-
Investigation of triangularity effects on tokamak edge turbulence through multi-fidelity gyrokinetic simulations
Authors:
A. C. D. Hoffmann,
P. Ricci
Abstract:
This paper uses the gyro-moment (GM) approach as a multi-fidelity tool to explore the effect of triangularity on tokamak edge turbulence. Considering experimental data from an L-mode DIII-D discharge, we conduct gyrokinetic (GK) simulations with realistic plasma edge geometry parameters at $ρ=0.95$. We find that employing ten GMs effectively captures essential features of both trapped electron mod…
▽ More
This paper uses the gyro-moment (GM) approach as a multi-fidelity tool to explore the effect of triangularity on tokamak edge turbulence. Considering experimental data from an L-mode DIII-D discharge, we conduct gyrokinetic (GK) simulations with realistic plasma edge geometry parameters at $ρ=0.95$. We find that employing ten GMs effectively captures essential features of both trapped electron mode (TEM) and ion temperature gradient (ITG) turbulence. By comparing electromagnetic GK simulations with adiabatic electron GK and reduced fluid simulations, we identify the range of validity of the reduced models. We observe that TEMs drive turbulent heat transport under nominal discharge conditions, hindering accurate transport level estimates by both simplified models. However, when TEMs are absent, and turbulence is ITG-driven, an agreement across the different models is observed. Finally, a parameter scan shows that the positive triangularity scenario destabilizes the TEM, therefore, the adiabatic electron model tends to show agreement with the electromagnetic simulations in zero and negative triangularity scenarios. On the other hand, the reduced fluid simulations exhibit limited sensitivity to triangularity changes, shedding light on the importance of retaining kinetic effects to accurately model the impact of triangularity turbulence in the tokamak edge. In conclusion, our multi-fidelity study suggests that a GM hierarchy with a limited number of moments is an ideal candidate for efficiently exploring triangularity effects on micro-scale turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Gyrokinetic moment-based simulations of the Dimits shift
Authors:
A. C. D. Hoffmann,
B. J. Frei,
P. Ricci
Abstract:
We present a convergence study of the gyromoment (GM) approach, which is based on projecting the gyrokinetic distribution function onto a Hermite-Laguerre polynomial basis, focused on the cyclone base case (CBC) (Lin et al. 1999) and Dimits shift (Dimits et al. 2000) as benchmarks. We report that the GM approach converges more rapidly in capturing the nonlinear dynamics of the CBC than the continu…
▽ More
We present a convergence study of the gyromoment (GM) approach, which is based on projecting the gyrokinetic distribution function onto a Hermite-Laguerre polynomial basis, focused on the cyclone base case (CBC) (Lin et al. 1999) and Dimits shift (Dimits et al. 2000) as benchmarks. We report that the GM approach converges more rapidly in capturing the nonlinear dynamics of the CBC than the continuum GENE code (Jenko et al. 2000) when comparing the number of points representing the velocity space. Increasing the velocity dissipation improves the convergence properties of the GM approach, albeit yielding a slightly larger saturated heat flux. By varying the temperature equilibrium gradient, we show that GM approach successfully reproduces the Dimits shift (Dimits et al. 2000) and effectively captures its width, which is in contrast to the gyrofluid framework. In the collisional regime, the convergence properties of the GM approach improve and a good agreement with previous global PIC results on transport is obtained (Lin et al. 1999). Finally, we report that the choice of collision model has a minimal impact both on the ITG growth rate and on the nonlinear saturated heat flux, at tokamak-relevant collisionality.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2023; v1 submitted 2 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Moment-Based Approach to the Flux-Tube linear Gyrokinetic Model
Authors:
B. J. Frei,
A. C. D. Hoffmann,
P. Ricci,
S. Brunner,
Z. Tecchiolli
Abstract:
This work reports on the development and numerical implementation of the linear electromagnetic gyrokinetic (GK) model in a tokamak flux-tube geometry using a moment approach based on the expansion of the perturbed distribution function on a velocity-space Hermite-Laguerre polynomials basis. A hierarchy of equations of the expansion coefficients, referred to as the gyro-moments (GM), is derived. W…
▽ More
This work reports on the development and numerical implementation of the linear electromagnetic gyrokinetic (GK) model in a tokamak flux-tube geometry using a moment approach based on the expansion of the perturbed distribution function on a velocity-space Hermite-Laguerre polynomials basis. A hierarchy of equations of the expansion coefficients, referred to as the gyro-moments (GM), is derived. We verify the numerical implementation of the GM hierarchy in the collisionless limit by performing a comparison with the continuum GK code GENE, recovering the linear properties of the ion-temperature gradient, trapped electron, kinetic ballooning, and microtearing modes, as well as the collisionless damping of zonal flows. The present investigation reveals the ability of the GM approach to describe fine velocity-space scale structures appearing near the trapped and passing boundary and kinetic effects associated with parallel and perpendicular particle drifts. In addition, the effects of collisions are studied using advanced collision operators, including the GK Coulomb collision operator. The main findings are that the number of GMs necessary for convergence decreases with plasma collisionality and is lower for pressure gradient-driven modes, such as in H-mode pedestal regions, compared to instabilities driven by trapped particles and magnetic gradient drifts often found in the core. The accuracy of approximations often used to model collisions (relative to the GK Coulomb operator) is studied, showing differences between collision operator models that increase with collisionality and electron temperature gradient in the case of TEM. The present linear analysis demonstrates that the GM approach efficiently describes the plasma dynamics for typical parameters of the tokamak boundary, ranging from the low-collisionality banana H-mode to the high-collisionality Pfirsch-Schlüter conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Gyrokinetic simulations of plasma turbulence in a Z-pinch using a moment based approach and advanced collision operators
Authors:
A. C. D. Hoffmann,
B. J. Frei,
P. Ricci
Abstract:
The first nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations obtained using a moment approach based on the Hermite-Laguerre decomposition of the distribution function are presented, implementing advanced models for the collision operator. Turbulence in a \modif{two-dimensional} Z-pinch is considered within a flux tube configuration. In the collisionless regime, our gyromoment approach shows very good agreement wit…
▽ More
The first nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations obtained using a moment approach based on the Hermite-Laguerre decomposition of the distribution function are presented, implementing advanced models for the collision operator. Turbulence in a \modif{two-dimensional} Z-pinch is considered within a flux tube configuration. In the collisionless regime, our gyromoment approach shows very good agreement with nonlinear simulations carried out with the continuum gyrokinetic code GENE, even with fewer gyromoments than required for the convergence of the linear growth rate. By using advanced linear collision operators, the role of collisions in setting the level of turbulent transport is then analyzed. The choice of collision operator model is shown to have a crucial impact when turbulence is quenched by the presence of zonal flows. The convergence properties of the gyromoment approach improve when collisions are included.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2023; v1 submitted 2 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Development of Advanced Linearized Gyrokinetic Collision Operators Using a Moment Approach
Authors:
B. J. Frei,
J. Ball,
A. C. D. Hoffmann,
R. Jorge,
P. Ricci,
L. Stenger
Abstract:
The derivation and numerical implementation of a linearized version of the gyrokinetic (GK) Coulomb collision operator (Jorge R. et al., J. Plasma Phys. 85, 905850604 (2019)) and of the widely-used linearized GK Sugama collision operator (Sugama H. et al., Phys. Plasmas 16, 112503 (2009)) is reported. An approach based on a Hermite-Laguerre moment expansion of the perturbed gyrocenter distribution…
▽ More
The derivation and numerical implementation of a linearized version of the gyrokinetic (GK) Coulomb collision operator (Jorge R. et al., J. Plasma Phys. 85, 905850604 (2019)) and of the widely-used linearized GK Sugama collision operator (Sugama H. et al., Phys. Plasmas 16, 112503 (2009)) is reported. An approach based on a Hermite-Laguerre moment expansion of the perturbed gyrocenter distribution function is used, referred to as gyro-moment expansion. This approach allows considering arbitrary perpendicular wavenumber and expressing the two linearized GK operators as a linear combination of gyro-moments where the expansion coefficients are given by closed analytical expressions that depend on the perpendicular wavenumber and on the temperature and mass ratios of the colliding species. The drift-kinetic (DK) limits of the GK linearized Coulomb and Sugama operators are also obtained. Comparisons between the gyro-moment approach with the GK continuum code GENE are reported focusing on the ion-temperature-gradient (ITG) instability and zonal flow (ZF) damping, finding an excellent agreement. In particular, we demonstrate that the GK linearized Sugama yields a stronger collisional damping of the ZF residual compared to the GK linearized Coulomb. Finally, we show that the numerical efficiency of the gyro-moment approach increases with collisionality, a desired property for boundary plasma applications.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2022; v1 submitted 23 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
