-
Resolving discrepancies in bang-time predictions for ICF experiments on the NIF: Insights from the Build-A-Hohlraum Campaign
Authors:
G. F. Swadling,
W. A. Farmer,
H. Chen,
N. Aybar,
M. S. Rubery,
M. B. Schneider,
D. A. Liedahl,
N. C. Lemos,
E. Tubman,
J. S. Ross,
D. E. Hinkel,
O. L. Landen,
M. D. Rosen,
S. Rogers K. Newman,
D. Yanagisawa,
N. Roskopf,
S. Vonhof,
L. Aghaian,
M. Mauldin,
B. L. Reichelt,
J. Kunimune
Abstract:
This study investigated discrepancies between measured and simulated x-ray drive in Inertial Confinement Fusion (ICF) hohlraums at the National Ignition Facility (NIF). Despite advances in radiation-hydrodynamic simulations, a consistent "drive deficit" remains. Experimentally measured ICF capsule bang-times are systematically 400-700 ps later than simulations predict. The Build-A-Hohlraum (BAH) c…
▽ More
This study investigated discrepancies between measured and simulated x-ray drive in Inertial Confinement Fusion (ICF) hohlraums at the National Ignition Facility (NIF). Despite advances in radiation-hydrodynamic simulations, a consistent "drive deficit" remains. Experimentally measured ICF capsule bang-times are systematically 400-700 ps later than simulations predict. The Build-A-Hohlraum (BAH) campaign explored potential causes for this discrepancy by systematically varying hohlraum features, including laser entrance hole (LEH) windows, capsules, and gas fills. Overall, the agreement between simulated and experimental x-ray drive was found to be largely unaffected by these changes. The data allows us to exclude some hypotheses put forward to potentially explain the discrepancy. Errors in the local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) atomic modeling, errors in the modeling of LEH closure and errors due to a lack of plasma species mix physics in simulations are shown to be inconsistent with our measurements. Instead, the data supports the hypothesis that errors in NLTE emission modeling are a significant contributor to the discrepancy. X-ray emission in the 2 - 4 keV range is found to be approximately 30% lower than in simulations. This is accompanied by higher than predicted electron temperatures in the gold bubble region, pointing to errors in non-LTE modeling. Introducing an opacity multiplier of 0.87 on energy groups above 1.8 keV improves agreement with experimental data, reducing the bang-time discrepancy from 300 ps to 100 ps. These results underscore the need for refined NLTE opacity models to enhance the predictive power of hohlraum simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2025; v1 submitted 17 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Quantitative assessment of fitting errors associated with streak camera noise in Thomson scattering data analysis
Authors:
G. F. Swadling,
C. Bruulsema,
W. Rozmus,
J. Katz
Abstract:
Thomson scattering measurements in High Energy Density experiments are often recorded using optical streak cameras. In the low-signal regime, noise introduced by the streak camera can become an important and sometimes the dominate source of measurement uncertainty. In this paper we present a formal method of accounting for the presence of streak camera noise in our measurements. We present a pheno…
▽ More
Thomson scattering measurements in High Energy Density experiments are often recorded using optical streak cameras. In the low-signal regime, noise introduced by the streak camera can become an important and sometimes the dominate source of measurement uncertainty. In this paper we present a formal method of accounting for the presence of streak camera noise in our measurements. We present a phenomenological description of the noise generation mechanisms and present a statistical model that may be used to construct the covariance matrix associated with a given measurement. This model is benchmarked against simulations of streak camera images. We demonstrate how this covariance may then be used to weight fitting of the data and provide quantitative assessments of the uncertainty in the fitting parameters determined by the best fit to the data. These methods will have general applicability to other measurements made using optical streak cameras.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2022; v1 submitted 22 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Counter-propagating radiative shock experiments on the Orion laser
Authors:
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
T. Clayson,
G. F. Swadling,
S. V. Lebedev,
G. C. Burdiak,
C. Stehlé,
U. Chaulagain,
R. L. Singh,
J. M. Foster,
J. Skidmore,
E. T. Gumbrell,
P. Graham,
S. Patankar,
C. Danson,
C. Spindloe,
J. Larour,
M. Kozlova,
R. Rodriguez,
J. M. Gil,
G. Espinosa,
P. Velarde
Abstract:
We present new experiments to study the formation of radiative shocks and the interaction between two counter-propagating radiative shocks. The experiments were performed at the Orion laser facility which was used to drive shocks in xenon inside large aspect ratio gas-cells. The collision between the two shocks and their respective radiative precursors, combined with the formation of inherently 3-…
▽ More
We present new experiments to study the formation of radiative shocks and the interaction between two counter-propagating radiative shocks. The experiments were performed at the Orion laser facility which was used to drive shocks in xenon inside large aspect ratio gas-cells. The collision between the two shocks and their respective radiative precursors, combined with the formation of inherently 3-dimensional shocks, provides a novel platform particularly suited for benchmarking of numerical codes. The dynamics of the shocks before and after the collision were investigated using point-projection X-ray backlighting while, simultaneously, the electron density in the radiative precursor was measured via optical laser interferometry. Modelling of the experiments using the 2-D radiation hydrodynamic codes NYM/PETRA show a very good agreement with the experimental results.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Formation and Structure of a Current Sheet in Pulsed-Power Driven Magnetic Reconnection Experiments
Authors:
J. D. Hare,
S. V. Lebedev,
L. G. Suttle,
N. F. Loureiro,
A. Ciardi,
G. C. Burdiak,
J. P. Chittenden,
T. Clayson,
S. J. Eardley,
C. Garcia,
J. W. D. Halliday,
N. Niasse,
T. Robinson,
R. A. Smith,
N. Stuart,
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
G. F. Swadling,
J. Ma,
J. Wu
Abstract:
We describe magnetic reconnection experiments using a new, pulsed-power driven experimental platform in which the inflows are super-sonic but sub-Alfvénic.The intrinsically magnetised plasma flows are long lasting, producing a well-defined reconnection layer that persists over many hydrodynamic time scales.The layer is diagnosed using a suite of high resolution laser based diagnostics which provid…
▽ More
We describe magnetic reconnection experiments using a new, pulsed-power driven experimental platform in which the inflows are super-sonic but sub-Alfvénic.The intrinsically magnetised plasma flows are long lasting, producing a well-defined reconnection layer that persists over many hydrodynamic time scales.The layer is diagnosed using a suite of high resolution laser based diagnostics which provide measurements of the electron density, reconnecting magnetic field, inflow and outflow velocities and the electron and ion temperatures.Using these measurements we observe a balance between the power flow into and out of the layer, and we find that the heating rates for the electrons and ions are significantly in excess of the classical predictions. The formation of plasmoids is observed in laser interferometry and optical self-emission, and the magnetic O-point structure of these plasmoids is confirmed using magnetic probes.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2017; v1 submitted 30 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Counter-propagating radiative shock experiments on the Orion laser and the formation of radiative precursors
Authors:
T. Clayson,
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
S. V. Lebedev,
G. F. Swadling,
C. Stehle,
G. C. Burdiak,
J. M. Foster,
J. Skidmore,
P. Graham,
E. Gumbrell,
S. Patankar,
C. Spindloe,
U. Chaulagain,
M. Kozlova,
J. Larour,
R. L. Singh,
R. Rodriguez,
J. M. Gil,
G. Espinosa,
P. Velarde,
C. Danson
Abstract:
We present results from new experiments to study the dynamics of radiative shocks, reverse shocks and radiative precursors. Laser ablation of a solid piston by the Orion high-power laser at AWE Aldermaston UK was used to drive radiative shocks into a gas cell initially pressurised between $0.1$ and $1.0 \ bar$ with different noble gases. Shocks propagated at {$80 \pm 10 \ km/s$} and experienced st…
▽ More
We present results from new experiments to study the dynamics of radiative shocks, reverse shocks and radiative precursors. Laser ablation of a solid piston by the Orion high-power laser at AWE Aldermaston UK was used to drive radiative shocks into a gas cell initially pressurised between $0.1$ and $1.0 \ bar$ with different noble gases. Shocks propagated at {$80 \pm 10 \ km/s$} and experienced strong radiative cooling resulting in post-shock compressions of { $\times 25 \pm 2$}. A combination of X-ray backlighting, optical self-emission streak imaging and interferometry (multi-frame and streak imaging) were used to simultaneously study both the shock front and the radiative precursor. These experiments present a new configuration to produce counter-propagating radiative shocks, allowing for the study of reverse shocks and providing a unique platform for numerical validation. In addition, the radiative shocks were able to expand freely into a large gas volume without being confined by the walls of the gas cell. This allows for 3-D effects of the shocks to be studied which, in principle, could lead to a more direct comparison to astrophysical phenomena. By maintaining a constant mass density between different gas fills the shocks evolved with similar hydrodynamics but the radiative precursor was found to extend significantly further in higher atomic number gases ($\sim$$4$ times further in xenon than neon). Finally, 1-D and 2-D radiative-hydrodynamic simulations are presented showing good agreement with the experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Anomalous Heating and Plasmoid Formation in a Driven Magnetic Reconnection Experiment
Authors:
J. D. Hare,
L. Suttle,
S. V. Lebedev,
N. F. Loureiro,
A. Ciardi,
G. C. Burdiak,
J. P. Chittenden,
T. Clayson,
C. Garcia,
N. Niasse,
T. Robinson,
R. A. Smith,
N. Stuart,
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
G. F. Swadling,
J. Ma,
J. Wu,
Q. Yang
Abstract:
We present a detailed study of magnetic reconnection in a quasi-two-dimensional pulsed-power driven laboratory experiment. Oppositely directed magnetic fields $(B=3$ T), advected by supersonic, sub-Alfvénic carbon plasma flows $(V_{in}=50$ km/s), are brought together and mutually annihilate inside a thin current layer ($δ=0.6$ mm). Temporally and spatially resolved optical diagnostics, including i…
▽ More
We present a detailed study of magnetic reconnection in a quasi-two-dimensional pulsed-power driven laboratory experiment. Oppositely directed magnetic fields $(B=3$ T), advected by supersonic, sub-Alfvénic carbon plasma flows $(V_{in}=50$ km/s), are brought together and mutually annihilate inside a thin current layer ($δ=0.6$ mm). Temporally and spatially resolved optical diagnostics, including interferometry, Faraday rotation imaging and Thomson scattering, allow us to determine the structure and dynamics of this layer, the nature of the inflows and outflows and the detailed energy partition during the reconnection process. We measure high electron and ion temperatures $(T_e=100$ eV, $T_i=600$ eV), far in excess of what can be attributed to classical (Spitzer) resistive and viscous dissipation. We observe the repeated formation and ejection of plasmoids, which we interpret as evidence of two-fluid effects in our experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2017; v1 submitted 29 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Bow shock fragmentation driven by a thermal instability in laboratory-astrophysics experiments
Authors:
F. Suzuki-Vidal,
S. V. Lebedev,
A. Ciardi,
L. A. Pickworth,
R. Rodriguez,
J. M. Gil,
G. Espinosa,
P. Hartigan,
G. F. Swadling,
J. Skidmore,
G. N. Hall,
M. Bennett,
S. N. Bland,
G. Burdiak,
P. de Grouchy,
J. Music,
L. Suttle,
E. Hansen,
A. Frank
Abstract:
The role of radiative cooling during the evolution of a bow shock was studied in laboratory-astrophysics experiments that are scalable to bow shocks present in jets from young stellar objects. The laboratory bow shock is formed during the collision of two counter-streaming, supersonic plasma jets produced by an opposing pair of radial foil Z-pinches driven by the current pulse from the MAGPIE puls…
▽ More
The role of radiative cooling during the evolution of a bow shock was studied in laboratory-astrophysics experiments that are scalable to bow shocks present in jets from young stellar objects. The laboratory bow shock is formed during the collision of two counter-streaming, supersonic plasma jets produced by an opposing pair of radial foil Z-pinches driven by the current pulse from the MAGPIE pulsed-power generator. The jets have different flow velocities in the laboratory frame and the experiments are driven over many times the characteristic cooling time-scale. The initially smooth bow shock rapidly develops small-scale non-uniformities over temporal and spatial scales that are consistent with a thermal instability triggered by strong radiative cooling in the shock. The growth of these perturbations eventually results in a global fragmentation of the bow shock front. The formation of a thermal instability is supported by analysis of the plasma cooling function calculated for the experimental conditions with the radiative packages ABAKO/RAPCAL.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2015; v1 submitted 22 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
