-
Dual Euler--Poincaré/Lie--Poisson formulation of subinertial stratified thermal ocean flow with identification of Casimirs as Noether quantities
Authors:
Francisco J. Beron-Vera,
Erwin Luesink
Abstract:
This paper investigates the geometric structure of a quasigeostrophic approximation to a recently introduced reduced-gravity thermal rotating shallow-water model that accounts for stratification. Specifically, it considers a low-frequency approximation of a model for flow above the ocean thermocline, governed by primitive equations with buoyancy variations in both horizontal and vertical direction…
▽ More
This paper investigates the geometric structure of a quasigeostrophic approximation to a recently introduced reduced-gravity thermal rotating shallow-water model that accounts for stratification. Specifically, it considers a low-frequency approximation of a model for flow above the ocean thermocline, governed by primitive equations with buoyancy variations in both horizontal and vertical directions. Like the thermal model, the stratified variant generates circulation patterns reminiscent of submesoscale instabilities visible in satellite images. An improvement is its ability to model mixed-layer restratification due to baroclinic instability.
The primary contribution of this paper is to demonstrate that the model is derived from an Euler--Poincaré variational principle, culminating in a Kelvin--Noether theorem, previously established solely for the primitive-equation parent model. The model's Lie--Poisson Hamiltonian structure, earlier obtained through direct calculation, is shown to result from a Legendre transform with the associated geometry elucidated by identifying the relevant momentum map.
Another significant contribution of this paper is the identification of the Casimirs of the Lie--Poisson system, including a newly found weaker Casimir family forming the kernel of the Lie--Poisson bracket, which results in potential vorticity evolution independent of buoyancy details as it advects under the flow. These conservation laws related to particle relabeling symmetry are explicitly linked to Noether quantities from the Euler--Poincaré principle when variations are not constrained to vanish at integration endpoints.
The dual Euler--Poincaré/Lie--Poisson formalism provides a unified framework for describing quasigeostrophic reduced-gravity stratified thermal flow, mirroring the approach used in the primitive-equation setting.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2024; v1 submitted 6 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Critical latitude in global quasi-geostrophic flow on a rotating sphere
Authors:
Arnout Franken,
Erwin Luesink,
Sagy Ephrati,
Bernard Geurts
Abstract:
In this paper, we study geostrophic turbulence without external forcing or dissipation, using a Casimir-preserving numerical method. The research examines the formation of large zonal jets, common in geophysical flows, especially in giant gas planets. These jets form due to the east-west stretching of vortices, influenced by the gradient of the Coriolis parameter, leading to a critical latitude be…
▽ More
In this paper, we study geostrophic turbulence without external forcing or dissipation, using a Casimir-preserving numerical method. The research examines the formation of large zonal jets, common in geophysical flows, especially in giant gas planets. These jets form due to the east-west stretching of vortices, influenced by the gradient of the Coriolis parameter, leading to a critical latitude beyond which jets do not form.
Using a global quasi-geostrophic model with a fully latitude-dependent Coriolis parameter, we investigate this critical latitude, which is theorized to depend only on the product of the Rossby number and the Lamb parameter. By simulating random flow fields, the critical latitude was identified through zonally averaged zonal velocity profiles.
Results align with geostrophic theory, especially near typical Rossby and Lamb parameter values for Earth's atmosphere. However, in the regime of weak rotation (high Rossby numbers) and strong stratification (high Lamb values), no clear critical latitude emerges; instead, zonal jet amplitude and width decrease gradually towards the poles. This research paves the way for further study of jet dynamics under a fully latitude-dependent Coriolis parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Casimir preserving numerical method for global multilayer geostrophic turbulence
Authors:
Arnout Franken,
Erwin Luesink,
Sagy Ephrati,
Bernard Geurts
Abstract:
Accurate long-term predictions of large-scale flow features on planets are crucial for understanding global atmospheric and oceanic systems, necessitating the development of numerical methods that can preserve essential physical structures over extended simulation periods without excessive computational costs. Recent advancements in the study of global single-layer barotropic models have led to no…
▽ More
Accurate long-term predictions of large-scale flow features on planets are crucial for understanding global atmospheric and oceanic systems, necessitating the development of numerical methods that can preserve essential physical structures over extended simulation periods without excessive computational costs. Recent advancements in the study of global single-layer barotropic models have led to novel numerical methods based on Lie-Poisson discretization that preserve energy, enstrophy and higher-order moments of potential vorticity. This work extends this approach to more complex stratified quasi-geostrophic (QG) systems on the sphere.
In this work, we present a formulation of the multi-layer QG equations on the full globe. This allows for extending the Lie-Poisson discretization to multi-layer QG models, ensuring consistency with the underlying structure and enabling long-term simulations without additional regularization. The numerical method is benchmarked through simulations of forced geostrophic turbulence and the long-term behaviour of unforced multi-layered systems. These results demonstrate the structure-preserving properties and robustness of the proposed numerical method, paving the way for a better understanding of the role of high-order conserved quantities in large-scale geophysical flow dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Geometric derivation and structure-preserving simulation of quasi-geostrophy on the sphere
Authors:
Erwin Luesink,
Arnout Franken,
Sagy Ephrati,
Bernard Geurts
Abstract:
We present a geometric derivation of the quasi-geostrophic equations on the sphere, starting from the rotating shallow water equations. We utilise perturbation series methods in vorticity and divergence variables. The derivation employs asymptotic analysis techniques, leading to a global quasi-geostrophic potential vorticity model on the sphere without approximation of the Coriolis parameter. The…
▽ More
We present a geometric derivation of the quasi-geostrophic equations on the sphere, starting from the rotating shallow water equations. We utilise perturbation series methods in vorticity and divergence variables. The derivation employs asymptotic analysis techniques, leading to a global quasi-geostrophic potential vorticity model on the sphere without approximation of the Coriolis parameter. The resulting model forms a closed system for the evolution of potential vorticity with a rich mathematical structure, including Lagrangian and Hamiltonian descriptions. Formulated using the Lie-Poisson bracket reveals the geometric invariants of the quasi-geostrophic model. Motivated by these geometric results, simulations of quasi-geostrophic flow on the sphere are presented based on structure-preserving Lie-Poisson time-integration. We explicitly demonstrate the preservation of Casimir invariants and show that the hyperbolic quasi-geostrophic equations can be simulated in a stable manner over long time. We show the emergence of longitudonal jets, wrapped around the circumference of the sphere in a general direction that is perpendicular to the axis of rotation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
A continuous data assimilation closure for modeling statistically steady turbulence in large-eddy simulation
Authors:
Sagy Ephrati,
Arnout Franken,
Erwin Luesink,
Paolo Cifani,
Bernard Geurts
Abstract:
A closure model is presented for large-eddy simulation (LES) based on the three-dimensional variational data assimilation algorithm. The approach aims at reconstructing high-fidelity kinetic energy spectra in coarse numerical simulations by including feedback control to represent unresolved dynamics interactions in the flow as stochastic processes. The forcing uses statistics obtained from offline…
▽ More
A closure model is presented for large-eddy simulation (LES) based on the three-dimensional variational data assimilation algorithm. The approach aims at reconstructing high-fidelity kinetic energy spectra in coarse numerical simulations by including feedback control to represent unresolved dynamics interactions in the flow as stochastic processes. The forcing uses statistics obtained from offline high-fidelity data and requires only few parameters compared to the number of degrees of freedom of LES. This modeling strategy is applied to geostrophic turbulence on the sphere and enables simulating indefinitely at reduced costs. It proves to accurately recover the energy spectra and the zonal velocity profiles in the coarse model, for three generic situations.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2024; v1 submitted 20 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Stochastic Geometric Mechanics for Fluid Dynamics
Authors:
Darryl D. Holm,
Erwin Luesink
Abstract:
Stochastic geometric mechanics (SGM) is known for its potential utility in quantifying uncertainty in global climate modelling of the Earth's ocean and atmosphere while also preserving the fundamental advective transport properties of ideal fluid flow. The present chapter describes the mathematical development of the framework of stochastic geometric mechanics in the context of fluid flow and wave…
▽ More
Stochastic geometric mechanics (SGM) is known for its potential utility in quantifying uncertainty in global climate modelling of the Earth's ocean and atmosphere while also preserving the fundamental advective transport properties of ideal fluid flow. The present chapter describes the mathematical development of the framework of stochastic geometric mechanics in the context of fluid flow and wave dynamics obtained from Lie group-invariant variational principles.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
An explicit method to determine Casimirs in 2D geophysical flows
Authors:
Erwin Luesink,
Bernard Geurts
Abstract:
Conserved quantities in geophysical flows play an important role in the characterisation of geophysical dynamics and aid the development of structure-preserving numerical methods. A significant family of conserved quantities is formed by the Casimirs i.e., integral conservation laws that are in the kernel of the underlying Poisson bracket. The Casimirs hence determine the geometric structure of th…
▽ More
Conserved quantities in geophysical flows play an important role in the characterisation of geophysical dynamics and aid the development of structure-preserving numerical methods. A significant family of conserved quantities is formed by the Casimirs i.e., integral conservation laws that are in the kernel of the underlying Poisson bracket. The Casimirs hence determine the geometric structure of the geophysical fluid equations among which the enstrophy is well known. Often Casimirs are proposed on heuristic grounds and later verified to be part of the kernel of the Poisson bracket. In this work, we will explicitly construct Casimirs by rewriting the Poisson bracket in vorticity-divergence coordinates thereby providing explicit construction of Casimirs for 2D geophysical flow dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2023; v1 submitted 23 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Casimir preserving spectrum of two-dimensional turbulence
Authors:
Paolo Cifani,
Milo Viviani,
Erwin Luesink,
Klas Modin,
Bernard J. Geurts
Abstract:
We present predictions of the energy spectrum of forced two-dimensional turbulence obtained by employing a structure-preserving integrator. In particular, we construct a finite-mode approximation of the Navier-Stokes equations on the unit sphere, which, in the limit of vanishing viscosity, preserves the Lie-Poisson structure. As a result, integrated powers of vorticity are conserved in the invisci…
▽ More
We present predictions of the energy spectrum of forced two-dimensional turbulence obtained by employing a structure-preserving integrator. In particular, we construct a finite-mode approximation of the Navier-Stokes equations on the unit sphere, which, in the limit of vanishing viscosity, preserves the Lie-Poisson structure. As a result, integrated powers of vorticity are conserved in the inviscid limit. We obtain robust evidence for the existence of the double energy cascade, including the formation of the -3 scaling of the inertial range of the direct cascade. We show that this can be achieved at modest resolutions compared to those required by traditional numerical methods.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2022; v1 submitted 25 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Data-driven stochastic Lie transport modelling of the 2D Euler equations
Authors:
Sagy Ephrati,
Paolo Cifani,
Erwin Luesink,
Bernard Geurts
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose and assess several stochastic parametrizations for data-driven modelling of the two-dimensional Euler equations using coarse-grid SPDEs. The framework of Stochastic Advection by Lie Transport (SALT) [Cotter et al., 2019] is employed to define a stochastic forcing that is decomposed in terms of a deterministic basis (empirical orthogonal functions, EOFs) multiplied by temp…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose and assess several stochastic parametrizations for data-driven modelling of the two-dimensional Euler equations using coarse-grid SPDEs. The framework of Stochastic Advection by Lie Transport (SALT) [Cotter et al., 2019] is employed to define a stochastic forcing that is decomposed in terms of a deterministic basis (empirical orthogonal functions, EOFs) multiplied by temporal traces, here regarded as stochastic processes. The EOFs are obtained from a fine-grid data set and are defined in conjunction with corresponding deterministic time series. We construct stochastic processes that mimic properties of the measured time series. In particular, the processes are defined such that the underlying probability density functions (pdfs) or the estimated correlation time of the time series are retained. These stochastic models are compared to stochastic forcing based on Gaussian noise, which does not use any information of the time series. We perform uncertainty quantification tests and compare stochastic ensembles in terms of mean and spread. Reduced uncertainty is observed for the developed models. On short timescales, such as those used for data assimilation [Cotter et al., 2020], the stochastic models show a reduced ensemble mean error and a reduced spread. Particularly, using estimated pdfs yields stochastic ensembles which rarely fail to capture the reference solution on small time scales, whereas introducing correlation into the stochastic models improves the quality of the coarse-grid predictions with respect to Gaussian noise.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2022; v1 submitted 25 March, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Computational modeling for high-fidelity coarsening of shallow water equations based on subgrid data
Authors:
Sagy Ephrati,
Erwin Luesink,
Golo Wimmer,
Paolo Cifani,
Bernard Geurts
Abstract:
Small-scale features of shallow water flow obtained from direct numerical simulation (DNS) with two different computational codes for the shallow water equations are gathered offline and subsequently employed with the aim of constructing a reduced-order correction. This is used to facilitate high-fidelity online flow predictions at much reduced costs on coarse meshes. The resolved small-scale feat…
▽ More
Small-scale features of shallow water flow obtained from direct numerical simulation (DNS) with two different computational codes for the shallow water equations are gathered offline and subsequently employed with the aim of constructing a reduced-order correction. This is used to facilitate high-fidelity online flow predictions at much reduced costs on coarse meshes. The resolved small-scale features at high resolution represent subgrid properties for the coarse representation. Measurements of the subgrid dynamics are obtained as the difference between the evolution of a coarse grid solution and the corresponding DNS result. The measurements are sensitive to the particular numerical methods used for the simulation on coarse computational grids and can be used to approximately correct the associated discretization errors. The subgrid features are decomposed into empirical orthogonal functions (EOFs), after which a corresponding correction term is constructed. By increasing the number of EOFs in the approximation of the measured values the correction term can in principle be made arbitrarily accurate. Both computational methods investigated here show a significant decrease in the simulation error already when applying the correction based on the dominant EOFs only. The error reduction accounts for the particular discretization errors that incur and are hence specific to the particular simulation method that is adopted. This improvement is also observed for very coarse grids which may be used for computational model reduction in geophysical and turbulent flow problems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2022; v1 submitted 15 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Stochastic geometric mechanics with diffeomorphisms
Authors:
Darryl D. Holm,
Erwin Luesink
Abstract:
Noether's celebrated theorem associating symmetry and conservation laws in classical field theory is adapted to allow for broken symmetry in geometric mechanics and is shown to play a central role in deriving and understanding the generation of fluid circulation via the Kelvin-Noether theorem for ideal fluids with stochastic advection by Lie transport (SALT).
Noether's celebrated theorem associating symmetry and conservation laws in classical field theory is adapted to allow for broken symmetry in geometric mechanics and is shown to play a central role in deriving and understanding the generation of fluid circulation via the Kelvin-Noether theorem for ideal fluids with stochastic advection by Lie transport (SALT).
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Stochastic mesoscale circulation dynamics in the thermal ocean
Authors:
Darryl D. Holm,
Erwin Luesink,
Wei Pan
Abstract:
In analogy with similar effects in adiabatic compressible fluid dynamics, the effects of buoyancy gradients on incompressible stratified flows are said to be `thermal'. The thermal rotating shallow water (TRSW) model equations contain three small nondimensional parameters. These are the Rossby number, the Froude number and the buoyancy parameter. Asymptotic expansion of the TRSW model equations in…
▽ More
In analogy with similar effects in adiabatic compressible fluid dynamics, the effects of buoyancy gradients on incompressible stratified flows are said to be `thermal'. The thermal rotating shallow water (TRSW) model equations contain three small nondimensional parameters. These are the Rossby number, the Froude number and the buoyancy parameter. Asymptotic expansion of the TRSW model equations in these three small parameters leads to the deterministic thermal versions of the Salmon's L1 (TL1) model and the thermal quasi-geostrophic (TQG) model, upon expanding in the neighbourhood of thermal quasi-geostrophic balance among the flow velocity and the gradients of free surface elevation and buoyancy. The linear instability of TQG at high wave number tends to create circulation at small scales. Such a high wave number instability could be unresolvable in many computational simulations, but its presence at small scales may contribute significantly to fluid transport at resolvable scales. Sometimes such effects are modelled via `stochastic backscatter of kinetic energy'. Here we try another approach. Namely, we model `stochastic transport' in the hierarchy of models TRSW/TL1/TQG. The models are derived via the approach of stochastic advection by Lie transport (SALT) as obtained from a recently introduced stochastic version of the Euler--Poincaré variational principle. We also indicate the potential next steps for applying these models in uncertainty quantification and data assimilation of the rapid, high wavenumber effects of buoyancy fronts at these three levels of description by using the data-driven stochastic parametrisation algorithms derived previously using the SALT approach.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2020; v1 submitted 10 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Stochastic wave-current interaction in thermal shallow water dynamics
Authors:
Darryl D Holm,
Erwin Luesink
Abstract:
Holm (Proc. Roy. Soc 2015) introduced a variational framework for stochastically parametrising unresolved scales of hydrodynamic motion. This variational framework preserves fundamental features of fluid dynamics, such as Kelvin's circulation theorem, while also allowing for dispersive nonlinear wave propagation, both within a stratified fluid and at its free surface. The present paper combines as…
▽ More
Holm (Proc. Roy. Soc 2015) introduced a variational framework for stochastically parametrising unresolved scales of hydrodynamic motion. This variational framework preserves fundamental features of fluid dynamics, such as Kelvin's circulation theorem, while also allowing for dispersive nonlinear wave propagation, both within a stratified fluid and at its free surface. The present paper combines asymptotic expansions and vertical averaging with the stochastic variational framework to formulate a new approach for developing stochastic parametrisation schemes for nonlinear wave fields. The approach is applied to a variety of shallow water equations which descend from Euler's three-dimensional fluid equations with rotation and stratification under approximation by asymptotic expansions and vertical averaging. In the entire family of nonlinear stochastic wave-current interaction equations derived here using this approach, Kelvin's circulation theorem reveals a barotropic mechanism for wave generation of horizontal circulation or convection (cyclogenesis) which is activated whenever the gradients of wave elevation and/or topography are not aligned with the gradient of the vertically averaged buoyancy.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2020; v1 submitted 23 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Lyapunov Exponents of Two Stochastic Lorenz 63 Systems
Authors:
Bernard J. Geurts,
Darryl D. Holm,
Erwin Luesink
Abstract:
Two different types of perturbations of the Lorenz 63 dynamical system for Rayleigh-Benard convection by multiplicative noise -- called stochastic advection by Lie transport (SALT) noise and fluctuation-dissipation (FD) noise -- are found to produce qualitatively different effects, possibly because the total phase-space volume contraction rates are different. In the process of making this comparis…
▽ More
Two different types of perturbations of the Lorenz 63 dynamical system for Rayleigh-Benard convection by multiplicative noise -- called stochastic advection by Lie transport (SALT) noise and fluctuation-dissipation (FD) noise -- are found to produce qualitatively different effects, possibly because the total phase-space volume contraction rates are different. In the process of making this comparison between effects of SALT and FD noise on the Lorenz 63 system, a stochastic version of a robust deterministic numerical algorithm for obtaining the individual numerical Lyapunov exponents was developed. With this stochastic version of the algorithm, the value of the sum of the Lyapunov exponents for the FD noise was found to differ significantly from the value of the deterministic Lorenz 63 system, whereas the SALT noise preserves the Lorenz 63 value with high accuracy. The Lagrangian averaged version of the SALT equations (LA SALT) is found to yield a closed deterministic subsystem for the expected solutions which is found to be isomorphic to the original Lorenz 63 dynamical system. The solutions of the closed chaotic subsystem, in turn, drive a linear stochastic system for the fluctuations of the LA SALT solutions around their expected values.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2019; v1 submitted 19 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
