-
Transport Characteristics and Modelling of ST40 Hot Ion Plasmas
Authors:
MS Anastopoulos Tzanis,
MR Hardman,
Y Zhang,
X Zhang,
A Sladkomedova,
A Dnestrovskii,
YS Na,
JH Lee,
SJ Park,
TO Gorman,
H Lowe,
M Romanelli,
M Sertoli,
M Gemmel,
J Woods,
HV Willett,
ST40 Team
Abstract:
In this paper, the turbulent transport properties of ST40 hot ion plasmas are examined and fully predictive time evolving modelling of a hot ion plasma pulse was performed. Understanding turbulent transport on spherical tokamaks (STs) is challenging due to their unique geometry characteristics. ST40 hot ion plasmas are typically unstable to ion scale Trapped Electron Modes (TEMs) and Ubiquitous Mo…
▽ More
In this paper, the turbulent transport properties of ST40 hot ion plasmas are examined and fully predictive time evolving modelling of a hot ion plasma pulse was performed. Understanding turbulent transport on spherical tokamaks (STs) is challenging due to their unique geometry characteristics. ST40 hot ion plasmas are typically unstable to ion scale Trapped Electron Modes (TEMs) and Ubiquitous Modes (UMs), driven from the kinetic response of trapped particles and passing ions, and electron scale Electron Temperature Gradient Modes (ETGs) at the edge of the plasma. A comparison between the linear unstable modes of the gyro-kinetic code GS2 and the gyro-fluid code TGLF showed that both models agree to a satisfactory level. However, some discrepancy was observed at the core of the plasma where a large fraction of beams ions exists, and electromagnetic effects are potentially important. Turbulent fluxes were also observed to be somewhat overpredicted with TGLF. The core heat ion transport is observed to be close to neoclassical levels due to turbulence suppression from high rotation and fast ion stabilisation, while the edge region is dominated by anomalous transport in both ions and electrons. As a result, enhanced energy confinement is observed in those plasmas driven by the reduced turbulent core region and the confined beam ions. Fully predictive simulations using the ASTRA transport solver coupled with SPIDER, NUBEAM, NCLASS and TGLF together with a novel reduced scrape of layer (SOL) model for the simulation of the last closed flux surface (LCFS) boundary conditions was attempted. Agreement in global quantities but also kinetic profiles between the predictive and interpretative modelling as well as experimental measurements was observed.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
$E\times B$ shear suppression of microtearing based transport in spherical tokamaks
Authors:
B. S. Patel,
M. R. Hardman,
D. Kennedy,
M. Giacomin,
D. Dickinson,
C. M. Roach
Abstract:
Electromagnetic microtearing modes (MTMs) have been observed in many different spherical tokamak regimes. Understanding how these and other electromagnetic modes nonlinearly saturate is likely critical in understanding the confinement of a high $β$ spherical tokamak (ST). Equilibrium $E\times B$ sheared flows have sometimes been found to significantly suppress low $β$ ion scale transport in both g…
▽ More
Electromagnetic microtearing modes (MTMs) have been observed in many different spherical tokamak regimes. Understanding how these and other electromagnetic modes nonlinearly saturate is likely critical in understanding the confinement of a high $β$ spherical tokamak (ST). Equilibrium $E\times B$ sheared flows have sometimes been found to significantly suppress low $β$ ion scale transport in both gyrokinetic simulations and in experiment. This work aims to understand the conditions under which $E\times B$ sheared flow impacts on the saturation of MTM simulations. Two experimental regimes are examined from MAST and NSTX, on surfaces that have unstable MTMs. The MTM driven transport on a local flux surface in MAST is shown to be more resilient to suppression via $E\times B$ shear, compared to the case from NSTX where the MTM transport is found to be significantly suppressed. This difference in the response to flow shear is explained through the impact of magnetic shear, $\hat{s}$ on the MTM linear growth rate dependence on ballooning angle, $θ_0$. At low $\hat{s}$, the growth rate depends weakly on $θ_0$, but at higher $\hat{s}$, the MTM growth rate peaks at $θ_0 = 0$, with regions of stability at higher $θ_0$. Equilibrium $E\times B$ sheared flows act to advect the $θ_0$ of a mode in time, providing a mechanism which suppresses the transport from these modes when they become stable. The dependence of $γ^{MTM}$ on $θ_0$ is in qualitative agreement with a recent theory [M.R. Hardman et al (2023)] at low $β$ when $q\sim1$, but the agreement worsens at higher $q$ where the theory breaks down. This work highlights the important role of the safety factor profile in determining the impact of equilibrium $E\times B$ shear on the saturation level of MTM turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Measurement of zero-frequency fluctuations generated by coupling between Alfven modes in the JET tokamak
Authors:
Juan Ruiz Ruiz,
Jeronimo Garcia,
Michael Barnes,
Mykola Dreval,
Carine Giroud,
Valerian H. Hall-Chen,
Michael R. Hardman,
Jon C. Hillesheim,
Yevgen Kazakov,
Samuele Mazzi,
Felix I. Parra,
Bhavin S. Patel,
Alexander A. Schekochihin,
Ziga Stancar,
the JET Contributors,
the EUROfusion Tokamak Exploitation Team
Abstract:
We report the first experimental detection of a zero-frequency fluctuation that is pumped by an Alfvèn mode in a magnetically confined plasma. Core-localized bidirectional Alfvèn modes of frequency inside the toroidicity-induced gap (and its harmonics) exhibit three-wave coupling interactions with a zero-frequency fluctuation. The observation of the zero-frequency fluctuation is consistent with th…
▽ More
We report the first experimental detection of a zero-frequency fluctuation that is pumped by an Alfvèn mode in a magnetically confined plasma. Core-localized bidirectional Alfvèn modes of frequency inside the toroidicity-induced gap (and its harmonics) exhibit three-wave coupling interactions with a zero-frequency fluctuation. The observation of the zero-frequency fluctuation is consistent with theoretical and numerical predictions of zonal modes pumped by Alfvén modes, and is correlated with an increase in the deep core ion temperature, temperature gradient, and confinement factor $H_{89,P}$. Despite the energetic particle transport induced by the Alfvèn eigenmodes, the generation of a zero-frequency fluctuation that can suppress the turbulence leads to an overall improvement of confinement.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2025; v1 submitted 1 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Doubling Fusion Power with Volumetric Optimization in Magnetic Confinement Fusion Devices
Authors:
J. F. Parisi,
J. W. Berkery,
A. Sladkomedova,
S. Guizzo,
M. R. Hardman,
J. R. Ball,
A. O. Nelson,
S. M. Kaye,
M. Anastopoulos-Tzanis,
S. A. M. McNamara,
J. Dominski,
S. Janhunen,
M. Romanelli,
D. Dickinson,
A. Diallo,
A. Dnestrovskii,
W. Guttenfelder,
C. Hansen,
O. Myatra,
H. R. Wilson
Abstract:
A technique, volumetric power optimization, is presented for enhancing the power output of magnetic confinement fusion devices. Applied to a tokamak, this approach involves shifting the burning plasma region to a larger plasma volume while introducing minimal perturbations to the plasma boundary shape. This edge perturbation -- squareness -- is analogous to pinching and stretching the edge boundar…
▽ More
A technique, volumetric power optimization, is presented for enhancing the power output of magnetic confinement fusion devices. Applied to a tokamak, this approach involves shifting the burning plasma region to a larger plasma volume while introducing minimal perturbations to the plasma boundary shape. This edge perturbation -- squareness -- is analogous to pinching and stretching the edge boundary. Stability calculations confirm that this edge alteration is compatible with maintaining plasma stability. This optimization method for optimizing fusion power output could improve the performance of magnetic confinement fusion power plants.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2025; v1 submitted 5 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
New linear stability parameter to describe low-$β$ electromagnetic microinstabilities driven by passing electrons in axisymmetric toroidal geometry
Authors:
M. R. Hardman,
F. I. Parra,
B. S. Patel,
C. M. Roach,
J. Ruiz Ruiz,
M. Barnes,
D. Dickinson,
W. Dorland,
J. F. Parisi,
D. St-Onge,
H. Wilson
Abstract:
In magnetic confinement fusion devices, the ratio of the plasma pressure to the magnetic field energy, $β$, can become sufficiently large that electromagnetic microinstabilities become unstable, driving turbulence that distorts or reconnects the equilibrium magnetic field. In this paper, a theory is proposed for electromagnetic, electron-driven linear instabilities that have current layers localis…
▽ More
In magnetic confinement fusion devices, the ratio of the plasma pressure to the magnetic field energy, $β$, can become sufficiently large that electromagnetic microinstabilities become unstable, driving turbulence that distorts or reconnects the equilibrium magnetic field. In this paper, a theory is proposed for electromagnetic, electron-driven linear instabilities that have current layers localised to mode-rational surfaces and binormal wavelengths comparable to the ion gyroradius. The model retains axisymmetric toroidal geometry with arbitrary shaping, and consists of orbit-averaged equations for the mode-rational surface layer, with a ballooning space kinetic matching condition for passing electrons. The matching condition connects the current layer to the large scale electromagnetic fluctuations, and is derived in the limit that $β$ is comparable to the square root of the electron-to-ion-mass ratio. Electromagnetic fluctuations only enter through the matching condition, allowing for the identification of an effective $β$ that includes the effects of equilibrium flux surface shaping. The scaling predictions made by the asymptotic theory are tested with comparisons to results from linear simulations of micro-tearing and electrostatic microinstabilities in MAST discharge #6252, showing excellent agreement. In particular, it is demonstrated that the effective $β$ can explain the dependence of the local micro-tearing mode (MTM) growth rate on the ballooning parameter $θ_0$ -- possibly providing a route to optimise local flux surfaces for reduced MTM-driven transport.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2023; v1 submitted 22 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Three-Dimensional Inhomogeneity of Electron-Temperature-Gradient Turbulence in the Edge of Tokamak Plasmas
Authors:
J. F. Parisi,
F. I. Parra,
C. M. Roach,
M. R. Hardman,
A. A. Schekochihin,
I. G. Abel,
N. Aiba,
J. Ball,
M. Barnes,
B. Chapman-Oplopoiou,
D. Dickinson,
W. Dorland,
C. Giroud,
D. R. Hatch,
J. C. Hillesheim,
J. Ruiz Ruiz,
S. Saarelma,
D. St-Onge
Abstract:
Nonlinear multiscale gyrokinetic simulations of a Joint European Torus edge pedestal are used to show that electron-temperature-gradient (ETG) turbulence has a rich three-dimensional structure, varying strongly according to the local magnetic-field configuration. In the plane normal to the magnetic field, the steep pedestal electron temperature gradient gives rise to anisotropic turbulence with a…
▽ More
Nonlinear multiscale gyrokinetic simulations of a Joint European Torus edge pedestal are used to show that electron-temperature-gradient (ETG) turbulence has a rich three-dimensional structure, varying strongly according to the local magnetic-field configuration. In the plane normal to the magnetic field, the steep pedestal electron temperature gradient gives rise to anisotropic turbulence with a radial (normal) wavelength much shorter than in the binormal direction. In the parallel direction, the location and parallel extent of the turbulence are determined by the variation in the magnetic drifts and finite-Larmor-radius (FLR) effects. The magnetic drift and FLR topographies have a perpendicular-wavelength dependence, which permits turbulence intensity maxima near the flux-surface top and bottom at longer binormal scales, but constrains turbulence to the outboard midplane at shorter electron-gyroradius binormal scales. Our simulations show that long-wavelength ETG turbulence does not transport heat efficiently, and significantly decreases overall ETG transport -- in our case by $\sim$40 \% -- through multiscale interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2022; v1 submitted 1 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Bistable turbulence in strongly magnetised plasmas with a sheared mean flow
Authors:
Nicolas Christen,
Michael Barnes,
Michael R. Hardman,
Alexander A. Schekochihin
Abstract:
The prevailing paradigm for plasma turbulence associates a unique stationary state to given equilibrium parameters. We report the discovery of bistable turbulence in a strongly magnetised plasma. Two distinct states, obtained with identical equilibrium parameters in first-principle gyrokinetic simulations, have turbulent fluxes of particles, momentum and energy that differ by an order of magnitude…
▽ More
The prevailing paradigm for plasma turbulence associates a unique stationary state to given equilibrium parameters. We report the discovery of bistable turbulence in a strongly magnetised plasma. Two distinct states, obtained with identical equilibrium parameters in first-principle gyrokinetic simulations, have turbulent fluxes of particles, momentum and energy that differ by an order of magnitude, with the low-transport state agreeing with experimental observations. Occurrences of the two states are regulated by the competition between an externally imposed mean flow shear and "zonal" flows generated by the plasma. With small turbulent amplitudes, zonal flows have little impact, and the mean shear causes turbulence to saturate in a low-transport state. With larger amplitudes, the zonal shear can (partially) oppose the effect of the mean shear, allowing the system to sustain a high-transport state. This poses a new challenge for research that has so far assumed a uniquely defined turbulent state.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2022; v1 submitted 16 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Extended electron tails in electrostatic microinstabilities and the nonadiabatic response of passing electrons
Authors:
M. R. Hardman,
F. I. Parra,
C. Chong,
T. Adkins,
M. S. Anastopoulos-Tzanis,
M. Barnes,
D. Dickinson,
J. F. Parisi,
H. Wilson
Abstract:
Ion-gyroradius-scale microinstabilities typically have a frequency comparable to the ion transit frequency. Due to the small electron-to-ion mass ratio and the large electron transit frequency, it is conventionally assumed that passing electrons respond adiabatically in ion-gyroradius-scale modes. However, in gyrokinetic simulations of ion-gyroradius-scale modes in axisymmetric toroidal magnetic f…
▽ More
Ion-gyroradius-scale microinstabilities typically have a frequency comparable to the ion transit frequency. Due to the small electron-to-ion mass ratio and the large electron transit frequency, it is conventionally assumed that passing electrons respond adiabatically in ion-gyroradius-scale modes. However, in gyrokinetic simulations of ion-gyroradius-scale modes in axisymmetric toroidal magnetic fields, the nonadiabatic response of passing electrons can drive the mode, and generate fluctuations with narrow radial layers, which may have consequences for turbulent transport in a variety of circumstances. In flux tube simulations, in the ballooning representation, these instabilities reveal themselves as modes with extended tails. The small electron-to-ion mass ratio limit of linear gyrokinetics for electrostatic instabilities is presented, in axisymmetric toroidal magnetic geometry, including the nonadiabatic response of passing electrons and associated narrow radial layers. This theory reveals the existence of ion-gyroradius-scale modes driven solely by the nonadiabatic passing electron response, and recovers the usual ion-gyroradius-scale modes driven by the response of ions and trapped electrons, where the nonadiabatic response of passing electrons is small. The collisionless and collisional limits of the theory are considered, demonstrating parallels in structure and physical processes to neoclassical transport theory. By examining initial-value simulations of fastest-growing eigenmodes, the predictions for mass-ratio scaling are tested and verified numerically for a range of collision frequencies. Insights from the small electron-to-ion mass ratio theory may lead to a computationally efficient treatment of extended modes.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2022; v1 submitted 5 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Stabilisation of short-wavelength instabilities by parallel-to-the-field shear in long-wavelength $\mathbf{E} \times \mathbf{B}$ flows
Authors:
M. R. Hardman,
M. Barnes,
C. M. Roach
Abstract:
Magnetised plasma turbulence can have a multiscale character: instabilities driven by mean temperature gradients drive turbulence at the disparate scales of the ion and the electron gyroradii. Simulations of multiscale turbulence, using equations valid in the limit of infinite scale separation, reveal novel cross-scale interaction mechanisms in these plasmas. In the case that both long-wavelength…
▽ More
Magnetised plasma turbulence can have a multiscale character: instabilities driven by mean temperature gradients drive turbulence at the disparate scales of the ion and the electron gyroradii. Simulations of multiscale turbulence, using equations valid in the limit of infinite scale separation, reveal novel cross-scale interaction mechanisms in these plasmas. In the case that both long-wavelength (ion-gyroradius-scale) and short-wavelength (electron-gyroradius-scale) linear instabilities are driven far from marginal stability, we show that the short-wavelength instabilities are suppressed by interactions with long-wavelength turbulence. The observed suppression is a result of two effects: parallel-to-the-field-line shearing by the long wavelength $\mathbf{E} \times \mathbf{B}$ flows, and the modification of the background density gradient by long-wavelength fluctuations. In contrast, simulations of multiscale turbulence where instabilities at both scales are driven near marginal stability demonstrate that when the long-wavelength turbulence is sufficiently collisional and zonally dominated the effect of cross-scale interaction can be parameterised solely in terms of the local modifications to the mean density and temperature gradients. We discuss physical arguments that qualitatively explain how a change in equilibrium drive leads to the observed transition in the impact of the cross-scale interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2020; v1 submitted 12 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
A Scale-Separated Approach for Studying Coupled Ion and Electron Scale Turbulence
Authors:
M. R. Hardman,
M. Barnes,
C. M. Roach,
F. I. Parra
Abstract:
Multiple space and time scales arise in plasma turbulence in magnetic confinement fusion devices because of the smallness of the square root of the electron-to-ion mass ratio $(m_e/m_i)^{1/2}$ and the consequent disparity of the ion and electron thermal gyroradii and thermal speeds. Direct simulations of this turbulence that include both ion and electron space-time scales indicate that there can b…
▽ More
Multiple space and time scales arise in plasma turbulence in magnetic confinement fusion devices because of the smallness of the square root of the electron-to-ion mass ratio $(m_e/m_i)^{1/2}$ and the consequent disparity of the ion and electron thermal gyroradii and thermal speeds. Direct simulations of this turbulence that include both ion and electron space-time scales indicate that there can be significant interactions between the two scales. The extreme computational expense and complexity of these direct simulations motivates the desire for reduced treatment. By exploiting the scale separation between ion and electron scales,and expanding the gyrokinetic equations for the turbulence in $(m_e/m_i)^{1/2}$, we derive such a reduced system of gyrokinetic equations that describes cross-scale interactions. The coupled gyrokinetic equations contain novel terms which provide candidate mechanisms for the observed cross-scale interaction. The electron scale turbulence experiences a modified drive due to gradients in the ion scale distribution function, and is advected by the ion scale $E \times B$ drift, which varies in the direction parallel to the magnetic field line. The largest possible cross-scale term in the ion scale equations is sub-dominant in our $(m_e/m_i)^{1/2}$ expansion. Hence, in our model the ion scale turbulence evolves independently of the electron scale turbulence. To complete the scale-separated approach, we provide and justify a parallel boundary condition for the coupled gyrokinetic equations in axisymmetric equilibria based on the standard "twist-and-shift" boundary condition. This approach allows one to simulate multi-scale turbulence using electron scale flux tubes nested within an ion scale flux tube.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
