-
Frequently Used References For Atomic Data In X-ray Spectroscopy
Authors:
N. Hell,
G. V. Brown,
M. E. Eckart,
A. J. Fairchild,
C. A. Kilbourne,
M. A. Leutenegger,
F. S. Porter,
M. C. Witthoeft
Abstract:
Accurate atomic physics reference data are a crucial requirement for analysis and interpretation of observed spectra, even more so for observations with high spectral resolution. This document provides a curated list of atomic physics references frequently used for plasma diagnostics in X-ray spectroscopy, outside of comprehensive plasma models that typically come with their own underlying atomic…
▽ More
Accurate atomic physics reference data are a crucial requirement for analysis and interpretation of observed spectra, even more so for observations with high spectral resolution. This document provides a curated list of atomic physics references frequently used for plasma diagnostics in X-ray spectroscopy, outside of comprehensive plasma models that typically come with their own underlying atomic databases. The list includes references to physical constants, laboratory benchmarks, transition energies, position and line shapes of neutral fluorescence lines, radiative branching ratios, and commonly used notation for prominent transitions. Quick-look tables for transition energies in H-, He-, and Li-like ions and line positions and shapes for fluorescence lines in neutrals. The main focus is on K-shell transitions. For the H- and He-like tables, we cite state-of-the art calculations that we consider currently the best available reference energies, which are considered high accuracy and thus typically used for energy scale calibration in laboratory measurements. Omissions in these tables are due to the lack of availability in the chosen references, and are not a statement about the relevance of these lines. Due to their complex and highly source-dependent line shape, the atomic data for neutrals is of lower accuracy than that for the highly charged ions, and the best reference data for these line shapes typically consist of empirical models derived from very high-resolution laboratory measurements. The table for neutrals provided here is consistent with the reference used for the energy gain scale calibration of XRISM/Resolve. This document is meant to serve as a resource to help find relevant references and conveniently formatted overview tables. When making use of the information found in these papers, credit should be given to their original authors by citing the appropriate references.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
A new benchmark of soft X-ray transition energies of Ne, CO$_2$, and SF$_6$: paving a pathway towards ppm accuracy
Authors:
J. Stierhof,
S. Kühn,
M. Winter,
P. Micke,
R. Steinbrügge,
C. Shah,
N. Hell,
M. Bissinger,
M. Hirsch,
R. Ballhausen,
M. Lang,
C. Gräfe,
S. Wipf,
R. Cumbee,
G. L. Betancourt-Martinez,
S. Park,
J. Niskanen,
M. Chung,
F. S. Porter,
T. Stöhlker,
T. Pfeifer,
G. V. Brown,
S. Bernitt,
P. Hansmann,
J. Wilms
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
A key requirement for the correct interpretation of high-resolution X-ray spectra is that transition energies are known with high accuracy and precision. We investigate the K-shell features of Ne, CO$_2$, and SF$_6$ gases, by measuring their photo ion-yield spectra at the BESSY II synchrotron facility simultaneously with the 1s-np fluorescence emission of He-like ions produced in the Polar-X EBIT.…
▽ More
A key requirement for the correct interpretation of high-resolution X-ray spectra is that transition energies are known with high accuracy and precision. We investigate the K-shell features of Ne, CO$_2$, and SF$_6$ gases, by measuring their photo ion-yield spectra at the BESSY II synchrotron facility simultaneously with the 1s-np fluorescence emission of He-like ions produced in the Polar-X EBIT. Accurate ab initio calculations of transitions in these ions provide the basis of the calibration. While the CO$_2$ result agrees well with previous measurements, the SF$_6$ spectrum appears shifted by ~0.5 eV, about twice the uncertainty of the earlier results. Our result for Ne shows a large departure from earlier results, but may suffer from larger systematic effects than our other measurements. The molecular spectra agree well with our results of time-dependent density functional theory. We find that the statistical uncertainty allows calibrations in the desired range of 1-10 meV, however, systematic contributions still limit the uncertainty to ~40-100 meV, mainly due to the temporal stability of the monochromator energy scale. Combining our absolute calibration technique with a relative energy calibration technique such as photoelectron energy spectroscopy will be necessary to realize its full potential of achieving uncertainties as low as 1-10 meV.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
High-resolution Laboratory Measurements of K-shell X-ray Line Polarization and Excitation Cross Sections in Heliumlike S XV Ions
Authors:
Chintan Shah,
Natalie Hell,
Antonia Hubbard,
Ming Feng Gu,
Michael J. MacDonald,
Megan E. Eckart,
Richard L. Kelley,
Caroline A. Kilbourne,
Maurice A. Leutenegger,
F. Scott Porter,
Gregory V. Brown
Abstract:
We report measurements of electron-impact excitation cross sections for the strong K-shell n=2-1 transitions in S XV using the LLNL EBIT-I electron beam ion trap, two crystal spectrometers, and the EBIT Calorimeter Spectrometer. The cross sections are determined by direct normalization to the well known cross sections of radiative electron capture, measured simultaneously. Using contemporaneous po…
▽ More
We report measurements of electron-impact excitation cross sections for the strong K-shell n=2-1 transitions in S XV using the LLNL EBIT-I electron beam ion trap, two crystal spectrometers, and the EBIT Calorimeter Spectrometer. The cross sections are determined by direct normalization to the well known cross sections of radiative electron capture, measured simultaneously. Using contemporaneous polarization measurements with the two crystal spectrometers, whose dispersion planes are oriented parallel and perpendicular to the electron beam direction, the polarization of the direct excitation line emission is determined, and in turn the isotropic total cross sections are extracted. We further experimentally investigate various line-formation mechanisms, finding that radiative cascades and collisional inner-shell ionization dominate the degree of linear polarization and total line-emission cross sections of the forbidden line $z$.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
High-Precision Determination of Oxygen-K$α$ Transition Energy Excludes Incongruent Motion of Interstellar Oxygen
Authors:
M. A. Leutenegger,
S. Kühn,
P. Micke,
R. Steinbrügge,
J. Stierhof,
C. Shah,
N. Hell,
M. Bissinger,
M. Hirsch,
R. Ballhausen,
M. Lang,
C. Gräfe,
S. Wipf,
R. Cumbee,
G. L. Betancourt-Martinez,
S. Park,
V. A. Yerokhin,
A. Surzhykov,
W. C. Stolte,
J. Niskanen,
M. Chung,
F. S. Porter,
T. Stöhlker,
T. Pfeifer,
J. Wilms
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We demonstrate a widely applicable technique to absolutely calibrate the energy scale of x-ray spectra with experimentally well-known and accurately calculable transitions of highly charged ions, allowing us to measure the K-shell Rydberg spectrum of molecular O$_2$ with 8 meV uncertainty. We reveal a systematic $\sim$450 meV shift from previous literature values, and settle an extraordinary discr…
▽ More
We demonstrate a widely applicable technique to absolutely calibrate the energy scale of x-ray spectra with experimentally well-known and accurately calculable transitions of highly charged ions, allowing us to measure the K-shell Rydberg spectrum of molecular O$_2$ with 8 meV uncertainty. We reveal a systematic $\sim$450 meV shift from previous literature values, and settle an extraordinary discrepancy between astrophysical and laboratory measurements of neutral atomic oxygen, the latter being calibrated against the aforementioned O$_2$ literature values. Because of the widespread use of such, now deprecated, references, our method impacts on many branches of x-ray absorption spectroscopy. Moreover, it potentially reduces absolute uncertainties there to below the meV level.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2020; v1 submitted 30 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Observation of strong two-electron--one-photon transitions in few-electron ion
Authors:
Moto Togawa,
Steffen Kühn,
Chintan Shah,
Pedro Amaro,
René Steinbrügge,
Jakob Stierhof,
Natalie Hell,
Michael Rosner,
Keisuke Fujii,
Matthias Bissinger,
Ralf Ballhausen,
Moritz Hoesch,
Jörn Seltmann,
SungNam Park,
Filipe Grilo,
F. Scott Porter,
José Paulo Santos,
Moses Chung,
Thomas Stöhlker,
Jörn Wilms,
Thomas Pfeifer,
Gregory V. Brown,
Maurice A. Leutenegger,
Sven Bernitt,
José R. Crespo López-Urrutia
Abstract:
We resonantly excite the $K$ series of O$^{5+}$ and O$^{6+}$ up to principal quantum number $n=11$ with monochromatic x rays, producing $K$-shell holes, and observe their relaxation by soft-x-ray emission. Some photoabsorption resonances of O$^{5+}$ reveal strong two-electron--one-photon (TEOP) transitions. We find that for the $[(1s\,2s)_1\,5p_{3/2}]_{3/2;1/2}$ states, TEOP relaxation is by far s…
▽ More
We resonantly excite the $K$ series of O$^{5+}$ and O$^{6+}$ up to principal quantum number $n=11$ with monochromatic x rays, producing $K$-shell holes, and observe their relaxation by soft-x-ray emission. Some photoabsorption resonances of O$^{5+}$ reveal strong two-electron--one-photon (TEOP) transitions. We find that for the $[(1s\,2s)_1\,5p_{3/2}]_{3/2;1/2}$ states, TEOP relaxation is by far stronger than the radiative decay and competes with the usually much faster Auger decay path. This enhanced TEOP decay arises from a strong correlation with the near-degenerate upper states $[(1s\,2p_{3/2})_1\,4s]_{3/2;1/2}$ of a Li-like satellite blend of the He-like $Kα$ transition. Even in three-electron systems, TEOP transitions can play a dominant role, and the present results should guide further research on the ubiquitous and abundant many-electron ions where electronic energy degeneracies are far more common and configuration mixing is stronger.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2020; v1 submitted 12 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
High Resolution Photoexcitation Measurements Exacerbate the Long-Standing Fe XVII Oscillator Strength Problem
Authors:
Steffen Kühn,
Chintan Shah,
José R. Crespo López-Urrutia,
Keisuke Fujii,
René Steinbrügge,
Jakob Stierhof,
Moto Togawa,
Zoltán Harman,
Natalia S. Oreshkina,
Charles Cheung,
Mikhail G. Kozlov,
Sergey G. Porsev,
Marianna S. Safronova,
Julian C. Berengut,
Michael Rosner,
Matthias Bissinger,
Ralf Ballhausen,
Natalie Hell,
SungNam Park,
Moses Chung,
Moritz Hoesch,
Jörn Seltmann,
Andrey S. Surzhykov,
Vladimir A. Yerokhin,
Jörn Wilms
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
For more than 40 years, most astrophysical observations and laboratory studies of two key soft x-ray diagnostic $2p-3d$ transitions, $3C$ and $3D$, in Fe XVII ions found oscillator strength ratios $f(3C)/f(3D)$ disagreeing with theory, but uncertainties had precluded definitive statements on this much studied conundrum. Here, we resonantly excite these lines using synchrotron radiation at PETRA II…
▽ More
For more than 40 years, most astrophysical observations and laboratory studies of two key soft x-ray diagnostic $2p-3d$ transitions, $3C$ and $3D$, in Fe XVII ions found oscillator strength ratios $f(3C)/f(3D)$ disagreeing with theory, but uncertainties had precluded definitive statements on this much studied conundrum. Here, we resonantly excite these lines using synchrotron radiation at PETRA III, and reach, at a millionfold lower photon intensities, a 10 times higher spectral resolution, and 3 times smaller uncertainty than earlier work. Our final result of $f(3C)/f(3D) = 3.09(8)(6)$ supports many of the earlier clean astrophysical and laboratory observations, while departing by five sigmas from our own newest large-scale ab initio calculations, and excluding all proposed explanations, including those invoking nonlinear effects and population transfers.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2020; v1 submitted 21 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Laboratory Calibrations of Fe XII-XIV Line-Intensity Ratios for Electron Density Diagnostics
Authors:
Thusitha P. Arthanayaka,
Peter Beiersdorfer,
Gregory V. Brown,
Ming Feng Gu,
Michael Hahn,
Natalie Hell,
Tom E. Lockard,
Daniel Wolf Savin
Abstract:
We have used an electron beam ion trap to measure electron-density-diagnostic line-intensity ratios for extreme ultraviolet lines from F XII, XIII, and XIV at wavelengths of 185-205 255-276 Angstroms. These ratios can be used as density diagnostics for astrophysical spectra and are especially relevant to solar physics. We found that density diagnostics using the Fe XIII 196.53/202.04 and the Fe XI…
▽ More
We have used an electron beam ion trap to measure electron-density-diagnostic line-intensity ratios for extreme ultraviolet lines from F XII, XIII, and XIV at wavelengths of 185-205 255-276 Angstroms. These ratios can be used as density diagnostics for astrophysical spectra and are especially relevant to solar physics. We found that density diagnostics using the Fe XIII 196.53/202.04 and the Fe XIV 264.79/274.21 and 270.52A/274.21 line ratios are reliable using the atomic data calculated with the Flexible Atomic Code. On the other hand, we found a large discrepancy between the FAC theory and experiment for the commonly used Fe XII (186.85 + 186.88)/195.12 line ratio. These FAC theory calculations give similar results to the data tabulated in CHIANTI, which are commonly used to analyze solar observations. Our results suggest that the discrepancies seen between solar coronal density measurements using the Fe XII (186.85 + 186.88)/195.12 and Fe XIII 196.54/202.04 line ratios are likely due to issues with the atomic calculations for Fe XII.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Laboratory Measurements of the K-shell transition energies in L-shell ions of Si and S
Authors:
N. Hell,
G. V. Brown,
J. Wilms,
V. Grinberg,
J. Clementson,
D. Liedahl,
F. S. Porter,
R. L. Kelley,
C. A. Kilbourne,
P. Beiersdorfer
Abstract:
We have measured the energies of the strongest 1s-2ell (ell=s,p) transitions in He- through Ne-like silicon and sulfur ions to an accuracy of better than 1eV using Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory's electron beam ion traps, EBIT-I and SuperEBIT, and the NASA/GSFC EBIT Calorimeter Spectrometer (ECS). We identify and measure the energies of 18 and 21 X-ray features from silicon and sulfur, res…
▽ More
We have measured the energies of the strongest 1s-2ell (ell=s,p) transitions in He- through Ne-like silicon and sulfur ions to an accuracy of better than 1eV using Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory's electron beam ion traps, EBIT-I and SuperEBIT, and the NASA/GSFC EBIT Calorimeter Spectrometer (ECS). We identify and measure the energies of 18 and 21 X-ray features from silicon and sulfur, respectively. The results are compared to new Flexible Atomic Code calculations and to semi-relativistic Hartree Fock calculations by Palmeri et al. (2008). These results will be especially useful for wind diagnostics in high mass X-ray binaries, such as Vela X-1 and Cygnus X-1, where high-resolution spectral measurements using Chandra's high energy transmission grating has made it possible to measure Doppler shifts of 100km/s. The accuracy of our measurements is consistent with that needed to analyze Chandra observations, exceeding Chandra's 100km/s limit. Hence, the results presented here not only provide benchmarks for theory, but also accurate rest energies that can be used to determine the bulk motion of material in astrophysical sources. We show the usefulness of our results by applying them to redetermine Doppler shifts from Chandra observations of Vela X-1.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
X-ray resonant photoexcitation: line widths and energies of Kα transitions in highly charged Fe ions
Authors:
J. K. Rudolph,
S. Bernitt,
S. W. Epp,
R. Steinbrügge,
C. Beilmann,
G. V. Brown,
S. Eberle,
A. Graf,
Z. Harman,
N. Hell,
M. Leutenegger,
A. Müller,
K. Schlage,
H. -C. Wille,
H. Yavas,
J. Ullrich,
J. R. Crespo López-Urrutia
Abstract:
Photoabsorption by and fluorescence of the Kα transitions in highly charged iron ions are essential mechanisms for X-ray radiation transfer in astrophysical environments. We study photoabsorption due to the main Kα transitions in highly charged iron ions from heliumlike to fluorinelike (Fe 24+...17+) using monochromatic X-rays around 6.6 keV at the PETRA III synchrotron photon source. Natural line…
▽ More
Photoabsorption by and fluorescence of the Kα transitions in highly charged iron ions are essential mechanisms for X-ray radiation transfer in astrophysical environments. We study photoabsorption due to the main Kα transitions in highly charged iron ions from heliumlike to fluorinelike (Fe 24+...17+) using monochromatic X-rays around 6.6 keV at the PETRA III synchrotron photon source. Natural linewidths were determined with hitherto unattained accuracy. The observed transitions are of particular interest for the understanding of photoexcited plasmas found in X-ray binaries and active galactic nuclei.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2013; v1 submitted 18 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
