-
Underdetermination in Classic and Modern Tests of General Relativity
Authors:
William J. Wolf,
Marco Sanchioni,
James Read
Abstract:
Canonically, `classic' tests of general relativity (GR) include perihelion precession, the bending of light around stars, and gravitational redshift; `modern' tests have to do with, inter alia, relativistic time delay, equivalence principle tests, gravitational lensing, strong field gravity, and gravitational waves. The orthodoxy is that both classic and modern tests of GR afford experimental conf…
▽ More
Canonically, `classic' tests of general relativity (GR) include perihelion precession, the bending of light around stars, and gravitational redshift; `modern' tests have to do with, inter alia, relativistic time delay, equivalence principle tests, gravitational lensing, strong field gravity, and gravitational waves. The orthodoxy is that both classic and modern tests of GR afford experimental confirmation of that theory in particular. In this article, we question this orthodoxy, by showing there are classes of both relativistic theories (with spatiotemporal geometrical properties different from those of GR) and non-relativistic theories (in which the lightcones of a relativistic spacetime are `widened') which would also pass such tests. Thus, (a) issues of underdetermination in the context of GR loom much larger than one might have thought, and (b) given this, one has to think more carefully about what exactly such tests in fact are testing.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2024; v1 submitted 19 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Lack of Value Definiteness in Quantum Gravity
Authors:
Enrico Cinti,
Cristian Mariani,
Marco Sanchioni
Abstract:
In this paper we consider the observables describing fundamental spatiotemporal properties and relations in the context of Quantum Gravity (QG). As we will show, in both Loop Quantum Gravity and in String Theory, these observables are non-commuting ones. By analogy with some recent arguments put forward in the context of non-relativistic quantum mechanics (QM), we shall propose to interpret these…
▽ More
In this paper we consider the observables describing fundamental spatiotemporal properties and relations in the context of Quantum Gravity (QG). As we will show, in both Loop Quantum Gravity and in String Theory, these observables are non-commuting ones. By analogy with some recent arguments put forward in the context of non-relativistic quantum mechanics (QM), we shall propose to interpret these physical quantities as ontologically indeterminate -- i.e., indeterminate in a non-epistemic, mind-independent way. This result has two important consequences for current debates in philosophy of physics. First, it shows that ontological indeterminacy may extend well beyond the non-relativistic case, thereby also suggesting a conceptual continuity between QM and QG. Second, when applied to QG, the notion of indeterminacy may provide a unified philosophical framework for understanding very distinct approaches that are usually considered incompatible.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
The Devil in the (Implicit) Details. On the AMPS Paradox and its Resolution
Authors:
Enrico Cinti,
Marco Sanchioni
Abstract:
The black hole information loss paradox has long been one of the most studied and fascinating aspects of black hole physics. In its latest incarnation, it takes the form of the firewall paradox. In this paper, we first give a conceptually oriented presentation of the paradox, based on the notion of causal structure. We then suggest a possible strategy for its resolutions and see that the core idea…
▽ More
The black hole information loss paradox has long been one of the most studied and fascinating aspects of black hole physics. In its latest incarnation, it takes the form of the firewall paradox. In this paper, we first give a conceptually oriented presentation of the paradox, based on the notion of causal structure. We then suggest a possible strategy for its resolutions and see that the core idea behind it is that there are connections that are non-local for semiclassical physics, which have to be taken into account when studying black holes. We see how to concretely implement this strategy in some physical models connected to the ER=EPR conjecture.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Humeanism in Light of Quantum Gravity
Authors:
Enrico Cinti,
Marco Sanchioni
Abstract:
Quantum Theory and Humeanism have long been thought to be incompatible due to the irreducibility of the correlations involved in entangled states. In this paper, we reconstruct the tension between Humeanism and entanglement via the concept of causal structure, and provide a philosophical introduction to the ER=EPR conjecture. With these tools, we then show how the concept of causal structure and t…
▽ More
Quantum Theory and Humeanism have long been thought to be incompatible due to the irreducibility of the correlations involved in entangled states. In this paper, we reconstruct the tension between Humeanism and entanglement via the concept of causal structure, and provide a philosophical introduction to the ER=EPR conjecture. With these tools, we then show how the concept of causal structure and the ER=EPR conjecture allow us to resolve the conflict between Humeanism and entanglement.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
