-
Anonymous monitoring enables turn-taking and sustainablity in collective resource governance: Multi-player evolutionary dynamical-systems game
Authors:
Kenji Itao,
Kunihiko Kaneko
Abstract:
Sustainable resource use in large societies requires social institutions that specify acceptable behavior and punish violators. Because mutual monitoring becomes prohibitively costly as populations grow, we examine whether sustainability can be maintained when only anonymized information is available. Using the evolutionary dynamical-systems game framework, we model the common-pool resource manage…
▽ More
Sustainable resource use in large societies requires social institutions that specify acceptable behavior and punish violators. Because mutual monitoring becomes prohibitively costly as populations grow, we examine whether sustainability can be maintained when only anonymized information is available. Using the evolutionary dynamical-systems game framework, we model the common-pool resource management game. In the model, each player's harvesting decisions shape the resource dynamics and depend on the resource's state, the player's wealth, and the group average wealth. Strategies are encoded as two-parameter decision-making functions that mutate across generations. Evolutionary simulations reveal that players self-organize into clusters that alternate harvesting turns: individuals within a cluster harvest synchronously, while the clusters themselves take turns. The emergent institutional rule is strikingly simple: "wait when rich, harvest when below average." While the majority cluster tends to exploit the minority, moderate diversity in decision parameters of strategies allows "turn-taking of turns" between the majority and minority roles, improving efficiency, equity, and resistance to selfish mutants. We quantify the difficulty of managing institutions as population size increases. When group size is fixed, the minimum number of groups required for cooperation grows exponentially with group size. If, however, groups enlarge gradually, the scaling transitions to a power law, indicating that institutions remain stable when they are first built in small populations and subsequently adapted to larger ones. Our findings provide a theoretical basis for the self-organization of institutions in large societies, illuminating how anonymized information can coordinate behavior and how institutional success depends on its developmental trajectory.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
Self-organized institutions in evolutionary dynamical-systems game
Authors:
Kenji Itao,
Kunihiko Kaneko
Abstract:
Social institutions are systems of shared norms and rules that regulate people's behaviors, often emerging without external enforcement. They provide criteria to distinguish cooperation from defection and establish rules to sustain cooperation, shaped through long-term trial and error. While principles for successful institutions have been proposed, the mechanisms underlying their emergence remain…
▽ More
Social institutions are systems of shared norms and rules that regulate people's behaviors, often emerging without external enforcement. They provide criteria to distinguish cooperation from defection and establish rules to sustain cooperation, shaped through long-term trial and error. While principles for successful institutions have been proposed, the mechanisms underlying their emergence remain poorly understood. Here, we introduce the evolutionary dynamical-systems game, a framework that couples game actions with environmental dynamics and explores the evolution of cognitive frameworks for decision-making. We analyze a minimal model of common-pool resource management, where resources grow naturally and are harvested. Players use decision-making functions to determine whether to harvest at each step, based on environmental and peer monitoring. As these functions evolve, players detect selfish harvesting and punish it by degrading the environment through harvesting. This process leads to the self-organization of norms that classify harvesting actions as cooperative, defective, or punitive. The emergent norms for ``cooperativeness'' and rules of punishment serve as institutions. The environmental and players' states converge to distinct modes characterized by limit-cycles, representing temporal regularities in socio-ecological systems. These modes remain stable despite slight variations in decision-making, illustrating the stability of institutions. The evolutionary robustness of decision-making functions serves as a measure of the evolutionary favorability of institutions, highlighting the role of plasticity in responding to diverse opponents. This work introduces foundational concepts in evolutionary dynamical-systems games and elucidates the mechanisms underlying the self-organization of institutions by modeling the interplay between ecological dynamics and human decision-making.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2025; v1 submitted 13 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Formation of human kinship structures depending on population size and cultural mutation rate
Authors:
Kenji Itao,
Kunihiko Kaneko
Abstract:
How does social complexity depend on population size and cultural transmission? Kinship structures in traditional societies provide a fundamental illustration, where cultural rules between clans determine people's marriage possibilities. Here we propose a simple model of kinship interactions that considers kin and in-law cooperation and sexual rivalry. In this model, multiple societies compete. So…
▽ More
How does social complexity depend on population size and cultural transmission? Kinship structures in traditional societies provide a fundamental illustration, where cultural rules between clans determine people's marriage possibilities. Here we propose a simple model of kinship interactions that considers kin and in-law cooperation and sexual rivalry. In this model, multiple societies compete. Societies consist of multiple families with different cultural traits and mating preferences. These values determine interactions and hence the growth rate of families and are transmitted to offspring with mutations. Through a multilevel evolutionary simulation, family traits and preferences are grouped into multiple clans with inter-clan mating preferences. It illustrates the emergence of kinship structures as the spontaneous formation of interdependent cultural associations. Emergent kinship structures are characterized by the cycle length of marriage exchange and the number of cycles in society. We numerically and analytically clarify their parameter dependence. The relative importance of cooperation versus rivalry determines whether attraction or repulsion exists between families. Different structures evolve as locally stable attractors. The probabilities of formation and collapse of complex structures depend on the number of families and the mutation rate, showing characteristic scaling relationships. It is now possible to explore macroscopic kinship structures based on microscopic interactions, together with their environmental dependence and the historical causality of their evolution. We propose the basic causal mechanism of the formation of typical human social structures by referring to ethnographic observations and concepts from statistical physics and multilevel evolution. Such interdisciplinary collaboration will unveil universal features in human societies.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Two universal pathways in demographic transition
Authors:
Kenji Itao
Abstract:
Demographic transition, characterized by declines in fertility and mortality, is a global phenomenon associated with modernization. While typical patterns of fertility decline are observed in Western countries, their applicability to other regions and the underlying mechanisms remain unclear. By analyzing demographic data from 195 countries over 200 years, this study identifies two universal pathw…
▽ More
Demographic transition, characterized by declines in fertility and mortality, is a global phenomenon associated with modernization. While typical patterns of fertility decline are observed in Western countries, their applicability to other regions and the underlying mechanisms remain unclear. By analyzing demographic data from 195 countries over 200 years, this study identifies two universal pathways in the changes in the crude birth rate (i.e., births per 1,000 individuals λ) and life expectancy at birth ({e_0}), characterized by the conservation of either {λe0} or {λ\exp(e_0/18)}. These pathways define two distinct phases governed by different mechanisms. Phase I, characterized by the conservation of {λe_0}, dominated until the mid-20th century, with high child mortality and steady population growth. In contrast, Phase II, conserving {λ\exp(e_0/18)}, has prevailed since 1950, featuring low child mortality and steady GDP per capita growth. A theoretical model considering the trade-off between reproduction and education elucidates the transition between these phases, demonstrating that population size is prioritized in Phase I, while productivity is maximized in Phase II. Modernization processes, such as declining educational costs and increasing social mobility, are identified as key accelerators of the transition to Phase II. The findings suggest that reducing educational costs can foster fertility recovery without compromising educational standards, offering potential policy interventions. This study provides a novel theoretical framework for understanding demographic transition by applying principles from statistical physics to uncover universal macroscopic laws and their underlying mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2025; v1 submitted 23 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Emergence of economic and social disparities through competitive gift-giving
Authors:
Kenji Itao,
Kunihiko Kaneko
Abstract:
Several tiers of social organization with varying economic and social disparities have been observed. However, a quantitative characterization of the types and the causal mechanisms for the transitions have hardly been explained. While anthropologists have emphasized that gift exchange, rather than market exchange, prevails in traditional societies and shapes social relations, few mathematical stu…
▽ More
Several tiers of social organization with varying economic and social disparities have been observed. However, a quantitative characterization of the types and the causal mechanisms for the transitions have hardly been explained. While anthropologists have emphasized that gift exchange, rather than market exchange, prevails in traditional societies and shapes social relations, few mathematical studies have explored its consequences for social organizations. In this study, we present a simple model of competitive gift-giving that describes how gifts bring goods to the recipient and honor to the donor, and simulate social change. Numerical simulations and an analysis of the corresponding mean-field theory demonstrate the transitions between the following four phases with different distribution shapes of wealth and social reputation: the band, without economic or social disparities; the tribe, with economic but without social disparities; the chiefdom, with both; and the kingdom, with economic disparity and weak social disparity except for an outlier, namely, the ``monarch''. The emergence of strong disparities is characterized by power law distributions and is attributed to the ``rich get richer'' process. In contrast, the absence of such a process leads to exponential distributions due to random fluctuations. The phases depend on the parameters characterizing the frequency and scale of gift interactions. Our findings provide quantitative criteria for classifying social organizations based on economic and social disparities, consistent with anthropological theory and empirical observations. Thus, we propose empirically measurable explanatory variables and characteristics for the evolution of social organizations. The constructive model, guided by social scientific theory, can provide the basic mechanistic explanation of social evolution and integrate theories of the social sciences.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2024; v1 submitted 15 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Transition of Social Organisations Driven by Gift Relationship
Authors:
Kenji Itao,
Kunihiko Kaneko
Abstract:
Anthropologists have observed gift relationships that establish social relations as well as the transference of goods in many human societies. The totality of such social relations constitutes the network. Social scientists have analysed different types of social organisations with their characteristic networks. However, the factors and mechanisms that cause the transition between these types have…
▽ More
Anthropologists have observed gift relationships that establish social relations as well as the transference of goods in many human societies. The totality of such social relations constitutes the network. Social scientists have analysed different types of social organisations with their characteristic networks. However, the factors and mechanisms that cause the transition between these types have hardly been explained. Here, we focus on the gift as the driving force for such changes. We build the model by idealising gift interactions and simulating the consequent social change due to long-term massive interactions. We demonstrate the emergence of disparities and various social organisations depending on the frequency of the gift, consistent with the empirical data. The constructive simulation study, as presented here, explains how people's interactions shape various social structures in response to environmental conditions. Combined with empirical studies, this could contribute to the formulation of a general theory in the social sciences.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2022; v1 submitted 23 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Emergence of Kinship Structures and Descent Systems: Multi-level Evolutionary Simulation and Empirical Data Analysis
Authors:
Kenji Itao,
Kunihiko kaneko
Abstract:
In many indigenous societies, people are categorised into several cultural groups, or clans, within which they believe to share ancestors. Clan attributions provide certain rules for marriage and descent. Such rules between clans constitute kinship structures. Anthropologists have revealed several kinship structures. Here, we propose an agent-based model of indigenous societies to reveal the evolu…
▽ More
In many indigenous societies, people are categorised into several cultural groups, or clans, within which they believe to share ancestors. Clan attributions provide certain rules for marriage and descent. Such rules between clans constitute kinship structures. Anthropologists have revealed several kinship structures. Here, we propose an agent-based model of indigenous societies to reveal the evolution of kinship structures. In the model, several societies compete. Societies themselves comprise multiple families with parameters for cultural traits and mate preferences. These values determine with whom each family cooperates and competes and are transmitted to a new generation with mutation. The growth rate of each family is determined by the number of cooperators and competitors. Through this multi-level evolution, family traits and preferences diverge to form clusters that can be regarded as clans. Subsequently, kinship structures emerge, including dual organisation and generalised or restricted exchange, as well as patrilineal, matrilineal, and double descent systems. These structures emerge depending on the necessity of cooperation and the strength of mating competition. Their dependence is also estimated analytically. Finally, statistical analysis using the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample, a global ethnographic database, empirically verified theoretical results. Such collaboration between theoretical and empirical approaches will unveil universal features in anthropology.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2021; v1 submitted 17 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Evolution of family systems and resultant socio-economic structures
Authors:
Kenji Itao,
Kunihiko Kaneko
Abstract:
Families form the basis of society, and anthropologists have characterised various family systems. This study developed a multi-level evolutionary model of pre-industrial agricultural societies to simulate the evolution of family systems and determine how each of them adapts to environmental conditions and forms a characteristic socio-economic structure. In the model, competing societies evolve, w…
▽ More
Families form the basis of society, and anthropologists have characterised various family systems. This study developed a multi-level evolutionary model of pre-industrial agricultural societies to simulate the evolution of family systems and determine how each of them adapts to environmental conditions and forms a characteristic socio-economic structure. In the model, competing societies evolve, which themselves comprise multiple evolving families that grow through family labour. Each family has two strategy parameters: the time children leave the parental home and the distribution of inheritance among siblings. The evolution of these parameters demonstrates that four basic family systems emerge; families can become either nuclear or extended, and have either an equal or unequal inheritance distribution. Nuclear families emerge where land resources are sufficient, whereas extended families emerge where land resources are limited. Equal inheritance emerges where the amount of wealth required for a family to survive is large, whereas unequal inheritance emerges where the required wealth is small. Analyses on the wealth distribution of families demonstrate a higher level of poverty in extended families, and that the accumulation of wealth is accelerated for unequal inheritance. By comparing wealth distributions in the model with historical data, family systems are associated with characteristic economic structures and modern social ideologies. Empirical data analyses using the cross-cultural ethnographic database verify the theoretical relationship between the environmental conditions, family systems, and socio-economic structures. Theoretical studies by this simple constructive model, as presented here, will integrate the understandings of family systems in evolutionary anthropology, demography, and socioeconomic histories.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2021; v1 submitted 23 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
