-
Morphology and stability of droplets sliding on soft viscoelastic substrates
Authors:
Mathieu Oléron,
Laurent Limat,
Julien Dervaux,
Matthieu Roché
Abstract:
We show that energy dissipation partition between a liquid and a solid controls the shape and stability of droplets sliding on viscoelastic gels. When both phases dissipate energy equally, droplet dynamics is similar to that on rigid solids. When only the solid dissipate, we observe an apparent contact angle hysteresis, of viscoelastic origin. We find excellent agreement between our data and a non…
▽ More
We show that energy dissipation partition between a liquid and a solid controls the shape and stability of droplets sliding on viscoelastic gels. When both phases dissipate energy equally, droplet dynamics is similar to that on rigid solids. When only the solid dissipate, we observe an apparent contact angle hysteresis, of viscoelastic origin. We find excellent agreement between our data and a non-linear model of the wetting of gels of our own that also indicates the presence of significant slip. Our work opens general questions on the dynamics of curved contact lines on compliant substrates.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2023; v1 submitted 10 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Circular hydraulic jumps: where does surface tension matter?
Authors:
Alexis Duchesne,
Laurent Limat
Abstract:
Recently, an unusual scaling law has been observed in circular hydraulic jumps and has been attributed to a supposed missing term in the local energy balance of the flow [\cite{bhagat_2018}]. In this paper, we show that - though the experimental observation is valuable and interesting - this interpretation is presumably not the good one. When transposed to the case of a axial sheet formed by two i…
▽ More
Recently, an unusual scaling law has been observed in circular hydraulic jumps and has been attributed to a supposed missing term in the local energy balance of the flow [\cite{bhagat_2018}]. In this paper, we show that - though the experimental observation is valuable and interesting - this interpretation is presumably not the good one. When transposed to the case of a axial sheet formed by two impinging liquid jets, the assumed principle leads in fact to a velocity distribution in contradiction with the present knowledge for this kind of flows. We show here how to correct this approach by keeping consistency with surface tension thermodynamics: for Savart-Taylor sheets, when adequately corrected, we recover the well known $1/r$ liquid thickness with a constant and uniform velocity dictated by Bernoulli's principle.
In the case of circular hydraulic jumps, we propose here a simple approach based on Watson description of the flow in the central region [\cite{Watson_JFM}]], combined with appropriate boundary conditions on the formed circular front. Depending on the specific condition, we find in turn the new scaling by \cite{bhagat_2018} and the more conventional scaling law found long ago by \cite{Bohr_1993}. We clarify here a few situations in which one should hold rather than the other, hoping to reconcile Bhagat et al. observations with the present knowledge of circular hydraulic jump modeling. However, the question of a possible critical Froude number imposed at the jump exit and dictating logarithmic corrections to scaling remains an opened and unsolved question.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Spreading of granular suspensions on a solid surface
Authors:
Menghua Zhao,
Alice Pelosse,
Mathieu Oléron,
Laurent Limat,
Elisabeth Guazzelli,
Matthieu Roché
Abstract:
We examine the spreading of a suspension of non-Brownian spheres suspended in a Newtonian liquid on a solid substrate. We show that the spreading dynamics is well described by the classical Cox-Voinov law provided the value of the fluid viscosity that arises in the capillary number of the problem is adjusted to a value that depends on particle size and volume fraction in a non-trivial way. We demo…
▽ More
We examine the spreading of a suspension of non-Brownian spheres suspended in a Newtonian liquid on a solid substrate. We show that the spreading dynamics is well described by the classical Cox-Voinov law provided the value of the fluid viscosity that arises in the capillary number of the problem is adjusted to a value that depends on particle size and volume fraction in a non-trivial way. We demonstrate that this behavior is a signature of the ability of the particles to approach the contact line close enough to affect dissipation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2020; v1 submitted 10 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
A criterion for the pinning and depinning of an advancing contact line on a cold substrate
Authors:
Rémy Herbaut,
Julien Dervaux,
Philippe Brunet,
Laurent Royon,
Laurent Limat
Abstract:
The influence of solidification on the spreading of liquids is addressed in the situation of an advancing liquid wedge on a cold substrate at $T_p < T_f$, of infinite thermal conductivity, where $T_f$ is the melting temperature. We propose a model derived from lubrication theory of contact-line dynamics, where an equilibrium between capillary pressure and viscous stress is at play, adapted here fo…
▽ More
The influence of solidification on the spreading of liquids is addressed in the situation of an advancing liquid wedge on a cold substrate at $T_p < T_f$, of infinite thermal conductivity, where $T_f$ is the melting temperature. We propose a model derived from lubrication theory of contact-line dynamics, where an equilibrium between capillary pressure and viscous stress is at play, adapted here for the geometry of a quadruple line where the vapour, liquid, solidified liquid and basal substrate meet. The Stefan thermal problem is solved in an intermediate region between molecular and mesoscopic scales, allowing to predict the shape of the solidified liquid surface. The apparent contact angle versus advancing velocity $U$ exhibits a minimal value, which is set as the transition from continuous advancing to pinning. We postulate that this transition corresponds to the experimentally observed critical velocity, dependent on undercooling temperature $T_f-T_p$, below which the liquid is pinned and advances with stick-slip dynamics. The analytical solution of the model shows a qualitatively fair agreement with experimental data. We discuss on the way to get better quantitative agreement, which in particular can be obtained when the mesoscopic cut-off length is made temperature-dependent.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Straight contact lines on a soft, incompressible solid
Authors:
Laurent Limat
Abstract:
The deformation of a soft substrate by a straight contact line is calculated, and the result applied to a static rivulet between two parallel contact lines. The substrate is supposed to be incompressible (Stokes like description of elasticity), and having a non-zero surface tension, that eventually differs depending on whether its surface is dry or wet. For a single straight line separating two do…
▽ More
The deformation of a soft substrate by a straight contact line is calculated, and the result applied to a static rivulet between two parallel contact lines. The substrate is supposed to be incompressible (Stokes like description of elasticity), and having a non-zero surface tension, that eventually differs depending on whether its surface is dry or wet. For a single straight line separating two domains with the same substrate surface tension, the ridge profile is shown to be be very close to that of Shanahan and de Gennes, but shift from the contact line of a distance equal to the elastocapillary length built upon substrate surface tension and shear modulus. As a result, the divergence near contact line disappears and is replaced by a balance of surface tensions at the contact line (Neumann equilibrium), though the profile remains nearly logarithmic. In the rivulet case, using the previous solution as a Green function allows one to calculate analytically the geometry of the distorted substrate, and in particular its slope on each side (wet and dry) of the contact lines. These two slopes are shown to be nearly proportional to the inverse of substrate surface tensions, though the respective weight of each side (wet and dry) in the final expressions is difficult to establish because of the linear nature of standard elasticity. A simple argument combining Neumann and Young equations is however provided to overcome this limitation. The result may have surprising implications for the modelling of hysteresis on systems having both plastic and elastic properties, as initiated long ago by Extrand and Kumagai.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Nonlinear force balance at moving contact lines
Authors:
Matthieu Roché,
Laurent Limat,
Julien Dervaux
Abstract:
The spreading of a liquid over a solid material is a key process in a wide range of applications. While this phenomenon is well understood when the solid is undeformable, its "soft" counterpart is still ill-understood and no consensus has been reached with regards to the physical mechanisms ruling the spreading of liquid drops over soft deformable materials. In this work we show that the motion of…
▽ More
The spreading of a liquid over a solid material is a key process in a wide range of applications. While this phenomenon is well understood when the solid is undeformable, its "soft" counterpart is still ill-understood and no consensus has been reached with regards to the physical mechanisms ruling the spreading of liquid drops over soft deformable materials. In this work we show that the motion of a triple line on a soft elastomer is opposed both by nonlinear localized capillary and visco-elastic forces. We give an explicit analytic formula relating the dynamic contact angle of a moving drop with its velocity for arbitrary rheology. We then specialize this formula to the experimentally relevant case of elastomers with Chasset-Thirion (power-law) type of rheologies. The theoretical prediction are in very good agreement with experimental data, without any adjustable parameters. Finally, we show that the nonlinear force balance presented in this work can also be used to recover the classical de Gennes model of wetting.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Corners in soft solids behave as defects in crystals
Authors:
Robin Masurel,
Matthieu Roché,
Laurent Limat,
Ioan Ionescu,
Julien Dervaux
Abstract:
All phases of matter, solid, liquid or gas, present some excess energy, compared to their bulk, at their interfaces with other materials. This excess of energy, known as the surface energy, is a fundamental property of matter and is involved in virtually all interface problems in science, from the shape of bubbles, crystals and biological cells to the delicate motion of some insects on water or th…
▽ More
All phases of matter, solid, liquid or gas, present some excess energy, compared to their bulk, at their interfaces with other materials. This excess of energy, known as the surface energy, is a fundamental property of matter and is involved in virtually all interface problems in science, from the shape of bubbles, crystals and biological cells to the delicate motion of some insects on water or the fluttering of red blood cells. Because of their high cohesive internal energies, the surface energies of solids differ fundamentally from those of fluids and depend on the solid deformations. This effect, known as the Shuttleworth effect, is well established for metals but is highly debated for amorphous materials such as glasses, elastomers or biological tissues with recent experimental results yielding strictly opposite conclusions with regards to its very existence. Using a combination of analytical results and numerical simulations, we show in this paper that those seemingly opposite results can be reconciled due to the existence of an analog of the Peach-Koehler force acting on the elastocapillary ridge and conclude that: i) there is no large Shuttleworth effect in soft elastomers and ii) the Neumann construction does not hold in elastowetting.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
A liquid contact line receding on a soft gel surface : dip-coating geometry investigation
Authors:
Tadashi Kajiya,
Philippe Brunet,
Laurent Royon,
Adrian Daerr,
Mathieu Receveur,
Laurent Limat
Abstract:
We studied the dynamics of a liquid contact line receding on a hydrophobic soft gel (SBS-paraffin). In order to realize a well-defined geometry with an accurate control of velocity, a dip-coating setup was implemented. Provided that the elastic modulus is small enough, a significant deformation takes place near the contact line, which in turn drastically influences the wetting behaviour. Depending…
▽ More
We studied the dynamics of a liquid contact line receding on a hydrophobic soft gel (SBS-paraffin). In order to realize a well-defined geometry with an accurate control of velocity, a dip-coating setup was implemented. Provided that the elastic modulus is small enough, a significant deformation takes place near the contact line, which in turn drastically influences the wetting behaviour. Depending on the translation velocity of the substrate, the contact line exhibits different regimes of motions. Continuous motions are observed at high and low velocities, meanwhile two types of stick-slip motion, periodic and erratic, appear at intermediate velocities. We suggest that the observed transitions could be explained in terms of the competition between different frequencies, i.e., the frequency of the strain field variation induced by the contact line motion and the crossover frequency of the gel related to the material relaxation. Our results provide systematic views on how the wetting of liquid is modified by the rheological properties of a complex soft substrate.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Constant Froude number in a circular hydraulic jump and its implication on the jump radius selection
Authors:
Alexis Duchesne,
Luc Lebon,
Laurent Limat
Abstract:
The properties of a standard hydraulic jump depend critically on a Froude number Fr defined as the ratio of the flow velocity to the gravity waves speed. In the case of a horizontal circular jump, the question of the Froude number is not well documented. Our experiments show that Fr measured just after the jump is locked on a constant value that does not depend on flow rate Q, kinematic viscosity…
▽ More
The properties of a standard hydraulic jump depend critically on a Froude number Fr defined as the ratio of the flow velocity to the gravity waves speed. In the case of a horizontal circular jump, the question of the Froude number is not well documented. Our experiments show that Fr measured just after the jump is locked on a constant value that does not depend on flow rate Q, kinematic viscosity ν and surface tension γ. Combining this result to a lubrication description of the outer flow yields, under appropriate conditions, a new and simple law ruling the jump radius RJ : $R_J (ln (\frac{R_\infty}{R_J}))^{3/8} \sim Q^{5/8}ν^{-3/8}$, in excellent agreement with our experimental data. This unexpected RJ result asks an unsolved question to all available models.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2014; v1 submitted 8 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Orbits and reversals of a drop rolling inside a horizontal circular hydraulic jump
Authors:
Alexis Duchesne,
Clément Savaro,
Luc Lebon,
Christophe Pirat,
Laurent Limat
Abstract:
We explore the complex dynamics of a non-coalescing drop of moderate size inside a circular hydraulic jump of the same liquid formed on a horizontal disk. In this situation the drop is moving along the jump and one observes two different motions: a periodic one (it orbitates at constant speed) and an irregular one involving reversals of the orbital motion. Modeling the drop as a rigid sphere excha…
▽ More
We explore the complex dynamics of a non-coalescing drop of moderate size inside a circular hydraulic jump of the same liquid formed on a horizontal disk. In this situation the drop is moving along the jump and one observes two different motions: a periodic one (it orbitates at constant speed) and an irregular one involving reversals of the orbital motion. Modeling the drop as a rigid sphere exchanging friction with liquid across a thin film of air, we recover the orbital motion and the internal rotation of the drop. This internal rotation is experimentally observed.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2013; v1 submitted 29 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Meandering rivulets on a plane: a simple balance between inertia and capillarity?
Authors:
Nolwenn Le Grand-Piteira,
Adrian Daerr,
Laurent Limat
Abstract:
Experiments on streams of water flowing down a rigid substrate have been performed for various plate inclinations and flow rates, and we focused on the regime of stationary meanders. The outcome is that (i) the flow is highly hysteretic : the shape of the meanders varies with flow rate only for increasing flow rates, and the straight rivulet regime does not appear for decreasing flow rate. (ii)…
▽ More
Experiments on streams of water flowing down a rigid substrate have been performed for various plate inclinations and flow rates, and we focused on the regime of stationary meanders. The outcome is that (i) the flow is highly hysteretic : the shape of the meanders varies with flow rate only for increasing flow rates, and the straight rivulet regime does not appear for decreasing flow rate. (ii) A simple force balance, including inertia, capillary forces, and also hysteresis of wetting, accounts well for the experimental instability threshold flow rate and for the final radius of curvature of the meanders.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2006; v1 submitted 11 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
Propagative waves pattern in a falling liquid curtain
Authors:
N. Le Grand,
P. Brunet,
L. Lebon,
L. Limat
Abstract:
We have preformed experiments on a liquid curtain falling from a horizontal, wetted, tube and lateraly constrained by two vertical wires. The fluid motion nearly reduces to a free-fall, with a very low detachment velocity below the tube. Thus, the curtain contains a large subsonic area, i.e. a domain where the sinuous waves travel faster than the fluid. The upper boundary not being constrained i…
▽ More
We have preformed experiments on a liquid curtain falling from a horizontal, wetted, tube and lateraly constrained by two vertical wires. The fluid motion nearly reduces to a free-fall, with a very low detachment velocity below the tube. Thus, the curtain contains a large subsonic area, i.e. a domain where the sinuous waves travel faster than the fluid. The upper boundary not being constrained in the transverse direction, we have observed the appearance of an up to now unreported instability when the flow rate is progressively reduced: the top of the curtain enters a pendulum-like motion, coupled to a propagative pattern of curtain undulations, structured as a chessboard. Measurements of the phase velocity and frequency of this pattern are reported. Data are in agreement with a simple dimensional argument suggesting that the wave velocity is proportional to the surface tension divided by the mass flux of liquid per unit length. This scaling is also that followed by the fluid velocity at the transonic point, i.e. the point where the fluid velocity equals that of sinuous waves. We finally discuss implications of these results on the global stability of falling curtains.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
