-
Generalized mixed variable-pullback scheme with non-ideal Ohm's law for electromagnetic gyrokinetic simulations
Authors:
Zhixin Lu,
Guo Meng,
Roman Hatzky,
Eric Sonnendrücker,
Alexey Mishchenko,
Matthias Hoelzl
Abstract:
In this work, the non-ideal Ohm's law is integrated in the mixed variable-pullback scheme for the gyrokinetic particle simulations. This scheme captures the evolution of the symplectic solution of the gyrokinetic model accurately not only in the MHD limit but also in the electrostatic limit. This scheme also provides a pure symplectic ($v_\shortparallel $) scheme for electromagnetic gyrokinetic pa…
▽ More
In this work, the non-ideal Ohm's law is integrated in the mixed variable-pullback scheme for the gyrokinetic particle simulations. This scheme captures the evolution of the symplectic solution of the gyrokinetic model accurately not only in the MHD limit but also in the electrostatic limit. This scheme also provides a pure symplectic ($v_\shortparallel $) scheme for electromagnetic gyrokinetic particle simulations without causing the traditional cancellation problem in the pure Hamiltonian scheme. Various mixed variable schemes have been comprehensively analyzed for the 1D shear Alfvèn wave problem with kinetic electrons, with the connection to the traditional pure Hamiltonian scheme and the symplectic scheme. It is demonstrated that the pure $v_\shortparallel $ form with the non-ideal Ohm's law has comparable performance to the widely used mixed variable-pullback scheme with the ideal Ohm's law. The mixed variable-pullback scheme without Ohm's law is also proposed as a feasible improvement of the traditional pure Hamiltonian scheme with minimum modification and considerable performance improvement in terms of a marker number reduction.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2025;
originally announced September 2025.
-
On the Poisson brackets of hybrid plasma models with kinetic ions and massless electrons
Authors:
Yingzhe Li,
Philip J. Morrison,
Stefan Possanner,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
We investigate the conditions under which the Jacobi identity holds for a class of recently introduced anti-symmetric brackets for the hybrid plasma models with kinetic ions and massless electrons. In particular, we establish the precise conditions under which the brackets for the vector-potential-based formulations satisfy the Jacobi identity, and demonstrate that these conditions are fulfilled b…
▽ More
We investigate the conditions under which the Jacobi identity holds for a class of recently introduced anti-symmetric brackets for the hybrid plasma models with kinetic ions and massless electrons. In particular, we establish the precise conditions under which the brackets for the vector-potential-based formulations satisfy the Jacobi identity, and demonstrate that these conditions are fulfilled by all physically relevant functionals. Moreover, for the magnetic-field-based formulation, we show that the corresponding anti-symmetric bracket constitutes a Poisson bracket under the divergence-free condition of the magnetic field, and we provide a direct proof of the Jacobi identity. These results are further extended to models incorporating electron entropy as well as more general hybrid kinetic-fluid models.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2025;
originally announced September 2025.
-
Semi-Lagrangian methods for a plasma hybrid model with multi-species kinetic ions and massless electrons
Authors:
Yingzhe Li,
Philip J. Morrison,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
The semi-Lagrangian methods with the improved number of one-dimensional advections are proposed for a plasma hybrid model with kinetic ions and mass-less electrons. Two subsystems with mass, momentum, and energy conservation are obtained by a Poisson bracket-based splitting method. For the subsystem in which the distribution functions and the fields are coupled, the second order and reversible mod…
▽ More
The semi-Lagrangian methods with the improved number of one-dimensional advections are proposed for a plasma hybrid model with kinetic ions and mass-less electrons. Two subsystems with mass, momentum, and energy conservation are obtained by a Poisson bracket-based splitting method. For the subsystem in which the distribution functions and the fields are coupled, the second order and reversible modified implicit mid-point rule is used in time with the specially designed mean velocity. The distribution functions are not involved in the iterations and are solved by exact splittings with only one dimensional advections, which makes the proposed schemes efficient. The cancellation problem is overcome by the numerical schemes constructed. Moreover, for the case with a periodic boundary condition, the magnetic field obtained is divergence free, mass, momentum, and energy are conserved. The methods can be extended to cases with multiple ion species.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2025; v1 submitted 5 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
A geometric Particle-In-Cell discretization of the drift-kinetic and fully kinetic Vlasov-Maxwell equations
Authors:
Guo Meng,
Katharina Kormann,
Emil Poulsen,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
In this paper, we extend the geometric Particle in Cell framework on dual grids to a gauge-free drift-kinetic Vlasov--Maxwell model and its coupling with the fully kinetic model. We derive a discrete action principle on dual grids for our drift-kinetic model, such that the dynamical system involves only the electric and magnetic fields and not the potentials as most drift-kinetic and gyrokinetic m…
▽ More
In this paper, we extend the geometric Particle in Cell framework on dual grids to a gauge-free drift-kinetic Vlasov--Maxwell model and its coupling with the fully kinetic model. We derive a discrete action principle on dual grids for our drift-kinetic model, such that the dynamical system involves only the electric and magnetic fields and not the potentials as most drift-kinetic and gyrokinetic models do. This yields a macroscopic Maxwell equation including polarization and magnetization terms that can be coupled straightforwardly with a fully kinetic model.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Piecewise Field-Aligned Finite Element Method for Multi-Mode Nonlinear Particle Simulations in tokamak plasmas
Authors:
Zhixin Lu,
Guo Meng,
Eric Sonnendrücker,
Roman Hatzky,
Alexey Mishchenko,
Fulvio Zonca,
Philipp Lauber,
Matthias Hoelzl
Abstract:
This paper presents a novel approach for simulating plasma instabilities in tokamak plasmas using the piecewise field-aligned finite element method in combination with the particle-in-cell method. Our method traditionally aligns the computational grid but defines the basis functions in piecewise field-aligned coordinates to avoid grid deformation while naturally representing the field-aligned mode…
▽ More
This paper presents a novel approach for simulating plasma instabilities in tokamak plasmas using the piecewise field-aligned finite element method in combination with the particle-in-cell method. Our method traditionally aligns the computational grid but defines the basis functions in piecewise field-aligned coordinates to avoid grid deformation while naturally representing the field-aligned mode structures. This scheme is formulated and implemented numerically. It also applied to the unstructured triangular meshes in principle. We have conducted linear benchmark tests, which agree well with previous results and traditional schemes. Furthermore, multiple-$n$ simulations are also carried out as a proof of principle, demonstrating the efficiency of this scheme in nonlinear turbulence simulations within the framework of the finite element method.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Gyrokinetic Electromagnetic Particle Simulations in Triangular Meshes with C1 Finite Elements
Authors:
Zhixin Lu,
Guo Meng,
Roman Hatzky,
Eric Sonnendrücker,
Alexey Mishchenko,
Jin Chen,
Philipp Lauber,
Fulvio Zonca,
Matthias Hoelzl
Abstract:
The triangular mesh-based gyrokinetic scheme enables comprehensive axis-to-edge studies across the entire plasma volume. Our approach employs triangular finite elements with first-derivative continuity (C1), building on previous work to facilitate gyrokinetic simulations. Additionally, we have adopted the mixed variable/pullback scheme for gyrokinetic electromagnetic particle simulations. The filt…
▽ More
The triangular mesh-based gyrokinetic scheme enables comprehensive axis-to-edge studies across the entire plasma volume. Our approach employs triangular finite elements with first-derivative continuity (C1), building on previous work to facilitate gyrokinetic simulations. Additionally, we have adopted the mixed variable/pullback scheme for gyrokinetic electromagnetic particle simulations. The filter-free treatment in the poloidal cross-section with triangular meshes introduces unique features and challenges compared to previous treatments using structured meshes. Our implementation has been validated through benchmarks using ITPA-TAE (Toroidicity-induced Alfvén Eigenmode) parameters, showing its capability in moderate to small electron skin depth regimes. Additional examinations using experimental parameters confirm its applicability to realistic plasma conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
A Hamiltonian structure-preserving discretization of Maxwell's equations in nonlinear media
Authors:
William Barham,
Yaman Güçlü,
Philip J. Morrison,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
A simple Hamiltonian modeling framework for general models in nonlinear optics is given. This framework is specialized to describe the Hamiltonian structure of electromagnetic phenomena in cubicly nonlinear optical media. The model has a simple Poisson bracket structure with the Hamiltonian encoding all of the nonlinear coupling of the fields. The field-independence of the Poisson bracket facilita…
▽ More
A simple Hamiltonian modeling framework for general models in nonlinear optics is given. This framework is specialized to describe the Hamiltonian structure of electromagnetic phenomena in cubicly nonlinear optical media. The model has a simple Poisson bracket structure with the Hamiltonian encoding all of the nonlinear coupling of the fields. The field-independence of the Poisson bracket facilitates a straightforward Hamiltonian structure-preserving discretization using finite element exterior calculus. The generality and relative simplicity of this Hamiltonian framework makes it amenable for simulating a broad class of time-domain nonlinear optical problems. The main contribution of this work is a finite element discretization of Maxwell's equations in cubicly nonlinear media which is energy-stable and exactly conserves Gauss's laws. Moreover, this approach may be readily adapted to consider more general nonlinear media in subsequent work.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Structure preserving hybrid Finite Volume Finite Element method for compressible MHD
Authors:
Francesco Fambri,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
In this manuscript we present a novel and efficient numerical method for the compressible viscous and resistive MHD equations for all Mach number regimes. The time-integration strategy is a semi-implicit splitting, combined with a hybrid finite-volume and finite-element (FE) discretization in space. The non-linear convection is solved by a robust explicit FV scheme, while the magneto-acoustic term…
▽ More
In this manuscript we present a novel and efficient numerical method for the compressible viscous and resistive MHD equations for all Mach number regimes. The time-integration strategy is a semi-implicit splitting, combined with a hybrid finite-volume and finite-element (FE) discretization in space. The non-linear convection is solved by a robust explicit FV scheme, while the magneto-acoustic terms are treated implicitly in time. The resulting CFL stability condition depends only on the fluid velocity, and not on the Alfvénic and acoustic modes. The magneto-acoustic terms are discretized by compatible FE based on a continuous and a discrete de Rham complexes designed using Finite Element Exterior Calculus (FEEC). Thanks to the use of FEEC, energy stability, magnetic-helicity conservation and the divergence-free conditions can be preserved also at the discrete level. A very efficient splitting approach is used to separate the acoustic and the Alfvénic modes in such a fashion that the original symmetries of the PDE governing equations are preserved. In this way, the algorithm relies on the solution of linear, symmetric and positive-definite algebraic systems, that are very efficiently handled by the simple matrix-free conjugate-gradient method. The resulting algorithm showed to be robust and accurate in low and high Mach regimes even at large Courant numbers. Non-trivial tests are solved in one-, two- and three- space dimensions to confirm the robustness, accuracy, and the low-dissipative and conserving properties of the final algorithm. While the formulation of the method is very general, numerical results for a second-order accurate FV-FE scheme will be presented.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Gauge-invariant variational formulations of electromagnetic gyrokinetic theory
Authors:
Ronald Remmerswaal,
Roman Hatzky,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
The use of gyrokinetics, wherein phase-space coordinate transformations result in a phase-space dimensionality reduction as well as the removal of fast time scales, has enabled the simulation of microturbulence in fusion devices. The state-of-the-art gyrokinetic models used in practice are parallel-only models wherein the perpendicular part of the vector potential is neglected. Such models are inh…
▽ More
The use of gyrokinetics, wherein phase-space coordinate transformations result in a phase-space dimensionality reduction as well as the removal of fast time scales, has enabled the simulation of microturbulence in fusion devices. The state-of-the-art gyrokinetic models used in practice are parallel-only models wherein the perpendicular part of the vector potential is neglected. Such models are inherently not gauge invariant. We generalise the work of [Burby, Brizard. Physics Letters A, 383(18):2172-2175] by deriving a sufficient condition on the gyrocentre coordinate transformation which ensures gauge invariance. This leads to a parametrized family of gyrokinetic models for which we motivate a specific choice of parameters that results in the smallest gyrocentre coordinate transformation for which the resulting gyrokinetic model is consistent, gyro-phase independent, gauge invariant and has an invariant magnetic moment. Due to gauge invariance this model can be expressed directly in terms of the electromagnetic fields, rather than the potentials, and the gyrokinetic model thereby results in the macroscopic Maxwell's equations. For the linearised model, it is demonstrated that the shear and compressional Alfvén waves are present with the correct frequencies. The fast compressional Alfvén wave can be removed by making use of a Darwin-like approximation. This approximation retains the gauge invariance of the proposed model.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2025; v1 submitted 22 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
A self-consistent Hamiltonian model of the ponderomotive force and its structure preserving discretization
Authors:
William Barham,
Yaman Güçlü,
Philip J. Morrison,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
In the presence of an inhomogeneous oscillatory electric field, charged particles experience a net force, averaged over the oscillatory timescale, known as the ponderomotive force. We derive a one-dimensional Hamiltonian model which self-consistently couples the electromagnetic field to a plasma which experiences the ponderomotive force. We derive a family of structure preserving discretizations o…
▽ More
In the presence of an inhomogeneous oscillatory electric field, charged particles experience a net force, averaged over the oscillatory timescale, known as the ponderomotive force. We derive a one-dimensional Hamiltonian model which self-consistently couples the electromagnetic field to a plasma which experiences the ponderomotive force. We derive a family of structure preserving discretizations of the model of varying order in space and time using conforming and broken finite element exterior calculus spectral element methods. In all variants of our discretization framework, the method is found to conserve the Casimir invariants of the continuous model to machine precision and the energy to the order of the splitting method used.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2023; v1 submitted 28 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Splitting scheme for gyro-kinetic equations with Semi-Lagrangian and Arakawa substeps
Authors:
Dominik Bell,
Martin Campos Pinto,
Davor Kumozec,
Frederik Schnack,
Emily Bourne,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
The gyro-kinetic model is an approximation of the Vlasov-Maxwell system in a strongly magnetized magnetic field. We propose a new algorithm for solving it combining the Semi-Lagrangian (SL) method and the Arakawa (AKW) scheme with a time-integrator. Both methods are successfully used in practice for different kinds of applications, in our case, we combine them by first decomposing the problem into…
▽ More
The gyro-kinetic model is an approximation of the Vlasov-Maxwell system in a strongly magnetized magnetic field. We propose a new algorithm for solving it combining the Semi-Lagrangian (SL) method and the Arakawa (AKW) scheme with a time-integrator. Both methods are successfully used in practice for different kinds of applications, in our case, we combine them by first decomposing the problem into a fast (parallel) and a slow (perpendicular) dynamical system. The SL approach and the AKW scheme will be used to solve respectively the fast and the slow subsystems. Compared to the scheme in [1], where the entire model is solved using only the SL method, our goal is to replace the method used in the slow subsystem by the AKW scheme, in order to improve the conservation of the physical constants.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2024; v1 submitted 24 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
A well-balanced and exactly divergence-free staggered semi-implicit hybrid finite volume/finite element scheme for the incompressible MHD equations
Authors:
F. Fambri,
E. Zampa,
S. Busto,
L. Río-Martín,
F. Hindenlang,
E. Sonnendrücker,
M. Dumbser
Abstract:
We present a new divergence-free and well-balanced hybrid FV/FE scheme for the incompressible viscous and resistive MHD equations on unstructured mixed-element meshes in 2 and 3 space dimensions. The equations are split into subsystems. The pressure is defined on the vertices of the primary mesh, while the velocity field and the normal components of the magnetic field are defined on an edge-based/…
▽ More
We present a new divergence-free and well-balanced hybrid FV/FE scheme for the incompressible viscous and resistive MHD equations on unstructured mixed-element meshes in 2 and 3 space dimensions. The equations are split into subsystems. The pressure is defined on the vertices of the primary mesh, while the velocity field and the normal components of the magnetic field are defined on an edge-based/face-based dual mesh in two and three space dimensions, respectively. This allows to account for the divergence-free conditions of the velocity field and of the magnetic field in a rather natural manner. The non-linear convective and the viscous terms are solved at the aid of an explicit FV scheme, while the magnetic field is evolved in a divergence-free manner via an explicit FV method based on a discrete form of the Stokes law in the edges/faces of each primary element. To achieve higher order of accuracy, a pw-linear polynomial is reconstructed for the magnetic field, which is guaranteed to be divergence-free via a constrained L2 projection. The pressure subsystem is solved implicitly at the aid of a classical continuous FE method in the vertices of the primary mesh. In order to maintain non-trivial stationary equilibrium solutions of the governing PDE system exactly, which are assumed to be known a priori, each step of the new algorithm takes the known equilibrium solution explicitly into account so that the method becomes exactly well-balanced. This paper includes a very thorough study of the lid-driven MHD cavity problem in the presence of different magnetic fields. We finally present long-time simulations of Soloviev equilibrium solutions in several simplified 3D tokamak configurations even on very coarse unstructured meshes that, in general, do not need to be aligned with the magnetic field lines.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Geometric Particle-In-Cell discretizations of a plasma hybrid model with kinetic ions and mass-less fluid electrons
Authors:
Yingzhe Li,
Martin Campos Pinto,
Florian Holderied,
Stefan Possanner,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
We explore the possibilities of applying structure-preserving numerical methods to a plasma hybrid model with kinetic ions and mass-less fluid electrons satisfying the quasi-neutrality relation. The numerical schemes are derived by finite element methods in the framework of finite element exterior calculus (FEEC) for field variables, particle-in-cell (PIC) methods for the Vlasov equation, and spli…
▽ More
We explore the possibilities of applying structure-preserving numerical methods to a plasma hybrid model with kinetic ions and mass-less fluid electrons satisfying the quasi-neutrality relation. The numerical schemes are derived by finite element methods in the framework of finite element exterior calculus (FEEC) for field variables, particle-in-cell (PIC) methods for the Vlasov equation, and splitting methods in time based on an anti-symmetric bracket proposed. Conservation properties of energy, quasi-neutrality relation, positivity of density, and divergence-free property of the magnetic field are given irrespective of the used resolution and metric. Local quasi-interpolation is used for dealing with the current terms in order to make the proposed methods more efficient. The implementation has been done in the framework of the Python package STRUPHY [1], and has been verified by extensive numerical experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Canonical variables based numerical schemes for hybrid plasma models with kinetic ions and massless electrons
Authors:
Yingzhe Li,
Florian Holderied,
Stefan Possanner,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
We study the canonical variables based numerical schemes of a hybrid model with kinetic ions and mass-less electrons. Two equivalent formulations of the hybrid model are presented with the vector potentials in different gauges and the distribution functions depending on canonical momentum (not velocity), which constitutes a pair of canonical variables with the position variable. Particle-in-cell m…
▽ More
We study the canonical variables based numerical schemes of a hybrid model with kinetic ions and mass-less electrons. Two equivalent formulations of the hybrid model are presented with the vector potentials in different gauges and the distribution functions depending on canonical momentum (not velocity), which constitutes a pair of canonical variables with the position variable. Particle-in-cell methods are used for the distribution functions, and the vector potentials are discretized by the finite element methods in the framework of finite element exterior calculus. Splitting methods are used for the time discretizations. It is illustrated that the second formulation is numerically superior and the schemes constructed based on the anti-symmetric bracket proposed have better conservation properties and lower noise, although the filters can be used to improve the schemes of the first formulation.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2024; v1 submitted 24 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Perfect Conductor Boundary Conditions for Geometric Particle-in-Cell Simulations of the Vlasov-Maxwell System in Curvilinear Coordinates
Authors:
Benedikt Perse,
Katharina Kormann,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
Structure-preserving methods can be derived for the Vlasov-Maxwell system from a discretisation of the Poisson bracket with compatible finite-elements for the fields and a particle representation of the distribution function. These geometric electromagnetic particle-in-cell (GEMPIC) discretisations feature excellent conservation properties and long-time numerical stability. This paper extends the…
▽ More
Structure-preserving methods can be derived for the Vlasov-Maxwell system from a discretisation of the Poisson bracket with compatible finite-elements for the fields and a particle representation of the distribution function. These geometric electromagnetic particle-in-cell (GEMPIC) discretisations feature excellent conservation properties and long-time numerical stability. This paper extends the GEMPIC formulation in curvilinear coordinates to realistic boundary conditions. We build a de Rham sequence based on spline functions with clamped boundaries and apply perfect conductor boundary conditions for the fields and reflecting boundary conditions for the particles. The spatial semi-discretisation forms a discrete Poisson system. Time discretisation is either done by Hamiltonian splitting yielding a semi-explicit Gauss conserving scheme or by a discrete gradient scheme applied to a Poisson splitting yielding a semi-implicit energy-conserving scheme. Our system requires the inversion of the spline finite element mass matrices, which we precondition with the combination of a Jacobi preconditioner and the spectrum of the mass matrices on a periodic tensor product grid.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
A mimetic discretization of the macroscopic Maxwell equations in Hamiltonian form
Authors:
William Barham,
Yaman Güçlü,
Philip J. Morrison,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
A mimetic spectral element discretization, utilizing a novel Galerkin projection Hodge star operator, of the macroscopic Maxwell equations in Hamiltonian form is presented. The idea of splitting purely topological and metric dependent quantities is natural in the Hamiltonian modeling framework as the Poisson bracket is metric free with the Hamiltonian containing all metric information. This idea m…
▽ More
A mimetic spectral element discretization, utilizing a novel Galerkin projection Hodge star operator, of the macroscopic Maxwell equations in Hamiltonian form is presented. The idea of splitting purely topological and metric dependent quantities is natural in the Hamiltonian modeling framework as the Poisson bracket is metric free with the Hamiltonian containing all metric information. This idea may be incorporated into the mimetic spectral element method by directly discretizing the Poincaré duality structure. This "split exterior calculus mimetic spectral element method" yields spatially discretized Maxwell's equations which are Hamiltonian and exactly and strongly conserve Gauss's laws. Moreover, the new discrete Hodge star operator is itself of interest as a partition of the purely topological and metric dependent portions of the Hodge star operator. As a simple test case, the numerical results of applying this method to a one-dimensional version of Maxwell's equations are given.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2022; v1 submitted 16 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
On Geometric Fourier Particle In Cell Methods
Authors:
Martin Campos Pinto,
Jakob Ameres,
Katharina Kormann,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
In this article we describe a unifying framework for variational electromagnetic particle schemes of spectral type, and we propose a novel spectral Particle-In-Cell (PIC) scheme that preserves a discrete Hamiltonian structure. Our work is based on a new abstract variational derivation of particle schemes which builds on a de Rham complex where Low's Lagrangian is discretized using a particle appro…
▽ More
In this article we describe a unifying framework for variational electromagnetic particle schemes of spectral type, and we propose a novel spectral Particle-In-Cell (PIC) scheme that preserves a discrete Hamiltonian structure. Our work is based on a new abstract variational derivation of particle schemes which builds on a de Rham complex where Low's Lagrangian is discretized using a particle approximation of the distribution function. In this framework, which extends the recent Finite Element based Geometric Electromagnetic PIC (GEMPIC) method to a variety of field solvers, the discretization of the electromagnetic potentials and fields is represented by a de Rham sequence of compatible spaces, and the particle-field coupling procedure is described by approximation operators that commute with the differential operators in the sequence. In particular, for spectral Maxwell solvers the choice of truncated $L^2$ projections using continuous Fourier transform coefficients for the commuting approximation operators yields the gridless Particle-in-Fourier method, whereas spectral Particle-in-Cell methods are obtained by using discrete Fourier transform coefficients computed from a grid. By introducing a new sequence of spectral pseudo-differential approximation operators, we then obtain a novel variational spectral PIC method with discrete Hamiltonian structure that we call Fourier-GEMPIC. Fully discrete schemes are then derived using a Hamiltonian splitting procedure, leading to explicit time steps that preserve the Gauss laws and the discrete Poisson bracket associated with the Hamiltonian structure. These explicit steps share many similarities with standard spectral PIC methods. As arbitrary filters are allowed in our framework, we also discuss aliasing errors and study a natural back-filtering procedure to mitigate the damping caused by anti-aliasing smoothing particle shapes.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Geometric Particle-in-Cell Simulations of the Vlasov--Maxwell System in Curvilinear Coordinates
Authors:
Benedikt Perse,
Katharina Kormann,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
Numerical schemes that preserve the structure of the kinetic equations can provide stable simulation results over a long time. An electromagnetic particle-in-cell solver for the Vlasov-Maxwell equations that preserves at the discrete level the non-canonical Hamiltonian structure of the Vlasov-Maxwell equations has been presented in [Kraus et al. 2017]. Whereas the original formulation has been obt…
▽ More
Numerical schemes that preserve the structure of the kinetic equations can provide stable simulation results over a long time. An electromagnetic particle-in-cell solver for the Vlasov-Maxwell equations that preserves at the discrete level the non-canonical Hamiltonian structure of the Vlasov-Maxwell equations has been presented in [Kraus et al. 2017]. Whereas the original formulation has been obtained for Cartesian coordinates, we extend the formulation to curvilinear coordinates in this paper. For the discretisation in time, we discuss several (semi-)implicit methods either based on a Hamiltonian splitting or a discrete gradient method combined with an antisymmetric splitting of the Poisson matrix and discuss their conservation properties and computational efficiency.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Energy-conserving time propagation for a geometric particle-in-cell Vlasov--Maxwell solver
Authors:
Katharina Kormann,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
This paper discusses energy-conserving time-discretizations for finite element particle-in-cell discretizations of the Vlasov--Maxwell system. A geometric spatially discrete system can be obtained using a standard particle-in-cell discretization of the particle distribution and compatible finite element spaces for the fields to discretize the Poisson bracket of the Vlasov--Maxwell model (see Kraus…
▽ More
This paper discusses energy-conserving time-discretizations for finite element particle-in-cell discretizations of the Vlasov--Maxwell system. A geometric spatially discrete system can be obtained using a standard particle-in-cell discretization of the particle distribution and compatible finite element spaces for the fields to discretize the Poisson bracket of the Vlasov--Maxwell model (see Kraus et al., J Plasma Phys 83, 2017). In this paper, we derive energy-conserving time-discretizations based on the discrete gradient method applied to an antisymmetric splitting of the Poisson matrix. Firstly, we propose a semi-implicit method based on the average-vector-field discretization of the subsystems. Moreover, we devise an alternative discrete gradient that yields a time discretization that can additionally conserve Gauss' law. Finally, we explain how substepping for fast species dynamics can be incorporated.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
ORB5: a global electromagnetic gyrokinetic code using the PIC approach in toroidal geometry
Authors:
E. Lanti,
N. Ohana,
N. Tronko,
T. Hayward-Schneider,
A. Bottino,
B. F. McMillan,
A. Mishchenko,
A. Scheinberg,
A. Biancalani,
P. Angelino,
S. Brunner,
J. Dominski,
P. Donnel,
C. Gheller,
R. Hatzky,
A. Jocksch,
S. Jolliet,
Z. X. Lu,
J. P. Martin Collar,
I. Novikau,
E. Sonnendrücker,
T. Vernay,
L. Villard
Abstract:
This paper presents the current state of the global gyrokinetic code ORB5 as an update of the previous reference [Jolliet et al., Comp. Phys. Commun. 177 409 (2007)]. The ORB5 code solves the electromagnetic Vlasov-Maxwell system of equations using a PIC scheme and also includes collisions and strong flows. The code assumes multiple gyrokinetic ion species at all wavelengths for the polarization d…
▽ More
This paper presents the current state of the global gyrokinetic code ORB5 as an update of the previous reference [Jolliet et al., Comp. Phys. Commun. 177 409 (2007)]. The ORB5 code solves the electromagnetic Vlasov-Maxwell system of equations using a PIC scheme and also includes collisions and strong flows. The code assumes multiple gyrokinetic ion species at all wavelengths for the polarization density and drift-kinetic electrons. Variants of the physical model can be selected for electrons such as assuming an adiabatic response or a ``hybrid'' model in which passing electrons are assumed adiabatic and trapped electrons are drift-kinetic. A Fourier filter as well as various control variates and noise reduction techniques enable simulations with good signal-to-noise ratios at a limited numerical cost. They are completed with different momentum and zonal flow-conserving heat sources allowing for temperature-gradient and flux-driven simulations. The code, which runs on both CPUs and GPUs, is well benchmarked against other similar codes and analytical predictions, and shows good scalability up to thousands of nodes.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
First principles gyrokinetic analysis of electromagnetic plasma instabilities
Authors:
Natalia Tronko,
Alberto Bottino,
Cristel Chandre,
Eric Sonnendrücker,
Emmanuel Lanti,
Noé Ohana,
Stephan Brunner,
Laurent Villard
Abstract:
A two-fold analysis of electromagnetic core tokamak instabilities in the framework of the gyrokinetic theory is presented. First principle theoretical foundations of the gyrokinetic theory are used to explain and justify the numerical results obtained with the global electromagnetic particle-in-cell code Orb5 whose model is derived from the Lagrangian formalism. The energy conservation law corresp…
▽ More
A two-fold analysis of electromagnetic core tokamak instabilities in the framework of the gyrokinetic theory is presented. First principle theoretical foundations of the gyrokinetic theory are used to explain and justify the numerical results obtained with the global electromagnetic particle-in-cell code Orb5 whose model is derived from the Lagrangian formalism. The energy conservation law corresponding to the Orb5 model is derived from the Noether theorem and implemented in the code as a diagnostics for energy balance and conservation verification. An additional Noether theorem based diagnostics is implemented in order to analyse destabilising mechanisms for the electrostatic and the electromagnetic Ion Temperature Gradient (ITG) instabilities in the core region of the tokamak. The transition towards the Kinetic Ballooning Modes (KBM) at high electromagnetic $β$ is also investigated.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Cross-code gyrokinetic verification and benchmark on the linear collisionless dynamics of the geodesic acoustic mode
Authors:
A. Biancalani,
A. Bottino,
C. Ehrlacher,
V. Grandgirard,
G. Merlo,
I. Novikau,
Z. Qiu,
E. Sonnendruecker,
X. Garbet,
T. Goerler,
S. Leerink,
F. Palermo,
D. Zarzoso
Abstract:
The linear properties of the geodesic acoustic modes (GAM) in tokamaks are investigated by means of the comparison of analytical theory and gyrokinetic numerical simulations. The dependence on the value of the safety factor, finite-orbit-width of the ions in relation to the radial mode width, magnetic-flux-surface shaping, and electron/ion mass ratio are considered. Nonuniformities in the plasma p…
▽ More
The linear properties of the geodesic acoustic modes (GAM) in tokamaks are investigated by means of the comparison of analytical theory and gyrokinetic numerical simulations. The dependence on the value of the safety factor, finite-orbit-width of the ions in relation to the radial mode width, magnetic-flux-surface shaping, and electron/ion mass ratio are considered. Nonuniformities in the plasma profiles (such as density, temperature, or safety factor), electro-magnetic effects, collisions and presence of minority species are neglected. Also, only linear simulations are considered, focusing on the local dynamics. We use three different gyrokinetic codes: the lagrangian (particle-in-cell) code ORB5, the eulerian code GENE and semi-lagrangian code GYSELA. One of the main aims of this paper is to provide a detailed comparison of the numerical results and analytical theory, in the regimes where this is possible. This helps understanding better the behavior of the linear GAM dynamics in these different regimes, the behavior of the codes, which is crucial in the view of a future work where more physics is present, and the regimes of validity of each specific analytical dispersion relation.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Hierarchy of second-order gyrokinetic Hamiltonian models for particle-in-cell codes
Authors:
Natalia Tronko,
A Bottino,
Cristel Chandre,
E Sonnendruecker
Abstract:
The reduced-particle model is the central element for the systematic derivation of the gyrokinetic Vlasov-Maxwell equations from first principles. Coupled to the fields inside the gyrokinetic field-particle Lagrangian, the reduced-particle model defines polarization and magnetization effects appearing in the gyrokinetic Maxwell equations. It is also used for the reconstruction of the gyrokinetic V…
▽ More
The reduced-particle model is the central element for the systematic derivation of the gyrokinetic Vlasov-Maxwell equations from first principles. Coupled to the fields inside the gyrokinetic field-particle Lagrangian, the reduced-particle model defines polarization and magnetization effects appearing in the gyrokinetic Maxwell equations. It is also used for the reconstruction of the gyrokinetic Vlasov equation from the particle characteristics. Various representations of reduced-particle models are available according to the choice of the gyrokinetic phase space coordinates. In this paper, the Hamiltonian representation of the reduced particle dynamics at an order suitable for the implementation in particle-in-cell simulations is explicitly derived from the general reduction procedure. The second-order (with respect to the fluctuating electromagnetic fields), full Finite Larmor Radius (FLR) Hamiltonian gyrokinetic particle model as well as the second-order model suitable specifically for the long-wavelength approximation (i.e., containing up to the second-order FLR corrections), are derived and compared to the model recently implemented in the particle-in-cell code ORB5. We show that the same long-wavelength approximate equations can also be derived by taking the proper limit of the full FLR model.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
GEMPIC: Geometric ElectroMagnetic Particle-In-Cell Methods
Authors:
Michael Kraus,
Katharina Kormann,
Philip J. Morrison,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
We present a novel framework for Finite Element Particle-in-Cell methods based on the discretization of the underlying Hamiltonian structure of the Vlasov-Maxwell system. We derive a semi-discrete Poisson bracket, which retains the defining properties of a bracket, anti-symmetry and the Jacobi identity, as well as conservation of its Casimir invariants, implying that the semi-discrete system is st…
▽ More
We present a novel framework for Finite Element Particle-in-Cell methods based on the discretization of the underlying Hamiltonian structure of the Vlasov-Maxwell system. We derive a semi-discrete Poisson bracket, which retains the defining properties of a bracket, anti-symmetry and the Jacobi identity, as well as conservation of its Casimir invariants, implying that the semi-discrete system is still a Hamiltonian system. In order to obtain a fully discrete Poisson integrator, the semi-discrete bracket is used in conjunction with Hamiltonian splitting methods for integration in time. Techniques from Finite Element Exterior Calculus ensure conservation of the divergence of the magnetic field and Gauss' law as well as stability of the field solver. The resulting methods are gauge invariant, feature exact charge conservation and show excellent long-time energy and momentum behaviour. Due to the generality of our framework, these conservation properties are guaranteed independently of a particular choice of the Finite Element basis, as long as the corresponding Finite Element spaces satisfy certain compatibility conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2017; v1 submitted 10 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Second order Gyrokinetic theory for Particle-In-Cell codes
Authors:
Natalia Tronko,
Alberto Bottino,
Eric Sonnendruecker
Abstract:
The main idea of Gyrokinetic dynamical reduction consists in systematical removing of fastest scale of motion (the gyro motion) from plasma's dynamics, resulting in a considerable model simplification and gain of computing time.
Gyrokinetic Maxwell-Vlasov system is broadly implemented in nowadays numerical experiments for modeling strongly magnetized plasma (both laboratory and astrophysical). D…
▽ More
The main idea of Gyrokinetic dynamical reduction consists in systematical removing of fastest scale of motion (the gyro motion) from plasma's dynamics, resulting in a considerable model simplification and gain of computing time.
Gyrokinetic Maxwell-Vlasov system is broadly implemented in nowadays numerical experiments for modeling strongly magnetized plasma (both laboratory and astrophysical). Different versions of reduced set of equations exist depending on the construction of the Gyrokinetic reduction procedure and approximations assumed while their derivation.
The purpose of this paper is to explicitly show the connection between the general second order gyrokinetic Maxwell-Vlasov system issued from the Modern Gyrokinetic theory derivation and the model currently implemented in global electromagnetic Particle in Cell code ORB5.
Strictly necessary information about the Modern Gyrokinetic formalism is given together with the consistent derivation of the gyrokinetic Maxwell-Vlasov equations from the first principle of dynamics. Variational formulation of dynamics is also used for simultaneously obtaining the corresponding exact energy conservation law. The result of that explicit derivation is used for verification of the energy conservation diagnostics currently implemented in ORB5 code.
This work subscribes into the context of codes verification project VeriGyro currently run in IPP Max Planck Institut in collaboration with others European institutions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2017; v1 submitted 12 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Simulations of Kinetic Electrostatic Electron Nonlinear (KEEN) Waves with Variable Velocity Resolution Grids and High-Order Time-Splitting
Authors:
Bedros Afeyan,
Fernando Casas,
Nicolas Crouseilles,
Adila Dodhy,
Erwan Faou,
Michel Mehrenberger,
Eric Sonnendrücker
Abstract:
KEEN waves are nonlinear, non-stationary, self-organized asymptotic states in Vlasov plasmas outside the scope or purview of linear theory constructs such as electron plasma waves or ion acoustic waves. Nonlinear stationary mode theories such as those leading to BGK modes also do not apply. The range in velocity that is strongly perturbed by KEEN waves depends on the amplitude and duration of the…
▽ More
KEEN waves are nonlinear, non-stationary, self-organized asymptotic states in Vlasov plasmas outside the scope or purview of linear theory constructs such as electron plasma waves or ion acoustic waves. Nonlinear stationary mode theories such as those leading to BGK modes also do not apply. The range in velocity that is strongly perturbed by KEEN waves depends on the amplitude and duration of the ponderomotive force used to drive them. Smaller amplitude drives create highly localized structures attempting to coalesce into KEEN waves. These cases have much more chaotic and intricate time histories than strongly driven ones. The narrow range in which one must maintain adequate velocity resolution in the weakly driven cases challenges xed grid numerical schemes. What is missing there is the capability of resolving locally in velocity while maintaining a coarse grid outside the highly perturbed region of phase space. We here report on a new Semi-Lagrangian Vlasov-Poisson solver based on conservative non-uniform cubic splines in velocity that tackles this problem head on. An additional feature of our approach is the use of a new high-order time-splitting scheme which allows much longer simulations per computational e ort. This is needed for low amplitude runs which take a long time to set up KEEN waves, if they are able to do so at all. The new code's performance is compared to uniform grid simulations and the advantages quanti ed. The birth pains associated with KEEN waves which are weakly driven is captured in these simulations. These techniques allow the e cient simulation of KEEN waves in multiple dimensions which will be tackled next as well as generalizations to Vlasov-Maxwell codes which are essential to understanding the impact of KEEN waves in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Vlasov on GPU (VOG Project)
Authors:
M. Mehrenberger,
C. Steiner,
L. Marradi,
N. Crouseilles,
E. Sonnendrucker,
B. Afeyan
Abstract:
This work concerns the numerical simulation of the Vlasov-Poisson set of equations using semi- Lagrangian methods on Graphical Processing Units (GPU). To accomplish this goal, modifications to traditional methods had to be implemented. First and foremost, a reformulation of semi-Lagrangian methods is performed, which enables us to rewrite the governing equations as a circulant matrix operating on…
▽ More
This work concerns the numerical simulation of the Vlasov-Poisson set of equations using semi- Lagrangian methods on Graphical Processing Units (GPU). To accomplish this goal, modifications to traditional methods had to be implemented. First and foremost, a reformulation of semi-Lagrangian methods is performed, which enables us to rewrite the governing equations as a circulant matrix operating on the vector of unknowns. This product calculation can be performed efficiently using FFT routines. Second, to overcome the limitation of single precision inherent in GPU, a δf type method is adopted which only needs refinement in specialized areas of phase space but not throughout. Thus, a GPU Vlasov-Poisson solver can indeed perform high precision simulations (since it uses very high order reconstruction methods and a large number of grid points in phase space). We show results for rather academic test cases on Landau damping and also for physically relevant phenomena such as the bump on tail instability and the simulation of Kinetic Electrostatic Electron Nonlinear (KEEN) waves.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Noiseless Vlasov-Poisson simulations with linearly transformed particles
Authors:
M. Campos Pinto,
E. Sonnendrücker,
A. Friedman,
D. Grote,
S. Lund
Abstract:
We introduce a deterministic discrete-particle simulation approach, the Linearly-Transformed Particle-In-Cell (LTPIC) method, that employs linear deformations of the particles to reduce the noise traditionally associated with particle schemes. Formally, transforming the particles is justified by local first order expansions of the characteristic flow in phase space. In practice the method amounts…
▽ More
We introduce a deterministic discrete-particle simulation approach, the Linearly-Transformed Particle-In-Cell (LTPIC) method, that employs linear deformations of the particles to reduce the noise traditionally associated with particle schemes. Formally, transforming the particles is justified by local first order expansions of the characteristic flow in phase space. In practice the method amounts to using deformation matrices within the particle shape functions; these matrices are updated via local evaluations of the forward numerical flow. Because it is necessary to periodically remap the particles on a regular grid to avoid excessively deforming their shapes, the method can be seen as a development of Denavit's Forward Semi-Lagrangian (FSL) scheme [J. Denavit, J. Comp. Physics 9, 75 (1972)]. However, it has recently been established [M. Campos Pinto, "Smooth particle methods without smoothing", arXiv:1112.1859 (2012)] that the underlying Linearly-Transformed Particle scheme converges for abstract transport problems, with no need to remap the particles; deforming the particles can thus be seen as a way to significantly lower the remapping frequency needed in the FSL schemes, and hence the associated numerical diffusion. To couple the method with electrostatic field solvers, two specific charge deposition schemes are examined, and their performance compared with that of the standard deposition method. Finally, numerical 1d1v simulations involving benchmark test cases and halo formation in an initially mismatched thermal sheet beam demonstrate some advantages of our LTPIC scheme over the classical PIC and FSL methods. Benchmarked test cases also indicate that, for numerical choices involving similar computational effort, the LTPIC method is capable of accuracy comparable to or exceeding that of state-of-the-art, high-resolution Vlasov schemes.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2013; v1 submitted 21 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
