-
Analysis of wall-modelled particle/mesh PDF methods for turbulent parietal flows
Authors:
Guilhem Balvet,
Jean-Pierre Minier,
Yelva Roustan,
Martin Ferrand
Abstract:
Lagrangian stochastic methods are widely used to model turbulent flows. Scarce consideration has, however, been devoted to the treatment of the near-wall region and to the formulation of a proper wall-boundary condition. With respect to this issue, the main purpose of this paper is to present an in-depth analysis of such flows when relying on particle/mesh formulations of the probability density f…
▽ More
Lagrangian stochastic methods are widely used to model turbulent flows. Scarce consideration has, however, been devoted to the treatment of the near-wall region and to the formulation of a proper wall-boundary condition. With respect to this issue, the main purpose of this paper is to present an in-depth analysis of such flows when relying on particle/mesh formulations of the probability density function (PDF) model. This is translated into three objectives. The first objective is to assess the existing an-elastic wall-boundary condition and present new validation results. The second objective is to analyse the impact of the interpolation of the mean fields at particle positions on their dynamics. The third objective is to investigate the spatial error affecting covariance estimators when they are extracted on coarse volumes. All these developments allow to ascertain that the key dynamical statistics of wall-bounded flows are properly captured even for coarse spatial resolutions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The dynamics of discrete particles in turbulent flows: open issues and current challenges in statistical modeling
Authors:
Jean-Pierre Minier,
Christophe Henry
Abstract:
This article is an invitation. It is, first, an invitation to consider as a subject worthy of attention the wide range of situations where small discrete elements, either bubbles, droplets or solid particles, are embedded in turbulent flows. Occurring often at a human scale and in our daily environments, these turbulent dispersed two-phase flows display complex behavior due to the interplay of two…
▽ More
This article is an invitation. It is, first, an invitation to consider as a subject worthy of attention the wide range of situations where small discrete elements, either bubbles, droplets or solid particles, are embedded in turbulent flows. Occurring often at a human scale and in our daily environments, these turbulent dispersed two-phase flows display complex behavior due to the interplay of two fundamental interactions, the fluid-particle and particle-particle interactions, compounded by the turbulence of the carrier flow. This is not a domain where the basic laws are unknown but where the huge number of degrees of freedom involved call for reduced, or coarse-grained, statistical descriptions to be developed. Since we are considering transport and collision phenomena or relaxation processes, it would seem that they can be handled by kinetic theory. In the general case of non-fully resolved turbulent flows, we are however dealing with particles influenced by random media with non-zero time and space correlations. The second invitation is therefore to recognize the limitations of kinetic-based descriptions and to address the challenges driving us to extend the classical framework, for fluid-particle as well as particle-particle interactions. Taking the standpoint provided by the modern formulation of stochastic processes and focusing on the description of the particle phase, this review proposes a step-by-step pedagogical presentation of current models while pointing out new directions and remaining uncharted territories. This is done to provide answers to the question `why?' as much as `how?' and to try to kindle interest into these open and fascinating issues.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
A time-step-robust algorithm to compute particle trajectories in 3-D unstructured meshes for Lagrangian stochastic methods
Authors:
Guilhem Balvet,
Jean-Pierre Minier,
Christophe Henry,
Yelva Roustan,
Martin Ferrand
Abstract:
The purpose of this paper is to propose a time-step-robust cell-to-cell integration of particle trajectories in 3-D unstructured meshes in particle/mesh Lagrangian stochastic methods. The main idea is to dynamically update the mean fields used in the time integration by splitting, for each particle, the time step into sub-steps such that each of these sub-steps corresponds to particle cell residen…
▽ More
The purpose of this paper is to propose a time-step-robust cell-to-cell integration of particle trajectories in 3-D unstructured meshes in particle/mesh Lagrangian stochastic methods. The main idea is to dynamically update the mean fields used in the time integration by splitting, for each particle, the time step into sub-steps such that each of these sub-steps corresponds to particle cell residence times. This reduces the spatial discretization error. Given the stochastic nature of the models, a key aspect is to derive estimations of the residence times that do not anticipate the future of the Wiener process. To that effect, the new algorithm relies on a virtual particle, attached to each stochastic one, whose mean conditional behavior provides free-of-statistical-bias predictions of residence times. After consistency checks, this new algorithm is validated on two representative test cases: particle dispersion in a statistically uniform flow and particle dynamics in a non-uniform flow.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Particle resuspension: challenges and perspectives for future models
Authors:
Christophe Henry,
Jean-Pierre Minier,
Sara Brambilla
Abstract:
The purpose of this review is to analyze the physics at play in particle resuspension in order to bring insights into the rich complexity of this common but challenging concern. Following the more-is-different vision, this is performed by starting from a range of practical observations and experimental data. We then work our way through the investigation of the key mechanisms which play a role in…
▽ More
The purpose of this review is to analyze the physics at play in particle resuspension in order to bring insights into the rich complexity of this common but challenging concern. Following the more-is-different vision, this is performed by starting from a range of practical observations and experimental data. We then work our way through the investigation of the key mechanisms which play a role in the overall process. In turn, these mechanisms reveal an array of fundamental interactions, such as particle-fluid, particle-particle and particle-surface, whose combined effects create the tapestry of current applications. At the core of this analysis are descriptions of these physical phenomena and the different ways through which they are intertwined to build up various models used to provide quantitative assessment of particle resuspension. The physics of particle resuspension implies to hold together processes occurring at extremely different space and time scales and models are key in providing a single vehicle to lead us through such multiscale journeys. This raises questions on what makes up a model and one objective of the present work is to clarify the essence of a modeling approach. In spite of its ubiquitous nature, particle resuspension is still at the early stages of developments. Many extensions need to be worked out and revisiting the art of modeling is not a moot point. The need to consider more complex objects than small and spherical particles and, moreover, to come up with unified descriptions of mono- and multilayer resuspension put the emphasis on solid model foundations if we are to go beyond current limits. This is very much modeling in the making and new ideas are proposed to stimulate interest into this everyday but challenging issue in physics.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Guidelines for the formulation of Lagrangian stochastic models for particle simulations of single-phase and dispersed two-phase turbulent flows
Authors:
J. -P. Minier,
S. Chibbaro,
S. B. Pope
Abstract:
In this paper, we establish a set of criteria which are applied to discuss various formulations under which Lagrangian stochastic models can be found. These models are used for the simulation of fluid particles in single-phase turbulence as well as for the fluid seen by discrete particles in dispersed turbulent two-phase flows. A central issue is to put forward reliable requirements which must be…
▽ More
In this paper, we establish a set of criteria which are applied to discuss various formulations under which Lagrangian stochastic models can be found. These models are used for the simulation of fluid particles in single-phase turbulence as well as for the fluid seen by discrete particles in dispersed turbulent two-phase flows. A central issue is to put forward reliable requirements which must be met by Lagrangian stochastic models and a new element brought by the present analysis is to address the single- and two-phase flow situations from a unified point of view.This analysis does not address the question of the relative predictive capacities of different models but concentrates on their formulation since advantages and disadvantages of different formulations are not always clear. Indeed, hidden in the changes from one structure to another are some possible pitfalls which can lead to flaws in the construction of practical models and to physically-unsound numerical calculations. A first interest of the present approach is illustrated by considering some models proposed in the literature and by showing that these criteria help to assess whether these Lagrangian stochastic models can be regarded as acceptable descriptions. A second interest is to indicate how future developments can be safely built, which is also relevant for stochastic subgrid models for particle-laden flows in the context of Large Eddy Simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Analysis of the incompressibility constraint in the Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics method
Authors:
Kamil Szewc,
Jacek Pozorski,
Jean-Pierre Minier
Abstract:
Smoothed particle hydrodynamics is a particle-based, fully Lagrangian, method for fluid-flow simulations. In this work, fundamental concepts of the method are first briefly recalled. Then, we present a thorough comparison of three different incompressibility treatments in SPH: the weakly compressible approach, where a suitably-chosen equation of state is used; and two truly incompressible methods,…
▽ More
Smoothed particle hydrodynamics is a particle-based, fully Lagrangian, method for fluid-flow simulations. In this work, fundamental concepts of the method are first briefly recalled. Then, we present a thorough comparison of three different incompressibility treatments in SPH: the weakly compressible approach, where a suitably-chosen equation of state is used; and two truly incompressible methods, where the velocity field projection onto a divergence-free space is performed. A noteworthy aspect of the study is that, in each incompressibility treatment, the same boundary conditions are used (and further developed) which allows a direct comparison to be made. Problems associated with implementation are also discussed and an optimal choice of the computational parameters has been proposed and verified. Numerical results show that the present state-of-the-art truly incompressible method (based on a velocity correction) suffer from density accumulation errors. To address this issue, an algorithm, based on a correction for both particle velocities and positions, is presented. The usefulness of this density correction is examined and demonstrated in the last part of the paper.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
-
The FDF or LES/PDF method for turbulent two-phase flows
Authors:
Sergio Chibbaro,
jean-Pierre Minier
Abstract:
In this paper, a new formalism for the filtered density function (FDF) approach is developed for the treatment of turbulent polydispersed two-phase flows in LES simulations. Contrary to the FDF used for turbulent reactive single-phase flows, the present formalislm is based on Lagrangian quantities and, in particular, on the Lagrangian filtered mass density function (LFMDF) as the central concept.…
▽ More
In this paper, a new formalism for the filtered density function (FDF) approach is developed for the treatment of turbulent polydispersed two-phase flows in LES simulations. Contrary to the FDF used for turbulent reactive single-phase flows, the present formalislm is based on Lagrangian quantities and, in particular, on the Lagrangian filtered mass density function (LFMDF) as the central concept. This framework allows modeling and simulation of particle flows for LES to be set in a rigorous context and various links with other approaches to be made. In particular, the relation between LES for particle simulations of single-phase flows and Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) is put forward. Then, the discussion and derivation of possible subgrid stochastic models used for Lagrangian models in two-phase flows can set in a clear probabilistic equivalence with the corresponding LFMDF.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Mean-field/PDF numerical approach for polydispersed turbulent two-phase flows
Authors:
Eric Peirano,
Sergio Chibbaro,
Jacek Pozorski,
Jean-Pierre Minier
Abstract:
The purpose of this paper is to give an overview in the realm of numerical computations of polydispersed turbulent two-phase flows, using a mean-field/PDF approach. In this approach, the numerical solution is obtained by resorting to a hybrid method where the mean fluid properties are computed by solving mean-field (RANS) equations with a classical finite volume procedure whereas the local instant…
▽ More
The purpose of this paper is to give an overview in the realm of numerical computations of polydispersed turbulent two-phase flows, using a mean-field/PDF approach. In this approach, the numerical solution is obtained by resorting to a hybrid method where the mean fluid properties are computed by solving mean-field (RANS) equations with a classical finite volume procedure whereas the local instantaneous properties of the particles are determined by solving stochastic differential equations (SDEs). The fundamentals of the general formalism are recalled and particular attention is focused on a specific theoretical issue: the treatment of the multiscale character of the dynamics of the discrete particles, that is the consistency of the system of SDEs in asymptotic cases. Then, the main lines of the particle/mesh algorithm are given and some specific problems, related to the integration of the SDEs, are discussed, for example, issues related to the specificity of the treatment of the averaging and projection operators, the time integration of the SDEs (weak numerical schemes consistent with all asymptotic cases), and the computation of the source terms. Practical simulations, for three different flows, are performed in order to demonstrate the ability of both the models and the numerics to cope with the stringent specificities of polydispersed turbulent two-phase flows.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
PDF modeling of near-wall turbulent flows: A New model, Weak second-order scheme and a numerical study in a Hybrid configuration
Authors:
Sergio Chibbaro,
Jean-Pierre Minier
Abstract:
In this work, we discuss some points relevant for stochastic modelling of one- and two-phase turbulent flows. In the framework of stochastic modelling, also referred to PDF approach, we propose a new Langevin model including all viscosity effects and thus that is consistent with viscous Navier-Stokes equations. In the second part of the work, we show how to develop a second-order unconditionally s…
▽ More
In this work, we discuss some points relevant for stochastic modelling of one- and two-phase turbulent flows. In the framework of stochastic modelling, also referred to PDF approach, we propose a new Langevin model including all viscosity effects and thus that is consistent with viscous Navier-Stokes equations. In the second part of the work, we show how to develop a second-order unconditionally stable numerical scheme for the stochastic equations proposed. Accuracy and consistency of the numerical scheme is demonstrated analytically. In the last part of the work, we study the fluid flow in a channel flow with the proposed viscous method. A peculiar approach is chosen: the flow is solved with a Eulerian method and after with the Lagrangian model proposed which uses some of the Eulerian quantities. In this way attention is devoted to the issue of consistency in hybrid Eulerian/Lagrangian methods. It is shown that the coupling is important indeed and that to couple the Lagrangian model to an Eulerian one which is not consistent with the same turbulence physics leads to large errors. This part of the work complements a recent article [Chibbaro and Minier International Journal of Multiphase flows submitted (arXiv:0912.2045)]
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
PDF model based on Langevin equation for polydispersed two-phase flows applied to a bluff-body gas-solid flow,
Authors:
J. P. Minier,
E. Peirano,
S. Chibbaro
Abstract:
The aim of the paper is to discuss the main characteristics of a complete theoretical and numerical model for turbulent polydispersed two-phase flows, pointing out some specific issues. The theoretical details of the model have already been presented [Minier and Peirano, Physics Reports, Vol. 352/1-3, 2001 ]. Consequently, the present work is mainly focused on complementary aspects, that are often…
▽ More
The aim of the paper is to discuss the main characteristics of a complete theoretical and numerical model for turbulent polydispersed two-phase flows, pointing out some specific issues. The theoretical details of the model have already been presented [Minier and Peirano, Physics Reports, Vol. 352/1-3, 2001 ]. Consequently, the present work is mainly focused on complementary aspects, that are often overlooked and that require particular attention. In particular, the following points are analysed : the necessity to add an extra term in the equation for the velocity of the fluid seen in the case of twoway coupling, the theoretical and numerical evaluations of particle averages and the fulfilment of the particle mass-continuity constraint. The theoretical model is developed within the PDF formalism. The important-physical choice of the state vector variables is first discussed and the model is then expressed as a stochastic differential equation (SDE) written in continuous time (Langevin equations) for the velocity of the fluid seen. The interests and limitations of Langevin equations, compared to the single-phase case, are reviewed. From the numerical point of view, the model corresponds to an hybrid Eulerian/Lagrangian approach where the fluid and particle phases are simulated by different methods. Important aspects of the Monte Carlo particle/mesh numerical method are emphasised. Finally, the complete model is validated and its performance is assessed by simulating a bluff-body case with an important recirculation zone and in which two-way coupling is noticeable.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
A note on the consistency of Hybrid Eulerian/Lagrangian approach to multiphase flows
Authors:
Sergio Chibbaro,
Jean-Pierre Minier
Abstract:
The aim of the present paper is to introduce and to discuss inconsistencies errors that may arise when Eulerian and Lagrangian models are coupled for the simulations of turbulent poly-dispersed two-phase flows. In these hydrid models, two turbulence models are in fact implicitely used at the same time and it is essential to check that they are consistent, in spite of their apparent different for…
▽ More
The aim of the present paper is to introduce and to discuss inconsistencies errors that may arise when Eulerian and Lagrangian models are coupled for the simulations of turbulent poly-dispersed two-phase flows. In these hydrid models, two turbulence models are in fact implicitely used at the same time and it is essential to check that they are consistent, in spite of their apparent different formulations. This issue appears in particular in the case of very-small particles, or tracer-limit particles, and it is shown that coupling inconsistent turbulence models (Eulerian and Lagrangian) can result in non-physical results, notably for second-order fluid velocity moments. This problem is illustrated by some computations for fluid particles in a turbulent channel flow using several coupling strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Langevin PDF simulation of particle deposition in a turbulent pipe flow
Authors:
Sergio Chibbaro,
Jean-Pierre Minier
Abstract:
The paper deals with the description of particle deposition on walls from a turbulent flow over a large range of particle diameter, using a Langevin PDF model. The first aim of the work is to test how the present Langevin model is able to describe this phenomenon and to outline the physical as- pects which play a major role in particle deposition. The general features and characteristics of the…
▽ More
The paper deals with the description of particle deposition on walls from a turbulent flow over a large range of particle diameter, using a Langevin PDF model. The first aim of the work is to test how the present Langevin model is able to describe this phenomenon and to outline the physical as- pects which play a major role in particle deposition. The general features and characteristics of the present stochastic model are first recalled. Then, results obtained with the standard form of the model are presented along with an analysis which has been carried out to check the sensitivity of the predictions on different mean fluid quantities. These results show that the physical repre- sentation of the near-wall physics has to be improved and that, in particular, one possible route is to introduce specific features related to the near-wall coherent structures. In the following, we propose a simple phenomenological model that introduces some of the effects due to the presence of turbulent coherent structures on particles in a thin layer close to the wall. The results obtained with this phenomenological model are in good agreement with experimental evidence and this suggests to pursue in that direction, towards the development of more general and rigorous stochastic models that provide a link between a geometrical description of turbulent flow and a statistical one.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
