-
The life cycle of scientific principles -- a template for characterizing physical principles
Authors:
Radin Dardashti,
Enno Fischer,
Robert Harlander
Abstract:
Scientific principles can undergo various developments. While philosophers of science have acknowledged that such changes occur, there is no systematic account of the development of scientific principles. Here we propose a template for analyzing the development of scientific principles called the 'life cycle' of principles. It includes a series of processes that principles can go through: prehisto…
▽ More
Scientific principles can undergo various developments. While philosophers of science have acknowledged that such changes occur, there is no systematic account of the development of scientific principles. Here we propose a template for analyzing the development of scientific principles called the 'life cycle' of principles. It includes a series of processes that principles can go through: prehistory, elevation, formalization, generalization, and challenge. The life cycle, we argue, is a useful heuristic for the analysis of the development of scientific principles. We illustrate this by discussing examples from foundational physics including Lorentz invariance, Mach's principle, the naturalness principle, and the perfect cosmological principle. We also explore two applications of the template. First, we propose that the template can be employed to diagnose the quality of scientific principles. Second, we discuss the ramifications of the life cycle's processes for the empirical testability of principles.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
FeynGame-2.1 -- Feynman diagrams made easy
Authors:
Robert Harlander,
Sven Yannick Klein,
Magnus Schaaf
Abstract:
FeynGame is an open-source software tool to draw Feynman diagrams, but also to get acquainted with their structure. This article reports on a number of new features which have been added to FeynGame since its first release. These include full support of LaTeX for the line and vertex labels, the possibility to automatically include momentum arrows, new graphical elements, and new pedagogical featur…
▽ More
FeynGame is an open-source software tool to draw Feynman diagrams, but also to get acquainted with their structure. This article reports on a number of new features which have been added to FeynGame since its first release. These include full support of LaTeX for the line and vertex labels, the possibility to automatically include momentum arrows, new graphical elements, and new pedagogical features. FeynGame is freely available as jar or MacOS app file from https://web.physik.rwth-aachen.de/user/harlander/software/feyngame, and as source code from https://gitlab.com/feyngame/FeynGame.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
AutoEFT: Automated Operator Construction for Effective Field Theories
Authors:
Robert V. Harlander,
Magnus C. Schaaf
Abstract:
The program AutoEFT is described. It allows one to generate Effective Field Theories (EFTs) from a given set of fields and symmetries. Allowed fields include scalars, spinors, gauge bosons, and gravitons. The symmetries can be local or global Lie groups based on U(1) and SU(N). The mass dimension of the EFT is limited only by the available computing resources. The operators are stored in a compact…
▽ More
The program AutoEFT is described. It allows one to generate Effective Field Theories (EFTs) from a given set of fields and symmetries. Allowed fields include scalars, spinors, gauge bosons, and gravitons. The symmetries can be local or global Lie groups based on U(1) and SU(N). The mass dimension of the EFT is limited only by the available computing resources. The operators are stored in a compact, human and machine-readable format. Aside from the program itself, we provide input files for EFTs based on the Standard Model and a number of its extensions. These include additional particles and symmetries, EFTs with minimal flavor violation, and gravitons.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2024; v1 submitted 27 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
FeynGame
Authors:
R. V. Harlander,
S. Y. Klein,
M. Lipp
Abstract:
A java-based graphical tool for drawing Feynman diagrams is presented. It differs from similar existing tools in various respects. For example, it is based on models, consisting of particles (lines) and (optionally) vertices, each of which can be given their individual properties (line style, color, arrows, label, etc.). The diagrams can be exported in any standard image format, or as PDF. Aside f…
▽ More
A java-based graphical tool for drawing Feynman diagrams is presented. It differs from similar existing tools in various respects. For example, it is based on models, consisting of particles (lines) and (optionally) vertices, each of which can be given their individual properties (line style, color, arrows, label, etc.). The diagrams can be exported in any standard image format, or as PDF. Aside from its plain graphical aspect, the goal of FeynGame is also educative, as it can check a Feynman diagrams validity. This provides the basis to play games with diagrams, for example. Here we describe on such game where a given set of initial and final states must be connected through a Feynman diagram within a given interaction model.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Naturalness, Wilsonian Renormalization, and "Fundamental Parameters" in Quantum Field Theory
Authors:
Joshua Rosaler,
Robert Harlander
Abstract:
The Higgs naturalness principle served as the basis for the so far failed prediction that signatures of physics beyond the Standard Model (SM) would be discovered at the LHC. One influential formulation of the principle, which prohibits fine tuning of bare Standard Model (SM) parameters, rests on the assumption that a particular set of values for these parameters constitute the "fundamental parame…
▽ More
The Higgs naturalness principle served as the basis for the so far failed prediction that signatures of physics beyond the Standard Model (SM) would be discovered at the LHC. One influential formulation of the principle, which prohibits fine tuning of bare Standard Model (SM) parameters, rests on the assumption that a particular set of values for these parameters constitute the "fundamental parameters" of the theory, and serve to mathematically define the theory. On the other hand, an old argument by Wetterich suggests that fine tuning of bare parameters merely reflects an arbitrary, inconvenient choice of expansion parameters and that the choice of parameters in an EFT is therefore arbitrary. We argue that these two interpretations of Higgs fine tuning reflect distinct ways of formulating and interpreting effective field theories (EFTs) within the Wilsonian framework: the first takes an EFT to be defined by a single set of physical, fundamental bare parameters, while the second takes a Wilsonian EFT to be defined instead by a whole Wilsonian renormalization group (RG) trajectory, associated with a one-parameter class of physically equivalent parametrizations. From this latter perspective, no single parametrization constitutes the physically correct, fundamental parametrization of the theory, and the delicate cancellation between bare Higgs mass and quantum corrections appears as an eliminable artifact of the arbitrary, unphysical reference scale with respect to which the physical amplitudes of the theory are parametrized. While the notion of fundamental parameters is well motivated in the context of condensed matter field theory, we explain why it may be superfluous in the context of high energy physics.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2019; v1 submitted 25 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Philosophical perspectives on ad hoc hypotheses and the Higgs mechanism
Authors:
Simon Friederich,
Robert V. Harlander,
Koray Karaca
Abstract:
We examine physicists' charge of ad hocness against the Higgs mechanism in the standard model of elementary particle physics. We argue that even though this charge never rested on a clear-cut and well-entrenched definition of "ad hoc", it is based on conceptual and methodological assumptions and principles that are well-founded elements of the scientific practice of high-energy particle physics. W…
▽ More
We examine physicists' charge of ad hocness against the Higgs mechanism in the standard model of elementary particle physics. We argue that even though this charge never rested on a clear-cut and well-entrenched definition of "ad hoc", it is based on conceptual and methodological assumptions and principles that are well-founded elements of the scientific practice of high-energy particle physics. We further evaluate the implications of the recent discovery of a Higgs-like particle at the CERN's Large Hadron Collider for the charge of ad hocness against the Higgs mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2014; v1 submitted 22 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
