mean poloidal flow $ ω_{\rm sh} $ drops, and the turbulent drive for the low-frequency zonal flow (the Reynolds power $ \mathcal{P}_{Re} $) collapses. Correspondingly, the turbulent particle transport increases drastically with increasing collision rates. The geodesic acoustic modes (GAMs) gain more energy from the ambient turbulence at higher densities, but have smaller shearing rate than low-frequency zonal flows. The increased density also introduces decreased adiabaticity which not only enhances the particle transport but is also related to a reduction in the eddy-tilting and the Reynolds power. Both effects may lead to the cooling of edge plasmas and therefore the onset of MHD instabilities that limit the plasma density.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2018; v1 submitted 3 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Characterization of SOL Plasma Flows and Potentials in Alcator C-Mod
Authors:
R. Hong,
S. J. Wukitch,
Y. Lin,
J. L. Terry,
I. Cziegler,
M. L. Reinke,
G. R. Tynan
Abstract:
Gas-puff imaging techniques are employed to determine the far SOL region radial electric field and the plasma potential in ICRF heated discharges in the Alcator C-Mod tokamak. The 2-dimensional velocity fields of the turbulent structures, which are advected by RF-induced $ \mathbf{E\times B} $ flows, are obtained via the time-delay estimation (TDE) techniques. Both the magnitude and radial extensi…
▽ More
Gas-puff imaging techniques are employed to determine the far SOL region radial electric field and the plasma potential in ICRF heated discharges in the Alcator C-Mod tokamak. The 2-dimensional velocity fields of the turbulent structures, which are advected by RF-induced $ \mathbf{E\times B} $ flows, are obtained via the time-delay estimation (TDE) techniques. Both the magnitude and radial extension of the radial electric field $ E_r $ are observed to increase with the toroidal magnetic field strength $ B_\varphi $ and the ICRF power. In particular, the RF-induced $ E_r $ extends from the vicinity of the ICRF antenna to the separatrix when $ B_\varphi=7.9\,\mathrm{T} $ and $ P_{\mathrm{ICRF}} \gtrsim 1\,\mathrm{MW} $. In addition, low-Z impurity seeding near the antenna is found to substantially reduce the sheath potential associated with ICRF power. The ICRF-induced potentials are also estimated in different antenna configurations: (1) conventional toroidally-aligned (TA) antenna versus field-aligned (FA) antenna; (2) FA monopole versus FA dipole. Results show that FA and TA antennas produce similar magnitude of plasma potentials, and the FA monopole induced greater potential than the FA dipole phasing.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2018; v1 submitted 22 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
A fast low-to-high mode bifurcation dynamics in a tokamak edge plasma gyrokinetic simulation
Authors:
C. S. Chang,
S. Ku,
G. R. Tynan,
R. Hager,
R. M. Churchill,
I. Cziegler,
M. Greenwald,
A. E. Hubbard,
J. W. Hughes
Abstract:
Transport barrier formation and its relation to sheared flows in fluids and plasmas are of fundamental interest in various natural and laboratory observations and of critical importance in achieving an economical energy production in a magnetic fusion device. Here we report the first observation of an edge transport barrier formation event in a gyrokinetic simulation carried out in a realistic tok…
▽ More
Transport barrier formation and its relation to sheared flows in fluids and plasmas are of fundamental interest in various natural and laboratory observations and of critical importance in achieving an economical energy production in a magnetic fusion device. Here we report the first observation of an edge transport barrier formation event in a gyrokinetic simulation carried out in a realistic tokamak edge geometry. The results show that turbulent Reynolds stress driven sheared ExB flows act in concert with neoclassical orbit loss to quench turbulent transport and form a transport barrier just inside the last closed magnetic flux surface.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2017; v1 submitted 19 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
