-
The Cosmic Ray Helium and Carbon Nuclei Spectra Measured by Voyager 1 at Low Energies and Earth Based Measurements of these Nuclei up to 200 GeV nuc Concordance at High Energies with a Leaky Box Propagation Model
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
P. R. Higbie
Abstract:
A comparison of the Helium and Carbon interstellar spectra measured at Voyager in the local interstellar medium leads to a different interpretation than a comparison of the Hydrogen to Helium spectra. This is because the He/C ratio is observed to increase rapidly with energy below 40 MeV/nuc in contrast to an almost constant H/He ratio at these low energies. Both the He and C spectra that are obse…
▽ More
A comparison of the Helium and Carbon interstellar spectra measured at Voyager in the local interstellar medium leads to a different interpretation than a comparison of the Hydrogen to Helium spectra. This is because the He/C ratio is observed to increase rapidly with energy below 40 MeV/nuc in contrast to an almost constant H/He ratio at these low energies. Both the He and C spectra that are observed at Voyager above 40 MeV/nuc and much higher energy spectra from the PAMELA measurements of these two components up to 100 GeV/nuc can be accurately fit to within 10% assuming galactic propagation in a leaky box type of diffusion model in the galaxy with identical source spectra P-2.28 for He and C using a diffusion coefficient P0.50 above 1 GV rigidity. These same exponents also fit the H spectrum from 40 MeV to over 100 GeV. At low energies an excess of He relative to C is observed that would amount to about 20% of the modeled galactic component at 10 MeV/nuc.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
A Fit to the Galactic Cosmic Ray Hydrogen and Helium Spectra at Voyager 1 at Low Energies and Earth Based Measurements at Much Higher Energies with Identical Rigidity Independent Source Spectra for the Hydrogen and Helium Nuclei
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
P. R. Higbie
Abstract:
Voyager 1 data from beyond the heliopause provide the first direct measurements of the interstellar cosmic ray spectra below 1 GeVnuc. In this paper we combine these Voyager measurements of H and He nuclei from 3-600 MeVnuc with higher energy measurements at 1 AU from the BESS and PAMELA experiments up to 100 GeVnuc. Using a Weighted Leaky Box Model for propagation in the galaxy, we obtain an exce…
▽ More
Voyager 1 data from beyond the heliopause provide the first direct measurements of the interstellar cosmic ray spectra below 1 GeVnuc. In this paper we combine these Voyager measurements of H and He nuclei from 3-600 MeVnuc with higher energy measurements at 1 AU from the BESS and PAMELA experiments up to 100 GeVnuc. Using a Weighted Leaky Box Model for propagation in the galaxy, we obtain an excellent fit to these new Voyager observations and the much higher energy spectra up to 100 GeVnuc by using source spectra which are P-2.28, with the exponent independent of rigidity from low to high rigidities; along with a rigidity dependence of the diffusion path length which is P-0.5 at rigidities 1.00 GV, and possibly changing to P1.0 at lower rigidities.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Calculations of the Propagated LIS Electron Spectrum Which Describe the Cosmic Ray Electron Spectrum below ~100 MeV Measured Beyond 122 AU at Voyager 1 and its Relationship to the PAMELA Electron Spectrum above 200 MeV
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
P. R. Higbie
Abstract:
The new Voyager measurements of cosmic ray electrons between 6-60 MeV beyond 122 AU are very sensitive indicators of cosmic ray propagation and acceleration in the galaxy at a very low modulation level. Using a Monte Carlo diffusion model with a source spectrum with a single spectral index of -2.2 at all energies we are able to fit this observed Voyager spectrum and the contemporary PAMELA electro…
▽ More
The new Voyager measurements of cosmic ray electrons between 6-60 MeV beyond 122 AU are very sensitive indicators of cosmic ray propagation and acceleration in the galaxy at a very low modulation level. Using a Monte Carlo diffusion model with a source spectrum with a single spectral index of -2.2 at all energies we are able to fit this observed Voyager spectrum and the contemporary PAMELA electron spectrum over an energy range from 6 MeV to ~200 GeV. This spectrum has a break in it but this break is due to propagation effects, not changes in the primary spectrum. This break is gradual, starting at > 2 GeV where the spectrum is ~E^-3.2 and continuing down to ~100 MeV or below where the spectrum becomes ~E^-1.5. At the higher energies the loss terms due to synchrotron radiation and inverse Compton effects which are ~E^2.0 steepen the exponent of the source spectrum by 1.0. At lower energies, these terms become unimportant and the loss is governed by diffusion and escape from the galaxy. A diffusion term which is proportional to beta^-1 below ~0.32 GV (which also fit the H and He spectra measured at Voyager) and has a value = 3x1028 cm^2 x s^-1 at 1 GV and a boundary at +/-1 Kpc will fit the Voyager or other similar spectra at low energies.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
A Comparison of the Galactic Cosmic Ray H, He and C/O Nuclei Spectra Measured Between ~5 and 500 MeV/nuc Beyond 122 AU at Voyager 1 with the Predictions of a Diffusion Model for Propagation in the Galaxy
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
P. R. Higbie,
F. B. McDonald
Abstract:
After the disappearance of lower energy heliospheric particles at Voyager 1 starting on August 25th, 2012, spectra of H, He and C/O nuclei were revealed that resembled those to be expected for galactic cosmic rays. These spectra had intensity peaks in the range of 30-60 MeV, decreasing at both lower energies down to a few MeV and at higher energies up to several hundred MeV. We have modeled the pr…
▽ More
After the disappearance of lower energy heliospheric particles at Voyager 1 starting on August 25th, 2012, spectra of H, He and C/O nuclei were revealed that resembled those to be expected for galactic cosmic rays. These spectra had intensity peaks in the range of 30-60 MeV, decreasing at both lower energies down to a few MeV and at higher energies up to several hundred MeV. We have modeled the propagation of these particles in the galaxy using an updated Leaky Box Diffusion model which determines the spectra of these components from ~2 MeV to >200 GeV. The key parameters used in the model are a galactic input spectrum ~P^-2.24, the same for all components and independent of rigidity, and a diffusion coefficient that is ~P^0.5 above a lower rigidity and increases ~beta^-1.0 below a lower rigidity ~0.56 GV. These same parameters also fit the high energy H and He data from ~10-200 GeV/nuc from the PAMELA and BESS experiments. The new Voyager spectra for all three nuclei are thus consistent with rigidity spectra ~P^-2.24 from the lowest energies to at least 100 GeV. Deviations from this spectrum can reasonably be attributed to propagation effects. Some deviations between the calculated and newly observed spectra are noted, however, below ~30 MeV/nuc, particularly for C/O nuclei, that could be significant regarding the propagation and sources of these particles.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
The Unfolding of the Spectra of Low Energy Galactic Cosmic Ray H and He Nuclei as the Voyager 1 Spacecraft Exits the Region of Heliospheric Modulation
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
P. R. Higbie,
F. B. McDonald
Abstract:
This paper describes the unfolding of the solar modulated galactic cosmic ray H and He nuclei spectra beyond ~105 AU in the heliosheath. Between 2008.0 and 2012.3 when Voyager 1 went from about 105 to 120.5 AU the spectral intensities of these two components between about 30 and 500 MeV/nuc unfolded (increased) in a manner consistent with an average modulation potential decrease ~5 MV per AU as de…
▽ More
This paper describes the unfolding of the solar modulated galactic cosmic ray H and He nuclei spectra beyond ~105 AU in the heliosheath. Between 2008.0 and 2012.3 when Voyager 1 went from about 105 to 120.5 AU the spectral intensities of these two components between about 30 and 500 MeV/nuc unfolded (increased) in a manner consistent with an average modulation potential decrease ~5 MV per AU as described by a Parker like cosmic ray transport in the heliosphere where the overall modulation is described by a modulation potential in MV. Between 120.5 and 121.7 AU, however, as a result of two sudden intensity increases starting on May 8th and August 25th, 2012, this modulation potential decreased by ~80 MV and spectra resembling possible local interstellar spectra for H and He were revealed. Considering these spectra to be the local interstellar spectra would imply that almost 1/3 of the total modulation potential of about 270 MV required to explain the spectra of these components observed at the Earth must occur in just a 1 AU radial interval in the outer heliosheath. As a result about ~80% of the total modulation potential observed at the Earth at this time occurs in the heliosheath itself. The remaining 20% of the total modulation occurs inside the heliospheric termination shock. The details of these intensity changes and their description by a simple modulation model are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Large periodic time variations of termination shock particles between ~0.5-20 mev and 6-14 mev electrons measured by the crs experiment on Voyager 2 as it crossed into the heliosheath in 2007: An example of freshly accelerated cosmic rays?
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
A. C. Cummings,
E. C. Stone,
F. B. McDonald,
D. S. Intriligator,
P. R. Higbie,
B. Heikkila,
N. Lal
Abstract:
We have examined features in the structure of the heliosheath using the fine scale time variations of termination shock particles (TSP) between ~0.5 - 20 MeV and electrons between 2.5-14 MeV measured by the CRS instrument as the V2 spacecraft crossed the heliospheric termination shock in 2007. The very disturbed heliosheath at V2 is particularly noteworthy for strong periodic intensity variations…
▽ More
We have examined features in the structure of the heliosheath using the fine scale time variations of termination shock particles (TSP) between ~0.5 - 20 MeV and electrons between 2.5-14 MeV measured by the CRS instrument as the V2 spacecraft crossed the heliospheric termination shock in 2007. The very disturbed heliosheath at V2 is particularly noteworthy for strong periodic intensity variations of the TSP just after V2 crossed the termination shock (2007.66) reaching a maximum between 2007.75 and 2008.0. A series of 42/21 day periodicities was observed at V2 along with spectral changes of low energy TSP and the acceleration of 6-14 MeV electrons. Evidence is presented for the acceleration of TSP and electrons at the times of the 42/21 day periodicities just after V2 crossed the HTS. Spectra for TSP between 2-20 MeV and electrons between 2.5-14 MeV are derived for three time periods including the time of the HTS crossing. The energy spectra of TSP and electrons at these times of intensity peaks are very similar above ~3 MeV, with exponents of a power law spectrum between -3.0 and -3.6. The ratio of TSP intensities to electron intensities at the same energy is ~500. The electron intensity peaks and minima are generally out of phase with those of nuclei by ~1/2 of a 42 day cycle. These charge dependent intensity differences and the large periodic intensity changes could provide new clues as to a possible acceleration mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
20-125 mev/nuc cosmic ray carbon nuclei intensities between 2004-2010 in solar cycle #23 as measured near the earth, at voyager 2 and also in the heliosheath at voyager 1 - modulation in a two zone heliospehre
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
A. C. Cummings,
E. C. Stone,
F. B. McDonald,
R. A. Mewaldt,
R. Leske,
M. Wiedenbeck,
P. R. Higbie,
B. Heikkila
Abstract:
The recovery of cosmic ray Carbon nuclei of energy ~20-125 MeV/nuc in solar cycle #23 from 2004 to 2010 has been followed at three locations, near the Earth using ACE data and at V2 between 74-92 AU and also at V1 beyond the heliospheric termination shock at between 91-113 AU. To describe the observed intensity changes and to predict the absolute intensities measured at all three locations we have…
▽ More
The recovery of cosmic ray Carbon nuclei of energy ~20-125 MeV/nuc in solar cycle #23 from 2004 to 2010 has been followed at three locations, near the Earth using ACE data and at V2 between 74-92 AU and also at V1 beyond the heliospheric termination shock at between 91-113 AU. To describe the observed intensity changes and to predict the absolute intensities measured at all three locations we have used a simple spherically symmetric (no drift) two-zone heliospheric transport model with specific values for the diffusion coefficient in both the inner and outer zones. The diffusion coefficient in the outer zone is determined to be ~5-10 times smaller than that in the inner zone out to 90 AU. For both V1 and V2 the calculated C nuclei intensities agree within an average of \pm 10% with the observed intensities. Because of this agreement between V1 and V2 observations and predictions there is no need to invoke an asymmetrical squashed heliosphere or other effects to explain the V2 intensities relative to V1 as is the case for He nuclei. The combination of the diffusion parameters used in this model and the interstellar spectrum give an unusually low overall solar modulation parameter φ= 250 MV to describe the Carbon intensities observed at the Earth in 2009. At all times both the observed and calculated spectra are very closely ~ E1.0 as would be expected in the adiabatic energy loss regime of solar modulation.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Recovery of 150-250 MeV Cosmic Ray Proton Intensities Between 2004-2010 as Measured Near the Earth, at Voyager 2 and also in the Heliosheath at Voyager 1 - A Two Zone Heliosphere
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
F. B. McDonald,
P. R. Higbie,
B. Heikkila
Abstract:
The recovery of cosmic ray protons of energy ~150-250 MeV/nuc in solar cycle #23 from 2004 to 2010 has been followed at the Earth using IMP, ACE and balloon data and also at V2 between 74-92 AU and at V1 beyond the heliospheric termination shock (91-113 AU). The correlation coefficient between the intensities the Earth and V1 during this time period, is 0.936, allowing for a ~0.9 year delay due to…
▽ More
The recovery of cosmic ray protons of energy ~150-250 MeV/nuc in solar cycle #23 from 2004 to 2010 has been followed at the Earth using IMP, ACE and balloon data and also at V2 between 74-92 AU and at V1 beyond the heliospheric termination shock (91-113 AU). The correlation coefficient between the intensities the Earth and V1 during this time period, is 0.936, allowing for a ~0.9 year delay due to the solar wind propagation time from the Earth to the outer heliosphere. To describe these intensity changes and to predict the absolute intensities measured at all three locations we have used a simple spherically symmetric (no drift) two-zone heliospheric transport model with specific values for the diffusion coefficient in both the inner and outer zones. The diffusion coefficient in the outer zone, from about 90 to 120 (130) AU, is determined to be ~5-10 times smaller than that in the inner zone out to 90 AU. This means that the outer zone acts much like a diffusing barrier in this model. The absolute magnitude of the intensities and the intensity changes at V1 and the Earth are described to within a few percent by a diffusion coefficient that varies with time by a factor ~4 in the inner zone and only ~1.8 (1.25) in the outer zone over the time period from 2004-2010. These diffusion coefficients and their variations are essentially the same as those derived earlier from a similar study using He nuclei of the same energy. This model and the diffusion coefficients used provide a total modulation potential at the Earth ~250 MV in 2009. The difference ~10-20% between calculated and observed intensities at V2 can be explained if the heliosphere is squashed by ~10% in distance (non-spherical) so that the HTS is closer to the Sun in the direction of V2 compared to V1.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Recovery of 150-250 MeV/nuc Cosmic Ray Helium Nuclei Intensities Between 2004-2010 Near the Earth, at Voyager 2 and Voyager 1 in the Heliosheath - A Two Zone Helioshpere
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
F. B. McDonald,
P. R. Higbie,
B. Heikkila
Abstract:
The recovery of cosmic ray He nuclei of energy ~150-250 MeV/nuc in solar cycle #23 from 2004 to 2010 has been followed at the Earth using IMP and ACE data and at V2 between 74-92 AU and also at V1 beyond the heliospheric termination shock (91-113 AU). The correlation coefficient between the intensities at the Earth and at V1 during this time period is remarkable (0.921), after allowing for a ~0.9…
▽ More
The recovery of cosmic ray He nuclei of energy ~150-250 MeV/nuc in solar cycle #23 from 2004 to 2010 has been followed at the Earth using IMP and ACE data and at V2 between 74-92 AU and also at V1 beyond the heliospheric termination shock (91-113 AU). The correlation coefficient between the intensities at the Earth and at V1 during this time period is remarkable (0.921), after allowing for a ~0.9 year delay due to the solar wind propagation time from the Earth to the outer heliosphere. To describe the intensity changes and to predict the absolute intensities measured at all three locations we have used a simple spherically symmetric (no drift) two-zone heliospheric transport model with specific values for the diffusion coefficient in both the inner and outer zones. The diffusion coefficient in the outer zone, assumed to be the heliosheath from about 90 to 120 (130) AU, is determined to be ~5 times smaller than that in the inner zone out to 90 AU. This means the Heliosheath acts much like a diffusing barrier in this model. The absolute magnitude of the intensities and the intensity changes at V1 and the Earth are described to within a few percent by a diffusion coefficient that varies with time by a factor ~4 in the inner zone and only a factor of ~1.5 in the outer zone over the time period from 2004-2010. For V2 the observed intensities follow a curve that is as much as 25% higher than the calculated intensities at the V2 radius and at times the observed V2 intensities are equal to those at V1. At least one-half of the difference between the calculated and observed intensities between V1 and V2 can be explained if the heliosphere is squashed by ~10% in distance (non-spherical) so that the HTS location is closer to the Sun in the direction of V2 compared to V1.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
A Comparison Of New Calculations Of The Yearly 10Be Production In The Earths Polar Atmosphere By Cosmic Rays With Yearly 10Be Measurements In Multiple Greenland Ice Cores Between 1939 And 1994 - A Troubling Lack Of Concordance Paper #2
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
P. R. Higbie,
C. W. Webber
Abstract:
We have compared the yearly production rates of 10Be by cosmic rays in the Earths polar atmosphere over the last 50-70 years with 10Be measurements from two separate ice cores in Greenland. These ice cores provide measurements of the annual 10Be concentration and 10Be flux levels during this time. The scatter in the ice core yearly data vs. the production data is larger than the average solar 11…
▽ More
We have compared the yearly production rates of 10Be by cosmic rays in the Earths polar atmosphere over the last 50-70 years with 10Be measurements from two separate ice cores in Greenland. These ice cores provide measurements of the annual 10Be concentration and 10Be flux levels during this time. The scatter in the ice core yearly data vs. the production data is larger than the average solar 11 year production variations that are being measured. The cross correlation coefficients between the yearly 10Be production and the ice core 10Be measurements for this time period are <0.4 in all comparisons between ice core data and 10Be production, including 10Be concentrations, 10Be fluxes and in comparing the two separate ice core measurements. In fact, the cross correlation between the two ice core measurements, which should be measuring the same source, is the lowest of all, only ~0.2. These values for the correlation coefficient are all indicative of a "poor" correlation. The regression line slopes for the best fit lines between the 10Be production and the 10Be measurements used in the cross correlation analysis are all in the range 0.4-0.6. This is a particular problem for historical projections of solar activity based on ice core measurements which assume a 1:1 correspondence. We have made other tests of the correspondence between the 10Be predictions and the ice core measurements which lead to the same conclusion, namely that other influences on the ice core measurements, as large as or larger than the production changes themselves, are occurring. These influences could be climatic or instrumentally based. We suggest new ice core measurements that might help in defining more clearly what these influences are and-if possible-to correct for them.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
A comparison of new calculations of 10be production in the earths polar atmosphere by cosmic rays with 10be concentration measurements in polar ice cores between 1939-2005 - a troubling lack of concordance paper #1
Authors:
W. R. Webber,
P. R. Higbie
Abstract:
Using new calculations of 10Be production in the Earths atmosphere which are based on direct measurements of the 11-year solar modulation effects on galactic cosmic rays and spacecraft measurements of the cosmic ray energy spectrum, we have calculated the yearly average production of 10Be in the Earths atmosphere by galactic and solar cosmic rays since 1939. During the last six 11-year cycles the…
▽ More
Using new calculations of 10Be production in the Earths atmosphere which are based on direct measurements of the 11-year solar modulation effects on galactic cosmic rays and spacecraft measurements of the cosmic ray energy spectrum, we have calculated the yearly average production of 10Be in the Earths atmosphere by galactic and solar cosmic rays since 1939. During the last six 11-year cycles the average amplitude of these production changes is 36%. These predictions are compared with measurements of 10Be concentration in polar ice cores in both the Northern and Southern hemisphere over the same time period. We find a large scatter between the predicted and measured yearly average data sets and a low cross correlation ~0.30. Also the normalized regression line slope between 10Be production changes and 10Be concentration changes is found to be only 0.4-0.6; much less than the value of 1.0 expected for a simple proportionality between these quantities, as is typically used for historical projections of the relationship between 10Be concentration and solar activity. The distribution of yearly averages in the 10Be concentration level in the data from the Dye-3 ice core in Greenland for the time period 1939-1985, contains a "spike" of high concentration one year averages which is not seen in the production calculations. These and other features suggest that galactic cosmic ray intensity changes which affect the production of 10Be in the Earths atmosphere are not the sole source of the 10Be concentration changes and confirm the importance of other effects, for example local and regional climatic effects, which could be of the same magnitude as the 10Be production changes.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
