-
Data-driven correlations for thermohydraulic roughness properties
Authors:
Simon Dalpke,
Jiasheng Yang,
Pourya Forooghi,
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Alexander Stroh
Abstract:
The influence of rough surfaces on fluid flow is characterized by the downward shift in the logarithmic layer of velocity and temperature profiles, namely the velocity roughness function $ΔU^+$ and the corresponding temperature roughness function $ΔΘ^+$. Their computation relies on computational simulations, and hence a simple prediction without such simulation is envisioned. We present a framewor…
▽ More
The influence of rough surfaces on fluid flow is characterized by the downward shift in the logarithmic layer of velocity and temperature profiles, namely the velocity roughness function $ΔU^+$ and the corresponding temperature roughness function $ΔΘ^+$. Their computation relies on computational simulations, and hence a simple prediction without such simulation is envisioned. We present a framework, where a data-driven model is developed using the dataset of Yang et al. 2023 \cite{yang_2023} with $93$ high fidelity direct numerical simulations of a fully-developed turbulent channel flow at $Re_τ\approx 800$ and $Pr = 0.71$. The model provides robust predictive capabilities (mean squared error $\text{MSE}_{k} = 0.09$ and $\text{MSE}_θ= 0.096$), but lacks interpretability. Simplistic statistical roughness parameters provide a more understandable route, so the framework is extended with a symbolic regression approach to distill an empirical correlation from the data-driven model. The derived expression leads to a predictive correlation for the equivalent sand-grain roughness $k_\text{s} = k_\text{99} (ES_x ( - ES_x + Sk + 2.37) + 0.772)$ with reasonable predictive powers. The predictive capability of the temperature roughness function is subject to limitations due to the missing Prandtl-number variation in the dataset. Nevertheless, the interpretable correlation and the neural network as well as the original dataset can be used to explore the roughness functions. The functional form of the derived correlations, along with visual analysis of these surfaces, suggests a strong relationship with roughness wavelengths, further linking them to explanations based on sheltered and windward regions.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Investigating the shortcomings of the Flow Convergence Method for quantification of Mitral Regurgitation in a pulsatile in-vitro environment and with Computational Fluid Dynamics
Authors:
Robin Leister,
Roger Karl,
Lubov Stroh,
Derliz Mereles,
Matthias Eden,
Luis Neff,
Raffaele de Simone,
Gabriele Romano,
Jochen Kriegseis,
Matthias Karck,
Christoph Lichtenstern,
Norbert Frey,
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Alexander Stroh,
Sandy Engelhardt
Abstract:
The flow convergence method includes calculation of the proximal isovelocity surface area (PISA) and is widely used to classify mitral regurgitation (MR) with echocardiography. It constitutes a primary decision factor for determination of treatment and should therefore be a robust quantification method. However, it is known for its tendency to underestimate MR and its dependence on user expertise.…
▽ More
The flow convergence method includes calculation of the proximal isovelocity surface area (PISA) and is widely used to classify mitral regurgitation (MR) with echocardiography. It constitutes a primary decision factor for determination of treatment and should therefore be a robust quantification method. However, it is known for its tendency to underestimate MR and its dependence on user expertise. The present work systematically compares different pulsatile flow profiles arising from different regurgitation orifices using transesophageal echocardiographic (TEE) probe and particle image velocimetry (PIV) as a reference in an in-vitro environment. It is found that the inter-observer variability using echocardiography is small compared to the systematic underestimation of the regurgitation volume for large orifice areas (up to 52%) where a violation of the flow convergence method assumptions occurs. From a flow perspective, a starting vortex was found as a dominant flow pattern in the regurgant jet for all orifice shapes and sizes. A series of simplified computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations indicate that selecting a suboptimal aliasing velocity during echocardiography measurements might be a primary source of potential underestimation in MR characterization via the PISA-based method, reaching up to 40%. In this study, it has been noted in clinical observations that physicians often select an aliasing velocity higher than necessary for optimal estimation in diagnostic procedures.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2024; v1 submitted 8 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Carrier-phase DNS of ignition and combustion of iron particles in a turbulent mixing layer
Authors:
Tien Duc Luu,
Ali Shamooni,
Andreas Kronenburg,
Daniel Braig,
Johannes Mich,
Bich-Diep Nguyen,
Arne Scholtissek,
Christian Hasse,
Gabriel Thäter,
Maurizio Carbone,
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Oliver Thomas Stein
Abstract:
Three-dimensional CP-DNS of reacting iron particle dust clouds in a turbulent mixing layer are conducted. The simulation approach considers the Eulerian transport equations for the reacting gas phase and resolves all scales of turbulence, whereas the particle boundary layers are modelled employing the Lagrangian point-particle framework for the dispersed phase. The CP-DNS employs an existing sub-m…
▽ More
Three-dimensional CP-DNS of reacting iron particle dust clouds in a turbulent mixing layer are conducted. The simulation approach considers the Eulerian transport equations for the reacting gas phase and resolves all scales of turbulence, whereas the particle boundary layers are modelled employing the Lagrangian point-particle framework for the dispersed phase. The CP-DNS employs an existing sub-model for iron particle combustion that considers the oxidation of iron to FeO and that accounts for both diffusion- and kinetically-limited combustion. At first, the particle sub-model is validated against experimental results for single iron particle combustion considering various particle diameters and ambient oxygen concentrations. Subsequently, the CP-DNS approach is employed to predict iron particle cloud ignition and combustion in a turbulent mixing layer. The upper stream of the mixing layer is initialised with cold particles in air, while the lower stream consists of hot air flowing in the opposite direction. Simulation results show that turbulent mixing induces heating, ignition and combustion of the iron particles. Significant increases in gas temperature and oxygen consumption occur mainly in regions where clusters of iron particles are formed. Over the course of the oxidation, the particles are subjected to different rate-limiting processes. While initially particle oxidation is kinetically-limited it becomes diffusion-limited for higher particle temperatures and peak particle temperatures are observed near the fully-oxidised particle state. Comparing the present non-volatile iron dust flames to general trends in volatile-containing solid fuel flames, non-vanishing particles at late simulation times and a stronger limiting effect of the local oxygen concentration on particle conversion is found for the present iron dust flames in shear-driven turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Prediction of equivalent sand-grain size and identification of drag-relevant scales of roughness -- a data driven approach
Authors:
Jiasheng Yang,
Alexander Stroh,
Sangseung Lee,
Shervin Bagheri,
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Pourya Forooghi
Abstract:
The purpose of the present work is to examine two possibilities; firstly, predicting equivalent sand-grain roughness size $k_s$ based on the roughness height probability density function and power spectrum leveraging machine learning as a regression tool, and secondly, extracting information about relevance of different roughness scales to skin-friction drag by interpreting the output of the train…
▽ More
The purpose of the present work is to examine two possibilities; firstly, predicting equivalent sand-grain roughness size $k_s$ based on the roughness height probability density function and power spectrum leveraging machine learning as a regression tool, and secondly, extracting information about relevance of different roughness scales to skin-friction drag by interpreting the output of the trained data-driven model. The model is an ensemble neural network consisting of 50 deep neural networks. The data for the training of the model is obtained from direct numerical simulations (DNSs) of turbulent flow in plane channels over 85 irregular multi-scale roughness samples at friction Reynolds number Re$_τ=800$. The 85 roughness samples are selected from a repository of 4200 samples, covering a wide parameter space, through an active learning (AL) framework. The selection is made in several iterations, based on the informativeness of samples in the repository, quantified by the variance of ENN predictions. This AL framework aims to maximize the generalizability of the predictions with a certain amount of data. This is examined using three different testing data sets with different types of roughness, including 21 surfaces from the literature. The model yields an overall mean error of 5\% to 10\% on different testing data sets. Subsequently, a data interpretation technique, known as layer-wise relevance propagation, is applied to measure the contributions of different roughness wave-lengths to the predicted $k_s$. High-pass filtering is then applied to the roughness PS to exclude the wave-numbers identified as drag-irrelevant. The filtered rough surfaces are investigated using DNS, and it is demonstrated that, despite significant impact of filtering on the roughness topographical appearance and statistics, the skin-friction coefficient of the original roughness is successfully preserved.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2023; v1 submitted 18 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
The effect of spanwise heterogeneous surfaces on mixed convection in turbulent channels
Authors:
K. Schäfer,
B. Frohnapfel,
J. P. Mellado
Abstract:
Turbulent mixed convection in channel flows with heterogeneous surfaces is studied using direct numerical simulations. The relative importance between buoyancy and shear effects, characterized by the bulk Richardson number $Ri_b$, is varied in order to cover the flow regimes of forced, mixed and natural convection, which are associated with different large-scale flow organization. The heterogeneou…
▽ More
Turbulent mixed convection in channel flows with heterogeneous surfaces is studied using direct numerical simulations. The relative importance between buoyancy and shear effects, characterized by the bulk Richardson number $Ri_b$, is varied in order to cover the flow regimes of forced, mixed and natural convection, which are associated with different large-scale flow organization. The heterogeneous surface consists of streamwise-aligned ridges, which are known to induce secondary motion in case of forced convection. The large-scale streamwise rolls emerging under smooth-wall mixed convection conditions are significantly affected by the heterogeneous surfaces and their appearance is considerably reduced for dense ridge spacings. It is found that the formation of these rolls requires larger buoyancy forces than over smooth walls due to the additional drag induced by the ridges. Therefore, the transition from forced convection structures to rolls is delayed towards larger $Ri_b$ for spanwise heterogeneous surfaces. The influence of the heterogeneous surface on the flow organization of mixed convection is particularly pronounced in the roll-to-cell transition range, where ridges favor the transition to convective cells at significantly lower $Ri_b$. In addition, the convective cells are observed to align perpendicular to the ridges with decreasing ridge spacing. We attribute this reorganization to the fact that flow parallel to the ridges experience less drag than flow across the ridges, which is energetically more beneficial. Furthermore, we find that streamwise rolls exhibit very slow dynamics for $Ri_b=1$ and $Ri_b=3.2$ when the ridge spacing is in the order of the rolls' width. For these cases the up- and downdrafts of the rolls move slowly across the entire channel instead of being fixed in space as observed for the smooth-wall cases.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2022; v1 submitted 18 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Tripping and laminar--turbulent transition: Implementation in RANS--EVM
Authors:
N. Tabatabaei,
G. Fahland,
A. Stroh,
D. Gatti,
B. Frohnapfel,
M. Atzori,
R. Vinuesa1,
P. Schlatter
Abstract:
Fundamental fluid--mechanics studies and many engineering developments are based on tripped cases. Therefore, it is essential for CFD simulations to replicate the same forced transition in spite of the availability of advanced transition modelling. In the last decade, both direct and large--eddy simulations (DNS and LES) include tripping methods in an effort to avoid the need for modeling the comp…
▽ More
Fundamental fluid--mechanics studies and many engineering developments are based on tripped cases. Therefore, it is essential for CFD simulations to replicate the same forced transition in spite of the availability of advanced transition modelling. In the last decade, both direct and large--eddy simulations (DNS and LES) include tripping methods in an effort to avoid the need for modeling the complex mechanisms associated with the natural transition process, which we would like to bring over to Reynolds--averaged Navier--Stokes (RANS) turbulence models. This paper investigates the necessity and applications of numerical tripping, despite of the developments in numerical modeling of natural transition. The second goal of this paper is to assess a technique to implement tripping in eddy-viscosity models (EVM) for RANS. A recent approach of turbulence generation, denoted as turbulence-injection method (kI), is evaluated and investigated through different test cases ranging from a turbulent boundary layer on a flat plate to the three dimensional(3D) flow over a wing section. The desired tripping is achieved at the target location and the simulation results compare favorably with the reference results (DNS, LES and measured data). With the application of the model, the challenging transition region can be minimized in a simulation, and consequently more reliable results are obtained.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Objective barriers to the transport of dynamically active vector fields
Authors:
George Haller,
Stergios Katsanoulis,
Markus Holzner,
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Davide Gatti
Abstract:
We derive a theory for material surfaces that maximally inhibit the diffusive transport of a dynamically active vector field, such as the linear momentum, the angular momentum or the vorticity, in general fluid flows. These special material surfaces (\emph{Lagrangian active barriers}) provide physics-based, observer-independent boundaries of dynamically active coherent structures. We find that Lag…
▽ More
We derive a theory for material surfaces that maximally inhibit the diffusive transport of a dynamically active vector field, such as the linear momentum, the angular momentum or the vorticity, in general fluid flows. These special material surfaces (\emph{Lagrangian active barriers}) provide physics-based, observer-independent boundaries of dynamically active coherent structures. We find that Lagrangian active barriers evolve from invariant surfaces of an associated steady and incompressible \emph{barrier equation}, whose right-hand side is the time-averaged pullback of the viscous stress terms in the evolution equation for the dynamically active vector field. Instantaneous limits of these barriers mark objective \emph{Eulerian active barriers} to the short-term diffusive transport of the dynamically active vector field. We obtain that in unsteady Beltrami flows, Lagrangian and Eulerian active barriers coincide exactly with purely advective transport barriers bounding observed coherent structures. In more general flows, active barriers can be identified by applying Lagrangian coherent structure (LCS) diagnostics, such as the finite-time Lyapunov exponent and the polar rotation angle, to the appropriate active barrier equation. In comparison to their passive counterparts, these \emph{active LCS diagnostics} require no significant fluid particle separation and hence provide substantially higher-resolved Lagrangian and Eulerian coherent structure boundaries from temporally shorter velocity data sets. We illustrate these results and their physical interpretation on two-dimensional, homogeneous, isotropic turbulence and on a three-dimensional turbulent channel flow.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2020; v1 submitted 16 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Rearrangement of secondary flow over spanwise heterogeneous roughness
Authors:
A. Stroh,
K. Schäfer,
B. Frohnapfel,
P. Forooghi
Abstract:
Turbulent flow over a surface with streamwise-elongated rough and smooth stripes is studied by means of direct numerical simulation (DNS) in a periodic plane open channel with fully resolved roughness. The goal is to understand how the mean height of roughness affects the characteristics of the secondary flow formed above a spanwise-heterogeneous rough surface. To this end, while the statistical p…
▽ More
Turbulent flow over a surface with streamwise-elongated rough and smooth stripes is studied by means of direct numerical simulation (DNS) in a periodic plane open channel with fully resolved roughness. The goal is to understand how the mean height of roughness affects the characteristics of the secondary flow formed above a spanwise-heterogeneous rough surface. To this end, while the statistical properties of roughness texture as well as the width and spacing of the rough stripes are kept constant, the elevation of the smooth stripes is systematically varied in different simulation cases. Utilizing this variation three configurations representing protruding, recessed and an intermediate type of roughness are analysed. In all cases secondary flows are present and the skin friction coefficients calculated for all the heterogeneous rough surfaces are meaningfully larger than what would result from the area-weighted average of those of homogeneous smooth and rough surfaces. This drag increase appears to be linked to the strength of the secondary flow. The rotational direction of the secondary motion is shown to depend on the relative surface elevation. The present results suggest that this rearrangement of the secondary flow is linked to the spatial distribution of the spanwise-wall-normal Reynolds stress component which carries opposing signs for protruding and recessed roughness.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2021; v1 submitted 16 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Assessment of skin-friction-reduction techniques on a turbulent wing section
Authors:
M. Atzori,
R. Vinuesa,
A. Stroh,
B. Frohnapfel,
P. Schlatter
Abstract:
The scope of the present project is to quantify the effects of uniform blowing and body-force damping on turbulent boundary layers subjected to a non-uniform adverse-pressure-gradient distribution. To this end, well-resolved large-eddy simulations are employed to describe the flow around the NACA4412 airfoil at moderate Reynolds number 200, 000 based on freestream velocity and chord length. In the…
▽ More
The scope of the present project is to quantify the effects of uniform blowing and body-force damping on turbulent boundary layers subjected to a non-uniform adverse-pressure-gradient distribution. To this end, well-resolved large-eddy simulations are employed to describe the flow around the NACA4412 airfoil at moderate Reynolds number 200, 000 based on freestream velocity and chord length. In the present paper we focus on uniform blowing and the conference presentation will include a comparison with body-force damping applied in the same region. The inner-scaled profiles of the mean velocity and of selected components of the Reynolds-stress tensor are examined and compared with the uncontrolled cases. It is known that uniform blowing and adverse-pressure gradients share some similarities in their effect on the boundary layers, and our results will show that these effects are not independent. The behaviour of the skin-friction coefficient is analyzed through the FIK decomposition, and the impact of this control strategy on the aerodynamic efficiency of the airfoil is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Global energy fluxes in fully-developed turbulent channels with flow control
Authors:
Davide Gatti,
Andrea Cimarelli,
Yosuke Hasegawa,
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Maurizio Quadrio
Abstract:
This paper addresses the integral energy fluxes in natural and controlled turbulent channel flows, where active skin-friction drag reduction techniques allow a more efficient use of the available power. We study whether the increased efficiency shows any general trend in how energy is dissipated by the mean velocity field (mean dissipation) and by the fluctuating velocity field (turbulent dissipat…
▽ More
This paper addresses the integral energy fluxes in natural and controlled turbulent channel flows, where active skin-friction drag reduction techniques allow a more efficient use of the available power. We study whether the increased efficiency shows any general trend in how energy is dissipated by the mean velocity field (mean dissipation) and by the fluctuating velocity field (turbulent dissipation).
Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) of different control strategies are performed at Constant Power Input (CPI), so that at statistical equilibrium each flow (either uncontrolled or controlled by different means) has the same power input, hence the same global energy flux and, by definition, the same total energy dissipation rate. The simulations reveal that changes in mean and turbulent energy dissipation rates can be of either sign in a successfully controlled flow.
A quantitative description of these changes is made possible by a new decomposition of the total dissipation, stemming from an extended Reynolds decomposition, where the mean velocity is split into a laminar component and a deviation from it. Thanks to the analytical expressions of the laminar quantities, exact relationships are derived that link the achieved flow rate increase and all energy fluxes in the flow system with two wall-normal integrals of the Reynolds shear stress and the Reynolds number. The dependence of the energy fluxes on the Reynolds number is elucidated with a simple model in which the control-dependent changes of the Reynolds shear stress are accounted for via a modification of the mean velocity profile. The physical meaning of the energy fluxes stemming from the new decomposition unveils their inter-relations and connection to flow control, so that a clear target for flow control can be identified.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
A systematic study of turbulent heat transfer over rough walls
Authors:
Pourya Forooghi,
Matthias Stripf,
Bettina Frohnapfel
Abstract:
Direct Numerical Simulations are used to solve turbulent flow and heat transfer over a variety of rough walls in a channel. The wall geometries are exactly resolved in the simulations. The aim is to understand the effect of roughness morphology and its scaling on the augmentation of heat transfer relative to that of skin friction. A number of realistic rough surface maps obtained from the scanning…
▽ More
Direct Numerical Simulations are used to solve turbulent flow and heat transfer over a variety of rough walls in a channel. The wall geometries are exactly resolved in the simulations. The aim is to understand the effect of roughness morphology and its scaling on the augmentation of heat transfer relative to that of skin friction. A number of realistic rough surface maps obtained from the scanning of gas turbine blades and internal combustion engines as well as several artificially generated rough surfaces are examined. In the first part of the paper, effects of statistical surface properties, namely surface slope and roughness density, at constant roughness height are systematically investigated, and it is shown that Reynolds analogy factor (two times Stanton number divided by skin friction coefficient) varies meaningfully but moderately with the surface parameters except for the case with extremely low slope or density where the Reynolds analogy factor grows significantly and tends to that of a smooth wall. In the second part of the paper, the roughness height is varied (independently in both inner and outer units) while the geometrical similarity is maintained. Considering all the simulated cases, it is concluded that Reynolds analogy factor correlates fairly well with the equivalent sand roughness scaled in inner units and asymptotically tends to a plateau.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Direct Numerical Simulation of Turbulent Channel Flow with Riblets at Low Reynolds Number
Authors:
Verena Fink,
Bettina Frohnapfel
Abstract:
In this report we briefly summarize the set-up and results for direct numerical simulations (DNS) of turbulent channel flows with riblets. The DNS are carried out with OpenFOAM which allows the use of an unstructured mesh. The present results were presented at the European Drag Reduction and Flow Control Meeting in 2015.
In this report we briefly summarize the set-up and results for direct numerical simulations (DNS) of turbulent channel flows with riblets. The DNS are carried out with OpenFOAM which allows the use of an unstructured mesh. The present results were presented at the European Drag Reduction and Flow Control Meeting in 2015.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Small scale dynamics of a shearless turbulent/non-turbulent interface in dilute polymer solutions
Authors:
Giacomo Cocconi,
Elisabetta De Angelis,
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Mark Baevsky,
Alex Liberzon
Abstract:
We study the physics of turbulent/non-turbulent interface of an isolated turbulent region in dilute polymer solutions and Newtonian fluid. The performance of a FENE-P model with a localized homogeneous forcing is verified using the specially designed experimental setup of a turbulent patch growing in water/dilute polymer solution, without mean shear and far from the walls. The results of the small…
▽ More
We study the physics of turbulent/non-turbulent interface of an isolated turbulent region in dilute polymer solutions and Newtonian fluid. The performance of a FENE-P model with a localized homogeneous forcing is verified using the specially designed experimental setup of a turbulent patch growing in water/dilute polymer solution, without mean shear and far from the walls. The results of the small scale dynamics of vorticity and strain help to reveal the key mechanism of polymer action in turbulent flows without mean shear. Modified degrees of alignment between vorticity, the polymer conformation and the rate-of-strain tensors found especially near the interface explain the reduced vorticity stretching and increased vorticity compression terms. These small scale alignments in the non-Newtonian turbulent flow thus lead to a reduced production of enstrophy and consequently to a reduced entrainment (seen as propagation or dispersion).
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2017; v1 submitted 18 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Global effect of local skin friction drag reduction in spatially developing turbulent boundary layer
Authors:
A. Stroh,
Y. Hasegawa,
P. Schlatter,
B. Frohnapfel
Abstract:
A numerical investigation of two locally applied drag reducing control schemes is carried out in the configuration of a spatially developing turbulent boundary layer (TBL). One control is designed to damp near-wall turbulence and the other induces constant mass flux in the wall-normal direction. Both control schemes yield similar local drag reduction rates within the control region. However, the f…
▽ More
A numerical investigation of two locally applied drag reducing control schemes is carried out in the configuration of a spatially developing turbulent boundary layer (TBL). One control is designed to damp near-wall turbulence and the other induces constant mass flux in the wall-normal direction. Both control schemes yield similar local drag reduction rates within the control region. However, the flow development downstream of the control significantly differs: persistent drag reduction is found for the uniform blowing case whereas drag increase is found for the turbulence damping case. In order to account for this difference the formulation of a global drag reduction rate is suggested. It represents the reduction of the streamwise force exerted by the fluid on a finite length plate. Furthermore, it is shown that the far downstream development of the TBL after the control region can be described by a single quantity, namely a streamwise shift of the uncontrolled boundary layer, i.e. a changed virtual origin. Based on this result, a simple model is developed that allows relating for the local drag reduction rate to the global one without the need of conducting expensive simulations or measurements far downstream of the control region.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2016; v1 submitted 8 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Does the choice of the forcing term affect flow statistics in DNS of turbulent channel flow?
Authors:
Maurizio Quadrio,
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Yosuke Hasegawa
Abstract:
We seek possible statistical consequences of the way a forcing term is added to the Navier--Stokes equations in the Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) of incompressible channel flow. Simulations driven by constant flow rate, constant pressure gradient and constant power input are used to build large databases, and in particular to store the complete temporal trace of the wall-shear stress for later…
▽ More
We seek possible statistical consequences of the way a forcing term is added to the Navier--Stokes equations in the Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) of incompressible channel flow. Simulations driven by constant flow rate, constant pressure gradient and constant power input are used to build large databases, and in particular to store the complete temporal trace of the wall-shear stress for later analysis. As these approaches correspond to different dynamical systems, it can in principle be envisaged that these differences are reflect by certain statistics of the turbulent flow field. The instantaneous realizations of the flow in the various simulations are obviously different, but, as expected, the usual one-point, one-time statistics do not show any appreciable difference. However, the PDF for the fluctuations of the streamwise component of wall friction reveals that the simulation with constant flow rate presents lower probabilities for extreme events of large positive friction. The low probability value of such events explains their negligible contribution to the commonly computed statistics; however, the very existence of a difference in the PDF demonstrates that the forcing term is not entirely uninfluential. Other statistics for wall-based quantities (the two components of friction and pressure) are examined; in particular spatio-temporal autocorrelations show small differences at large temporal separations, where unfortunately the residual statistical uncertainty is still of the same order of the observed difference. Hence we suggest that the specific choice of the forcing term does not produce important statistical consequences, unless one is interested in the strongest events of high wall friction, that are underestimated by a simulation run at constant flow rate.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Numerical simulation of turbulent duct flows with constant power input
Authors:
Yosuke Hasegawa,
Maurizio Quadrio,
Bettina Frohnapfel
Abstract:
The numerical simulation of a flow through a duct requires an externally specified forcing that makes the fluid flow against viscous friction. To this aim, it is customary to enforce a constant value for either the flow rate (CFR) or the pressure gradient (CPG). When comparing a laminar duct flow before and after a geometrical modification that induces a change of the viscous drag, both approaches…
▽ More
The numerical simulation of a flow through a duct requires an externally specified forcing that makes the fluid flow against viscous friction. To this aim, it is customary to enforce a constant value for either the flow rate (CFR) or the pressure gradient (CPG). When comparing a laminar duct flow before and after a geometrical modification that induces a change of the viscous drag, both approaches (CFR and CPG) lead to a change of the power input across the comparison. Similarly, when carrying out the (DNS and LES) numerical simulation of unsteady turbulent flows, the power input is not constant over time. Carrying out a simulation at constant power input (CPI) is thus a further physically sound option, that becomes particularly appealing in the context of flow control, where a comparison between control-on and control-off conditions has to be made.
We describe how to carry out a CPI simulation, and start with defining a new power-related Reynolds number, whose velocity scale is the bulk flow that can be attained with a given pumping power in the laminar regime. Under the CPI condition, we derive a relation that is equivalent to the Fukagata--Iwamoto--Kasagi relation valid for CFR (and to its extension valid for CPG), that presents the additional advantage of natively including the required control power. The implementation of the CPI approach is then exemplified in the standard case of a plane turbulent channel flow, and then further applied to a flow control case, where the spanwise-oscillating wall is used for skin friction drag reduction. For this low-Reynolds number flow, using 90% of the available power for the pumping system and the remaining 10% for the control system is found to be the optimum share that yields the largest increase of the flow rate above the reference case, where 100% of the power goes to the pump.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Prediction of turbulence control for arbitrary periodic spanwise wall movement
Authors:
Andrea Cimarelli,
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Yosuke Hasegawa,
Elisabetta De Angelis,
Maurizio Quadrio
Abstract:
In order to generalize the well-known spanwise-oscillating-wall technique for drag reduction, non-sinusoidal oscillations of a solid wall are considered as a means to alter the skin-friction drag in a turbulent channel flow. A series of Direct Numerical Simulations is conducted to evaluate the control performance of nine different temporal waveforms, in addition to the usual sinusoid, systematical…
▽ More
In order to generalize the well-known spanwise-oscillating-wall technique for drag reduction, non-sinusoidal oscillations of a solid wall are considered as a means to alter the skin-friction drag in a turbulent channel flow. A series of Direct Numerical Simulations is conducted to evaluate the control performance of nine different temporal waveforms, in addition to the usual sinusoid, systematically changing the wave amplitude and the period for each waveform.
The turbulent average spanwise motion is found to coincide with the laminar Stokes solution that is constructed, for the generic waveform, through harmonic superposition. This allows us to define and compute, for each waveform, a new penetration depth of the Stokes layer which correlates with the amount of turbulent drag reduction, and eventually to predict both turbulent drag reduction and net energy saving rate for arbitrary waveforms.
Among the waveforms considered, the maximum net energy saving rate is obtained by the sinusoidal wave at its optimal amplitude and period. However, the sinusoid is not the best waveform at every point in the parameter space. Our predictive tool offers simple guidelines to design waveforms that outperform the sinusoid for given (suboptimal) amplitude and period of oscillation. This is potentially interesting in view of applications, where physical limitations often preclude the actuator to reach its optimal operating conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Money versus Time: Evaluation of Flow Control in Terms of Energy Consumption and Convenience
Authors:
Bettina Frohnapfel,
Yosuke Hasegawa,
Maurizio Quadrio
Abstract:
Flow control with the goal of reducing the skin friction drag on the fluid-solid interface is an active fundamental research area, motivated by its potential for significant energy savings and reduced emissions in the transport sector. Customarily, the performance of drag reduction techniques in internal flows is evaluated under two alternative flow conditions, i.e. at constant mass flow rate or c…
▽ More
Flow control with the goal of reducing the skin friction drag on the fluid-solid interface is an active fundamental research area, motivated by its potential for significant energy savings and reduced emissions in the transport sector. Customarily, the performance of drag reduction techniques in internal flows is evaluated under two alternative flow conditions, i.e. at constant mass flow rate or constant pressure gradient. Successful control leads to reduction of drag and pumping power within the former approach, whereas the latter leads to an increase of the mass flow rate and pumping power. In practical applications, however, money and time define the flow control challenge: a compromise between the energy expenditure (money) and the corresponding convenience (flow rate) achieved with that amount of energy has to be reached so as to accomplish a goal which in general depends on the specific application. Based on this idea, we derive two dimensionless parameters which quantify the total energy consumption and the required time (convenience) for transporting a given volume of fluid through a given duct. Performances of existing drag reduction strategies as well as the influence of wall roughness are re-evaluated within the present framework; how to achieve the (application-dependent) optimum balance between energy consumption and convenience is addressed. It is also shown that these considerations can be extended to external flows.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.