-
A weakly non-hydrostatic shallow model for dry granular flows
Authors:
José Garres-Díaz,
Enrique D. Fernández-Nieto,
Anne Mangeney,
Tomás Morales de Luna
Abstract:
A non-hydrostatic depth-averaged model for dry granular flows is proposed, taking into account vertical acceleration. A variable friction coefficient based on the $μ(I)$ rheology is considered. The model is obtained from an asymptotic analysis in a local reference system, where the non-hydrostatic contribution is supposed to be small compared to the hydrostatic one. The non-hydrostatic counterpart…
▽ More
A non-hydrostatic depth-averaged model for dry granular flows is proposed, taking into account vertical acceleration. A variable friction coefficient based on the $μ(I)$ rheology is considered. The model is obtained from an asymptotic analysis in a local reference system, where the non-hydrostatic contribution is supposed to be small compared to the hydrostatic one. The non-hydrostatic counterpart of the pressure may be written as the sum of two terms: one corresponding to the stress tensor and the other to the vertical acceleration. The model introduced here is weakly non-hydrostatic, in the sense that the non-hydrostatic contribution related to the stress tensor is not taken into account due to its complex implementation. A simple and efficient numerical scheme is proposed. It consists of a three-step splitting procedure, and it is based on a hydrostatic reconstruction. Two key points are: (i) the friction force has to be taken into account before solving the non-hydrostatic pressure. Otherwise, the incompressibility condition is not ensured; (ii) both the hydrostatic and the non-hydrostatic pressure are taken into account when dealing with the friction force. The model and numerical scheme are then validated based on several numerical tests, including laboratory experiments of granular collapse. The influence of non-hydrostatic terms and of the choice of the coordinate system (Cartesian or local) is analyzed. We show that non-hydrostatic models are less sensitive to the choice of the coordinate system. In general, the non-hydrostatic model introduced here much better reproduces granular collapse experiments compared to hydrostatic models. An important result is that the simulated mass profiles up to the deposit and the front velocity are greatly improved. As expected, the influence of the non-hydrostatic pressure is shown to be larger for small values of the slope.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Multilayer models for shallow two-phase debris flows with dilatancy effects
Authors:
José Garres-Díaz,
François Bouchut,
Enrique D. Fernández-Nieto,
Anne Mangeney,
Gladys Narbona-Reina
Abstract:
We present here a multilayer model for shallow grain-fluid mixtures with dilatancy effects. It can be seen as a generalization of the depth-averaged model presented in Bouchut et al. (2016), that includes dilatancy effects by considering a two-layer model, a mixture grain-fluid layer and an upper fluid layer, to allow the exchange of fluid between them. In the present work the approximation of the…
▽ More
We present here a multilayer model for shallow grain-fluid mixtures with dilatancy effects. It can be seen as a generalization of the depth-averaged model presented in Bouchut et al. (2016), that includes dilatancy effects by considering a two-layer model, a mixture grain-fluid layer and an upper fluid layer, to allow the exchange of fluid between them. In the present work the approximation of the mixture layer is improved including normal variations of the velocities and concentrations of the two phases thanks to the multilayer approach. In the model presented here dilatancy effects induce in particular a non-hydrostatic pressure for both phases related to the excess pore fluid pressure. We identified here one of the main numerical difficulty of solving two-phase shallow debris flows models: the strongly non-linear behaviour and abrupt changes of the excess pore fluid pressure when starting from non-equilibrium conditions. We propose a simplified approach to approximate the excess pore fluid pressure in the simple case of uniform flows. Our method makes it possible to introduce two or three layers in the normal directions with a reasonable approximation. Analytical solutions for uniform grain-fluid flows over inclined planes, with and without side wall friction, are calculated and compared to the proposed model. In the numerical results, we observe that the proposed model with a two layer description of the mixture accurately represents the velocity measured at the surface of the mixture in the laboratory experiments. This is obviously poorly represented by the depth-averaged velocity in single-layer models. Our numerical results show a significant impact of the parameters involved in dilatancy law, in particular on the calculation of the time evolution of the excess pore fluid pressure.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
A two-layer shallow water model for bedload sediment transport: convergence to Saint-Venant-Exner model
Authors:
C. Escalante,
E. D. Fernández-Nieto,
T. Morales de Luna,
G. Narbona-Reina
Abstract:
A two-layer shallow water type model is proposed to describe bedload sediment transport. The upper layer is filled by water and the lower one by sediment. The key point falls on the definition of the friction laws between the two layers, which are a generalization of those introduced in Fernández-Nieto et al. (ESAIM: M2AN, 51:115-145, 2017). This definition allows to apply properly the two-layer s…
▽ More
A two-layer shallow water type model is proposed to describe bedload sediment transport. The upper layer is filled by water and the lower one by sediment. The key point falls on the definition of the friction laws between the two layers, which are a generalization of those introduced in Fernández-Nieto et al. (ESAIM: M2AN, 51:115-145, 2017). This definition allows to apply properly the two-layer shallow water model for the case of intense and slow bedload sediment transport. Moreover, we prove that the two-layer model converges to a Saint-Venant-Exner system (SVE) including gravitational effects when the ratio between the hydrodynamic and morphodynamic time scales is small. The SVE with gravitational effects is a degenerated nonlinear parabolic system. This means that its numerical approximation is very expensive from a computational point of view, see for example T. Morales de Luna et al. (J. Sci. Comp., 48(1): 258-273, 2011). In this work, gravitational effects are introduced into the two-layer system without such extra computational cost. Finally, we also consider a generalization of the model that includes a non-hydrostatic pressure correction for the fluid layer and the boundary condition at the sediment surface. Numerical tests show that the model provides promising results and behave well in low transport rate regimes as well as in many other situations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
2D granular flows with the $μ(I)$ rheology and side walls friction: a well balanced multilayer discretization
Authors:
E. D. Fernández-Nieto,
J. Garres-Díaz,
A. Mangeney,
G. Narbona-Reina
Abstract:
We present here numerical modelling of granular flows with the $μ(I)$ rheology in confined channels. The contribution is twofold: (i) a model to approximate the Navier-Stokes equations with the $μ(I)$ rheology through an asymptotic analysis. Under the hypothesis of a one-dimensional flow, this model takes into account side walls friction; (ii) a multilayer discretization following Fernández-Nieto…
▽ More
We present here numerical modelling of granular flows with the $μ(I)$ rheology in confined channels. The contribution is twofold: (i) a model to approximate the Navier-Stokes equations with the $μ(I)$ rheology through an asymptotic analysis. Under the hypothesis of a one-dimensional flow, this model takes into account side walls friction; (ii) a multilayer discretization following Fernández-Nieto et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 798, 2016, pp. 643-681). In this new numerical scheme, we propose an appropriate treatment of the rheological terms through a hydrostatic reconstruction which allows this scheme to be well-balanced and therefore to deal with dry areas. Based on academic tests, we first evaluate the influence of the width of the channel on the normal profiles of the downslope velocity thanks to the multilayer approach that is intrinsically able to describe changes from Bagnold to S-shaped (and vice versa) velocity profiles. We also check the well balance property of the proposed numerical scheme. We show that approximating side walls friction using single-layer models may lead to strong errors. Secondly, we compare the numerical results with experimental data on granular collapses. We show that the proposed scheme allows us to qualitatively reproduce the deposit in the case of a rigid bed (i. e. dry area) and that the error made by replacing the dry area by a small layer of material may be large if this layer is not thin enough. The proposed model is also able to reproduce the time evolution of the free surface and of the flow/no-flow interface. In addition, it reproduces the effect of erosion for granular flows over initially static material lying on the bed. This is possible when using a variable friction coefficient $μ(I)$ but not with a constant friction coefficient.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Derivation of a multilayer approach to model suspended sediment transport: application to hyperpycnal and hypopycnal plumes
Authors:
T. Morales de Luna,
E. D. Fernández-Nieto,
M. J. Castro Díaz
Abstract:
We propose a multi-layer approach to simulate hyperpycnal and hypopycnal plumes in flows with free surface. The model allows to compute the vertical profile of the horizontal and the vertical components of the velocity of the fluid flow. The model can describe as well the vertical profile of the sediment concentration and the velocity components of each one of the sediment species that form the tu…
▽ More
We propose a multi-layer approach to simulate hyperpycnal and hypopycnal plumes in flows with free surface. The model allows to compute the vertical profile of the horizontal and the vertical components of the velocity of the fluid flow. The model can describe as well the vertical profile of the sediment concentration and the velocity components of each one of the sediment species that form the turbidity current. To do so, it takes into account the settling velocity of the particles and their interaction with the fluid. This allows to better describe the phenomena than a single layer approach. It is in better agreement with the physics of the problem and gives promising results. The numerical simulation is carried out by rewriting the multi-layer approach in a compact formulation, which corresponds to a system with non-conservative products, and using path-conservative numerical scheme. Numerical results are presented in order to show the potential of the model.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
A multilayer shallow model for dry granular flows with the $μ(I)$ rheology: Application to granular collapse on erodible beds
Authors:
Enrique D. Fernández-Nieto,
José Garres-Díaz,
Anne Mangeney,
Gladys Narbona-Reina
Abstract:
In this work we present a multilayer shallow model to approximate the Navier-Stokes equations with hydrostatic pressure and the $μ(I)$-rheology. The main advantages of this approximation are (i) the low cost associated with the numerical treatment of the free surface of the modelled flows, (ii) exact conservation of mass and (iii) the ability to compute 3D profiles of the velocities in the directi…
▽ More
In this work we present a multilayer shallow model to approximate the Navier-Stokes equations with hydrostatic pressure and the $μ(I)$-rheology. The main advantages of this approximation are (i) the low cost associated with the numerical treatment of the free surface of the modelled flows, (ii) exact conservation of mass and (iii) the ability to compute 3D profiles of the velocities in the directions along and normal to the slope. The derivation of the model follows [14] and introduces a dimensional analysis based on the shallow flow hypothesis. The proposed first order multilayer model fully satisfies a dissipative energy equation. A comparison with an analytical solution with a non-constant normal profile of the downslope velocity demonstrates the accuracy of the numerical model. Finally, by comparing the numerical results with experimental data, we show that the proposed multilayer model with the $μ(I)$-rheology reproduces qualitatively the effect of the erodible bed on granular flow dynamics and deposits, such as the increase of runout distance with increasing thickness of the erodible bed. We show that the use of a constant friction coefficient in the multilayer model leads to the opposite behaviour. This multilayer model captures the different normal profiles of the downslope velocity during the different phases of the flow (acceleration, stopping, etc.) including the presence of static and flowing zones within the granular column.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Formal deduction of the Saint-Venant-Exner model including arbitrarily sloping sediment beds and associated energy
Authors:
E. D. Fernández-Nieto,
T. Morales de Luna,
G. Narbona-Reina,
J. D. Zabsonré
Abstract:
In this work we present a deduction of the Saint-Venant-Exner model through an asymptotic analysis of the Navier-Stokes equations. A multi-scale analysis is performed in order to take into account that the velocity of the sediment layer is smaller than the one of the fluid layer. This leads us to consider a shallow water type system for the fluid layer and a lubrication Reynolds equation for the s…
▽ More
In this work we present a deduction of the Saint-Venant-Exner model through an asymptotic analysis of the Navier-Stokes equations. A multi-scale analysis is performed in order to take into account that the velocity of the sediment layer is smaller than the one of the fluid layer. This leads us to consider a shallow water type system for the fluid layer and a lubrication Reynolds equation for the sediment one. This deduction provides some improvements with respect to the classical Saint-Venant-Exner model: (i) the deduced model has an associated energy. Moreover, it allows us to explain why classical models do not have an associated energy and how to modify them in order to recover a model with this property. (ii) The model incorporates naturally a necessary modification that must be taken into account in order to be applied to arbitrarily sloping beds. Furthermore, we show that this modification is different of the ones considered classically, and that it coincides with a classical one only if the solution has a constant free surface. (iii) The deduced solid transport discharge naturally depends on the thickness of the moving sediment layer, what allows to ensure sediment mass conservation. Moreover, we include a simplified version of the model for the case of quasi-stationary regimes. Some of these simplified models correspond to the generalization of classical ones such as Meyer-Peter$\&$Müller and Ashida-Michiue models. Three numerical tests are presented to study the evolution of a dune for several definition of the repose angle, to see the influence of the proposed definition of the effective shear stress in comparison with the classical one, and by comparing with experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
