-
Near-ideal relaxed MHD in slab geometry
Authors:
Arash Tavassoli,
Stuart R. Hudson,
Zhisong Qu,
Matthew Hole
Abstract:
We investigate the solutions of the relaxed MHD model (RxMHD) of Dewar \& Qu [J. Plasma Phys. {\bf 88}, 835880101 (2022)]. This model generalizes Taylor relaxation by including the ideal Ohm's law constraint using an augmented Lagrangian method, providing a pathway to extend the multi-region relaxed MHD (MRxMHD) model. We present the first numerical solution of the RxMHD model by Dewar \& Qu, demo…
▽ More
We investigate the solutions of the relaxed MHD model (RxMHD) of Dewar \& Qu [J. Plasma Phys. {\bf 88}, 835880101 (2022)]. This model generalizes Taylor relaxation by including the ideal Ohm's law constraint using an augmented Lagrangian method, providing a pathway to extend the multi-region relaxed MHD (MRxMHD) model. We present the first numerical solution of the RxMHD model by Dewar \& Qu, demonstrating that it is mathematically well-defined and computationally feasible for constructing MHD equilibria in slab geometry. We also show that a cross-field flow can exist without enforcing an arbitrary constraint on the angular momentum, as is done in the case of MRxMHD with flow. Our results also demonstrate the self-organization of fully relaxed regions during the optimization, which was an important motivation behind developing this model.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2025; v1 submitted 5 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Beyond Strang: A practical assessment of some second-order 3-splitting methods
Authors:
Raymond J. Spiteri,
Arash Tavassoli,
Siqi Wei,
Andrei Smolyakov
Abstract:
Operator splitting is a popular divide-and-conquer strategy for solving differential equations. Typically, the right-hand side of the differential equation is split into a number of parts that are then integrated separately. Many methods are known that split the right-hand side into two parts. This approach is limiting, however, and there are situations when 3-splitting is more natural and ultimat…
▽ More
Operator splitting is a popular divide-and-conquer strategy for solving differential equations. Typically, the right-hand side of the differential equation is split into a number of parts that are then integrated separately. Many methods are known that split the right-hand side into two parts. This approach is limiting, however, and there are situations when 3-splitting is more natural and ultimately more advantageous. The second-order Strang operator-splitting method readily generalizes to a right-hand side splitting into any number of operators. It is arguably the most popular method for 3-splitting because of its efficiency, ease of implementation, and intuitive nature. Other 3-splitting methods exist, but they are less well-known, and \rev{analysis and} evaluation of their performance in practice are scarce. We demonstrate the effectiveness of some alternative 3-split, second-order methods to Strang splitting on two problems: the reaction-diffusion Brusselator, which can be split into three parts that each have closed-form solutions, and the kinetic Vlasov--Poisson equations that is used in semi-Lagrangian plasma simulations. We find alternative second-order 3-operator-splitting methods that realize efficiency gains of 10\%--20\% over traditional Strang splitting. Our analysis for the practical assessment of efficiency of operator-splitting methods includes the computational cost of the integrators and can be used in method design.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2023; v1 submitted 15 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
The electron cyclotron drift instability: a comparison of particle-in-cell and continuum Vlasov simulations
Authors:
Arash Tavassoli,
Mina Papahn Zadeh,
Andrei Smolyakov,
Magdi Shoucri,
Raymond J. Spiteri
Abstract:
The linear and nonlinear characteristics of the electron cyclotron drift instability (ECDI) have been studied through the particle-in-cell (PIC) and continuum Vlasov simulation methods in connection with the effects of the azimuthal length (in the $E \times B$ direction) on the simulations. Simulation results for a long azimuthal length (17.82 cm $= 627\;v_d/ω_{ce}$, where $ω_{ce}$ is the electron…
▽ More
The linear and nonlinear characteristics of the electron cyclotron drift instability (ECDI) have been studied through the particle-in-cell (PIC) and continuum Vlasov simulation methods in connection with the effects of the azimuthal length (in the $E \times B$ direction) on the simulations. Simulation results for a long azimuthal length (17.82 cm $= 627\;v_d/ω_{ce}$, where $ω_{ce}$ is the electron cyclotron frequency and $v_d$ is the $E\times B$ drift of the electrons) are reported, for which a high resolution is achieved in Fourier space. For simulations with a long azimuthal length, the linear growth rates of the PIC simulations show a considerable discrepancy with the theory, whereas the linear growth rate of the Vlasov simulations remains close to the theory. In the nonlinear regime, the inverse cascade is shown in both PIC and Vlasov simulations with a sufficiently large azimuthal length. In simulations with a short azimuthal length, however, the inverse cascade is barely observed. Instead, the PIC simulations with a short azimuthal length (0.5625 cm $=19.8\;v_d/ω_{ce}$) show an essentially continuous nonlinear dispersion, similar to what is predicted by the ion-sound turbulence theory. It is shown that, in the PIC and Vlasov simulations, the inverse cascade coincides with the formation and merging of electron structures in phase space. This process, however, terminates differently in the PIC simulations compared with the Vlasov simulations. Larger amplitudes of ECDI fluctuations are observed in the PIC simulations compared with the Vlasov simulations, leading to an intensified electron heating and anomalous current. This suggests that the statistical noise of PIC simulations might contribute to the extreme electron heating that has been observed in previous studies.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2023; v1 submitted 10 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Backward waves in the nonlinear regime of the Buneman instability
Authors:
Arash Tavassoli,
Magdi Shoucri,
Andrei Smolyakov,
Mina Papahn Zadeh,
Raymond J. Spiteri
Abstract:
Observation of low- and high-frequency backward waves in the nonlinear regime of the Buneman instability is reported. Intense low-frequency backward waves propagating in the direction opposite to the electron drift (with respect to the ion population) of ions and electrons are found. The excitation of these waves is explained based on the linear theory for the stability of the electron velocity di…
▽ More
Observation of low- and high-frequency backward waves in the nonlinear regime of the Buneman instability is reported. Intense low-frequency backward waves propagating in the direction opposite to the electron drift (with respect to the ion population) of ions and electrons are found. The excitation of these waves is explained based on the linear theory for the stability of the electron velocity distribution function that is modified by nonlinear effects. In the nonlinear regime, the electron distribution exhibits a wide plateau formed by electron hole trapping and extends into the negative velocity region. It is shown that within the linear approach, the backward waves correspond to the weakly unstable or marginally stable modes generated by the large population of particles with negative velocities.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
The role of noise in PIC and Vlasov simulations of the Buneman instability
Authors:
Arash Tavassoli,
Oleksandr Chapurin,
Marilyn Jimenez,
Mina Papahn Zadeh,
Trevor Zinte,
Meghraj Sengupta,
Lénaïc Couëdel,
Raymond J. Spiteri,
Magdi Shoucri,
Andrei Smolyakov
Abstract:
The effects of noise in particle-in-cell (PIC) and Vlasov simulations of the Buneman instability in unmagnetized plasmas are studied. It is found that, in the regime of low drift velocity, the linear stage of the instability in PIC simulations differs significantly from the theoretical predictions, whereas in the Vlasov simulations it does not. A series of highly resolved PIC simulations with incr…
▽ More
The effects of noise in particle-in-cell (PIC) and Vlasov simulations of the Buneman instability in unmagnetized plasmas are studied. It is found that, in the regime of low drift velocity, the linear stage of the instability in PIC simulations differs significantly from the theoretical predictions, whereas in the Vlasov simulations it does not. A series of highly resolved PIC simulations with increasingly large numbers of macroparticles per cell is performed using a number of different PIC codes.
All the simulations predict highly similar growth rates that are several times larger than those calculated from the linear theory. As a result, we find that the true convergence of the PIC simulations in the linear regime is elusive to achieve in practice and can easily be misidentified.
The discrepancy between the theoretical and observed growth rates is attributed to the initial noise inherently present in PIC simulations, but not in Vlasov simulations, that causes particle trapping even though the fraction of trapped particles is low. We show analytically that even weak distortions of the electron velocity distribution function (such as flattening due to particle trapping) result in significant modifications of the growth rates. It is also found that the common quiet-start method for PIC simulations leads to more accurate growth rates but only if the maximum growth rate mode is perturbed initially. We demonstrate that the quiet-start method does not completely remedy the noise problem because the simulations generally exhibit inconsistencies with the linear theory.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Nonlinear regimes of the electron cyclotron drift instability in Vlasov simulations
Authors:
Arash Tavassoli,
Andrei Smolyakov,
Magdi Shoucri,
Raymond J. Spiteri
Abstract:
We report on a novel investigation of the nonlinear regime of the electron cyclotron drift instability, using a grid-based Vlasov simulation. It is shown that the instability occurs as a series of cyclotron resonances with the electron beam mode due to the $E\times B$ drift. In the nonlinear regime, we observe condensation of fluctuations energy toward the lowest resonance mode and below, i.e., an…
▽ More
We report on a novel investigation of the nonlinear regime of the electron cyclotron drift instability, using a grid-based Vlasov simulation. It is shown that the instability occurs as a series of cyclotron resonances with the electron beam mode due to the $E\times B$ drift. In the nonlinear regime, we observe condensation of fluctuations energy toward the lowest resonance mode and below, i.e., an inverse energy cascade. It is shown that the characteristics of the nonlinear saturation state remain far from the ion-sound regime.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2022; v1 submitted 22 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Microcanonical entropy: consistency and adiabatic invariance
Authors:
Arash Tavassoli,
Afshin Montakhab
Abstract:
Attempts to establish microcanonical entropy as an adiabatic invariant date back to works of Gibbs and Hertz. More recently, a consistency relation based on adiabatic invariance has been used to argue for the validity of Gibbs (volume) entropy over Boltzmann (surface) entropy. Such consistency relation equates derivatives of thermodynamic entropy to ensemble average of the corresponding quantity…
▽ More
Attempts to establish microcanonical entropy as an adiabatic invariant date back to works of Gibbs and Hertz. More recently, a consistency relation based on adiabatic invariance has been used to argue for the validity of Gibbs (volume) entropy over Boltzmann (surface) entropy. Such consistency relation equates derivatives of thermodynamic entropy to ensemble average of the corresponding quantity in micro-state space (phase space or Hilbert space). In this work we propose to re-examine such a consistency relation when the number of particles ($N$) is considered as the independent thermodynamic variable. In other words, we investigate the consistency relation for the chemical potential which is a fundamental thermodynamic quantity. We show both by simple analytical calculations as well as model example that neither definitions of entropy satisfy the consistency condition when one considers such a relation for the chemical potential. This remains true regardless of the system size. Therefore, our results cast doubt on the validity of the adiabatic invariance as a required property of thermodynamic entropy. We close by providing commentary on the derivation of thermostatistics from mechanics which typically leads to controversial and inconsistent results.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2015; v1 submitted 9 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
