-
Turbulence-induced anti-Stokes flow: experiments and theory
Authors:
Simen Å. Ellingsen,
Olav Rømcke,
Benjamin K. Smeltzer,
Miguel A. C. Teixeira,
Ton S. van den Bremer,
Kristoffer S. Moen,
R. Jason Hearst
Abstract:
We report experimental evidence of an Eulerian-mean flow, $\overline{u}(z)$, created by the interaction of surface waves and tailored ambient sub-surface turbulence, which partly cancels the Stokes drift, $u_s(z)$, and present supporting theory. Water-side turbulent velocity fields and Eulerian-mean flows were measured with particle image velocimetry before vs after the passage of a wave group, an…
▽ More
We report experimental evidence of an Eulerian-mean flow, $\overline{u}(z)$, created by the interaction of surface waves and tailored ambient sub-surface turbulence, which partly cancels the Stokes drift, $u_s(z)$, and present supporting theory. Water-side turbulent velocity fields and Eulerian-mean flows were measured with particle image velocimetry before vs after the passage of a wave group, and with vs without the presence of regular waves. We compare different wavelengths, steepnesses and turbulent intensities. In all cases, a significant change in the Eulerian-mean current is observed, strongly focused near the surface, where it opposes the Stokes drift. The observations support the picture that when waves encounter ambient sub-surface turbulence, the flow undergoes a transition during which Eulerian-mean momentum is redistributed vertically (without changing the depth-integrated mass transport) until a new equilibrium state is reached, wherein the near-surface ratio between $\mathrm{d}\overline{u}/\mathrm{d}z$ and $|\mathrm{d}u_s/\mathrm{d} z|$ approximately equals the ratio between the streamwise and vertical Reynolds normal stresses. This accords with a simple statistical theory derived here and holds regardless of the absolute turbulence level, whereas stronger turbulence means faster growth of the Eulerian-mean current. We present a model based on Rapid Distortion Theory which describes the generation of the Eulerian-mean flow as a consequence of the action of the Stokes drift on the background turbulence. Predictions are in qualitative, and reasonable quantitative, agreement with experiments on wave groups, where equilibrium has not yet been reached. Our results could have substantial consequences for predicting the transport of water-borne material in the oceans.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
The Effect of Horizontal Shear on Extracting Water Currents From Surface Wave Data
Authors:
Stefan Weichert,
Benjamin K. Smeltzer,
Simen Å. Ellingsen
Abstract:
The dispersive motion of surface waves is now routinely used to remotely measure the currents close beneath the surface of oceans and other natural flows. The current manifests as wavelength-dependent Doppler shifts in the spatiotemporal wave spectrum, which is obtained by performing a Fourier transform of an observed wave field, a procedure which assumes that the current is horizontally uniform w…
▽ More
The dispersive motion of surface waves is now routinely used to remotely measure the currents close beneath the surface of oceans and other natural flows. The current manifests as wavelength-dependent Doppler shifts in the spatiotemporal wave spectrum, which is obtained by performing a Fourier transform of an observed wave field, a procedure which assumes that the current is horizontally uniform within the field of view. This assumption is frequently not satisfied. We here analyze the effects of the presence of horizontal shear in the velocity field, with special emphasis on biases: ``measured'' velocities which differ systematically in magnitude and/or direction compared to the average current within the field of view. We generate random synthetic wave data according to a spectrum prescribed at the domain center while varying the current and its gradient, and the mean direction $θ_0$ and angular spread of the waves' propagation direction, from which we extract Doppler shift velocities (DSVs) using one of the most common numerical schemes. Assuming currents vary by up to 10\% of a characteristic wave phase velocity across the field of view, we find that strong biases can occur for highly directional wave spectra, strongly dependent on $θ_0$ and the current direction relative to that of its magnitude gradient. We discuss how biases arise in the DSV extraction procedure and suggest practical steps to discover the presence of biases.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Biases from spectral leakage in remote sensing of near-surface currents
Authors:
Stefan Weichert,
Benjamin K. Smeltzer,
Simen Å. Ellingsen
Abstract:
Remotely measuring subsurface water currents from imagery of the wave field has become a much-used technique. We study the biases and errors in such measurements due to spectral leakage, and suggest mitigating procedures. Deviations between peak values in the three-dimensional wave spectrum and the known dispersion relation in quiescent water are extracted and interpreted as current-induced Dopple…
▽ More
Remotely measuring subsurface water currents from imagery of the wave field has become a much-used technique. We study the biases and errors in such measurements due to spectral leakage, and suggest mitigating procedures. Deviations between peak values in the three-dimensional wave spectrum and the known dispersion relation in quiescent water are extracted and interpreted as current-induced Doppler shifts, from which the sub-surface current is inferred. The use of discrete Fourier transforms, however, introduces spectral leakage between nearby frequency bins. Analysing synthetically generated wave data adhering to realistic input spectra we show that although no current is in fact present, spurious currents can be "measured" which can amount to a significant fraction of the phase speed at the spectral peak. We analyse the effects of data tapering, method of Doppler shift extraction, limited wavenumber and frequency resolution, peakedness and angular width of the input spectrum, and average misalignment between waves and Doppler shift velocity direction. The narrower the input wave spectrum in frequency and/or direction, the greater the biases become. The use of a window function reduces the severity in nearly all cases, yet mitigates the effects of limited resolution more effectively in space than in time. When a current is present the absolute biases remain essentially unchanged, when waves and currents are roughly aligned tapering much alleviates the concomitant biases, whereas in the case of a cross-current, biases remain significant even for tapered data.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
On the measurement of the dispersion relation by a radar and the implication on the current retrieval
Authors:
Susanne Støle-Hentschel,
Benjamin Keeler Smeltzer,
Yaron Toledo
Abstract:
The work analyses the error in current retrievals from images of marine radars. The study is based on simulations of waves interacting with a shear current. The measured dispersion is related to the underlying wavenumber-dependent effective current. The highest tested radar antenna (H=45 m) with vertical polarization performed the best. For that case the root mean square error was at most 0.05 m/s…
▽ More
The work analyses the error in current retrievals from images of marine radars. The study is based on simulations of waves interacting with a shear current. The measured dispersion is related to the underlying wavenumber-dependent effective current. The highest tested radar antenna (H=45 m) with vertical polarization performed the best. For that case the root mean square error was at most 0.05 m/s above the one for the simulated wave field without imaging mechanism. The observation time of 20 minutes was compared to shorter windows. Depending on the needed accuracy, the time may be reduced to five minutes, associated with an loss of accuracy below 12%. The study shows the error of the current reconstruction depends on the shape of the profile and varies considerably from realization to realization
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Current Mapping from the Wave Spectrum
Authors:
Benjamin K. Smeltzer,
Simen Å. Ellingsen
Abstract:
In this chapter we review methods by which near--surface ocean currents can be measured remotely using images of the water surface, as obtained by X-band radar in particular. The presence of a current changes the dispersive behavior of surface waves, so our challenge is to solve the inverse problem: to infer the spatially-varying current from measurements of the wavy surface. We examine how remote…
▽ More
In this chapter we review methods by which near--surface ocean currents can be measured remotely using images of the water surface, as obtained by X-band radar in particular. The presence of a current changes the dispersive behavior of surface waves, so our challenge is to solve the inverse problem: to infer the spatially-varying current from measurements of the wavy surface. We examine how remote sensing of currents is achieved in practice by analyzing the wave spectrum, as may be measured for example by X-band radar. A set of consecutive backscatter images recorded as a function of time is Fourier-transformed to produce the spectrum, which gives information concerning the propagation of waves whose dispersion is altered by currents. X-band radar images measure the wave field over multiple square kilometers, and analyzing various spatial subsets of the images allows a map of the spatial variation of the currents to be reconstructed. Several algorithms for obtaining empirical dispersion relations from the measured spectrum and extracting the currents are reviewed: the least squares and iterative least squares method, the normalized scalar product method, and the polar current shell method. We go on to describe how the same methods and algorithms can be extended to also allowing the depth-dependence of the current to be determined. Reasonable agreement between radar-derived currents and in situ measurements has been demonstrated in multiple field measurements. However, more validation is necessary especially in the context of depth-varying flows. Understanding the extent to which Stokes drift is measured as part of the radar-derived current is not well-understood yet potentially important.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
An improved method for determining near-surface currents from wave dispersion measurements
Authors:
Benjamin K. Smeltzer,
Eirik Æsøy,
Anna Ådnøy,
Simen Å. Ellingsen
Abstract:
A new inversion method for determining near-surface shear currents from a measured wave spectrum is introduced. The method is straightforward to implement and starts from the existing state-of-the-art technique of assigning effective depths to measured wavenumber-dependent Doppler shift velocities. A polynomial fit is performed, with the coefficients scaled based on a simple derived relation to pr…
▽ More
A new inversion method for determining near-surface shear currents from a measured wave spectrum is introduced. The method is straightforward to implement and starts from the existing state-of-the-art technique of assigning effective depths to measured wavenumber-dependent Doppler shift velocities. A polynomial fit is performed, with the coefficients scaled based on a simple derived relation to produce a current profile that is an improved estimate of the true profile. The method involves no user-input parameters, with the optimal parameters involved in the polynomial fit being chosen based on a simple criterion involving the measured Doppler shift data only. The method is tested on experimental data obtained from a laboratory where current profiles of variable depth dependence could be created and measured by particle image velocimetry, which served as "truth" measurements. Applying the new inversion method to experimentally measured Doppler shifts resulted in a $>3\times$ improvement in accuracy relative to the state-of-the-art for current profiles with significant near-surface curvature. The experiments are dynamically similar to typical oceanographic flows such as wind-drift profiles and our laboratory thus makes a suitable and eminently useful scale model of the real-life setting. Our results show that the new method can achieve improved accuracy in reconstructing near-surface shear profiles from wave measurements by a simple extension of methods which are currently in use, incurring little extra complexity and effort. A novel adaptation of the normalized scalar product method has been implemented, able to extract Doppler shift velocities as a function of wavenumber from the measured wave spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2019; v1 submitted 24 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Observation of surface wave patterns modified by sub-surface shear currents
Authors:
Benjamin K. Smeltzer,
Eirik Æsøy,
Simen Å. Ellingsen
Abstract:
We report experimental observations of two canonical surface wave patterns --- ship waves and ring waves --- skewed by sub-surface shear, thus confirming effects predicted by recent theory. Observed ring waves on a still surface with sub-surface shear current are strikingly asymmetric, an effect of strongly anisotropic wave dispersion. Ship waves for motion across a sub--surface current on a still…
▽ More
We report experimental observations of two canonical surface wave patterns --- ship waves and ring waves --- skewed by sub-surface shear, thus confirming effects predicted by recent theory. Observed ring waves on a still surface with sub-surface shear current are strikingly asymmetric, an effect of strongly anisotropic wave dispersion. Ship waves for motion across a sub--surface current on a still surface exhibit striking asymmetry about the ship's line of motion, and large differences in wake angle and transverse wavelength for upstream vs downstream motion are demonstrated, all of which in good agreement with theoretical predictions. Neither of these phenomena can occur on a depth-uniform current. A quantitative comparison of measured vs predicted average phase shift for a ring wave is grossly mispredicted by no-shear theory, but in good agreement with predictions for the measured shear current. A clear difference in wave frequency within the ring wave packet is observed in the upstream vs downstream direction for all shear flows, while it conforms with theory for quiescent water for propagation normal to the shear current, as expected. Peak values of the measured 2-dimensional Fourier spectrum for ship waves are shown to agree well with the predicted criterion of stationary ship waves, with the exception of some cases where results are imperfect due to the limited wave-number resolution, transient effects and/or experimental noise.
Experiments were performed on controlled shear currents created in two different ways, with a curved mesh, and beneath a blocked stagnant-surface flow. Velocity profiles were measured with particle image velocimetry, and surface waves with a synthetic schlieren method. Our observations lend strong empirical support to recent predictions that wave forces on vessels and structures can be greatly affected by shear in estuarine and tidal waters.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Transient wave resistance upon a real shear current
Authors:
Yan Li,
Benjamin K. Smeltzer,
Simen Å. Ellingsen
Abstract:
We study the waves and wave-making forces acting on ships travelling on currents which vary as a function of depth. Our concern is realism; we consider a real current profile from the Columbia River, and model ships with dimensions and Froude numbers typical of three classes of vessels operating in these waters. To this end we employ the most general theory of waves from free-surface sources on sh…
▽ More
We study the waves and wave-making forces acting on ships travelling on currents which vary as a function of depth. Our concern is realism; we consider a real current profile from the Columbia River, and model ships with dimensions and Froude numbers typical of three classes of vessels operating in these waters. To this end we employ the most general theory of waves from free-surface sources on shear current to date, which we derive and present here. Expressions are derived for ship waves which satisfy an arbitrary dispersion relation and are generated by a wave source acting on the free surface, with the source's shape and time-dependence is also being arbitrary. Practical calculation procedures for numerically calculating dispersion on a shear current which may vary arbitrarily with depth both in direction and magnitude, are indicated.
For ships travelling at oblique angle to a shear-current, the ship wave pattern is asymmetrical, and wave-making radiation forces have a lateral component in addition to the conventional wave resistance, the sternward component. No corresponding lateral force exists in the absence of shear. We consider the dependence of wave resistance and lateral force for upstream, downstream and cross-stream motion on the Columbia River current, both in steady motion and during two different maneouvres: a ship suddenly set in motion, and a ship turning through 360 deg. We find that for smaller ships (tugboats, fishing-boats) the wave resistance can differ drastically from that in quiescent water, and depends strongly on Froude number and direction of motion. For Froude numbers typical of such boats, wave resistance can vary by a factor 3 between upstream and downstream motion, and the strong Froude number dependence is made more complicated by interference effects. The lateral radiation force ... [abstract truncated due to ArXiV's space restrictions]
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Surface waves on arbitrary vertically-sheared currents
Authors:
Benjamin K. Smeltzer,
Simen Å. Ellingsen
Abstract:
We study dispersion properties of linear surface gravity waves propagating in an arbitrary direction atop a current profile of depth-varying magnitude using a piecewise linear approximation, and develop a robust numerical framework for practical calculation. The method has been much used in the past for the case of waves propagating along the same axis as the background current, and we herein exte…
▽ More
We study dispersion properties of linear surface gravity waves propagating in an arbitrary direction atop a current profile of depth-varying magnitude using a piecewise linear approximation, and develop a robust numerical framework for practical calculation. The method has been much used in the past for the case of waves propagating along the same axis as the background current, and we herein extend and apply it to problems with an arbitrary angle between the wave propagation and current directions. Being valid for all wavelengths without loss of accuracy, the scheme is particularly well suited to solve problems involving a broad range of wave vectors, such as ship waves and Cauchy-Poisson initial value problems for example. We examine the group and phase velocities over different wavelength regimes and current profiles, highlighting characteristics due to the depth-variable vorticity. We show an example application to ship waves on an arbitrary current profile, and demonstrate qualitative differences in the wake patterns between concave down and concave up profiles when compared to a constant shear profile with equal depth-averaged vorticity. We also discuss the nature of additional solutions to the dispersion relation when using the piecewise-linear model. These are vorticity waves, drifting vortical structures which are artifacts of the piecewise model. They are absent for a smooth profile and are spurious in the present context.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2017; v1 submitted 13 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
