Showing 1–41 of 41 results for author: Tiwari, S C

A note on diffeomorphism-invariance in gravitational field equations

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: The notion of diffeomorphism invariance and general covariance are conceptually delicate issues for the field equations and the actions. A thorough study on the original Einstein field equation and its two modifications by Einstein is presented. It is concluded that the cosmological constant and the unimodular condition are independent concepts, and the unimodular condition has no direct role in t… ▽ More The notion of diffeomorphism invariance and general covariance are conceptually delicate issues for the field equations and the actions. A thorough study on the original Einstein field equation and its two modifications by Einstein is presented. It is concluded that the cosmological constant and the unimodular condition are independent concepts, and the unimodular condition has no direct role in the derivation of the traceless field equation. Unimodular gravity with unambiguous action does not exist, and the derivation of traceless equation from the action principle is an open question. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

Comments: 7 pages

Physical mechanism for the geometric phases in optics and angular momentum holonomy

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: Vast literature on the experiments and mathematical formulations on the geometric phases signifies the importance of this subject. Physical mechanism for the origin of the geometric phases in optics was suggested in 1992 by the author in terms of the exchange of the angular momentum. Some of the literature has taken notice of it, however, the real import of the suggested mechanism and the angular… ▽ More Vast literature on the experiments and mathematical formulations on the geometric phases signifies the importance of this subject. Physical mechanism for the origin of the geometric phases in optics was suggested in 1992 by the author in terms of the exchange of the angular momentum. Some of the literature has taken notice of it, however, the real import of the suggested mechanism and the angular momentum holonomy conjecture has remained elusive. The present contribution delineates the prevailing confusions and offers a thorough discussion on the nature of the light waves to resolve the conceptual issues. It is argued that at a fundamental level there exist only two types of geometric phases arising from (i) the geometry of the wave vector space, and (ii) the polarization state space. For the light beams of definite polarization spatial modes (HG or LG modes) the geometric phase has origin in the wave vector space that is different than the spin redirection phase for the polarized light. Angular momentum holonomy is proposed to be equivalent to the geometric phase in general. △ Less

Submitted 3 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 25 pages

Topological photon, spin, and Euclidean group E(2)

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: The proposition that photon is a topological object (J. Math. Phys. 49, 032303, 2008) is given rigorous foundation based on pure vector field theory independent of the electromagnetic fields. Holomorphy of 4-dimensional space-time and the nature of topological obstructions are investigated to articulate singular vortex model for photon. The utility of the Euclidean symmetry group is discussed in d… ▽ More The proposition that photon is a topological object (J. Math. Phys. 49, 032303, 2008) is given rigorous foundation based on pure vector field theory independent of the electromagnetic fields. Holomorphy of 4-dimensional space-time and the nature of topological obstructions are investigated to articulate singular vortex model for photon. The utility of the Euclidean symmetry group is discussed in detail for the proposed photon model. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 13 pages

Symmetry of Dirac two-oscillator system, gauge-invariance, and Landau problem

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: Role of gauge symmetry in the proton spin problem has intricate and unresolved aspects. One of the interesting approaches to gain physical insights is to explore tha Landau problem in this context. A detailed study using the group theoretic method to understand the Landau problem establishes the significance of the gauge transformation intimately related with the space translation symmetry. An imp… ▽ More Role of gauge symmetry in the proton spin problem has intricate and unresolved aspects. One of the interesting approaches to gain physical insights is to explore tha Landau problem in this context. A detailed study using the group theoretic method to understand the Landau problem establishes the significance of the gauge transformation intimately related with the space translation symmetry. An important implication of this result is that the E(2)-like Wigner's little group for massless particles could throw more light on the question of gauge symmetry in QED and QCD. A generalized Landau-Zeeman Hamiltonian is proposed in which Dirac two-oscillator system and the symmetry of the group SO(3,2) become important. It is argued that nontrivial topology of pure gauge field holds promise to resolve the unsettled questions. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 12 pages

Journal ref: Modern Physics Letters A 2023

New Approach to Unimodular Relativity

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: A thorough study and analysis on the conceptual foundations of unimodular gravity shows that this theory is essentially general relativity disguised as unimodular relativity in the literature. The main reason for this dilemma is accepting the Einsteinian paradigm: general relativistic framework, covariant divergence law for matter energy-momentum tensor, and cosmological constant as an integration… ▽ More A thorough study and analysis on the conceptual foundations of unimodular gravity shows that this theory is essentially general relativity disguised as unimodular relativity in the literature. The main reason for this dilemma is accepting the Einsteinian paradigm: general relativistic framework, covariant divergence law for matter energy-momentum tensor, and cosmological constant as an integration constant, but introducing the artefact of unimodular description absent in Einstein's work. A new approach is proposed in this paper in which pure unimodular relativity is defined in terms of equi-projective geodesics with the fundamental metric tensor having determinant unity and the geometric tensors constructed from them. Modification of covariant divergence law for the matter energy-momentum tensor is shown to have two new consequences. In the conventional unimodular gravity an effective cosmological term comprising of two variable scalar fields, namely, the unimodular geometric ambiguity and unimodular matter energy ambiguity, is proposed. A radical departure on the cosmological constant problem is possible assuming differing evolution of the two scalars: the Einstein equations emerge when the two ambiguities cancel each other. Secondly, in the case of pure unimodular relativity the gravitational field equations are proposed consistent with the unimodular space-time structure. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2023; v1 submitted 12 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: This version is published one

Journal ref: Physica Scripta, 98 065303, 2023

Dirac representation of the group SO(3,2) and the Landau problem

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: A systematic study carried out on the infinite degeneracy and the constants of motion in the Landau problem establishes the central extension of the Euclidean group in two dimension as a dynamical symmetry group, and Sp(2,R) as spectrum generating group irrespective of the choice of the gauge. It may be noted that the siginificance of the Euclidean group was already implicit in the earlier works o… ▽ More A systematic study carried out on the infinite degeneracy and the constants of motion in the Landau problem establishes the central extension of the Euclidean group in two dimension as a dynamical symmetry group, and Sp(2,R) as spectrum generating group irrespective of the choice of the gauge. It may be noted that the siginificance of the Euclidean group was already implicit in the earlier works on the Landau problem; in the present paper the method of group contraction plays an important role. Dirac's remarkable representation of the group SO(3,2) and the isomorphism of this group with Sp(4,R) are re-visited. New insights are gained on the meaning of two-oscillator system in Dirac representation. It is argued that in view of the fact that even the two dimensional isotropic oscillator having SU(2) as dynamical symmetry group does not arise in the Landau problem the relevance or applicability of SO(3,2) group becomes invalid. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2023; v1 submitted 22 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: Appendix added and left out term in one of the equations inserted

Comment on 'New perspective on thermodynamics of spacetime: The emergence of unimodular gravity and the equivalence of entropies'

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: In this comment on the article by Alonso-Serrano and Liska (arXiv: 2008.04805) a formal resemblance between their expression of curvature scale and the scale dependent on the matter energy-momentum ambiguity of Finkelstein et al (JMP, 2001) is pointed out. Physical significance of this observation is also discussed. In this comment on the article by Alonso-Serrano and Liska (arXiv: 2008.04805) a formal resemblance between their expression of curvature scale and the scale dependent on the matter energy-momentum ambiguity of Finkelstein et al (JMP, 2001) is pointed out. Physical significance of this observation is also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 4 March, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 2 pages

Computational framework for polymer synthesis to study dielectric properties using polarizable reactive molecular dynamics

Authors: Ankit Mishra, Lihua Chen, ZongZe Li, Ken-ichi Nomura, Aravind Krishnamoorthy, Shogo Fukushima, Subodh C. Tiwari, Rajiv K. Kalia, Aiichiro Nakano, Rampi Ramprasad, Greg Sotzing, Yang Cao, Fuyuki Shimojo, Priya Vashishta

Abstract: The increased energy and power density required in modern electronics poses a challenge for designing new dielectric polymer materials with high energy density while maintaining low loss at high applied electric fields. Recently, an advanced computational screening method coupled with hierarchical modelling has accelerated the identification of promising high energy density materials. It is well k… ▽ More The increased energy and power density required in modern electronics poses a challenge for designing new dielectric polymer materials with high energy density while maintaining low loss at high applied electric fields. Recently, an advanced computational screening method coupled with hierarchical modelling has accelerated the identification of promising high energy density materials. It is well known that the dielectric response of polymeric materials is largely influenced by their phases and local heterogeneous structures as well as operational temperature. Such inputs are crucial to accelerate the design and discovery of potential polymer candidates. However, an efficient computational framework to probe temperature dependence of the dielectric properties of polymers, while incorporating effects controlled by their morphology is still lacking. In this paper, we propose a scalable computational framework based on reactive molecular dynamics with a valence-state aware polarizable charge model, which is capable of handling practically relevant polymer morphologies and simultaneously provide near-quantum accuracy in estimating dielectric properties of various polymer systems. We demonstrate the predictive power of our framework on high energy density polymer systems recently identified through rational experimental-theoretical co-design. Our scalable and automated framework may be used for high-throughput theoretical screenings of combinatorial large design space to identify next-generation high energy density polymer materials. △ Less

Submitted 18 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Weyl geometry, topology of space-time and reality of electromagnetic potentials, and new perspective on particle physics

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Consistency of Weyl natural gauge, Lorentz gauge and nonlinear gauge is studied in Weyl geometry. Field equations in generalized Weyl-Dirac theory show that spinless electron and photon are topological defects. Statistical metric and fluctuating metric in 3D space with time as a measure of spatial relations are discussed to propose a statistical interpretation of Maxwell field equations. It is arg… ▽ More Consistency of Weyl natural gauge, Lorentz gauge and nonlinear gauge is studied in Weyl geometry. Field equations in generalized Weyl-Dirac theory show that spinless electron and photon are topological defects. Statistical metric and fluctuating metric in 3D space with time as a measure of spatial relations are discussed to propose a statistical interpretation of Maxwell field equations. It is argued that physical geometry is an approximation to mathematical geometry, and 4D relativistic spacetime is essentially 3D space with changing spatial relations. The present work is suggested to have radical new outlook on elementary particle physics. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2020; v1 submitted 14 August, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 16 pages, revised version published in Physica Scripta

Journal ref: Physica Scripta, 2020

Anomalous magnetic moment and vortex structure of the electron

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: The electron magnetic moment decomposition calculated in QED is proposed to have origin in a multi-vortex internal structure of the electron. This proposition is founded on two important contributions of the present work. First, a critical review on Weyl model of electron, Einstein-Rosen bridge and Wheeler's wormholes leads to a new idea of a topological defect in cylindrical space-time geometry a… ▽ More The electron magnetic moment decomposition calculated in QED is proposed to have origin in a multi-vortex internal structure of the electron. This proposition is founded on two important contributions of the present work. First, a critical review on Weyl model of electron, Einstein-Rosen bridge and Wheeler's wormholes leads to a new idea of a topological defect in cylindrical space-time geometry as a natural representation of the electron. A concrete realization of this idea in terms of the derivation of a new vortex-metric, and its physical interpretation to establish the geometric origin of the electron magnetic moment decomposition constitute the second contribution. Remarkable occurrence of a vortex structure in the basis mode function used in BLFQ is also pointed out indicating wider ramification of the proposed electron model. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 10 pages

Journal ref: Modern Physics Letters A Vol. 33, No. 31, 1850180 (2018)

Real wave equations, spin origin of charge, and outlook on particle physics

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: Radical revision on the conventional spacetime picture, illusion or emergent phenomenon, has been the focus of the speculations on the unified frameworks for fundamental interactions in nature. Compared to strong experimental credence to the standard model of particle physics there is practically no relation of these speculations with the world of real particles. In this paper we present a new con… ▽ More Radical revision on the conventional spacetime picture, illusion or emergent phenomenon, has been the focus of the speculations on the unified frameworks for fundamental interactions in nature. Compared to strong experimental credence to the standard model of particle physics there is practically no relation of these speculations with the world of real particles. In this paper we present a new conceptual framework for particle physics in which nontrivial geometry and topology of space and time have fundamental reality. To develop this model we proceed with the analysis of the standard wave equations and make them real using the transformation rule $i=\sqrt{-1} \rightarrow C=\begin{bmatrix} 0 & 1 \\ -1 & 0 \end{bmatrix}$. Topological significance is attached to $i$ in terms of a point defect in 1D directed line. New interpretation of Schroedinger wave equation and $Z_2$ vortex throw light on the nature of spin. A new meaning is also obtained on U(1) gauge symmetry and charge. Novel properties of C-matrix and known applications are presented. Topological origin of spin is inferred from the interpretation of Pauli algebra that they signify 2D directed area in phase space as topological obstruction. Electron magnetic moment decomposition in QED serves the basis for the proposition: spin origin of charge (SOC). A dynamical logarithmic spiral geometric structure comprising of 2+1D braids, 3 vortices with associated three 2-spinors is envisaged based on SOC. It is termed as meta-electron; meta-neutrino has 2-vortex structure. These are the only building blocks of all particles having the knotted vortex structures in our model. Coupling strengths of the three fundamental interactions are related with the magnitudes of the spin angular momentum of constituent spinors of the meta-electron. △ Less

Submitted 15 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 24 pages

Stochasticity, topology, and spin

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: Complex Schroedinger equation is transformed to spinor or coupled scalar field equations replacing the imaginary unit $i$ by a matrix $\begin{bmatrix} 0 & 1 \\-1 & 0 \end{bmatrix}$. New perspecive on stochasic approach is developed with spin as topological invariant and mass having stochastic origin in this Spinor Random Field formalism. Complex Schroedinger equation is transformed to spinor or coupled scalar field equations replacing the imaginary unit $i$ by a matrix $\begin{bmatrix} 0 & 1 \\-1 & 0 \end{bmatrix}$. New perspecive on stochasic approach is developed with spin as topological invariant and mass having stochastic origin in this Spinor Random Field formalism. △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 5 pages

Journal ref: Quantum Stud.: Math. Found. 2019

Physics and mathematical reality: comments on Aharonov et al, arXiv:1902.08798

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Do we have two kinds of reality: physical and mathematical? What is the role of mathematics in physics? These fundamental questions have intrigued original and brilliant minds since ancient times. A recent article (Aharonov, Cohen and Oaknin, arXiv:1902.08798) offers a viewpoint on the use of abstract mathematics in quantum theory. They argue that, in some cases, it may result into a paradox focus… ▽ More Do we have two kinds of reality: physical and mathematical? What is the role of mathematics in physics? These fundamental questions have intrigued original and brilliant minds since ancient times. A recent article (Aharonov, Cohen and Oaknin, arXiv:1902.08798) offers a viewpoint on the use of abstract mathematics in quantum theory. They argue that, in some cases, it may result into a paradox focusing on an example in quantum mechanics regarding Aharonov-Bergmann-Lebowitz (ABL) rule. In this comment we discuss three issues: theory reduction and approximation, origin of a paradox, and the reality of time. It is pointed out that paradoxes appear even in mathematics; we explain them as the results of the acceptance of pure logical artifacts. In physics too, the impact of the so called quantum and relativity revolutions, have led to the emergence of counter-intuitive and mysterious notion of the physical reality. The most fundamental change has been on rejecting the reality of time. A radically new perspective that physics is the language of mathematics is suggested. The mathematical reality of the natural numbers manifests in the form of physical time. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 5 pages

Coulomb- quantum oscillator correspondence in two dimension, pure gauge field and half-quantized vortex

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Isotropic oscillator and Coulomb problems are known to have interesting correspondence. We focus on 2D quantum problems and present complete treatment on the correspondence including the Schroedinger equation, eigenfunctions and eigenvalues, and the integrals of motion. We find only partial equivalence. The wavefunction correspondence is examined introducing local gauge transformation and the emer… ▽ More Isotropic oscillator and Coulomb problems are known to have interesting correspondence. We focus on 2D quantum problems and present complete treatment on the correspondence including the Schroedinger equation, eigenfunctions and eigenvalues, and the integrals of motion. We find only partial equivalence. The wavefunction correspondence is examined introducing local gauge transformation and the emergence of half-quantized vortex with the associated spin-half is established. Vortex structure of the electron proposed by us and the origin of charge are discussed in the present context. Outlook on the implications for QCD and hadron spectrum is outlined. △ Less

Submitted 31 January, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 7 pages

Journal ref: Mod. Phys. Letters A 34, 1950128 (2019)

Magnon-phonon conversion experiment and phonon spin

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: Recent experiment demonstrates magnon to phonon conversion in a YIG film under the application of a non-uniform magnetic field. Light scattered from phonons is observed to change its polarization state interpreted by the authors signifying phonon spin. In this note we argue that the experimental data merely shows the exchange of angular momentum $\pm \hbar$ per photon. We suggest that it has physi… ▽ More Recent experiment demonstrates magnon to phonon conversion in a YIG film under the application of a non-uniform magnetic field. Light scattered from phonons is observed to change its polarization state interpreted by the authors signifying phonon spin. In this note we argue that the experimental data merely shows the exchange of angular momentum $\pm \hbar$ per photon. We suggest that it has physical origin in the orbital angular momentum of phonons. The distinction between spin and orbital parts of the total angular momentum, and between phonons and photons with added emphasis on their polarizations is explained. The main conclusion of the present note is that phonon spin hypothesis is unphysical. △ Less

Submitted 6 August, 2018; v1 submitted 17 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 4 pages, a new section added to elaborate the discussion on phonon-photon analogy

Do phonons carry spin?

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: Recently the question of phonon angular momentum has been raised : phonon angular momentum in a magnetic crystal could play an important role in the angular momentum balance in the Einstein-de Haas effect. This proposition is quite natural and understandable, however the idea of phonon spin seems ambiguous in the literature. In 1988 McLellan presented phonon angular momentum states for circular an… ▽ More Recently the question of phonon angular momentum has been raised : phonon angular momentum in a magnetic crystal could play an important role in the angular momentum balance in the Einstein-de Haas effect. This proposition is quite natural and understandable, however the idea of phonon spin seems ambiguous in the literature. In 1988 McLellan presented phonon angular momentum states for circular and elliptical polarizations of phonons that represent orbital angular momentum and also pointed out analogy to isotropic quantum harmonic oscillator. In view of its fundamental importance we investigate this issue and conclude that phonon spin hypothesis is physically untenable, and the phonon angular momentum has to be interpreted as orbital. The photon-phonon analogy is also misleading. It is argued that Cosserat elastic medium having internal torque may have lattice excitations different from phonons having spin one or spin two that we term as Cosseratons. In addition a new source of angular momentum balance originationg from anomalous electron magnetic moment is suggested. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2017; v1 submitted 18 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: Literature survey shows that already in 1988 McLellan discussed phonon angular momentum. The abstract and Introduction are revised in this light. Appendix and four new references added to address some questions

Spintronics: Maxwell-Dirac theory, charge and spin

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: The nature of spin current and the separation of charge current and spin current are two of the fundamental questions in spintronics. For this purpose the classical limit of the Maxwell-Dirac theory is investigated in the present contribution. Since the Dirac equation reduces to the Weyl equation for massless particles, a vortex solution is obtained for the Weyl equation and it is argued that mass… ▽ More The nature of spin current and the separation of charge current and spin current are two of the fundamental questions in spintronics. For this purpose the classical limit of the Maxwell-Dirac theory is investigated in the present contribution. Since the Dirac equation reduces to the Weyl equation for massless particles, a vortex solution is obtained for the Weyl equation and it is argued that mass has stochastic origin. The Weyl vortex is embedded in a Gaussian wavepacket to define physical vortex. Two-vortex internal structure of electron is developed in terms of Weyl and sub-quantum Weyl vortices characterized by $\hbar$ and $f=e^2/2πc$ respectively. It is suggested that this model may find application in spintronics with a new perspective. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 10 pages

Comment on 'Relativistic electron wavepackets carrying angular momentum'

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: This is a comment on arXiv:1611.04445 (PRL, 118, 114801 (2017)). It is pointed out that the fundamental problems in light beam vortices and the relativistic electron vortices are not identical and have subtle differences. The significance of two length scales is underlined for the electron vortices. Local gauge transformation on the Gordon current admits vortex structure. This is a comment on arXiv:1611.04445 (PRL, 118, 114801 (2017)). It is pointed out that the fundamental problems in light beam vortices and the relativistic electron vortices are not identical and have subtle differences. The significance of two length scales is underlined for the electron vortices. Local gauge transformation on the Gordon current admits vortex structure. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 2 pages

Proton spin: a topological invariant

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: Proton spin problem is given a new perspective with the proposition that spin is a topological invariant represented by a de Rham 3-period. The idea is developed generalizing Finkelstein-Rubinstein theory for Skyrmions/kinks to topological defects, and using nonabelian de Rham theorems. Two kinds of de Rham theorems are discussed applicable to matrix valued differential forms, and traces. Physical… ▽ More Proton spin problem is given a new perspective with the proposition that spin is a topological invariant represented by a de Rham 3-period. The idea is developed generalizing Finkelstein-Rubinstein theory for Skyrmions/kinks to topological defects, and using nonabelian de Rham theorems. Two kinds of de Rham theorems are discussed applicable to matrix valued differential forms, and traces. Physical and mathematical interpretations of de Rham periods are presented. It is suggested that Wilson lines and loop operators probe the local properties of the topology, and spin as a topological invariant in pDIS measurements could appear with any value from 0 to $\frac{\hbar}{2}$, i. e. proton spin decomposition has no meaning in this approach. △ Less

Submitted 9 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: Published in IJMPA

Journal ref: International Journal of Modern Physics A Vol. 31, 1650174(2016)

Comment on 'Attempts to test an alternative electrodynamic theory of superconductors by low-temperature scanning tunneling and atomic force microscopy'

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: It is argued that alternative electrodynamics of superconductivity proposed by Hirsch lacks mathematical rigour and it is conceptually flawed. Gauge non-invariance of the theory makes justification of the experiment reported in [arXiv:1607.05060] to test its prediction doubtful. It seems even with improved techniques the outcome would remain inconclusive. It is argued that alternative electrodynamics of superconductivity proposed by Hirsch lacks mathematical rigour and it is conceptually flawed. Gauge non-invariance of the theory makes justification of the experiment reported in [arXiv:1607.05060] to test its prediction doubtful. It seems even with improved techniques the outcome would remain inconclusive. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2016; v1 submitted 28 November, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 3 pages A note based on the original London and London (1935) paper is added

Physical reality of electromagnetic potentials and the classical limit of the Aharonov-Bohm effect

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Recent literature on the Aharonov-Bohm effect has raised fundamental questions on the classical correspondence of this effect and the physical reality of the electromagnetic potentials in quantum mechanics. Reappraisal on Feynman's approach to the classical limit of AB effect is presented. The critique throws light on the significance of quantum interference and quantum phase shifts in any such cl… ▽ More Recent literature on the Aharonov-Bohm effect has raised fundamental questions on the classical correspondence of this effect and the physical reality of the electromagnetic potentials in quantum mechanics. Reappraisal on Feynman's approach to the classical limit of AB effect is presented. The critique throws light on the significance of quantum interference and quantum phase shifts in any such classical correspondence. Detailed analysis shows that Feynman arguments are untenable on physical grounds and the claim made in the original AB paper that this effect had no classical analog seems valid. The importance of nonintegrable phase factor distinct from the AB phase factor, here termed as Fock-London-Weyl phase factor for the historical reasons, is underlined in connection with the classical aspects/limits. A topological approach incorporating the physical significance of the interaction field momentum is proposed. A new idea emerges from this approach that attributes the origin of the AB effect to the exchange of modular angular momentum. △ Less

Submitted 12 August, 2017; v1 submitted 11 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: Section III revised, 10 pages, 4 figures, Quantum Studies: Mathematics and Foundations Online published 11 August, 2017

Journal ref: Quantum Stud. :Math. Found volume 5, number 2 pp 279-205 (2018)

Topological approach to proton spin problem: decomposition controversy and beyond

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Lorentz covariant and gauge invariant definitions of quark and gluon spin and orbital angular momenta continue to pose a great theoretical challenge. A major controversy on the fundamental concepts followed Chen et al proposal: the basic idea is to split the gauge potential into pure gauge and physical components motivated by the gauge symmetry. We term it gauge symmetry paradigm (GSP) to distingu… ▽ More Lorentz covariant and gauge invariant definitions of quark and gluon spin and orbital angular momenta continue to pose a great theoretical challenge. A major controversy on the fundamental concepts followed Chen et al proposal: the basic idea is to split the gauge potential into pure gauge and physical components motivated by the gauge symmetry. We term it gauge symmetry paradigm (GSP) to distinguish it from the well-known inertial frame dependent transverse-longitudinal decomposition (TLP). A thorough study adhering to the traditional meaning of Lorentz covariance and gauge invariance is reported; it leads to a new result: logically consistent development of GSP does not exist and Chen et al proposal turns out to be either trivial or metamorphosed into TLP. Going beyond the controversy and the spin sum rules the necessity for a nonperurbative QCD approach to address the proton spin problem is underlined. We suggest topological approach: generalized de Rham theorems for QCD, and spin as a topological invariant for baryons are discussed. Nonabelian Stokes theorem is applied to derive color flux for the closed loop in a variant of Burkardt's U-shaped path. Similarity between Chen et al decomposition and Kondo decomposition of the gauge potential is suggestive of a topological perspective on the Chen et al proposal with interesting physics △ Less

Submitted 25 May, 2016; v1 submitted 10 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: An appendix is added to explain the applicability of de Rham theorems to Lorentzian manifolds and nonabelian gauge theories; and two new references are added

Lorentz covariance and gauge invariance in the proton spin problem

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: In this brief note insightful remarks are made on the controversy on the decomposition of the proton spin into the spin and orbital angular momenta of quarks and gluons. It is argued that the difference in the perception on the nature of the problem is the main reason for the persistent disputes. There is no decomposition that simultaneously satisfies the twin principles of manifest Lorentz covari… ▽ More In this brief note insightful remarks are made on the controversy on the decomposition of the proton spin into the spin and orbital angular momenta of quarks and gluons. It is argued that the difference in the perception on the nature of the problem is the main reason for the persistent disputes. There is no decomposition that simultaneously satisfies the twin principles of manifest Lorentz covariance and gauge invariance, and partial considerations hide likely inconsistencies. It is suggested that field equations and matter (i. e. electron in QED and quarks in QCD) equations must be analyzed afresh rather than beginning with the expressions of total angular momentum; canonical or otherwise. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2014; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: 8 pages

Comment on 'Single-slit electron diffraction with Aharonov-Bohm phase: Feynman's thought experiment with quantum point contacts'

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: We comment on the paper published in PRL 112, 010403 (2014). We comment on the paper published in PRL 112, 010403 (2014). △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2014; originally announced May 2014.

Comments: Submitted to PRL

Journal ref: Physical Review Letters, 113, 158901 (2014)

Gordon decomposition of Dirac current: a new interpretation

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Historically Gordon decomposition of Dirac current played an important role in the interpretation of Dirac equation. We revisit it to understand the correspondence between Maxwell-Dirac and Maxwell-Lorentz theories. Arguments are presented to show that classical charge current corresponds to Gordon current. Consistency with Maxwell-Dirac theory leads to a new result: antisymmetric spin tensor in s… ▽ More Historically Gordon decomposition of Dirac current played an important role in the interpretation of Dirac equation. We revisit it to understand the correspondence between Maxwell-Dirac and Maxwell-Lorentz theories. Arguments are presented to show that classical charge current corresponds to Gordon current. Consistency with Maxwell-Dirac theory leads to a new result: antisymmetric spin tensor in spin magnetization current of Dirac electron must be hidden as internal part of classical Maxwell tensor. It becomes natural to extend our previous interpretation in which electromagnetic field tensor represents angular momentum of photon or spacetime fluid (aether!) in the presence of sources such that the duality between field and source disappears. Both Gordon current and spin current are proposed to have 'spinning origin'. Formal expression of Gordon current makes it possible to apply the idea of optical vortex in this case, and quantized vortex and quantized orbital angular momentum could be related with the conjecture of mechanical interpretation of electric charge. Separate mass and charge centers for spinning point charge are well known in the literature; we discuss them in the context of two-vortex model of electron and Gordon decomposition. △ Less

Submitted 1 April, 2017; v1 submitted 16 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: 10 pages Typing errors are corrected and one reference added

On local duality invariance in electromagnetism

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Duality is one of the oldest known symmetries of Maxwell equations. In recent years the significance of duality symmetry has been recognized in superstrings and high energy physics and there has been a renewed interest on the question of local duality rotation invariance. In the present paper we re-visit global duality symmetry in the Maxwell action and delineate the ambiguous role of gauge invari… ▽ More Duality is one of the oldest known symmetries of Maxwell equations. In recent years the significance of duality symmetry has been recognized in superstrings and high energy physics and there has been a renewed interest on the question of local duality rotation invariance. In the present paper we re-visit global duality symmetry in the Maxwell action and delineate the ambiguous role of gauge invariance and time locality. We have recently demonstrated that local duality invariance in a Lorentz covariant form can be carried out in the Maxwell equations. In this paper it is shown that in the four-pseudo vector Lagrangian theory of Sudbery a local duality generalization can be naturally and unambiguously implemented and the Euler-Lagrange equations of motion are consistent with the generalized Maxwell field equations. It is pointed out that the extension of Noether theorem in full generality for a vector action is an important open problem in mathematical physics. Physical consequences of this theory for polarized light and topological insulators are also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2012; v1 submitted 24 October, 2011; originally announced October 2011.

Comments: 13 pages

Role of local duality invariance in axion electrodynamics of topological insulators

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Advances in material technology and confluence of ideas from particle physics, quantum field theory and condensed matter physics have led to the discovery of new states of matter as well as new physical phenomena: one of them termed as topological insulator has attracted a great deal of attention recently. Speculations on the possibility of observing the most elusive objects like axions and monopo… ▽ More Advances in material technology and confluence of ideas from particle physics, quantum field theory and condensed matter physics have led to the discovery of new states of matter as well as new physical phenomena: one of them termed as topological insulator has attracted a great deal of attention recently. Speculations on the possibility of observing the most elusive objects like axions and monopoles in topological insulators have led to studies that emphasize the role of symmetry and universality. In this paper we argue that electric-magnetic duality could be of deep significance in this context. We develop a duality invariant theory of topological insulators and show that under appropriate conditions this theory reduces to the axion electrodynamics for static case, topological quantization is related with the multi-valuedness of the duality gauge potential, and modifies Faraday's law for dynamical axion that would change the dispersion relation of axionic polariton. A new effect dual to the dynamical axion field effect is predicted and its physical consequences are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2011; originally announced September 2011.

Comments: 5 pages

Two-vortex structure of electron, nonlocality and Dirac equation

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: The dimensionless electromagnetic coupling constant $α=e^2 /\hbar c$ may have three interpretations: as the well known ratio between the electron charge radius $e^2/mc^2$ and the Compton wavelength of electron $λ_c= \hbar /mc$, as a ratio of two angular momenta since Planck constant has the dimension of angular momentum, and two flux quanta $e$ and $hc/e$. The anomalous part of the electron magnet… ▽ More The dimensionless electromagnetic coupling constant $α=e^2 /\hbar c$ may have three interpretations: as the well known ratio between the electron charge radius $e^2/mc^2$ and the Compton wavelength of electron $λ_c= \hbar /mc$, as a ratio of two angular momenta since Planck constant has the dimension of angular momentum, and two flux quanta $e$ and $hc/e$. The anomalous part of the electron magnetic moment together with the unified picture of the three interpretations of $α$ is suggested to have deep physical significance. The electric charge is proposed to be a new quantum of flux such that a two-vortex structure of electron is envisaged. In analogy with quantum conditions we postulate sub-quantum conditions applicable in a region of the order of $λ_c$ replacing $\hbar$ by a universal constant $f=e^2 /2πc$ and apply it to Dirac equation in internal space that gives rise to the anomalous magnetic moment of electron. Dirac spinor and 2-spinor representation for vortex structure of electron in the single particle Dirac framework are discussed. The role of sub-quantum rules and the internal variables for developing the present ideas is also debated. A critical discussion on the past attempts to give fundamental importance to magnetism and flux quantum is given to delineate the new ideas in the present work. △ Less

Submitted 20 January, 2012; v1 submitted 23 July, 2011; originally announced July 2011.

Comments: 12 pages, no figures. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1104.3506

Journal ref: Physica Scripta, 85, 025005 (2012)

Electric Charge, Fractional Spin and Flux

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Ratio of electron charge radius and Compton wavelength of electron is known to be equal to the dimensionless electromagnetic coupling constant $e^2 /\hbar c$. It is pointed out that the coupling constant has two alternative interpretations: as a ratio of two angular momenta since Planck constant has the dimension of angular momentum, and two flux quanta $e$ and $hc/e$. We argue that it has deep ph… ▽ More Ratio of electron charge radius and Compton wavelength of electron is known to be equal to the dimensionless electromagnetic coupling constant $e^2 /\hbar c$. It is pointed out that the coupling constant has two alternative interpretations: as a ratio of two angular momenta since Planck constant has the dimension of angular momentum, and two flux quanta $e$ and $hc/e$. We argue that it has deep physical significance such that the electronic charge becomes flus itself and at a fundamental level fractional spin of quantized vortex. A unified perspective of the three interpretations of the coupling constant is presented invoking the new interpretation of the magnetic moment of the electron comprising of three terms. A critical discussion on the past attempts to give fundamental importance to magnetism and flux quantum is given and the implication on the unification quest of our ideas is outlined. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: To be submitted for publication

Rotating light, OAM paradox and relativistic complex scalar field

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Recent studies show that the angular momentum, both spin and orbital, of rotating light beams possesses counter-intuitive characteristics. We present a new approach to the question of orbital angular momentum of light based on the complex massless scalar field representation of light. The covariant equation for the scalar field is treated in rotating system using the general relativistic framewo… ▽ More Recent studies show that the angular momentum, both spin and orbital, of rotating light beams possesses counter-intuitive characteristics. We present a new approach to the question of orbital angular momentum of light based on the complex massless scalar field representation of light. The covariant equation for the scalar field is treated in rotating system using the general relativistic framework. First we show the equivalence of the U(1) gauge current for the scalar field with the Poynting vector continuity equation for paraxial light, and then apply the formalism to the calculation of the orbital angular momentum of rotating light beams. If the difference between the co-, contra-, and physical quantities is properly accounted for there does not result any paradox in the orbital angular momentum of rotating light. An artificial analogue of the paradoxical situation could be constructed but it is wrong within the present formalism. It is shown that the orbital angular momentum of rotating beam comprising of modes with opposite azimuthal indices corresponds to that of rigid rotation. A short review on the electromagnetism in noninertial systems is presented to motivate a fully covariant Maxwell field approach in rotating system to address the rotating light phenomenon. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2008; originally announced September 2008.

Comments: No figures

Comment on "Spin and Orbital Angular Momentum in Gauge Theories: Nucleon Spin Structure and Multipole Radiation Revisited"

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: This is a comment on Chen et al Letter PRL,100, 232002 (2008). This is a comment on Chen et al Letter PRL,100, 232002 (2008). △ Less

Submitted 4 July, 2008; originally announced July 2008.

Comments: Submitted to Physical Review Letters

Comment on "Cyclotron resonance study of the electron and hole velocity in graphene monolayers"

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: In this comment it is pointed out that the electron velocity of the same order as observed in graphene had been measured in GaAs submicron devices long ago. Particle- antiparticle asymmetry related with electron and hole effective masses in graphene seems puzzling as hole in a condensed matter system cannot be treated as anti-electron. It is argued that there should be a universal electrodynamic… ▽ More In this comment it is pointed out that the electron velocity of the same order as observed in graphene had been measured in GaAs submicron devices long ago. Particle- antiparticle asymmetry related with electron and hole effective masses in graphene seems puzzling as hole in a condensed matter system cannot be treated as anti-electron. It is argued that there should be a universal electrodynamics for QHE and superconductivity. In this context attention is drawn to the new approach based on massless electron and the interpretation that magnetic field represents angular momentum of the photon fluid. Measurement of electron velocity in graphene and GaAs in parallel is suggested for testing the massless electrodynamics. △ Less

Submitted 26 May, 2007; originally announced May 2007.

Comments: 2 pages no figures

Unified field theories and Einstein

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: Einstein's contribution to relativity is reviewed. It is pointed out that Weyl gave first unified theory of gravitation and electromagnetism and it was different than the five dimensional theory of Kaluza. Einstein began his work on unification in 1925 that continued all through the rest of his life. A discussion is presented on the recent advances in Weyl theory, and also on the unification appro… ▽ More Einstein's contribution to relativity is reviewed. It is pointed out that Weyl gave first unified theory of gravitation and electromagnetism and it was different than the five dimensional theory of Kaluza. Einstein began his work on unification in 1925 that continued all through the rest of his life. A discussion is presented on the recent advances in Weyl theory, and also on the unification approach in which space-time is believed not to be fundamental. The significance of the gravitational waves observed recently seems to indicate a new paradigm of unification. It is suggested that the nature of time is the most fundamental issue for a break-through in the unification quest. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2019; v1 submitted 16 February, 2006; originally announced February 2006.

Comments: 5 pages, updated version with typo corrections and revising the last section adding discussion on twistors and gravitational waves

Pancharatnam Phase and Photon Polarization Optics

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: Parallel transport of a vector around a closed curve on the surface of a sphere leads to a direction holonomy which can be related with a geometric phase that is equal to the solid angle subtended by the closed curve. Since Pancharatnam phase is half of the solid angle subtended by the polarization cycle on the Poincare sphere, quantum parallel transport law takes recourse o spin-half wave funct… ▽ More Parallel transport of a vector around a closed curve on the surface of a sphere leads to a direction holonomy which can be related with a geometric phase that is equal to the solid angle subtended by the closed curve. Since Pancharatnam phase is half of the solid angle subtended by the polarization cycle on the Poincare sphere, quantum parallel transport law takes recourse o spin-half wave function to obtain this result. A critique is offered on this factor of half anomaly in the geometric phase, and a natural resolution using Riemann sphere polarization representation is suggested. It is argued that spin angular momentum of photon is fundamental in polarization optics, and new insights are gained based on the hypothesis that two helicity states correspond to two distinct species of photon. This approach leads to the concept of a physical Poincare sphere: nonlinearity and jumps in the Pancharatnam phase find a simple physical explanation while novel features pertaining to the discrete and pulsating sphere are predicted. Paired photon spin zero structure of unpolarized light is also discussed. An outline of possible experimental tests is presented. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2006; originally announced February 2006.

Comments: Submitted to Physical Review A

Comment on "Roentgen quantum phase shift: a semiclassical local electrodynamical effect?"

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: In this short note we amplify our comments on the paper PRL 95,010405 (2005). In this short note we amplify our comments on the paper PRL 95,010405 (2005). △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2005; originally announced August 2005.

Comments: Expanded version of the comment submitted to PRL

Journal ref: Physical Review Letters vol 95, 248903 (2005)

On the dark energy

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: The dark energy problem may have a simple solution in the model of cosmology based on the space-time interaction hypothesis. The hypothesis throws light on the nature of time (see Time-Transcendence-Truth, Monograph published in 2006). The dark energy problem may have a simple solution in the model of cosmology based on the space-time interaction hypothesis. The hypothesis throws light on the nature of time (see Time-Transcendence-Truth, Monograph published in 2006). △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2020; v1 submitted 8 February, 2005; originally announced February 2005.

Comments: 3 pages; typing errors corrected and references updated

The nature of electronic charge

Authors: S C Tiwari

Abstract: Advances in gauge theories and unified theories have not thrown light on the meaning of electron. The problem of the origin of electronic charge is made precise, new insights gained from Weyl space are summarized, and the origin of charge in terms of fractional spin is suggested. New perspective on the abelian Chern-Simons theory is presented to explain charge. Advances in gauge theories and unified theories have not thrown light on the meaning of electron. The problem of the origin of electronic charge is made precise, new insights gained from Weyl space are summarized, and the origin of charge in terms of fractional spin is suggested. New perspective on the abelian Chern-Simons theory is presented to explain charge. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2006; v1 submitted 12 August, 2004; originally announced August 2004.

Comments: Final version as published

Journal ref: Found.Phys.Lett. 19 (2006) 51-62

Massless Electron and Fractional Spin as Electronic Charge

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: The standard model (SM) of particle physics has been supported by several experimental findings, the most remarkable of them being the discovery of the weak gauge bosons, W and Z. It is expected that the Higgs boson could show up by 2007 at LHC, CERN. In spite of this, the unsatisfactory features of the SM at conceptual level, and exclusion of gravity from the unification scheme have led to expl… ▽ More The standard model (SM) of particle physics has been supported by several experimental findings, the most remarkable of them being the discovery of the weak gauge bosons, W and Z. It is expected that the Higgs boson could show up by 2007 at LHC, CERN. In spite of this, the unsatisfactory features of the SM at conceptual level, and exclusion of gravity from the unification scheme have led to explore 'the physics beyond the SM'. A critique and comprehensive review of the contemporary fundamental physics was presented in a monograph completed in the centenary year,1997 of the discovery of the electron. A radically new approach to address foundational problems was outlined: masslessness of bare electron, interpretation of the squared electronic charge in terms of the fractional spin, $e^2/c$; new physicalsignificance of the electromagnetic potentials, 2+1 dimensional internal structure of electron and neutrino, and composite photon are some of the ideas proposed. Though the monograph was reviewed by E. J. Post(Physics Essays, June1999), it has remained largely inaccessible. I believe some of these unconventional ideas have a potential to throw light on the fundamental questions in physics, and therefore deserve a wider dissemination. The reader may find illuminating to supplement Section 3 on the weak gauge bosons with a candid, graceful and personal recollection by Pierre Darriulat(CERN Courier, April 2004, p.13). △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2004; originally announced June 2004.

On the anomalous extreme ultraviolet emission lines in helium-hydrogen plasma

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: The idea of photonic de Broglie waves is discussed in the context of recent obsrved lines in the helium-hydrogen plasma. The idea of photonic de Broglie waves is discussed in the context of recent obsrved lines in the helium-hydrogen plasma. △ Less

Submitted 19 November, 2003; originally announced November 2003.

Journal ref: Current Science (India) vol 86 p1478, 2004

Comments on "Geometric Phase Associated with Transformations of Optical Beams Bearing Orbital Angular Momentum"

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: In the present note I am presenting my point of view about the idea proposed in the above said paper. In the present note I am presenting my point of view about the idea proposed in the above said paper. △ Less

Submitted 18 October, 2003; originally announced October 2003.

Comments: Any comment to [email protected]

Reality of Time

Authors: S. C. Tiwari

Abstract: The meaning of instantaneous action at a distance is elucidated. It is shown that the absence of a medium to transmit action (usually referred to as AAD in the literature) and instantaneous action are not identical. Since the term "instantaneous" is incompatible with relativity and field theory, a critique is presented on the concept of time in relativity. It is argued that relativity does not d… ▽ More The meaning of instantaneous action at a distance is elucidated. It is shown that the absence of a medium to transmit action (usually referred to as AAD in the literature) and instantaneous action are not identical. Since the term "instantaneous" is incompatible with relativity and field theory, a critique is presented on the concept of time in relativity. It is argued that relativity does not deal with the nature of time. Physical reality of the absolute time is envisaged, and instantaneous action is proposed to be a natural consequence of it. Possibly gravity is such kind of a force, however the electromagnetic force, though envisaged as direct particle interaction (i.e. without intermediary fields) can not be instantaneous. △ Less

Submitted 8 October, 2001; originally announced October 2001.

Comments: Invited essay published in "Action at a Distance in Modern Physics:Pro & Contra", edited by A.E. Chubykalo et al(Nova NY 1999), pp. 184-192, e-mail:[email protected]