-
From annular cavity to rotor-stator flow: nonlinear dynamics of axisymmetric rolls
Authors:
Artur Gesla,
Patrick Le Quéré,
Yohann Duguet,
Laurent Martin Witkowski
Abstract:
Spatio-temporally complex flows are found at the onset of unsteadiness in (axisymmetric) rotor-stator turbulence in the shape of concentric rolls. The emergence of these rolls is rationalised using a homotopy approach, where the original flow configuration is continuously deformed into a simpler, better understood configuration. We deform here rotor-stator flow into an annular flow, thereby contro…
▽ More
Spatio-temporally complex flows are found at the onset of unsteadiness in (axisymmetric) rotor-stator turbulence in the shape of concentric rolls. The emergence of these rolls is rationalised using a homotopy approach, where the original flow configuration is continuously deformed into a simpler, better understood configuration. We deform here rotor-stator flow into an annular flow, thereby controlling curvature effects, and we investigate numerically the transition scenarios as functions of the Reynolds number. Increasing curvature starting from the planar limit reveals a clear path towards a subcritical scenario as a function of the Reynolds number. As the rotor-stator configuration is approached, supercritical branches shift to increasing Reynolds number while a subcritical branch of chaotic states takes over. Modal selection in the supercritical scenario involves the competition between two modal families. It rests on a specific radial localisation property of all eigenmodes, linked to the space-dependent convective radial velocity which intensifies as curvature is increased. A new nonlinear mechanism for the pairing of rolls is proposed based on multiple resonances. The critical point where the original rotor-stator flow loses its stability to axisymmetric perturbations is identified for the first time for the geometry under study.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2025; v1 submitted 20 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Computation and stability analysis of periodic orbits using finite differences, Fourier or Chebyshev spectral expansions in time
Authors:
Artur Gesla,
Yohann Duguet,
Patrick Le Quéré,
Laurent Martin Witkowski
Abstract:
We analyse and compare several algorithms to compute numerically periodic solutions of high-dimensional dynamical systems and investigate their Floquet stability without building the monodromy matrix. The solution and its perturbation are discretised in time either using finite differences, Fourier-Galerkin or Chebyshev expansions. The resulting nonlinear set of equations describing the periodic o…
▽ More
We analyse and compare several algorithms to compute numerically periodic solutions of high-dimensional dynamical systems and investigate their Floquet stability without building the monodromy matrix. The solution and its perturbation are discretised in time either using finite differences, Fourier-Galerkin or Chebyshev expansions. The resulting nonlinear set of equations describing the periodic orbit is solved using a Newton-Raphson algorithm. The linearised equations determining the stability lead to a generalised eigenvalue problem. Unlike the Fourier-Galerkin method, the use of Chebyshev polynomials or finite differences has the advantage that the relevant Floquet exponents are directly given without the well known issue of having to sort out the eigenvalues. The speed of convergence of these three methods is illustrated with examples from the Lorenz system, the Langford system and a two-dimensional thermal convection flow inside a differentially heated cavity. This last example demonstrates the potential of the newly proposed Chebyshev expansion for large-scale problems arising from the discretisation of the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2025; v1 submitted 25 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
On the origin of circular rolls in rotor-stator flow
Authors:
Artur Gesla,
Yohann Duguet,
Patrick Le Quéré,
Laurent Martin Witkowski
Abstract:
Rotor-stator flows are known to exhibit instabilities in the form of circular and spiral rolls. While the spirals are known to emanate from a supercritical Hopf bifurcation, the origin of the circular rolls is still unclear. In the present work we suggest a quantitative scenario for the circular rolls as a response of the system to external forcing. We consider two types of axisymmetric forcing: b…
▽ More
Rotor-stator flows are known to exhibit instabilities in the form of circular and spiral rolls. While the spirals are known to emanate from a supercritical Hopf bifurcation, the origin of the circular rolls is still unclear. In the present work we suggest a quantitative scenario for the circular rolls as a response of the system to external forcing. We consider two types of axisymmetric forcing: bulk forcing (based on the resolvent analysis) and boundary forcing using direct numerical simulation. Using the singular value decomposition of the resolvent operator the optimal response is shown to take the form of circular rolls. The linear gain curve shows strong amplification at non-zero frequencies following a pseudo-resonance mechanism. The optimal energy gain is found to scale exponentially with the Reynolds number $Re$ (for $Re$ based on the rotation rate and interdisc spacing $H$). The results for both types of forcing are compared with former experimental works and previous numerical studies. Our findings suggest that the circular rolls observed experimentally are the effect of the high forcing gain together with the roll-like form of the leading response of the linearised operator. For high enough Reynolds number it is possible to delineate between linear and nonlinear response. For sufficiently strong forcing amplitudes, the nonlinear response is consistent with the self-sustained states found recently for the unforced problem. The onset of such non-trivial dynamics is shown to correspond in state space to a deterministic leaky attractor, as in other subcritical wall-bounded shear flows.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2024; v1 submitted 3 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Subcritical axisymmetric solutions in rotor-stator flow
Authors:
Artur Gesla,
Yohann Duguet,
Patrick Le Quéré,
Laurent Martin Witkowski
Abstract:
Rotor-stator cavity flows are known to exhibit unsteady flow structures in the form of circular and spiral rolls. While the origin of the spirals is well understood, that of the circular rolls is not. In the present study the axisymmetric flow in an aspect ratio $R/H=10$ cavity is revisited {numerically using recent concepts and tools from bifurcation theory}. It is confirmed that a linear instabi…
▽ More
Rotor-stator cavity flows are known to exhibit unsteady flow structures in the form of circular and spiral rolls. While the origin of the spirals is well understood, that of the circular rolls is not. In the present study the axisymmetric flow in an aspect ratio $R/H=10$ cavity is revisited {numerically using recent concepts and tools from bifurcation theory}. It is confirmed that a linear instability takes place at a finite critical Reynolds number $Re=Re_c$, and that there exists a subcritical branch of large amplitude chaotic solutions. This motivates the search for subcritical finite-amplitude solutions. The branch of periodic states born in a Hopf bifurcation at $Re=Re_c$, identified using a Self-Consistent Method (SCM) and arclength continuation, is found to be supercritical. The associated solutions only exist, however, in a very narrow range of $Re$ and do not explain the subcritical chaotic rolls. Another subcritical branch of periodic solutions is found using the Harmonic Balance Method with an initial guess obtained by SCM. In addition, edge states separating the steady laminar and chaotic regimes are identified using a bisection algorithm. These edge states are bi-periodic in time for most values of $Re$, {where} their dynamics is {analysed in detail}. Both solution branches fold around at approximately the same value of $Re$, which is lower than $Re_c$ yet still larger than the values reported in experiments. This suggests that, at least in the absence of external forcing, sustained chaotic rolls have their origin in the bifurcations from these unstable solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2024; v1 submitted 15 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
