-
WTMAD-4: A Fair Weighting Scheme for GMTKN55
Authors:
Kyle R. Bryenton,
Erin R. Johnson
Abstract:
The GMTKN55 data set is a collection of standard benchmarks used in molecular quantum chemistry that spans small- and large-molecule thermochemistry, reaction barriers, and non-covalent interactions. Herein, we identify a flaw in the weighted mean absolute deviation (WTMAD) definitions commonly used to quantify performance of various electronic-structure methods for the GMTKN55 set, which under-we…
▽ More
The GMTKN55 data set is a collection of standard benchmarks used in molecular quantum chemistry that spans small- and large-molecule thermochemistry, reaction barriers, and non-covalent interactions. Herein, we identify a flaw in the weighted mean absolute deviation (WTMAD) definitions commonly used to quantify performance of various electronic-structure methods for the GMTKN55 set, which under-weight some of its component benchmarks by orders of magnitude. A new WTMAD-4 metric is proposed, based on typical errors observed for well-behaved density-functional approximations (DFAs), ensuring fair treatment across all benchmarks. The performance of 135 dispersion-corrected DFAs is assessed by combining literature data with new results for 20 minimally empirical methods, primarily involving the exchange-hole dipole moment and many-body dispersion corrections, available in the FHI-aims code. Lastly, we highlight a literature example where a DFA parametrised by minimising WTMAD-2 underperforms for benchmarks marginalised by that metric.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2025;
originally announced September 2025.
-
The exchange-correlation dipole moment dispersion method
Authors:
Kyle R Bryenton,
Erin R Johnson
Abstract:
Density-functional theory (DFT) has become the workhorse of modern computational chemistry, with dispersion corrections such as the exchange-hole dipole moment (XDM) model playing a key role in high-accuracy modelling of large-scale systems. Here, we introduce a new physics-guided XDM variant, termed the exchange-correlation dipole moment (XCDM) model, which supplements XDM with same- and opposite…
▽ More
Density-functional theory (DFT) has become the workhorse of modern computational chemistry, with dispersion corrections such as the exchange-hole dipole moment (XDM) model playing a key role in high-accuracy modelling of large-scale systems. Here, we introduce a new physics-guided XDM variant, termed the exchange-correlation dipole moment (XCDM) model, which supplements XDM with same- and opposite-spin dynamical correlation terms, substantially improving accuracy for molecular $C_6$ dispersion coefficients. Both XDM and XCDM are implemented for use with the Becke-Johnson damping function based on atomic radii, as well as a one-parameter damping function based on atomic numbers, recently proposed by Becke. All four variants are benchmarked on the comprehensive GMTKN55 database using minimally empirical generalised-gradient-approximation, global hybrid, and range-separated hybrid functionals. This marks the first time that the XDM (and many-body dispersion, MBD) corrections have been tested for the GMTKN55 set. Five solid-state benchmarks spanning molecular crystals and layered materials are also considered. The B86bPBE0 hybrid functional, paired with any of the XDM variants, shows excellent performance for molecular systems. Finally, we identify a flaw in the weighted mean absolute deviation (WTMAD-2) scheme commonly used for the GMTKN55 set, which underweights some of its component benchmarks by orders of magnitude. We propose a new WTMAD-4 scheme based on typical errors observed for well-behaved functionals, ensuring fair treatment across all benchmarks.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Roadmap on Advancements of the FHI-aims Software Package
Authors:
Joseph W. Abbott,
Carlos Mera Acosta,
Alaa Akkoush,
Alberto Ambrosetti,
Viktor Atalla,
Alexej Bagrets,
Jörg Behler,
Daniel Berger,
Björn Bieniek,
Jonas Björk,
Volker Blum,
Saeed Bohloul,
Connor L. Box,
Nicholas Boyer,
Danilo Simoes Brambila,
Gabriel A. Bramley,
Kyle R. Bryenton,
María Camarasa-Gómez,
Christian Carbogno,
Fabio Caruso,
Sucismita Chutia,
Michele Ceriotti,
Gábor Csányi,
William Dawson,
Francisco A. Delesma
, et al. (177 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Electronic-structure theory is the foundation of the description of materials including multiscale modeling of their properties and functions. Obviously, without sufficient accuracy at the base, reliable predictions are unlikely at any level that follows. The software package FHI-aims has proven to be a game changer for accurate free-energy calculations because of its scalability, numerical precis…
▽ More
Electronic-structure theory is the foundation of the description of materials including multiscale modeling of their properties and functions. Obviously, without sufficient accuracy at the base, reliable predictions are unlikely at any level that follows. The software package FHI-aims has proven to be a game changer for accurate free-energy calculations because of its scalability, numerical precision, and its efficient handling of density functional theory (DFT) with hybrid functionals and van der Waals interactions. It treats molecules, clusters, and extended systems (solids and liquids) on an equal footing. Besides DFT, FHI-aims also includes quantum-chemistry methods, descriptions for excited states and vibrations, and calculations of various types of transport. Recent advancements address the integration of FHI-aims into an increasing number of workflows and various artificial intelligence (AI) methods. This Roadmap describes the state-of-the-art of FHI-aims and advancements that are currently ongoing or planned.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2025; v1 submitted 30 April, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Endofullerenes and Dispersion-Corrected Density Functional Approximations: A Cautionary Tale
Authors:
K. Panchagnula,
D. Graf,
K. R. Bryenton,
E. R. Johnson,
A. J. W. Thom
Abstract:
A recent study by Panchagnula et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 161, 054308 (2024)] illustrated the non-concordance of a variety of electronic structure methods at describing the symmetric double-well potential expected along the anisotropic direction of the endofullerene Ne@C$_{70}$. In this article we delve deeper into the difficulties of accurately capturing the dispersion interaction within this system,…
▽ More
A recent study by Panchagnula et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 161, 054308 (2024)] illustrated the non-concordance of a variety of electronic structure methods at describing the symmetric double-well potential expected along the anisotropic direction of the endofullerene Ne@C$_{70}$. In this article we delve deeper into the difficulties of accurately capturing the dispersion interaction within this system, scrutinising a variety of state-of-the-art density-functional approximations (DFAs) and dispersion corrections (DCs). We identify rigorous criteria for the double-well potential and compare the shapes, barrier heights, and minima positions obtained with the DFAs and DCs to the correlated wavefunction data in the previous study, alongside new coupled-cluster calculations. We show that many of the DFAs are extremely sensitive to the numerical integration grid used, and note that the choice of DC is not independent of the DFA. Functionals with many empirical parameters tuned for main-group thermochemistry do not necessarily result in a reasonable PES, while improved performance can be obtained using nearly dispersionless DFAs with very few empirical parameters and allowing the DC to compensate. We pose the Ne@C$_{70}$ system as a challenge to functional developers and as a diagnostic system for testing dispersion corrections, and reiterate the need for more experimental data for comparison.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Targeting spectroscopic accuracy for dispersion bound systems from ab initio techniques: translational eigenstates of Ne@C$_{70}$
Authors:
K. Panchagnula,
D. Graf,
E. R. Johnson,
A. J. W. Thom
Abstract:
We investigate the endofullerene system Ne@C$_{70}$, by constructing a three-dimensional Potential Energy Surface (PES) describing the translational motion of the Ne atom. We compare a plethora of electronic structure methods including: MP2, SCS-MP2, SOS-MP2, RPA@PBE, C(HF)-RPA, which were previously used for He@C$_{60}$ in J. Chem. Phys. 160, 104303 (2024), alongside B86bPBE-25X-XDM and B86bPBE-5…
▽ More
We investigate the endofullerene system Ne@C$_{70}$, by constructing a three-dimensional Potential Energy Surface (PES) describing the translational motion of the Ne atom. We compare a plethora of electronic structure methods including: MP2, SCS-MP2, SOS-MP2, RPA@PBE, C(HF)-RPA, which were previously used for He@C$_{60}$ in J. Chem. Phys. 160, 104303 (2024), alongside B86bPBE-25X-XDM and B86bPBE-50X-XDM. The reduction in symmetry moving from C$_{60}$ to C$_{70}$ introduces a double well potential along the anisotropic direction, which forms a test of the sensitivity and effectiveness of the methods. Due to the large cost of these calculations, the PES is interpolated using Gaussian Process Regression due to its effectiveness with sparse training data. The nuclear Hamiltonian is diagonalised using a symmetrised double minimum basis set outlined in J. Chem. Phys. 159, 164308 (2023), with translational energies having error bars $\pm 1$ and $\pm 2$ cm$^{-1}$. We quantify the shape of the ground state wavefunction by considering its prolateness and kurtosis, and compare the eigenfunctions between electronic structure methods from their Hellinger distance. We find no consistency between electronic structure methods as they find a range of barrier heights and minima positions of the double well, and different translational eigenspectra which also differ from the Lennard-Jones (LJ) PES given in J. Chem. Phys. 101, 2126,2140 (1994). We find that generating effective LJ parameters for each electronic structure method cannot reproduce the full PES, nor recreate the eigenstates and this suggests that the LJ form of the PES, while simple, may not be best suited to describe these systems. Even though MP2 and RPA@PBE performed best for He@C$_{60}$, due to the lack of concordance between all electronic structure methods we require more experimental data in order to properly validate the choice.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Spectral Methods for Coastal-Trapped Waves and Instabilities in a Background Flow
Authors:
Matthew N. Crowe,
Edward R. Johnson
Abstract:
Here we present a numerical method for finding non-hydrostatic coastal-trapped wave and instability solutions to the non-hydrostatic Boussinesq equations in the presence of a background flow and complicated coastal topography. We use spectral methods to discretise the two-dimensional eigenvalue problem and solve the resulting discrete problem by standard methods. Our approach is applied to three e…
▽ More
Here we present a numerical method for finding non-hydrostatic coastal-trapped wave and instability solutions to the non-hydrostatic Boussinesq equations in the presence of a background flow and complicated coastal topography. We use spectral methods to discretise the two-dimensional eigenvalue problem and solve the resulting discrete problem by standard methods. Our approach is applied to three examples and shown to be consistent with previous numerical and analytical results. In particular, we show that our method is able to reliably identify coastal-trapped wave solutions that correspond to waves seen in realistic simulations of the Southeast Greenland shelf.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Modon solutions in an N-layer quasi-geostrophic model
Authors:
Matthew N. Crowe,
Edward R. Johnson
Abstract:
Modons, or dipolar vortices, are common and long-lived features of the upper ocean, consisting of a pair of monopolar vortices moving through self-advection. Such structures remain stable over long times and may be important for fluid transport over large distances. Here we present a semi-analytical method for finding fully nonlinear modon solutions in a multi-layer quasi-geostrophic model with ar…
▽ More
Modons, or dipolar vortices, are common and long-lived features of the upper ocean, consisting of a pair of monopolar vortices moving through self-advection. Such structures remain stable over long times and may be important for fluid transport over large distances. Here we present a semi-analytical method for finding fully nonlinear modon solutions in a multi-layer quasi-geostrophic model with arbitrarily many layers. Our approach works by reducing the problem to a multi-parameter linear eigenvalue problem which can be solved using numerical techniques from linear algebra. The method is shown to replicate previous results for one and two-layer models and is applied to a three-layer model to find a solution describing a mid-depth propagating, topographic vortex.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Attached and separated rotating flow over a finite height ridge
Authors:
Stefan Frei,
Erik Burman,
Edward R Johnson
Abstract:
This paper discusses the effect of rotation on the boundary layer in high Reynolds number flow over a ridge using a numerical method based on stabilised finite elements that captures steady solutions up to Reynolds number of order $10^6$. The results are validated against boundary layer computations in shallow flows and for deep flows against experimental observations reported in Machicoane et al.…
▽ More
This paper discusses the effect of rotation on the boundary layer in high Reynolds number flow over a ridge using a numerical method based on stabilised finite elements that captures steady solutions up to Reynolds number of order $10^6$. The results are validated against boundary layer computations in shallow flows and for deep flows against experimental observations reported in Machicoane et al. (Phys. Rev. Fluids, 2018). In all cases considered the boundary layer remains attached, even at large Reynolds numbers, provided the Rossby number of the flow is sufficiently small. At any fixed Rossby number the flow detaches at sufficiently high Reynolds number to form a steady recirculating region in the lee of the ridge. At even higher Reynolds numbers no steady flow is found. This disappearance of steady solutions closely reproduces the transition to unsteadiness seen in the laboratory.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The evolution of surface quasi-geostrophic modons on sloping topography
Authors:
Matthew N. Crowe,
Edward R. Johnson
Abstract:
This work discusses modons, or dipolar vortices, propagating along sloping topography. Two different regimes exist which are studied separately using the surface quasi-geostrophic equations. First, when the modon propagates in the opposite direction to topographic Rossby waves, steady solutions exist and a semi-analytical method is presented for calculating these solutions. Second, when the modon…
▽ More
This work discusses modons, or dipolar vortices, propagating along sloping topography. Two different regimes exist which are studied separately using the surface quasi-geostrophic equations. First, when the modon propagates in the opposite direction to topographic Rossby waves, steady solutions exist and a semi-analytical method is presented for calculating these solutions. Second, when the modon propagates in the same direction of the Rossby waves, a wave wake is generated. This wake removes energy from the modon causing it to decay slowly. Asymptotic predictions are presented for this decay and found to agree closely with numerical simulations. Over long times, decaying vortices are found to break down due to an asymmetry resulting from the generation of waves inside the vortex. A monopolar vortex moving along a wall is shown to behave in a similar way to a dipole, though the presence of the wall is found to stabilise the vortex and prevent the long-time breakdown. The problem is mathematically equivalent to a dipolar vortex moving along a density front hence our results apply directly to this case.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Oceanic dipoles in a surface quasigeostrophic model
Authors:
E. R. Johnson,
M. N. Crowe
Abstract:
Analysis of satellite altimetry and Argo float data leads Ni et al. (2020, JGR Oceans) to argue that mesoscale dipoles are widespread features of the global ocean having a relatively uniform three-dimensional structure that can lead to strong vertical exchanges. Almost all the features of the composite dipole they construct can be derived from a model for multipoles in the surface quasigeostrophic…
▽ More
Analysis of satellite altimetry and Argo float data leads Ni et al. (2020, JGR Oceans) to argue that mesoscale dipoles are widespread features of the global ocean having a relatively uniform three-dimensional structure that can lead to strong vertical exchanges. Almost all the features of the composite dipole they construct can be derived from a model for multipoles in the surface quasigeostrophic equations for which we present a straightforward novel solution in terms of an explicit linear eigenvalue problem, allowing simple evaluation of the higher radial modes that appear to be present in the observations and suggesting that mass conservation may explain the observed frontogenetic velocities.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
The propagation and decay of a coastal vortex on a shelf
Authors:
Matthew N. Crowe,
Edward R. Johnson
Abstract:
A coastal eddy is modelled as a barotropic vortex propagating along a coastal shelf. If the vortex speed matches the phase speed of any coastal trapped shelf wave modes, a shelf wave wake is generated leading to a flux of energy from the vortex into the wave field. Using a simply shelf geometry, we determine analytic expressions for the wave wake and the leading order flux of wave energy. By consi…
▽ More
A coastal eddy is modelled as a barotropic vortex propagating along a coastal shelf. If the vortex speed matches the phase speed of any coastal trapped shelf wave modes, a shelf wave wake is generated leading to a flux of energy from the vortex into the wave field. Using a simply shelf geometry, we determine analytic expressions for the wave wake and the leading order flux of wave energy. By considering the balance of energy between the vortex and wave field, this energy flux is then used to make analytic predictions for the evolution of the vortex speed and radius under the assumption that the vortex structure remains self similar. These predictions are examined in the asymptotic limit of small rotation rate and shelf slope and tested against numerical simulations.
If the vortex speed does not match the phase speed of any shelf wave, steady vortex solutions are expected to exist. We present a numerical approach for finding these nonlinear solutions and examine the parameter dependence of their structure.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2021; v1 submitted 9 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Global empirical potentials from purely rotational measurements
Authors:
Nikesh S. Dattani,
Lindsay N. Zack,
Ming Sun,
Erin R. Johnson,
Robert J. Le Roy,
Lucy M. Ziurys
Abstract:
The recent advent of chirped-pulse FTMW technology has created a plethora of pure rotational spectra for molecules for which no vibrational information is known. The growing number of such spectra demands a way to build empirical potential energy surfaces for molecules, without relying on any vibrational measurements. Using ZnO as an example, we demonstrate a powerful technique for efficiently acc…
▽ More
The recent advent of chirped-pulse FTMW technology has created a plethora of pure rotational spectra for molecules for which no vibrational information is known. The growing number of such spectra demands a way to build empirical potential energy surfaces for molecules, without relying on any vibrational measurements. Using ZnO as an example, we demonstrate a powerful technique for efficiently accomplishing this. We first measure eight new ultra-high precision ($\pm2$ kHz) pure rotational transitions in the $X$-state of ZnO. Combining them with previous high-precision ($\pm50$ kHz) pure rotational measurements of different transitions in the same system, we have data that spans the bottom 10\% of the well. Despite not using any vibrational information, our empirical potentials are able to determine the size of the vibrational spacings and bond lengths, with precisions that are more than three and two orders of magnitude greater, respectively, than the most precise empirical values previously known, and the most accurate \emph{ab initio} calculations in today's reach. By calculating the $C_{6},$ $C_{8},$ and $C_{10}$ long-range constants and using them to anchor the top of the well, our potential is \emph{globally} in excellent agreement with \emph{ab initio} calculations, without the need for vibrational spectra and without the need for \emph{any} data in the top 90\% of the well.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Deformation of vortex patches by boundaries
Authors:
A. Crosby,
E. R. Johnson,
P. J. Morrison
Abstract:
The deformation of two-dimensional vortex patches in the vicinity of fluid boundaries is investigated. The presence of a boundary causes an initially circular patch of uniform vorticity to deform. Sufficiently far away from the boundary, the deformed shape is well approximated by an ellipse. This leading order elliptical deformation is investigated via the elliptic moment model of Melander, Zabusk…
▽ More
The deformation of two-dimensional vortex patches in the vicinity of fluid boundaries is investigated. The presence of a boundary causes an initially circular patch of uniform vorticity to deform. Sufficiently far away from the boundary, the deformed shape is well approximated by an ellipse. This leading order elliptical deformation is investigated via the elliptic moment model of Melander, Zabusky & Styczek [M. V. Melander, N. J. Zabusky & A. S. Styczek, J. Fluid. Mech., 167, 95 (1986)]. When the boundary is straight, the centre of the elliptic patch remains at a constant distance from the boundary, and the motion is integrable. Furthermore, since the straining flow acting on the patch is constant in time, the problem is that of an elliptic vortex patch in constant strain, which was analysed by Kida [S. Kida, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 50, 3517 (1981)]. For more complicated boundary shapes, such as a square corner, the motion is no longer integrable. Instead, there is an adiabatic invariant for the motion. This adiabatic invariant arises due to the separation in times scales between the relatively rapid time scale associated with the rotation of the patch and the slower time scale associated with the self-advection of the patch along the boundary. The interaction of a vortex patch with a circular island is also considered. Without a background flow, conservation of angular impulse implies that the motion is again integrable. The addition of an irrotational flow past the island can drive the patch towards the boundary, leading to the possibility of large deformations and breakup.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
