-
On the noise in statistics of PIV measurements
Authors:
William K. George,
Michel Stanislas
Abstract:
It is argued herein that when PIV is used to measure turbulence, it can be treated as a time-dependent signal. The `output' velocity consists of three primary contributions: the time-dependent velocity, a noise arising from the quantization (or pixelization), and a noise contribution from the fact that the velocity is not uniform inside the interrogation volume. For both of the latter their varian…
▽ More
It is argued herein that when PIV is used to measure turbulence, it can be treated as a time-dependent signal. The `output' velocity consists of three primary contributions: the time-dependent velocity, a noise arising from the quantization (or pixelization), and a noise contribution from the fact that the velocity is not uniform inside the interrogation volume. For both of the latter their variances depend inversely on the average number of particles or images) in this interrogation volume. All three of these are spatially filtered by the finite extent of the interrogation window. Since the above noises are associated directly with the individual particles (or particle images), the noise between different realizations and different interrogation volumes is statistically independent.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2020; v1 submitted 21 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Velocity derivatives in a high Reynolds number turbulent boundary layer. Part III: Optimization of an SPIV experiment for derivative moments assessment
Authors:
Jean-Marc Foucaut,
William K. George,
Michel Stanislas,
Christophe Cuvier
Abstract:
An SPIV experiment using two orthogonal planes simultaneously was performed in the LML boundary layer facility to specifically measure all of the derivative moments needed to estimate the dissipation rate of the Turbulence Kinetic Energy. The Reynolds number was $Re_θ= 7500$ or $Re_τ= 2300$. A detailed analysis of the errors in derivative measurements was carried out, as well as applying and using…
▽ More
An SPIV experiment using two orthogonal planes simultaneously was performed in the LML boundary layer facility to specifically measure all of the derivative moments needed to estimate the dissipation rate of the Turbulence Kinetic Energy. The Reynolds number was $Re_θ= 7500$ or $Re_τ= 2300$. A detailed analysis of the errors in derivative measurements was carried out, as well as applying and using consistency checks derived from the continuity equation. The random noise error was quantified, and used to ``de-noise'' the derivative moments. A comparison with a DNS channel flow at comparable Reynolds number demonstrated the capability of the technique. The results were further validated using the recent theory developed by George and Stanislas 2020. The resulting data have been extensively used in parts I and II of the present contribution to study near wall dissipation. An important result of the present work is the provision of reliable rules for an accurate assessment of the dissipation in future PIV experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Velocity Derivatives in Turbulent Boundary Layers. Part II: Statistical Properties
Authors:
William K. George,
Michel Stanislas,
Jean-Marc Foucaut,
Jean-Philippe Laval,
Christophe Cuvier
Abstract:
An experiment was performed using Dual-plane-SPIV in the LMFL boundary layer facility to determine all of the derivative moments needed to estimate the average dissipation rate of the turbulent kinetic energy, $\varepsilon$, and its Reynolds stress counterpart the dissipation tensor, $\varepsilon_{ij}$. For this experiment, the Reynolds number was $Re_θ= 7500$ or $Re_τ= 2300$. Part I of this contr…
▽ More
An experiment was performed using Dual-plane-SPIV in the LMFL boundary layer facility to determine all of the derivative moments needed to estimate the average dissipation rate of the turbulent kinetic energy, $\varepsilon$, and its Reynolds stress counterpart the dissipation tensor, $\varepsilon_{ij}$. For this experiment, the Reynolds number was $Re_θ= 7500$ or $Re_τ= 2300$. Part I of this contribution \cite{stanislas20} presented in short the experiment and discussed in detail the dissipation profile and all twelve derivative moments required to compute it. The data were compared to a channel flow DNS at approximately the same Reynolds number and to previous results. They were also used to evaluate recent theoretical results for the overlap region.
In this Part II the experimental and DNS results are used to evaluate the assumptions of `local isotropy', `local axisymmetry', and `local homogeneity'. They are extended to include the full dissipation tensor, $\varepsilon_{ij}$ and the `pseudo-dissipation tensor', $\mathcal{D}_{ij}$ and explain the strong anisotropy of the dissipation tensors observed. Two important results of the present study are that {\it local isotropy} is never valid inside the outer limit of the overlap region, $y/δ_{99} \approx 0.1$; and that the assumptions of {\it local axisymmetry} and {\it local homogeneity} fail inside of $y^+ =100$. The implications of {\it homogeneity in planes parallel to the wall} is introduced to partially explain observations throughout the wall layer. The dissipation characteristics in this very near wall region show that $\varepsilon_{ij}$ is close to but different from $\mathcal{D}_{ij}$ .
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Velocity derivatives in a high Reynolds number turbulent boundary layer. Part I: Dissipation and Energy Balance
Authors:
Michel Stanislas,
Jean Marc Foucaut,
William K. George,
Christophe Cuvier,
Jean Philippe Laval
Abstract:
An experiment was performed using SPIV in the LMFL boundary layer facility to determine all the derivative moments needed to estimate the average dissipation rate of the turbulence kinetic energy, $\varepsilon = 2 ν\langle s_{ij}s_{ij} \rangle$ where $s_{ij}$ is the fluctuating strain-rate and $\langle~\rangle$ denotes ensemble averages. Also measured were all the moments of the full average defor…
▽ More
An experiment was performed using SPIV in the LMFL boundary layer facility to determine all the derivative moments needed to estimate the average dissipation rate of the turbulence kinetic energy, $\varepsilon = 2 ν\langle s_{ij}s_{ij} \rangle$ where $s_{ij}$ is the fluctuating strain-rate and $\langle~\rangle$ denotes ensemble averages. Also measured were all the moments of the full average deformation rate tensor, as well as all of the first, second and third fluctuating velocity moments except those involving pressure. The Reynolds number was $Re_θ= 7500$ or $Re_τ= 2300$. The results are presented in three separate papers. This first paper (Part I) presents the measured average dissipation, $\varepsilon$ and the derivative moments comprising it. It compares the results to the earlier measurements of \cite{balint91,honkan97} at lower Reynolds numbers and a new results from a plane channel flow DNS at comparable Reynolds number. It then uses the results to extend and evaluate the theoretical predictions of \cite{george97b,wosnik00} for all quantities in the overlap region. Of special interest is the prediction that $\varepsilon^+ \propto {y^+}^{-1}$ for streamwise homogeneous flows and a nearly indistinguishable power law, $\varepsilon \propto {y^+}^{γ-1}$, for boundary layers. In spite of the modest Reynolds number, the predictions seem to be correct. It also predicts and confirms that the transport moment contribution to the energy balance in the overlap region, $\partial \langle - pv /ρ- q^2 v/2 \rangle/ \partial y$ behaves similarly. An immediate consequence is that the usual eddy viscosity model for these terms cannot be correct. The second paper, Part II, examines in detail the statistical character of the velocity derivatives. The details of the SPIV methodology is in Part III, since it will primarily be of interest to experimentalists.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Comparison of turbulence profiles in high Reynolds number turbulent boundary layers and validation of a predictive model
Authors:
Jean-Philippe Laval,
John Christos Vassilicos,
Jean-Marc Foucaut,
Michel Stanislas
Abstract:
The modified Townsend-Perry attached eddy model of Vassilicos et al (2015) combines the outer peak/plateau behaviour of rms streamwise turbulence velocity profiles and the Townsend-Perry log-decay of these profiles at higher distances from the wall. This model was validated by these authors for high Reynolds number tur- bulent pipe flow data and is shown here to describe equally well and with abou…
▽ More
The modified Townsend-Perry attached eddy model of Vassilicos et al (2015) combines the outer peak/plateau behaviour of rms streamwise turbulence velocity profiles and the Townsend-Perry log-decay of these profiles at higher distances from the wall. This model was validated by these authors for high Reynolds number tur- bulent pipe flow data and is shown here to describe equally well and with about the same parameter values turbulent boundary layer flow data from four different facilities and a wide range of Reynolds numbers. The model has predictive value as, when extrapolated to the extremely high Reynolds numbers of the SLTEST data obtained at the Great Salt Lake Desert atmospheric test facility, it matches these data quite well.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Attached flow structure and streamwise energy spectra in a turbulent boundary layer
Authors:
Sricharan Srinath,
J. C Vassilicos,
Christophe Cuvier,
Jean-Philippe Laval,
Michel Stanislas,
Jean-Marc Foucaut
Abstract:
On the basis of (i) Particle Image Velocimetry data of a Turbulent Boundary Layer with large field of view and good spatial resolution and (ii) a mathematical relation between the energy spectrum and specifically modeled flow structures, we show that the scalings of the streamwise energy spectrum $E_{11}(k_{x})$ in a wavenumber range directly affected by the wall are determined by wall-attached ed…
▽ More
On the basis of (i) Particle Image Velocimetry data of a Turbulent Boundary Layer with large field of view and good spatial resolution and (ii) a mathematical relation between the energy spectrum and specifically modeled flow structures, we show that the scalings of the streamwise energy spectrum $E_{11}(k_{x})$ in a wavenumber range directly affected by the wall are determined by wall-attached eddies but are not given by the Townsend-Perry attached eddy model's prediction of these spectra, at least at the Reynolds numbers $Re_τ$ considered here which are between $10^{3}$ and $10^{4}$. Instead, we find $E_{11}(k_{x}) \sim k_{x}^{-1-p}$ where $p$ varies smoothly with distance to the wall from negative values in the buffer layer to positive values in the inertial layer. The exponent $p$ characterises the turbulence levels inside wall-attached streaky structures conditional on the length of these structures.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2017; v1 submitted 23 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Extensive characterization of a high Reynolds number decelerating boundary layer using advanced optical metrology
Authors:
C. Cuvier,
S. Srinath,
M. Stanislas,
J. -M. Foucaut,
J. -P. Laval,
C. J. Kähler,
R. Hain,
S. Scharnowski,
A. Schröder,
R. Geisler,
J. Agocs,
A. Röse,
C. Willert,
J. Klinner,
O. Amili,
C. Atkinson,
J. Soria
Abstract:
An experiment conducted in the framework of the EUHIT project and designed to characterize large scale structures in an adverse pressure gradient boundary layer flow is presented. Up to 16 sCMOS cameras were used in order to perform large scale turbulent boundary layer PIV measurements with a large field of view and appropriate spatial resolution. To access the span-wise / wall-normal signature of…
▽ More
An experiment conducted in the framework of the EUHIT project and designed to characterize large scale structures in an adverse pressure gradient boundary layer flow is presented. Up to 16 sCMOS cameras were used in order to perform large scale turbulent boundary layer PIV measurements with a large field of view and appropriate spatial resolution. To access the span-wise / wall-normal signature of the structures as well, stereoscopic PIV measurements in span-wise/wall-normal planes were performed at specific stream-wise locations. To complement these large field of view measurements, long-range micro-PIV, time resolved near wall velocity profiles and film-based measurements were performed in order to determine the wall-shear stress and its fluctuations at some specific locations along the model.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Feedback Control of Turbulent Shear Flows by Genetic Programming
Authors:
Thomas Duriez,
Vladimir Parezanović,
Kai von Krbek,
Jean-Paul Bonnet,
Laurent Cordier,
Bernd R. Noack,
Marc Segond,
Markus Abel,
Nicolas Gautier,
Jean-Luc Aider,
Cedric Raibaudo,
Christophe Cuvier,
Michel Stanislas,
Antoine Debien,
Nicolas Mazellier,
Azeddine Kourta,
Steven L. Brunton
Abstract:
Turbulent shear flows have triggered fundamental research in nonlinear dynamics, like transition scenarios, pattern formation and dynamical modeling. In particular, the control of nonlinear dynamics is subject of research since decades. In this publication, actuated turbulent shear flows serve as test-bed for a nonlinear feedback control strategy which can optimize an arbitrary cost function in an…
▽ More
Turbulent shear flows have triggered fundamental research in nonlinear dynamics, like transition scenarios, pattern formation and dynamical modeling. In particular, the control of nonlinear dynamics is subject of research since decades. In this publication, actuated turbulent shear flows serve as test-bed for a nonlinear feedback control strategy which can optimize an arbitrary cost function in an automatic self-learning manner. This is facilitated by genetic programming providing an analytically treatable control law. Unlike control based on PID laws or neural networks, no structure of the control law needs to be specified in advance. The strategy is first applied to low-dimensional dynamical systems featuring aspects of turbulence and for which linear control methods fail. This includes stabilizing an unstable fixed point of a nonlinearly coupled oscillator model and maximizing mixing, i.e.\ the Lyapunov exponent, for forced Lorenz equations. For the first time, we demonstrate the applicability of genetic programming control to four shear flow experiments with strong nonlinearities and intrinsically noisy measurements. These experiments comprise mixing enhancement in a turbulent shear layer, the reduction of the recirculation zone behind a backward facing step, and the optimized reattachment of separating boundary layers. Genetic programming control has outperformed tested optimized state-of-the-art control and has even found novel actuation mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
The streamwise turbulence intensity in the intermediate layer of turbulent pipe flow
Authors:
J. C. Vassilicos,
J. -P. Laval,
J. -M. Foucaut,
M. Stanislas
Abstract:
The spectral model of Perry, Henbest & Chong (1986) predicts that the integral length-scale varies very slowly with distance to the wall in the intermediate layer. The only way for the integral length scale's variation to be more realistic while keeping with the Townsend-Perry attached eddy spectrum is to add a new wavenumber range to the model at wavenumbers smaller than that spectrum. This neces…
▽ More
The spectral model of Perry, Henbest & Chong (1986) predicts that the integral length-scale varies very slowly with distance to the wall in the intermediate layer. The only way for the integral length scale's variation to be more realistic while keeping with the Townsend-Perry attached eddy spectrum is to add a new wavenumber range to the model at wavenumbers smaller than that spectrum. This necessary addition can also account for the high Reynolds number outer peak of the turbulent kinetic energy in the intermediate layer. An analytic expression is obtained for this outer peak in agreement with extremely high Reynolds number data by Hultmark, Vallikivi, Bailey & Smits (2012, 2013). The finding of Dallas, Vassilicos & Hewitt (2009) that it is the eddy turnover time and not the mean flow gradient which scales with distance to the wall and skin friction velocity in the intermediate layer implies, when combined with Townsend's (1976) production-dissipation balance, that the mean flow gradient has an outer peak at the same location as the turbulent kinetic energy. This is seen in the data of Hultmark, Vallikivi, Bailey & Smits (2012, 2013). The same approach also predicts that the mean flow gradient has a logarithmic decay at distances to the wall larger than the position of the outer peak, a qualitative prediction which the aforementioned data also support.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2014; v1 submitted 26 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
