Showing 1–16 of 16 results for author: Mandal, B

Applications of the Quantum Phase Difference Estimation Algorithm to the Excitation Energies in Spin Systems on a NISQ Device

Authors: Boni Paul, Sudhindu Bikash Mandal, Kenji Sugisaki, B. P. Das

Abstract: The Quantum Phase Difference Estimation (QPDE) algorithm, as an extension of the Quantum Phase Estimation (QPE), is a quantum algorithm designed to compute the differences of two eigenvalues of a unitary operator by exploiting the quantum superposition of two eigenstates. Unlike QPE, QPDE is free of controlled-unitary operations, and is suitable for calculations on noisy intermediate-scale quantum… ▽ More The Quantum Phase Difference Estimation (QPDE) algorithm, as an extension of the Quantum Phase Estimation (QPE), is a quantum algorithm designed to compute the differences of two eigenvalues of a unitary operator by exploiting the quantum superposition of two eigenstates. Unlike QPE, QPDE is free of controlled-unitary operations, and is suitable for calculations on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. We present the implementation and verification of a novel early fault-tolerant QPDE algorithm for determining energy gaps across diverse spin system configurations using NISQ devices. The algorithm is applied to the systems described by two and three-spin Heisenberg Hamiltonians with different geometric arrangements and coupling strengths, including symmetric, asymmetric, spin-frustrated, and non-frustrated configurations. By leveraging the match gate-like structure of the time evolution operator of Heisenberg Hamiltonian, we achieve constant-depth quantum circuits suitable for NISQ hardware implementation. Our results on IBM quantum processors show remarkable accuracy ranging from 85\% to 93\%, demonstrating excellent agreement with classical calculations even in the presence of hardware noise. The methodology incorporates sophisticated quantum noise suppression techniques, including Pauli Twirling and Dynamical Decoupling, and employs an adaptive framework. Our findings demonstrate the practical viability of the QPDE algorithm for quantum many-body simulations on current NISQ hardware, establishing a robust framework for future applications. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2025; originally announced February 2025.

Isochronous oscillator with a singular position-dependent mass and its quantization

Authors: Aritra Ghosh, Bhabani Prasad Mandal, Bijan Bagchi

Abstract: In this paper, we present an analysis of the equation $\ddot{x} - (1/2x) \dot{x}^2 + 2 ω^2 x - 1/8x = 0$, where $ω> 0$ and $x = x(t)$ is a real-valued variable. We first discuss the appearance of this equation from a position-dependent-mass scenario in which the mass profile goes inversely with $x$, admitting a singularity at $x = 0$. The associated potential is also singular at $x = 0$, splitting… ▽ More In this paper, we present an analysis of the equation $\ddot{x} - (1/2x) \dot{x}^2 + 2 ω^2 x - 1/8x = 0$, where $ω> 0$ and $x = x(t)$ is a real-valued variable. We first discuss the appearance of this equation from a position-dependent-mass scenario in which the mass profile goes inversely with $x$, admitting a singularity at $x = 0$. The associated potential is also singular at $x = 0$, splitting the real axis into two halves, i.e., $x > 0$ and $x < 0$. The dynamics is exactly solvable for both the branches and so for definiteness, we stick to the $x > 0$ branch. Performing a canonical quantization in the position representation and upon employing the ordering strategy of the kinetic-energy operator due to von Roos, we show that the problem is isospectral with the isotonic oscillator. Thus, the quantum spectrum consists of an infinite number of equispaced levels which is in line with the expectation that classical systems that support isochronous oscillations are associated in their quantized versions with equally-spaced spectra. The spacing between energy levels is found to be insensitive to the specific choices of the ambiguity parameters that are employed for ordering the kinetic-energy operator à la von Roos. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2025; originally announced January 2025.

Comments: v1: Comments are welcome

Ferroelectric HfO$_2$-ZrO$_2$ multilayers with reduced wake-up

Authors: Barnik Mandal, Adrian-Marie Philippe, Nathalie Valle, Emmanuel Defay, Torsten Granzow, Sebastjan Glinsek

Abstract: Since the discovery of ferroelectricity in HfO$_2$ thin films, significant research has focused on Zr-doped HfO$_2$ and solid solution (Hf,Zr)O$_2$ thin films. Functional properties can be further tuned via multilayering, however, this approach has not yet been fully explored in HfO$_2$-ZrO$_2$ films. This work demonstrates ferroelectricity in a 50 nm thick, solution-processed HfO$_2$-ZrO$_2$ mult… ▽ More Since the discovery of ferroelectricity in HfO$_2$ thin films, significant research has focused on Zr-doped HfO$_2$ and solid solution (Hf,Zr)O$_2$ thin films. Functional properties can be further tuned via multilayering, however, this approach has not yet been fully explored in HfO$_2$-ZrO$_2$ films. This work demonstrates ferroelectricity in a 50 nm thick, solution-processed HfO$_2$-ZrO$_2$ multilayer film, marking it as the thickest multilayer film to date exhibiting ferroelectric properties. The multilayer structure was confirmed through transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy, with high-resolution TEM revealing grain continuity across multiple layers. This finding indicates that a polar phase in the originally paraelectric ZrO$_2$ layer, can be stabilized by the HfO$_2$ layer. The film attains a remanent polarization of 9 uC/cm$^2$ and exhibits accelerated wake-up behavior, attributed to its higher breakdown strength resulting from the incorporation of multiple interfaces. These results offer a faster wake-up mechanism for thick ferroelectric hafnia films. △ Less

Submitted 29 March, 2025; v1 submitted 13 November, 2024; originally announced November 2024.

Highly Transparent Lead-Free Piezoelectric Haptic Device

Authors: Longfei Song, Sebastjan Glinsek, Nagamalleswara Rao Alluri, Veronika Kovacova, Michele Melchiorr, Alfredo Blazquez Martinez, Barnik Mandal, Juliette Cardoletti, Emmanuel Defay

Abstract: Acoustic haptic technology adds touch sensations to human-machine interfaces by integrating piezoelectric actuators onto touchscreens. Traditional piezoelectric haptic technologies use opaque lead-containing ceramics that are both toxic and visible. We have developed a highly transparent lead-free piezoelectric haptic device using potassium sodium niobate (KNN) and transparent conductive oxide thi… ▽ More Acoustic haptic technology adds touch sensations to human-machine interfaces by integrating piezoelectric actuators onto touchscreens. Traditional piezoelectric haptic technologies use opaque lead-containing ceramics that are both toxic and visible. We have developed a highly transparent lead-free piezoelectric haptic device using potassium sodium niobate (KNN) and transparent conductive oxide thin films. The KNN film, grown on glass, exhibits a pure perovskite phase and a dense microstructure. This device achieves up to 80% transmittance, surpassing lead zirconate titanate (PZT) thin films. It generates an acoustic resonance at 16.5 kHz and produces a peak-to-peak displacement of 1.0 um at 28 V unipolar, making it suitable for surface rendering applications. This demonstrates the potential of transparent lead-free piezoelectric actuators as an effective alternative to conventional PZT haptic actuators. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2025; v1 submitted 21 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

On Mixed Quantum/Classical Theory for Rotationally Inelastic Scattering of Identical Collision Partners

Authors: Dulat Bostan, Bikramaditya Mandal, Dmitri Babikov

Abstract: Mixed quantum/classical theory (MQCT) for the treatment of rotationally inelastic transitions during collisions of two identical molecules, described either as indistinguishable or distinguishable partners, is reviewed. The treatment of two molecules as indistinguishable includes symmetrization of rotational wavefunctions, introduces exchange parity, and gives state-to-state transition matrix elem… ▽ More Mixed quantum/classical theory (MQCT) for the treatment of rotationally inelastic transitions during collisions of two identical molecules, described either as indistinguishable or distinguishable partners, is reviewed. The treatment of two molecules as indistinguishable includes symmetrization of rotational wavefunctions, introduces exchange parity, and gives state-to-state transition matrix elements different from those in the straightforward treatment of molecules as distinguishable. Moreover, the treatment of collision partners as indistinguishable is eight times faster. Numerical results, presented for $H_2 + H_2$, CO + CO and $H_2O + H_2O$ systems, indicate good agreement of MQCT calculations with full-quantum calculations from literature and show that an a posteriori correction, applied after the treatment of collision partners as distinguishable, generally produces good results that agree well with the rigorous treatment of collision partners as indistinguishable. This correction for cross section includes either multiplication by 2, or summation over physically indistinguishable processes, depending on the transition type. After this correction, the results of two treatments agree within 5% for most but may reach 10-20% for some transitions. At low collision energies dominated by scattering resonances these differences can be larger, but they tend to decrease as collision energy is increased. It is also shown that if the system is artificially forced to follow the same collision path in the indistinguishable and distinguishable treatments, then all differences between the results of two treatments disappear. This interesting finding gives new insight into the collision process and indicates that indistinguishability of identical collision partners comes into play through the collision path itself, rather than through matrix elements of inelastic transitions. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2024; originally announced September 2024.

Relativistic VQE calculations of molecular electric dipole moments on trapped ion quantum hardware

Authors: Palak Chawla, Shweta, K. R. Swain, Tushti Patel, Renu Bala, Disha Shetty, Kenji Sugisaki, Sudhindu Bikash Mandal, Jordi Riu, Jan Nogue, V. S. Prasannaa, B. P. Das

Abstract: The quantum-classical hybrid variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm is among the most actively studied topics in atomic and molecular calculations on quantum computers, yet few studies address properties other than energies or account for relativistic effects. This work presents high-precision 18-qubit relativistic VQE simulations for calculating the permanent electric dipole moments (PDM… ▽ More The quantum-classical hybrid variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm is among the most actively studied topics in atomic and molecular calculations on quantum computers, yet few studies address properties other than energies or account for relativistic effects. This work presents high-precision 18-qubit relativistic VQE simulations for calculating the permanent electric dipole moments (PDMs) of BeH to RaH molecules on traditional computers, and 6- and 12-qubit PDM computations for SrH on IonQ quantum devices. To achieve high precision on current noisy intermediate scale era quantum hardware, we apply various resource reduction methods, including Reinforcement Learning and causal flow preserving ZX-Calculus routines, along with error mitigation and post-selection techniques. Our approach reduces the two-qubit gate count in our 12-qubit circuit by 99.71%, with only a 2.35% trade-off in precision for PDM when evaluated classically within a suitably chosen active space. On the current generation IonQ Forte-I hardware, the error in PDM is -1.17% relative to classical calculations and only 1.21% compared to the unoptimized circuit. △ Less

Submitted 2 January, 2025; v1 submitted 7 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: V3, with some minor changes

Mixed Quantum/Classical Theory (MQCT) Approach to the Dynamics of Molecule-Molecule Collisions in Complex Systems

Authors: Carolin Joy, Bikramaditya Mandal, Dulat Bostan, Marie-Lise Dubernet, Dmitri Babikov

Abstract: We developed a general theoretical approach and a user-ready computer code that permit to study the dynamics of collisional energy transfer and ro-vibrational energy exchange in complex molecule-molecule collisions. The method is a mixture of classical and quantum mechanics. The internal ro-vibrational motion of collision partners is treated quantum mechanically using time-dependent Schrodinger eq… ▽ More We developed a general theoretical approach and a user-ready computer code that permit to study the dynamics of collisional energy transfer and ro-vibrational energy exchange in complex molecule-molecule collisions. The method is a mixture of classical and quantum mechanics. The internal ro-vibrational motion of collision partners is treated quantum mechanically using time-dependent Schrodinger equation that captures many quantum phenomena including state quantization and zero-point energy, propensity and selection rules for state-to-state transitions, quantum symmetry and interference phenomena. A significant numerical speed up is obtained by describing the translational motion of collision partners classically, using the Ehrenfest mean-field trajectory approach. Within this framework a family of approximate methods for collision dynamics is developed. Several benchmark studies for diatomic and triatomic molecules, such as H$_2$O and ND$_3$ collided with He, H$_2$ and D$_2$, show that the results of MQCT are in good agreement with full-quantum calculations in a broad range of energies, especially at high collision energies where they become nearly identical to the full quantum results. Numerical efficiency of the method and massive parallelism of the MQCT code permit us to embrace some of the most complicated collisional systems ever studied, such as C$_6$H$_6$ + He, CH$_3$COOH + He and H$_2$O + H$_2$O. Application of MQCT to the collisions of chiral molecules such as CH$_3$CHCH$_2$O + He, and to the molecule-surface collisions is also possible and will be pursued in the future. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2024; v1 submitted 4 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: This paper is invited to submit to the Faraday's discussion and is accepted

Improved temperature dependence of rate coefficients for rotational state-to-state transitions in H$_{2}$O + H$_{2}$O collisions

Authors: Bikramaditya Mandal, Dmitri Babikov

Abstract: Aim: We present an improved database of temperature dependent rate coefficients for rotational state-to-state transitions in H$_{2}$O + H$_{2}$O collisions. The database includes 231 transitions between the lower $para$- and 210 transitions between the lower $ortho$-states of H$_{2}$O (up to $j=7$) and can be employed for cometary and planetary applications up to the temperature of 1000 K. Metho… ▽ More Aim: We present an improved database of temperature dependent rate coefficients for rotational state-to-state transitions in H$_{2}$O + H$_{2}$O collisions. The database includes 231 transitions between the lower $para$- and 210 transitions between the lower $ortho$-states of H$_{2}$O (up to $j=7$) and can be employed for cometary and planetary applications up to the temperature of 1000 K. Methods: New general method is developed and applied which permits to generate rate coefficients for excitation and quenching processes that automatically satisfy the principle of microscopic reversibility and, also, helps to cover the range of low collision energies by interpolation of cross sections between the process threshold and the computed data points. Results: It is found that in the range of intermediate temperatures, $150 < T < 600$ K, new rate coefficients are in good agreement with those reported earlier, but for higher temperatures, $600 < T < 1000$ K, the new revised temperature dependence is recommended. The low temperature range, $5 < T < 150$ K, is now covered, by the abovementioned interpolation of cross sections down to the process threshold. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Mixed Quantum/Classical Theory for Rotational Energy Exchange in Symmetric-Top-Rotor + Linear-Rotor Collisions and a Case Study of $ \rm ND_3 + \rm D_2$ System

Authors: Carolin Joy, Bikramaditya Mandal, Dulat Bostan, Dmitri Babikov

Abstract: The extension of mixed quantum/classical theory (MQCT) to describe collisional energy transfer is developed for symmetric-top-rotor + linear-rotor system type and is applied to $ \rm ND_3 + \rm D_2 $. State-to-state transition cross sections are computed in a broad energy range for all possible processes: when both $ \rm ND_3$ and $ \rm D_2$ molecules are excited or both are quenched, when one is… ▽ More The extension of mixed quantum/classical theory (MQCT) to describe collisional energy transfer is developed for symmetric-top-rotor + linear-rotor system type and is applied to $ \rm ND_3 + \rm D_2 $. State-to-state transition cross sections are computed in a broad energy range for all possible processes: when both $ \rm ND_3$ and $ \rm D_2$ molecules are excited or both are quenched, when one is excited while the other is quenched and vice versa, when $ \rm ND_3 $ state changes its parity while $ \rm D_2 $ is excited or quenched, and when $ \rm ND_3 $ is excited or quenched while $ \rm D_2 $ remains in the same state, ground or excited. In all these processes the results of MQCT are found to approximately satisfy the principle of microscopic reversibility. For a set of sixteen state-to-state transitions available from literature for collision energy $ \rm 800 cm^{-1} $ the values of cross sections predicted by MQCT are within 8% of accurate full-quantum results. A useful time-dependent insight is obtained by monitoring the evolution of state populations along MQCT trajectories. It is shown that, if before the collision, $ \rm D_2 $ is in its ground state, the excitation of to $ \rm ND_3 $ rotational states proceeds through a two-step mechanism in which the kinetic energy of molecule-molecule collision is first used to excite $ \rm D_2 $ and only then is transferred to the excited rotational states of to $ \rm ND_3 $. It is found that both potential coupling and Coriolis coupling play important roles in $ \rm ND_3 + \rm D_2 $collisions. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: Submitted to journal of Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics

Adapting the HHL algorithm to quantum many-body theory

Authors: Nishanth Baskaran, Abhishek Singh Rawat, Akshaya Jayashankar, Dibyajyoti Chakravarti, K. Sugisaki, Shibdas Roy, Sudhindu Bikash Mandal, D. Mukherjee, V. S. Prasannaa

Abstract: Rapid progress in developing near- and long-term quantum algorithms for quantum chemistry has provided us with an impetus to move beyond traditional approaches and explore new ways to apply quantum computing to electronic structure calculations. In this work, we identify the connection between quantum many-body theory and a quantum linear solver, and implement the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algor… ▽ More Rapid progress in developing near- and long-term quantum algorithms for quantum chemistry has provided us with an impetus to move beyond traditional approaches and explore new ways to apply quantum computing to electronic structure calculations. In this work, we identify the connection between quantum many-body theory and a quantum linear solver, and implement the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm to make precise predictions of correlation energies for light molecular systems via the (non-unitary) linearised coupled cluster theory. We alter the HHL algorithm to integrate two novel aspects- (a) we prescribe a novel scaling approach that allows one to scale any arbitrary symmetric positive definite matrix A, to solve for Ax = b and achieve x with reasonable precision, all the while without having to compute the eigenvalues of A, and (b) we devise techniques that reduce the depth of the overall circuit. In this context, we introduce the following variants of HHL for different eras of quantum computing- AdaptHHLite in its appropriate forms for noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ), late-NISQ, and the early fault-tolerant eras, as well as AdaptHHL for the fault-tolerant quantum computing era. We demonstrate the ability of the NISQ variant of AdaptHHLite to capture correlation energy precisely, while simultaneously being resource-lean, using simulation as well as the 11-qubit IonQ quantum hardware. △ Less

Submitted 9 November, 2023; v1 submitted 30 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Journal ref: Published in Phys. Rev. Research 5, 043113 (2023)

Double Hodge Theory for a particle on Torus

Authors: Vipul Kumar Pandey, Bhabani Prasad Mandal

Abstract: We investigate all possible nilpotent symmetries for a particle on torus. We explicitly construct four independent nilpotent BRST symmetries for such systems and derive the algebra between the generators of such symmetries. We show that such a system has rich mathematical properties and behaves as double Hodge theory. We further construct the finite field dependent BRST transformation for such sys… ▽ More We investigate all possible nilpotent symmetries for a particle on torus. We explicitly construct four independent nilpotent BRST symmetries for such systems and derive the algebra between the generators of such symmetries. We show that such a system has rich mathematical properties and behaves as double Hodge theory. We further construct the finite field dependent BRST transformation for such systems by integrating the infinitesimal BRST transformation systematically. Such a finite transformation is useful in realizing the various theories with toric geometry. △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 14 pages. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1308.0982, text overlap with arXiv:hep-th/0312073 by other authors

Journal ref: Adv. in High Energy Physics, 10, 1155 (2017)

BRST Symmetry for Torus Knot

Authors: Vipul Kumar Pandey, Bhabani Prasad Mandal

Abstract: We develop BRST symmetry for the first time for a particle on the surface of a torus knot by analyzing the constraints of the system. The theory contains $2^{nd}$ class constraints and has been extended by introducing Wess-Zumino term to the convert it into a theory with first class constraints. BFV analysis of the extended theory is performed to construct BRST/anti-BRST symmetries for the particl… ▽ More We develop BRST symmetry for the first time for a particle on the surface of a torus knot by analyzing the constraints of the system. The theory contains $2^{nd}$ class constraints and has been extended by introducing Wess-Zumino term to the convert it into a theory with first class constraints. BFV analysis of the extended theory is performed to construct BRST/anti-BRST symmetries for the particle on torus knot. The nilpotent BRST/anti-BRST charges which generate such symmetries are constructed explicitly. The states annihilated by these nilpotent charges consist the physical Hilbert space. We indicate how various effective theories on the surface of the torus knot are related through the generalized version of BRST transformation with finite field dependent parameters. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2017; v1 submitted 8 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 10 pages, Revised version

Journal ref: Euro Phys. Lett. 119, 31003 (2017)

Comments on interactions in the SUSY models

Authors: Sudhaker Upadhyay, Alexander Reshetnyak, Bhabani Prasad Mandal

Abstract: We consider special supersymmetry (SUSY) transformations with $m$ generators $\overleftarrow{s}_{α}$ for a certain class of models and study some physical consequences of Grassmann-odd transformations which form an Abelian supergroup with finite parameters and respective group-like elements being functionals of field variables. The SUSY-invariant path integral measure within conventional quantizat… ▽ More We consider special supersymmetry (SUSY) transformations with $m$ generators $\overleftarrow{s}_{α}$ for a certain class of models and study some physical consequences of Grassmann-odd transformations which form an Abelian supergroup with finite parameters and respective group-like elements being functionals of field variables. The SUSY-invariant path integral measure within conventional quantization implies the appearance, under a change of variables related to such SUSY transformations, of a Jacobian which is explicitly calculated. The Jacobian implies, first of all, the appearance of trivial interactions in the transformed action, and, second, the presence of a modified Ward identity which reduces to the standard Ward identities in the case of constant parameters. We examine the case of ${N}=1$ and $N=2$ supersymmetric harmonic oscillators to illustrate the general concept by a simple free model with $(1,1)$ physical degrees of freedom. It is shown that the interaction terms $U_{tr}$ have a corresponding SUSY-exact form: $U_{tr}=% \big(V_{(1)}\overleftarrow{s};V_{(2)}\overleftarrow{\bar{s}}\overleftarrow{s}% \big)$ naturally generated in this generalized formulation. We argue that the case of non-trivial interactions cannot be obtained in such a way. △ Less

Submitted 1 July, 2016; v1 submitted 5 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: Final version, to appear in EPJC

Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. C (2016) 76:391

A black potential for spin less particles

Authors: Ananya Ghatak, Mohammad Hasan, Bhabani Prasad Mandal

Abstract: We consider the most general non-Hermitian Hulthen potential to study the scattering of spin-less relativistic particles. The conditions for CC, SS and CPA are obtained analytically for this potential. We show that almost total absorption occurs for entire range of incidence energy for certain parameter ranges of the potential and hence term this as `black potential'. Time reversed of the same pot… ▽ More We consider the most general non-Hermitian Hulthen potential to study the scattering of spin-less relativistic particles. The conditions for CC, SS and CPA are obtained analytically for this potential. We show that almost total absorption occurs for entire range of incidence energy for certain parameter ranges of the potential and hence term this as `black potential'. Time reversed of the same potential shows perfect emission for the entire range of particle energy. We also present the classical analog of this potential in terms of waveguide cross section. △ Less

Submitted 2 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: Latex, 23 pages, 7 Figs

Journal ref: Phys. Lett. A 379, 1326 (2015)

Statistical Mechanics of DNA Rupture: Theory and Simulations

Authors: S. Nath, T. Modi, R. K. Mishra, D. Giri, B. P. Mandal, S. Kumar

Abstract: We study the effects of the shear force on the rupture mechanism on a double stranded DNA. Motivated by recent experiments, we perform the atomistic simulations with explicit solvent to obtain the distributions of extension in hydrogen and covalent bonds below the rupture force. We obtain a significant difference between the atomistic simulations and the existing results in the iterature based on… ▽ More We study the effects of the shear force on the rupture mechanism on a double stranded DNA. Motivated by recent experiments, we perform the atomistic simulations with explicit solvent to obtain the distributions of extension in hydrogen and covalent bonds below the rupture force. We obtain a significant difference between the atomistic simulations and the existing results in the iterature based on the coarse-grained models (theory and simulations). We discuss the possible reasons and improve the coarse-grained model by incorporating the consequences of semi-microscopic details of the nucleotides in its description. The distributions obtained by the modified model (simulations and theoretical) are qualitatively similar to the one obtained using atomistic simulations. △ Less

Submitted 8 October, 2013; v1 submitted 5 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 18 pages, 9 figures. Accepted in J. Chem. Phys. (2013). arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1104.3059

Comment on "Gauge transformations are Canonical transformations"

Authors: Pathikrit Bhattacharya, Bhabani Prasad Mandal

Abstract: We comment on the work of Tai L Chow, Eur. J. Phys. 18, 467 (1997). By considering the Lagrangians which are uniquely defined only to within an additive total time derivative of a function of co-ordinates and time the author has tried to show that the gauge transformations which relate these Lagrangians are canonical transformations. He has obtained the right conclusion only by using wrong canon… ▽ More We comment on the work of Tai L Chow, Eur. J. Phys. 18, 467 (1997). By considering the Lagrangians which are uniquely defined only to within an additive total time derivative of a function of co-ordinates and time the author has tried to show that the gauge transformations which relate these Lagrangians are canonical transformations. He has obtained the right conclusion only by using wrong canonical equations and the entire exercise has hence become erroneous and inconclusive. By using the definition of canonical transformation through Poisson brackets we prove that the above gauge transformations are canonical transformations. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2006; originally announced April 2006.

Comments: 2 pages, latex