-
Limit theorems for the neutron transport equation
Authors:
Eric Dumonteil,
Emma Horton,
Andreas E. Kyprianou,
Andrea Zola
Abstract:
Over the last decade, ingenuous developments in Monte Carlo methods have enabled the unbiased estimation of adjoint-weighted reactor parameters expressed as bilinear forms, such as kinetics parameters and sensitivity coefficients. A prominent example is the Iterated Fission Probability method, which relies on the simulation of the fission chains descending from an ancestor neutron: the neutron pop…
▽ More
Over the last decade, ingenuous developments in Monte Carlo methods have enabled the unbiased estimation of adjoint-weighted reactor parameters expressed as bilinear forms, such as kinetics parameters and sensitivity coefficients. A prominent example is the Iterated Fission Probability method, which relies on the simulation of the fission chains descending from an ancestor neutron: the neutron population at an asymptotic fission generation yields an estimate of the importance function (and hence of the adjoint fundamental eigenmode) at the phase-space coordinates of the ancestor neutron. In this paper we first establish rigorous results concerning the moments of the asymptotic neutron population stemming from a single initial particle, with special focus on the average and the variance. Then, we propose a simple benchmark configuration where exact solutions are derived for these moments, which can be used for the verification of new functionalities of production Monte Carlo codes involving the Iterated Fission Probability method.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Improvement of Geant4 Neutron-HP package: Unresolved Resonance Region description with Probability Tables
Authors:
M. Zmeškal,
L. Thulliez,
P. Tamagno,
E. Dumonteil
Abstract:
Whether for shielding applications or for criticality safety studies, solving the neutron transport equation with good accuracy requires to take into account the resonant structure of cross sections in part of the Unresolved Resonance Region (URR). In this energy range even if the resonances can no longer be resolved experimentally, neglecting them can lead to significant numerical biases, namely…
▽ More
Whether for shielding applications or for criticality safety studies, solving the neutron transport equation with good accuracy requires to take into account the resonant structure of cross sections in part of the Unresolved Resonance Region (URR). In this energy range even if the resonances can no longer be resolved experimentally, neglecting them can lead to significant numerical biases, namely in flux-based quantities. In Geant4, low energy neutrons are transported using evaluated nuclear data libraries handled by the Neutron High-Precision (Neutron-HP) package. In the version 11.01.p02 of the code, the URR can only be described by average smooth cross sections that do not take into account the statistical resonant structure of the cross sections. To overcome this shortcoming, the treatment of the URR with the use of the probability table method has been implemented in Geant4 and successfully validated with the reference Monte Carlo neutron transport codes MCNP6 (version 6.2) and Tripoli-4 (version 12). These developments will be taken into account in the next release of Geant4. All the validations of Geant4 have been performed with probability tables generated from both the NJOY and CALENDF pre-processing tools. Therefore Geant4 now has this unique feature to study the relative impact of the strategies involved during the production of probability table by the two pre-processing codes. This has been used to show that self-shielding is important also for inelastic cross sections in the example of 238U. The tool to generate probability tables usable by Geant4 either from NJOY or from CALENDF is made available on a dedicated GitLab repository and will be included in Geant4.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Study of collision and $γ$-cascade times following neutron-capture processes in cryogenic detectors
Authors:
CRAB collaboration,
G. Soum-Sidikov,
H. Abele,
J. Burkhart,
F. Cappella,
N. Casali,
R. Cerulli,
A. Chalil,
A. Chebboubi,
J-P. Crocombette,
G. del Castello,
M. del Gallo Roccagiovine,
A. Doblhammer,
S. Dorer,
E. Dumonteil,
A. Erhart,
A. Giuliani,
C. Goupy,
F. Gunsing,
E. Jericha,
M. Kaznacheeva,
A. Kinast,
H. Kluck,
A. Langenkämper,
T. Lasserre
, et al. (25 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The emission of $γ$-rays after a neutron capture in a cryogenic detector can generate mono-energetic nuclear recoils in the sub-keV regime, of direct interest for the calibration of Dark Matter and Coherent Elastic Neutrino Nucleus Scattering experiments. Here we show that accurate predictions of the nuclear recoil spectra induced by neutron captures require taking into account the interplay betwe…
▽ More
The emission of $γ$-rays after a neutron capture in a cryogenic detector can generate mono-energetic nuclear recoils in the sub-keV regime, of direct interest for the calibration of Dark Matter and Coherent Elastic Neutrino Nucleus Scattering experiments. Here we show that accurate predictions of the nuclear recoil spectra induced by neutron captures require taking into account the interplay between the development in time of the de-excitation $γ$-cascade of the target nucleus and that of the associated atomic collisions in matter. We present detailed simulations coupling the FIFRELIN code for the description of the $γ$-cascades and the IRADINA code for the modelling of the fast atomic movements in matter. Nuclear recoil spectra are predicted, and made available to the community, for concrete cases of Al$_2$O$_3$, Si, Ge and CaWO$_4$ crystals exposed to a low intensity beam of thermal neutrons. We find that timing effects cause new calibration peaks to emerge in the recoil spectra and also impact the shape of the continuous recoil distribution. We discuss how they could give access to a rich physics program, spanning the accurate study of the response of cryogenic detectors in the sub-keV range, tests of solid state physics simulations and tests of nuclear models.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
TOUCANS: a versatile Monte Carlo neutron transport code based on Geant4
Authors:
L. Thulliez,
B. Mom,
E. Dumonteil
Abstract:
This paper reports the development of TOUCANS, a new Monte Carlo neutron transport code fully written using the Geant4 toolkit. It aims at modeling complex systems easily and rapidly, thanks to a simple key-value input file. While its main focus is the transport of low energy neutrons -- below 20 MeV -- using evaluated cross-section libraries, it also takes advantage of the state-of-the-art capabi…
▽ More
This paper reports the development of TOUCANS, a new Monte Carlo neutron transport code fully written using the Geant4 toolkit. It aims at modeling complex systems easily and rapidly, thanks to a simple key-value input file. While its main focus is the transport of low energy neutrons -- below 20 MeV -- using evaluated cross-section libraries, it also takes advantage of the state-of-the-art capabilities offered by Geant4 regarding the modeled cross-sections for practically all particles at all energies. Hence it gives access to non-specialists to a wide variety of applications involving different particles, such as for instance the simulation of compact accelerator based neutron sources (CANS) which initially motivated its development. It leverages on recent implementations performed within Geant4 to provide both shielding calculation capabilities (using Adaptive Multilevel Splitting, which is a fully automated variance reduction technique) and criticality calculation capabilities (to estimate the keff of a multiplicative system). It also benefits from a tight coupling with CADMesh to readily import CAD models, with NCrystal to extend the support of thermal neutron transport to crystals, with FIFRELIN to increase compound nucleus de-excitation accuracy, and with FUNZ to provide to the user parametric simulation capabilities (such as multi-objective algorithms, calculation of Pareto sets, etc). Thanks to recent improvements of the neutron physics within the Geant4 Neutron-HP package, the TOUCANS code can be considered on-par with industrial neutron transport codes such as Tripoli-4 or MCNP in term of neutron physics accuracy. Its sources should be released soon amongst Geant4 advanced examples.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Improvement of Geant4 Neutron-HP package: Doppler broadening of the neutron elastic scattering kernel and cross sections
Authors:
M. Zmeškal,
L. Thulliez,
E. Dumonteil
Abstract:
Whether it is for shielding applications or for safety criticality studies, numerically solving the neutron transport equation with a good accuracy requires to precisely estimate the Doppler broadened elastic scattering kernel in the thermal and epithermal energy range of neutrons travelling in a free gas. In Geant4, low energy neutrons are transported using evaluated data libraries handled by the…
▽ More
Whether it is for shielding applications or for safety criticality studies, numerically solving the neutron transport equation with a good accuracy requires to precisely estimate the Doppler broadened elastic scattering kernel in the thermal and epithermal energy range of neutrons travelling in a free gas. In Geant4, low energy neutrons are transported using evaluated data libraries handled by the Neutron High-Precision (Neutron-HP) package. Version 11.00.p03 of the code features in particular the Doppler broadened elastic scattering kernel, provided by the so-called 'Sampling of the Velocity of the Target' (SVT) method. However this latter fails for resonant heavy nuclei such as 238U and can severely impact the solving of the Boltzmann equation in fissile media. To overcome this shortcoming, the Doppler Broadened Rejection Correction (DBRC) method has been implemented in Geant4 and successfully validated with the reference Monte Carlo neutron transport code Tripoli4 (version 11). This development will be taken into account in the next release of the code. The cross section Doppler broadening process, which is performed on-the-fly, is also carefully investigated and ways to improve it on a simulation-by-simulation basis are presented. All the validations have been performed with an automated benchmark tool which has been designed to support the quality assurance of the Geant4 Neutron-HP package. This tool is currently available on an ad hoc Gitlab repository and will be included in Geant4.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Generational variance reduction in Monte Carlo criticality simulations as a way of mitigating unwanted correlations
Authors:
Kévin Fröhlicher,
Eric Dumonteil,
Loïc Thulliez,
Julien Taforeau,
Mariya Brovchenko
Abstract:
Monte Carlo criticality simulations are widely used in nuclear safety demonstrations, as they offer an arbitrarily precise estimation of global and local tallies while making very few assumptions. However, since the inception of such numerical approaches, it is well known that bias might affect both the estimation of errors on these tallies and the tallies themselves. In particular, stochastic mod…
▽ More
Monte Carlo criticality simulations are widely used in nuclear safety demonstrations, as they offer an arbitrarily precise estimation of global and local tallies while making very few assumptions. However, since the inception of such numerical approaches, it is well known that bias might affect both the estimation of errors on these tallies and the tallies themselves. In particular, stochastic modeling approaches developed in the past decade have shed light on the prominent role played by spatial correlations through a phenomenon called neutron clustering. This effect is particularly of great significance when simulating loosely coupled systems (i.e., with a high dominance ratio). In order to tackle this problem, this paper proposes to recast the power iteration technique of Monte Carlo criticality codes into a variance reduction technique called Adaptative Multilevel Splitting. The central idea is that iterating over neutron generations can be seen as pushing a sub-population of neutrons towards a generational detector (instead of a spatial detector as variance reduction techniques usually do). While both approaches allow for neutron population control, the former blindly removes or splits neutrons. In contrast, the latter optimizes spatial, generational, and spectral attributes of neutrons when they are removed or split through an adjoint flux estimation, hence tempering both generational and spatial correlations. This is illustrated in the present article with a simple case of a bare slab reactor in the one speed theory on which the Adaptive Multilevel Splitting was applied and compared to variations of the Monte Carlo power iteration method used in neutron transport. Besides looking at the resulting efficiency of the methods, this work also aims at highlighting the main mechanisms of the Adaptive Multilevel Splitting in criticality calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Observation of a nuclear recoil peak at the 100 eV scale induced by neutron capture
Authors:
CRAB Collaboration,
NUCLEUS Collaboration,
H. Abele,
G. Angloher,
A. Bento,
L. Canonica,
F. Cappella,
L. Cardani,
N. Casali,
R. Cerulli,
A. Chalil,
A. Chebboubi,
I. Colantoni,
J. -P. Crocombette,
A. Cruciani,
G. Del Castello,
M. del Gallo Roccagiovine,
D. Desforge,
A. Doblhammer,
E. Dumonteil,
S. Dorer,
A. Erhart,
A. Fuss,
M. Friedl,
A. Garai
, et al. (53 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering and low-mass Dark Matter detectors rely crucially on the understanding of their response to nuclear recoils. We report the first observation of a nuclear recoil peak at around 112 eV induced by neutron capture. The measurement was performed with a CaWO$_4$ cryogenic detector from the NUCLEUS experiment exposed to a $^{252}$Cf source placed in a compact…
▽ More
Coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering and low-mass Dark Matter detectors rely crucially on the understanding of their response to nuclear recoils. We report the first observation of a nuclear recoil peak at around 112 eV induced by neutron capture. The measurement was performed with a CaWO$_4$ cryogenic detector from the NUCLEUS experiment exposed to a $^{252}$Cf source placed in a compact moderator. The measured spectrum is found in agreement with simulations and the expected peak structure from the single-$γ$ de-excitation of $^{183}$W is identified with 3 $σ$ significance. This result demonstrates a new method for precise, in-situ, and non-intrusive calibration of low-threshold experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2023; v1 submitted 7 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Improvement of Geant4 Neutron-HP package: from methodology to evaluated nuclear data library
Authors:
Loic Thulliez,
Cédric Jouanne,
Eric Dumonteil
Abstract:
An accurate description of interactions between thermal neutrons (below 4 eV) and materials is key to simulate the transport of neutrons in a wide range of applications such as criticality-safety, reactor physics, compact accelerator-driven neutron sources, radiological shielding or nuclear instrumentation, just to name a few. While the Monte Carlo transport code Geant4 was initially developed to…
▽ More
An accurate description of interactions between thermal neutrons (below 4 eV) and materials is key to simulate the transport of neutrons in a wide range of applications such as criticality-safety, reactor physics, compact accelerator-driven neutron sources, radiological shielding or nuclear instrumentation, just to name a few. While the Monte Carlo transport code Geant4 was initially developed to simulate particle physics experiments, %-with a large emphasis given on modeled cross-sections for all known particles at all conceivable energies-, its use has spread to neutronics applications, requiring evaluated cross-sections for neutrons and gammas between $0$ and $20$ MeV (the so-called neutron High Precision -HP- package), as well as a proper offline or on-the-flight treatment of these cross-sections. In this paper we will point out limitations affecting Geant4 (version 10.07.p01) thermal neutron treatment and associated nuclear data libraries, by using comparisons with the reference Monte Carlo neutron transport code \tripoli, version 11, and we will present the results of various modifications of the Geant4 neutron-HP package, required to overcome these limitations. Also, in order to broaden the support of nuclear data libraries compatible with Geant4, a nuclear processing tool has been developed and validated allowing the use of the code together with ENDF-BVIII.0 and JEFF-3.3 libraries for example. These changes should be taken into account in an upcoming Geant4 release.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2021; v1 submitted 10 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Calibration of nuclear recoils at the 100 eV scale using neutron capture
Authors:
L. Thulliez,
D. Lhuillier,
F. Cappella,
N. Casali,
R. Cerulli,
A. Chalil,
A. Chebboubi,
E. Dumonteil,
A. Erhart,
A. Giuliani,
F. Gunsing,
E. Jericha,
M. Kaznacheeva,
A. Kinast,
A. Langenkämper,
T. Lasserre,
A. Letourneau,
O. Litaize,
P. de Marcillac,
S. Marnieros,
T. Materna,
B. Mauri,
E. Mazzucato,
C. Nones,
T. Ortmann
, et al. (12 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The development of low-threshold detectors for the study of coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering and for the search for light dark matter necessitates methods of low-energy calibration. We suggest this can be provided by the nuclear recoils resulting from the $γ$ emission following thermal neutron capture. In particular, several MeV-scale single-$γ$ transitions induce well-defined nuclear…
▽ More
The development of low-threshold detectors for the study of coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering and for the search for light dark matter necessitates methods of low-energy calibration. We suggest this can be provided by the nuclear recoils resulting from the $γ$ emission following thermal neutron capture. In particular, several MeV-scale single-$γ$ transitions induce well-defined nuclear recoil peaks in the 100 eV range. Using the FIFRELIN code, complete schemes of $γ$-cascades for various isotopes can be predicted with high accuracy to determine the continuous background of nuclear recoils below the calibration peaks. We present a comprehensive experimental concept for the calibration of CaWO$_4$ and Ge cryogenic detectors at a research reactor. For CaWO$_4$ the simulations show that two nuclear recoil peaks at 112.5 eV and 160.3 eV should be visible above background simply in the spectrum of the cryogenic detector. Then we discuss how the additional tagging for the associated $γ$ increases the sensitivity of the method and extends its application to a wider energy range and to Ge cryogenic detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2021; v1 submitted 27 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Patchy nuclear chain reactions
Authors:
Eric Dumonteil,
Rian Bahran,
Theresa Cutler,
Benjamin Dechenaux,
Travis Grove,
Jesson Hutchinson,
George McKenzie,
Alexander McSpaden,
Wilfried Monange,
Mark Nelson,
Nicholas Thompson,
Andrea Zoia
Abstract:
Stochastic fluctuations of the neutron population within a nuclear reactor are typically prevented by operating the core at a sufficient power, since a deterministic behavior of the neutron population is required by automatic safety systems to detect unwanted power excursions. Recent works however pointed out that, under specific circumstances, non-Poissonian patterns could affect neutron spatial…
▽ More
Stochastic fluctuations of the neutron population within a nuclear reactor are typically prevented by operating the core at a sufficient power, since a deterministic behavior of the neutron population is required by automatic safety systems to detect unwanted power excursions. Recent works however pointed out that, under specific circumstances, non-Poissonian patterns could affect neutron spatial distributions. This motivated an international program to experimentally detect and characterize such fluctuations and correlations, which took place in 2017 at the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Reactor Critical Facility. The main findings of this program will indeed unveil patchiness in snapshots of neutron spatial distributions -- obtained with a dedicated numerical twin of the reactor -- that support this first experimental characterization of the 'neutron clustering' phenomenon, while a stochastic model based on reaction-diffusion processes and branching random walks will reveal the key role played by the reactor intrinsic sources in understanding neutron spatial correlations.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Poisson-Box Sampling algorithms for three-dimensional Markov binary mixtures
Authors:
Colline Larmier,
Andrea Zoia,
Fausto Malvagi,
Eric Dumonteil,
Alain Mazzolo
Abstract:
Particle transport in Markov mixtures can be addressed by the so-called Chord Length Sampling (CLS) methods, a family of Monte Carlo algorithms taking into account the effects of stochastic media on particle propagation by generating on-the-fly the material interfaces crossed by the random walkers during their trajectories. Such methods enable a significant reduction of computational resources as…
▽ More
Particle transport in Markov mixtures can be addressed by the so-called Chord Length Sampling (CLS) methods, a family of Monte Carlo algorithms taking into account the effects of stochastic media on particle propagation by generating on-the-fly the material interfaces crossed by the random walkers during their trajectories. Such methods enable a significant reduction of computational resources as opposed to reference solutions obtained by solving the Boltzmann equation for a large number of realizations of random media. CLS solutions, which neglect correlations induced by the spatial disorder, are faster albeit approximate, and might thus show discrepancies with respect to reference solutions. In this work we propose a new family of algorithms (called 'Poisson Box Sampling', PBS) aimed at improving the accuracy of the CLS approach for transport in $d$-dimensional binary Markov mixtures. In order to probe the features of PBS methods, we will focus on three-dimensional Markov media and revisit the benchmark problem originally proposed by Adams, Larsen and Pomraning and extended by Brantley: for these configurations we will compare reference solutions, standard CLS solutions and the new PBS solutions for scalar particle flux, transmission and reflection coefficients. PBS will be shown to perform better than CLS at the expense of a reasonable increase in computational time.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2017; v1 submitted 7 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Online Monitoring of the Osiris Reactor with the Nucifer Neutrino Detector
Authors:
G. Boireau,
L. Bouvet,
A. P. Collin,
G. Coulloux,
M. Cribier,
H. Deschamp,
V. Durand,
M. Fechner,
V. Fischer,
J. Gaffiot,
N. Gerard Castaing,
R. Granelli,
Y. Kato,
T. Lasserre,
L. Latron,
P. Legou,
A. Letourneau,
D. Lhuillier,
G. Mention,
T. Mueller,
T-A. Nghiem,
N. Pedrol,
J. Pelzer,
M. Pequignot,
Y. Piret
, et al. (29 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Originally designed as a new nuclear reactor monitoring device, the Nucifer detector has successfully detected its first neutrinos. We provide the second shortest baseline measurement of the reactor neutrino flux. The detection of electron antineutrinos emitted in the decay chains of the fission products, combined with reactor core simulations, provides an new tool to assess both the thermal power…
▽ More
Originally designed as a new nuclear reactor monitoring device, the Nucifer detector has successfully detected its first neutrinos. We provide the second shortest baseline measurement of the reactor neutrino flux. The detection of electron antineutrinos emitted in the decay chains of the fission products, combined with reactor core simulations, provides an new tool to assess both the thermal power and the fissile content of the whole nuclear core and could be used by the Inter- national Agency for Atomic Energy (IAEA) to enhance the Safeguards of civil nuclear reactors. Deployed at only 7.2m away from the compact Osiris research reactor core (70MW) operating at the Saclay research centre of the French Alternative Energies and Atomic Energy Commission (CEA), the experiment also exhibits a well-suited configuration to search for a new short baseline oscillation. We report the first results of the Nucifer experiment, describing the performances of the 0.85m3 detector remotely operating at a shallow depth equivalent to 12m of water and under intense background radiation conditions. Based on 145 (106) days of data with reactor ON (OFF), leading to the detection of an estimated 40760 electron antineutrinos, the mean number of detected antineutrinos is 281 +- 7(stat) +- 18(syst) electron antineutrinos/day, in agreement with the prediction 277(23) electron antineutrinos/day. Due the the large background no conclusive results on the existence of light sterile neutrinos could be derived, however. As a first societal application we quantify how antineutrinos could be used for the Plutonium Management and Disposition Agreement.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2016; v1 submitted 18 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Experimental Parameters for a Cerium 144 Based Intense Electron Antineutrino Generator Experiment at Very Short Baselines
Authors:
J. Gaffiot,
T. Lasserre,
G. Mention,
M. Vivier,
M. Cribier,
M. Durero,
V. Fischer,
A. Letourneau,
E. Dumonteil,
I. S. Saldikov,
G. V. Tikhomirov
Abstract:
The standard three-neutrino oscillation paradigm, associated with small squared mass splittings $\ll 0.1\ \mathrm{eV^2}$, has been successfully built up over the last 15 years using solar, atmospheric, long baseline accelerator and reactor neutrino experiments. However, this well-established picture might suffer from anomalous results reported at very short baselines in some of these experiments.…
▽ More
The standard three-neutrino oscillation paradigm, associated with small squared mass splittings $\ll 0.1\ \mathrm{eV^2}$, has been successfully built up over the last 15 years using solar, atmospheric, long baseline accelerator and reactor neutrino experiments. However, this well-established picture might suffer from anomalous results reported at very short baselines in some of these experiments. If not experimental artifacts, such results could possibly be interpreted as the existence of at least an additional fourth sterile neutrino species, mixing with the known active flavors with an associated mass splitting $\ll 0.1\ \mathrm{eV^2}$, and being insensitive to standard weak interactions. Precision measurements at very short baselines (5 to 15 m) with intense MeV electronic antineutrino emitters can be used to probe these anomalies. In this article, the expected antineutrino signal and backgrounds of a generic experiment which consists of deploying an intense beta minus radioactive source inside or in the vicinity of a large liquid scintillator detector are studied. The technical challenges to perform such an experiment are identified, along with quantifying the possible source and detector induced systematics, and their impact on the sensitivity to the observation of neutrino oscillations at short baselines.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2015; v1 submitted 24 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
