-
On the applicability of the actuator line method for unsteady aerodynamics
Authors:
Elías Alva,
Vitor G. Kleine,
André V. G. Cavalieri
Abstract:
We develop a linear theory for unsteady aerodynamic effects of the actuator line method (ALM). This theory is validated using ALM simulations, where we compute the lift generated by the harmonic transverse oscillation of a thin airfoil in uniform flow, comparing the results with Theodorsen's theory. This comparison elucidates the underlying characteristics and limitations of ALM when applied to un…
▽ More
We develop a linear theory for unsteady aerodynamic effects of the actuator line method (ALM). This theory is validated using ALM simulations, where we compute the lift generated by the harmonic transverse oscillation of a thin airfoil in uniform flow, comparing the results with Theodorsen's theory. This comparison elucidates the underlying characteristics and limitations of ALM when applied to unsteady aerodynamics. Numerical simulations were conducted across a range of chord lengths and oscillation frequencies. Comparison of ALM results with theoretical predictions shows consistent accuracy, with all Gaussian parameter choices yielding accurate results at low reduced frequencies. Furthermore, the study indicates that selecting a width parameter ratio of $\varepsilon/c$ (the Gaussian width parameter over the chord length) between 0.33 and 0.4 in ALM yields the closest alignment with analytical results across a broader frequency range. Additionally, a proper definition of angle of attack for a pitching airfoil is shown to be important for accurate computations. These findings offer valuable guidance for the application of ALM in unsteady aerodynamics and aeroelasticity.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2025; v1 submitted 28 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Simulating Airplane Aerodynamics with Body Forces: Actuator Line Method for Non-planar Wings
Authors:
Vitor G. Kleine,
Ardeshir Hanifi,
Dan S. Henningson
Abstract:
Two configurations typical of fixed-wing aircraft are simulated with the actuator line method (ALM): a wing with winglets and a T-tail. The ALM is extensively used in rotor simulations to model the blades by body forces, which are calculated from airfoil data and the relative flow velocity. This method has not been used to simulate airplane aerodynamics, despite its advantage of allowing coarser g…
▽ More
Two configurations typical of fixed-wing aircraft are simulated with the actuator line method (ALM): a wing with winglets and a T-tail. The ALM is extensively used in rotor simulations to model the blades by body forces, which are calculated from airfoil data and the relative flow velocity. This method has not been used to simulate airplane aerodynamics, despite its advantage of allowing coarser grids. This may be credited to the failure of the uncorrected ALM to accurately predict forces near the tip of wings, even for simple configurations. The recently-proposed vortex-based smearing correction shows improved results, suggesting those limitations are part of the past. For the non-planar configurations studied in this work, differences between the ALM with the original smearing correction and a non-linear lifting line method (LL) are observed near the intersection of surfaces, because the circulation generated in the numerical simulation differs from the calculated corrected circulation. A vorticity magnitude correction is proposed, which improves the agreement between ALM and LL. This second-order correction resolves the ambiguity in the velocity used to define the lift force. The good results indicate that the improved ALM can be used for airplane aerodynamics, with an accuracy similar to the LL.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2023; v1 submitted 31 August, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Non-iterative vortex-based smearing correction for the actuator line method
Authors:
Vitor G. Kleine,
Ardeshir Hanifi,
Dan S. Henningson
Abstract:
The actuator line method (ALM) is extensively used in wind turbine and rotor simulations. However, its original uncorrected formulation overestimates the forces near the tip of the blades and does not reproduce well forces on translating wings. The recently proposed vortex-based smearing correction for the ALM is a correction based on physical and mathematical properties of the simulation that all…
▽ More
The actuator line method (ALM) is extensively used in wind turbine and rotor simulations. However, its original uncorrected formulation overestimates the forces near the tip of the blades and does not reproduce well forces on translating wings. The recently proposed vortex-based smearing correction for the ALM is a correction based on physical and mathematical properties of the simulation that allows for a more accurate and general ALM. So far, to correct the forces on the blades, the smearing correction depended on an iterative process at every time step, which is usually slower, less stable and less deterministic than direct methods. In this work, a non-iterative process is proposed and validated. First, we propose a formulation of the non-linear lifting line that is equivalent to the ALM with smearing correction, showing that their results are practically identical for a translating wing. Then, by linearizing the lifting line method, the iterative process of the correction is substituted by the direct solution of a small linear system. No significant difference is observed in the results of the iterative and non-iterative corrections, both in wing and rotor simulations. Additional contributions of the present work include the use of a more accurate approximation for the velocity induced by a smeared vortex segment and the implementation of a free-vortex wake model to define the vortex sheet, that contribute to the accuracy and generality of the method. The results present here may motivate the adoption of the ALM by other communities, for example, in fixed-wing applications.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2023; v1 submitted 11 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
The Stability of Wakes of Floating Wind Turbines
Authors:
Vitor G. Kleine,
Lucas Franceschini,
Bruno S. Carmo,
Ardeshir Hanifi,
Dan S. Henningson
Abstract:
Floating offshore wind turbines (FOWTs) are subjected to platform motion induced by wind and wave loads. The oscillatory movement trigger vortex instabilities, modifying the wake structure, influencing the flow reaching downstream wind turbines. In this work, the wake of a FOWT is analysed by means of numerical simulations and comparison with linear stability theory. Two simplified models based on…
▽ More
Floating offshore wind turbines (FOWTs) are subjected to platform motion induced by wind and wave loads. The oscillatory movement trigger vortex instabilities, modifying the wake structure, influencing the flow reaching downstream wind turbines. In this work, the wake of a FOWT is analysed by means of numerical simulations and comparison with linear stability theory. Two simplified models based on the stability of vortices are developed for all degrees of freedom of turbine motion. In our numerical simulations, the wind turbine blades are modeled as actuator lines and a spectral-element method with low dispersion and dissipation is employed to study the evolution of the perturbations. The turbine motion excites vortex instability modes predicted by the linear stability of helical vortices. The flow structures that are formed in the non-linear regime are a consequence of the growth of these modes and preserve some of the characteristics that can be explained and predicted by the linear theory. The number of vortices that interact and the growth rate of disturbances are well predicted by a simple stability model of a two-dimensional row of vortices. For all types of motion, the highest growth rate is observed when the frequency of motion is one and a half the frequency of rotation of the turbine; that induces the out-of-phase vortex pairing mechanism. For lower frequencies of motion, several vortices coalesce to form large flow structures, which cause high amplitude of oscillations in the streamwise velocities, that may increase fatigue or induce high amplitude motion on downstream turbines.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2022; v1 submitted 22 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Stability of Two-dimensional Potential Flows Using Bicomplex Numbers
Authors:
Vitor G. Kleine,
Ardeshir Hanifi,
Dan S. Henningson
Abstract:
The use of the complex velocity potential and the complex velocity is widely disseminated in the study of two-dimensional incompressible potential flows. The advantages of working with complex analytical functions made this representation of the flow ubiquitous in the field of theoretical aerodynamics. However, this representation is not usually employed in linear stability studies, where the repr…
▽ More
The use of the complex velocity potential and the complex velocity is widely disseminated in the study of two-dimensional incompressible potential flows. The advantages of working with complex analytical functions made this representation of the flow ubiquitous in the field of theoretical aerodynamics. However, this representation is not usually employed in linear stability studies, where the representation of the velocity as real vectors is preferred by most authors, in order to allow the representation of the perturbation as the complex exponential function. Some of the classical attempts to use the complex velocity potential in stability studies suffer from formal errors. In this work, we present a framework that reconciles these two complex representations using bicomplex numbers. This framework is applied to the stability of the von Kármán vortex street and a generalized formula is found. It is shown that the classical results of the symmetric and staggered von Kármán vortex streets are just particular cases of the generalized dynamical system in bicomplex formulation.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2022; v1 submitted 11 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
