-
Mechanisms and timing of carbonaceous chondrite delivery to the Earth
Authors:
Francis Nimmo,
Thorsten Kleine,
Alessandro Morbidelli,
David Nesvorny
Abstract:
The nucleosynthetic isotope signatures of meteorites and the bulk silicate Earth (BSE) indicate that Earth consists of a mixture of "carbonaceous" (CC) and "non-carbonaceous" (NC) materials. We show that the fration of CC material recorded in the isotopic composition of the BSE varies for different elements, and depends on the element's tendency to partition into metal and its volatility. The obse…
▽ More
The nucleosynthetic isotope signatures of meteorites and the bulk silicate Earth (BSE) indicate that Earth consists of a mixture of "carbonaceous" (CC) and "non-carbonaceous" (NC) materials. We show that the fration of CC material recorded in the isotopic composition of the BSE varies for different elements, and depends on the element's tendency to partition into metal and its volatility. The observed behaviour indicates that the majority of material accreted to the Earth was NC-dominated, but that CC-dominated material enriched in moderately-volatile elements by a factor of ~10 was delivered during the last ~2-10% of Earth's acccretion. The late delivery of CC material to Earth contrasts with dynamical evidence for the early implantation of CC objects into the inner solar system during the growth and migration of the giant planets. This, together with the NC-dominated nature of both Earth's late veneer and bulk Mars, suggests that material scattered inwards had the bulk of its mass concentrated in a few, large CC embryos rather than in smaller planetesimals. We propose that Earth accreted a few of these CC embryos while Mars did not, and that at least one of the CC embryos impacted Earth relatively late (when accretion was 90-90% complete). This scenario is consistent with the subsequent Moon-formign impact of a large NC body, as long as this impact did not re-homogenize the entire Earth's mantle.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Comparing NASA Discovery and New Frontiers Class Mission Concepts for the Io Volcano Observer (IVO)
Authors:
Christopher W. Hamilton,
Alfred S. McEwen,
Laszlo Keszthelyi,
Lynn M. Carter,
Ashley G. Davies,
Katherine de Kleer,
Kandis Lea Jessup,
Xianzhe Jia,
James T. Keane,
Kathleen Mandt,
Francis Nimmo,
Chris Paranicas,
Ryan S. Park,
Jason E. Perry,
Anne Pommier,
Jani Radebaugh,
Sarah S. Sutton,
Audrey Vorburger,
Peter Wurz,
Cauê Borlina,
Amanda F. Haapala,
Daniella N. DellaGiustina,
Brett W. Denevi,
Sarah M. Hörst,
Sascha Kempf
, et al. (9 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Jupiter's moon Io is a highly compelling target for future exploration that offers critical insight into tidal dissipation processes and the geology of high heat flux worlds, including primitive planetary bodies, such as the early Earth, that are shaped by enhanced rates of volcanism. Io is also important for understanding the development of volcanogenic atmospheres and mass-exchange within the Ju…
▽ More
Jupiter's moon Io is a highly compelling target for future exploration that offers critical insight into tidal dissipation processes and the geology of high heat flux worlds, including primitive planetary bodies, such as the early Earth, that are shaped by enhanced rates of volcanism. Io is also important for understanding the development of volcanogenic atmospheres and mass-exchange within the Jupiter System. However, fundamental questions remain about the state of Io's interior, surface, and atmosphere, as well as its role in the evolution of the Galilean satellites. The Io Volcano Observer (IVO) would address these questions by achieving the following three key goals: (A) Determine how and where tidal heat is generated inside Io; (B) Understand how tidal heat is transported to the surface of Io; and (C) Understand how Io is evolving. IVO was selected for Phase A study through the NASA Discovery program in 2020 and, in anticipation of a New Frontiers 5 opportunity, an enhanced IVO-NF mission concept was advanced that would increase the Baseline mission from 10 flybys to 20, with an improved radiation design; employ a Ka-band communications to double IVO's total data downlink; add a wide angle camera for color and stereo mapping; add a dust mass spectrometer; and lower the altitude of later flybys to enable new science. This study compares and contrasts the mission architecture, instrument suite, and science objectives for Discovery (IVO) and New Frontiers (IVO-NF) missions to Io, and advocates for continued prioritization of Io as an exploration target for New Frontiers.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Tidal dissipation of binaries in asteroid pairs
Authors:
Laurent Pou,
Francis Nimmo
Abstract:
Tidal dissipation in a celestial body can be used to probe its internal structure. Tides govern the orbital evolution of binary systems and therefore constraints on the interior of binary system members can be derived by knowing the age and tidal state of the binary system. For asteroids, age estimates are challenging due to a lack of direct observation of their surface. However, the age of astero…
▽ More
Tidal dissipation in a celestial body can be used to probe its internal structure. Tides govern the orbital evolution of binary systems and therefore constraints on the interior of binary system members can be derived by knowing the age and tidal state of the binary system. For asteroids, age estimates are challenging due to a lack of direct observation of their surface. However, the age of asteroid pairs formed by rotational fission of a parent body can be derived from dynamical modeling, and as such can be used to constrain the age of binary systems existing within asteroid pairs.We study 13 binary asteroid systems existing in asteroid pairs by modeling their tidal locking and eccentricity damping timescales from tidal dissipation in the primaries and secondaries. We consider the impact of thermal torques on these timescales from the YORP and BYORP effects. The resulting constraints on the tidal dissipation ratio Q/k2 are compared to monolithic and rubble pile asteroid theories, showing that all secondaries are consistent with rubble piles with regolith layers greater than 3m and suggest that Q/k2 for rubble piles increases with radius. A particular case is the first bound secondary of asteroid (3749) Balam, whose Q/k2 is constrained to be between 2.7x10^4 and 1.4x10^6, consistent with a rubble-pile with a regolith thickness between 30m and 100m.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Resonant stratification in Titan's global ocean
Authors:
Benjamin Idini,
Francis Nimmo
Abstract:
Titan's ice shell floats on top of a global ocean revealed by the large tidal Love number $k_2 = 0.616\pm0.067$ registered by Cassini. The Cassini observation exceeds the predicted $k_2$ by one order of magnitude in the absence of an ocean, and is 3-$σ$ away from the predicted $k_2$ if the ocean is pure water resting on top of a rigid ocean floor. Previous studies demonstrate that an ocean heavily…
▽ More
Titan's ice shell floats on top of a global ocean revealed by the large tidal Love number $k_2 = 0.616\pm0.067$ registered by Cassini. The Cassini observation exceeds the predicted $k_2$ by one order of magnitude in the absence of an ocean, and is 3-$σ$ away from the predicted $k_2$ if the ocean is pure water resting on top of a rigid ocean floor. Previous studies demonstrate that an ocean heavily enriched in salts (salinity $S\gtrsim200$ g/kg) can explain the 3-$σ$ signal in $k_2$. Here we revisit previous interpretations of Titan's large $k_2$ using simple physical arguments and propose a new interpretation based on the dynamic tidal response of a stably stratified ocean in resonance with eccentricity tides raised by Saturn. Our models include inertial effects from a full consideration of the Coriolis force and the radial stratification of the ocean, typically neglected or approximated elsewhere. The stratification of the ocean emerges from a salinity profile where salt concentration linearly increases with depth. We find multiple salinity profiles that lead to the $k_2$ required by Cassini. In contrast with previous interpretations that neglect stratification, resonant stratification reduces the bulk salinity required by observations by an order of magnitude, reaching a salinity for Titan's ocean that is compatible with that of Earth's oceans and close to Enceladus' plumes. Consequently, no special process is required to enrich Titan's ocean to a high salinity as previously suggested.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
A mushy source for the geysers of Enceladus
Authors:
Colin R. Meyer,
Jacob J. Buffo,
Francis Nimmo,
Andrew J. Wells,
Samuel Boury,
Tara C. Tomlinson,
Jamie R. G. Parkinson,
Geoffrey M. Vasil
Abstract:
Enceladus is a primary target for astrobiology due to the $\rm H_2O$ plume ejecta measured by the Cassini spacecraft and the inferred subsurface ocean sustained by tidal heating. Sourcing the plumes via a direct connection from the ocean to the surface requires a fracture through the entire ice shell ($\sim$10 km). Here we explore an alternative mechanism in which shear heating within shallower ti…
▽ More
Enceladus is a primary target for astrobiology due to the $\rm H_2O$ plume ejecta measured by the Cassini spacecraft and the inferred subsurface ocean sustained by tidal heating. Sourcing the plumes via a direct connection from the ocean to the surface requires a fracture through the entire ice shell ($\sim$10 km). Here we explore an alternative mechanism in which shear heating within shallower tiger stripe fractures produces partial melting in the ice shell and interstitial convection allows fluid to be ejected as geysers. We use an idealized two-dimensional multiphase reactive transport model to simulate the thermomechanics of a mushy region generated by an upper bound estimate for the localized shear heating rate in a salty ice shell. From our simulations, we predict the temperature, porosity, salt content, melting rate, and liquid volume of an intrashell mushy zone surrounding a fracture. We find that the rate of internal melting can match the observed $\rm H_2O$ eruption rate and that there is sufficient brine volume within the mushy zone to sustain the geysers for $\sim350$ kyr without additional melting. The composition of the liquid brine is, however, distinct from that of the ocean, due to partial melting. This shear heating mechanism for geyser formation applies to Enceladus and other icy moons and has implications for our understanding of the geophysical processes and astrobiological potential of icy satellites.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2023; v1 submitted 13 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
An Investigation of Libration Heating and the Thermal State of Enceladus's Ice Shell
Authors:
Wencheng D. Shao,
Francis Nimmo
Abstract:
Tidal dissipation is thought to be responsible for the observed high heat loss on Enceladus. Forced librations can enhance tidal dissipation in the ice shell, but how such librations affect the thermal state of Enceladus has not been investigated. Here we investigate the heating effect of forced librations using the model of Van Hoolst et al. (2013), which includes the elasticity of the ice shell.…
▽ More
Tidal dissipation is thought to be responsible for the observed high heat loss on Enceladus. Forced librations can enhance tidal dissipation in the ice shell, but how such librations affect the thermal state of Enceladus has not been investigated. Here we investigate the heating effect of forced librations using the model of Van Hoolst et al. (2013), which includes the elasticity of the ice shell. We find that libration heating in the ice shell is insufficient to match the inferred conductive heat loss of Enceladus. This suggests that either Enceladus is not in a thermal steady state, or additional heating mechanisms beneath the ice shell are contributing the bulk of the power. In the presence of such an additional heat source, Enceladus resides in a stable thermal equilibrium, resisting small perturbations to the shell thickness. Our results do not support the occurrence of a runaway melting process proposed by Luan and Goldreich (2017). In our study, the strong dependence of conductive loss on shell thickness stabilizes the thermal state of Enceladus's ice shell. Our study implies that thermal runaway (if it occurred) or episodic heating on Enceladus is unlikely to originate from librations of the ice shell.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Nucleosynthetic Pt isotope anomalies and the Hf-W chronology of core formation in inner and outer solar system planetesimals
Authors:
Fridolin Spitzer,
Christoph Burkhardt,
Francis Nimmo,
Thorsten Kleine
Abstract:
The 182Hf-182W chronology of iron meteorites provides crucial information on the timescales of accretion and differentiation of some of the oldest planetesimals of the Solar System. Determining accurate Hf-W model ages of iron meteorites requires correction for cosmic ray expo-sure (CRE) induced modifications of W isotope compositions, which can be achieved using in-situ neutron dosimeters such as…
▽ More
The 182Hf-182W chronology of iron meteorites provides crucial information on the timescales of accretion and differentiation of some of the oldest planetesimals of the Solar System. Determining accurate Hf-W model ages of iron meteorites requires correction for cosmic ray expo-sure (CRE) induced modifications of W isotope compositions, which can be achieved using in-situ neutron dosimeters such as Pt isotopes. Until now it has been assumed that all Pt isotope variations in meteorites reflect CRE, but here we show that some ungrouped iron meteorites display small nucleosynthetic Pt isotope anomalies. These provide the most appropriate starting composition for the correction of CRE-induced W isotope variations in iron meteorites from all major chemical groups, which leads to a ~1 Ma upward revision of previously reported Hf-W model ages. The revised ages indicate that core formation in non-carbonaceous (NC) iron meteorite parent bodies occurred at ~1-2 Ma after CAI formation, whereas most carbonaceous (CC) iron meteorite parent bodies underwent core formation ~2 Ma later. We show that the younger CC cores have lower Fe/Ni ratios than the earlier-formed NC cores, indicating that core formation under more oxidizing conditions occurred over a more protracted timescale. Thermal modeling of planetesimals heated by 26Al-decay reveals that this protracted core formation timescale is consistent with a higher fraction of water ice in CC compared to NC planetesimals, implying that in spite of distinct core formation timescales, NC and CC iron meteorite parent bodies accreted about contemporaneously within ~1 Ma after CAI formation, but at different radial locations in the disk.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
A Recipe for Geophysical Exploration of Enceladus
Authors:
Anton I. Ermakov,
Ryan S. Park,
Javier Roa,
Julie C. Castillo-Rogez,
James T. Keane,
Francis Nimmo,
Edwin S. Kite,
Christophe Sotin,
T. Joseph W. Lazio,
Gregor Steinbrügge,
Samuel M. Howell,
Bruce G. Bills,
Douglas J. Hemingway,
Vishnu Viswanathan,
Gabriel Tobie,
Valery Lainey
Abstract:
Orbital geophysical investigations of Enceladus are critical to understanding its energy balance. We identified key science questions for the geophysical exploration of Enceladus, answering which would support future assessment of Enceladus' astrobiological potential. Using a Bayesian framework, we explored how science requirements map to measurement requirements. We performed mission simulations…
▽ More
Orbital geophysical investigations of Enceladus are critical to understanding its energy balance. We identified key science questions for the geophysical exploration of Enceladus, answering which would support future assessment of Enceladus' astrobiological potential. Using a Bayesian framework, we explored how science requirements map to measurement requirements. We performed mission simulations to study the sensitivity of a single spacecraft and dual spacecraft configurations to static gravity and tidal Love numbers of Enceladus. We find that mapping Enceladus' gravity field, improving the accuracy of the physical libration amplitude, and measuring Enceladus' tidal response would provide critical constraints on the internal structure, and establish a framework for assessing Enceladus' long-term habitability. This kind of investigation could be carried out as part of a life search mission at little additional resource requirements.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2021; v1 submitted 6 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Modeling glacial flow on and onto Pluto's Sputnik Planitia
Authors:
O. M. Umurhan,
A. D. Howard,
J. M. Moore,
A. M. Earle,
R. P. Binzel,
S. A. Stern,
P. M. Schenk,
R. A. Beyer,
O. L. White,
F. NImmo,
W. B. McKinnon,
K. Ennico,
C. B. Olkin,
H. A. Weaver,
L. A. Young
Abstract:
Observations of Pluto's surface made by the New Horizons spacecraft indicates present-day nitrogen ice glaciation in and around the basin known as Sputnik Planum. Motivated by these observations, we have developed an evolutionary glacial flow model of solid nitrogen ice taking into account its published thermophysical and rheologies properties. This model assumes that glacial ice layers flow lamin…
▽ More
Observations of Pluto's surface made by the New Horizons spacecraft indicates present-day nitrogen ice glaciation in and around the basin known as Sputnik Planum. Motivated by these observations, we have developed an evolutionary glacial flow model of solid nitrogen ice taking into account its published thermophysical and rheologies properties. This model assumes that glacial ice layers flow laminarly and have low aspect ratios which permits a vertically integrated mathematical formulation. We assess the conditions for the validity of laminar nitrogen ice motion by revisiting the problem of the onset of solid-state buoyant convection of nitrogen ice for a variety of bottom thermal boundary conditions. Subject to uncertainties in nitrogen ice rheology, nitrogen ice layers are estimated to flow laminarly for thicknesses less than 400-1000 meters. The resulting mass-flux formulation for when the nitrogen ice flows as a laminar dry glacier is characterized by an Arrhenius-Glen functional form. The flow model developed is used here to qualitatively answer some questions motivated by observed glacial flow features found on Sputnik Planum. We find that the wavy transverse dark features found along the northern shoreline of Sputnik Planum may be a transitory imprint of shallow topography just beneath the ice surface suggesting the possibility that a major shoreward flow event happened relatively recently within the last few hundred years. Model results also support the interpretation that the prominent darkened features resembling flow lobes observed along the eastern shoreline of the Sputnik Planum basin may be a result of wet nitrogen glacial ice flowing into the basin from the pitted highlands of eastern Tombaugh Regio.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2018; v1 submitted 18 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
