-
From lab to landscape-scale experiments for the morphodynamics of sand dunes
Authors:
P. Claudin,
S. Courrech du Pont,
C. Narteau
Abstract:
We review the main processes that drive the morphodynamics of dunes, i.e. their growth in height, migration and elongation, and emphasise the contribution of experiments to the understanding of these mechanisms. The main control parameters are the sediment flux $Q$ and the saturation length $L_{\rm sat}$ associated with the spatial relaxation of the flux towards the transport capacity. The other r…
▽ More
We review the main processes that drive the morphodynamics of dunes, i.e. their growth in height, migration and elongation, and emphasise the contribution of experiments to the understanding of these mechanisms. The main control parameters are the sediment flux $Q$ and the saturation length $L_{\rm sat}$ associated with the spatial relaxation of the flux towards the transport capacity. The other relevant quantities are essentially dimensionless: fluid response to a bed perturbation, dune geometry (orientation, aspect ratio), transport ratios under multi-directional wind regimes. We argue that laboratory experiments dealing with sedimentary bedforms in water flows are good analogues to study the morphodynamics of aeolian dunes at reduced length and time scales, as $L_{\rm sat}$ and $L_{\rm sat}^2/Q$ are expected to be smaller for subaqueous bedload. Besides, dune shape and dynamics are mainly governed by flow and boundary conditions, independent of the transport mode. We discuss different experimental set-ups and results, especially concerning dune pattern orientation and dune interaction. Under natural wind regimes in terrestrial deserts, we show the potential of field experiments in which the control of initial and boundary conditions allows for the quantification of all the relevant mechanisms involved in dune growth. We emphasise the general agreement between observations, measurements and theoretical predictions, which indicates a robust comprehension of the underlying processes. This understanding can serve as a foundation for further investigations, including the interpretation of dune landscapes and the resolution of inverse problems.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Improving propulsive efficiency using bio-inspired intermittent locomotion
Authors:
Tristan Aurégan,
Mathilde Lemoine,
Benjamin Thiria,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont
Abstract:
Many swimmers, especially small to medium-sized animals, use intermittent locomotion that differs from continuous swimming of large species. This type of locomotion, called burst-and-coast, is often associated with an energetic advantage. In this work, we investigate the intermittent locomotion inspired by fish locomotion but applied to a propeller. The energy consumption of burst-and-coast cycles…
▽ More
Many swimmers, especially small to medium-sized animals, use intermittent locomotion that differs from continuous swimming of large species. This type of locomotion, called burst-and-coast, is often associated with an energetic advantage. In this work, we investigate the intermittent locomotion inspired by fish locomotion but applied to a propeller. The energy consumption of burst-and-coast cycles is measured and compared to the continuous rotation regime. We show that a substantial drag ratio between the active and passive phases of the motion, as observed in fish, is critical for energy savings. Such a contrast can be obtained using a folding propeller that passively opens and closes as the propeller starts and stops rotating. For this reconfigurable propeller, intermittent propulsion is found to be energetically advantageous, saving up to 24% of the energy required to cruise at a given speed. Using an analytical model, we show that intermittent motion is more efficient than continuous motion when the drag reduction in the coast phase exceeds 65%. For fish-like locomotion, this threshold seems to be closer to 30%. A formal analogy allows us to explain the difference between propeller propulsion and fish locomotion.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2024; v1 submitted 26 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Emergence of tip singularities in dissolution patterns
Authors:
Martin Chaigne,
Sabrina Carpy,
Marion Massé,
Julien Derr,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont,
Michael Berhanu
Abstract:
Chemical erosion, one of the two major erosion processes along with mechanical erosion, occurs when a soluble rock like salt, gypsum or limestone is dissolved in contact with a water flow. The coupling between the geometry of the rocks, the mass-transfer and the flow leads to the formation of remarkable patterns, like scallop patterns in caves. We emphasize the common presence of very sharp shapes…
▽ More
Chemical erosion, one of the two major erosion processes along with mechanical erosion, occurs when a soluble rock like salt, gypsum or limestone is dissolved in contact with a water flow. The coupling between the geometry of the rocks, the mass-transfer and the flow leads to the formation of remarkable patterns, like scallop patterns in caves. We emphasize the common presence of very sharp shapes and spikes, despite the diversity of hydrodynamic conditions and the nature of the soluble materials. We explain the generic emergence of such spikes in dissolution processes by a geometrical approach. Singularities at the interface emerge as a consequence of the erosion directed in the normal direction, when the surface displays curvature variations, like those associated to a dissolution pattern. First, we demonstrate the presence of singular structures in natural interfaces shaped by dissolution. Then, we propose simple surface evolution models of increasing complexity demonstrating the emergence of spikes and allowing us to explain at long term by coarsening the formation of cellular structures. Finally, we perform a dissolution pattern experiment driven by solutal convection and we report the emergence of a cellular pattern following well the model predictions. Although the precise prediction of dissolution shapes necessitates to perform a complete hydrodynamic study, we show that the characteristic spikes which are reported ultimately for dissolution shapes are explained generically by geometrical arguments due to the surface evolution. These findings can be applied to other ablation patterns, reported for example in melting ice.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2023; v1 submitted 20 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Coexistence of two dune growth mechanisms in a landscape-scale experiment
Authors:
Ping Lü,
Clément Narteau,
Zhibao Dong,
Philippe Claudin,
Sébastien Rodriguez,
Zhishan An,
Cyril Gadal,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont
Abstract:
In landscape-scale experiments at the edge of the Gobi desert, we show that various dune types develop simultaneously under natural wind conditions. Using 4 years of high-resolution topographic data, we demonstrate that, depending on sand availability, the same wind regime can lead to two different dune orientations, which reflect two independent dune growth mechanisms. As periodic oblique dunes e…
▽ More
In landscape-scale experiments at the edge of the Gobi desert, we show that various dune types develop simultaneously under natural wind conditions. Using 4 years of high-resolution topographic data, we demonstrate that, depending on sand availability, the same wind regime can lead to two different dune orientations, which reflect two independent dune growth mechanisms. As periodic oblique dunes emerge from a sand bed and develop to 2 meters in height, we analyze defect dynamics that drive the non-linear phase of pattern coarsening. Starting from conical sand heaps deposited on gravels, we observe the transition from dome to barchan and asymmetric barchan shapes. We identify a minimum size for arm elongation and evaluate the contribution of wind reversals to its longitudinal alignment. These experimental field observations support existing theoretical models of dune dynamics boosting confidence in their applicability for quantitative predictions of dune evolution under various wind regimes and bed conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Direct validation of dune instability theory
Authors:
Ping Lü,
Clément Narteau,
Zhibao Dong,
Philippe Claudin,
Sébastien Rodriguez,
Zhishan An,
Laura Fernandez-Cascales,
Cyril Gadal,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont
Abstract:
Modern dune fields are valuable sources of information for the large-scale analysis of terrestrial and planetary environments and atmospheres, but their study relies on understanding the small-scale dynamics that constantly generate new dunes and reshape older ones. Here we designed a landscape-scale experiment at the edge of the Gobi desert, China, to quantify the development of incipient dunes u…
▽ More
Modern dune fields are valuable sources of information for the large-scale analysis of terrestrial and planetary environments and atmospheres, but their study relies on understanding the small-scale dynamics that constantly generate new dunes and reshape older ones. Here we designed a landscape-scale experiment at the edge of the Gobi desert, China, to quantify the development of incipient dunes under the natural action of winds. High-resolution topographic data documenting 42~months of bedform dynamics are examined to provide a spectral analysis of dune pattern formation. We identified two successive phases in the process of dune growth, from the initial flat sand bed to a meter-high periodic pattern. We focus on the initial phase, when the linear regime of dune instability applies, and measure the growth rate of dunes of different wavelengths. We identify the existence of a maximum growth rate, which readily explains the mechanism by which dunes select their size, leading to the prevalence of a 15~m-wavelength pattern. We quantitatively compare our experimental results to the prediction of the dune instability theory using transport and flow parameters independently measured in the field. The remarkable agreement between theory and observations demonstrates that the linear regime of dune growth is permanently expressed on low-amplitude bed topography, before larger regular patterns and slip faces eventually emerge. Our experiment underpin existing theoretical models for the early development of eolian dunes, which can now be used to provide reliable insights into atmospheric and surface processes on Earth and other planetary bodies.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Streamwise Dissolution Patterns Created by a Flowing Water Film
Authors:
Adrien Guérin,
Julien Derr,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont,
Michael Berhanu
Abstract:
The dissolution of rocks by rainfall commonly generates streamwise parallel channels, yet the occurrence of these natural patterns remains to be understood. Here, we report the emergence in the laboratory of a streamwise dissolution pattern at the surface of an initially flat soluble material, inclined and subjected to a thin runoff water flow. Nearly parallel grooves about 1 mm wide and directed…
▽ More
The dissolution of rocks by rainfall commonly generates streamwise parallel channels, yet the occurrence of these natural patterns remains to be understood. Here, we report the emergence in the laboratory of a streamwise dissolution pattern at the surface of an initially flat soluble material, inclined and subjected to a thin runoff water flow. Nearly parallel grooves about 1 mm wide and directed along the main slope spontaneously form. Their width and depth increase continuously with time until their crests emerge and channelize the flow. Our observations may constitute the early stage of the patterns observed in the field.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Buoyancy driven dissolution of inclined blocks: Erosion rate and pattern formation
Authors:
Caroline Cohen,
Michael Berhanu,
Julien Derr,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont
Abstract:
The dissolution of a body into quiescent water leads to density stratifications at the interfaces that drive buoyant flows. Where the stratification is unstable, the flow destabilizes into convective solute plumes. By analogy with the Rayleigh-Bénard instability where concentration replaces temperature, this phenomenon is known as the solutal Rayleigh-Bénard instability. Here we report experiments…
▽ More
The dissolution of a body into quiescent water leads to density stratifications at the interfaces that drive buoyant flows. Where the stratification is unstable, the flow destabilizes into convective solute plumes. By analogy with the Rayleigh-Bénard instability where concentration replaces temperature, this phenomenon is known as the solutal Rayleigh-Bénard instability. Here we report experiments of the dissolution of inclined rectangular blocks made of salt, caramel or plaster in aqueous solutions of various concentrations. The solute flows along the block while forming plumes before they detach and sink. This flow along the block organizes the emission of plumes within longitudinal parallel stripes with a well-defined millimeter scale wavelength. The instability of the flow reflects on the concentration field in the boundary layer, which engraves longitudinal grooves onto the block. These grooves interact with the flow and turn into a paving of 3 dimensional cup like patterns that grow in size and propagate upstream. These bedforms are reminiscent of the scallop bedforms observed on the walls of cave or icebergs. Whereas the block interface is highly dynamical and evolves through time, it remains flat on the global scale and recedes at a stationary rate. We derive scaling laws for the receding velocity and the pattern genesis at the inclined interface that is based on a concentration boundary layer of constant thickness, which is controlled by the flow instability, but where the patterns nor the flow along the block do not play any role. We apply these results to the formation of sublimation patterns.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2020; v1 submitted 21 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Material optimization of flexible blades for wind turbines
Authors:
Vincent Cognet,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont,
Benjamin Thiria
Abstract:
Bioinspired flexible blades have been recently shown to significantly improve the versatility of horizontal-axis wind turbines, by widening their working range and increasing their efficiency. The aerodynamic and centrifugal forces bend the blade along its chord, varying the pitch angle by means of non-consuming mechanisms. Here we introduce a general method based on a universal scaling, which fin…
▽ More
Bioinspired flexible blades have been recently shown to significantly improve the versatility of horizontal-axis wind turbines, by widening their working range and increasing their efficiency. The aerodynamic and centrifugal forces bend the blade along its chord, varying the pitch angle by means of non-consuming mechanisms. Here we introduce a general method based on a universal scaling, which finds the optimal soft materials for the blades to maximize the overall turbine efficiency or rotational power, for any required geometry of classical horizontal-axis turbines. The optimization problem, which depends on various parameters, such as the wind velocity, the rotation rate, the density, the rigidity and the geometry of the blade, is reduced to only two dimensionless parameters: the Cauchy number and the centrifugal number. The blade-element momentum theory is coupled to a torsion spring-based model for the blade deformation. Taking into account realistic incoming wind-velocity distributions in the North Sea and a large wind-turbine geometry, we found a significant increase of the total harvested power, up to +35%. In addition, the optimal soft material corresponding to the maximal efficiency over the entire working range for a given wind turbine geometry is, within the limits of small blade deformations, scale-independent. Thus experiments on small wind turbines are a possible way to determine the optimal soft materials for larger ones. These flexible blades are found to be between 5% and 20% lighter than the current rigid blades.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Elongation and stability of a linear dune
Authors:
O. Rozier,
C. Narteau,
C. Gadal,
P. Claudin,
S. Courrech du Pont
Abstract:
Compared to barchan dunes, the morphodynamics of linear dunes that elongate on a non-erodible bed is barely investigated by means of laboratory experiments or numerical simulations. Using a cellular automaton model, we study the elongation of a solitary linear dune from a sand source and show that it can reach a steady state. This steady state is analyzed to understand the physical processes at wo…
▽ More
Compared to barchan dunes, the morphodynamics of linear dunes that elongate on a non-erodible bed is barely investigated by means of laboratory experiments or numerical simulations. Using a cellular automaton model, we study the elongation of a solitary linear dune from a sand source and show that it can reach a steady state. This steady state is analyzed to understand the physical processes at work along the dune. Crest reversals together with avalanche processes control the shape of transverse sections. Dune width and height decrease almost linearly with distance downstream until the minimum size for dunes. This is associated with a constant sand loss along the dune, which eventually compensates for the sediment influx and sets the dune length. This sand budget is discussed to distinguish an elongating linear dune from a barchan dune and to explain the complexity of linear dune fields in nature.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Periodicity in fields of elongating dunes
Authors:
Cyril Gadal,
Clément Narteau,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont,
Olivier Rozier,
Philippe Claudin
Abstract:
Dune fields are commonly associated with periodic patterns that are among the most recognizable landscapes on Earth and other planetary bodies. However, in zones of limited sediment supply, where periodic dunes elongate and align in the direction of the resultant sand flux, there has been no attempt to explain the emergence of such a regular pattern. Here, we show, by means of numerical simulation…
▽ More
Dune fields are commonly associated with periodic patterns that are among the most recognizable landscapes on Earth and other planetary bodies. However, in zones of limited sediment supply, where periodic dunes elongate and align in the direction of the resultant sand flux, there has been no attempt to explain the emergence of such a regular pattern. Here, we show, by means of numerical simulations, that the elongation growth mechanism does not produce a pattern with a specific wavelength. Periodic elongating dunes appear to be a juxtaposition of individual structures, the arrangement of which is due to regular landforms at the border of the field acting as boundary conditions. This includes, among others, dune patterns resulting from bed instability, or the crestline reorganization induced by dune migration. The wavelength selection in fields of elongating dunes therefore reflects the interdependence of dune patterns over the course of their evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2020; v1 submitted 26 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Incipient bedforms in a bidirectional wind regime
Authors:
Cyril Gadal,
Clément Narteau,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont,
Olivier Rozier,
Philippe Claudin
Abstract:
Most terrestrial sand seas form at `horse' latitudes, where the wind direction exhibits seasonal variation. Here, we extend the two-dimensional linear stability analysis of a flat sand bed associated with a unidirectional wind to the three-dimensional case in order to account for multidirectional wind regimes. Focusing on the simplest case of bidirectional flow regimes, we show that the transition…
▽ More
Most terrestrial sand seas form at `horse' latitudes, where the wind direction exhibits seasonal variation. Here, we extend the two-dimensional linear stability analysis of a flat sand bed associated with a unidirectional wind to the three-dimensional case in order to account for multidirectional wind regimes. Focusing on the simplest case of bidirectional flow regimes, we show that the transition from transverse to oblique or longitudinal patterns is controlled by the transport ratio and the divergence angle between the two flows. Our predictions agree with previous results for dune orientation, and also provide a wider range of possible alignments depending on flow strength, especially when the two winds are perpendicular, at which the transition occurs. This analysis also predicts the selected pattern wavelength, which either decreases close to the transition angle for strong winds, due to a geometric effect, or increases at low winds, when the bed slope affects the transport. This theoretical analysis is complemented by analogous subaqueous experiments, where bedforms are submitted to alternate water flows. For transverse bedforms, the experimental data validate the model at strong flows, providing evidence for the predicted geometric effect, but also for the increase of the wavelength close to the transport threshold. For longitudinal bedforms, a discrepancy is observed, which we interpret as the sign of enhanced nonlinearities induced by the development of slip faces when the flow alternately blows on both sides of the dune.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2020; v1 submitted 28 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
When dunes move together, structure of deserts emerges
Authors:
Mathieu Génois,
Pascal Hersen,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont,
Guillaume Grégoire
Abstract:
Crescent shaped barchan dunes are highly mobile dunes that are usually presented as a prototypical model of sand dunes. Although they have been theoretically shown to be unstable when considered separately, it is well known that they form large assemblies in desert. Collisions of dunes have been proposed as a mechanism to redistribute sand between dunes and prevent the formation of heavily large d…
▽ More
Crescent shaped barchan dunes are highly mobile dunes that are usually presented as a prototypical model of sand dunes. Although they have been theoretically shown to be unstable when considered separately, it is well known that they form large assemblies in desert. Collisions of dunes have been proposed as a mechanism to redistribute sand between dunes and prevent the formation of heavily large dunes, resulting in a stabilizing effect in the context of a dense barchan field. Yet, no models are able to explain the spatial structures of dunes observed in deserts. Here, we use an agent-based model with elementary rules of sand redistribution during collisions to access the full dynamics of very large barchan dune fields. Consequently, stationnary, out of equilibrium states emerge. Trigging the dune field density by a sand load/lost ratio, we show that large dune fields exhibit two assymtotic regimes: a dilute regime, where sand dune nucleation is needed to maintain a dune field, and a dense regime, where dune collisions allow to stabilize the whole dune field. In this dense regime, spatial structures form: the dune field is structured in narrow corridors of dunes extending in the wind direction, as observed in dense barchan deserts.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Comment on ``Force Balance at the Transition from Selective Withdrawal to Viscous Entrainment
Authors:
J. Eggers,
S. Courrech du Pont
Abstract:
Comment on paper by Blanchette and Zhang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 144501 (2009).
Comment on paper by Blanchette and Zhang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 144501 (2009).
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Sink flow deforms the interface between a viscous liquid and air into a tip singularity
Authors:
S. Courrech du Pont,
J. Eggers
Abstract:
In our experiment, an interface between a viscous liquid and air is deformed by a sink flow of constant flow rate to form a sharp tip. Using a microscope, the interface shape is recorded down to a tip size of 1 $\rm{μm}$. The curvature at the tip is controlled by the distance $h$ between the tip and the sink. As a critical distance $h^{\star}$ is approached, the curvature diverges like…
▽ More
In our experiment, an interface between a viscous liquid and air is deformed by a sink flow of constant flow rate to form a sharp tip. Using a microscope, the interface shape is recorded down to a tip size of 1 $\rm{μm}$. The curvature at the tip is controlled by the distance $h$ between the tip and the sink. As a critical distance $h^{\star}$ is approached, the curvature diverges like $1/(h-h^{\star})^3$ and the tip becomes cone-shaped. As the distance to the sink is decreased further, the opening angle of the cone vanishes like $h^2$. No evidence for air entrainment was found, except when the tip was inside the orifice.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2005;
originally announced December 2005.
