-
Historical synthesis supporting Duhem's demonstration of the impossibility of the `experimentum crucis' of comparison of the speed of light in air and water
Authors:
Olivier Morizot
Abstract:
In 1850, Foucault was the first to compare experimentally the velocity of light in air to its velocity in water. And as the wave and projectile theories competing at the time predicted inverse results to such a measurement, Foucault ''declared the emission system incompatible with the reality of the facts''. Yet, in his Physical Theory, Duhem uses this very example to illustrate his epistemologica…
▽ More
In 1850, Foucault was the first to compare experimentally the velocity of light in air to its velocity in water. And as the wave and projectile theories competing at the time predicted inverse results to such a measurement, Foucault ''declared the emission system incompatible with the reality of the facts''. Yet, in his Physical Theory, Duhem uses this very example to illustrate his epistemological demonstration of the impossibility of the 'experimentum crucis' in physics. Then, the ambition of the present article is to augment Duhem's demonstration with historical evidence relating precisely to the question of the speed of light in water. We will review the four major opinions on the nature of light developed between 1637 and 1801; all leading to theories concluding that the ratio of sines is constant and equal to the ratio of the velocities in the two media, but all being defended by at least two authors concluding to inverse ratios of those velocities -- and thus to opposite predictions on the result of an experiment such as Foucault's. The convergence of historical evidence will then confirm that the nature of light, considered in isolation, is in no way constrained by the measurement of its speed in water.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
David Brewster's and William Herschel's experiments on inflection that delivered the coup de gr{â}ce to Thomas Young's ether distribution hypothesis
Authors:
Olivier Morizot
Abstract:
In his Theory of Light and Colours, presented to the Royal Society in November 1801, Thomas Young defended a mechanical explanation of the coloured fringes observed outside of the shadow of an opaque object-the so-called 'colours by inflection'-that was based on the hypothesis of an ethereal density gradient surrounding all material bodies. However, two years later, he publicly rejected that hypot…
▽ More
In his Theory of Light and Colours, presented to the Royal Society in November 1801, Thomas Young defended a mechanical explanation of the coloured fringes observed outside of the shadow of an opaque object-the so-called 'colours by inflection'-that was based on the hypothesis of an ethereal density gradient surrounding all material bodies. However, two years later, he publicly rejected that hypothesis, without giving much detail on his reasons. Now, although Geoffrey Cantor demonstrated the crucial role of mechanical and astronomical arguments in explaining the withdrawal of this fundamental hypothesis long ago, the purpose of this article is to draw deeper attention on a set of experiments performed by David Brewster on the inflection of light, described in a letter he addressed to the Royal Society in January 1802, but which kept retained in the hands of William Herschel and never reached its original destination. For the hypothesis that will be evaluated here is that these unpublished experiments of Brewster's were eventually known to Young through the mediation of William Herschel, and eventually played a significant role in his rejection of his own ether distribution hypothesis too.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Traduction commmentée en francais de La Conférence Bakerienne sur la Théorie de la Lumière et des Couleurs de Thomas Young
Authors:
Olivier Morizot
Abstract:
On November 12, 1802, Thomas Young lays down in front of the Royal Society of London his Theory of Light and Colours. In this text, he defends a vibratory model or light, in which the peculiar attention he gives to the consequence of the crossing of two light beams allows him to formulate the first version of the interference principle. And to deduce out of it the first correct justification of th…
▽ More
On November 12, 1802, Thomas Young lays down in front of the Royal Society of London his Theory of Light and Colours. In this text, he defends a vibratory model or light, in which the peculiar attention he gives to the consequence of the crossing of two light beams allows him to formulate the first version of the interference principle. And to deduce out of it the first correct justification of the colours of thin plates, from which he computes the very first series of measurements of the wavelength of light ; a concept he introduces for the very occasion. Based on this same principle, he presents the first experience of diffraction from a grating, allowing him to anticipate the reason of the origin of the colours of certain insects and butterflies. Finally, the defense of this vibratory model is also the occasion for him to elaborate the visionary hypothesis of the triple structure of the photoreceptors of the retina involved in colour vision. The very high density of concepts and innovative results embedded in this short text justifies by itself the interest of bringing a translated and commented version of it at the disposal of the French audience.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2021;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Traduction commentée en français de la Conférence Bakerienne Sur le Mécanisme de l'Oeil de Thomas Young (1800)
Authors:
Olivier Morizot
Abstract:
On November 27, 1800, Thomas Young presents for the second time to the Royal Society of London his theory of the musclurity of the crystalline lens, as being the cause of the accommodation of the eye to different distances. This question had indeed been the topic of his very first communication to the Royal Society seven years earlier; from which he had been forced to withdraw in the meanwhile by…
▽ More
On November 27, 1800, Thomas Young presents for the second time to the Royal Society of London his theory of the musclurity of the crystalline lens, as being the cause of the accommodation of the eye to different distances. This question had indeed been the topic of his very first communication to the Royal Society seven years earlier; from which he had been forced to withdraw in the meanwhile by a series of articles claiming either the priority on his discovery, or the demonstration of it being erroneous. Seven years later, Young turns back to the topic with a very strongly elaborated text indeniably proving the role of the crystalline in accommodation, as well as offering a new and convenient method for measuring the amplitude of accommodation, discovering the default of astigmatism of the eye, and setting the most precise and complete measurement of the living eye of its time. For these reasons, and for the tight intellectual connections between this text and the Theory of Light and Colours Thomas Young will publish a year later, we thought it important to bring a translation and commentary of this text at the disposal of the French audience.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2021;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Noise characterization of an Optical Frequency Comb using Offline Cross-Correlation
Authors:
Ramin Khayatzadeh,
Mathieu Collombon,
Didier Guyomarc'h,
Didier Ferrand,
Gaëtan Hagel,
Marie Houssin,
Olivier Morizot,
Caroline Champenois,
Martina Knoop
Abstract:
Using an offline cross-correlation technique, we have analyzed the noise behavior of a new type of optical frequency comb (OFC), which is carrier envelope offset (CEO) free by configuration, due to difference frequency generation. In order to evaluate the instrument's ultimate noise floor, the phase and amplitude noise of a stabilized OFC are measured simultaneously using two analog-to-digital con…
▽ More
Using an offline cross-correlation technique, we have analyzed the noise behavior of a new type of optical frequency comb (OFC), which is carrier envelope offset (CEO) free by configuration, due to difference frequency generation. In order to evaluate the instrument's ultimate noise floor, the phase and amplitude noise of a stabilized OFC are measured simultaneously using two analog-to-digital converters. Carrier recovery and phase detection are done by post-processing, eliminating the need for external phase-locked loops and complex calibration techniques. In order to adapt the measurement noise floor and the number of averages used in cross correlation, an adaptive frequency resolution for noise measurement is applied. Phase noise results are in excellent agreement with measurements of the fluctuations of the repetition frequency of the OFC obtained from optical signal.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Coherent internal state transfer by three-photon STIRAP-like scheme for many-atom samples
Authors:
Marius Romuald Kamsap,
Thierry Blanchard Ekogo,
Jofre Pedregosa-Gutierrez,
Gaetan Hagel,
Marie Houssin,
Olivier Morizot,
Martina Knoop,
Caroline Champenois
Abstract:
A STIRAP-like scheme is proposed to exploit a three-photon resonance taking place in alkaline-earth-metal ions. This scheme is designed for state transfer between the two fine structure components of the metastable D-state which are two excited states that can serve as optical or THz qu-bit. The advantage of a coherent three-photon process compared to two-photon STIRAP lies in the possibility of e…
▽ More
A STIRAP-like scheme is proposed to exploit a three-photon resonance taking place in alkaline-earth-metal ions. This scheme is designed for state transfer between the two fine structure components of the metastable D-state which are two excited states that can serve as optical or THz qu-bit. The advantage of a coherent three-photon process compared to two-photon STIRAP lies in the possibility of exact cancellation of the first order Doppler shift which opens the way for an application to a sample composed of many ions. The transfer efficiency and its dependence with experimental parameters are analyzed by numerical simulations. This efficiency is shown to reach a fidelity as high as $(1-8.10^{-5})$ with realistic parameters. The scheme is also extended to the synthesis of a linear combination of three stable or metastable states.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
A modern Fizeau experiment for education and outreach purposes
Authors:
Olivier Morizot,
Adrien Sellé,
Sandrine Ferri,
Didier Guyomarc'H,
Jean-Marie Laugier,
Martina Knoop
Abstract:
On the occasion of the laser's 50th anniversary, we performed a modern Fizeau experiment, measuring the speed of light with a laser beam passing over the city centre of Marseille. For a round trip distance of almost five kilometers, the measurement has reached an uncertainty of about 10$^{-4}$, mainly due to atmospheric fluctuations. We present the experimental and pedagogical challenges of this b…
▽ More
On the occasion of the laser's 50th anniversary, we performed a modern Fizeau experiment, measuring the speed of light with a laser beam passing over the city centre of Marseille. For a round trip distance of almost five kilometers, the measurement has reached an uncertainty of about 10$^{-4}$, mainly due to atmospheric fluctuations. We present the experimental and pedagogical challenges of this brilliant outreach experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Photoassociative ionization of Na inside a storage ring
Authors:
R. Paiva,
R. Muhammad,
R. Shiozaki,
A. L. de Oliveira,
O. Morizot,
V. S. Bagnato,
K. M. F. Magalhães
Abstract:
Motivated by recent interest in low dimensional arrays of atoms, we experimentally investigated the way cold collisional processes are affected by the geometry of the considered atomic sample. More specifically, we studied the case of photoassociative ionization (PAI) both in a storage ring where collision is more unidirectional in character and in a trap with clear undefinition of collision axis.…
▽ More
Motivated by recent interest in low dimensional arrays of atoms, we experimentally investigated the way cold collisional processes are affected by the geometry of the considered atomic sample. More specifically, we studied the case of photoassociative ionization (PAI) both in a storage ring where collision is more unidirectional in character and in a trap with clear undefinition of collision axis. First, creating a ring shaped trap (atomotron) we investigated two-color PAI dependence with intensity and polarization of a probing laser. The intensity dependence of the PAI rate was also measured in a magneto-optical trap presenting equivalent temperature and density conditions. Indeed, the results show that in the ring trap, the value of the PAI rate constant is much lower and does not show evidences of saturation, unlike in the case of the 3D-MOT. Cold atomic collisions in storage ring may represent new possibilities for study.
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2011; v1 submitted 31 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
-
Influence of the Radio-Frequency source properties on RF-based atom traps
Authors:
Olivier Morizot,
Laurent Longchambon,
Raghavan Kollengode Easwaran,
Romain Dubessy,
Elena Knyazchyan,
Paul-Eric Pottie,
Vincent Lorent,
Hélène Perrin
Abstract:
We discuss the quality required for the RF source used to trap neutral atoms in RF-dressed potentials. We illustrate this discussion with experimental results obtained on a Bose-Einstein condensation experiment with different RF sources.
We discuss the quality required for the RF source used to trap neutral atoms in RF-dressed potentials. We illustrate this discussion with experimental results obtained on a Bose-Einstein condensation experiment with different RF sources.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
-
Trapping and cooling of rf-dressed atoms in a quadrupole magnetic field
Authors:
Olivier Morizot,
Carlos L. Garrido Alzar,
Paul-Eric Pottie,
Vincent Lorent,
Hélène Perrin
Abstract:
We observe the spontaneous evaporation of atoms confined in a bubble-like rf-dressed trap (Zobay and Garraway, 2001). The atoms are confined in a quadrupole magnetic trap and are dressed by a linearly polarized rf field. The evaporation is related to the presence of holes in the trap, at the positions where the rf coupling vanishes, due to its vectorial character. The final temperature results f…
▽ More
We observe the spontaneous evaporation of atoms confined in a bubble-like rf-dressed trap (Zobay and Garraway, 2001). The atoms are confined in a quadrupole magnetic trap and are dressed by a linearly polarized rf field. The evaporation is related to the presence of holes in the trap, at the positions where the rf coupling vanishes, due to its vectorial character. The final temperature results from a competition between residual heating and evaporation efficiency, which is controlled via the height of the holes with respect to the bottom of the trap. The experimental data are modeled by a Monte-Carlo simulation predicting a small increase in phase space density limited by the heating rate. This increase was within the phase space density determination uncertainty of the experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2007;
originally announced September 2007.
-
Agile low phase noise radio-frequency sine wave generator applied to experiments on ultracold atoms
Authors:
Olivier Morizot,
Julien De Lapeyre De Bellair,
Fabrice Wiotte,
Olivier Lopez,
Paul-Eric Pottie,
Hélène Perrin
Abstract:
We report on the frequency performance of a low cost (~500$) radio-frequency sine wave generator, using direct digital synthesis (DDS) and a field-programmable gate array (FPGA). The output frequency of the device may be changed dynamically to any arbitrary value ranging from DC to 10 MHz without any phase slip. Sampling effects are substantially reduced by a high sample rate, up to 1 MHz, and b…
▽ More
We report on the frequency performance of a low cost (~500$) radio-frequency sine wave generator, using direct digital synthesis (DDS) and a field-programmable gate array (FPGA). The output frequency of the device may be changed dynamically to any arbitrary value ranging from DC to 10 MHz without any phase slip. Sampling effects are substantially reduced by a high sample rate, up to 1 MHz, and by a large memory length, more than 2.10^5 samples. By using a low noise external oscillator to clock the DDS, we demonstrate a phase noise as low as that of the master clock, that is at the level of -113 dB.rad^2/Hz at 1 Hz from the carrier for an output frequency of 3.75 MHz. The device is successfully used to confine an ultracold atomic cloud of rubidium 87 in a RF-based trap, and there is no extra heating from the RF source.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2007;
originally announced April 2007.
-
A ring trap for ultracold atoms
Authors:
Olivier Morizot,
Yves Colombe,
Vincent Lorent,
Hélène Perrin,
Barry M. Garraway
Abstract:
We propose a new kind of toroidal trap, designed for ultracold atoms. It relies on a combination of a magnetic trap for rf-dressed atoms, which creates a bubble-like trap, and a standing wave of light. This new trap is well suited for investigating questions of low dimensionality in a ring potential. We study the trap characteristics for a set of experimentally accessible parameters. A loading p…
▽ More
We propose a new kind of toroidal trap, designed for ultracold atoms. It relies on a combination of a magnetic trap for rf-dressed atoms, which creates a bubble-like trap, and a standing wave of light. This new trap is well suited for investigating questions of low dimensionality in a ring potential. We study the trap characteristics for a set of experimentally accessible parameters. A loading procedure from a conventional magnetic trap is also proposed. The flexible nature of this new ring trap, including an adjustable radius and adjustable transverse oscillation frequencies, will allow the study of superfluidity in variable geometries and dimensionalities.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2006; v1 submitted 2 December, 2005;
originally announced December 2005.
