Global Optimization-Based Calibration Algorithm for a 2D Distributed Hydrologic-Hydrodynamic and Water Quality Model
Authors:
Marcus N. Gomes Jr.,
Marcio H. Giacomoni,
Fabricio A. R. Navarro,
Eduardo M. Mendiondo
Abstract:
Hydrodynamic models with rain-on-the-grid capabilities are usually computationally expensive. This makes the use of automatic calibration algorithms hard to apply due to the large number of model runs. However, with the recent advances in parallel processing, computational resources, and increasing high-resolution climatologic and GIS data, high-resolution hydrodynamic models can be used for optim…
▽ More
Hydrodynamic models with rain-on-the-grid capabilities are usually computationally expensive. This makes the use of automatic calibration algorithms hard to apply due to the large number of model runs. However, with the recent advances in parallel processing, computational resources, and increasing high-resolution climatologic and GIS data, high-resolution hydrodynamic models can be used for optimization-based calibration. This paper presents a global optimization-based algorithm to calibrate a fully distributed hydrologic-hydrodynamic and water quality model (HydroPol2D) using observed data (i.e., discharge, or pollutant concentration) as input. The algorithm can find a near-optimal set of parameters to explain observed gauged data. The modeling framework presented here, although applied in a poorly-gauged catchment, can be adapted for catchments with more detailed observations. We applied the algorithm in different cases of the V-Tilted Catchment, the Wooden-Board catchment, and in an existing urban catchment with heterogeneous data. The results of automatic calibration indicate $\mathrm{NSE} = 0.99$ for the V-Tilted catchment, $\mathrm{RMSE} = 830~\mathrm{mgL^{-1}}$ for salt concentration pollutographs (i.e., 8.3% of the event mean concentration), and $\mathrm{NSE} = 0.89$ for the urban catchment case study. This paper also explores the issue of equifinality in modeling calibration (EqMC). Equifinality is defined as the set of different parameter combinations that can provide equally good or accepted results, within the physical parameter ranges. EqMC decreases with the number of events and increases with the choice of partially or nonproducing runoff ones. Furthermore, results indicate that providing more accurate parameter ranges based on a priori knowledge of the catchment is fundamental to reduce the chances of finding a set of parameters with equifinality.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
HydroPol2D -- Distributed Hydrodynamic and Water Quality Model: Challenges and Opportunities in Poorly-Gauged Catchments
Authors:
Marcus Nóbrega Gomes Jr.,
César Ambrogi Ferreira do Lago,
Luis Miguel Castillo Rápalo,
Paulo Tarso S. Oliveira,
Marcio Hofheinz Giacomoni,
Eduardo Mario Mendiondo
Abstract:
Floods are one of the deadliest natural hazards and are fueled by excessive urbanization. Urban development decreases infiltration by reducing pervious areas and increases the accumulation of pollutants during dry weather. During wet weather events, there is an increase in the levels of pollution concentrations and stormwater runoff that eventually reach creeks and rivers. Polluted stormwater runo…
▽ More
Floods are one of the deadliest natural hazards and are fueled by excessive urbanization. Urban development decreases infiltration by reducing pervious areas and increases the accumulation of pollutants during dry weather. During wet weather events, there is an increase in the levels of pollution concentrations and stormwater runoff that eventually reach creeks and rivers. Polluted stormwater runoff may be sources of water supply. Modeling the quantity and quality dynamics of stormwater runoff requires a coupled hydrodynamic module capable of estimating the transport and fate of pollutants. In this paper, we evaluate the applicability of a distributed hydrodynamic model coupled with a water quality model (HydroPol2D). First, the model is compared to GSSHA and WCA2D in the V-Tilted catchment, and the limitation of the critical velocity of WCA2D is investigated. We also applied the model in a laboratory wooden board catchment, focusing on the validation of the numerical approach to simulate water quality dynamics. Then, we apply HydroPol2D in the Tijuco Preto catchment, in Sao Carlos - Brazil, and compare the modeling results with the full momentum solver of the Hydrologic Engineering Center - River System Analysis (HEC-RAS). The model implementation, the governing equations, and the estimation of input data are discussed, indicating the challenges and opportunities of the application of distributed models in poorly-gauged catchments. For a 1-yr return period of rainfall and antecedent dry days and assuming an uncertainty of $40\%$ in the water quality parameters, the results indicate that the maximum concentration of total suspended solids (TSS), the maximum load and the mass of the pollutant washed in $30\%$ of the volume are, $456~\pm~260~\mathrm{mg.L^{-1}.km^{-2}}$, $\mathrm{2.56 \pm 0.4~kg.s^{-1}.km^{-2}}$, and $\mathrm{89\%~\pm~10\%}$, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
