-
EPR-Bell realism as a part of logic
Authors:
I. Schmelzer
Abstract:
We argue that for the proof of Bell's theorem no assumptions about realism or free will are necessary. The key formula \[E(AB|a,b) = \int A(a,b,λ)B(a,b,λ)ρ(λ) dλ\] follows from the logic of plausible reasoning (the objective Bayesian interpretation of probability theory) taken alone, without any further assumptions about realism. The space $Λ$, usually interpreted as some space of `hidden variable…
▽ More
We argue that for the proof of Bell's theorem no assumptions about realism or free will are necessary. The key formula \[E(AB|a,b) = \int A(a,b,λ)B(a,b,λ)ρ(λ) dλ\] follows from the logic of plausible reasoning (the objective Bayesian interpretation of probability theory) taken alone, without any further assumptions about realism. The space $Λ$, usually interpreted as some space of `hidden variables', can be constructed for an arbitrary `field of discourse' using Stone's theorem. The rejection of superdeterminism follows from logical independence -- the non-existence of information which suggest a dependence -- of the free decisions of the experimenters from everything else.
To prove the Bell inequality it is, then, sufficient to reduce this to \[E(AB|a,b) = \int A(a,λ)B(b,λ)ρ(λ) dλ.\] This follows for space-like separated measurements from Einstein causality alone. So, the consequence of the violation of Bell's inequality is that Einstein causality has been empirically falsified, without any loopholes left.
We consider and reject the idea of weakening the logic of plausible reasoning could be used to create a loophole. Finally, we discuss what can be used to replace Einstein causality. While weak (signal) Einstein causality holds, it follows either from a notion of strong causality or from human inability to prepare states which violate quantum uncertainty, which makes it uninteresting for fundamental considerations. A notion of strong causality has either unacceptable causal loops or requires a hidden preferred frame. Given that a hidden preferred frame is completely compatible with modern physics, it is argued that this choice is preferable.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2018; v1 submitted 9 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Do ghost fields really make massive gravity invalid?
Authors:
I. Schmelzer
Abstract:
Theories which contain ghost fields are considered to be invalid. It is assumed that for such theories the energy is unbounded from below, and the theory will be unstable, allowing the creation of particle pairs with arbitrarily large positive and negative energies. Such ghost fields are a serious problem for theories of massive gravity.
We present here an example of such a theory of gravity wit…
▽ More
Theories which contain ghost fields are considered to be invalid. It is assumed that for such theories the energy is unbounded from below, and the theory will be unstable, allowing the creation of particle pairs with arbitrarily large positive and negative energies. Such ghost fields are a serious problem for theories of massive gravity.
We present here an example of such a theory of gravity with a ghost field which avoids this problem. While its equations are locally equivalent to those of a theory of massive gravity with a ghost field, global restrictions of the configuration space have the result that the ghost mode has to remain small, and the energy has to remain positive.
As a consequence, the existence of a ghost-like mode in the equations of the theory is not a decisive argument against this theory.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2019; v1 submitted 20 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Black Holes or Frozen Stars? A Viable Theory of Gravity without Black Holes
Authors:
I. Schmelzer
Abstract:
Do observations of black hole candidates rule out alternative theories of gravity without horizon formation? This depends on the existence, viability and reasonableness of alternative theories of gravity without black holes.
Here a theory of gravity without black hole horizon formation is presented. The gravitational collapse stops shortly before horizon formation and leaves a stable frozen star…
▽ More
Do observations of black hole candidates rule out alternative theories of gravity without horizon formation? This depends on the existence, viability and reasonableness of alternative theories of gravity without black holes.
Here a theory of gravity without black hole horizon formation is presented. The gravitational collapse stops shortly before horizon formation and leaves a stable frozen star. In the limit $Ξ, Υ\to 0$ the Einstein equations of GR are recovered, and the frozen stars become observationally indistinguishable from GR black holes. The theory therefore provides a counterexample to recent claims that observational evidence from black hole candidates "all but requires the existence of a horizon".
The theory presented here shares its equations with RTG. Nonetheless, as is shown, there remain important conceptual and physical differences. In particular, some serious problems of RTG are not present in the theory proposed here. So it can be argued that the theory is a physically viable and conceptually sound alternative to GR.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2012; v1 submitted 7 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
The Standard Model fermions as excitations of an ether
Authors:
I. Schmelzer
Abstract:
The three-dimensional complexified exteriour bundle $C \otimes Λ(R^3)$ is proposed as a geometric interpretation of electroweak doublets of Dirac fermions. The Dirac equation on this bundle allows a staggered discretization on a three-dimensional scalar complex lattice field $C(Z^3)$.
The three-dimensional affine group $Aff(3)$ is proposed as a geometric interpretation for the matrix defined by…
▽ More
The three-dimensional complexified exteriour bundle $C \otimes Λ(R^3)$ is proposed as a geometric interpretation of electroweak doublets of Dirac fermions. The Dirac equation on this bundle allows a staggered discretization on a three-dimensional scalar complex lattice field $C(Z^3)$.
The three-dimensional affine group $Aff(3)$ is proposed as a geometric interpretation for the matrix defined by the three generations, with the three quark doublets and a lepton doublet in each generation. The corresponding lattice space $(Aff(3) \otimes C)(Z^3)$ allows a simple condensed matter (ether) interpretation. A possibility to construct anticommuting fermion operators based on canonical quantization is given.
A set of axioms of the gauge action is defined such that the gauge action of the SM gauge group $SU(3)_c x SU(2)_L x U(1)_{Y}$ is the maximal possible one. This includes preservation of Euclidean symmetry and the symplectic structure, anomaly freedom, ground state neutrality, and the possibility of realization on the lattice. Strong interactions are realized as Wilson-like gauge fields, weak gauge fields as effective gauge fields describing lattice deformations, and the EM field as a combination of above types.
Some possibilities to explain the qualitative characteristics of the mass parameters are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2012; v1 submitted 19 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
A symmetry problem in the Copenhagen interpretation
Authors:
I. Schmelzer
Abstract:
A non-uniqueness result for the canonical structure in quantum theory shows that the classical part of the Copenhagen interpretation contains physically important information not contained in its quantum part. As a consequence, we cannot compute the symmetry group of a quantum theory considering only the quantum part. The unavoidable vagueness of the classical part therefore leads to a similar v…
▽ More
A non-uniqueness result for the canonical structure in quantum theory shows that the classical part of the Copenhagen interpretation contains physically important information not contained in its quantum part. As a consequence, we cannot compute the symmetry group of a quantum theory considering only the quantum part. The unavoidable vagueness of the classical part therefore leads to a similar vagueness in the definition of the symmetry group. This makes it at least problematic, if not impossible, to establish the true symmetry group of a quantum theory in the Copenhagen interpretation. Different from the old measurement problem, the symmetry group is to important physically to be rejected as a metaphysical pseudoproblem.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
A condensed matter interpretation of SM fermions and gauge fields
Authors:
I. Schmelzer
Abstract:
We present the bundle Aff(3) x C x /(R^3), with a geometric Dirac equation on it, as a three-dimensional geometric interpretation of the SM fermions. Each C x /(R^3) describes an electroweak doublet. The Dirac equation has a doubler-free staggered spatial discretization on the lattice space Aff(3) x C (Z^3). This space allows a simple physical interpretation as a phase space of a lattice of cell…
▽ More
We present the bundle Aff(3) x C x /(R^3), with a geometric Dirac equation on it, as a three-dimensional geometric interpretation of the SM fermions. Each C x /(R^3) describes an electroweak doublet. The Dirac equation has a doubler-free staggered spatial discretization on the lattice space Aff(3) x C (Z^3). This space allows a simple physical interpretation as a phase space of a lattice of cells in R^3. We find the SM SU(3)_c x SU(2)_L x U(1)_Y action on Aff(3) x C x /(R^3) to be a maximal anomaly-free special gauge action preserving E(3) symmetry and symplectic structure, which can be constructed using two simple types of gauge-like lattice fields: Wilson gauge fields and correction terms for lattice deformations. The lattice fermion fields we propose to quantize as low energy states of a canonical quantum theory with Z_2-degenerated vacuum state. We construct anticommuting fermion operators for the resulting Z_2-valued (spin) field theory. A metric theory of gravity compatible with this model is presented too.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
