Showing 1–22 of 22 results for author: Gaitonde, D

Optimal and suboptimal spatiotemporal dynamics of multi-shear-layers in rectangular jet

Authors: Mitesh Thakor, Datta V. Gaitonde, Yiyang Sun

Abstract: We analyze the perturbation dynamics of a complex supersonic multi-stream rectangular jet. The dynamics are examined through application of spectral proper orthogonal decomposition (SPOD) to elicit coherent structure and linear resolvent analysis to reveal forcing-response characteristics. SPOD of a large-eddy simulation identifies Kelvin--Helmholtz coherent structures at the dominating frequency… ▽ More We analyze the perturbation dynamics of a complex supersonic multi-stream rectangular jet. The dynamics are examined through application of spectral proper orthogonal decomposition (SPOD) to elicit coherent structure and linear resolvent analysis to reveal forcing-response characteristics. SPOD of a large-eddy simulation identifies Kelvin--Helmholtz coherent structures at the dominating frequency in the splitter plate shear layer region, formed by mixing core Mach $1.6$ and bypass Mach $1.0$ streams. Resolvent analysis leverages the time-averaged flowfield on the center plane with discounting to capture flow response over a finite time window, addressing base flow instabilities. The optimal and first sub-optimal resolvent energy amplifications peak near the dominant frequency for a wide range of frequencies and spanwise wavenumbers. Comparing the resolvent and SPOD results, we find that the linear operator over-optimizes the optimal mechanism, and the sub-optimal mode instead is more aligned with the leading SPOD mode. An intriguing shift phenomenon where the optimal and sub-optimal gain distributions crossover is observed; these events are associated with receptive regions in the different shear layers. Subsequent input-output analyses with state-variable and spatial restrictions provide insights into componentwise amplification of the jet flow response, thus providing direction for tailored practical flow control. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

High-speed micro-actuation in a supersonic dual-stream jet flow

Authors: Melissa Yeung, Datta V. Gaitonde, Yiyang Sun

Abstract: Supersonic shear layers experience instabilities that generate significant adverse effects; in complex configurations, these instabilities have global impacts as they foster compounding complications with other independent flow features. We consider the flow near the exit of a dual-stream rectangular nozzle, in which the supersonic core and sonic bypass streams mix downstream of a splitter plate t… ▽ More Supersonic shear layers experience instabilities that generate significant adverse effects; in complex configurations, these instabilities have global impacts as they foster compounding complications with other independent flow features. We consider the flow near the exit of a dual-stream rectangular nozzle, in which the supersonic core and sonic bypass streams mix downstream of a splitter plate trailing edge (SPTE) just above an adjacent deck representative of a wing surface. Active flow control is explored to alleviate the prominent tone associated with vortices shed at the SPTE; these vortices also initiate an unsteady shock system that affects the entire flow field through a shock-induced separation and the downstream evolution of plume shear layers. Resolvent analysis is performed on the baseline flow. The identified optimal location guides the placement of steady-blowing micro-jet actuators. A Navier--Stokes-based parametric study is carried out to consider various actuation angles and locations. Since the resolvent analysis fundamentally investigates the input-output dynamics of a system, it is also utilized to uncover actuation-induced changes in the forcing-response dynamics. Spectral analysis shows that the baseline flow fluctuating energy is concentrated in the shedding instability. Actuating at optimal angles based on location disperses this energy into various flow features; this affects the shedding itself, and the structure and unsteadiness of the shock system and thus the response of the deck and nozzle wall boundary layers and the plume. The resolvent analysis indicates, and Navier-Stokes solutions confirm, that favorable control is obtained by either indirectly or directly mitigating the baseline instability. △ Less

Submitted 15 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

Responses to Disturbance of Supersonic Shear Layer: Input-Output Analysis

Authors: Mitesh Thakor, Yiyang Sun, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: We investigate the perturbation dynamics in a supersonic shear layer using a combination of large-eddy simulations (LES) and linear-operator-based input-output analysis. The flow consists of two streams-a main stream (Mach 1.23) and a bypass stream (Mach 1.0)-separated by a splitter plate of non-negligible thickness. We employ spectral proper orthogonal decomposition to identify the most energetic… ▽ More We investigate the perturbation dynamics in a supersonic shear layer using a combination of large-eddy simulations (LES) and linear-operator-based input-output analysis. The flow consists of two streams-a main stream (Mach 1.23) and a bypass stream (Mach 1.0)-separated by a splitter plate of non-negligible thickness. We employ spectral proper orthogonal decomposition to identify the most energetic coherent structures and bispectral mode decomposition to explore the nonlinear energy cascade within the turbulent shear layer flow. Structures at the dominant frequency are also obtained from a resolvent analysis of the mean flow. We observe higher gain at the dominant frequency in resolvent analysis, indicating the dominance of Kelvin-Helmholtz (KH) instability as the primary disturbance energy-amplification mechanism. To focus on realizable actuator placement locations, we further conduct an input-output analysis by restricting a state variable and spatial location of an input and output. Various combinations of inputs and output indicate that the splitter plate trailing surface is the most sensitive location for introducing a perturbation. For all combinations, the KH instability plays a key role in amplification, which reduces significantly as the input location is moved upstream relative to the splitter plate trailing edge. Furthermore, two-dimensional nonlinear simulations with unsteady input at the upper surface of the splitter plate show remarkable similarities between pressure modes obtained through dynamic mode decomposition and those predicted from linear input-output analysis at a given frequency. This study emphasizes the strength of linear analysis and demonstrates that predicted coherent structures remain active in highly nonlinear turbulent flow. The insights gained from the input-output analysis can be further leveraged to formulate practical flow control strategies. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: 27 pages, 20 figures

Shear-Layer Perturbation Responses from Time-Resolved Schlieren Data

Authors: Spencer L. Stahl, Chandan Kumar, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: A novel combination of physics-based and data-driven post-processing techniques is proposed to extract acoustic-related shear-layer perturbation responses directly from spatio-temporally resolved schlieren video. The physics-based component is derived from a momentum potential theory extension that extracts irrotational (acoustic and thermal) information from density gradients embedded in schliere… ▽ More A novel combination of physics-based and data-driven post-processing techniques is proposed to extract acoustic-related shear-layer perturbation responses directly from spatio-temporally resolved schlieren video. The physics-based component is derived from a momentum potential theory extension that extracts irrotational (acoustic and thermal) information from density gradients embedded in schlieren pixel intensities. For the unheated shear layer, the method spotlights acoustic structures and tones otherwise hidden. The filtered data is then subjected to a data-driven Dynamic Mode Decomposition Reduced Order Model (DMD-ROM), which provides the response to forced perturbations. This method applies a learned linear model to isolate and quantify growth rates of acoustic phenomena suited for efficient parametric studies. A shear-layer comprised of two streams at Mach 2.461 and 0.175, corresponding to a convective Mach number 0.88 and containing shocks, is adopted for illustration. The overall perturbation response is first obtained using an impulse forcing in the wall normal direction of the splitter plate, extending in both subsonic and supersonic streams. Subsequently, impulse and harmonic forcings are independently applied in a local pixel-by-pixel manner for a precise receptivity study. The acoustic response shows a convective wavepacket and an acoustic burst from the splitter plate. The interaction with the primary shock and associated wave dispersion emits a second, slower, acoustic wave. Harmonic forcing indicates higher frequency-dependent sensitivity in the supersonic stream, with the most sensitive location near the outer boundary layer region. Excitation here yields an order of magnitude larger acoustic response compared to disturbances in the subsonic stream. Some receptive forcing inputs do not generate significant acoustic waves, which may guide excitation with low noise impact. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: 27 pages

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 1007 (2025) A77

A data-driven approach to guide supersonic impinging jet control

Authors: Spencer L. Stahl, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: A data-driven framework using snapshots of an uncontrolled flow is proposed to identify, and subsequently demonstrate, effective control strategies for different objectives in supersonic impinging jets. The approach, based on a dynamic mode decomposition reduced order model (DMD-ROM), determines forcing receptivity in an economical manner by projecting flow and actuator-specific forcing snapshots… ▽ More A data-driven framework using snapshots of an uncontrolled flow is proposed to identify, and subsequently demonstrate, effective control strategies for different objectives in supersonic impinging jets. The approach, based on a dynamic mode decomposition reduced order model (DMD-ROM), determines forcing receptivity in an economical manner by projecting flow and actuator-specific forcing snapshots onto a reduced subspace and then evolving the results forward in time. Since it effectively determines a linear response around the unsteady flow in the time-domain, the method differs materially from typical techniques that use steady basic states, such as stability or input-output approaches that employ linearized Navier-Stokes operators in the frequency-domain. The method naturally accounts for factors inherent to the snapshot basis, including configuration complexity and flow parameters such as Reynolds number. Furthermore, gain metrics calculated in the reduced subspace facilitate rapid assessments of flow sensitivities to a wide range of forcing parameters, from which optimal actuator inputs may be selected and results confirmed in scale-resolved simulations or experiments. The DMD-ROM approach is demonstrated from two different perspectives. The first concerns asymptotic feedback resonance, where the effects of harmonic pressure forcing are estimated and verified with nonlinear simulations using a blowing-suction actuator. The second examines time-local behavior within critical feedback events, where the phase of actuation becomes important. For this, a conditional space-time mode is used to identify the optimal forcing phase that minimizes convective instability initiation within the resonance cycle. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2023; v1 submitted 4 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 10 pages, 7 figures

Full trajectory optimizing operator inference for reduced-order modeling using differentiable programming

Authors: Surya Chakrabarti, Arvind T. Mohan, Datta V. Gaitonde, Daniel Livescu

Abstract: Accurate and inexpensive Reduced Order Models (ROMs) for forecasting turbulent flows can facilitate rapid design iterations and thus prove critical for predictive control in engineering problems. Galerkin projection based Reduced Order Models (GP-ROMs), derived by projecting the Navier-Stokes equations on a truncated Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) basis, are popular because of their low com… ▽ More Accurate and inexpensive Reduced Order Models (ROMs) for forecasting turbulent flows can facilitate rapid design iterations and thus prove critical for predictive control in engineering problems. Galerkin projection based Reduced Order Models (GP-ROMs), derived by projecting the Navier-Stokes equations on a truncated Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) basis, are popular because of their low computational costs and theoretical foundations. However, the accuracy of traditional GP-ROMs degrades over long time prediction horizons. To address this issue, we extend the recently proposed Neural Galerkin Projection (NeuralGP) data driven framework to compressibility-dominated transonic flow, considering a prototypical problem of a buffeting NACA0012 airfoil governed by the full Navier-Stokes equations. The algorithm maintains the form of the ROM-ODE obtained from the Galerkin projection; however coefficients are learned directly from the data using gradient descent facilitated by differentiable programming. This blends the strengths of the physics driven GP-ROM and purely data driven neural network-based techniques, resulting in a computationally cheaper model that is easier to interpret. We show that the NeuralGP method minimizes a more rigorous full trajectory error norm compared to a linearized error definition optimized by the calibration procedure. We also find that while both procedures stabilize the ROM by displacing the eigenvalues of the linear dynamics matrix of the ROM-ODE to the complex left half-plane, the NeuralGP algorithm adds more dissipation to the trailing POD modes resulting in its better long-term performance. The results presented highlight the superior accuracy of the NeuralGP technique compared to the traditional calibrated GP-ROM method. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Report number: LA-UR-23-20434

Linear and Nonlinear Disturbance Evolution on the Frustum of Hypersonic Ogive-Cylinders

Authors: Hemanth Goparaju, Kunal Kanawade, S Unnikrishnan, Datta V Gaitonde

Abstract: Aspects of transition mechanisms on a $14^{\circ}$ sharp-nosed ogive-cylinder at Mach~$6$ are elucidated by considering linear and nonlinear disturbance evolution of freestream stochastic and wave packet forcing at different locations downstream of the ogive-cylinder junction. The spectral response of the stochastic forcing displays favorable agreement with experimental observations from AFRL on w… ▽ More Aspects of transition mechanisms on a $14^{\circ}$ sharp-nosed ogive-cylinder at Mach~$6$ are elucidated by considering linear and nonlinear disturbance evolution of freestream stochastic and wave packet forcing at different locations downstream of the ogive-cylinder junction. The spectral response of the stochastic forcing displays favorable agreement with experimental observations from AFRL on which the configuration is based. Intermittent wave packets are generated from small-amplitude continuous freestream pressure forcing. Linear wave packet evolution reveals that Mack modes are the dominant primary instabilities, followed by relatively weaker first-mode waves. The non-linear wavepacket displays a three-legged wall pressure perturbation signature, which is traced to spanwise curvature effects, and fundamental resonance is the dominant secondary instability mechanism. At higher amplitudes of excitation, weak signatures of sub-harmonic and oblique resonance phenomena are identified. Downstream placement of the small-amplitude disturbance diminishes receptivity of first-mode waves; however, with high-amplitude forcing, the location of actuation does not significantly vary the disturbance evolution signature or the secondary instability mechanisms. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: Under review in AIAA Journal

Conditional space-time POD extensions for stability and prediction analysis

Authors: Spencer Stahl, Chitrarth Prasad, Hemanth Goparaju, Datta Gaitonde

Abstract: The correlation and extraction of coherent structures from a turbulent flow is a principle objective of data-driven modal decomposition techniques. The Conditional space-time Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (CPOD) offers insight into transient dynamics, revealing the causation of specific flow phenomenon - or events, in a customizable manner. This work exploits the temporal evolution of CPOD modes… ▽ More The correlation and extraction of coherent structures from a turbulent flow is a principle objective of data-driven modal decomposition techniques. The Conditional space-time Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (CPOD) offers insight into transient dynamics, revealing the causation of specific flow phenomenon - or events, in a customizable manner. This work exploits the temporal evolution of CPOD modes in a reduced subspace, resulting in new extensions and adaptations that meet or exceed the capabilities of other decomposition methods. Chiefly, it is demonstrated that the subsequent application of dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) to CPOD modes, provides a flexible tool to investigate targeted flow instabilities, both tonal and convective in nature. By extending the CPOD time-horizon to educe the former type, it is shown that CPOD-DMD can exactly reproduce Spectral POD modes. Regarding the latter, a multi-resolution framework (CPOD-mrDMD) yields a refined "cause and effect" stability analysis, capable of diagnosing the natural forcing mechanisms within the flow, and the resulting unstable modes. In a separate application, CPOD properties are appreciated in the context of reduced order models, with an example of real-time flow prediction of extreme events derived from an active sensor correlated to a CPOD mode. The various CPOD functions and perspectives in this work are demonstrated on: the nonlinear chaotic Lorenz system, 3D intermittent turbulent spots in supersonic boundary layer transition, Schlieren video processing of unstarted inlet buzz, the aeroacoustic feedback forcing of a resonating impinging jet, and prediction of intermittent bluff-body wake structures impinging on a channel wall. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: 30 pages, 23 figures

Turbulence Modeling of 3D High-speed Flows with Upstream-Informed Corrections

Authors: Chitrarth Prasad, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: Turbulence modeling has the potential to revolutionize high-speed vehicle design by serving as a co-equal partner to costly and challenging ground and flight testing. However, the fundamental assumptions that make turbulence modeling such an appealing alternative to its scale-resolved counterparts also degrade its accuracy for practical high-speed configurations, especially when fully 3D flows are… ▽ More Turbulence modeling has the potential to revolutionize high-speed vehicle design by serving as a co-equal partner to costly and challenging ground and flight testing. However, the fundamental assumptions that make turbulence modeling such an appealing alternative to its scale-resolved counterparts also degrade its accuracy for practical high-speed configurations, especially when fully 3D flows are considered. The current investigation develops a methodology to improve the performance of turbulence modeling for a complex Mach 8.3, 3D shock boundary layer interaction (SBLI) in a double fin geometry. A representative two-equation model, with low-Reynolds number terms, is used as a test-bed. Deficiencies in the baseline model are first elucidated using benchmark test cases involving a Mach~11.1 zero pressure gradient boundary layer and a Mach~6.17 flow over an axisymmetric compression corner. From among different possibilities, two coefficients are introduced to inhibit the non-physical over-amplification of (i) turbulence production and (ii) turbulence length-scale downstream of a shock wave. The coefficients rely on terms already present in the original model, which simplifies implementation and maintains computational costs. The values of the coefficients are predicated on the distribution of turbulence quantities upstream of the shock; this ensures that the modifications do not degrade the model predictions in simpler situations such as attached boundary layers, where they are unnecessary. The effects of the modifications are shown to result in significant improvements in surface pressure and wall heat flux for the 3D SBLI test case, which contains numerous features not observed in 2D situations, such as 3D separation, skewed boundary layers and centerline vortices. Considerations on the inflow values of turbulence variables and mesh resolution are provided. △ Less

Submitted 9 August, 2022; v1 submitted 30 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Resolvent Analysis of an Under-expanded Planar Supersonic Impinging Jet

Authors: Qiong Liu, Chitrarth Prasad, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: This investigation aims to assess the effect of different types of actuator forcing on the feedback loop of an under-expanded Mach 1.27 planar impinging jet using a resolvent framework. To this end, we employ a Large Eddy Simulation database as a truth model. The time and spanwise-averaged mean flow is taken as an input to global stability and resolvent analyses with the purpose of examining both… ▽ More This investigation aims to assess the effect of different types of actuator forcing on the feedback loop of an under-expanded Mach 1.27 planar impinging jet using a resolvent framework. To this end, we employ a Large Eddy Simulation database as a truth model. The time and spanwise-averaged mean flow is taken as an input to global stability and resolvent analyses with the purpose of examining both the intrinsic instability and input-output characteristics. The results show that the inherent instability and primary energy amplification are attributed to the Kelvin-Helmholtz (K-H) instability. Moreover, the K-H response modes obtained from the resolvent analysis are in reasonable agreement with Spectral Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (SPOD) modes from the unsteady LES data. Insights into noise control are obtained by localizing the actuator forcing to the nozzle lip and the ground plate by imposing component-wise forcing to mimic different notional actuators. It is observed that energy amplification obtained for the localized component-wise forcing is different from the global resolvent analysis and dependent on the type of actuator. This provides insights into the type, wavenumber, and frequency of actuators for active flow control. △ Less

Submitted 15 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 12 pages, 9 figures

The role of entropic-instabilities in laminar-turbulent transition on a blunted flat plate

Authors: Hemanth Goparaju, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: The effects of entropic-instabilities on the laminar-turbulent transition dynamics of a blunted flat plate at Mach~$4$ are numerically investigated through linear and nonlinear approaches. Linear wavepacket analysis reveals amplifying oblique first-modes as well as planar and oblique entropy-layer disturbances. The receptivity of entropic-instabilities is found to be largest for actuation seeded i… ▽ More The effects of entropic-instabilities on the laminar-turbulent transition dynamics of a blunted flat plate at Mach~$4$ are numerically investigated through linear and nonlinear approaches. Linear wavepacket analysis reveals amplifying oblique first-modes as well as planar and oblique entropy-layer disturbances. The receptivity of entropic-instabilities is found to be largest for actuation seeded in the entropy-layer; the corresponding linear evolution is characterized by an intensification in the wall-normal plane, coupled with streamwise tilting. The transition process that arises from entropy-layer wave interactions via the oblique breakdown mechanism is examined in detail. Oblique entropy-layer disturbances interact non-linearly with each other and induce streamwise streaks in the boundary-layer. These undergo further destabilization downstream, through a combination of lift-up and Orr-like mechanisms, leading to turbulence onset. Sinuous subharmonic oscillations induced by the entropic-disturbances are the dominant streak instabilities. Slanted hook-shaped structures are observed in the temperature perturbations, and are attributed to an Orr-like mechanism in the entropy-layer. Further, temperature perturbations amplify on the crests of the low-speed streaks in the entropy-layer and generate disturbances through triadic interactions. These disturbances aid in the transfer of perturbation energy into the boundary-layer, eventually leading to spanwise homogenization and near-wall streak generation. Towards the end of the breakdown region, spectral broadening accompanied by the appearance of an inertial sub-range in the boundary-layer indicates the approach of the flow towards turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2022; v1 submitted 18 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Physical Review Fluids

A Robust Physics-based Method to Filter Coherent Wavepackets from High-speed Schlieren Images

Authors: Chitrarth Prasad, Datta Gaitonde

Abstract: A complete understanding of jet dynamics is greatly enabled by accurate separation of the acoustically efficient wavepackets from their higher-energy convecting turbulent counterparts. Recent developments using Momentum Potential Theory (MPT) have successfully isolated the acoustic component in all regions of the jet, to better understand the dynamics as well as to develop wavepacket models. MPT i… ▽ More A complete understanding of jet dynamics is greatly enabled by accurate separation of the acoustically efficient wavepackets from their higher-energy convecting turbulent counterparts. Recent developments using Momentum Potential Theory (MPT) have successfully isolated the acoustic component in all regions of the jet, to better understand the dynamics as well as to develop wavepacket models. MPT is however a data-intensive method since the inherent Poisson equation solution requires fluctuation quantities in the entire flowfield; as such, it has to date been applied only to numerically obtained data. This work develops an approach to extend its application to extract coherent wavepackets from high-speed schlieren images. The procedure maps pixel intensities from the schlieren to a scaled surrogate for the density gradient integrated along the line of sight. The effectiveness of the procedure is demonstrated using experimental as well as simulated schlieren images representing a wide range of imperfectly-expanded free and impinging jet configurations. When combined with Spectral Proper Orthogonal Decomposition, the method yields modes that accurately capture (i) the Mach wave radiation from a military-style jet, (ii) the mode shapes of the feedback tones in an impinging jet, and (iii) the screech signature in twin rectangular jets, without recourse to user adjusted parameters. This technique has the potential to greatly expand the use of high-speed diagnostics and provide real-time monitoring of the acoustic content of the jet in the nearfield, with feedback control implications. Additionally, although the present study focuses on jets, the general nature of the approach allows a straightforward application to other flows, such as cavity flow-acoustic interactions, among others. △ Less

Submitted 26 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

A Time-Domain Linear Method for Jet Noise Prediction and Control Trend Analysis

Authors: Chitrarth Prasad, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: Large-scale turbulent structures in the form of coherent wavepackets play a significant role in the generation of prominent shallow angle noise radiation of jets. Economical prediction tools often model these wavepackets in the frequency-domain using stability modes of the mean flow. The use of simplifying choices, such as parabolized equations and azimuthal decomposition, provide efficient method… ▽ More Large-scale turbulent structures in the form of coherent wavepackets play a significant role in the generation of prominent shallow angle noise radiation of jets. Economical prediction tools often model these wavepackets in the frequency-domain using stability modes of the mean flow. The use of simplifying choices, such as parabolized equations and azimuthal decomposition, provide efficient methods but can impose constraints on rate of streamwise variation of the mean state or geometric complexity. The current investigation develops a time-domain linearized Navier-Stokes-based approach predicated on the mean basic state for two goals: i) to obtain the radiated shallow-angle noise field, including that from imperfectly expanded jets containing shock trains, and ii) to estimate noise control trends with actuator frequency. A previously developed implicit linearization technique repurposing native non-linear Navier-Stokes code capabilities avoids any additional constraints on nozzle geometry, while its time-domain nature facilitates control analysis through transient pulse response. Two other integral components of the method are the sifting of linearized perturbations to isolate the acoustic component with Doak's Momentum Potential Theory, and subsequently Dynamic Mode Decomposition to analyze the response in different spectral ranges. Comparisons with well-validated LES databases show accurate model predictions for super-radiative shallow angle noise, including for hot jets from military-style nozzles. For a specific jet with extensive published experimental data using plasma actuators, it is shown that the method correctly predicts noise amplification at lower frequencies and reduction at higher values, at the observed crossover location. Considerations on the costs associated with the approach, which exploits linearity to extract multiple frequencies with each simulation, are outlined. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Global stability analysis of flow behind an upswept aftbody

Authors: Qiong Liu, Datta V. Gaitonde, Rajesh Ranjan

Abstract: Wakes of aircraft and automobiles with relatively flat slanted aftbodies are often characterized by a streamwise-oriented vortex pair, whose strength affects drag and other crucial performance parameters. We examine the stability characteristics of the vortex pair emerging over an abstraction comprised of a streamwise-aligned cylinder terminated with an upswept plane. The Reynolds number is fixed… ▽ More Wakes of aircraft and automobiles with relatively flat slanted aftbodies are often characterized by a streamwise-oriented vortex pair, whose strength affects drag and other crucial performance parameters. We examine the stability characteristics of the vortex pair emerging over an abstraction comprised of a streamwise-aligned cylinder terminated with an upswept plane. The Reynolds number is fixed at 5000 and the upsweep angle is increased from 20deg to 32deg. At 20deg, the LES yields a steady streamwise-oriented vortex pair, and the global modes are also stable. At 32deg, the LES displays unsteady flow behavior. Linear analysis of the mean flow reveals different unstable modes. The lowest oscillation frequency is an antisymmetric mode, which is attached to the entire slanted base. At the highest frequency, the mode is symmetric and has the same rotational orientation as the mean vortex pair. Its support is prominent in the rear part of the slanted base and spreads relatively rapidly downstream with prominent helical structures. A receptivity analysis of low- and high-frequency modes suggests the latter holds promise to affect the vortical flow, providing a potential starting point for a control strategy to modify the vortex pair. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures

Lagrangian approach for modal analysis of fluid flows

Authors: Vilas J. Shinde, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: Common modal decomposition techniques for flowfield analysis, data-driven modeling and flow control, such as proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) and dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) are usually performed in an Eulerian (fixed) frame of reference with snapshots from measurements or evolution equations. The Eulerian description poses some difficulties, however, when the domain or the mesh deforms… ▽ More Common modal decomposition techniques for flowfield analysis, data-driven modeling and flow control, such as proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) and dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) are usually performed in an Eulerian (fixed) frame of reference with snapshots from measurements or evolution equations. The Eulerian description poses some difficulties, however, when the domain or the mesh deforms with time as, for example, in fluid-structure interactions. For such cases, we first formulate a Lagrangian modal analysis (LMA) ansatz by a posteriori transforming the Eulerian flow fields into Lagrangian flow maps through an orientation and measure-preserving domain diffeomorphism. The development is then verified for Lagrangian variants of POD and DMD using direct numerical simulations (DNS) of two canonical flow configurations at Mach 0.5, the lid-driven cavity and flow past a cylinder, representing internal and external flows, respectively, at pre- and post-bifurcation Reynolds numbers. The LMA is demonstrated for several situations encompassing unsteady flow without and with boundary and mesh deformation as well as non-uniform base flows that are steady in Eulerian but not in Lagrangian frames. We show that LMA application to steady nonuniform base flow yields insights into flow stability and post-bifurcation dynamics. LMA naturally leads to Lagrangian coherent flow structures and connections with finite-time Lyapunov exponents (FTLE). We examine the mathematical link between FTLE and LMA by considering a double-gyre flow pattern. Dynamically important flow features in the Lagrangian sense are recovered by performing LMA with forward and backward (adjoint) time procedures. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2021; v1 submitted 3 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 928 (2021) A35

Acoustic response of turbulent cavity flow using resolvent analysis

Authors: Qiong Liu, Datta Gaitonde

Abstract: The decomposition of hydrodynamic and acoustic components of cavity flows can aid the understanding of the flow-acoustic interaction, which produces a variety of adverse effects in applications. We apply the approach of combining the resolvent analysis and Doak's momentum potential theory to examine the input-output flow-acoustic characteristics of compressible flow over an open cavity at Re=10,00… ▽ More The decomposition of hydrodynamic and acoustic components of cavity flows can aid the understanding of the flow-acoustic interaction, which produces a variety of adverse effects in applications. We apply the approach of combining the resolvent analysis and Doak's momentum potential theory to examine the input-output flow-acoustic characteristics of compressible flow over an open cavity at Re=10,000. The methodology can decompose hydrodynamic and acoustic components from an input-output framework. We further localize the forcing at the leading-edge and front wall of the cavity and filter with a single component of velocity, density, and temperature forcing. For the subsonic flow at M=0.6, The strong acoustic component appears at the trailing edge of the cavity at a lower frequency. while as the frequency increases, the intense acoustic structure moves close to upstream and overlap with the hydrodynamic component. This tendency is also observed in the supersonic flow condition M=1.4. Compared to different types of forcing, the streamwise velocity forcing achieves the largest energy amplification. However, it substantially reduces by moving the forcing location from the leading-edge to the front wall of the cavity. This work provides an alternative approach to examine input-output flow-acoustic characteristics where resonance is dominant and provides guidance for the development of flow control strategies. △ Less

Submitted 13 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 21 pages, 15 figures

Meandering dynamics of streamwise vortex pairs in afterbody wakes

Authors: Rajesh Ranjan, J. -Ch. Robinet, Datta Gaitonde

Abstract: Wakes of upswept afterbodies are often characterized by a counter-rotating streamwise vortex pair. The unsteady dynamics of these vortices are examined with a spatio-temporally resolved Large-Eddy Simulation dataset on a representative configuration consisting of a cylinder with an upswept basal surface. Emphasis is placed on understanding the meandering motion of the vortices in the pair, includi… ▽ More Wakes of upswept afterbodies are often characterized by a counter-rotating streamwise vortex pair. The unsteady dynamics of these vortices are examined with a spatio-temporally resolved Large-Eddy Simulation dataset on a representative configuration consisting of a cylinder with an upswept basal surface. Emphasis is placed on understanding the meandering motion of the vortices in the pair, including vortex core displacement, spectral content, stability mechanisms and overall rank-behavior. The first two energy-ranked modes obtained through Proper Orthogonal Decomposition(POD) of the time-resolved vorticity field reveals a pair of vortex dipoles aligned relatively perpendicularly to each other. The dynamics is successfully mapped to a matched Batchelor vortex pair whose spatial and temporal stability analyses indicate similar dipole structures associated with an |m|=1 elliptic mode pair. This short-wave elliptic instability dominates the meandering motion, with strain due to axial velocity playing a key role in breakdown. The low frequency of the unstable mode (Strouhal number StD =0.3 based on cylinder diameter) is consistent with spectral analysis of meandering in the LES. The wake is examined for its rank behavior; the number of modes required to reproduce the flow to given degree of accuracy diminishes rapidly outside of the immediate vicinity of the base. Beyond two diameters downstream, only two leading POD modes are required to reconstruct the dominant meandering motion and spatial structure in the LES data with < 15% performance loss, while ten modes nearly completely recover the flow field. This low-rank behavior may hold promise in constructing a reduced-order model for control purposes. △ Less

Submitted 30 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 39 pages, 10 figures

Instabilities and transition in cooled-wall hypersonic boundary layers

Authors: S. Unnikrishnan, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: Wall cooling has substantial effects on the development of instabilities and transition processes in hypersonic boundary layers (HBLs). A sequence of linear stability theory, two-dimensional and non-linear three-dimensional DNSs is used to analyze Mach~6 boundary layers, with wall temperatures ranging from near-adiabatic to highly cooled conditions, where the second-mode instability radiates energ… ▽ More Wall cooling has substantial effects on the development of instabilities and transition processes in hypersonic boundary layers (HBLs). A sequence of linear stability theory, two-dimensional and non-linear three-dimensional DNSs is used to analyze Mach~6 boundary layers, with wall temperatures ranging from near-adiabatic to highly cooled conditions, where the second-mode instability radiates energy. Fluid-thermodynamic analysis shows that this radiation comprises both acoustic as well as vortical waves. 2D simulations show that the conventional "trapped" nature of second-mode instability is ruptured. Although the energy efflux of both acoustic and vortical components increases with wall-cooling, the destabilization effect is much stronger and no significant abatement of pressure perturbations is realized. In the near-adiabatic HBL, the wavepacket remains trapped within the boundary layer and attenuates outside the region of linear instability. However, wavepackets in the cooled-wall HBLs amplify and display nonlinear distortion, and transition more rapidly. The structure of the wavepacket displays different behavior; moderately-cooled walls show bifurcation into a leading turbulent head region and a trailing harmonic region, while highly-cooled wall cases display lower convection speeds and significant wavepacket elongation, with intermittent spurts of turbulence in the wake of the head region. This elongation effect is associated with a weakening of the lateral jet mechanism due to the breakdown of spanwise coherent structures. In moderately cooled-walls, the spatially-localized wall loading is due to coherent structures in the leading turbulent head region. In highly-cooled walls, the elongated near-wall streaks in the wake region of the wavepacket result in more than twice as large levels of skin friction and heat transfer over a sustained period of time. △ Less

Submitted 21 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Linear, nonlinear and transitional regimes of second mode instability

Authors: S. Unnikrishnan, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: The 2D second-mode is a potent instability in hypersonic boundary layers (HBLs). We study its linear and nonlinear evolution, followed by its role in transition and eventual breakdown of the HBL into a fully turbulent state. Linear stability theory (LST) is utilized to identify the second-mode wave through FS-synchronization, which is then recreated in linearly and nonlinearly forced 2D direct num… ▽ More The 2D second-mode is a potent instability in hypersonic boundary layers (HBLs). We study its linear and nonlinear evolution, followed by its role in transition and eventual breakdown of the HBL into a fully turbulent state. Linear stability theory (LST) is utilized to identify the second-mode wave through FS-synchronization, which is then recreated in linearly and nonlinearly forced 2D direct numerical simulations (DNSs). The nonlinear DNS shows saturation of the fundamental frequency, and the resulting superharmonics induce tightly braided ``rope-like'' patterns near the generalized inflection point (GIP). The instability exhibits a second region of growth constituted by the fundamental frequency, downstream of the primary envelope, which is absent in the linear scenario. Subsequent 3D DNS identifies this region to be crucial in amplifying oblique instabilities riding on the 2D second-mode ``rollers''. This results in lambda vortices below the GIP, which are detached from the ``rollers'' in the inner boundary layer. Streamwise vortex-stretching results in a localized peak in length-scales inside the HBL, eventually forming haripin vortices. Spectral analyses track the transformation of harmonic peaks into a turbulent spectrum, and appearance of oblique modes at the fundamental frequency, which suggests that fundamental resonance is the most dominant mechanism of transition. Bispectrum reveals coupled nonlinear interactions between the fundamental and its superharmonics leading to spectral broadening, and traces of subharmonic resonance as well. △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

A Robust Approach for Stability Analysis of Complex Flows Using Navier-Stokes Solvers

Authors: Rajesh Ranjan, S. Unnikrishnan, Datta Gaitonde

Abstract: Direct methods to obtain global stability modes are restricted by the daunting sizes and complexity of Jacobians encountered in general three-dimensional flows. Jacobian-free iterative approaches such as Arnoldi methods have greatly alleviated the required computational burden. However, operations such as orthonormalization and shift-and-invert transformation of matrices with appropriate shift gue… ▽ More Direct methods to obtain global stability modes are restricted by the daunting sizes and complexity of Jacobians encountered in general three-dimensional flows. Jacobian-free iterative approaches such as Arnoldi methods have greatly alleviated the required computational burden. However, operations such as orthonormalization and shift-and-invert transformation of matrices with appropriate shift guesses can stll introduce computational and parameter-dependent costs that inhibit their routine application to general three-dimensional flowfields. The present work addresses these limitations by proposing and implementing a robust, generalizable approach to extract the principal global modes, suited for curvilinear coordinates as well as the effects of compressibility. Accurate linearized perturbation snapshots are obtained using high-order schemes by leveraging the same non-linear Navier-Stokes code as used to obtain the basic state by appropriately constraining the equations using a body-force. It is shown that with random impulse forcing, dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) of the subspace formed by these products yields the desired physically meaningful modes when appropriately scaled. The leading eigenmodes are thus obtained without spurious modes or the need for an iterative procedure. Further, since orthonormalization is not required, large subspaces can be processed to capture converged low frequency or stationary modes. The validity and versatility of the method are demonstrated with numerous examples encompassing essential elements expected in realistic flows, such as compressibility effects and complicated domains requiring general curvilinear meshes. Favorable comparisons with Arnoldi-based method, complemented with substantial savings in computational resources show the potential of the current approach for relatively complex flows. △ Less

Submitted 15 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 40 pages, 16 figures, 3 tables

Journal ref: Journal of Computational Physics (2020)

A Deep Learning based Approach to Reduced Order Modeling for Turbulent Flow Control using LSTM Neural Networks

Authors: Arvind T. Mohan, Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: Reduced Order Modeling (ROM) for engineering applications has been a major research focus in the past few decades due to the unprecedented physical insight into turbulence offered by high-fidelity CFD. The primary goal of a ROM is to model the key physics/features of a flow-field without computing the full Navier-Stokes (NS) equations. This is accomplished by projecting the high-dimensional dynami… ▽ More Reduced Order Modeling (ROM) for engineering applications has been a major research focus in the past few decades due to the unprecedented physical insight into turbulence offered by high-fidelity CFD. The primary goal of a ROM is to model the key physics/features of a flow-field without computing the full Navier-Stokes (NS) equations. This is accomplished by projecting the high-dimensional dynamics to a low-dimensional subspace, typically utilizing dimensionality reduction techniques like Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD), coupled with Galerkin projection. In this work, we demonstrate a deep learning based approach to build a ROM using the POD basis of canonical DNS datasets, for turbulent flow control applications. We find that a type of Recurrent Neural Network, the Long Short Term Memory (LSTM) which has been primarily utilized for problems like speech modeling and language translation, shows attractive potential in modeling temporal dynamics of turbulence. Additionally, we introduce the Hurst Exponent as a tool to study LSTM behavior for non-stationary data, and uncover useful characteristics that may aid ROM development for a variety of applications. △ Less

Submitted 24 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Plasma-based Control of Supersonic Nozzle Flow

Authors: Datta V. Gaitonde

Abstract: The flow structure obtained when Localized Arc Filament Plasma Actuators (LAFPA) are employed to control the flow issuing from a perfectly expanded Mach 1.3 nozzle is elucidated by visualizing coherent structures obtained from Implicit Large-Eddy Simulations. The computations reproduce recent experimental observations at the Ohio State University to influence the acoustic and mixing properties o… ▽ More The flow structure obtained when Localized Arc Filament Plasma Actuators (LAFPA) are employed to control the flow issuing from a perfectly expanded Mach 1.3 nozzle is elucidated by visualizing coherent structures obtained from Implicit Large-Eddy Simulations. The computations reproduce recent experimental observations at the Ohio State University to influence the acoustic and mixing properties of the jet. Eight actuators were placed on a collar around the periphery of the nozzle exit and selectively excited to generate various modes, including first and second mixed (m = +/- 1 and m = +/- 2) and axisymmetric (m = 0). In this fluid dynamics video http://ecommons.library.cornell.edu/bitstream/1813/13723/2/Alljoinedtotalwithmodetextlong2-Datta%20MPEG-1.m1v, http://ecommons.library.cornell.edu/bitstream/1813/13723/3/Alljoinedtotalwithmodetextlong2-Datta%20MPEG-2.m2v}, unsteady and phase-averaged quantities are displayed to aid understanding of the vortex dynamics associated with the m = +/- 1 and m = 0 modes excited at the preferred column-mode frequency (Strouhal number 0.3). The unsteady flow in both contains a broad spectrum of coherent features. For m = +/- 1, the phase-averaged flow reveals the generation of successive distorted elliptic vortex rings with axes in the flapping plane, but alternating on either side of the jet axis. This generates a chain of structures where each interacts with its predecessor on one side and its successor on the other. Through self and mutual interaction, the leading segment of each loop is pinched and passes through the previous ring before rapidly breaking up, and the mean jet flow takes on an elliptic shape. The m = 0 mode exhibits relatively stable roll-up events, with vortex ribs in the braid regions connecting successive large coherent structures. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2009; originally announced September 2009.

Comments: 3 pages. Video submission to Gallery of Fluid Motion, American Physical Society, Division of Fluid Dynamics, 62nd Annual Meeting, November 22-24, 2009, Minneapolis, MN. Replacement deletes TeX commands to correct web links