-
Equatorial Waves and Superrotation in the Stratosphere of a Titan General Circulation Model
Authors:
Neil T. Lewis,
Nicholas A. Lombardo,
Peter L. Read,
Juan M. Lora
Abstract:
We investigate the characteristics of equatorial waves associated with the maintenance of superrotation in the stratosphere of a Titan general circulation model. A variety of equatorial waves are present in the model atmosphere, including equatorial Kelvin waves, equatorial Rossby waves, and mixed Rossby-gravity waves. In the upper stratosphere, acceleration of superrotation is strongest around so…
▽ More
We investigate the characteristics of equatorial waves associated with the maintenance of superrotation in the stratosphere of a Titan general circulation model. A variety of equatorial waves are present in the model atmosphere, including equatorial Kelvin waves, equatorial Rossby waves, and mixed Rossby-gravity waves. In the upper stratosphere, acceleration of superrotation is strongest around solstice and is due to interaction between equatorial Kelvin waves and Rossby-type waves in winter-hemisphere mid-latitudes. The existence of this 'Rossby-Kelvin'-type wave appears to depend on strong meridional shear of the background zonal wind that occurs in the upper stratosphere at times away from the equinoxes. In the lower stratosphere, acceleration of superrotation occurs throughout the year and is partially induced by equatorial Rossby waves, which we speculate are generated by quasigeostrophic barotropic instability. Acceleration of superrotation is generally due to waves with phase speeds close to the zonal velocity of the mean flow. Consequently, they have short vertical wavelengths which are close to the model's vertical grid scale, and therefore are likely to be not properly represented. We suggest this may be a common issue amongst Titan GCMs which should be addressed by future model development.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The dependence of global super-rotation on planetary rotation rate
Authors:
Neil T. Lewis,
Greg J. Colyer,
Peter L. Read
Abstract:
An atmosphere may be described as globally super-rotating if its total zonal angular momentum exceeds that associated with solid-body co-rotation with the underlying planet. In this paper, we discuss the dependence of global super-rotation in terrestrial atmospheres on planetary rotation rate. This dependence is revealed through analysis of global super-rotation in idealised General Circulation Mo…
▽ More
An atmosphere may be described as globally super-rotating if its total zonal angular momentum exceeds that associated with solid-body co-rotation with the underlying planet. In this paper, we discuss the dependence of global super-rotation in terrestrial atmospheres on planetary rotation rate. This dependence is revealed through analysis of global super-rotation in idealised General Circulation Model experiments with time-independent axisymmetric forcing, compared with estimates for global super-rotation in Solar System atmospheres. Axisymmetric and three-dimensional experiments are conducted. We find that the degree of global super-rotation in the three-dimensional experiments is closely related to that of the axisymmetric experiments, with some differences in detail. A scaling theory for global super-rotation in an axisymmetric atmosphere is derived from the Held-Hou model. At high rotation rate, our numerical experiments inhabit a regime where global super-rotation scales geostrophically, and we suggest that the Earth and Mars occupy this regime. At low rotation rate, our experiments occupy a regime determined by angular momentum conservation, where global super-rotation is independent of rotation rate. Global super-rotation in our experiments saturates at a value significantly lower than that achieved in the atmospheres of Venus and Titan, which instead occupy a regime where global super-rotation scales cyclostrophically. This regime can only be accessed when eddy induced up-gradient angular momentum transport is sufficiently large, which is not the case in our idealised numerical experiments. We suggest that the 'default' regime for a slowly rotating planet is the angular momentum conserving regime, characterised by mild global (and local) superrotation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Shadowing the rotating annulus. Part II: Gradient descent in the perfect model scenario
Authors:
Roland M. B. Young,
Roman Binter,
Falk Niehörster,
Peter L. Read,
Leonard A. Smith
Abstract:
Shadowing trajectories are model trajectories consistent with a sequence of observations of a system, given a distribution of observational noise. The existence of such trajectories is a desirable property of any forecast model. Gradient descent of indeterminism is a well-established technique for finding shadowing trajectories in low-dimensional analytical systems. Here we apply it to the thermal…
▽ More
Shadowing trajectories are model trajectories consistent with a sequence of observations of a system, given a distribution of observational noise. The existence of such trajectories is a desirable property of any forecast model. Gradient descent of indeterminism is a well-established technique for finding shadowing trajectories in low-dimensional analytical systems. Here we apply it to the thermally-driven rotating annulus, a laboratory experiment intermediate in model complexity and physical idealisation between analytical systems and global, comprehensive atmospheric models. We work in the perfect model scenario using the MORALS model to generate a sequence of noisy observations in a chaotic flow regime. We demonstrate that the gradient descent technique recovers a pseudo-orbit of model states significantly closer to a model trajectory than the initial sequence. Gradient-free descent is used, where the adjoint model is set to $λ$I in the absence of a full adjoint model. The indeterminism of the pseudo-orbit falls by two orders of magnitude during the descent, but we find that the distance between the pseudo-orbit and the initial, true, model trajectory reaches a minimum and then diverges from truth. We attribute this to the use of the $λ$-adjoint, which is well suited to noise reduction but not to finely-tuned convergence towards a model trajectory. We find that $λ=0.25$ gives optimal results, and that candidate model trajectories begun from this pseudo-orbit shadow the observations for up to 80 s, about the length of the longest timescale of the system, and similar to expected shadowing times based on the distance between the pseudo-orbit and the truth. There is great potential for using this method with real laboratory data.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Investigating the Semiannual Oscillation on Mars using data assimilation
Authors:
Tao Ruan,
Neil T. Lewis,
Stephen R. Lewis,
Luca Montabone,
Peter L. Read
Abstract:
A Martian semiannual oscillation (SAO), similar to that in the Earth's tropical stratosphere, is evident in the Mars Analysis Correction Data Assimilation reanalysis dataset (MACDA) version 1.0, not only in the tropics, but also extending to higher latitudes. Unlike on Earth, the Martian SAO is found not always to reverse its zonal wind direction, but only manifests itself as a deceleration of the…
▽ More
A Martian semiannual oscillation (SAO), similar to that in the Earth's tropical stratosphere, is evident in the Mars Analysis Correction Data Assimilation reanalysis dataset (MACDA) version 1.0, not only in the tropics, but also extending to higher latitudes. Unlike on Earth, the Martian SAO is found not always to reverse its zonal wind direction, but only manifests itself as a deceleration of the dominant wind at certain pressure levels and latitudes. Singular System Analysis (SSA) is further applied on the zonal-mean zonal wind in different latitude bands to reveal the characteristics of SAO phenomena at different latitudes. The second pair of principal components (PCs) is usually dominated by a SAO signal, though the SAO signal can be strong enough to manifest itself also in the first pair of PCs. An analysis of terms in the Transformed Eulerian Mean equation (TEM) is applied in the tropics to further elucidate the forcing processes driving the tendency of the zonal-mean zonal wind. The zonal-mean meridional advection is found to correlate strongly with the observed oscillations of zonal-mean zonal wind, and supplies the majority of the westward (retrograde) forcing in the SAO cycle. The forcing due to various non-zonal waves supplies forcing to the zonal-mean zonal wind that is nearly the opposite of the forcing due to meridional advection above ~3 Pa altitude, but it also partly supports the SAO between 40 Pa and 3 Pa. Some distinctive features occurring during the period of the Mars year (MY) 25 global-scale dust storm (GDS) are also notable in our diagnostic results with substantially stronger values of eastward and westward momentum in the second half of MY 25 and stronger forcing due to vertical advection, transient waves and thermal tides.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Exploring the Venus global super-rotation using a comprehensive General Circulation Model
Authors:
João M. Mendonça,
Peter L. Read
Abstract:
The atmospheric circulation in Venus is well known to exhibit strong super-rotation. However, the atmospheric mechanisms responsible for the formation of this super-rotation are still not fully understood. In this work, we developed a new Venus general circulation model to study the most likely mechanisms driving the atmosphere to the current observed circulation. Our model includes a new radiativ…
▽ More
The atmospheric circulation in Venus is well known to exhibit strong super-rotation. However, the atmospheric mechanisms responsible for the formation of this super-rotation are still not fully understood. In this work, we developed a new Venus general circulation model to study the most likely mechanisms driving the atmosphere to the current observed circulation. Our model includes a new radiative transfer, convection and suitably adapted boundary layer schemes and a dynamical core that takes into account the dependence of the heat capacity at constant pressure with temperature.
The new Venus model is able to simulate a super-rotation phenomenon in the cloud region quantitatively similar to the one observed. The mechanisms maintaining the strong winds in the cloud region were found in the model results to be a combination of zonal mean circulation, thermal tides and transient waves. In this process, the semi-diurnal tide excited in the upper clouds has a key contribution in transporting axial angular momentum mainly from the upper atmosphere towards the cloud region. The magnitude of the super-rotation in the cloud region is sensitive to various radiative parameters such as the amount of solar radiative energy absorbed by the surface, which controls the static stability near the surface. In this work, we also discuss the main difficulties in representing the flow below the cloud base in Venus atmospheric models.
Our new radiative scheme is more suitable for 3D Venus climate models than those used in previous work due to its easy adaptability to different atmospheric conditions. This flexibility of the model was crucial to explore the uncertainties in the lower atmospheric conditions and may also be used in the future to explore, for example, dynamical-radiative-microphysical feedbacks.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Direct Numerical Simulation of structural vacillation in the transition to geostrophic turbulence
Authors:
Anthony Randriamampianina,
Pierre Maubert,
Wolf-Gerrit Fruh,
Peter L. Read
Abstract:
The onset of small-scale fluctuations around a steady convection pattern in a rotating baroclinic annulus filled with air is investigated using Direct Numerical Simulation. In previous laboratory experiments of baroclinic waves, such fluctuations have been associated with a flow regime termed Structural Vacillation which is regarded as the first step in the transition to fully-developed geostrop…
▽ More
The onset of small-scale fluctuations around a steady convection pattern in a rotating baroclinic annulus filled with air is investigated using Direct Numerical Simulation. In previous laboratory experiments of baroclinic waves, such fluctuations have been associated with a flow regime termed Structural Vacillation which is regarded as the first step in the transition to fully-developed geostrophic turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
DNS of bifurcations in an air-filled rotating baroclinic annulus
Authors:
Anthony Randriamampianina,
Wolf-Gerrit Fruh,
Peter L. Read,
Pierre Maubert
Abstract:
Three-dimensional Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) on the nonlinear dynamics and a route to chaos in a rotating fluid subjected to lateral heating is presented here and discussed in the context of laboratory experiments in the baroclinic annulus. Following two previous preliminary studies by Maubert and Randriamampianina, the fluid used is air rather than a liquid as used in all other previous…
▽ More
Three-dimensional Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) on the nonlinear dynamics and a route to chaos in a rotating fluid subjected to lateral heating is presented here and discussed in the context of laboratory experiments in the baroclinic annulus. Following two previous preliminary studies by Maubert and Randriamampianina, the fluid used is air rather than a liquid as used in all other previous work. This study investigated a bifurcation sequence from the axisymmetric flow to a number of complex flows. The transition sequence, on increase of the rotation rate, from the axisymmetric solution via a steady, fully-developed baroclinic wave to chaotic flow followed a variant of the classical quasi-periodic bifurcation route, starting with a subcritical Hopf and associated saddle-node bifurcation. This was followed by a sequence of two supercritical Hopf-type bifurcations, first to an amplitude vacillation, then to a three-frequency quasi-periodic modulated amplitude vacillation (MAV), and finally to a chaotic MAV\@. In the context of the baroclinic annulus this sequence is unusual as the vacillation is usually found on decrease of the rotation rate from the steady wave flow. Further transitions of a steady wave with a higher wave number pointed to the possibility that a barotropic instability of the side wall boundary layers and the subsequent breakdown of these barotropic vortices may play a role in the transition to structural vacillation and, ultimately, geostrophic turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
