-
Solver Performance of Accelerated MoM for Connected Arrays
Authors:
Harald Hultin,
Lucas Åkerstedt,
B. L. G. Jonsson
Abstract:
Simulating and developing large rectangularly shaped arrays with equidistant interspacing is challenging as the computational complexity grows quickly with array size. However, the geometrical shape of the array, appropriately meshed, leads to a multilevel Toeplitz structure in the RWG-based Method of Moment impedance matrix representation that can be used to mitigate the increased complexity. Thi…
▽ More
Simulating and developing large rectangularly shaped arrays with equidistant interspacing is challenging as the computational complexity grows quickly with array size. However, the geometrical shape of the array, appropriately meshed, leads to a multilevel Toeplitz structure in the RWG-based Method of Moment impedance matrix representation that can be used to mitigate the increased complexity. This paper develops, presents and compares two different accelerated solvers that both utilize the matrix structure to determine antenna properties. Both methods use a novel mesh-partitioning algorithm and its associated data representation, reducing storage and computational costs. The first solver is an iterative method based on multilevel fast Fourier transform to accelerate matrix multiplications. The second solver approach is based on an extension of a fast direct Toeplitz solver, adapted to a block-matrix structure. This fast direct solver is demonstrated to have close to machine epsilon accuracy. Both accelerated methods are evaluated on two different array element types, for arrays with up to 900 elements. The results are compared with conventional direct and iterative matrix solvers. Improvements are seen in both the time and required storage to solve the problem. The choice of the most efficient method depends on the residual thresholds in the iterative method, geometry of the element and frequency. Two different preconditioners for the iterative method are investigated to evaluate their performance. The two accelerated methods vastly outperform regular matrix inversion methods.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
On Adaptive Frequency Sampling for Data-driven Model Order Reduction Applied to Antenna Responses
Authors:
Lucas Åkerstedt,
Darwin Blanco,
B. L. G. Jonsson
Abstract:
Frequency domain sweeps of array antennas are well-known to be time-intensive, and different surrogate models have been used to improve the performance. Data-driven model order reduction algorithms, such as the Loewner framework and vector fitting, can be integrated with these adaptive error estimates, in an iterative algorithm, to reduce the number of full-wave simulations required to accurately…
▽ More
Frequency domain sweeps of array antennas are well-known to be time-intensive, and different surrogate models have been used to improve the performance. Data-driven model order reduction algorithms, such as the Loewner framework and vector fitting, can be integrated with these adaptive error estimates, in an iterative algorithm, to reduce the number of full-wave simulations required to accurately capture the requested frequency behavior of multiport array antennas. In this work, we propose two novel adaptive methods exploiting a block matrix function which is a key part of the Loewner framework generating system approach. The first algorithm leverages an inherent matrix parameter freedom in the block matrix function to identify frequency points with large errors, whereas the second utilizes the condition number of the block matrix function. Both methods effectively provide frequency domain error estimates, which are essential for improved performance. Numerical experiments on multiport array antenna S-parameters demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed algorithms within the Loewner framework, where the proposed algorithms reach the smallest errors for the smallest number of frequency points chosen.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2025; v1 submitted 27 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Physical limitations of phased array antennas
Authors:
Andrei Ludvig-Osipov,
Jari-Matti Hannula,
Patricia Naccachian,
B. L. G. Jonsson
Abstract:
In this paper, the bounds on the Q-factor, a quantity inversely proportional to bandwidth, are derived and investigated for narrow-band phased array antennas. Arrays in free space and above a ground plane are considered. The Q-factor bound is determined by solving a minimization problem over the electric current density. The support of these current densities is on an element-enclosing region, and…
▽ More
In this paper, the bounds on the Q-factor, a quantity inversely proportional to bandwidth, are derived and investigated for narrow-band phased array antennas. Arrays in free space and above a ground plane are considered. The Q-factor bound is determined by solving a minimization problem over the electric current density. The support of these current densities is on an element-enclosing region, and the bound holds for lossless antenna elements enclosed in this region. The Q-factor minimization problem is formulated as a quadratically constrained quadratic optimization problem that is solved either by a semi-definite relaxation or an eigenvalue-based method. We illustrate numerically how these bounds can be used to determine trade-off relations between the Q-factor and other design specifications: element form-factor, size, efficiency, scanning capabilities, and polarization purity.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2021; v1 submitted 4 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Q-factor and bandwidth of periodic antenna arrays over ground plane
Authors:
Andrei Ludvig-Osipov,
B. L. G. Jonsson
Abstract:
In this paper, the Q-factor expression for periodic arrays over a ground plane is determined in terms of the electric current density within the array's unit cell. The expression accounts for the exact shape of the array element. The Q-factor formula includes integration only over a volume of an element in a unit cell, and can thus be efficiently implemented numerically. The examples show good agr…
▽ More
In this paper, the Q-factor expression for periodic arrays over a ground plane is determined in terms of the electric current density within the array's unit cell. The expression accounts for the exact shape of the array element. The Q-factor formula includes integration only over a volume of an element in a unit cell, and can thus be efficiently implemented numerically. The examples show good agreement between the proposed Q-factor, the full-wave-calculated tuned fractional bandwidth, and the input-impedance-based formula by Yaghjian and Best (2005) for the array of tilted dipoles and the loops array.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Stored energies and Q-factor of two-dimensionally periodic antenna arrays
Authors:
Andrei Ludvig-Osipov,
B. L. G. Jonsson
Abstract:
The Q-factor for lossless three-dimensional structures with two-dimensional periodicity is here derived in terms of the electric current density. The derivation in itself is shape-independent and based on the periodic free-space Green's function. The expression for Q-factor takes into account the exact shape of a periodic element, and permits beam steering. The stored energies and the radiated pow…
▽ More
The Q-factor for lossless three-dimensional structures with two-dimensional periodicity is here derived in terms of the electric current density. The derivation in itself is shape-independent and based on the periodic free-space Green's function. The expression for Q-factor takes into account the exact shape of a periodic element, and permits beam steering. The stored energies and the radiated power, both required to evaluate Q-factor, are coordinate independent and expressed in a similar manner to the periodic Electric Field Integral equation, and can thus be rapidly calculated. Numerical investigations, performed for several antenna arrays, indicate fine agreement, accurate enough to be predictive, between the proposed Q-factor and the tuned fractional bandwidth, when the arrays are not too wideband (i.e., when $Q\geq 5$). For completeness, the input-impedance Q-factor, proposed by Yaghjian and Best in 2005, is included and agrees well numerically with the derived Q-factor expression. The main advantage of the proposed representation is its explicit connection to the current density, which allows the Q-factor to give bandwidth estimates based on the shape and current of the array element.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2019; v1 submitted 4 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Fundamental bounds on transmission through periodically perforated metal screens with experimental validation
Authors:
Andrei Ludvig-Osipov,
Johan Lundgren,
Casimir Ehrenborg,
Yevhen Ivanenko,
Andreas Ericsson,
Mats Gustafsson,
B. L. G. Jonsson,
Daniel Sjöberg
Abstract:
This paper presents a study of transmission through arrays of periodic sub-wavelength apertures. Fundamental limitations for this phenomenon are formulated as a sum rule, relating the transmission coefficient over a bandwidth to the static polarizability. The sum rule is rigorously derived for arbitrary periodic apertures in thin screens. By this sum rule we establish a physical bound on the trans…
▽ More
This paper presents a study of transmission through arrays of periodic sub-wavelength apertures. Fundamental limitations for this phenomenon are formulated as a sum rule, relating the transmission coefficient over a bandwidth to the static polarizability. The sum rule is rigorously derived for arbitrary periodic apertures in thin screens. By this sum rule we establish a physical bound on the transmission bandwidth which is verified numerically for a number of aperture array designs. We utilize the sum rule to design and optimize sub-wavelength frequency selective surfaces with a bandwidth close to the physically attainable. Finally, we verify the sum rule and simulations by measurements of an array of horseshoe-shaped slots milled in aluminum foil.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2019; v1 submitted 17 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Optimal Planar Electric Dipole Antenna
Authors:
Miloslav Capek,
Lukas Jelinek,
Kurt Schab,
Mats Gustafsson,
B. L. G. Jonsson,
Fabien Ferrero,
Casimir Ehrenborg
Abstract:
Considerable time is often spent optimizing antennas to meet specific design metrics. Rarely, however, are the resulting antenna designs compared to rigorous physical bounds on those metrics. Here we study the performance of optimized planar meander line antennas with respect to such bounds. Results show that these simple structures meet the lower bound on radiation Q-factor (maximizing single res…
▽ More
Considerable time is often spent optimizing antennas to meet specific design metrics. Rarely, however, are the resulting antenna designs compared to rigorous physical bounds on those metrics. Here we study the performance of optimized planar meander line antennas with respect to such bounds. Results show that these simple structures meet the lower bound on radiation Q-factor (maximizing single resonance fractional bandwidth), but are far from reaching the associated physical bounds on efficiency. The relative performance of other canonical antenna designs is compared in similar ways, and the quantitative results are connected to intuitions from small antenna design, physical bounds, and matching network design.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2019; v1 submitted 31 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Evaluation of the Electric Polarizability for Planar Frequency Selective Arrays
Authors:
Andrei Ludvig-Osipov,
B. L. G. Jonsson
Abstract:
This paper presents a method to estimate the static electric polarizability of two-dimensional infinitely periodic metal patch arrays with dielectric substrate. The main features of the proposed method is its numerical efficiency and a deep insight into the physics of the fields interacting with the structure. We provide derivation and analysis of the method, and its verification against two anoth…
▽ More
This paper presents a method to estimate the static electric polarizability of two-dimensional infinitely periodic metal patch arrays with dielectric substrate. The main features of the proposed method is its numerical efficiency and a deep insight into the physics of the fields interacting with the structure. We provide derivation and analysis of the method, and its verification against two another commercial solver-based approaches for various structure geometries. Additionally, we suggest the guidelines for applying the method to bandwidth optimization of frequency selective structures and illustrate this with an example.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2018; v1 submitted 28 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Antenna Current Optimization and Realizations for Far-Field Pattern Shaping
Authors:
Shuai Shi,
Lei Wang,
B. L. G. Jonsson
Abstract:
Far-field shaping of small antennas is a challenge and the realizations of non-dipole radiation of small to intermediate sized antennas are difficult. Here we examine the antenna bandwidth cost associated with such constraints, and in certain cases we design antennas that approach the bounds. Far-field shaping is in particular interesting for Internet-of-things (IoT) and Wi-Fi applications since e…
▽ More
Far-field shaping of small antennas is a challenge and the realizations of non-dipole radiation of small to intermediate sized antennas are difficult. Here we examine the antenna bandwidth cost associated with such constraints, and in certain cases we design antennas that approach the bounds. Far-field shaping is in particular interesting for Internet-of-things (IoT) and Wi-Fi applications since e.g. spatial filtering can mitigate package loss through a reduction of mutual interference, and hence increase the power efficiency of the devices. Even a rather careful far-field shaping of smaller antennas can be associated with a steep reduction in the best available bandwidth. It is thus important to develop constraints that a small antenna can support. We describe a power front-to-back ratio, and a related, beam-shaping constraint that can be used in optimization for the minimum Q-factor. We show that such a non-convex Q-factor optimization can be solved with the semi-definite relaxation technique. We furthermore show that certain of the above optimized non-standard radiation patterns can be realized with a multi-position feeding strategy with a moderate loss of Q-factor: $Q_\text{antenna}\leq 1.61Q_\text{optimal}$.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2018; v1 submitted 27 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
On methods to determine bounds on the Q-factor for a given directivity
Authors:
B. L. G. Jonsson,
Shuai Shi,
Lei Wang,
Fabien Ferrero,
Leonardo Lizzi
Abstract:
This paper revisit and extend the interesting case of bounds on the Q-factor for a given directivity for a small antenna of arbitrary shape. A higher directivity in a small antenna is closely connected with a narrow impedance bandwidth. The relation between bandwidth and a desired directivity is still not fully understood, not even for small antennas. Initial investigations in this direction has r…
▽ More
This paper revisit and extend the interesting case of bounds on the Q-factor for a given directivity for a small antenna of arbitrary shape. A higher directivity in a small antenna is closely connected with a narrow impedance bandwidth. The relation between bandwidth and a desired directivity is still not fully understood, not even for small antennas. Initial investigations in this direction has related the radius of a circumscribing sphere to the directivity, and bounds on the Q-factor has also been derived for a partial directivity in a given direction. In this paper we derive lower bounds on the Q-factor for a total desired directivity for an arbitrarily shaped antenna in a given direction as a convex problem using semi-definite relaxation techniques (SDR). We also show that the relaxed solution is also a solution of the original problem of determining the lower Q-factor bound for a total desired directivity.
SDR can also be used to relax a class of other interesting non-convex constraints in antenna optimization such as tuning, losses, front-to-back ratio. We compare two different new methods to determine the lowest Q-factor for arbitrary shaped antennas for a given total directivity. We also compare our results with full EM-simulations of a parasitic element antenna with high directivity.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2017; v1 submitted 10 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
On the Accuracy of Equivalent Antenna Representations
Authors:
Johan Malmström,
Henrik Holter,
B. L. G. Jonsson
Abstract:
The accuracy of two equivalent antenna representations, near-field sources and far-field sources, are evaluated for an antenna installed on a simplified platform in a series of case studies using different configurations of equivalent antenna representations. The accuracy is evaluated in terms of installed far-fields and surface currents on the platform. The results show large variations between c…
▽ More
The accuracy of two equivalent antenna representations, near-field sources and far-field sources, are evaluated for an antenna installed on a simplified platform in a series of case studies using different configurations of equivalent antenna representations. The accuracy is evaluated in terms of installed far-fields and surface currents on the platform. The results show large variations between configurations. The root-mean-square installed far-field error is 4.4% for the most accurate equivalent representation. When using far-field sources, the design parameters have a large influence of the achieved accuracy. There is also a varying accuracy depending on the type of numerical method used. Based on the results, some recommendations on the choice of sub-domain for the equivalent antenna representation are given. In industrial antenna applications, the accuracy in determining e.g. installed far-fields and antenna isolation on large platforms are critical. Equivalent representations can reduce the fine-detail complexity of antennas and thus give an efficient numerical descriptions to be used in large-scale simulations. The results in this paper can be used as a guideline by antenna designers or system engineers when using equivalent sources.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Stored energies for electric and magnetic current densities
Authors:
B. L. G. Jonsson,
Mats Gustafsson
Abstract:
Electric and magnetic current densities are an essential part of electromagnetic theory. The goal of the present paper is to define and investigate stored energies that are valid for structures that can support both electric and magnetic current densities. Stored energies normalized with the dissipated power give us the Q factor, or antenna Q, for the structure. Lower bounds of the Q factor provid…
▽ More
Electric and magnetic current densities are an essential part of electromagnetic theory. The goal of the present paper is to define and investigate stored energies that are valid for structures that can support both electric and magnetic current densities. Stored energies normalized with the dissipated power give us the Q factor, or antenna Q, for the structure. Lower bounds of the Q factor provide information about the available bandwidth for passive antennas that can be realized in the structure. The definition that we propose is valid beyond the leading order small antenna limit. Our starting point is the energy density with subtracted far-field form which we obtain an explicit and numerically attractive current density representation. This representation gives us the insight to propose a coordinate independent stored energy. Furthermore, we find here that lower bounds on antenna Q for structures with e.g. electric dipole radiation can be formulated as convex optimization problems. We determine lower bounds on both open and closed surfaces that support electric and magnetic current densities.
The here derived representation of stored energies has in its electrical small limit an associated Q factor that agrees with known small antenna bounds. These stored energies have similarities to earlier efforts to define stored energies. However, one of the advantages with this method is the above mentioned formulation as convex optimization problems, which makes it easy to predict lower bounds for antennas of arbitrary shapes. The present formulation also gives us insight into the components that contribute to Chu's lower bound for spherical shapes. We utilize scalar and vector potentials to obtain a compact direct derivation of these stored energies. Examples and comparisons end the paper.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2016; v1 submitted 28 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Stored energies in electric and magnetic current densities for small antennas
Authors:
B. L. G. Jonsson,
Mats Gustafsson
Abstract:
Electric and magnetic currents are essential to describe electromagnetic stored energy, as well as the associated quantities of antenna Q and the partial directivity to antenna Q-ratio, D/Q, for general structures. The upper bound of previous D/Q-results for antennas modeled by electric currents is accurate enough to be predictive, this motivates us here to extend the analysis to include magnetic…
▽ More
Electric and magnetic currents are essential to describe electromagnetic stored energy, as well as the associated quantities of antenna Q and the partial directivity to antenna Q-ratio, D/Q, for general structures. The upper bound of previous D/Q-results for antennas modeled by electric currents is accurate enough to be predictive, this motivates us here to extend the analysis to include magnetic currents. In the present paper we investigate antenna Q bounds and D/Q-bounds for the combination of electric- and magnetic-currents, in the limit of electrically small antennas. This investigation is both analytical and numerical, and we illustrate how the bounds depend on the shape of the antenna. We show that the antenna Q can be associated with the largest eigenvalue of certain combinations of the electric and magnetic polarizability tensors. The results are a fully compatible extension of the electric only currents, which come as a special case. The here proposed method for antenna Q provides the minimum Q-value, and it also yields families of minimizers for optimal electric and magnetic currents that can lend insight into the antenna design.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Array Antenna Limitations
Authors:
B. L. G. Jonsson,
C. I. Kolitsidas,
N. Hussain
Abstract:
This letter defines a physical bound based array figure of merit that provides a tool to compare the performance of both single and multi-band array antennas with respect to return-loss, thickness of the array over the ground-plane, and scan-range. The result is based on a sum-rule result of Rozanov-type for linear polarization. For single-band antennas it extends an existing limit for a given fix…
▽ More
This letter defines a physical bound based array figure of merit that provides a tool to compare the performance of both single and multi-band array antennas with respect to return-loss, thickness of the array over the ground-plane, and scan-range. The result is based on a sum-rule result of Rozanov-type for linear polarization. For single-band antennas it extends an existing limit for a given fixed scan-angle to include the whole scan-range of the array, as well as the unit-cell structure in the bound. The letter ends with an investigation of the array figure of merit for some wideband and/or wide-scan antennas with linear polarization. We find arrays with a figure of merit >0.6 that empirically defines high-performance antennas with respect to this measure.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2013; v1 submitted 10 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Stored Electromagnetic Energy and Antenna Q
Authors:
Mats Gustafsson,
B. L. G. Jonsson
Abstract:
Decomposition of the electromagnetic energy into its stored and radiated parts is instrumental in the evaluation of antenna Q and the corresponding fundamental limitations on antennas. This decomposition is not unique and there are several proposals in the literature. Here, it is shown that stored energy defined from the difference between the energy density and the far field energy equals the new…
▽ More
Decomposition of the electromagnetic energy into its stored and radiated parts is instrumental in the evaluation of antenna Q and the corresponding fundamental limitations on antennas. This decomposition is not unique and there are several proposals in the literature. Here, it is shown that stored energy defined from the difference between the energy density and the far field energy equals the new energy expressions proposed by Vandenbosch for many cases. This also explains the observed cases with negative stored energy and suggests a possible remedy to them. The results are compared with the classical explicit expressions for spherical regions where the results only differ by ka that is interpreted as the far-field energy in the interior of the sphere. Numerical results of the Q-factors for dipole, loop, and inverted L-antennas are also compared with estimates from circuit models and differentiation of the impedance. The results indicate that the stored energy in the field agrees with the stored energy in the Brune synthesized circuit models whereas the differentiated impedance gives a lower value for some cases. The corresponding results for the bandwidth suggest that the inverse proportionality between bandwidth and Q depends on the relative bandwidth or equivalent the threshold of the reflection coefficient. The Q from the differentiated impedance and stored energy are most useful for relative narrow and wide bandwidths, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2013; v1 submitted 23 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.