-
The vertical velocity skewness in the atmospheric boundary layer without buoyancy and Coriolis effects
Authors:
Elia Buono,
Gabriel Katul,
Michael Heisel,
Davide Poggi,
Cosimo Peruzzi,
Davide Vettori,
Costantino Manes
Abstract:
One of the main statistical features of near-neutral atmospheric boundary layer (ABL) turbulence is the positive vertical velocity skewness $Sk_w$ above the roughness sublayer or the buffer region in smooth-walls. The $Sk_w$ variations are receiving renewed interest in many climate-related parameterizations of the ABL given their significance to cloud formation and to testing sub-grid schemes for…
▽ More
One of the main statistical features of near-neutral atmospheric boundary layer (ABL) turbulence is the positive vertical velocity skewness $Sk_w$ above the roughness sublayer or the buffer region in smooth-walls. The $Sk_w$ variations are receiving renewed interest in many climate-related parameterizations of the ABL given their significance to cloud formation and to testing sub-grid schemes for Large Eddy Simulations (LES). The vertical variations of $Sk_w$ are explored here using high Reynolds number wind tunnel and flume experiments collected above smooth, rough, and permeable-walls in the absence of buoyancy and Coriolis effects. These laboratory experiments form a necessary starting point to probe the canonical structure of $Sk_w$ as they deal with a key limiting case (i.e. near-neutral conditions) that has received much less attention compared to its convective counterpart in atmospheric turbulence studies. Diagnostic models based on cumulant expansions, realizability constraints, and the now-popular constant mass flux approach routinely employed in the convective boundary layer as well as prognostic models based on third-order budgets are used to explain variations in $Sk_w$ for the idealized laboratory conditions. The failure of flux-gradient relations to model $Sk_w$ from the gradients of the vertical velocity variance $σ_w^2$ are explained and corrections based on models of energy transport offered. Novel links between the diagnostic and prognostic models are also featured, especially for the inertial term in the third order budget of the vertical velocity fluctuation. The co-spectral properties of $w'/σ_w$ versus $w'^2/σ_w^2$ are also presented for the first time to assess the dominant scales governing $Sk_w$ in the inner and outer layers, where $w'$ is the fluctuating vertical velocity and $σ_w$ is the vertical velocity standard deviation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
The vertical-velocity skewness in the inertial sublayer of turbulent wall flows
Authors:
Elia Buono,
Gabriel Katul,
Michael Heisel,
Davide Vettori,
Davide Poggi,
Cosimo Peruzzi,
Costantino Manes
Abstract:
We provide empirical evidence that within the inertial sub layer of adiabatic turbulent flows over smooth walls, the skewness of the vertical velocity component $Sk_w$ displays universal behaviour, being constant and constrained within the range $Sk_w \approx 0.1-0.16$, regardless of flow configuration and Reynolds number. A theoretical model is proposed to explain the observed behaviour, includin…
▽ More
We provide empirical evidence that within the inertial sub layer of adiabatic turbulent flows over smooth walls, the skewness of the vertical velocity component $Sk_w$ displays universal behaviour, being constant and constrained within the range $Sk_w \approx 0.1-0.16$, regardless of flow configuration and Reynolds number. A theoretical model is proposed to explain the observed behaviour, including the observed range of variations of $Sk_w$. The model clarifies why $Sk_w$ cannot be predicted from down-gradient closure approximations routinely employed in meteorological and climate models whereby $Sk_w$ impacts cloud formation and dispersion processes. The model also offers an alternative and implementable approach.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Revisiting a drag partition model for canopy-like roughness elements
Authors:
Elia Buono,
Gabriel G. Katul,
Davide Vettori,
Davide Poggi,
Costantino Manes
Abstract:
Turbulent flows over a large surface area (S) covered by n obstacles experience an overall drag due to the presence of the ground and the protruding obstacles into the flow. The drag partition between the roughness obstacles and the ground is analyzed using an analytical model proposed by Raupach (1992) and is hereafter referred to as R92. The R92 is based on the premise that the wake behind an is…
▽ More
Turbulent flows over a large surface area (S) covered by n obstacles experience an overall drag due to the presence of the ground and the protruding obstacles into the flow. The drag partition between the roughness obstacles and the ground is analyzed using an analytical model proposed by Raupach (1992) and is hereafter referred to as R92. The R92 is based on the premise that the wake behind an isolated roughness element can be described by a shelter area A and a shelter volume V. The individual sizes of A and V without any interference from other obstacles can be determined from scaling analysis for the spread of wakes. To upscale from an individual roughness element to n/S elements where wakes may interact, R92 adopted a background stress re-normalizing instead of reducing A or V with each element addition. This work shows that R92's approach only converges to a linear reduction in A and V for small n/S where wakes have low probability of interacting with one another. This probabilistic nature suggests that up-scaling from individual to multiple roughness elements can be re-formulated using stochastic averaging methods proposed here. The two approaches are shown to recover R92 under plausible conditions. Comparisons between R92 and available data on blocks and vegetation-like roughness elements confirm the practical utility of R92 and its potential use in large-scale models provided the relevant parameters accommodate certain features of the roughness element type (cube versus vegetation-like) and, to a lesser extent, their configuration throughout S.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
The advancing wave front on a sloping channel covered by a rod canopy following an instantaneous dam break
Authors:
Elia Buono,
Gabriel G. Katul,
Davide Poggi
Abstract:
The drag coefficient $C_d$ for a rigid and uniformly distributed rod canopy covering a sloping channel following the instantaneous collapse of a dam was examined using flume experiments. The measurements included space $x$ and time $t$ high resolution images of the water surface $h(x,t)$ for multiple channel bed slopes $S_o$ and water depths behind the dam $H_o$ along with drag estimates provided…
▽ More
The drag coefficient $C_d$ for a rigid and uniformly distributed rod canopy covering a sloping channel following the instantaneous collapse of a dam was examined using flume experiments. The measurements included space $x$ and time $t$ high resolution images of the water surface $h(x,t)$ for multiple channel bed slopes $S_o$ and water depths behind the dam $H_o$ along with drag estimates provided by sequential load cells. Analysis of the Saint-Venant Equation (SVE) for the front speed using the diffusive wave approximation lead to a front velocity $U_f=\sqrt{Γ_h 2 g φ_v'/(C_d m D)}$, where $Γ_h=-\partial h/\partial x$, $g$ is the gravitational acceleration, $φ_v'=1-φ_v$ is fluid volume fraction per ground area, $φ_v=m πD^2/4$ is the solid volume fraction per ground area, $m$ is the number of rods per ground area, and $D$ is the rod diameter. An inferred $C_d=0.4$ from the $h(x,t)$ data near the advancing front region, also confirmed by load cell measurements, is much reduced relative to its independently measured steady-uniform flow case. This finding suggests that drag reduction mechanisms associated with transients and flow disturbances are more likely to play a dominant role when compared to conventional sheltering or blocking effects on $C_d$ examined in uniform flow. The increased air volume entrained into the advancing wave front region as determined from an inflow-outflow volume balance partly explains the $C_d$ reduction from unity.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
