-
Stabilisation of falling liquid films with restricted observations
Authors:
Oscar A. Holroyd,
Radu Cimpeanu,
Susana N. Gomes
Abstract:
We propose a method to stabilise a solution to equations describing the interface of thin liquid films falling under gravity with a finite number of actuators and restricted observations. As for many complex systems, full observation of the system state is challenging in physical settings, so methods able to take this into account are important. The Navier-Stokes equations modelling the flow are a…
▽ More
We propose a method to stabilise a solution to equations describing the interface of thin liquid films falling under gravity with a finite number of actuators and restricted observations. As for many complex systems, full observation of the system state is challenging in physical settings, so methods able to take this into account are important. The Navier-Stokes equations modelling the flow are a complex, highly nonlinear set of PDEs, so standard control theoretical results are not applicable. Instead, we chain together a hierarchy of increasingly idealised approximations, developing a control strategy for the simplified model which is shown to be successfully applied to simulations of the full system.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Steering opinion dynamics through control of social networks
Authors:
Andrew Nugent,
Susana N. Gomes,
Marie-Therese Wolfram
Abstract:
In this paper we propose a novel control approach for opinion dynamics on evolving networks. The controls modify the strength of connections in the network, rather than influencing opinions directly, with the overall goal of steering the population towards a target opinion. This requires that the social network remains sufficiently connected, the population does not break into separate opinion clu…
▽ More
In this paper we propose a novel control approach for opinion dynamics on evolving networks. The controls modify the strength of connections in the network, rather than influencing opinions directly, with the overall goal of steering the population towards a target opinion. This requires that the social network remains sufficiently connected, the population does not break into separate opinion clusters, and that the target opinion remains accessible. We present several approaches to addressing these challenges, considering questions of controllability, instantaneous control and optimal control. Each of these approaches provides a different view on the complex relationship between opinion and network dynamics and raises interesting questions for future research.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
On evolving network models and their influence on opinion formation
Authors:
Andrew J. Nugent,
Susana N. Gomes,
Marie-Therese Wolfram
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a new model for continuous time opinion dynamics on an evolving network. As opposed to existing models, in which the network typically evolves by discretely adding or removing edges, we instead propose a model for opinion formation which is coupled to a network evolving through a system of ordinary differential equations for the edge weights. We interpret each edge weight…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a new model for continuous time opinion dynamics on an evolving network. As opposed to existing models, in which the network typically evolves by discretely adding or removing edges, we instead propose a model for opinion formation which is coupled to a network evolving through a system of ordinary differential equations for the edge weights. We interpret each edge weight as the strength of the relationship between a pair of individuals, with edges increasing in weight if pairs continually listen to each others' opinions and decreasing if not. We investigate the impact of various edge dynamics at different timescales on the opinion dynamic itself. This is done partly through analytic results and partly through extensive numerical simulations of two case studies: one using bounded confidence interaction dynamics in the opinion formation process (as in the classical Hegselmann-Krause model) and one using an exponentially decaying interaction function. We find that the dynamic edge weights can have a significant impact on the opinion formation process, since they may result in consensus formation but can also reinforce polarisation. Overall, the proposed modelling approach allows us to quantify and investigate how the network and opinion dynamics influence each other.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Linear quadratic regulation control for falling liquid films
Authors:
Oscar A. Holroyd,
Radu Cimpeanu,
Susana N. Gomes
Abstract:
We propose and analyse a new methodology based on linear-quadratic regulation (LQR) for stabilising falling liquid films via blowing and suction at the base. LQR methods enable rapidly responding feedback control by precomputing a gain matrix, but are only suitable for systems of linear ordinary differential equations (ODEs). By contrast, the Navier-Stokes equations that describe the dynamics of a…
▽ More
We propose and analyse a new methodology based on linear-quadratic regulation (LQR) for stabilising falling liquid films via blowing and suction at the base. LQR methods enable rapidly responding feedback control by precomputing a gain matrix, but are only suitable for systems of linear ordinary differential equations (ODEs). By contrast, the Navier-Stokes equations that describe the dynamics of a thin liquid film flowing down an inclined plane are too complex to stabilise with standard control-theoretical techniques. To bridge this gap we use reduced-order models - the Benney equation and a weighted-residual integral boundary layer model - obtained via asymptotic analysis to derive a multi-level control framework. This framework consists of an LQR feedback control designed for a linearised and discretised system of ODEs approximating the reduced-order system, which is then applied to the full Navier-Stokes system. The control scheme is tested via direct numerical simulation (DNS), and compared to analytical predictions of linear stability thresholds and minimum required actuator numbers. Comparing the strategy between the two reduced-order models we show that in both cases we can successfully stabilise towards a uniform flat film across their respective ranges of valid parameters, with the more accurate weighted-residual model outperforming the Benney-derived controls. The weighted-residual controls are also found to work successfully far beyond their anticipated range of applicability. The proposed methodology increases the feasibility of transferring robust control techniques towards real-world systems, and is also generalisable to other forms of actuation.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2023; v1 submitted 26 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Electrostatic control of the Navier-Stokes equations for thin films
Authors:
Alexander W. Wray,
Radu Cimpeanu,
Susana N. Gomes
Abstract:
A robust control scheme is derived and tested for the Navier-Stokes equations for two-dimensional multiphase flow of a thin film underneath an inclined solid surface. Control is exerted via the use of an electrode parallel to the substrate, which induces an electric field in the gas phase, and a resultant Maxwell stress at the liquid-gas interface. The imposed potential at the second electrode is…
▽ More
A robust control scheme is derived and tested for the Navier-Stokes equations for two-dimensional multiphase flow of a thin film underneath an inclined solid surface. Control is exerted via the use of an electrode parallel to the substrate, which induces an electric field in the gas phase, and a resultant Maxwell stress at the liquid-gas interface. The imposed potential at the second electrode is derived using a model predictive control loop, together with optimal control of a high-fidelity reduced-dimensional model. In this implementation the interfacial shape of the fluid is successfully controlled; however, the algorithm is sufficiently general to control any other quantity of interest.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2022; v1 submitted 25 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Active control of liquid film flows: beyond reduced-order models
Authors:
Radu Cimpeanu,
Susana N. Gomes,
Demetrios T. Papageorgiou
Abstract:
The ability to robustly and efficiently control the dynamics of nonlinear systems lies at the heart of many current technological challenges, ranging from drug delivery systems to ensuring flight safety. Most such scenarios are too complex to tackle directly and reduced-order modelling is used in order to create viable representations of the target systems. The simplified setting allows for the de…
▽ More
The ability to robustly and efficiently control the dynamics of nonlinear systems lies at the heart of many current technological challenges, ranging from drug delivery systems to ensuring flight safety. Most such scenarios are too complex to tackle directly and reduced-order modelling is used in order to create viable representations of the target systems. The simplified setting allows for the development of rigorous control theoretical approaches, but the propagation of their effects back up the hierarchy and into real-world systems remains a significant challenge. Using the canonical setup of a liquid film falling down an inclined plane under the action of active feedback controls in the form of blowing and suction, we develop a multi-level modelling framework containing both analytical models and direct numerical simulations acting as an in silico experimental platform. Constructing strategies at the inexpensive lower levels in the hierarchy, we find that offline control transfer is not viable, however analytically-informed feedback strategies show excellent potential, even far beyond the anticipated range of applicability of the models. The detailed effects of the controls in terms of stability and treatment of nonlinearity are examined in detail in order to gain understanding of the information transfer inside the flows, which can aid transition towards other control-rich frameworks and applications.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2021; v1 submitted 28 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Point-actuated feedback control of multidimensional interfaces
Authors:
Ruben J. Tomlin,
Susana N. Gomes
Abstract:
We consider the application of feedback control strategies with point actuators to stabilise desired interface shapes. We take a multidimensional Kuramoto--Sivashinsky equation as a test case; this equation arises in the study of thin liquid films, exhibiting a wide range of dynamics in different parameter regimes, including unbounded growth and full spatiotemporal chaos. In the case of limited ob…
▽ More
We consider the application of feedback control strategies with point actuators to stabilise desired interface shapes. We take a multidimensional Kuramoto--Sivashinsky equation as a test case; this equation arises in the study of thin liquid films, exhibiting a wide range of dynamics in different parameter regimes, including unbounded growth and full spatiotemporal chaos. In the case of limited observability, we utilise a proportional control strategy where forcing at a point depends only on the local observation. We find that point-actuated controls may inhibit unbounded growth of a solution, if they are sufficient in number and in strength, and can exponentially stabilise the desired state. We investigate actuator arrangements, and find that the equidistant case is optimal, with heavy penalties for poorly arranged actuators. We additionally consider the problem of synchronising two chaotic solutions using proportional controls. In the case when the full interface is observable, we construct feedback gain matrices using the linearised dynamics. Such controls improve on the proportional case, and are applied to stabilise non-trivial steady and travelling wave solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Optimal control of thin liquid films and transverse mode effects
Authors:
Ruben J. Tomlin,
Susana N. Gomes,
Grigorios A. Pavliotis,
Demetrios T. Papageorgiou
Abstract:
We consider the control of a three-dimensional thin liquid film on a flat substrate, inclined at a non-zero angle to the horizontal. Controls are applied via same-fluid blowing and suction through the substrate surface. We consider both overlying and hanging films, where the liquid lies above or below the substrate, respectively. We study the weakly nonlinear evolution of the system, which is gove…
▽ More
We consider the control of a three-dimensional thin liquid film on a flat substrate, inclined at a non-zero angle to the horizontal. Controls are applied via same-fluid blowing and suction through the substrate surface. We consider both overlying and hanging films, where the liquid lies above or below the substrate, respectively. We study the weakly nonlinear evolution of the system, which is governed by a forced Kuramoto--Sivashinsky equation in two space dimensions. The uncontrolled problem exhibits three ranges of dynamics depending on the incline of the substrate: stable flat film solution, bounded chaotic dynamics, or unbounded exponential growth of unstable transverse modes. We proceed with the assumption that we may actuate at every point on the substrate. The main focus is the optimal control problem, which we first study in the special case that the forcing may only vary in the spanwise direction. The structure of the Kuramoto--Sivashinsky equation allows the explicit construction of optimal controls in this case using the classical theory of linear quadratic regulators. Such controls are employed to prevent the exponential growth of transverse waves in the case of a hanging film, revealing complex dynamics for the streamwise and mixed modes. We then consider the optimal control problem in full generality, and prove the existence of an optimal control. For numerical simulations, we employ an iterative gradient descent algorithm. In the final section, we consider the effects of transverse mode forcing on the chaotic dynamics present in the streamwise and mixed modes for the case of a vertical film flow. Coupling through nonlinearity allows us to reduce the average energy in solutions without directly forcing the linearly unstable dominant modes.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Stabilising falling liquid film flows using feedback control
Authors:
Alice B. Thompson,
Susana N. Gomes,
Grigorios A. Pavliotis,
Demetrios T. Papageorgiou
Abstract:
Falling liquid films become unstable due to inertial effects when the fluid layer is sufficiently thick or the slope sufficiently steep. This free surface flow of a single fluid layer has industrial applications including coating and heat transfer, which benefit from smooth and wavy interfaces, respectively. Here we discuss how the dynamics of the system are altered by feedback controls based on o…
▽ More
Falling liquid films become unstable due to inertial effects when the fluid layer is sufficiently thick or the slope sufficiently steep. This free surface flow of a single fluid layer has industrial applications including coating and heat transfer, which benefit from smooth and wavy interfaces, respectively. Here we discuss how the dynamics of the system are altered by feedback controls based on observations of the interface height, and supplied to the system via the perpendicular injection and suction of fluid through the wall. In this study, we model the system using both Benney and weighted-residual models that account for the fluid injection through the wall. We find that feedback using injection and suction is a remarkably effective control mechanism: the controls can be used to drive the system towards arbitrary steady states and travelling waves, and the qualitative effects are independent of the details of the flow modelling. Furthermore, we show that the system can still be successfully controlled when the feedback is applied via a set of localised actuators and only a small number of system observations are available, and that this is possible using both static (where the controls are based on only the most recent set of observations) and dynamic (where the controls are based on an approximation of the system which evolves over time) control schemes. This study thus provides a solid theoretical foundation for future experimental realisations of the control of falling liquid films.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2015; v1 submitted 4 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Stabilising nontrivial solutions of the generalised Kuramoto-Sivashinsky equation using feedback and optimal control
Authors:
Susana N. Gomes,
Demetrios T. Papageorgiou,
Grigorios A. Pavliotis
Abstract:
The problem of controlling and stabilising solutions to the Kuramoto-Sivashinsky equation is studied in this paper. We consider a generalised form of the equation in which the effects of an electric field and dispersion are included. Both the feedback and optimal control problems are studied. We prove that we can control arbitrary nontrivial steady states of the Kuramoto-Sivashinsky equation, incl…
▽ More
The problem of controlling and stabilising solutions to the Kuramoto-Sivashinsky equation is studied in this paper. We consider a generalised form of the equation in which the effects of an electric field and dispersion are included. Both the feedback and optimal control problems are studied. We prove that we can control arbitrary nontrivial steady states of the Kuramoto-Sivashinsky equation, including travelling wave solutions, using a finite number of point actuators. The number of point actuators needed is related to the number of unstable modes of the equation. Furthermore, the proposed control methodology is shown to be robust with respect to changing the parameters in the equation, e.g. the viscosity coefficient or the intensity of the electric field. We also study the problem of controlling solutions of coupled systems of Kuramoto-Sivashinsky equations. Possible applications to controlling thin film flows are discussed. Our rigorous results are supported by extensive numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
