-
Radical scaling: beyond our feet and fingers
Authors:
Marc-Antoine Fardin,
Mathieu Hautefeuille,
Vivek Sharma
Abstract:
Scaling laws arise and are eulogized across disciplines from natural to social sciences for providing pithy, quantitative, `scale-free', and `universal' power law relationships between two variables. On a log-log plot, the power laws display as straight lines, with a slope set by the exponent of the scaling law. In practice, a scaling relationship works only for a limited range, bookended by cross…
▽ More
Scaling laws arise and are eulogized across disciplines from natural to social sciences for providing pithy, quantitative, `scale-free', and `universal' power law relationships between two variables. On a log-log plot, the power laws display as straight lines, with a slope set by the exponent of the scaling law. In practice, a scaling relationship works only for a limited range, bookended by crossovers to other scaling laws. Leading with Taylor's oft-cited scaling law for the blast radius of an explosion against time, and by collating an unprecedented amount of datasets for laser-induced, chemical and nuclear explosions, we show distinct kinematics arise at the early and late stages. We illustrate that picking objective scales for the two axes using the transitions between regimes leads to the collapse of the data for the two regimes and their crossover, but the third regime is typically not mapped to the master curve. The objective scales permit us to abandon the arbitrarily chosen anthropocentric units of measurement, like feet for length and heart-beat for time, but the decimal system with ten digits (fingers) is still part of the picture. We show a remarkable collapse of all three regimes onto a common master curve occurs if we replace the base 10 by a dimensionless radix that combines the scales from the two crossovers. We also illustrate this approach of radical scaling for capillarity-driven pinching, coalescence and spreading of drops and bubbles, expecting such generalizations will be made for datasets across many disciplines.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
The size of the Sun
Authors:
Marc-Antoine Fardin,
Mathieu Hautefeuille
Abstract:
Why does the Sun have a radius around 696000~km? We will see in this article that dimensional arguments can be used to understand the size of the Sun and of a few other things along the way. These arguments are not new and can be found scattered in textbooks. They are presented here in a succinct way in order to better confront the kinematic and mechanical viewpoints on size. We derive and compare…
▽ More
Why does the Sun have a radius around 696000~km? We will see in this article that dimensional arguments can be used to understand the size of the Sun and of a few other things along the way. These arguments are not new and can be found scattered in textbooks. They are presented here in a succinct way in order to better confront the kinematic and mechanical viewpoints on size. We derive and compare a number of expressions for the size of the Sun and relate large and small scales. We hope that such presentation will be useful to students, instructors and researchers alike.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Dynamic duos: the building blocks of dimensional mechanics
Authors:
Marc-Antoine Fardin,
Mathieu Hautefeuille,
Vivek Sharma
Abstract:
Mechanics studies the relationships between space, time, and matter, which can be expressed in terms of the dimensions of length $\mathcal{L}$, time $\mathcal{T}$, and mass $\mathcal{M}$. Each dimension broadens the scope of mechanics, from geometric quantities with dimensions of the form $\mathcal{L}^x$ (like lengths or areas), to kinematic quantities of the form $\mathcal{L}^x\mathcal{T}^y$ (lik…
▽ More
Mechanics studies the relationships between space, time, and matter, which can be expressed in terms of the dimensions of length $\mathcal{L}$, time $\mathcal{T}$, and mass $\mathcal{M}$. Each dimension broadens the scope of mechanics, from geometric quantities with dimensions of the form $\mathcal{L}^x$ (like lengths or areas), to kinematic quantities of the form $\mathcal{L}^x\mathcal{T}^y$ (like speeds or accelerations), and eventually ``mass-carrying'' quantities such as mass, force, momentum, energy, action, power, viscosity, etc. These standard mechanical quantities have dimensions of the form $\mathcal{M}\mathcal{L}^x\mathcal{T}^y$, where $x$ and $y$ are integers. In this contribution, we use this dimensional structure to arrange these mass-carrying quantities into a table indexed by $x$ and $y$. Ratios of quantities in the same rows provide characteristic lengths, and in the same columns characteristic times, encompassing a great variety of physical phenomena from atomic to astronomical scales. Most generally, we show that picking duos of mechanical quantities that are neither on the same row nor column yields dynamics, where one mechanical quantity is understood as impelling motion, while the other is impeding it. The force and the mass are the prototypes of impelling and impeding factors, but many other duos are possible. This review provides a novel synthesis revealing the power of dimensional analysis, to understand processes governed by the interplay of two mechanical quantities. This elementary decomposition of space, time and motion into pairs of mechanical factors is the foundation of ``dimensional mechanics'', a method that this review wishes to promote and advance. The review is complemented by online video lectures, which initiate a discussion on the elaborate interplay of two or more mechanical quantities.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2024; v1 submitted 25 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Spreading, pinching, and coalescence: the Ohnesorge units
Authors:
Marc-Antoine Fardin,
Mathieu Hautefeuille,
Vivek Sharma
Abstract:
Understanding the kinematics and dynamics of spreading, pinching, and coalescence of drops is critically important for a diverse range of applications involving spraying, printing, coating, dispensing, emulsification, and atomization. Hence experimental studies visualize and characterize the increase in size over time for drops spreading over substrates, or liquid bridges between coalescing drops,…
▽ More
Understanding the kinematics and dynamics of spreading, pinching, and coalescence of drops is critically important for a diverse range of applications involving spraying, printing, coating, dispensing, emulsification, and atomization. Hence experimental studies visualize and characterize the increase in size over time for drops spreading over substrates, or liquid bridges between coalescing drops, or the decrease in the radius of pinching necks during drop formation. Even for Newtonian fluids, the interplay of inertial, viscous, and capillary stresses can lead to a number of scaling laws, with three limiting self-similar cases: visco-inertial (VI), visco-capillary (VC) and inertio-capillary (IC). Though experiments are presented as examples of the methods of dimensional analysis, the lack of precise values or estimates for pre-factors, transitions, and scaling exponents presents difficulties for quantitative analysis and material characterization. In this tutorial review, we reanalyze and summarize an elaborate set of landmark published experimental studies on a wide range of Newtonian fluids. We show that moving beyond VI, VC, and IC units in favor of intrinsic timescale and lengthscale determined by all three material properties (viscosity, surface tension and density), creates a complementary system that we call the Ohnesorge units. We find that in spite of large differences in topological features, timescales, and material properties, the analysis of spreading, pinching and coalescing drops in the Ohnesorge units results in a remarkable collapse of the experimental datasets, highlighting the shared and universal features displayed in such flows.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2022; v1 submitted 13 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Measurement of particle motion in optical tweezers embedded in a Sagnac interferometer
Authors:
Ivan Galinskiy,
Oscar Isaksson,
Israel Rebolledo Salgado,
Mathieu Hautefeuille,
Bernhard Mehlig,
Dag Hanstorp
Abstract:
We have constructed a counterpropagating optical tweezers setup embedded in a Sagnac interferometer in order to increase the sensitivity of position tracking for particles in the geometrical optics regime. Enhanced position determination using a Sagnac interferometer has previously been described theoretically by Taylor et al. [Journal of Optics 13, 044014 (2011)] for Rayleigh-regime particles tra…
▽ More
We have constructed a counterpropagating optical tweezers setup embedded in a Sagnac interferometer in order to increase the sensitivity of position tracking for particles in the geometrical optics regime. Enhanced position determination using a Sagnac interferometer has previously been described theoretically by Taylor et al. [Journal of Optics 13, 044014 (2011)] for Rayleigh-regime particles trapped in an antinode of a standing wave. We have extended their theory to a case of arbitrarily-sized particles trapped with orthogonally-polarized counterpropagating beams. The working distance of the setup was sufficiently long to optically induce particle oscillations orthogonally to the axis of the tweezers with an auxiliary laser beam. Using these oscillations as a reference, we have experimentally shown that Sagnac-enhanced back focal plane interferometry is capable of providing an improvement of more than 5 times in the signal-to-background ratio, corresponding to a more than 30-fold improvement of the signal-to-noise ratio. The experimental results obtained are consistent with our theoretical predictions. In the experimental setup, we used a method of optical levitator-assisted liquid droplet delivery in air based on commercial inkjet technology, with a novel method to precisely control the size of droplets.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2015; v1 submitted 19 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
