-
Buoyant finite-size particles in turbulent duct flow
Authors:
Sagar Zade,
Walter Fornari,
Fredrik Lundell,
Luca Brandt
Abstract:
Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) and Particle Tracking Velocimetry (PTV) have been employed to investigate the dynamics of finite-size spherical particles, slightly heavier than the carrier fluid, in a horizontal turbulent square duct flow. Interface resolved Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) have also been performed with the Immersed Boundary Method (IBM) at the same experimental conditions, bul…
▽ More
Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) and Particle Tracking Velocimetry (PTV) have been employed to investigate the dynamics of finite-size spherical particles, slightly heavier than the carrier fluid, in a horizontal turbulent square duct flow. Interface resolved Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) have also been performed with the Immersed Boundary Method (IBM) at the same experimental conditions, bulk Reynolds number $Re_{2H}$ = 5600, duct height to particle size ratio $2H/d_p$ = 14.5, particle volume fraction $Φ$ = 1% and particle to fluid density ratio $ρ_p/ρ_f$ = 1.0035. A good agreement has been observed between experiments and simulations in terms of the overall pressure drop, concentration distribution and turbulent statistics of the two phases. Additional experimental results considering two particle sizes, $2H/d_p$ = 14.5 and 9 and multiple $Φ$ = 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5% are reported at the same $Re_{2H}$. The pressure drop monotonically increases with the volume fraction, almost linearly and nearly independently of the particle size for the above parameters. However, despite the similar pressure drop, the microscopic picture, the fluid velocity statistics, differs significantly with the particle size. This one-to-one comparison between simulations and experiments extends the validity of interface resolved DNS in complex turbulent multiphase flows and highlights the ability of experiments to investigate such flows in considerable details, even in regions where the local volume fraction is relatively high.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Experimental investigation of turbulent suspensions of spherical particles in a square duct
Authors:
Sagar Zade,
Pedro Costa,
Walter Fornari,
Fredrik Lundell,
Luca Brandt
Abstract:
We report experimental observations of turbulent flow with spherical particles in a square duct. Three particle sizes namely: $2H/d_{p}$ = 40, 16 and 9 ($2H$ being the duct full height and $d_{p}$ being the particle diameter) are investigated. The particles are nearly neutrally-buoyant with respect to the suspending fluid. Refractive Index Matched - Particle Image Velocimetry is used for fluid vel…
▽ More
We report experimental observations of turbulent flow with spherical particles in a square duct. Three particle sizes namely: $2H/d_{p}$ = 40, 16 and 9 ($2H$ being the duct full height and $d_{p}$ being the particle diameter) are investigated. The particles are nearly neutrally-buoyant with respect to the suspending fluid. Refractive Index Matched - Particle Image Velocimetry is used for fluid velocity measurement even at the highest particle volume fraction (20%) and Particle Tracking Velocimetry for the particle velocity statistics for the flows seeded with particles of the two largest sizes, whereas only pressure measurements are reported for the smallest particles. Settling effects are seen at the lowest bulk Reynolds number $Re_{2H}\approx$ 10000 whereas, at the highest $Re_{2H}\approx$ 27000, particles are in almost full suspension. The friction factor of the suspensions is found to be significantly larger than that of single-phase duct flow at the lower $Re_{2H}$ investigated; however, the difference decreases when increasing the flow rate and the total drag approaches the values of the single phase flow at the higher Reynolds number considered. The pressure drop is found to decrease with the particle diameter for volume fractions lower than $φ$ = 10% for nearly all $Re_{2H}$. However, at the highest volume fraction $φ$ = 20%, we report a peculiar non-monotonic behavior: the pressure drop first decreases and then increases with increasing particle size. The decrease of the turbulent drag with particle size at the lowest volume fractions is related to an attenuation of the turbulence. The drag increase for the two largest particle sizes at $φ$ = 20%, however, occurs despite this large reduction of the turbulent stresses, and it is therefore due to significant particle-induced stresses.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Suspensions of finite-size neutrally-buoyant spheres in turbulent duct flow
Authors:
Walter Fornari,
Hamid Tabaei Kazerooni,
Jeanette Hussong,
Luca Brandt
Abstract:
We study the turbulent square duct flow of dense suspensions of neutrally-buoyant spherical particles. Direct numerical simulations (DNS) are performed in the range of volume fractions $φ=0-0.2$, using the immersed boundary method (IBM) to account for the dispersed phase. Based on the hydraulic diameter a Reynolds number of $5600$ is considered. We report flow features and particle statistics spec…
▽ More
We study the turbulent square duct flow of dense suspensions of neutrally-buoyant spherical particles. Direct numerical simulations (DNS) are performed in the range of volume fractions $φ=0-0.2$, using the immersed boundary method (IBM) to account for the dispersed phase. Based on the hydraulic diameter a Reynolds number of $5600$ is considered. We report flow features and particle statistics specific to this geometry, and compare the results to the case of two-dimensional channel flows. In particular, we observe that for $φ=0.05$ and $0.1$, particles preferentially accumulate on the corner bisectors, close to the duct corners as also observed for laminar square duct flows of same duct-to-particle size ratios. At the highest volume fraction, particles preferentially accumulate in the core region. For channel flows, in the absence of lateral confinement particles are found instead to be uniformily distributed across the channel. We also observe that the intensity of the cross-stream secondary flows increases (with respect to the unladen case) with the volume fraction up to $φ=0.1$, as a consequence of the high concentration of particles along the corner bisector. For $φ=0.2$ the turbulence activity is strongly reduced and the intensity of the secondary flows reduces below that of the unladen case. The friction Reynolds number increases with $φ$ in dilute conditions, as observed for channel flows. However, for $φ=0.2$ the mean friction Reynolds number decreases below the value for $φ=0.1$.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Clustering and increased settling speed of oblate particles at finite Reynolds number
Authors:
Walter Fornari,
Mehdi Niazi Ardekani,
Luca Brandt
Abstract:
We study the settling of rigid oblates in quiescent fluid using interface-resolved Direct Numerical Simulations. In particular, an immersed boundary method is used to account for the dispersed solid phase together with lubrication correction and collision models to account for short-range particle-particle interactions. We consider semi-dilute suspensions of oblate particles with aspect ratio AR=1…
▽ More
We study the settling of rigid oblates in quiescent fluid using interface-resolved Direct Numerical Simulations. In particular, an immersed boundary method is used to account for the dispersed solid phase together with lubrication correction and collision models to account for short-range particle-particle interactions. We consider semi-dilute suspensions of oblate particles with aspect ratio AR=1/3 and solid volume fractions $φ=0.5\%-10\%$. The solid-to-fluid density ratio $R=1.5$ and the Galileo number (i.e. the ratio between buoyancy and viscous forces) based on the diameter of a sphere with equivalent volume $Ga=60$. With this choice of parameters, an isolated oblate falls vertically with a steady wake with its broad side perpendicular to the gravity direction. At this $Ga$, the mean settling speed of spheres is a decreasing function of the volume $φ$ and is always smaller than the terminal velocity of the isolated particle, $V_t$. On the contrary, we show here that the mean settling speed of oblate particles increases with $φ$ in dilute conditions and is $33\%$ larger than $V_t$. At higher concentrations, the mean settling speed decreases becoming smaller than the terminal velocity $V_t$ between $φ=5\%$ and $10\%$. The increase of the mean settling speed is due to the formation of particle clusters that for $φ=0.5\%-1\%$ appear as columnar-like structures. From the pair-distribution function we observe that it is most probable to find particle-pairs almost vertically aligned. However, the pair-distribution function is non-negligible all around the reference particle indicating that there is a substantial amount of clustering at radial distances between 2 and $6c$ (with $c$ the polar radius of the oblate).
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
A numerical approach for particle-vortex interactions based on volume-averaged equations
Authors:
Toshiaki Fukada,
Walter Fornari,
Luca Brandt,
Shintaro Takeuchi,
Takeo Kajishima
Abstract:
To study the dynamics of particles in turbulence when their sizes are comparable to the smallest eddies in the flow, the Kolmogorov length scale, efficient and accurate numerical models for the particle-fluid interaction are still missing. Therefore, we here extend the treatment of the particle feedback on the fluid based on the volume-averaged fluid equations (VA simulation) in the previous study…
▽ More
To study the dynamics of particles in turbulence when their sizes are comparable to the smallest eddies in the flow, the Kolmogorov length scale, efficient and accurate numerical models for the particle-fluid interaction are still missing. Therefore, we here extend the treatment of the particle feedback on the fluid based on the volume-averaged fluid equations (VA simulation) in the previous study of the present authors, by estimating the fluid force correlated with the disturbed flow. We validate the model against interface-resolved simulations using the immersed-boundary method. Simulations of single particles show that the history effect is well captured by the present estimation method based on the disturbed flow. Similarly, the simulation of the flow around a rotating particle demonstrates that the lift force is also well captured by the proposed method. We also consider the interaction between non-negligible size particles and an array of Taylor-Green vortices. For density ratios $ρ_d/ρ_c\geq$ 10, the results show that the particle motion captured by the VA approach is closer to that of the fully-resolved simulations than that obtained with a traditional two-way coupling simulation. The flow disturbance is also well represented by the VA simulation. In particular, it is found that history effects enhance the curvature of the trajectory in vortices and this enhancement increases with the particle size. Furthermore, the flow field generated by a neighboring particle at distances of around ten particle diameters significantly influences particle trajectories. The computational cost of the VA simulation proposed here is considerably lower than that of the interface-resolved simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2018; v1 submitted 26 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Inertial migration in dilute and semi-dilute suspensions of rigid particles in laminar square duct flow
Authors:
H. Tabaei Kazerooni,
W. Fornari,
J. Hussong,
L. Brandt
Abstract:
We study the inertial migration of finite-size neutrally buoyant spherical particles in dilute and semi-dilute suspensions in laminar square duct flow. We perform several direct numerical simulations using an immersed boundary method to investigate the effects of the bulk Reynolds number $Re_b$, particle Reynolds number $Re_p$ and duct to particle size ratio $h/a$ at different solid volume fractio…
▽ More
We study the inertial migration of finite-size neutrally buoyant spherical particles in dilute and semi-dilute suspensions in laminar square duct flow. We perform several direct numerical simulations using an immersed boundary method to investigate the effects of the bulk Reynolds number $Re_b$, particle Reynolds number $Re_p$ and duct to particle size ratio $h/a$ at different solid volume fractions $φ$, from very dilute conditions to $20\%$. We show that the bulk Reynolds number $Re_b$ is the key parameter in inertial migration of particles in dilute suspensions. At low solid volume fraction ($φ=0.4\%$) and low bulk Reynolds number $(Re_b= 144)$, particles accumulate at the center of the duct walls. As $Re_b$ is increased, the focusing position moves progressively towards the corners of the duct. At higher volume fractions, $φ=5, 10$ and $20\%$, and in wider ducts with $Re_b=550$, particles are found to migrate away from the duct core towards the walls. In particular, for $φ=5$ and $10\%$, particles accumulate preferentially at the corners. At the highest volume fraction considered, $φ=20\%$, particles sample all the volume of the duct, with a lower concentration at the duct core. The presence of particles induces secondary cross-stream motions in the duct cross-section, for all $φ$. The intensity of these secondary flows depends strongly on particle rotation rate, on the maximum concentration of particles in focusing positions, and on the solid volume fraction. We find that the secondary flow intensity increases with the volume fraction up to $φ=5\%$. However, beyond $φ=5\%$ excluded volume effects lead to a strong reduction of cross-stream velocities.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
The effect of polydispersity in a turbulent channel flow laden with finite-size particles
Authors:
Walter Fornari,
Francesco Picano,
Luca Brandt
Abstract:
We study turbulent channel flows of monodisperse and polydisperse suspensions of finite-size spheres by means of Direct Numerical Simulations using an immersed boundary method to account for the dispersed phase. Suspensions with 3 different Gaussian distributions of particle radii are considered (i.e. 3 different standard deviations). The distributions are centered on the reference particle radius…
▽ More
We study turbulent channel flows of monodisperse and polydisperse suspensions of finite-size spheres by means of Direct Numerical Simulations using an immersed boundary method to account for the dispersed phase. Suspensions with 3 different Gaussian distributions of particle radii are considered (i.e. 3 different standard deviations). The distributions are centered on the reference particle radius of the monodisperse suspension. In the most extreme case, the radius of the largest particles is 4 times that of the smaller particles. We consider two different solid volume fractions, 2% and 10%. We find that for all polydisperse cases, both fluid and particles statistics are not substantially altered with respect to those of the monodisperse case. Mean streamwise fluid and particle velocity profiles are almost perfectly overlapping. Slightly larger differences are found for particle velocity fluctuations. These increase close to the wall and decrease towards the centerline as the standard deviation of the distribution is increased. Hence, the behavior of the suspension is mostly governed by excluded volume effects regardless of particle size distribution (at least for the radii here studied). Due to turbulent mixing, particles are uniformly distributed across the channel. However, smaller particles can penetrate more into the viscous and buffer layer and velocity fluctuations are therein altered. Non trivial results are presented for particle-pair statistics.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Reduced particle settling speed in turbulence
Authors:
Walter Fornari,
Francesco Picano,
Gaetano Sardina,
Luca Brandt
Abstract:
We study the settling of finite-size rigid spheres in sustained homogeneous isotropic turbulence (HIT) by direct numerical simulations using an immersed boundary method to account for the dispersed solid phase. We study semi-dilute suspensions at different Galileo numbers, Ga. The Galileo number is the ratio between buoyancy and viscous forces, and is here varied via the solid-to-fluid density rat…
▽ More
We study the settling of finite-size rigid spheres in sustained homogeneous isotropic turbulence (HIT) by direct numerical simulations using an immersed boundary method to account for the dispersed solid phase. We study semi-dilute suspensions at different Galileo numbers, Ga. The Galileo number is the ratio between buoyancy and viscous forces, and is here varied via the solid-to-fluid density ratio. The focus is on particles that are slightly heavier than the fluid. We find that in HIT, the mean settling speed is less than that in quiescent fluid; in particular, it reduces by 6%-60% with respect to the terminal velocity of an isolated sphere in quiescent fluid as the ratio between the latter and the turbulent velocity fluctuations is decreased. Analysing the fluid-particle relative motion, we find that the mean settling speed is progressively reduced while reducing the density ratio due to the increase of the vertical drag induced by the particle cross-flow velocity. Unsteady effects contribute to the mean overall drag by about 6%-10%. The probability density functions of particle velocities and accelerations reveal that these are closely related to the features of the turbulent flow. The particle mean-square displacement in the settling direction is found to be similar for all Ga if time is scaled by (2a)/u' (where 2a is the particle diameter and u' is the turbulence velocity root mean square).
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2016; v1 submitted 30 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
The effect of particle density in turbulent channel flow laden with finite size particles in semi-dilute conditions
Authors:
Walter Fornari,
Alberto Formenti,
Francesco Picano,
Luca Brandt
Abstract:
We study the effect of varying the mass and volume fraction of a suspension of rigid spheres dispersed in a turbulent channel flow. We performed several Direct Numerical Simulations using an Immersed Boundary Method for finite-size particles changing the solid to fluid density ratio, the mass fraction and the volume fraction. We find that varying the density ratio between 1 and 10 at constant volu…
▽ More
We study the effect of varying the mass and volume fraction of a suspension of rigid spheres dispersed in a turbulent channel flow. We performed several Direct Numerical Simulations using an Immersed Boundary Method for finite-size particles changing the solid to fluid density ratio, the mass fraction and the volume fraction. We find that varying the density ratio between 1 and 10 at constant volume fraction does not alter the flow statistics as much as when varying the volume fraction at constant and at constant mass fraction. Interestingly, the increase in overall drag found when varying the volume fraction is considerably higher than that obtained for increasing density ratios at same volume fraction. The main effect at density ratios of the order of 10 is a strong shear-induced migration towards the centerline of the channel. When the density ratio is further increased up to 1000 the particle dynamics decouple from that of the fluid. The solid phase behaves as a dense gas and the fluid and solid phase statistics drastically change. In this regime, the collision rate is high and dominated by the normal relative velocity among particles.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2016; v1 submitted 4 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Sedimentation of finite-size spheres in quiescent and turbulent environments
Authors:
Walter Fornari,
Francesco Picano,
Luca Brandt
Abstract:
Sedimentation of a dispersed solid phase is widely encountered in applications and environmental flows, yet little is known about the behavior of finite-size particles in homogeneous isotropic turbulence. To fill this gap, we perform Direct Numerical Simulations of sedimentation in quiescent and turbulent environments using an Immersed Boundary Method to account for the dispersed rigid spherical p…
▽ More
Sedimentation of a dispersed solid phase is widely encountered in applications and environmental flows, yet little is known about the behavior of finite-size particles in homogeneous isotropic turbulence. To fill this gap, we perform Direct Numerical Simulations of sedimentation in quiescent and turbulent environments using an Immersed Boundary Method to account for the dispersed rigid spherical particles. The solid volume fractions considered are 0.5-1%, while the solid to fluid density ratio 1.02. The particle radius is chosen to be approximately 6 Komlogorov lengthscales. The results show that the mean settling velocity is lower in an already turbulent flow than in a quiescent fluid. The reduction with respect to a single particle in quiescent fluid is about 12\% and 14\% for the two volume fractions investigated. The probability density function of the particle velocity is almost Gaussian in a turbulent flow, whereas it displays large positive tails in quiescent fluid. These tails are associated to the intermittent fast sedimentation of particle pairs in drafting-kissing-tumbling motions. The particle lateral dispersion is higher in a turbulent flow, whereas the vertical one is, surprisingly, of comparable magnitude as a consequence of the highly intermittent behavior observed in the quiescent fluid. Using the concept of mean relative velocity we estimate the mean drag coefficient from empirical formulas and show that non stationary effects, related to vortex shedding, explain the increased reduction in mean settling velocity in a turbulent environment.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2015; v1 submitted 16 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
