-
Dynamics of systems with varying number of particles: from Liouville equations to general master equations for open systems
Authors:
Mauricio J. del Razo,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
A varying number of particles is one of the most relevant characteristics of systems of interest in nature and technology, ranging from the exchange of energy and matter with the surrounding environment to the change of particle number through internal dynamics such as reactions. The physico-mathematical modeling of these systems is extremely challenging, with the major difficulty being the time d…
▽ More
A varying number of particles is one of the most relevant characteristics of systems of interest in nature and technology, ranging from the exchange of energy and matter with the surrounding environment to the change of particle number through internal dynamics such as reactions. The physico-mathematical modeling of these systems is extremely challenging, with the major difficulty being the time dependence of the number of degrees of freedom and the additional constraint that the increment or reduction of the number and species of particles must not violate basic physical laws. Theoretical models, in such a case, represent the key tool for the design of computational strategies for numerical studies that deliver trustful results. In this manuscript, we review complementary physico-mathematical approaches of varying number of particles inspired by rather different specific numerical goals. As a result of the analysis on the underlying common structure of these models, we propose a unifying master equation for general dynamical systems with varying number of particles. This equation embeds all the previous models and can potentially model a much larger range of complex systems, ranging from molecular to social agent-based dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2024; v1 submitted 21 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Computationally feasible bounds for the free energy of nonequilibrium steady states, applied to simple models of heat conduction
Authors:
Luigi Delle Site,
Carsten Hartmann
Abstract:
In this paper we study computationally feasible bounds for relative free energies between two many-particle systems. Specifically, we consider systems out of equilibrium that do not necessarily satisfy a fluctuation-dissipation relation, but that nevertheless admit a nonequilibrium steady state that is reached asymptotically in the long-time limit. The bounds that we suggest are based on the well-…
▽ More
In this paper we study computationally feasible bounds for relative free energies between two many-particle systems. Specifically, we consider systems out of equilibrium that do not necessarily satisfy a fluctuation-dissipation relation, but that nevertheless admit a nonequilibrium steady state that is reached asymptotically in the long-time limit. The bounds that we suggest are based on the well-known Bogoliubov inequality and variants of Gibbs' and Donsker-Varadhan variational principles. As a general paradigm, we consider systems of oscillators coupled to heat baths at different temperatures. For such systems, we define the free energy of the system relative to any given reference system (that may or may not be in thermal equilibrium) in terms of the Kullback-Leibler divergence between steady states. By employing a two-sided Bogoliubov inequality and a mean-variance approximation of the free energy (or cumulant generating function, we can efficiently estimate the free energy cost needed in passing from the reference system to the system out of equilibrium (characterised by a temperature gradient). A specific test case to validate our bounds are harmonic oscillator chains with ends that are coupled to Langevin thermostats at different temperatures; such a system is simple enough to allow for analytic calculations and general enough to be used as a prototype to estimate, e.g., heat fluxes or interface effects in a larger class of nonequilibrium particle systems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Simulation of a particle domain in a continuum/fluctuating hydrodynamics reservoir
Authors:
Abbas Gholami,
Rupert Klein,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
In molecular simulation and fluid mechanics, the coupling of a particle domain with a continuum representation of its embedding environment is an ongoing challenge. In this work, we show a novel approach where the latest version of the adaptive resolution scheme (AdResS), with non-interacting tracers as particles reservoir, is combined with a fluctuating hydrodynamics (FHD) solver. The resulting a…
▽ More
In molecular simulation and fluid mechanics, the coupling of a particle domain with a continuum representation of its embedding environment is an ongoing challenge. In this work, we show a novel approach where the latest version of the adaptive resolution scheme (AdResS), with non-interacting tracers as particles reservoir, is combined with a fluctuating hydrodynamics (FHD) solver. The resulting algorithm, supported by a solid mathematical model, allows for a physically consistent exchange of matter and energy between the particle domain and its fluctuating continuum reservoir. Numerical tests are performed to show the validity of the algorithm. Differently from previous algorithms of the same kind, the current approach allows for simulations where, in addition to density fluctuations, also thermal fluctuations can be accounted for, thus large complex molecular systems, as for example hydrated biological membranes in a thermal field, can now be efficiently treated.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2022; v1 submitted 27 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Two-sided Bogoliubov inequality to estimate finite size effects in quantum molecular simulations
Authors:
Benedikt Reible,
Carsten Hartmann,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We generalise the two-sided Bogoliubov inequality for classical particles from [L. Delle Site et al., J.Stat.Mech.Th.Exp. 083201 (2017)] to systems of quantum particles. As in the classical set-up, the inequality leads to upper and lower bounds for the free energy difference associated with the partitioning of a large system into smaller, independent subsystems. From a thermodynamic modelling poin…
▽ More
We generalise the two-sided Bogoliubov inequality for classical particles from [L. Delle Site et al., J.Stat.Mech.Th.Exp. 083201 (2017)] to systems of quantum particles. As in the classical set-up, the inequality leads to upper and lower bounds for the free energy difference associated with the partitioning of a large system into smaller, independent subsystems. From a thermodynamic modelling point of view, the free energy difference determines the finite size correction needed to consistently treat a small system as a representation of a large system. Applications of the bounds to quantify finite size effects are ubiquitous in physics, chemistry, material science, or biology, to name just a few; in particular it is relevant for molecular dynamics simulations in which a small portion of a system is usually taken as representative of the idealized large system.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2022; v1 submitted 19 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Thermodynamic relations at the coupling boundary in adaptive resolution simulations for open systems
Authors:
Abbas Gholami,
Felix Höfling,
Rupert Klein,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
The adaptive resolution simulation (AdResS) technique couples regions with different molecular resolutions and allows the exchange of molecules between different regions in an adaptive fashion. The latest development of the technique allows to abruptly couple the atomistically resolved region with a region of non-interacting point-like particles. The abrupt set-up was derived having in mind the id…
▽ More
The adaptive resolution simulation (AdResS) technique couples regions with different molecular resolutions and allows the exchange of molecules between different regions in an adaptive fashion. The latest development of the technique allows to abruptly couple the atomistically resolved region with a region of non-interacting point-like particles. The abrupt set-up was derived having in mind the idea of the atomistically resolved region as an open system embedded in a large reservoir at a given macroscopic state. In this work, starting from the idea of open system, we derive thermodynamic relations for AdResS which justify conceptually and numerically the claim of AdResS as a technique for simulating open systems. In particular, we derive the relation between the chemical potential of the AdResS set-up and that of its reference fully atomistic simulation. The implication of this result is that the grand potential of AdResS can be explicitly written and thus, from a statistical mechanics point of view, the atomistically resolved region of AdResS can be identified with a well defined open system.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Free energy computation of particles with membrane-mediated interactions via Langevin dynamics
Authors:
Tobias Kies,
Carsten Gräser,
Luigi Delle Site,
Ralf Kornhuber
Abstract:
We apply well-established concepts of Langevin sampling to derive a new class of algorithms for the efficient computation of free energy differences of fluctuating particles embedded in a 'fast' membrane, i.e., a membrane that instantaneously adapts to varying particle positions. A geometric potential accounting for membrane-mediated particle interaction is derived in the framework of variational…
▽ More
We apply well-established concepts of Langevin sampling to derive a new class of algorithms for the efficient computation of free energy differences of fluctuating particles embedded in a 'fast' membrane, i.e., a membrane that instantaneously adapts to varying particle positions. A geometric potential accounting for membrane-mediated particle interaction is derived in the framework of variational hybrid models for particles in membranes. Recent explicit representations of the gradient of the geometric interaction potential allows to apply well-known gradient based Markov Chain Monte-Carlo (MCDC) methods such as Langevin-based sampling.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Nonequilibrium induced by reservoirs: Physico-mathematical models and numerical tests
Authors:
Rupert Klein,
Roya Ebrahimi Viand,
Felix Höfling,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
In a recently proposed computational model of open molecular systems out of equilibrium [Ebrahimi Viand et al. J.Chem.Phys. 153, 101102 (2020)], the action of different reservoirs enters as a linear sum into the Liouville-type evolution equations for the open system's statistics. The linearity of the coupling is common to different mathematical models of open systems and essentially relies on negl…
▽ More
In a recently proposed computational model of open molecular systems out of equilibrium [Ebrahimi Viand et al. J.Chem.Phys. 153, 101102 (2020)], the action of different reservoirs enters as a linear sum into the Liouville-type evolution equations for the open system's statistics. The linearity of the coupling is common to different mathematical models of open systems and essentially relies on neglecting the feedback of the system onto the reservoir due to their interaction. In this paper, we test the range of applicability of the computational model with a linear coupling to two different reservoirs, which induces a nonequilibrium situation. To this end, we studied the density profiles of Lennard-Jones liquids in large thermal gradients using nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulations with open boundaries. We put in perspective the formulation of an extension of the mathematical model that can account for nonlinear effects.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2021; v1 submitted 28 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Open Systems out of Equilibrium: Theory and Simulation
Authors:
Roya Ebrahimi Viand,
Felix Höfling,
Rupert Klein,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We consider the theoretical model of Bergmann and Lebowitz for open systems out of equilibrium and translate its principles in the adaptive resolution molecular dynamics technique (AdResS). We simulate Lennard-Jones fluids with open boundaries in a thermal gradient and find excellent agreement of the stationary responses with results obtained from the simulation of a larger, locally forced closed…
▽ More
We consider the theoretical model of Bergmann and Lebowitz for open systems out of equilibrium and translate its principles in the adaptive resolution molecular dynamics technique (AdResS). We simulate Lennard-Jones fluids with open boundaries in a thermal gradient and find excellent agreement of the stationary responses with results obtained from the simulation of a larger, locally forced closed system. The encouraging results pave the way for a computational treatment of open systems far from equilibrium framed in a well-established theoretical model that avoids possible numerical artifacts and physical misinterpretations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Liouville-type equations for the n-particle distribution functions of an open system
Authors:
Luigi Delle Site,
Rupert Klein
Abstract:
In this work we derive a mathematical model for an open system that exchanges particles and momentum with a reservoir from their joint Hamiltonian dynamics. The complexity of this many-particle problem is addressed by introducing a countable set of n-particle phase space distribution functions just for the open subsystem, while accounting for the reservoir only in terms of statistical expectations…
▽ More
In this work we derive a mathematical model for an open system that exchanges particles and momentum with a reservoir from their joint Hamiltonian dynamics. The complexity of this many-particle problem is addressed by introducing a countable set of n-particle phase space distribution functions just for the open subsystem, while accounting for the reservoir only in terms of statistical expectations. From the Liouville equation for the full system we derive a set of coupled Liouville-type equations for the n-particle distributions by marginalization with respect to reservoir states. The resulting equation hierarchy describes the external momentum forcing of the open system by the reservoir across its boundaries, and it covers the effects of particle exchanges, which induce probability transfers between the n- and (n+1)-particle distributions. Similarities and differences with the Bergmann-Lebowitz model of open systems (P.G.Bergmann, J.L. Lebowitz, Phys.Rev., 99:578--587 (1955)) are discussed in the context of the implementation of these guiding principles in a computational scheme for molecular simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2020; v1 submitted 17 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
On the formalization of Asynchronous First Passage Algorithms
Authors:
Luigi Sbailò,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
The formalization of First Passage schemes is revisited and the emerging of a conceptual contradiction is underlined. We then show why, despite such a contradiction, the numerical results are not explicitly affected. Through a different formalization of the problem, we recast the current principles of the algorithm in a more solid conceptual framework, and numerical evidence gives further justific…
▽ More
The formalization of First Passage schemes is revisited and the emerging of a conceptual contradiction is underlined. We then show why, despite such a contradiction, the numerical results are not explicitly affected. Through a different formalization of the problem, we recast the current principles of the algorithm in a more solid conceptual framework, and numerical evidence gives further justification to our claims.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Nanoscale domains in ionic liquids: A statistical mechanics definition for molecular dynamics studies
Authors:
B. Shadrack Jabes,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
One of the many open questions concerning Ionic Liquids (ILs) is the existence of nanoscale supramolecular domains which characterize the bulk. The hypothesis of their existence does not meet a general consensus since their definition seems to be based on ad hoc arbitrary criteria rather than on general and solid first principles of physics. In this work, we propose a suitable definition of supram…
▽ More
One of the many open questions concerning Ionic Liquids (ILs) is the existence of nanoscale supramolecular domains which characterize the bulk. The hypothesis of their existence does not meet a general consensus since their definition seems to be based on ad hoc arbitrary criteria rather than on general and solid first principles of physics. In this work, we propose a suitable definition of supramolecular domains based on first principles of statistical mechanics. Such principles can be realized through the application of a recently developed computational tool which employs adaptive molecular resolution. The method can identify the smallest region of a liquid for which the atomistic details are strictly required, while the exterior plays the role of a generic structureless thermodynamic reservoir. We consider four different imidazolium-based ILs and show that indeed one can quantitatively represent the liquid as a collection of atomistically self-contained nanodroplets embedded in a generic thermodynamic bath. Such nanodroplets express a characteristic length scale for heterogeneity in ILs.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Simulation of many-electron systems that exchange matter with the environment
Authors:
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
The computational treatment of many-electron systems capable of exchanging {electrons and nuclei} with the environment represents one of the outermost frontiers in simulation methodology. The exchanging process occurs in a large variety of natural and artificially induced phenomena which are of major relevance to several leading fields of academic research and modern technology. In this progress r…
▽ More
The computational treatment of many-electron systems capable of exchanging {electrons and nuclei} with the environment represents one of the outermost frontiers in simulation methodology. The exchanging process occurs in a large variety of natural and artificially induced phenomena which are of major relevance to several leading fields of academic research and modern technology. In this progress report I will present an overview of problems in current materials science and chemical physics where the corresponding computational approaches require the concept of an electronic system with open boundaries. Quantum and Quantum/Classical computational techniques treat the exchange of electrons with the environment at different computational efficiency, conceptual rigorousness and numerical accuracy. The overall emerging picture shows a rich availability of interesting ideas, some with a higher weight on the pragmatic side, others with higher weight on the conceptual side; possible combinations, in perspective, may push the field much beyond its current frontiers.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Molecular dynamics of open systems: construction of a mean-field particle reservoir
Authors:
Luigi Delle Site,
Christian Krekeler,
John Whittaker,
Animesh Agarwal,
Rupert Klein,
Felix Höfling
Abstract:
The simulation of open molecular systems requires explicit or implicit reservoirs of energy and particles. Whereas full atomistic resolution is desired in the region of interest, there is some freedom in the implementation of the reservoirs. Here, we construct a combined, explicit reservoir by interfacing the atomistic region with regions of point-like, non-interacting particles (tracers) embedded…
▽ More
The simulation of open molecular systems requires explicit or implicit reservoirs of energy and particles. Whereas full atomistic resolution is desired in the region of interest, there is some freedom in the implementation of the reservoirs. Here, we construct a combined, explicit reservoir by interfacing the atomistic region with regions of point-like, non-interacting particles (tracers) embedded in a thermodynamic mean field. The tracer molecules acquire atomistic resolution upon entering the atomistic region and equilibrate with this environment, while atomistic molecules become tracers governed by an effective mean-field potential after crossing the atomistic boundary. The approach is extensively tested on thermodynamic, structural, and dynamic properties of liquid water. Conceptual and numerical advantages of the procedure as well as new perspectives are highlighted and discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Adaptive Resolution Molecular Dynamics Technique: Down to the Essential
Authors:
Christian Krekeler,
Animesh Agarwal,
Christoph Junghans,
Matej Praprotnik,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We investigate the role of the thermodynamic (TD) force, as an essential and sufficient technical ingredient for an efficient and accurate adaptive resolution algorithm. Such a force applied in the coupling region of an adaptive resolution Molecular Dynamics (MD) set-up, assures thermodynamic equilibrium between atomistically resolved and coarse-grained regions, allowing the proper exchange of mol…
▽ More
We investigate the role of the thermodynamic (TD) force, as an essential and sufficient technical ingredient for an efficient and accurate adaptive resolution algorithm. Such a force applied in the coupling region of an adaptive resolution Molecular Dynamics (MD) set-up, assures thermodynamic equilibrium between atomistically resolved and coarse-grained regions, allowing the proper exchange of molecules. We numerically prove that indeed for systems as relevant as liquid water and 1,3-dimethylimidazolium chloride ionic liquid, the combined action of the TD force and thermostat allows for computationally efficient and numerically accurate simulations, beyond the current capabilities of adaptive resolution set-ups, which employ switching functions in the coupling region.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Towards Open Boundary Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Ionic Liquids
Authors:
Christian Krekeler,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We extend the use of the adaptive resolution method (AdResS) in its Grand Canonical-like version (GC-AdResS) to the molecular dynamics simulation of 1,3-dimethylimidazolium chloride. We show that the partitioning of the total system in a subsystem of interest with atomistic details and a reservoir of coarse-grained particles leads to satisfactory results. The challenging aspect of this study, comp…
▽ More
We extend the use of the adaptive resolution method (AdResS) in its Grand Canonical-like version (GC-AdResS) to the molecular dynamics simulation of 1,3-dimethylimidazolium chloride. We show that the partitioning of the total system in a subsystem of interest with atomistic details and a reservoir of coarse-grained particles leads to satisfactory results. The challenging aspect of this study, compared to previous AdResS simulations, is the presence of charged particles and the necessity of addressing the question about the minimal physical input needed to model the coarse-grained particles in the reservoir. We propose two different approaches and show that in both cases they are sufficient to capture the decisive physical characteristics that allow a valid system-reservoir coupling. The technical satisfactory result paves the way for multiscale analysis of ionic liquids and for truly open boundary molecular simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Probing Spatial Locality in Ionic Liquids with the Grand Canonical Adaptive Resolution Molecular Dynamics Technique
Authors:
B. Shadrack Jabes,
C. Krekeler,
R. Klein,
L. Delle Site
Abstract:
We employ the Grand Canonical Adaptive Resolution Molecular Dynamics Technique (GC-AdResS) to test the spatial locality of the 1-ethyl 3-methyl imidazolium chloride liquid. In GC-AdResS atomistic details are kept only in an open sub-region of the system while the environment is treated at coarse-grained level, thus if spatial quantities calculated in such a sub-region agree with the equivalent qua…
▽ More
We employ the Grand Canonical Adaptive Resolution Molecular Dynamics Technique (GC-AdResS) to test the spatial locality of the 1-ethyl 3-methyl imidazolium chloride liquid. In GC-AdResS atomistic details are kept only in an open sub-region of the system while the environment is treated at coarse-grained level, thus if spatial quantities calculated in such a sub-region agree with the equivalent quantities calculated in a full atomistic simulation then the atomistic degrees of freedom outside the sub-region play a negligible role. The size of the sub-region fixes the degree of spatial locality of a certain quantity. We show that even for sub-regions whose radius corresponds to the size of a few molecules, spatial properties are reasonably {reproduced} thus suggesting a higher degree of spatial locality, a hypothesis put forward also by other {researchers} and that seems to play an important role for the characterization of fundamental properties of a large class of ionic liquids.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2017; v1 submitted 16 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Grand Canonical Adaptive Resolution Simulation for Molecules with Electrons: A Theoretical Framework based on Physical Consistency
Authors:
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
A theoretical scheme for the treatment of an open molecular system with electrons and nuclei is proposed. The idea is based on the Grand Canonical description of a quantum region embedded in a classical reservoir of molecules. Electronic properties of the quantum region are calculated at constant electronic chemical potential equal to that of the corresponding (large) bulk system treated at full q…
▽ More
A theoretical scheme for the treatment of an open molecular system with electrons and nuclei is proposed. The idea is based on the Grand Canonical description of a quantum region embedded in a classical reservoir of molecules. Electronic properties of the quantum region are calculated at constant electronic chemical potential equal to that of the corresponding (large) bulk system treated at full quantum level. Instead, the exchange of molecules between the quantum region and the classical environment occurs at the chemical potential of the macroscopic thermodynamic conditions. T he Grand Canonical Adaptive Resolution Scheme is proposed for the treatment of the classical environment; such an approach can treat the exchange of molecules according to first principles of statistical mechanics and thermodynamic. The overall scheme is build on the basis of physical consistency, with the corresponding definition of numerical criteria of control of the approximations implied by the coupling. Given the wide range of expertise required, this work has the intention of providing guiding principles for the construction of a well founded computational protocol for actual multiscale simulations from the electronic to the mesoscopic scale.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Computational Efficiency and Amdahl's law for the Adaptive Resolution Simulation Technique
Authors:
Christoph Junghans,
Animesh Agarwal,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We discuss the computational performance of the adaptive resolution technique in molecular simulation when it is compared with equivalent full coarse-grained and full atomistic simulations. We show that an estimate of its efficiency, within $10-15\%$ accuracy, is given by the Amdahl's Law adapted to the specific quantities involved in the problem. The derivation of the predictive formula is genera…
▽ More
We discuss the computational performance of the adaptive resolution technique in molecular simulation when it is compared with equivalent full coarse-grained and full atomistic simulations. We show that an estimate of its efficiency, within $10-15\%$ accuracy, is given by the Amdahl's Law adapted to the specific quantities involved in the problem. The derivation of the predictive formula is general enough that it may be applied to the general case of molecular dynamics approaches where a reduction of degrees of freedom in a multiscale fashion occurs.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Adaptive Molecular Resolution Approach in Hamiltonian Form: An Asymptotic Analysis
Authors:
Jinglong Zhu,
Rupert Klein,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
Adaptive Molecular Resolution approaches in Molecular Dynamics are becoming relevant tools for the analysis of molecular liquids characterized by the interplay of different physical scales. The essential difference among these methods is in the way the change of molecular resolution is made in a buffer/transition region. In particular a central question concerns the possibility of the existence of…
▽ More
Adaptive Molecular Resolution approaches in Molecular Dynamics are becoming relevant tools for the analysis of molecular liquids characterized by the interplay of different physical scales. The essential difference among these methods is in the way the change of molecular resolution is made in a buffer/transition region. In particular a central question concerns the possibility of the existence of a global Hamiltonian which, by describing the change of resolution, is at the same time physically consistent, mathematically well defined and numerically accurate. In this paper we present an asymptotic analysis of the adaptive process complemented by numerical results and show that under certain mathematical conditions a Hamiltonian, which is physically consistent and numerically accurate, may exist. Such conditions show that molecular simulations in the current computational implementation require systems of large size and thus a Hamiltonian approach as the one proposed, at this stage, would not be practical from the numerical point of view. However, the Hamiltonian proposed provides the basis for a simplification and generalization of the numerical implementation of adaptive resolution algorithms to other molecular dynamics codes.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2016; v1 submitted 4 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Grand-Canonical Adaptive Resolution Centroid Molecular Dynamics: Implementation and Application
Authors:
Animesh Agarwal,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We have implemented the Centroid Molecular Dynamics scheme (CMD) into the Grand Canonical-like version of the Adaptive Resolution Simulation Molecular Dynamics (GC-AdResS) method. We have tested the implementation on two different systems, liquid parahydrogen at extreme thermodynamic conditions and liquid water at ambient conditions; the reproduction of structural as well as dynamical results of r…
▽ More
We have implemented the Centroid Molecular Dynamics scheme (CMD) into the Grand Canonical-like version of the Adaptive Resolution Simulation Molecular Dynamics (GC-AdResS) method. We have tested the implementation on two different systems, liquid parahydrogen at extreme thermodynamic conditions and liquid water at ambient conditions; the reproduction of structural as well as dynamical results of reference systems are highly satisfactory. The capability of performing GC-AdResS CMD simulations allows for the treatment of a system characterized by some quantum features and open boundaries. This latter characteristic not only is of computational convenience, allowing for equivalent results of much larger and computationally more expensive systems, but also suggests a tool of analysis so far not explored, that is the unambiguous identification of the essential (quantum) degrees of freedom required for a given property.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2016; v1 submitted 29 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Simulation of Macromolecular Liquids with the Adaptive Resolution Molecular Dynamics Technique
Authors:
Jan Henning Peters,
Rupert Klein,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We extend the application of the adaptive resolution technique (AdResS) to liquid systems composed of alkane chains of different lengths. The aim of the study is to develop and test the modifications of AdResS required in order to handle the change of representation of large molecules. The robustness of the approach is shown by calculating several relevant structural properties and comparing them…
▽ More
We extend the application of the adaptive resolution technique (AdResS) to liquid systems composed of alkane chains of different lengths. The aim of the study is to develop and test the modifications of AdResS required in order to handle the change of representation of large molecules. The robustness of the approach is shown by calculating several relevant structural properties and comparing them with the results of full atomistic simulations. The extended scheme represents a robust prototype for the simulation of macromolecular systems of interest in several fields, from material science to biophysics.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2017; v1 submitted 5 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Formulation of Liouville's Theorem for Grand Ensemble Molecular Simulations
Authors:
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
Liouville's theorem in a grand ensemble, that is for situations where a system is in equilibrium with a reservoir of energy and particles, is a subject that, to our knowledge, has not been explicitly treated in literature related to molecular simulation. Instead Liouville's theorem, a central concept for the correct employment of molecular simulation techniques, is implicitly considered only withi…
▽ More
Liouville's theorem in a grand ensemble, that is for situations where a system is in equilibrium with a reservoir of energy and particles, is a subject that, to our knowledge, has not been explicitly treated in literature related to molecular simulation. Instead Liouville's theorem, a central concept for the correct employment of molecular simulation techniques, is implicitly considered only within the framework of systems where the total number of particles is fixed. However the pressing demand of applied science in treating open systems leads to the question of the existence and possible exact formulation of Liouville's theorem when the number of particles changes during the dynamical evolution of the system. The intention of this note is to stimulate a debate about this crucial issue for molecular simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2016; v1 submitted 5 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Influence of pH and sequence in peptide aggregation via molecular simulation
Authors:
Marta Enciso,
Christof Schuette,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We employ a recently developed coarse-grained model for peptides and proteins where the effect of pH is automatically included. We explore the effect of pH in the aggregation process of the amyloidogenic peptide KTVIIE and two related sequences, using three different pH environments. Simulations using large systems (24 peptides chains per box) allow us to correctly account for the formation of rea…
▽ More
We employ a recently developed coarse-grained model for peptides and proteins where the effect of pH is automatically included. We explore the effect of pH in the aggregation process of the amyloidogenic peptide KTVIIE and two related sequences, using three different pH environments. Simulations using large systems (24 peptides chains per box) allow us to correctly account for the formation of realistic peptide aggregates. We evaluate the thermodynamic and kinetic implications of changes in sequence and pH upon peptide aggregation, and we discuss how a minimalistic coarse-grained model can account for these details.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Path Integral Molecular Dynamics within the Grand Canonical-like Adaptive Resolution Technique: Simulation of Liquid Water
Authors:
Animesh Agarwal,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
Quantum effects due to the spatial delocalization of light atoms are treated in molecular simulation via the path integral technique. Among several methods, Path Integral (PI) Molecular Dynamics (MD) is nowadays a powerful tool to investigate properties induced by spatial delocalization of atoms; however computationally this technique is very demanding. The abovementioned limitation implies the re…
▽ More
Quantum effects due to the spatial delocalization of light atoms are treated in molecular simulation via the path integral technique. Among several methods, Path Integral (PI) Molecular Dynamics (MD) is nowadays a powerful tool to investigate properties induced by spatial delocalization of atoms; however computationally this technique is very demanding. The abovementioned limitation implies the restriction of PIMD applications to relatively small systems and short time scales. One possible solution to overcome size and time limitation is to introduce PIMD algorithms into the Adaptive Resolution Simulation Scheme (AdResS). AdResS requires a relatively small region treated at path integral level and embeds it into a large molecular reservoir consisting of generic spherical coarse grained molecules. It was previously shown that the realization of the idea above, at a simple level, produced reasonable results for toy systems or simple/test systems like liquid parahydrogen. Encouraged by previous results, in this paper we show the simulation of liquid water at room conditions where AdResS, in its latest and more accurate Grand-Canonical-like version (GC-AdResS), is merged with two of the most relevant PIMD techniques available in literature. The comparison of our results with those reported in literature and/or with those obtained from full PIMD simulations shows a highly satisfactory agreement.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2015; v1 submitted 29 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Adaptive Resolution Simulation as a Grand Canonical Molecular Dynamics Scheme: Principles, Applications and Perspectives
Authors:
Luigi Delle Site,
Animesh Agarwal,
Christoph Junghans,
Han Wang
Abstract:
We describe the adaptive resolution multiscale method AdResS. The conceptual evolution as well as the improvements of its technical efficiency are described step by step, with an explicit reference to current limitations and open problems.
We describe the adaptive resolution multiscale method AdResS. The conceptual evolution as well as the improvements of its technical efficiency are described step by step, with an explicit reference to current limitations and open problems.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Molecular Dynamics in a Grand Ensemble: Bergmann-Lebowitz model and Adaptive Resolution Simulation
Authors:
Animesh Agarwal,
Jinglong Zhu,
Carsten Hartmann,
Han Wang,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
This article deals with the molecular dynamics simulation of open systems that can exchange energy and matter with a reservoir; the physics of the reservoir and its interactions with the system are described by the model introduced by Bergmann and Lebowitz.Despite its conceptual appeal, the model did not gain popularity in the field of molecular simulation and, as a consequence, did not play a rol…
▽ More
This article deals with the molecular dynamics simulation of open systems that can exchange energy and matter with a reservoir; the physics of the reservoir and its interactions with the system are described by the model introduced by Bergmann and Lebowitz.Despite its conceptual appeal, the model did not gain popularity in the field of molecular simulation and, as a consequence, did not play a role in the development of open system molecular simulation techniques, even though it can provide the conceptual legitimation of simulation techniques that mimic open systems. We shall demonstrate that the model can serve as a tool to devise both numerical procedures and conceptual definitions of physical quantities that cannot be defined in a straightforward way by systems with a fixed number of molecules. In particular, we discuss the utility of the Bergmann-Lebowitz (BL) model for the calculation of equilibrium time correlation functions within the Grand Canonical Adaptive Resolution method (GC-AdResS) and report numerical results for the case of liquid water.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2015; v1 submitted 2 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Levy-Lieb principle: The bridge between the electron density of Density Functional Theory and the wavefunction of Quantum Monte Carlo
Authors:
L. Delle Site
Abstract:
The constrained-search principle introduced by Levy and Lieb, is proposed as a practical, though conceptually rigorous, link between Density Functional Theory (DFT) and Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC). The resulting numerical protocol realizes in practice the implicit key statement of DFT: "Given the three dimensional electron density of the ground state of a system of N electrons with external potentia…
▽ More
The constrained-search principle introduced by Levy and Lieb, is proposed as a practical, though conceptually rigorous, link between Density Functional Theory (DFT) and Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC). The resulting numerical protocol realizes in practice the implicit key statement of DFT: "Given the three dimensional electron density of the ground state of a system of N electrons with external potential v(r) it is possible to find the corresponding 3N-dimensional wavefunction of ground state." From a numerical point of view, the proposed protocol can be employed to speed up the QMC procedure by employing DFT densities as a pre-selection criterion for the sampling of wavefunctions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
On Some Open Problems in Many-Electron Theory
Authors:
Volker Bach,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
Mel Levy and Elliott Lieb are two of the most prominent researchers who have dedicated their efforts to the investigation of fundamental questions in many-electron theory. Their results have not only revolutionized the theoretical approach of the field, but, directly or indirectly, allowed for a quantum jump in the computational treatment of realistic systems as well. For this reason, at the concl…
▽ More
Mel Levy and Elliott Lieb are two of the most prominent researchers who have dedicated their efforts to the investigation of fundamental questions in many-electron theory. Their results have not only revolutionized the theoretical approach of the field, but, directly or indirectly, allowed for a quantum jump in the computational treatment of realistic systems as well. For this reason, at the conclusion of our book where the subject is treated across different disciplines, we have asked Mel Levy and Elliott Lieb to provide us with some open problems, which they believe will be a worth challenge for the future also in the perspective of a synergy among the various disciplines.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2014; v1 submitted 17 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Chemical potential of liquids and mixtures via Adaptive Resolution Simulation
Authors:
Animesh Agarwal,
Han Wang,
Christof Schütte,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We employ the adaptive resolution approach AdResS, in its recently developed Grand Canonical-like version (GC-AdResS) [Wang et al. Phys.Rev.X 3, 011018 (2013)], to calculate the excess chemical potential, $μ^{ex}$, of various liquids and mixtures. We compare our results with those obtained from full atomistic simulations using the technique of thermodynamic integration and show a satisfactory agre…
▽ More
We employ the adaptive resolution approach AdResS, in its recently developed Grand Canonical-like version (GC-AdResS) [Wang et al. Phys.Rev.X 3, 011018 (2013)], to calculate the excess chemical potential, $μ^{ex}$, of various liquids and mixtures. We compare our results with those obtained from full atomistic simulations using the technique of thermodynamic integration and show a satisfactory agreement. In GC-AdResS the procedure to calculate $μ^{ex}$ corresponds to the process of standard initial equilibration of the system; this implies that, independently of the specific aim of the study, $μ^{ex}$, for each molecular species, is automatically calculated every time a GC-AdResS simulation is performed.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2014; v1 submitted 27 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Levy-Lieb Principle meets Quantum Monte Carlo
Authors:
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We review an approach where the energy functional of Density-Functional Theory (DFT) can be determined without empiricism via a Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) procedure. The idea consists of a nested iterative loop where the configurational space of the electrons in the QMC procedure is determined by a trial oneparticle electron density; this allows then for the determination of a first guess for the e…
▽ More
We review an approach where the energy functional of Density-Functional Theory (DFT) can be determined without empiricism via a Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) procedure. The idea consists of a nested iterative loop where the configurational space of the electrons in the QMC procedure is determined by a trial oneparticle electron density; this allows then for the determination of a first guess for the energy functional, which is then in turn used for a DFT minimization process. This latter delivers a new electron density and the loop is repeated iteratively until convergence is reached and thus the electronic structure of the system determined. In essence, from the applied point of view, such an approach is a compromise between the large computational cost but high accuracy of QMC and the reasonable computational cost but lower accuracy of DFT. The proposed approach goes beyond the standard Kohn-Sham method, which is the standard in DFT, and requires neither orbitals nor the a priori specification of the exchange and correlation functional. From the conceptual point of view, the relevant aspect is that the 3N-dimensional wavefunction is derived as a function(al) of the three-dimensional electron density, which is the key principle of DFT.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Exploring the conformational dynamics of alanine dipeptide in solution subjected to an external electric field: A nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulation
Authors:
Han Wang,
Christof Schütte,
Giovanni Ciccotti,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
In this paper, we investigate the conformational dynamics of alanine dipeptide under an external electric field by nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulation. We consider the case of a constant and of an oscillatory field. In this context we propose a procedure to implement the temperature control, which removes the irrelevant thermal effects of the field. For the constant field different time-s…
▽ More
In this paper, we investigate the conformational dynamics of alanine dipeptide under an external electric field by nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulation. We consider the case of a constant and of an oscillatory field. In this context we propose a procedure to implement the temperature control, which removes the irrelevant thermal effects of the field. For the constant field different time-scales are identified in the conformational, dipole moment, and orientational dynamics. Moreover, we prove that the solvent structure only marginally changes when the external field is switched on. In the case of oscillatory field, the conformational changes are shown to be as strong as in the previous case, and non-trivial nonequilibrium circular paths in the conformation space are revealed by calculating the integrated net probability fluxes.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2014; v1 submitted 5 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Is there a third order phase transition for supercritical fluids?
Authors:
Jinglong Zhu,
Pingwen Zhang,
Han Wang,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We prove that according to Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of liquid mixtures of Lennard-Jones (L-J) particles, there is no third order phase transition in the supercritical regime beyond Andrew's critical point. This result is in open contrast with recent theoretical studies and experiments which instead suggest not only its existence but also its universality regarding the chemical nature of…
▽ More
We prove that according to Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of liquid mixtures of Lennard-Jones (L-J) particles, there is no third order phase transition in the supercritical regime beyond Andrew's critical point. This result is in open contrast with recent theoretical studies and experiments which instead suggest not only its existence but also its universality regarding the chemical nature of the fluid. We argue that our results are solid enough to go beyond the limitations of MD and the generic character of L-J models, thus suggesting a rather smooth liquid-vapor thermodynamic behavior of fluids in supercritical regime.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2013; v1 submitted 17 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
pH-dependent Response of Coiled Coils: A Coarse-Grained Molecular Simulation Study
Authors:
Marta Enciso,
Christof Schuette,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
In a recent work we proposed a coarse-grained methodology for studying the response of peptides when simulated at different values of pH; in this work we extend the methodology to analyze the pH-dependent behavior of coiled coils. This protein structure presents a remarkable chain stiffness andis formed by two or more long helical peptides that are interacting like the strands of a rope. Chain len…
▽ More
In a recent work we proposed a coarse-grained methodology for studying the response of peptides when simulated at different values of pH; in this work we extend the methodology to analyze the pH-dependent behavior of coiled coils. This protein structure presents a remarkable chain stiffness andis formed by two or more long helical peptides that are interacting like the strands of a rope. Chain length and rigidity are the key aspects needed to extend previous peptide interaction potentials to this particular case; however the original model is naturally recovered when the length or the ridigity of the simulated chain are reduced. We apply the model and discuss results for two cases: (a) the folding/unfolding transition of a generic coiled coil as a function of pH; (b) behavior of a specific sequence as a function of the acidity conditions. In this latter case results are compared with experimental data from the literature in order to comment about the consistency of our approach.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Grand-canonical-like molecular-dynamics simulations by using an adaptive-resolution technique
Authors:
Han Wang,
Carsten Hartmann,
Christof Schütte,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
In this work, we provide a detailed theoretical analysis, supported by numerical tests, of the reliability of the adaptive resolution simulation (AdResS) technique in sampling the Grand Canonical ensemble. We demonstrate that the correct density and radial distribution functions in the hybrid region, where molecules change resolution, are two necessary conditions for considering the atomistic and…
▽ More
In this work, we provide a detailed theoretical analysis, supported by numerical tests, of the reliability of the adaptive resolution simulation (AdResS) technique in sampling the Grand Canonical ensemble. We demonstrate that the correct density and radial distribution functions in the hybrid region, where molecules change resolution, are two necessary conditions for considering the atomistic and coarse-grained regions in AdResS equivalent to subsystems of a full atomistic system with an accuracy up to the second order with respect to the probability distribution of the system. Moreover, we show that the work done by the thermostat and a thermodynamic force in the transition region is formally equivalent to balance the chemical potential difference between the different resolutions. From these results follows the main conclusion that the atomistic region exchanges molecules with the coarse-grained region in a Grand Canonical fashion with an accuracy up to (at least) second order. Numerical tests, for the relevant case of liquid water at ambient conditions, are carried out to strengthen the conclusions of the theoretical analysis. Finally, in order to show the computational convenience of AdResS as a Grand Canonical set up, we compare our method to the Insertion Particle Method (IMP) in its most efficient computational implementation. This fruitful combination of theoretical principles and numerical evidence candidates the adaptive resolution technique as a natural, general and efficient protocol for Grand Canonical Molecular Dynamics for the case of large systems.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
pH-dependent coarse-grained model of peptides
Authors:
Marta Enciso,
Christof Schuette,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We propose the first, to our knowledge, coarse-grained modeling strategy for peptides where the effect of changes of the pH can be efficiently described. The idea is based on modeling the effects of the pH value on the main driving interactions. We use reference data from atomistic simulations and experimental databases and transfer its main physical features to the coarse-grained resolution accor…
▽ More
We propose the first, to our knowledge, coarse-grained modeling strategy for peptides where the effect of changes of the pH can be efficiently described. The idea is based on modeling the effects of the pH value on the main driving interactions. We use reference data from atomistic simulations and experimental databases and transfer its main physical features to the coarse-grained resolution according the principle of "consistency across the scales". The coarse-grained model is refined by finding a set of parameters that, when applied to peptides with different sequences and experimental properties, reproduces the experimental and atomistic data of reference. We use the such parameterized model for performing several numerical tests to check its transferability to other systems and to prove the universality of the related modeling strategy. We have tried systems with rather different response to pH variations, showing a highly satisfactory performance of the model.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2013; v1 submitted 18 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Autocatalytic and cooperatively-stabilized dissociation of water on a stepped platinum surface
Authors:
Davide Donadio,
Luca M. Ghiringhelli,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
Water-metal interfaces are ubiquitous and play a key role in many chemical processes, from catalysis to corrosion. Whereas water adlayers on atomically flat transition metal surfaces have been investigated in depth, little is known about the chemistry of water on stepped surfaces, commonly occurring in realistic situations. Using first-principles simulations we study the adsorption of water on a s…
▽ More
Water-metal interfaces are ubiquitous and play a key role in many chemical processes, from catalysis to corrosion. Whereas water adlayers on atomically flat transition metal surfaces have been investigated in depth, little is known about the chemistry of water on stepped surfaces, commonly occurring in realistic situations. Using first-principles simulations we study the adsorption of water on a stepped platinum surface. We find that water adsorbs preferentially at the step edge, forming linear clusters or chains, stabilized by the cooperative effect of chemical bonds with the substrate and hydrogen bonds. In contrast with flat Pt, at steps water molecules dissociate forming mixed hydroxyl/water structures, through an autocatalytic mechanism promoted by hydrogen bonding. Nuclear quantum effects contribute to stabilize partially dissociated cluster and chains. Together with the recently demonstrated attitude of water chains adsorbed on stepped Pt surfaces to transfer protons via thermally activated hopping, these findings candidate these systems as viable proton wires.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Adaptive resolution molecular dynamics simulation through coupling to an internal particle reservoir
Authors:
Sebastian Fritsch,
Simon Poblete,
Christoph Junghans,
Giovanni Ciccotti,
Luigi Delle Site,
Kurt Kremer
Abstract:
For simulation studies of (macro) molecular liquids it would be of significant interest to be able to adjust or increase the level of resolution within one region of space, while allowing for the free exchange of molecules between open regions of different resolution or representation. We generalize the adaptive resolution idea and suggest an interpretation in terms of an effective generalized gra…
▽ More
For simulation studies of (macro) molecular liquids it would be of significant interest to be able to adjust or increase the level of resolution within one region of space, while allowing for the free exchange of molecules between open regions of different resolution or representation. We generalize the adaptive resolution idea and suggest an interpretation in terms of an effective generalized grand canonical approach. The method is applied to liquid water at ambient conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2012; v1 submitted 14 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
The momentum distribution of the homogeneous electron gas
Authors:
Markus Holzmann,
Bernard Bernu,
Carlo Pierleoni,
Jeremy McMinis,
David M. Ceperley,
Valerio Olevano,
Luigi Delle Site
Abstract:
We calculate the off-diagonal density matrix of the homogeneous electron gas at zero temperature using unbiased Reptation Monte Carlo for various densities and extrapolate the momentum distribution, and the kinetic and potential energies to the thermodynamic limit. Our results on the renormalization factor allows us to validate approximate G_0W_0 calculations concerning quasiparticle properties ov…
▽ More
We calculate the off-diagonal density matrix of the homogeneous electron gas at zero temperature using unbiased Reptation Monte Carlo for various densities and extrapolate the momentum distribution, and the kinetic and potential energies to the thermodynamic limit. Our results on the renormalization factor allows us to validate approximate G_0W_0 calculations concerning quasiparticle properties over a broad density region (1 <= r_s <= 10) and show that near the Fermi surface, vertex corrections and self-consistency aspects almost cancel each other out.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2011; v1 submitted 11 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
Classical kinetic energy, quantum fluctuation terms and kinetic-energy functionals
Authors:
I. P. Hamilton,
Ricardo A. Mosna,
L. Delle Site
Abstract:
We employ a recently formulated dequantization procedure to obtain an exact expression for the kinetic energy which is applicable to all kinetic-energy functionals. We express the kinetic energy of an N-electron system as the sum of an N-electron classical kinetic energy and an N-electron purely quantum kinetic energy arising from the quantum fluctuations that turn the classical momentum into th…
▽ More
We employ a recently formulated dequantization procedure to obtain an exact expression for the kinetic energy which is applicable to all kinetic-energy functionals. We express the kinetic energy of an N-electron system as the sum of an N-electron classical kinetic energy and an N-electron purely quantum kinetic energy arising from the quantum fluctuations that turn the classical momentum into the quantum momentum. This leads to an interesting analogy with Nelson's stochastic approach to quantum mechanics, which we use to conceptually clarify the physical nature of part of the kinetic-energy functional in terms of statistical fluctuations and in direct correspondence with Fisher Information Theory. We show that the N-electron purely quantum kinetic energy can be written as the sum of the (one-electron) Weizsacker term and an (N-1)-electron kinetic correlation term. We further show that the Weizsacker term results from local fluctuations while the kinetic correlation term results from the nonlocal fluctuations. For one-electron orbitals (where kinetic correlation is neglected) we obtain an exact (albeit impractical) expression for the noninteracting kinetic energy as the sum of the classical kinetic energy and the Weizsacker term. The classical kinetic energy is seen to be explicitly dependent on the electron phase and this has implications for the development of accurate orbital-free kinetic-energy functionals. Also, there is a direct connection between the classical kinetic energy and the angular momentum and, across a row of the periodic table, the classical kinetic energy component of the noninteracting kinetic energy generally increases as Z increases.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2007; v1 submitted 17 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
