-
Quantitative analysis of thin metal powder layers via transmission X-ray imaging and discrete element simulation: Blade-based spreading approaches
Authors:
Ryan W. Penny,
Daniel Oropeza,
Patrick M. Praegla,
Reimar Weissbach,
Christoph Meier,
Wolfgang A. Wall,
A. John Hart
Abstract:
Spreading uniform and dense layers is of paramount importance to creating high-quality components using powder bed additive manufacturing (AM). Blade-like tools are often employed for spreading powder metal feedstocks, especially in laser powder bed fusion and electron beam melting, where powders are characterized by a D50 of 30 microns or greater. Along with variations in boundary conditions intr…
▽ More
Spreading uniform and dense layers is of paramount importance to creating high-quality components using powder bed additive manufacturing (AM). Blade-like tools are often employed for spreading powder metal feedstocks, especially in laser powder bed fusion and electron beam melting, where powders are characterized by a D50 of 30 microns or greater. Along with variations in boundary conditions introduced by the layer-wise geometry and surface topography of the printed component, stochastic interactions between the spreading tool and powder result in spatial variations of layer quality that are still not well understood. Here, to study powder spreading under conditions representative of powder bed AM, we employ a modular, mechanized apparatus to create powder layers from moderately and highly cohesive powders with a selection of blade-like spreading tools. Powder layer effective depth is spatially mapped using transmission X-ray imaging, and uniformity is quantified via a statistical approach. We first compare layer density, or the effective depth of powder layer, and show that blade geometries with a curved profile lead to increased material deposition. Second, this approach enables quantification of local fluctuations, or layer defect severity. For example, we observe that the primary benefit of a V-shaped rubber blade, as compared to a 45 degree rigid blade, lies in enabling local deflection of the blade edge to eliminate streaking from large particles, while also increasing deposition. Additionally, we employ a custom DEM simulation to elucidate the opposing roles of particle density and surface energy with a pseudo-material approach, where the balance of inertial and cohesive forces determine macro-scale powder flowability. For specific alloy densities, we find a critical surface energy beyond which layer density is greatly impaired when powder spreading is performed using a blade.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Quantitative analysis of thin metal powder layers via transmission X-ray imaging and discrete element simulation: Roller-based spreading approaches
Authors:
Ryan W. Penny,
Daniel Oropeza,
Reimar Weissbach,
Patrick M. Praegla,
Christoph Meier,
Wolfgang A. Wall,
A. John Hart
Abstract:
A variety of tools can be used for spreading metal, ceramic, and polymer feedstocks in powder bed additive manufacturing methods. Rollers are often employed when spreading powders with limited flowability, as arises in powders comprising fine particle sizes or high surface energy materials. Here, we study roller-based powder spreading for powder bed AM using the unique combination of a purpose-bui…
▽ More
A variety of tools can be used for spreading metal, ceramic, and polymer feedstocks in powder bed additive manufacturing methods. Rollers are often employed when spreading powders with limited flowability, as arises in powders comprising fine particle sizes or high surface energy materials. Here, we study roller-based powder spreading for powder bed AM using the unique combination of a purpose-built powder spreading testbed with a proven method for X-ray mapping of powder layer depth. We focus on the density and uniformity of nominally 100 micrometer thick layers of roller-spread Ti-6Al-4V and Al-10Si-Mg powders. Our results indicate that when rotation is too rapid, roller-applied shear force impedes the creation of dense and uniform layers from powders of high innate flowability, or where inertial forces driven by particle density dominate cohesive forces. Roller counter-rotation augments the uniformity of cohesive powder layers, primarily though reducing the influence of particle clusters in the flowing powder, which are otherwise shown to cause deep, trench-like streaks. Companion discrete element method (DEM) simulations further contextualize the experiments through isolation of the effects of cohesion on layer attributes. Results suggest that roller motion parameters could apply a strategic level of additional shear force to the flowing powder, thereby mitigating the clumping behavior characteristic of highly cohesive feedstocks while maintaining high layer uniformity.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Spatial Mapping of Powder Layer Density for Metal Additive Manufacturing via X-ray Microscopy
Authors:
Ryan W. Penny,
Patrick M. Praegla,
Marvin Ochsenius,
Daniel Oropeza,
Christoph Meier,
Wolfgang A. Wall,
A. John Hart
Abstract:
Uniform powder spreading is a requisite for creating consistent, high-quality components via powder bed additive manufacturing (AM), wherein layer density and uniformity are complex functions of powder characteristics, spreading kinematics, and mechanical boundary conditions. High spatial variation in particle packing density, driven by the stochastic nature of the spreading process, impedes optic…
▽ More
Uniform powder spreading is a requisite for creating consistent, high-quality components via powder bed additive manufacturing (AM), wherein layer density and uniformity are complex functions of powder characteristics, spreading kinematics, and mechanical boundary conditions. High spatial variation in particle packing density, driven by the stochastic nature of the spreading process, impedes optical interrogation of these layer attributes. Thus, we present transmission X-ray imaging as a method for directly mapping the effective depth of powder layers at process-relevant scale and resolution. Specifically, we study layers of nominal 50-250 micrometer thickness, created by spreading a selection of commercially obtained Ti-6Al-4V, 316 SS, and Al-10Si-Mg powders into precision-depth templates. We find that powder layer packing fraction may be predicted from a combination of the relative thickness of the layer as compared to mean particle size, and flowability assessed by macroscale powder angle of repose. Power spectral density analysis is introduced as a tool for quantification of defect severity as a function of morphology, and enables separate consideration of layer uniformity and sparsity. Finally, spreading is studied using multi-layer templates, providing insight into how particles interact with both previously deposited material and abrupt changes in boundary condition. Experimental results are additionally compared to a purpose-built discrete element method (DEM) powder spreading simulation framework, clarifying the competing role of adhesive and gravitational forces in layer uniformity and density, as well as particle motion within the powder bed during spreading.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.