-
Rescaled Equations for Well-Conditioned Direct Numerical Simulations of Rapidly Rotating Convection
Authors:
Keith Julien,
Adrian van Kan,
Benjamin Miquel,
Edgar Knobloch,
Geoffrey Vasil
Abstract:
Convection is a ubiquitous process driving geophysical/astrophysical fluid flows, which are typically strongly constrained by planetary rotation on large scales. A celebrated model of such flows, rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection, has been extensively studied in direct numerical simulations (DNS) and laboratory experiments, but the parameter values attainable by state-of-the-art methods…
▽ More
Convection is a ubiquitous process driving geophysical/astrophysical fluid flows, which are typically strongly constrained by planetary rotation on large scales. A celebrated model of such flows, rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection, has been extensively studied in direct numerical simulations (DNS) and laboratory experiments, but the parameter values attainable by state-of-the-art methods are limited to moderately rapid rotation (Ekman numbers $Ek\gtrsim10^{-8}$), while realistic geophysical/astrophysical $Ek$ are significantly smaller. Asymptotically reduced equations of motion, the nonhydrostatic quasi-geostrophic equations (NHQGE), describing the flow evolution in the limit $Ek\to 0$, do not apply at finite rotation rates. The geophysical/astrophysical regime of small but finite $Ek$ therefore remains currently inaccessible. Here, we introduce a new, numerically advantageous formulation of the Navier-Stokes-Boussinesq equations informed by the scalings valid for $Ek\to0$, the \textit{Rescaled Rapidly Rotating incompressible Navier-Stokes Equations} (RRRiNSE). We solve the RRRiNSE using a spectral quasi-inverse method resulting in a sparse, fast algorithm to perform efficient DNS in this previously unattainable parameter regime. We validate our results against the literature across a range of $Ek$ and demonstrate that the algorithmic approaches taken remain accurate and numerically stable at $Ek$ as low as $10^{-15}$. Like the NHQGE, the RRRiNSE derive their efficiency from adequate conditioning, eliminating spurious growing modes that otherwise induce numerical instabilities at small $Ek$. We show that the time derivative of the mean temperature is inconsequential for accurately determining the Nusselt number in the stationary state, significantly reducing the required simulation time, and demonstrate that full DNS using RRRiNSE agree with the NHQGE at very small $Ek$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2025; v1 submitted 3 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Bridging the Rossby number gap in rapidly rotating thermal convection
Authors:
Adrian van Kan,
Keith Julien,
Benjamin Miquel,
Edgar Knobloch
Abstract:
Geophysical and astrophysical fluid flows are typically driven by buoyancy and strongly constrained at large scales by planetary rotation. Rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RRRBC) provides a paradigm for experiments and direct numerical simulations (DNS) of such flows, but the accessible parameter space remains restricted to moderately fast rotation rates (Ekman numbers…
▽ More
Geophysical and astrophysical fluid flows are typically driven by buoyancy and strongly constrained at large scales by planetary rotation. Rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RRRBC) provides a paradigm for experiments and direct numerical simulations (DNS) of such flows, but the accessible parameter space remains restricted to moderately fast rotation rates (Ekman numbers $Ek \gtrsim 10^{-8}$), while realistic $Ek$ for astro-/geophysical applications are orders of magnitude smaller. On the other hand, previously derived reduced equations of motion describing the leading-order behaviour in the limit of very rapid rotation ($Ek\to 0$) cannot capture finite rotation effects, and the physically most relevant part of parameter space with small but finite $Ek$ has remained elusive. Here, we employ the rescaled incompressible Navier-Stokes equations (RiNSE) -- a reformulation of the Navier-Stokes-Boussinesq equations informed by the scalings valid for $Ek\to 0$, recently introduced by Julien et al. (2024) -- to provide full DNS of RRRBC at unprecedented rotation strengths down to $Ek=10^{-15}$ and below, revealing the disappearance of cyclone-anticyclone asymmetry at previously unattainable Ekman numbers ($Ek \approx 10^{-9}$). We also identify an overshoot in the heat transport as $Ek$ is varied at fixed $\widetilde{Ra}= Ra Ek^{4/3}$, associated with dissipation due to ageostrophic motions in the boundary layers. The simulations validate theoretical predictions based on thermal boundary layer theory for RRRBC and show that the solutions of RiNSE agree with the reduced equations at very small $Ek$. These results represent a first foray into the vast, largely unexplored parameter space of very rapidly rotating convection rendered accessible by RiNSE.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2024; v1 submitted 13 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Rapidly rotating radiatively driven convection: experimental and numerical validation of the `geostrophic turbulence' scaling predictions
Authors:
Gabriel Hadjerci,
Vincent Bouillaut,
Benjamin Miquel,
Basile Gallet
Abstract:
We experimentally and numerically characterize rapidly rotating radiatively driven thermal convection, beyond the sole heat transport measurements reported in Bouillaut et al. (2021). Based on a suite of direct numerical simulations (DNS) and additional processing of the experimental data collected by Bouillaut et al. (2021), we report the simultaneous validation of the scaling predictions of the…
▽ More
We experimentally and numerically characterize rapidly rotating radiatively driven thermal convection, beyond the sole heat transport measurements reported in Bouillaut et al. (2021). Based on a suite of direct numerical simulations (DNS) and additional processing of the experimental data collected by Bouillaut et al. (2021), we report the simultaneous validation of the scaling predictions of the `geostrophic turbulence' regime -- the diffusivity-free or `ultimate' regime of rapidly rotating convection -- for the heat transport, the temperature fluctuations, the flow speed and the flow structure. Radiatively driven convection thus appears as a versatile setup for the laboratory observation of the diffusivity-free regimes of various convective flows of geophysical and/or astrophysical interest.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2024; v1 submitted 29 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Vertical structure of buoyancy transport by ocean baroclinic turbulence
Authors:
Julie Meunier,
Benjamin Miquel,
Basile Gallet
Abstract:
Ocean mesoscale eddies enhance meridional buoyancy transport, notably in the Antarctic Circumpolar Current where they contribute to setting the deep stratification of the neighboring ocean basins. The much-needed parameterization of this buoyancy transport in global climate models requires a theory for the overall flux, but also for its vertical structure inside the fluid column. Based on the quas…
▽ More
Ocean mesoscale eddies enhance meridional buoyancy transport, notably in the Antarctic Circumpolar Current where they contribute to setting the deep stratification of the neighboring ocean basins. The much-needed parameterization of this buoyancy transport in global climate models requires a theory for the overall flux, but also for its vertical structure inside the fluid column. Based on the quasi-geostrophic dynamics of an idealized patch of ocean hosting an arbitrary vertically sheared zonal flow, we provide a quantitative prediction for the vertical structure of the buoyancy flux without adjustable parameters. The prediction agrees quantitatively with meridional flux profiles obtained through numerical simulations of an idealized patch of ocean with realistic parameter values. This work empowers modelers with an explicit and physically based expression for the vertical profile of buoyancy transport by ocean baroclinic turbulence, as opposed to the common practice of using arbitrary prescriptions for the depth-dependence of the transport coefficients.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
A direct derivation of the Gent-McWilliams/Redi diffusion tensor from quasi-geostrophic dynamics
Authors:
Julie Meunier,
Benjamin Miquel,
Basile Gallet
Abstract:
The transport induced by ocean mesoscale eddies remains unresolved in most state-of-the-art climate models and needs to be parameterized instead. The natural scale separation between the forcing and the emergent turbulent flow calls for a diffusive parameterization, where the eddy-induced fluxes are related to the large-scale gradients by a diffusion tensor. The standard parameterization scheme in…
▽ More
The transport induced by ocean mesoscale eddies remains unresolved in most state-of-the-art climate models and needs to be parameterized instead. The natural scale separation between the forcing and the emergent turbulent flow calls for a diffusive parameterization, where the eddy-induced fluxes are related to the large-scale gradients by a diffusion tensor. The standard parameterization scheme in climate modeling consists in adopting the Gent-McWilliams/Redi (GM/R) form for the diffusion tensor, initially put forward based on physical intuition and educated guesses before being put on firm analytical footing using thickness-weighted average (TWA). In the present contribution we provide a direct derivation of this diffusion tensor from the quasi-geostrophic (QG) dynamics of a horizontally homogeneous three-dimensional patch of ocean hosting a large-scale vertically-sheared zonal flow on the beta plane. While less general than the TWA approach, the present QG framework leads to rigorous constraints on the diffusion tensor. First, there is no diapycnal diffusivity arising in the QG GM/R tensor for low viscosity and small-scale diffusivities. The diffusion tensor then involves only two vertically dependent coefficients, namely the GM transport coefficient $K_{GM}(z)$ and the Redi diffusivity $K_R(z)$. Secondly, as already identified by previous authors the vertical structures of the two coefficients are related by the so-called Taylor-Bretherton relation. Finally, while the two coefficients generically differ in the interior of the water column, we show that they are equal to one another near the surface and near the bottom of the domain for low-enough dissipative coefficients. We illustrate these findings by numerically simulating the QG dynamics of a horizontally homogeneous patch of ocean hosting a vertically sheared zonal current resembling the Antarctic Circumpolar Current.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Velocity-informed upper bounds on the convective heat transport induced by internal heat sources and sinks
Authors:
Vincent Bouillaut,
Benoît Flesselles,
Benjamin Miquel,
Sébastien Aumaître,
Basile Gallet
Abstract:
Three-dimensional convection driven by internal heat sources and sinks (CISS) leads to experimental and numerical scaling-laws compatible with a mixing-length - or `ultimate' - scaling regime $Nu \sim \sqrt{Ra}$. However, asymptotic analytic solutions and idealized 2D simulations have shown that laminar flow solutions can transport heat even more efficiently, with $Nu \sim Ra$. The turbulent natur…
▽ More
Three-dimensional convection driven by internal heat sources and sinks (CISS) leads to experimental and numerical scaling-laws compatible with a mixing-length - or `ultimate' - scaling regime $Nu \sim \sqrt{Ra}$. However, asymptotic analytic solutions and idealized 2D simulations have shown that laminar flow solutions can transport heat even more efficiently, with $Nu \sim Ra$. The turbulent nature of the flow thus has a profound impact on its transport properties. In the present contribution we give this statement a precise mathematical sense. We show that the Nusselt number maximized over all solutions is bounded from above by const.$\times Ra$, before restricting attention to 'fully turbulent branches of solutions', defined as families of solutions characterized by a finite nonzero limit of the dissipation coefficient at large driving amplitude. Maximization of $Nu$ over such branches of solutions yields the better upper-bound $Nu \lesssim \sqrt{Ra}$. We then provide 3D numerical and experimental data of CISS compatible with a finite limiting value of the dissipation coefficient at large driving amplitude. It thus seems that CISS achieves the maximal heat transport scaling over fully turbulent solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Experimental observation of the geostrophic turbulence regime of rapidly rotating convection
Authors:
Vincent Bouillaut,
Benjamin Miquel,
Keith Julien,
Sébastien Aumaître,
Basile Gallet
Abstract:
The competition between turbulent convection and global rotation in planetary and stellar interiors governs the transport of heat and tracers, as well as magnetic-field generation. These objects operate in dynamical regimes ranging from weakly rotating convection to the `geostrophic turbulence' regime of rapidly rotating convection. However, the latter regime has remained elusive in the laboratory…
▽ More
The competition between turbulent convection and global rotation in planetary and stellar interiors governs the transport of heat and tracers, as well as magnetic-field generation. These objects operate in dynamical regimes ranging from weakly rotating convection to the `geostrophic turbulence' regime of rapidly rotating convection. However, the latter regime has remained elusive in the laboratory, despite a worldwide effort to design ever-taller rotating convection cells over the last decade. Building on a recent experimental approach where convection is driven radiatively, we report heat transport measurements in quantitative agreement with this scaling regime, the experimental scaling-law being validated against direct numerical simulations (DNS) of the idealized setup. The scaling exponent from both experiments and DNS agrees well with the geostrophic turbulence prediction. The prefactor of the scaling-law is greater than the one diagnosed in previous idealized numerical studies, pointing to an unexpected sensitivity of the heat transport efficiency to the precise distribution of heat sources and sinks, which greatly varies from planets to stars.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Transport and emergent stratification in the equilibrated Eady model: the vortex gas scaling regime
Authors:
Basile Gallet,
Benjamin Miquel,
Gabriel Hadjerci,
Keaton J. Burns,
Glenn R. Flierl,
Raffaele Ferrari
Abstract:
We numerically and theoretically investigate the Boussinesq Eady model, where a rapidly rotating density-stratified layer of fluid is subject to a meridional temperature gradient in thermal wind balance with a uniform vertically sheared zonal flow. Through a suite of numerical simulations, we show that the transport properties of the resulting turbulent flow are governed by quasi-geostrophic (QG)…
▽ More
We numerically and theoretically investigate the Boussinesq Eady model, where a rapidly rotating density-stratified layer of fluid is subject to a meridional temperature gradient in thermal wind balance with a uniform vertically sheared zonal flow. Through a suite of numerical simulations, we show that the transport properties of the resulting turbulent flow are governed by quasi-geostrophic (QG) dynamics in the rapidly rotating strongly stratified regime. The 'vortex gas' scaling predictions put forward in the context of the two-layer QG model carry over to this fully 3D system: the functional dependence of the meridional flux on the control parameters is the same, the two ajustable parameters entering the theory taking slightly different values. In line with the QG prediction, the meridional buoyancy flux is depth-independent. The vertical buoyancy flux is such that turbulence transports buoyancy along isopycnals, except in narrow layers near the the top and bottom boundaries, the thickness of which decreases as the diffusivities go to zero. The emergent (re)stratification is set by a simple balance between the vertical buoyancy flux and diffusion along the vertical direction. Overall, this study demonstrates how the vortex-gas scaling theory can be adapted to quantitatively predict the magnitude and vertical structure of the meridional and vertical buoyancy fluxes, and of the emergent stratification, without additional fitting parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2022; v1 submitted 6 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Low frequency spectra of bending wave turbulence
Authors:
Benjamin Miquel,
Antoine Naert,
Sébastien Aumaître
Abstract:
We study experimentally the dynamics of long waves among turbulent bending waves in a thin elastic plate set into vibration by a monochromatic forcing at a frequency $f_0$. This frequency is chosen large compared with the characteristic frequencies of bending waves. As a consequence, a range of conservative scales, without energy flux in average, exists for frequencies $f<f_0$. Within this range,…
▽ More
We study experimentally the dynamics of long waves among turbulent bending waves in a thin elastic plate set into vibration by a monochromatic forcing at a frequency $f_0$. This frequency is chosen large compared with the characteristic frequencies of bending waves. As a consequence, a range of conservative scales, without energy flux in average, exists for frequencies $f<f_0$. Within this range, we report a flat power density spectrum for the orthogonal velocity, corresponding to energy equipartition between modes. Thus, the average energy per mode $β^{-1}$ -- analogous to a temperature -- fully characterizes the large-scale turbulent wave field. We present an expression for $β$ as a function of the forcing frequency and amplitude, and of the plate characteristics.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Convection driven by internal heat sources and sinks: heat transport beyond the mixing-length or "ultimate" scaling regime
Authors:
B. Miquel,
S. Lepot,
V. Bouillaut,
B. Gallet
Abstract:
Thermal convection driven by internal heat sources and sinks was recently shown experimentally to exhibit the mixing-length, or "ultimate", scaling-regime: the Nusselt number $Nu$ (dimensionless heat flux) increases as the square-root of the Rayleigh-number $Ra$ (dimensionless internal temperature difference). While for standard Rayleigh-Bénard convection this scaling regime was proven to be a rig…
▽ More
Thermal convection driven by internal heat sources and sinks was recently shown experimentally to exhibit the mixing-length, or "ultimate", scaling-regime: the Nusselt number $Nu$ (dimensionless heat flux) increases as the square-root of the Rayleigh-number $Ra$ (dimensionless internal temperature difference). While for standard Rayleigh-Bénard convection this scaling regime was proven to be a rigorous upper bound on the Nusselt number, we show that this is not so for convection driven by internal sources and sinks. To wit, we introduce an asymptotic expansion to derive steady nonlinear solutions in the limit of large $Ra_Q$, the Rayleigh-number based on the strength of the heat source. We illustrate this procedure for a simple sinusoidal heat source and show that it achieves heat transport enhancement beyond the mixing-length scaling regime: $Nu$ increases linearly with $Ra$ over this branch of solutions. Using rigorous upper bound theory, we prove that the scaling regime $Nu \sim Ra$ of the asymptotic solution corresponds to a maximization of the heat flux subject to simple dynamical constraints, up to a dimensionless prefactor. Not only do 2D numerical simulations confirm the analytical solution for the sinusoidal source, but, more surprisingly, they indicate that it is stable and indeed achieved by the system up to the highest $Ra_Q$ investigated numerically, with a heat transport efficiency orders of magnitude higher than the standard mixing-length estimate.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
On the role of the Prandtl number in convection driven by heat sources and sinks
Authors:
Benjamin Miquel,
Vincent Bouillaut,
Sebastien Aumaitre,
Basile Gallet
Abstract:
We report on a numerical study of turbulent convection driven by a combination of internal heat sources and sinks. Motivated by a recent experimental realisation (Lepot et al. 2018), we focus on the situation where the cooling is uniform, while the internal heating is localised near the bottom boundary, over approximately one tenth of the domain height. We obtain scaling laws $Nu \sim Ra^γPr^χ$ fo…
▽ More
We report on a numerical study of turbulent convection driven by a combination of internal heat sources and sinks. Motivated by a recent experimental realisation (Lepot et al. 2018), we focus on the situation where the cooling is uniform, while the internal heating is localised near the bottom boundary, over approximately one tenth of the domain height. We obtain scaling laws $Nu \sim Ra^γPr^χ$ for the heat transfer as measured by the Nusselt number $Nu$ expressed as a function of the Rayleigh number $Ra$ and the Prandtl number $Pr$. After confirming the experimental value $γ\approx 1/2$ for the dependence on $Ra$, we identify several regimes of dependence on $Pr$. For a stress-free bottom surface and within a range as broad as $Pr \in [0.003, 10]$, we observe the exponent $χ\approx 1/2$, in agreement with Spiegel's mixing length theory. For a no-slip bottom surface we observe a transition from $χ\approx 1/2$ for $Pr \leq 0.04$ to $χ\approx 1/6$ for $Pr \geq 0.04$, in agreement with scaling predictions by Bouillaut et al. The latter scaling regime stems from heat accumulation in the stagnant layer adjacent to a no-slip bottom boundary, which we characterise by comparing the local contributions of diffusive and convective thermal fluxes.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2020; v1 submitted 12 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Intermittency and emergence of coherent structures in wave turbulence of a vibrating plate
Authors:
Nicolas Mordant,
Benjamin Miquel
Abstract:
We report numerical investigations of wave turbulence in a vibrating plate. The possibility to implement advanced measurement techniques and long time numerical simulations makes this system extremely valuable for wave turbulence studies. The purely 2D character of dynamics of the elastic plate makes it much simpler to handle compared to much more complex 3D physical systems that are typical of ge…
▽ More
We report numerical investigations of wave turbulence in a vibrating plate. The possibility to implement advanced measurement techniques and long time numerical simulations makes this system extremely valuable for wave turbulence studies. The purely 2D character of dynamics of the elastic plate makes it much simpler to handle compared to much more complex 3D physical systems that are typical of geo- and astrophysical issues (ocean surface or internal waves, magnetized plasmas or strongly rotating and/or stratified flows). When the forcing is small the observed wave turbulence is consistent with the predictions of the Weak Turbulent Theory. Here we focus on the case of stronger forcing for which coherent structures can be observed. These structures look similar to the folds and D-cones that are commonly observed for strongly deformed static thin elastic sheets (crumpled paper) except that they evolve dynamically in our forced system. We describe their evolution and show that their emergence is associated with statistical intermittency (lack of self similarity) of strongly nonlinear wave turbulence. This behavior is reminiscent of intermittency in Navier-Stokes turbulence. Experimental data show hints of the weak to strong turbulence transition. However, due to technical limitations and dissipation, the strong nonlinear regime remains out of reach of experiments and therefore has been explored numerically.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Hybrid Chebyshev function bases for sparse spectral methods in parity-mixed PDEs on an infinite domain
Authors:
Benjamin Miquel,
Keith Julien
Abstract:
We present a numerical spectral method to solve systems of differential equations on an infinite interval $y\in (-\infty, \infty)$ in presence of linear differential operators of the form $Q(y) \left(\partial/\partial_y\right)^b$ (where $Q(y)$ is a rational fraction and $b$ a positive integer). Even when these operators are not parity-preserving, we demonstrate how a mixed expansion in interleaved…
▽ More
We present a numerical spectral method to solve systems of differential equations on an infinite interval $y\in (-\infty, \infty)$ in presence of linear differential operators of the form $Q(y) \left(\partial/\partial_y\right)^b$ (where $Q(y)$ is a rational fraction and $b$ a positive integer). Even when these operators are not parity-preserving, we demonstrate how a mixed expansion in interleaved Chebyshev rational functions $TB_n(y)$ and $SB_n(y)$ preserves the sparsity of their discretization. This paves the way for fast $O(N\ln N)$ and spectrally accurate mixed implicit-explicit time-marching of sets of linear and nonlinear equations in unbounded geometries.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2017; v1 submitted 21 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
A reduced model for salt-finger convection in the small diffusivity ratio limit
Authors:
Jin-Han Xie,
Benjamin Miquel,
Keith Julien,
Edgar Knobloch
Abstract:
A simple model of nonlinear salt-finger convection in two dimensions is derived and studied. The model is valid in the limit of small solute to heat diffusivity ratio and large density ratio, which is relevant to both oceanographic and astrophysical applications. Two limits distinguished by the magnitude of the Schmidt number are found. For order one Schmidt numbers, appropriate for astrophysical…
▽ More
A simple model of nonlinear salt-finger convection in two dimensions is derived and studied. The model is valid in the limit of small solute to heat diffusivity ratio and large density ratio, which is relevant to both oceanographic and astrophysical applications. Two limits distinguished by the magnitude of the Schmidt number are found. For order one Schmidt numbers, appropriate for astrophysical applications, a modified Rayleigh-Bénard system with large-scale damping due to a stabilizing temperature is obtained. For large Schmidt numbers, appropriate for the oceanic setting, the model combines a prognostic equation for the solute field and a diagnostic equation for inertia-free momentum dynamics. Two distinct saturation regimes are identified for the second model: The weakly driven regime is characterized by a large-scale flow associated with a balance between advection and linear instability, while the strongly driven regime produces multiscale structures, resulting in a balance between the energy input through linear instability and the energy transfer between scales. For both regimes, we analytically predict and numerically confirm the dependence of the kinetic energy and salinity fluxes on the ratio between solute and heat Rayleigh numbers. The spectra and probability density functions are also computed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Wave turbulence buildup in a vibrating plate
Authors:
Maria Ines Auliel,
Benjamin Miquel,
Nicolas Mordant
Abstract:
We report experimental and numerical results on the buildup of the energy spectrum in wave turbulence of a vibrating thin elastic plate. Three steps are observed: first a short linear stage, then the turbulent spectrum is constructed by the propagation of a front in wave number space and finally a long time saturation due to the action of dissipation. The propagation of a front at the second step…
▽ More
We report experimental and numerical results on the buildup of the energy spectrum in wave turbulence of a vibrating thin elastic plate. Three steps are observed: first a short linear stage, then the turbulent spectrum is constructed by the propagation of a front in wave number space and finally a long time saturation due to the action of dissipation. The propagation of a front at the second step is compatible with scaling predictions from the Weak Turbulence Theory.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Role of the basin boundary conditions in gravity wave turbulence
Authors:
Luc Deike,
Benjamin Miquel,
Pablo Gutiérrez-Matus,
Timothée Jamin,
Benoit Semin,
Michael Berhanu,
Eric Falcon,
Félicien Bonnefoy
Abstract:
Gravity wave turbulence is studied experimentally in a large wave basin where irregular waves are generated unidirectionally. The role of the basin boundary conditions (absorbing or reflecting) and of the forcing properties are investigated. To that purpose, an absorbing sloping beach opposite to the wavemaker can be replaced by a reflecting vertical wall. We observe that the wave field properties…
▽ More
Gravity wave turbulence is studied experimentally in a large wave basin where irregular waves are generated unidirectionally. The role of the basin boundary conditions (absorbing or reflecting) and of the forcing properties are investigated. To that purpose, an absorbing sloping beach opposite to the wavemaker can be replaced by a reflecting vertical wall. We observe that the wave field properties depend strongly on these boundary conditions. Quasi-one dimensional field of nonlinear waves propagate before to be damped by the beach whereas a more multidirectional wave field is observed with the wall. In both cases, the wave spectrum scales as a frequency-power law with an exponent that increases continuously with the forcing amplitude up to a value close to -4, which is the value predicted by the weak turbulence theory. The physical mechanisms involved are probably different according to the boundary condition used, but cannot be easily discriminated with only temporal measurements. We have also studied freely decaying gravity wave turbulence in the closed basin. No self-similar decay of the spectrum is observed, whereas its Fourier modes decay first as a time power law due to nonlinear mechanisms, and then exponentially due to linear viscous damping. We estimate the linear, nonlinear and dissipative time scales to test the time scale separation that highlights the important role of a large scale Fourier mode. By estimation of the mean energy flux from the initial decay of wave energy, the Kolmogorov-Zakharov constant is evaluated and found to be compatible with a recent theoretical value.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2015; v1 submitted 16 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
The role of dissipation in flexural wave turbulence: from experimental spectrum to Kolmogorov-Zakharov spectrum
Authors:
Benjamin Miquel,
Alexandros Alexakis,
Nicolas Mordant
Abstract:
The Weak Turbulence Theory has been applied to waves in thin elastic plates obeying the Föppl-Von Kármán dynamical equations. Subsequent experiments have shown a strong discrepancy between the theoretical predictions and the measurements. Both the dynamical equations and the Weak Turbulence Theory treatment require some restrictive hypotheses. Here a direct numerical simulation of the Föppl-Von Ká…
▽ More
The Weak Turbulence Theory has been applied to waves in thin elastic plates obeying the Föppl-Von Kármán dynamical equations. Subsequent experiments have shown a strong discrepancy between the theoretical predictions and the measurements. Both the dynamical equations and the Weak Turbulence Theory treatment require some restrictive hypotheses. Here a direct numerical simulation of the Föppl-Von Kármán equations is performed and reproduces qualitatively and quantitatively the experimental results when the experimentally measured damping rate of waves $γ_\mathbf{k}= a + bk^2$ is used. This confirms that the Föppl-Von Kármán equations are a valid theoretical framework to describe our experiments. When we progressively tune the dissipation so that to localize it at the smallest scales, we observe a gradual transition between the experimental spectrum and the Kolmogorov-Zakharov prediction. Thus it is shown dissipation has a major influence on the scaling properties stationary solutions of weakly non linear wave turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Transition from wave turbulence to dynamical crumpling in vibrated elastic plates
Authors:
Benjamin Miquel,
Alexandros Alexakis,
Christophe Josserand,
Nicolas Mordant
Abstract:
We study the dynamical regime of wave turbulence of a vibrated thin elastic plate based on experimental and numerical observations. We focus our study to the strongly non linear regime described in a previous letter by N. Yokoyama & M. Takaoka. At small forcing, a weakly non linear regime is compatible with the Weak Turbulence Theory when the dissipation is localized at high wavenumber. When the f…
▽ More
We study the dynamical regime of wave turbulence of a vibrated thin elastic plate based on experimental and numerical observations. We focus our study to the strongly non linear regime described in a previous letter by N. Yokoyama & M. Takaoka. At small forcing, a weakly non linear regime is compatible with the Weak Turbulence Theory when the dissipation is localized at high wavenumber. When the forcing intensity is increased, a strongly non linear regime emerges: singular structures dominate the dynamics at large scale whereas at small scales the weak turbulence is still present. A turbulence of singular structures, with folds and D-cones, develops that alters significantly the energy spectra and causes the emergence of intermittency.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2013; v1 submitted 3 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Nonlinear dynamics of flexural wave turbulence
Authors:
Benjamin Miquel,
Nicolas Mordant
Abstract:
The Kolmogorov-Zakharov spectrum predicted by the Weak Turbulence Theory remains elusive for wave turbulence of flexural waves at the surface of an thin elastic plate. We report a direct measurement of the nonlinear timescale $T_{NL}$ related to energy transfer between waves. This time scale is extracted from the space-time measurement of the deformation of the plate by studying the temporal dynam…
▽ More
The Kolmogorov-Zakharov spectrum predicted by the Weak Turbulence Theory remains elusive for wave turbulence of flexural waves at the surface of an thin elastic plate. We report a direct measurement of the nonlinear timescale $T_{NL}$ related to energy transfer between waves. This time scale is extracted from the space-time measurement of the deformation of the plate by studying the temporal dynamics of wavelet coefficients of the turbulent field. The central hypothesis of the theory is the time scale separation between dissipative time scale, nonlinear time scale and the period of the wave ($T_d>>T_{NL}>>T$). We observe that this scale separation is valid in our system. The discrete modes due to the finite size effects are responsible for the disagreement between observations and theory. A crossover from continuous weak turbulence and discrete turbulence is observed when the nonlinear time scale is of the same order of magnitude as the frequency separation of the discrete modes. The Kolmogorov-Zakharov energy cascade is then strongly altered and is frozen before reaching the dissipative regime expected in the theory.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
Non stationary wave turbulence in an elastic plate
Authors:
Benjamin Miquel,
Nicolas Mordant
Abstract:
We report experimental results on the decay of wave turbulence in an elastic plate obtained by stopping the forcing from a stationary turbulent state. In the stationary case, the forcing is seen to induce some anisotropy and a spectrum in disagreement with the weak turbulence theory. After stopping the forcing, almost perfect isotropy is restored. The decay of energy is self similar and the observ…
▽ More
We report experimental results on the decay of wave turbulence in an elastic plate obtained by stopping the forcing from a stationary turbulent state. In the stationary case, the forcing is seen to induce some anisotropy and a spectrum in disagreement with the weak turbulence theory. After stopping the forcing, almost perfect isotropy is restored. The decay of energy is self similar and the observed decaying spectrum is in better agreement with the prediction of the weak turbulence theory. The dissipative part of the spectrum is partially consistent with the theoretical prediction based on previous work by Kolmakov. This suggest that the non agreement with the weak turbulence theory is mostly due to a spurious effect of the forcing related to the finite size of the system.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
