-
Effectiveness of Alter Sampling in Social Networks
Authors:
Naghmeh Momeni,
Michael G. Rabbat
Abstract:
Social networks play a key role in studying various individual and social behaviors. To use social networks in a study, their structural properties must be measured. For offline social networks, the conventional procedure is surveying/interviewing a set of randomly-selected respondents. In many practical applications, inferring the network structure via sampling is too prohibitively costly. There…
▽ More
Social networks play a key role in studying various individual and social behaviors. To use social networks in a study, their structural properties must be measured. For offline social networks, the conventional procedure is surveying/interviewing a set of randomly-selected respondents. In many practical applications, inferring the network structure via sampling is too prohibitively costly. There are also applications in which it simply fails. For example, for optimal vaccination or employing influential spreaders for public health interventions, we need to efficiently and quickly target well-connected individuals, which random sampling does not accomplish. In a few studies, an alternative sampling scheme (which we dub `alter sampling') has proven useful. This method simply targets randomly-chosen neighbors of the randomly-selected respondents. A natural question that arises is: to what extent does this method generalize? Is the method suitable for every social network or only the very few ones considered so far? In this paper, we demonstrate the robustness of this method across a wide range of networks with diverse structural properties. The method outperforms random sampling by a large margin for a vast majority of cases. We then propose an estimator to assess the advantage of choosing alter sampling over random sampling in practical scenarios, and demonstrate its accuracy via Monte Carlo simulations on diverse synthetic networks.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2018; v1 submitted 7 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Measuring the Generalized Friendship Paradox in Networks with Quality-dependent Connectivity
Authors:
Naghmeh Momeni,
Michael G. Rabbat
Abstract:
The friendship paradox is a sociological phenomenon stating that most people have fewer friends than their friends do. The generalized friendship paradox refers to the same observation for attributes other than degree, and it has been observed in Twitter and scientific collaboration networks. This paper takes an analytical approach to model this phenomenon. We consider a preferential attachment-li…
▽ More
The friendship paradox is a sociological phenomenon stating that most people have fewer friends than their friends do. The generalized friendship paradox refers to the same observation for attributes other than degree, and it has been observed in Twitter and scientific collaboration networks. This paper takes an analytical approach to model this phenomenon. We consider a preferential attachment-like network growth mechanism governed by both node degrees and `qualities'. We introduce measures to quantify paradoxes, and contrast the results obtained in our model to those obtained for an uncorrelated network, where the degrees and qualities of adjacent nodes are uncorrelated. We shed light on the effect of the distribution of node qualities on the friendship paradox. We consider both the mean and the median to measure paradoxes, and compare the results obtained by using these two statistics.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Generalized Friendship Paradox: An Analytical Approach
Authors:
Babak Fotouhi,
Naghmeh Momeni,
Michael G. Rabbat
Abstract:
The friendship paradox refers to the sociological observation that, while the people's assessment of their own popularity is typically self-aggrandizing, in reality they are less popular than their friends. The generalized friendship paradox is the average alter superiority observed empirically in social settings, scientific collaboration networks, as well as online social media. We posit a qualit…
▽ More
The friendship paradox refers to the sociological observation that, while the people's assessment of their own popularity is typically self-aggrandizing, in reality they are less popular than their friends. The generalized friendship paradox is the average alter superiority observed empirically in social settings, scientific collaboration networks, as well as online social media. We posit a quality-based network growth model in which the chance for a node to receive new links depends both on its degree and a quality parameter. Nodes are assigned qualities the first time they join the network, and these do not change over time. We analyse the model theoretically, finding expressions for the joint degree-quality distribution and nearest-neighbor distribution. We then demonstrate that this model exhibits both the friendship paradox and the generalized friendship paradox at the network level, regardless of the distribution of qualities. We also show that, in the proposed model, the degree and quality of each node are positively correlated regardless of how node qualities are distributed.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Degree Correlation in Scale-Free Graphs
Authors:
Babak Fotouhi,
Michael G. Rabbat
Abstract:
We obtain closed form expressions for the expected conditional degree distribution and the joint degree distribution of the linear preferential attachment model for network growth in the steady state. We consider the multiple-destination preferential attachment growth model, where incoming nodes at each timestep attach to $β$ existing nodes, selected by degree-proportional probabilities. By the co…
▽ More
We obtain closed form expressions for the expected conditional degree distribution and the joint degree distribution of the linear preferential attachment model for network growth in the steady state. We consider the multiple-destination preferential attachment growth model, where incoming nodes at each timestep attach to $β$ existing nodes, selected by degree-proportional probabilities. By the conditional degree distribution $p(\ell| k)$, we mean the degree distribution of nodes that are connected to a node of degree $k$. By the joint degree distribution $p(k,\ell)$, we mean the proportion of links that connect nodes of degrees $k$ and $\ell$. In addition to this growth model, we consider the shifted-linear preferential growth model and solve for the same quantities, as well as a closed form expression for its steady-state degree distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Voter Model with Arbitrary Degree Dependence: Clout, Confidence and Irreversibility
Authors:
Babak Fotouhi,
Michael G. Rabbat
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider the voter model with popularity bias. The influence of each node on its neighbors depends on its degree. We find the consensus probabilities and expected consensus times for each of the states. We also find the fixation probability, which is the probability that a single node whose state differs from every other node imposes its state on the entire system. In addition, w…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider the voter model with popularity bias. The influence of each node on its neighbors depends on its degree. We find the consensus probabilities and expected consensus times for each of the states. We also find the fixation probability, which is the probability that a single node whose state differs from every other node imposes its state on the entire system. In addition, we find the expected fixation time. Then two extensions to the model are proposed and the motivations behind them are discussed. The first one is confidence, where in addition to the states of neighbors, nodes take their own state into account at each update. We repeat the calculations for the augmented model and investigate the effects of adding confidence to the model. The second proposed extension is irreversibility, where one of the states is given the property that once nodes adopt it, they cannot switch back. The dynamics of densities, fixation times and consensus times are obtained.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Network Growth with Arbitrary Initial Conditions: Analytical Results for Uniform and Preferential Attachment
Authors:
Babak Fotouhi,
Michael G. Rabbat
Abstract:
This paper provides time-dependent expressions for the expected degree distribution of a given network that is subject to growth, as a function of time. We consider both uniform attachment, where incoming nodes form links to existing nodes selected uniformly at random, and preferential attachment, when probabilities are assigned proportional to the degrees of the existing nodes. We consider the ca…
▽ More
This paper provides time-dependent expressions for the expected degree distribution of a given network that is subject to growth, as a function of time. We consider both uniform attachment, where incoming nodes form links to existing nodes selected uniformly at random, and preferential attachment, when probabilities are assigned proportional to the degrees of the existing nodes. We consider the cases of single and multiple links being formed by each newly-introduced node. The initial conditions are arbitrary, that is, the solution depends on the degree distribution of the initial graph which is the substrate of the growth. Previous work in the literature focuses on the asymptotic state, that is, when the number of nodes added to the initial graph tends to infinity, rendering the effect of the initial graph negligible. Our contribution provides a solution for the expected degree distribution as a function of time, for arbitrary initial condition. Previous results match our results in the asymptotic limit.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2013; v1 submitted 3 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
The Effect of Exogenous Inputs and Defiant Agents on Opinion Dynamics with Local and Global Interactions
Authors:
Babak Fotouhi,
Michael G. Rabbat
Abstract:
Most of the conventional models for opinion dynamics mainly account for a fully local influence, where myopic agents decide their actions after they interact with other agents that are adjacent to them. For example, in the case of social interactions, this includes family, friends, and other strong social ties. The model proposed in this contribution, embodies a global influence as well where, by…
▽ More
Most of the conventional models for opinion dynamics mainly account for a fully local influence, where myopic agents decide their actions after they interact with other agents that are adjacent to them. For example, in the case of social interactions, this includes family, friends, and other strong social ties. The model proposed in this contribution, embodies a global influence as well where, by global, we mean that each node also observes a sample of the average behavior of the entire population (in the social example, people observe other people on the streets, subway, and other social venues). We consider a case where nodes have dichotomous states (examples include elections with two major parties, whether or not to adopt a new technology or product, and any yes/no opinion such as in voting on a referendum). The dynamics of states on a network with arbitrary degree distribution are studied. For a given initial condition, we find the probability to reach consensus on each state and the expected time reach to consensus. The effect of an exogenous bias on the average orientation of the system is investigated, to model mass media. To do so, we add an external field to the model that favors one of the states over the other. This field interferes with the regular decision process of each node and creates a constant probability to lean towards one of the states. We solve for the average state of the system as a function of time for given initial conditions. Then anti-conformists (stubborn nodes who never revise their states) are added to the network, in an effort to circumvent the external bias. We find necessary conditions on the number of these defiant nodes required to cancel the effect of the external bias. Our analysis is based on a mean field approximation of the agent opinions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2012; v1 submitted 15 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Dynamics of Influence on Hierarchical Structures
Authors:
Babak Fotouhi,
Michael G. Rabbat
Abstract:
Dichotomous spin dynamics on a pyramidal hierarchical structure (the Bethe lattice) are studied. The system embodies a number of \emph{classes}, where a class comprises of nodes that are equidistant from the root (head node). Weighted links exist between nodes from the same and different classes. The spin (hereafter, \emph{state}) of the head node is fixed. We solve for the dynamics of the system…
▽ More
Dichotomous spin dynamics on a pyramidal hierarchical structure (the Bethe lattice) are studied. The system embodies a number of \emph{classes}, where a class comprises of nodes that are equidistant from the root (head node). Weighted links exist between nodes from the same and different classes. The spin (hereafter, \emph{state}) of the head node is fixed. We solve for the dynamics of the system for different boundary conditions. We find necessary conditions so that the classes eventually repudiate or acquiesce in the state imposed by the head node. The results indicate that to reach unanimity across the hierarchy, it suffices that the bottom-most class adopts the same state as the head node. Then the rest of the hierarchy will inevitably comply. This also sheds light on the importance of mass media as a means of synchronization between the top-most and bottom-most classes. Surprisingly, in the case of discord between the head node and the bottom-most classes, the average state over all nodes inclines towards that of the bottom-most class regardless of the link weights and intra-class configurations. Hence the role of the bottom-most class is signified.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013; v1 submitted 31 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Migration in a Small World: A Network Approach to Modeling Immigration Processes
Authors:
Babak Fotouhi,
Michael G. Rabbat
Abstract:
Existing theories of migration either focus on micro- or macroscopic behavior of populations; that is, either the average behavior of entire population is modeled directly, or decisions of individuals are modeled directly. In this work, we seek to bridge these two perspectives by modeling individual agents decisions to migrate while accounting for the social network structure that binds individual…
▽ More
Existing theories of migration either focus on micro- or macroscopic behavior of populations; that is, either the average behavior of entire population is modeled directly, or decisions of individuals are modeled directly. In this work, we seek to bridge these two perspectives by modeling individual agents decisions to migrate while accounting for the social network structure that binds individuals into a population. Pecuniary considerations combined with the decisions of peers are the primary elements of the model, being the main driving forces of migration. People of the home country are modeled as nodes on a small-world network. A dichotomous state is associated with each node, indicating whether it emigrates to the destination country or it stays in the home country. We characterize the emigration rate in terms of the relative welfare and population of the home and destination countries. The time evolution and the steady-state fraction of emigrants are also derived.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.