-
Thermo-poro-elastic behaviour of a transversely isotropic shale: Thermal expansion and pressurization
Authors:
Philipp Braun,
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Pierre Delage,
Jean Sulem,
Nathalie Conil
Abstract:
The Callovo-Oxfordian (COx) claystone is considered as a candidate host rock for a deep geological radioactive waste repository in France. Due to the exothermic waste packages, the rock is expected to be submitted to temperatures up to 90 °C. The temperature rise induces deformations of the host rock, together with an increase in pore pressures, involving complex thermo-hydro-mechanical (THM) coup…
▽ More
The Callovo-Oxfordian (COx) claystone is considered as a candidate host rock for a deep geological radioactive waste repository in France. Due to the exothermic waste packages, the rock is expected to be submitted to temperatures up to 90 °C. The temperature rise induces deformations of the host rock, together with an increase in pore pressures, involving complex thermo-hydro-mechanical (THM) couplings. This study aims to better characterize the THM response of the COx claystone to temperature changes in the laboratory. To this end, claystone specimens were tested in a temperature controlled, high pressure isotropic compression cell, under stress conditions close to the in-situ ones. Thermal loads were applied on the specimens along different heating and cooling paths. A temperature corrected strain gage system provided precise measurements of the anisotropic strain response of the specimens. Drained and undrained thermal expansion coefficients in both transversely isotropic directions were determined. The measurement of pore pressure changes in undrained condition yielded the thermal pressurization coefficient. All parameters were analysed for their compatibility within the thermo-poro-elastic framework, and their stress and temperature dependency was identified.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2020; v1 submitted 20 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Transversely isotropic poroelastic behaviour of the Callovo-Oxfordian claystone: A set of stress-dependent parameters
Authors:
Philipp Braun,
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Pierre Delage,
Jean Sulem,
Nathalie Conil
Abstract:
In the framework of a deep geological radioactive waste disposal in France, the hydromechanical properties of the designated host rock, the Callovo-Oxfordian claystone (COx), are investigated in laboratory tests. Experiments presented in this study are carried out to determine several coefficients required within a transversely isotropic material model. They include isotropic compression tests, po…
▽ More
In the framework of a deep geological radioactive waste disposal in France, the hydromechanical properties of the designated host rock, the Callovo-Oxfordian claystone (COx), are investigated in laboratory tests. Experiments presented in this study are carried out to determine several coefficients required within a transversely isotropic material model. They include isotropic compression tests, pore pressure tests, and deviatoric loading tests parallel and perpendicular to the bedding plane. We emphasize the adapted experimental devices and testing procedures, necessary to detect small strains under high pressures, on a material, which is sensitive to water and has a very low permeability. In particular, we discovered a significant decrease of elastic stiffness with decreasing effective stress, which was observed to be reversible. In both isotropic and deviatoric tests, a notable anisotropic strain response was found. The Young modulus parallel to bedding was about 1.8 times higher than the one perpendicular to the bedding plane. A notably low Poisson ratio perpendicular to the bedding plane with values between 0.1 and 0.2 was evidenced. While the anisotropy of the back-calculated Biot coefficient was found to be low, a significant anisotropy of the Skempton coefficient was computed. The performed experiments provide an overdetermined set of material parameters at different stress levels. Using all determined parameters in a least square error regression scheme, seven independent elastic coefficients and their effective stress dependency are characterized. Parameters measured under isotropic loading are well represented by this set of coefficients, while the poroelastic framework with isotropic stress dependency is not sufficient to describe laboratory findings from triaxial loading.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2020; v1 submitted 20 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
A laboratory investigation of thermally induced pore pressures in the Callovo-Oxfordian Claystone
Authors:
Mehrdokht Mohajerani,
Pierre Delage,
Jean Sulem,
Mohammad Monfared,
Anh-Minh Tang,
Behrouz Gatmiri
Abstract:
In the framework of research into radioactive waste disposal, it was decided to investigate the thermally induce pore pressure occurring in the Callovo-Oxfordian claystone, a possible host rock in which the ANDRA underground laboratory of Bure (East of France) has been excavated. Thermal pore pressures appear in low permeability soils and rocks because the thermal expansion coefficient of water is…
▽ More
In the framework of research into radioactive waste disposal, it was decided to investigate the thermally induce pore pressure occurring in the Callovo-Oxfordian claystone, a possible host rock in which the ANDRA underground laboratory of Bure (East of France) has been excavated. Thermal pore pressures appear in low permeability soils and rocks because the thermal expansion coefficient of water is significantly higher than that of the solid grains (Campanella and Mitchell; 1968 [1], Ghabezloo and Sulem; 2009 [2]). This phenomenon has clearly been observed in various in-situ heating tests conducted in Opalinus claystone in the Mont-Terri Underground Research Laboratory (URL) in Switzerland (HE-D test) and in Callovo-Oxfordian (COx) claystone in the Bure URL in France (TER test, Wileveau and Su; 2007 [3]) The processes of coring, transportation, storage and specimen trimming induce some desaturation in the sample. Due to the very low permeability (10-20 m2) of the COx claystone, a long period of time is necessary to properly resaturate the sample, a mandatory condition to satisfactorily investigate thermal pressurisation. Particular emphasis was hence put on the previous saturation procedure that was carried out under in-situ effective stress condition. Thermal pressurization has been investigated by performing undrained heating tests while measuring pore pressures changes in a specially adapted thermal isotropic compression cell. Special care was devoted to calibration procedures to account for the effects of the system on the pore pressure measurements. The thermal pressurization coefficient measured appeared to change with temperature, mainly because of the changes with temperature of both the water thermal expansion coefficient of water and the drained compression coefficient of the claystone.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Experimental artefacts in undrained triaxial testing
Authors:
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Jean Sulem
Abstract:
For evaluation of the undrained thermo-poro-elastic properties of saturated porous materials in conventional triaxial cells, it is important to take into account the effect of the dead volume of the drainage system. The compressibility and the thermal expansion of the drainage system along with the dead volume of the fluid filling this system, influence the measured pore pressure and volumetric st…
▽ More
For evaluation of the undrained thermo-poro-elastic properties of saturated porous materials in conventional triaxial cells, it is important to take into account the effect of the dead volume of the drainage system. The compressibility and the thermal expansion of the drainage system along with the dead volume of the fluid filling this system, influence the measured pore pressure and volumetric strain during undrained thermal or mechanical loading in a triaxial cell. A correction method is presented in this paper to correct these effects during an undrained isotropic compression test or an undrained heating test. A parametric study has demonstrated that the porosity and the drained compressibility of the tested material and the ratio of the vol-ume of the drainage system to the one of the tested sample are the key parameters which influence the most the error induced on the measurements by the drainage system.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Temperature induced pore fluid pressurization in geomaterials
Authors:
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Jean Sulem
Abstract:
The theoretical basis of the thermal response of the fluid-saturated porous materials in undrained condition is presented. It has been demonstrated that the thermal pressurization phenomenon is controlled by the discrepancy between the thermal expansion of the pore fluid and of the solid phase, the stress-dependency of the compressibility and the non-elastic volume changes of the porous material.…
▽ More
The theoretical basis of the thermal response of the fluid-saturated porous materials in undrained condition is presented. It has been demonstrated that the thermal pressurization phenomenon is controlled by the discrepancy between the thermal expansion of the pore fluid and of the solid phase, the stress-dependency of the compressibility and the non-elastic volume changes of the porous material. For evaluation of the undrained thermo-poro-elastic properties of saturated porous materials in conventional triaxial cells, it is important to take into account the effect of the dead volume of the drainage system. A simple correction method is presented to correct the measured pore pressure change and also the measured volumetric strain during an undrained heating test. It is shown that the porosity of the tested material, its drained compressibility and the ratio of the volume of the drainage system to the one of the tested sample, are the key parameters which influence the most the error induced on the measurements by the drainage system. An example of the experimental evaluation of undrained thermoelastic parameters is presented for an undrained heating test performed on a fluid-saturated granular rock.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Effect of the volume of the drainage system on the measurement of undrained thermo-poro-elastic parameters
Authors:
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Jean Sulem
Abstract:
For evaluation of the undrained thermo-poro-elastic properties of saturated porous materials in conventional triaxial cells, it is important to take into account the effect of the dead volume of the drainage system. The compressibility and the thermal expansion of the drainage system along with the dead volume of the fluid filling this system, influence the measured pore pressure and volumetric…
▽ More
For evaluation of the undrained thermo-poro-elastic properties of saturated porous materials in conventional triaxial cells, it is important to take into account the effect of the dead volume of the drainage system. The compressibility and the thermal expansion of the drainage system along with the dead volume of the fluid filling this system, influence the measured pore pressure and volumetric strain during an undrained thermal or mechanical loading in a triaxial cell. The correction methods previously presented by Wissa (1969), Bishop (1976) and Ghabezloo and Sulem (2009) only permit to correct the measured pore pressures during an undrained isotropic compression test or an undrained heating test. An extension of these methods is presented in this paper to correct also the measured volumetric strain and consequently the measured undrained bulk compressibility and undrained thermal expansion coefficients during these tests. Two examples of application of the proposed correction method are presented on the results of an undrained isotropic compression test and an undrained heating test performed on a fluid-saturated granular rock. A parametric study has demonstrated that the porosity and the drained compressibility of the tested material, and the ratio of the volume of the drainage system to the one of the tested sample are the key parameters which influence the most the error induced on the measurements by the drainage system.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Evaluation of a permeability-porosity relationship in a low permeability creeping material using a single transient test
Authors:
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Jean Sulem,
Jérémie Saint-Marc
Abstract:
A method is presented for the evaluation of the permeability-porosity relationship in a low-permeability porous material using the results of a single transient test. This method accounts for both elastic and non-elastic deformations of the sample during the test and is applied to a hardened class G oil well cement paste. An initial hydrostatic undrained loading is applied to the sample. The gen…
▽ More
A method is presented for the evaluation of the permeability-porosity relationship in a low-permeability porous material using the results of a single transient test. This method accounts for both elastic and non-elastic deformations of the sample during the test and is applied to a hardened class G oil well cement paste. An initial hydrostatic undrained loading is applied to the sample. The generated excess pore pressure is then released at one end of the sample while monitoring the pore pressure at the other end and the radial strain in the middle of the sample during the dissipation of the pore pressure. These measurements are back analysed to evaluate the permeability and its evolution with porosity change. The effect of creep of the sample during the test on the measured pore pressure and volume change is taken into account in the analysis. This approach permits to calibrate a power law permeability-porosity relationship for the tested hardened cement paste. The porosity sensitivity exponent of the power-law is evaluated equal to 11 and is shown to be mostly independent of the stress level and of the creep strains.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2009; v1 submitted 4 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
The effect of undrained heating on a fluid-saturated hardened cement paste
Authors:
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Jean Sulem,
Jérémie Saint-Marc
Abstract:
The effect of undrained heating on volume change and induced pore pressure increase is an important point to properly understand the behaviour and evaluate the integrity of an oil well cement sheath submitted to rapid temperature changes. This thermal pressurization of the pore fluid is due to the discrepancy between the thermal expansion coefficients of the pore fluid and of the solid matrix. T…
▽ More
The effect of undrained heating on volume change and induced pore pressure increase is an important point to properly understand the behaviour and evaluate the integrity of an oil well cement sheath submitted to rapid temperature changes. This thermal pressurization of the pore fluid is due to the discrepancy between the thermal expansion coefficients of the pore fluid and of the solid matrix. The equations governing the undrained thermo-hydro-mechanical response of a porous material are presented and the effect of undrained heating is studied experimentally for a saturated hardened cement paste. The measured value of the thermal pressurization coefficient is equal to 0.6MPa/°C. The drained and undrained thermal expansion coefficients of the hardened cement paste are also measured in the heating tests. The anomalous thermal behaviour of cement pore fluid is back analysed from the results of the undrained heating test.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2008; v1 submitted 10 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
Effective stress law for the permeability of a limestone
Authors:
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Jean Sulem,
Sylvine Guédon,
François Martineau
Abstract:
The effective stress law for the permeability of a limestone is studied experimentally by performing constant head permeability tests in a triaxial cell with different conditions of confining pressure and pore pressure. Test results have shown that a pore pressure increase and a confining pressure decrease both result in an increase of the permeability, and that the effect of the pore pressure c…
▽ More
The effective stress law for the permeability of a limestone is studied experimentally by performing constant head permeability tests in a triaxial cell with different conditions of confining pressure and pore pressure. Test results have shown that a pore pressure increase and a confining pressure decrease both result in an increase of the permeability, and that the effect of the pore pressure change on the variation of the permeability is more important than the effect of a change of the confining pressure. A power law is proposed for the variation of the permeability with the effective stress. The permeability effective stress coefficient increases linearly with the differential pressure and is greater than one as soon the differential pressure exceeds few bars. The test results are well reproduced using the proposed permeability-effective stress law. A conceptual pore-shell model based on a detailed observation of the microstructure of the studied limestone is proposed. This model is able to explain the experimental observations on the effect of the total stress and of the pore pressure on the permeability of the limestone. Effective stress coefficients for the stress-dependent permeability which are greater than one are obtained. It is shown that the controlling factor is the ratio of the different bulk moduli of the various constituents of the rock. This ratio is studied experimentally by performing microhardness tests.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Poromechanical behaviour of hardened cement paste under isotropic loading
Authors:
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Jean Sulem,
Sylvine Guédon,
Francçois Martineau,
Jérémie Saint-Marc
Abstract:
The poromechanical behaviour of hardened cement paste under isotropic loading is studied on the basis of an experimental testing program of drained, undrained and unjacketed compression tests. The macroscopic behaviour of the material is described in the framework of the mechanics of porous media. The poroelastic parameters of the material are determined and the effect of stress and pore pressur…
▽ More
The poromechanical behaviour of hardened cement paste under isotropic loading is studied on the basis of an experimental testing program of drained, undrained and unjacketed compression tests. The macroscopic behaviour of the material is described in the framework of the mechanics of porous media. The poroelastic parameters of the material are determined and the effect of stress and pore pressure on them is evaluated. Appropriate effective stress laws which control the evolution of total volume, pore volume, solid volume, porosity and drained bulk modulus are discussed. A phenomenon of degradation of elastic properties is observed in the test results. The microscopic observations showed that this degradation is caused by the microcracking of the material under isotropic loading. The good compatibility and the consistency of the obtained poromechanical parameters demonstrate that the behaviour of the hardened cement paste can be indeed described within the framework of the theory of porous media.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Stress dependent thermal pressurization of a fluid-saturated rock
Authors:
Siavash Ghabezloo,
Jean Sulem
Abstract:
Temperature increase in saturated porous materials under undrained conditions leads to thermal pressurization of the pore fluid due to the discrepancy between the thermal expansion coefficients of the pore fluid and of the solid matrix. This increase in the pore fluid pressure induces a reduction of the effective mean stress and can lead to shear failure or hydraulic fracturing. The equations go…
▽ More
Temperature increase in saturated porous materials under undrained conditions leads to thermal pressurization of the pore fluid due to the discrepancy between the thermal expansion coefficients of the pore fluid and of the solid matrix. This increase in the pore fluid pressure induces a reduction of the effective mean stress and can lead to shear failure or hydraulic fracturing. The equations governing the phenomenon of thermal pressurization are presented and this phenomenon is studied experimentally for a saturated granular rock in an undrained heating test under constant isotropic stress. Careful analysis of the effect of mechanical and thermal deformation of the drainage and pressure measurement system is performed and a correction of the measured pore pressure is introduced. The test results are modelled using a non-linear thermo-poro-elastic constitutive model of the granular rock with emphasis on the stress-dependent character of the rock compressibility. The effects of stress and temperature on thermal pressurization observed in the tests are correctly reproduced by the model.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2009; v1 submitted 28 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Stress orientation evaluated from strain localisation analysis in Aigion fault
Authors:
Jean Sulem
Abstract:
Within the frame of the 'CRL' (Corinth Rift Laboratory project) (Cornet et al, 2004a) centered on the south western sector of the Gulf of Corinth (http://www.corinth-rift-lab.org), fault zone cores from the active Aigion fault have been collected continuously from depths between 708 m to 782 m. Inside this clayey core, a clear shearing surface with marked slip lines is visible on a plane that ma…
▽ More
Within the frame of the 'CRL' (Corinth Rift Laboratory project) (Cornet et al, 2004a) centered on the south western sector of the Gulf of Corinth (http://www.corinth-rift-lab.org), fault zone cores from the active Aigion fault have been collected continuously from depths between 708 m to 782 m. Inside this clayey core, a clear shearing surface with marked slip lines is visible on a plane that makes a 68 degree angle with respect to the core axis. This failure surface was not induced by the decompression process but is indeed a slip plane as clear striation is observed at the interface. On the basis of an elastoplastic constitutive model calibrated on triaxial tests on the clayey gouge, it is shown that shear band formation inside the clayey core is possible. The solution for the orientation of the shear band is compared to the orientation of an existing slip surface inside the clayey gouge and this result is used to deduce the orientation of the principal stresses. It is shown that as commonly observed in weak fault zones, the orientation of the principal stresses is locally almost parallel and perpendicular to the fault axis.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Finite element analysis of the indentation test on rocks with microstructure
Authors:
Jean Sulem,
Miguel Cerrolaza
Abstract:
Strength parameters of rocks are currently determined from indentation tests. In this paper, a finite element analysis of this test is presented and scale effect is studied. The rock is modelled as an elasto-plastic medium with Cosserat microstructure and consequently possesses an internal length. The response of the indentation curve is studied for various values of the size of the indentor as…
▽ More
Strength parameters of rocks are currently determined from indentation tests. In this paper, a finite element analysis of this test is presented and scale effect is studied. The rock is modelled as an elasto-plastic medium with Cosserat microstructure and consequently possesses an internal length. The response of the indentation curve is studied for various values of the size of the indentor as compared to the internal length of the rock in order to assess the scale effect.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Thermo-Poro-Mechanical Properties of Clayey Gouge and Application to Rapid Fault Shearing
Authors:
Jean Sulem,
Paul Lazar,
Ioannis Vardoulakis
Abstract:
In this paper, the mechanism of fault pressurization in rapid slip events is analyzed on the basis of a complete characterization of the thermo-poro-mechanical behavior of a clayey gouge extracted at 760m depth in Aigion fault in the active seismic zone of the Gulf of Corinth, Greece. It is shown that the thermally collapsible character of this clayey gouge can be responsible for a dramatic redu…
▽ More
In this paper, the mechanism of fault pressurization in rapid slip events is analyzed on the basis of a complete characterization of the thermo-poro-mechanical behavior of a clayey gouge extracted at 760m depth in Aigion fault in the active seismic zone of the Gulf of Corinth, Greece. It is shown that the thermally collapsible character of this clayey gouge can be responsible for a dramatic reduction of effective stress and a full fluidization of the material. The thickness of the 'ultra localized' zone of highly strained material is a key parameter that controls the competing phenomena of pore pressure increase leading to fluidization of the fault gouge and temperature increase leading to pore fluid vaporization.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
