-
Impact of embedded $^{163}$Ho on the performance of the transition-edge sensor microcalorimeters of the HOLMES experiment
Authors:
Douglas Bennett,
Matteo Borghesi,
Pietro Campana,
Rodolfo Carobene,
Giancarlo Ceruti,
Matteo De Gerone,
Marco Faverzani,
Lorenzo Ferrari Barusso,
Elena Ferri,
Joseph Fowler,
Sara Gamba,
Flavio Gatti,
Andrea Giachero,
Marco Gobbo,
Danilo Labranca,
Roberto Moretti,
Angelo Nucciotti,
Luca Origo,
Stefano Ragazzi,
Dan Schmidt,
Daniel Swetz,
Joel Ullom
Abstract:
We present a detailed investigation of the performance of transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters with $^{163}$Ho atoms embedded by ion implantation, as part of the HOLMES experiment aimed at neutrino mass determination. The inclusion of $^{163}$Ho atoms introduces an excess heat capacity due to a pronounced Schottky anomaly, which can affect the detector's energy resolution, signal height,…
▽ More
We present a detailed investigation of the performance of transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters with $^{163}$Ho atoms embedded by ion implantation, as part of the HOLMES experiment aimed at neutrino mass determination. The inclusion of $^{163}$Ho atoms introduces an excess heat capacity due to a pronounced Schottky anomaly, which can affect the detector's energy resolution, signal height, and response time. We fabricated TES arrays with varying levels of $^{163}$Ho activity and characterized their performance in terms of energy resolution, decay time constants, and heat capacity. The intrinsic energy resolution was found to degrade with increasing $^{163}$Ho activity, consistent with the expected scaling of heat capacity. From the analysis, we determined the specific heat capacity of $^{163}$Ho to be $(2.9 \pm 0.4 \mathrm{(stat)} \pm 0.7 \mathrm{(sys)})$ J/K/mol at $(94 \pm 1)$\,mK, close to the literature values for metallic holmium. No additional long decay time constants correlated with $^{163}$Ho activity were observed, indicating that the excess heat capacity does not introduce weakly coupled thermodynamic systems. These results suggest that our present TES microcalorimeters can tolerate $^{163}$Ho activities up to approximately 5 Bq without significant performance degradation. For higher activities, reducing the TES transition temperature is necessary to maintain energy resolution. These findings provide critical insights for optimizing TES microcalorimeters for future neutrino mass experiments and other applications requiring embedded radioactive sources. The study also highlights the robustness of TES technology in handling implanted radionuclides while maintaining high-resolution performance.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Most stringent bound on electron neutrino mass obtained with a scalable low temperature microcalorimeter array
Authors:
B. K. Alpert,
M. Balata,
D. T. Becker,
D. A. Bennett,
M. Borghesi,
P. Campana,
R. Carobene,
M. De Gerone,
W. B. Doriese,
M. Faverzani,
L. Ferrari Barusso,
E. Ferri,
J. W. Fowler,
G. Gallucci,
S. Gamba,
J. D. Gard,
F. Gatti,
A. Giachero,
M. Gobbo,
U. Köster,
D. Labranca,
M. Lusignoli,
P. Manfrinetti,
J. A. B. Mates,
E. Maugeri
, et al. (14 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The determination of the absolute neutrino mass scale remains a fundamental open question in particle physics, with profound implications for both the Standard Model and cosmology. Direct kinematic measurements, independent of model-dependent assumptions, provide the most robust approach to address this challenge. In this Letter, we present the most stringent upper bound on the effective electron…
▽ More
The determination of the absolute neutrino mass scale remains a fundamental open question in particle physics, with profound implications for both the Standard Model and cosmology. Direct kinematic measurements, independent of model-dependent assumptions, provide the most robust approach to address this challenge. In this Letter, we present the most stringent upper bound on the effective electron neutrino mass ever obtained with a calorimetric measurement of the electron capture decay of $^{163}$Ho. The HOLMES experiment employs an array of ion-implanted transition-edge sensor (TES) microcalorimeters, achieving an average energy resolution of 6 eV FWHM with a scalable, multiplexed readout technique. With a total of $7\times10^7$ decay events recorded over two months and a Bayesian statistical analysis, we derive an upper limit of $m_β<27$ eV/c$^2$ at 90% credibility. These results validate the feasibility of $^{163}$Ho calorimetry for next-generation neutrino mass experiments and demonstrate the potential of a scalable TES-based microcalorimetric technique to push the sensitivity of direct neutrino mass measurements beyond the current state of the art.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2025; v1 submitted 10 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Measuring the electron neutrino mass using the electron capture decay of 163Ho
Authors:
Joel Ullom,
Daniel Schmidt,
Simon Bandler,
Thomas Stevenson,
Mark Croce,
Katrina Koehler,
Matteo De Gerone,
Loredana Gastaldo,
Christian Enss,
Geonbo Kim,
Angelo Nucciotti,
Stefano Ragazzi,
Kyle Leach,
Diana Parno,
Brian Mong,
Josef Frisch,
Christopher Kenney
Abstract:
While the mass differences between neutrino mass states are known, their absolute masses and mass hierarchy have not yet been determined. Determining the mass of neutrinos provides access to physics beyond the Standard Model and the resulting value has implications for the growth of large-scale structure in the universe over cosmic history. Because of the importance of the topic, a number of effor…
▽ More
While the mass differences between neutrino mass states are known, their absolute masses and mass hierarchy have not yet been determined. Determining the mass of neutrinos provides access to physics beyond the Standard Model and the resulting value has implications for the growth of large-scale structure in the universe over cosmic history. Because of the importance of the topic, a number of efforts are already underway to determine the mass of neutrinos including direct kinematic measurements and indirect measurements of astrophysical phenomena that constrain the sum of the mass eigenstates through models of cosmic evolution. Here, we advocate for a collaborative international effort to perform a kinematic determination of the effective electron neutrino mass using calorimetric measurements of the decay of 163Ho. This effort is justified by the success of current experiments using the technique, its high benefit-to-cost ratio, the value of approaches with different systematic errors, and the value of measuring the electron neutrino mass rather than the electron anti-neutrino mass.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Status of the HOLMES Experiment to Directly Measure the Neutrino Mass
Authors:
A. Nucciotti,
B. Alpert,
M. Balata,
D. BeckerD. Bennett,
A. Bevilacqua,
M. Biasotti,
V. Ceriale,
G. Ceruti,
D. Corsini,
M. De Gerone,
R. Dressler,
M. Faverzani,
E. Ferri,
J. Fowler,
G. Gallucci,
J. Gard,
F. Gatti,
A. Giachero,
J. Hays-Wehle,
S. Heinitz,
G. Hilton,
U. Köster,
M. Lusignoli,
J. Mates,
S. Nisi
, et al. (13 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The assessment of neutrino absolute mass scale is still a crucial challenge in today particle physics and cosmology. Beta or electron capture spectrum end-point study is currently the only experimental method which can provide a model independent measurement of the absolute scale of neutrino mass. HOLMES is an experiment funded by the European Research Council to directly measure the neutrino mass…
▽ More
The assessment of neutrino absolute mass scale is still a crucial challenge in today particle physics and cosmology. Beta or electron capture spectrum end-point study is currently the only experimental method which can provide a model independent measurement of the absolute scale of neutrino mass. HOLMES is an experiment funded by the European Research Council to directly measure the neutrino mass. HOLMES will perform a calorimetric measurement of the energy released in the electron capture decay of the artificial isotope $^{163}$Ho. In a calorimetric measurement the energy released in the decay process is entirely contained into the detector, except for the fraction taken away by the neutrino. This approach eliminates both the issues related to the use of an external source and the systematic uncertainties arising from decays on excited final states. The most suitable detectors for this type of measurement are low temperature thermal detectors, where all the energy released into an absorber is converted into a temperature increase that can be measured by a sensitive thermometer directly coupled with the absorber. This measurement was originally proposed in 1982 by A. De Rujula and M. Lusignoli, but only in the last decade the technological progress in detectors development has allowed to design a sensitive experiment. HOLMES plans to deploy a large array of low temperature microcalorimeters with implanted $^{163}$Ho nuclei. In this contribution we outline the HOLMES project with its physics reach and technical challenges, along with its status and perspectives.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Measuring the electron neutrino mass with improved sensitivity: the HOLMES experiment
Authors:
A. Giachero,
B. Alpert,
D. Becker,
D. Bennett,
M. Biasotti,
C. Brofferio,
V. Ceriale,
G. Ceruti,
D. Corsini,
P. Day,
M. De Gerone,
R. Dressler,
M. Faverzani,
E. Ferri,
J. Fowler,
E. Fumagalli,
G. Gallucci,
J. Gard,
F. Gatti J. Hays-Wehle,
S. Heinitz,
G. Hilton,
U. Koester,
M. Lusignoli,
J. Mates,
S. Nisi
, et al. (17 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
HOLMES is a new experiment aiming at directly measuring the neutrino mass with a sensitivity below 2 eV. HOLMES will perform a calorimetric measurement of the energy released in the decay of $^{163}$Ho. The calorimetric measurement eliminates systematic uncertainties arising from the use of external beta sources, as in experiments with spectrometers. This measurement was proposed in 1982 by A. De…
▽ More
HOLMES is a new experiment aiming at directly measuring the neutrino mass with a sensitivity below 2 eV. HOLMES will perform a calorimetric measurement of the energy released in the decay of $^{163}$Ho. The calorimetric measurement eliminates systematic uncertainties arising from the use of external beta sources, as in experiments with spectrometers. This measurement was proposed in 1982 by A. De Rujula and M. Lusignoli, but only recently the detector technological progress has allowed to design a sensitive experiment. HOLMES will deploy a large array of low temperature microcalorimeters with implanted $^{163}$Ho nuclei. HOLMES, besides being an important step forward in the direct neutrino mass measurement with a calorimetric approach, will also establish the potential of this approach to extend the sensitivity down to 0.1 eV and lower. In its final configuration HOLMES will collect about $3\cdot 10^{13}$ decays with 1000 detectors characterized by an instrumental energy resolution of the order of few eV and a time resolution of few microseconds. To embed the $^{163}$Ho into the gold absorbers a custom mass separator ion implanter is being developed. The detectors used for the HOLMES experiment will be Mo/Cu bilayers TESs (Transition Edge Sensors) on SiN$_x$ membrane with gold absorbers. Microwave multiplexed rf-SQUIDs are the best available technique to read out large array of such detectors. An extensive R&D activity is in progress in order to maximize the multiplexing factor while preserving the performances of the individual detectors. The current activities are focused on the the single detector performances optimization and on the $^{163}$Ho isotope production and embedding. A preliminary measurement of a sub-array of $4\times 16$ detectors is planned late in 2017. In this contribution we present the HOLMES project with its technical challenges, its status and perspectives.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2017; v1 submitted 12 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
HOLMES - The Electron Capture Decay of 163Ho to Measure the Electron Neutrino Mass with sub-eV sensitivity
Authors:
B. Alpert,
M. Balata,
D. Bennett,
M. Biasotti,
C. Boragno,
C. Brofferio,
V. Ceriale,
D. Corsini,
P. K. Day,
M. De Gerone,
R. Dressler,
M. Faverzani,
E. Ferri,
J. Fowler,
F. Gatti,
A. Giachero,
J. Hays-Wehle,
S. Heinitz,
G. Hilton,
U. Koester,
M. Lusignoli,
M. Maino,
J. Mates,
S. Nisi,
R. Nizzolo
, et al. (13 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The European Research Council has recently funded HOLMES, a new experiment to directly measure the neutrino mass. HOLMES will perform a calorimetric measurement of the energy released in the decay of 163Ho. The calorimetric measurement eliminates systematic uncertainties arising from the use of external beta sources, as in experiments with beta spectrometers. This measurement was proposed in 1982…
▽ More
The European Research Council has recently funded HOLMES, a new experiment to directly measure the neutrino mass. HOLMES will perform a calorimetric measurement of the energy released in the decay of 163Ho. The calorimetric measurement eliminates systematic uncertainties arising from the use of external beta sources, as in experiments with beta spectrometers. This measurement was proposed in 1982 by A. De Rujula and M. Lusignoli, but only recently the detector technological progress allowed to design a sensitive experiment. HOLMES will deploy a large array of low temperature microcalorimeters with implanted 163Ho nuclei. The resulting mass sensitivity will be as low as 0.4 eV. HOLMES will be an important step forward in the direct neutrino mass measurement with a calorimetric approach as an alternative to spectrometry. It will also establish the potential of this approach to extend the sensitivity down to 0.1 eV. We outline here the project with its technical challenges and perspectives.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2015; v1 submitted 16 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
The Electron Capture Decay of 163-Ho to Measure the Electron Neutrino Mass with sub-eV Accuracy (and Beyond)
Authors:
Massimiliano Galeazzi,
Flavio Gatti,
Maurizio Lusignoli,
Angelo Nucciotti,
Stefano Ragazzi,
Maria Ribeiro Gomes
Abstract:
We have investigated the possibility of measuring the electron neutrino mass with sub-eV sensitivity by studying the electron capture decay of 163-Ho with cryogenic microcalorimeters. In this paper we will introduce an experiment's concept, discuss the technical requirements, and identify a roadmap to reach a sensitivity of 0.1 eV and beyond.
We have investigated the possibility of measuring the electron neutrino mass with sub-eV sensitivity by studying the electron capture decay of 163-Ho with cryogenic microcalorimeters. In this paper we will introduce an experiment's concept, discuss the technical requirements, and identify a roadmap to reach a sensitivity of 0.1 eV and beyond.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2012; v1 submitted 21 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Radiation hardness qualification of PbWO4 scintillation crystals for the CMS Electromagnetic Calorimeter
Authors:
The CMS Electromagnetic Calorimeter Group,
P. Adzic,
N. Almeida,
D. Andelin,
I. Anicin,
Z. Antunovic,
R. Arcidiacono,
M. W. Arenton,
E. Auffray,
S. Argiro,
A. Askew,
S. Baccaro,
S. Baffioni,
M. Balazs,
D. Bandurin,
D. Barney,
L. M. Barone,
A. Bartoloni,
C. Baty,
S. Beauceron,
K. W. Bell,
C. Bernet,
M. Besancon,
B. Betev,
R. Beuselinck
, et al. (245 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Ensuring the radiation hardness of PbWO4 crystals was one of the main priorities during the construction of the electromagnetic calorimeter of the CMS experiment at CERN. The production on an industrial scale of radiation hard crystals and their certification over a period of several years represented a difficult challenge both for CMS and for the crystal suppliers. The present article reviews t…
▽ More
Ensuring the radiation hardness of PbWO4 crystals was one of the main priorities during the construction of the electromagnetic calorimeter of the CMS experiment at CERN. The production on an industrial scale of radiation hard crystals and their certification over a period of several years represented a difficult challenge both for CMS and for the crystal suppliers. The present article reviews the related scientific and technological problems encountered.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Detectors and flux instrumentation for future neutrino facilities
Authors:
T. Abe,
H. Aihara,
C. Andreopoulos,
A. Ankowski,
A. Badertscher,
G. Battistoni,
A. Blondel,
J. Bouchez,
A. Bross,
A. Bueno,
L. Camilleri,
J. E. Campagne,
A. Cazes,
A. Cervera-Villanueva,
G. De Lellis,
F. Di Capua,
M. Ellis,
A. Ereditato,
L. S. Esposito,
C. Fukushima,
E. Gschwendtner,
J. J. Gomez-Cadenas,
M. Iwasaki,
K. Kaneyuki,
Y. Karadzhov
, et al. (44 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This report summarises the conclusions from the detector group of the International Scoping Study of a future Neutrino Factory and Super-Beam neutrino facility. The baseline detector options for each possible neutrino beam are defined as follows:
1. A very massive (Megaton) water Cherenkov detector is the baseline option for a sub-GeV Beta Beam and Super Beam facility.
2. There are a number…
▽ More
This report summarises the conclusions from the detector group of the International Scoping Study of a future Neutrino Factory and Super-Beam neutrino facility. The baseline detector options for each possible neutrino beam are defined as follows:
1. A very massive (Megaton) water Cherenkov detector is the baseline option for a sub-GeV Beta Beam and Super Beam facility.
2. There are a number of possibilities for either a Beta Beam or Super Beam (SB) medium energy facility between 1-5 GeV. These include a totally active scintillating detector (TASD), a liquid argon TPC or a water Cherenkov detector.
3. A 100 kton magnetized iron neutrino detector (MIND) is the baseline to detect the wrong sign muon final states (golden channel) at a high energy (20-50 GeV) neutrino factory from muon decay. A 10 kton hybrid neutrino magnetic emulsion cloud chamber detector for wrong sign tau detection (silver channel) is a possible complement to MIND, if one needs to resolve degeneracies that appear in the $δ$-$θ_{13}$ parameter space.
△ Less
Submitted 26 December, 2007;
originally announced December 2007.
