-
Modeling the debonding process of osseointegrated implants due to coupled adhesion and friction
Authors:
Katharina Immel,
Vu-Hieu Nguyen,
Guillaume Haiat,
Roger A. Sauer
Abstract:
Cementless implants have become widely used for total hip replacement surgery. The long-term stability of these implants is achieved by bone growing around and into the porous surface of the implant, a process called osseointegration. However, debonding of the bone-implant interface can still occur due to aseptic implant loosening and insufficient osseointegration, which may have dramatic conseque…
▽ More
Cementless implants have become widely used for total hip replacement surgery. The long-term stability of these implants is achieved by bone growing around and into the porous surface of the implant, a process called osseointegration. However, debonding of the bone-implant interface can still occur due to aseptic implant loosening and insufficient osseointegration, which may have dramatic consequences. The aim of this work is to describe a new 3D finite element frictional contact formulation for the debonding of partially osseointegrated implants. The contact model is based on a modified Coulomb's friction law (Immel et al. 2020, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol.) that takes into account the tangential debonding of the bone-implant interface. This model is extended in the direction normal to the bone-implant interface by considering a cohesive zone model, to account for adhesion phenomena in the normal direction and for adhesive friction of partially bonded interfaces. The model is applied to simulate the debonding of an acetabular cup implant. The influence of partial osseointegration and adhesive effects on the long-term stability of the implant is assessed. The influence of different patient- and implant-specific parameters such as the friction coefficient, the trabecular Young's modulus and the interference fit is also analyzed, in order to determine the optimal stability for different configurations. Furthermore, this work provides guidelines for future experimental and computational studies, that are necessary for further parameter calibration.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2022; v1 submitted 13 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Using an Impact Hammer to Perform Biomechanical Measurements during Osteotomies: Study of an Animal Model
Authors:
Léo Lamassoure,
Justine Giunta,
Giuseppe Rosi,
Anne-Sophie Poudrel,
Romain Bosc,
Guillaume Haïat,
Henri Mondor
Abstract:
Osteotomies are common surgical procedures used for instance in rhinoplasty and usually performed using an osteotome impacted by a mallet. Visual control being difficult, osteotomies are often based on the surgeon proprioception to determine the number and energy of each impact. The aim of this study is to determine whether a hammer instrumented with a piezoelectric force sensor can be used to i)…
▽ More
Osteotomies are common surgical procedures used for instance in rhinoplasty and usually performed using an osteotome impacted by a mallet. Visual control being difficult, osteotomies are often based on the surgeon proprioception to determine the number and energy of each impact. The aim of this study is to determine whether a hammer instrumented with a piezoelectric force sensor can be used to i) follow the displacement of the osteotome and ii) determine when the tip of the osteotome arrives in frontal bone, which corresponds to the end of the osteotomy pathway. Seven New Zealand White rabbit heads were collected, and two osteotomies were performed on their left and right nasal bones using the instrumented hammer to record the variation of the force as a function of time during each impact. The second peak time $τ$ was derived from each signal while the displacement of the osteotome tip D was determined using video motion tracking. The results showed a significant correlation between $τ$ and D ($ρ$${}^2$ = 0,74), allowing to estimate the displacement of the osteotome through the measurement of $τ$. The values of $τ$ measured in the frontal bone were significantly lower than in the nasal bone (p < 10-10), which allows to determine the transition between the nasal and frontal boneswhen $τ$ becomes lower than 0.78 its initial averaged value. Although results should be validated clinically, this technology could be used by surgeons in the future as a decision support system to help assessing the osteotome environment.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Stress shielding at the bone-implant interface: influence of surface roughness and of the bone-implant contact ratio
Authors:
Maria Letizia Raffa,
Vu-Hieu Nguyen,
Philippe Hernigou,
Charles-Henri Flouzat- Lachaniette,
Guillaume Haiat
Abstract:
Short and long-term stabilities of cementless implants are strongly determined by the interfacial load transfer between implants and bone tissue. Stress-shielding effects arise from shear stresses due to the difference of material properties between bone and the implant. It remains difficult to measure the stress field in periprosthetic bone tissue. This study proposes to investigate the dependenc…
▽ More
Short and long-term stabilities of cementless implants are strongly determined by the interfacial load transfer between implants and bone tissue. Stress-shielding effects arise from shear stresses due to the difference of material properties between bone and the implant. It remains difficult to measure the stress field in periprosthetic bone tissue. This study proposes to investigate the dependence of the stress field in periprosthetic bone tissue on i) the implant surface roughness, ii) material properties of bone and of the implant, iii) the bone-implant contact ratio. To do so, a microscale 2-D finite element model of an osseointegrated boneimplant interface was developed where the surface roughness was modeled by a sinusoidal surface. The results show that the isostatic pressure is not affected by the presence of the bone-implant interface while shear stresses arise due to the combined effects of a geometrical singularity (for low surface roughness) and of shear stresses at the bone-implant interface (for high surface roughness). Stress-shielding effects are likely to be more important when the bone-implant contact ratio value is low, which corresponds to a case of relatively low implant stability. Shear stress reach a maximum value at a distance from the interface comprised between 0 and 0.1 time roughness wavelength $λ$ and tend to 0 at a distance from the implant surface higher than $λ$, independently from bone-implant contact ratio and waviness ratio. A comparison with an analytical model allows validating the numerical results. Future work should use the present approach to model osseointegration phenomena.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Ex vivo estimation of cementless femoral stem stability using an instrumented hammer
Authors:
Hugues Albini Lomami,
Camille Damour,
Giuseppe Rosi,
Anne-Sophie Poudrel,
Arnaud Dubory,
Charles-Henri Flouzat-Lachaniette,
Guillaume Haiat
Abstract:
Background 15 The success of cementless hip arthroplasty depends on the primary stability of the femoral stem. It remains difficult to assess the optimal number of impacts to guarantee the femoral stem stability while avoiding bone fracture. The aim of this study is to validate a method using a hammer instrumented with a force sensor to monitor the insertion of femoral stem in bovine femoral sampl…
▽ More
Background 15 The success of cementless hip arthroplasty depends on the primary stability of the femoral stem. It remains difficult to assess the optimal number of impacts to guarantee the femoral stem stability while avoiding bone fracture. The aim of this study is to validate a method using a hammer instrumented with a force sensor to monitor the insertion of femoral stem in bovine femoral samples. Methods 20 Different cementless femoral stem were impacted into five bovine femur samples, leading to 99 configurations. Three methods were used to quantify the insertion endpoint: the impact hammer, video motion tracking and the surgeon proprioception. For each configuration, the number of impacts performed by the surgeon until he felt a correct insertion was noted Nsurg. The insertion depth E was measured through video motion tracking, and the impact number Nvid corresponding to the end of the insertion was estimated. Two indicators, noted I and D, 25 were determined from the analysis of the time variation of the force, and the impact number Nd corresponding to a threshold reached in D variation was estimated. Findings The pullout force of the femoral stem was significantly correlated with I (R${}^2$=0.81). The values of Nsurg, Nvid and Nd were similar for all configurations. 30 Interpretation The results validate the use of the impact hammer to assess the primary stability of the femoral stem and the moment when the surgeon should stop the impaction procedure for an optimal insertion, which could lead to the development of a decision support system. Abstract: 248 words. Main text: 4658 words
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
A modified Coulomb's law for the tangential debonding of osseointegrated implants
Authors:
Katharina Immel,
Thang X. Duong,
Vu-Hieu Nguyen,
Guillaume Haiat,
Roger A. Sauer
Abstract:
Cementless implants are widely used in orthopedic and oral surgery. However, debonding-related failure still occurs at the bone-implant interface. It remains difficult to predict such implant failure since the underlying osseointegration phenomena are still poorly understood. Especially in terms of friction and adhesion at the macro-scale, there is a lack of data and reliable models. The aim of th…
▽ More
Cementless implants are widely used in orthopedic and oral surgery. However, debonding-related failure still occurs at the bone-implant interface. It remains difficult to predict such implant failure since the underlying osseointegration phenomena are still poorly understood. Especially in terms of friction and adhesion at the macro-scale, there is a lack of data and reliable models. The aim of this work is to present a new friction formulation that can model the tangential contact behavior between osseointegrated implants and bone tissue, with focus on debonding. The classical Coulomb's law is combined with a state variable friction law to model a displacement-dependent friction coefficient. A smooth state function, based on the sliding distance, is used to model implant debonding. The formulation is implemented in a 3D nonlinear finite element framework, and it is calibrated with experimental data and compared to an analytical model for mode III cleavage of a coin-shaped, titanium implant (Mathieu et al. 2012). Overall, the results show close agreement with the experimental data, especially the peak and the softening part of the torque curve with a relative error of less than 2.25 %. In addition, better estimates of the bone's shear modulus and the adhesion energy are obtained. The proposed model is particularly suitable to account for partial osseointegration, as is also shown.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2020; v1 submitted 12 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Evaluation of dental implant stability in bone phantoms: comparison between a quantitative ultrasound technique and resonance frequency analysis
Authors:
Romain Vayron,
Vu Hieu Nguyen,
Benoît Lecuelle,
Guillaume Haiat
Abstract:
Background Resonance frequency analyses and quantitative ultrasound methods have been suggested to assess dental implant primary stability. PurposeThe purpose of this study was to compare the results obtained using these two techniques applied to the same dental implants inserted in various bone phantoms. Materials and MethodsDifferent values of trabecular bone density and cortical thickness were…
▽ More
Background Resonance frequency analyses and quantitative ultrasound methods have been suggested to assess dental implant primary stability. PurposeThe purpose of this study was to compare the results obtained using these two techniques applied to the same dental implants inserted in various bone phantoms. Materials and MethodsDifferent values of trabecular bone density and cortical thickness were considered to assess the effect of bone quality on the respective indicators (UI and ISQ). The effect of the implant insertion depth and of the final drill diameter was also investigated. ResultsISQ values increase and UI values decrease as a function of trabecular density, cortical thickness and the screwing of the implant. When the implant diameter varies, the UI values are significantly different for all final drill diameters (except for two), while the ISQ values are similar for all final drill diameters lower than 3.2 mm and higher than 3.3 mm. The error on the estimation of parameters with the QUS device is between 4 and 8 times lower compared to that made with the RFA technique.ConclusionsThe results show that ultrasound technique provides a better estimation of different parameters related to the implant stability compared to the RFA technique.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Monitoring cementless femoral stem insertion by impact
Authors:
Antoine Tijou,
Giuseppe Rosi,
Romain Vayron,
Hugues Lomami,
Philippe Hernigou,
Charles-Henri Flouzat-Lachaniette,
Guillaume Haiat
Abstract:
The primary stability of the femoral stem (FS) implant determines the surgical success of cementless 15 hip arthroplasty. During the insertion, a compromise must be found for the number and energy of 16 impacts that should be sufficiently large to obtain an adapted primary stability of the FS and not too high 17 to decrease fracture risk. The aim of this study is to determine whether a hammer inst…
▽ More
The primary stability of the femoral stem (FS) implant determines the surgical success of cementless 15 hip arthroplasty. During the insertion, a compromise must be found for the number and energy of 16 impacts that should be sufficiently large to obtain an adapted primary stability of the FS and not too high 17 to decrease fracture risk. The aim of this study is to determine whether a hammer instrumented with a 18 force sensor can be used to monitor the insertion of FS. 19 Cementless FS of different sizes were impacted in four artificial femurs with an instrumented hammer, 20 leading to 72 configurations. The impact number when the surgeon empirically felt that the FS was fully 21 inserted was noted Nsurg. The insertion depth E was assessed using video motion tracking and the impact 22 number Nvid corresponding to the end of the insertion was estimated. For each impact, two indicators 23 noted I and D were determined based on the analysis of the variation of the force as a function of time. 24 The pull-out force F was significantly correlated with the indicator I (R${}^2$ =0.67). The variation of D was 25 analyzed using a threshold to determine an impact number Nd, which is shown to be closely related to 26 Nsurg and Nvid, with an average difference of around 0.2. This approach allows to determine i) the moment 27 when the surgeon should stop the impaction procedure in order to obtain an optimal insertion of the FS 28 and ii) the FS implant primary stability. This study paves the way towards the development of a decision 29 support system to assist the surgeon in hip arthroplasty.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Reflection of an ultrasonic wave on the bone-implant interface: effect of the roughness parameters
Authors:
Yoann Hériveaux,
Vu-Hieu Nguyen,
Vladimir Brailovski,
Cyril Gorny,
Guillaume Haiat
Abstract:
Quantitative ultrasound can be used to characterize the evolution of the bone-implant interface (BII), which is a complex system due to the implant surface roughness and to partial contact between bone and the implant. The aim of this study is to derive the main determinants of the ultrasonic response of the BII during osseointegration phenomena. The influence of i) the 25 surface roughness parame…
▽ More
Quantitative ultrasound can be used to characterize the evolution of the bone-implant interface (BII), which is a complex system due to the implant surface roughness and to partial contact between bone and the implant. The aim of this study is to derive the main determinants of the ultrasonic response of the BII during osseointegration phenomena. The influence of i) the 25 surface roughness parameters and ii) the thickness W of a soft tissue layer on the reflection coefficient r of the BII was investigated using a two-dimensional finite element model. When W increases from 0 to 150 $μ$m, r increases from values in the range [0.45; 0.55] to values in the range [0.75; 0.88] according to the roughness parameters. An optimization method was developed to determine the sinusoidal roughness profile leading to the most similar ultrasonic 30 response for all values of W compared to the original profile. The results show that the difference between the ultrasonic responses of the optimal sinusoidal profile and of the original profile was lower to typical experimental errors. This approach provides a better understanding of the ultrasonic response of the BII, which may be used in future numerical simulation realized at the scale of an implant.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Resonant frequency analysis of dental implants
Authors:
D Rittel,
A Dorogoy,
G. Haiat,
K Shemtov-Yona
Abstract:
Dental implant stability influences the decision on the determination of the duration between implant insertion and loading, This work investigates the resonant frequency analysis by means of a numerical model. The investigation is done numerically through the determination of the eigenfrequencies and performing a steady state response analyses using a commercial finite element package. A peri-imp…
▽ More
Dental implant stability influences the decision on the determination of the duration between implant insertion and loading, This work investigates the resonant frequency analysis by means of a numerical model. The investigation is done numerically through the determination of the eigenfrequencies and performing a steady state response analyses using a commercial finite element package. A peri-implant interface, of simultaneously varying stiffness (density) and layer thickness is introduced in the numerical 3D model in order to probe the sensitivity of the eigenfrequencies and steady state response to an evolving weakened layer, in an attempt to identify the bone reconstruction around the implant. For the first two modes, the resonant frequency is somewhat insensitive to the healing process, unless the weakened layer is rather large and compliant, like in the very early stages of the implantation. A "Normalized Healing Factor" is devised in the spirit of the Implant Stability Quotient, which can identify the healing process especially at the early stages after implantation. The sensitivity of the RFA to changes of mechanical properties of periprosthetic bone tissue seems relatively weak. Another indicator considering the amplitude as well as the resonance frequency might be more adapted to bone healing estimations. However, these results need to be verified experimentally as well as clinically.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Three-dimensional Simulation of Quantitative Ultrasound in Cancellous Bone using the Echographic Response of a Metallic Pin
Authors:
Yoshiki Nagatani,
Séraphin Guipieri,
Vu-Hieu Nguyen,
Christine Chappard,
Didier Geiger,
Salah Naili,
Guillaume Haïat
Abstract:
Degenerative discopathy is a common pathology which may require spine surgery. A metallic cylindrical pin is inserted into the vertebral body to maintain soft tissues and may be used as a reflector of ultrasonic wave to estimate bone density. The first aim of this paper is to validate a 3D model to simulate the ultrasonic propagation in a trabecular bone sample in which a metallic pin has been ins…
▽ More
Degenerative discopathy is a common pathology which may require spine surgery. A metallic cylindrical pin is inserted into the vertebral body to maintain soft tissues and may be used as a reflector of ultrasonic wave to estimate bone density. The first aim of this paper is to validate a 3D model to simulate the ultrasonic propagation in a trabecular bone sample in which a metallic pin has been inserted. We also aim at determining the effect of changes of bone volume fraction (BV/TV) and of positioning errors on the quantitative ultrasound (QUS) parameters in this specific configuration. The approach consists in coupling finite difference time domain simulation with X-ray microcomputed tomography. The correlation coefficient between experimental and simulated speed of sound (SOS) (respectively broadband ultrasonic attenuation (BUA)) was equal to 0.90 (respectively 0.55). The results show a significant correlation of SOS with BV/TV (R = 0.82), while BUA values exhibit a non-linear behavior versus BV/TV. The orientation of the pin should be controlled with an accuracy of around 1{\textdegree} in order to obtain accurate results. The results indicate that using the ultrasonic wave reflected by a pin has a potential to estimate the bone density. SOS is more reliable than BUA due its lower sensitivity to the tilt angle.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Mimetization of the elastic properties of cancellous bone via a parameterized cellular material
Authors:
Lucas Colabella,
Adrián Cisilino,
Guillaume Haiat,
Piotr Kowalczyk
Abstract:
Bone tissue mechanical properties and trabecular microarchitecture are the main factors that determine the biomechanical properties of cancellous bone. Artificial cancellous microstructures, typically described by a reduced number of geometrical parameters, can be designed to obtain a mechanical behavior mimicking that of natural bone. In this work, we assess the ability of the parameterized micro…
▽ More
Bone tissue mechanical properties and trabecular microarchitecture are the main factors that determine the biomechanical properties of cancellous bone. Artificial cancellous microstructures, typically described by a reduced number of geometrical parameters, can be designed to obtain a mechanical behavior mimicking that of natural bone. In this work, we assess the ability of the parameterized microstructure introduced by Kowalczyk (2006) to mimic the elastic response of cancellous bone. Artificial microstructures are compared with actual bone samples in terms of elasticity matrices and their symmetry classes. The capability of the parameterized microstructure to combine the dominant isotropic, hexagonal, tetragonal and orthorhombic symmetry classes in the proportions present in the cancellous bone is shown. Based on this finding, two optimization approaches are devised to find the geometrical parameters of the artificial microstructure that better mimics the elastic response of a target natural bone specimen: a Sequential Quadratic Programming algorithm that minimizes the norm of the difference between the elasticity matrices, and a Pattern Search algorithm that minimizes the difference between the symmetry class decompositions. The pattern search approach is found to produce the best results. The performance of the method is demonstrated via analyses for 146 bone samples.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
